12 ms·
And the US double taxes their citizens living abroad the same way. As an American making the same money as your non-american co-worker you are left with a lot
by sschueller 11y ago
And the US double taxes their citizens living abroad the same way.
As an American making the same money as your non-american co-worker you are left with a lot less just for having a US passport.
It is even possible you have never set foot in the US yet are required to pay uncle sam's taxes.
Wanna get rid of your US passport? Not before you pay 10 years projected taxes and pay an abhorrent fee. You will also be listed on a government website so you can be shamed like a sex offender.
- sremani 11y agoThey have painted the picture of these rich billionaires getting away without paying taxes, and once they got the draconian laws, they are applying it to every day Joe, who hardly make a six figure salary overseas. For a country which has no short supply of aspiring immigrants and US is actually very petty towards people who want to abdicate their citizenship.
- statictype 11y agoIf you make less than 6 figures overseas, then you likely don't have to pay anything to the IRS
- kspaans 11y agoThat's not double-taxation if the US has a tax treaty with the other nation (which is does with most nations). You get tax credits for foreign income taxes paid such that you pay max(foreign_tax, us_tax).
- theandrewbailey 11y ago(IANATA) If you get tax credits, wouldn't you pay us_tax-foreign_tax if us_tax>foreign_tax ?
- kspaans 11y agoYes, that's my understanding as well (IANATA)! And it's still not double-taxation: if us_tax>foreign_tax, then you pay foreign_tax + us_tax-foreign_tax == us_tax. (Or foreign_tax, if it's greater.) The citizenship taxation system means you can't move away and legally pay LESS taxes than if you'd stayed in the US. But you're welcome to pay more and not have to remit anything extra to the US. ;)
- lisivka 11y agoIf you pay two taxes instead of one, as everyone else, then it IS double taxation.
- kspaans 11y agoWikipedia disagrees with you: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_taxation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_taxation Specifically, double-taxation is when you pay taxes twice on the SAME earnings. Take the example of a US citizen living abroad in a country with lower income taxes. They will have to pay foreign as well as US income taxes: two like, you point out, rather than one. But the IRS agrees that double-taxation is mean, so they give you a foreign tax credit for the tax you've already paid. You pay an amount to the IRS to make up the difference in income tax. If it were double-taxation you would have to pay the full US income tax on the money you earned, after already having paid the full foreign income tax on it as well. (Note I've been talking about plain-vanilla income, it's a whole new ball-game if you think about other investment income.)
- lisivka 11y agoWikipedia agrees with me: Double taxation is the levying of tax by two or more jurisdictions on the same declared income (in the case of income taxes), asset (in the case of capital taxes), or financial transaction (in the case of sales taxes).
- Larrikin 11y agoOnly if you've been living there over a year. I made the mistake of moving abroad in January and had to pay all of the foreign taxes and all of the US taxes for basically an entire year.
- zschallz 11y agoThere's a large income exclusion that means unless you earn a really kick ass salary, you're unlikely to be double taxed.
- sremani 11y agotax is one part, but paperwork and penalties are the other scary part. I have only heard of it, how minute mistakes can end up with 50K fines etc. Probably some one who has gone through the filing taxes from overseas can give better insight.
- coredog64 11y agoUS citizen who worked in New Caledonia for 2+ years. The scariest part is that I don't have any official documentation for what I earned. I had access to our payroll system that records the amount I earned in the local payroll system -- I didn't generally have a need to convert that to USD every pay period and record it. I was paid "in kind" for housing. And at the end of it all I got an unofficial letter stating what that amount was.
- 55555 11y agoIt's true. There are two specific forms which have 10,000 USD late fees which can compound at least three times per year each. So doing your taxes late could cost dozens of thousands of dollars. These are specific to controlling CFCs, not applying for the FEIE though.
- codegeek 11y agoI agree that double taxation is crazy BUT lets add the fact that US will tax you ONLY if your worldwide income is over a certain threshold (believe it is $90,000 currently). Not that I am defending this but there is difference between saying that you are double taxed vs you are double taxed only for a certain portion of income
- kspaans 11y agoSee my sibling reply, it's _not_ double-taxation. If a US citizen works in a foreign country and happens to pay higher income taxes than they would in the US (e.g. in Canada), the US won't charge them any extra.
- drcoopster 11y agoBut it is. If I earn $120k in let's say the Netherlands, I pay NL taxes on all of it and US taxes on about $20k of it. I'm getting double-taxed on the amount over $100k. (Nice round numbers might not be accurate, but the idea is still there.)
- kspaans 11y agoThat's why you claim a foreign tax credit on those income taxes you paid in NL. If NL charges less income tax than you'd be charged in the US, then your tax credits will reduce your taxable income to, say, $20k like you mentioned. But this isn't double taxation because you are only be charged tax to top up the amount of tax you pay to be in line with US income taxes. This is exactly like state income taxes. It's not "double taxation" because you get to deduct your federal taxable income by the amount you pay in state income tax.
- arjie 11y agoHang on. If it reduces taxable income, that's not the same as topping up. You were right in the first part where you said it's a tax credit. But those subtract from your tax owed, not your taxable income, a difference that's important because it's a pretty large sum in dollars. Here's a simplified model to illustrate: Wlog, suppose the US charges a straight m rate per dollar, country X charges n. Suppose first k dollars of an expat are untaxed by the US. Let's say the expat makes j dollars, an equivalent US citizen in the US makes the same, and so too a citizen of X. The citizen of X is taxed nj by X, the US citizen resident in the US is taxed mj, and the expat would be charged (j-k-nj)×m by the US and nj by X for a total of m(j-k-nj) + nj if it were a deduction to taxable income. Notably if there's no fixed deduction, every tax rate causes you to pay more than otherwise.
- colechristensen 11y agoThe fist $100,000 income isn't taxed this way[1]. And it's not abhorrent. If you earned enough money to think it's advantageous to lose one of the most valuable passports in the world, you probably earned that money in large parts due to the support of the people and infrastructure of the United States. You don't get to drop your duties once you win big. [1] $97,600 for 2013, $99,200 for 2014 and $100,800 for 2015
- x5n1 11y agoEmpire costs money to build. Your money.
- lowpro 11y agoAmerican Imperialism at its finest. "Since we're the best country in the world, you couldn't have possibly become rich without us, and therefore you must pay to leave us!"
- colechristensen 11y agoGreatness aside, you probably couldn't have become rich without roads, national defense, clean water...
- ionised 11y agoThose things aren't exclusive to the US.
- colechristensen 11y agoYes, but if you earned your billion on the backs of US peoples and infrastructure, you have to pay a toll when you leave.
- sushid 11y agoBut what if you weren't even born in the US, much less have ever set foot in the US. Do you think it's fair to "pay a toll" when you're working in a foreign country?
- cr1895 11y ago>As an American making the same money as your non-american co-worker you are left with a lot less just for having a US passport. This is not quite so clear cut. Yes, as an American working and living abroad you've got the privelege of forever dealing with the IRS/FBAR, some banks who simply won't talk to you because you're American, and probably an expensive tax professional to sort it all out for you so you avoid the devastating penalties for screwing it up. But, most people won't actually be paying anything to the US government. I'm strongly opposed to taxation by citizenship, but let's not give the impression that everyone who lives abroad is paying twice.
- jaredklewis 11y agoWhile I agree, there are a lot of problems with the tax system for ex-pats, and I would love some reform being an ex-pat myself, it's not clear to me why citizens shouldn't be double taxed. Sure, for some things (national funding for roads, schools, etc...), ex-pats may receive no benefit. But 53% of US discretionary spending is military spending. In what way does the US military provide more service to resident citizens than ex-pats? Now to my mind, all this military spending doesn't help anyone and just causes a bunch of problems, but that's not how our democracy works. I don't get to opt out of paying for the war in Iraq just because I didn't support it. And what about programs like NASA, which I do support? They provide no less benefit to me than they do to resident citizens. Given that large portions of the budget (Military, Veteran's Benefits, International Services together make up 63% of discretionary spending) serve residents and ex-pats, it seems like the most logical thing would be for ex-pats to get a tax discount (which they do), not to pay no taxes at all.
- mattmcknight 11y agoTalking just about just "discretionary" spending is not an accurate way to talk about where our tax money goes.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> discretionary spending "Discretionary spending" is a term the left made up to lie about how much of the budget is things they want. Things they want are non-discretionary, other things are discretionary. It's political newspeak, not a comprehensible way to measure the government budget.
- caseydurfee 11y agoIncorrect, it has a perfectly precise legal meaning. Discretionary spending is government spending allocated through an appropriations bill. It's useful to distinguish between entitlement programs and non-entitlement programs. Where did you get the idea it was simply "political newspeak"? Perhaps you should reassess the value of your contributions to these types of discussions in light of your demonstrated ignorance here.
- rayiner 11y ago> And the US double taxes their citizens living abroad the same way. The tax code has provisions to avoid "double taxes" on foreign income. You file Form 1116 to claim credit for taxes you paid to a foreign country as an offset against your U.S. tax liability.[1] That tax credit is separate from the income exclusion, which excludes the first ~$100k of foreign income from U.S. taxation. Generally, your total tax liability will be your foreign liability on the first $100k, plus the greater of your U.S. liability or your foreign liability on the remainder. I don't see the big injustice, honestly. It's very similar to how state income taxes work in the U.S. where people are citizens of one state but work in another. [1] Corporations file Form 1118 to claim similar credits.
- iheartmemcache 11y ago(Meta-comment: Just jumping in here to voice my appreciation for you & @kspaans correcting a highly voted comment but very incorrect assertion, which is a dangerous combination because some people only read the first few comments and leave with that falsehood impressioned as fact. Responding with a factual source and doing so in a graceful manner (i.e. not disrespecting the poster, but gently correcting them) is what makes HN great. Meta-meta-comment: I've seen your posts for well over half a decade and you remark consistently with the quality of StravosK, patio11, grellas, pjmlp, et al. Never clicked on your profile but you're an engineer-turned-attorney, so that's from where the rigor and @grellas vibe originates. Anyways, thought I'd take the moment to say "hey, insightful stuff, keep it up.")
- davidw 11y agoIt's perhaps not a big injustice as far as these things go, but it is not fair either. I easily lost out on a thousand dollars of lost wages, accounting fees, and general hassle and stress doing my US taxes in Italy last year.
- cr1895 11y agoI think this is something that people who don't live abroad often have trouble grasping. "Well, you left so you don't get to complain"
- st3v3r 11y ago"And the US double taxes their citizens living abroad the same way." Except they don't. You have an exemption for foreign income. "It is even possible you have never set foot in the US yet are required to pay uncle sam's taxes." I don't believe this for a second. You would be a US Citizen, therefore you would have stepped foot in US territory.
- slyall 11y ago> "And the US double taxes their citizens living abroad the same way." > Except they don't. You have an exemption for foreign income. Because all the other 20 year olds working part-time at Starbucks employee the best accountant in town for a few hours per year to do their taxes. > "It is even possible you have never set foot in the US yet are required to pay uncle sam's taxes." > I don't believe this for a second. You would be a US Citizen, therefore you would have stepped foot in US territory. Ever hear of a guy called Ted Cruz?
- st3v3r 11y ago"Because all the other 20 year olds working part-time at Starbucks employee the best accountant in town for a few hours per year to do their taxes." Your inability to do your taxes is no one's problem but your own. "Ever hear of a guy called Ted Cruz?" You mean the guy who's going all over the country right now?
- slyall 11y agoThe point I mean with the kid working at Starbucks is that most wage earners will have a very simple tax requirements. In many countries they won't even need to send in a tax return since it'll be done automatically. If they are a US citizen on the other hand they will now need to employee a specialist tax accoutant to handle tax requirements from the US and put in their paperwork. All to determine they owe the US nothing. Ted Cruz was born in Canada. HE was a US citizen at the moment of his birth without having set foot in the US. If his family hadn't moved back to the US then he could have grown up in Canada as a US citizen and he would have had to file US taxes once he started making money. All without ever having set foot in the US.