11 ms·
The Loophole in the Hedonic Treadmill
- lisper 11y agoTL;DR: Use your money to buy experiences, not things.
- phreeza 11y agoThat part has been widely discussed. The second one was new to me: buy plastic surgery.
- lisper 11y agoI didn't notice the plastic surgery part. I think the article may not have completely loaded the first time.
- jmiserez 11y agoThe article only mentions surgery that directly improves ones looks. Surgery that improves functionality such as corrective eye surgery should also be considered, and the cost is far easier to justify. E.g. I have IOL implants to fix my eyesight and it's both useful on a daily basis and still very satisying even years later.
- phreeza 11y agoYes, also other things that improve your well-being/physique should be studied, like hiring a personal trainer (and getting in shape).
- redthrowaway 11y agoYeah, I got LASIK a year ago and it's probably the fourth-best large purchase I ever made, behind school, travel, and a motorcycle.
- J-dawg 11y agoIf you don't mind sharing, how was the surgery? You seem happy with the results, are there any downsides? Why did you choose IOLs over Lasik?
- cpfohl 11y agoDid a quick Google: IOL surgery is cataract repair if I understood what I read correctly. LASIK is repair for myopia. Not sure I used all the words correctly... Is there a word for myopia that includes reading distance too?
- J-dawg 11y agoI believe it can be both. In cataract surgery, the eye's lens is removed (because it has gone cloudy) and replaced with an implantable lens. IOLs can also be used in myopia. The implantable lens is placed in front of the natural lens to correct the near-sightedness, like a contact lens but INSIDE the eye. The natural lens is left intact so you don't lost the ability to focus close up (accommodation). There are also accommodating lens implants, which are pretty new. So a cataract patient can regain their ability to focus close up.
- cpfohl 11y agoSuper nifty!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- VLM 11y agoThe topic of looks was a major analysis mistake in the article. Given the example in the article of the woman who got plastic surgery, she doesn't get the dopamine hit the day of surgery and now mysteriously years later she's still happy, instead she gets the dopamine hit every time some guy pays attention to her or she gets someones attention, which might be as recently as today, therefore there's no mystery why she's still happy. Your situation is probably a long term / permanent memory of having vision problems combined with those problems being gone now. The article seems to imply no matter how poor you have been, you'll forget it eventually once you're rich enough, which I find unlikely.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoYou're making the incorrect assumption that women get plastic surgery so men will pay attention to them. Perhaps some do but many also get it for themselves.
- VLM 11y ago"Perhaps some do" Ah, we agree then, because a statistically relevant correlation never requires 100% participation. Or lack of 100% participation never disproves a correlation. Certainly ongoing peer / public recognition is a very significant difference between that example in the article of plastic surgery and the other example provided of buying a, now obsolete, original ipad. An analogous plastic surgery / body mod that can become obsolete over time is obscure, hard to think of, unlikely... maybe a tattoo with the name of a former S.O. Maybe fad piercings.
- nommm-nommm 11y ago"ongoing peer / public recognition" is not the same as "some guy pay[ing] attention to her."
- greggman 11y agoIf plastic surgery works it would seem fashion (which is things) would also work. Feeling like you look great is a good feeling, at least for me. And getting compliments on my look feels great too. Whether or not that equates to more or less happiness than spending that money on some other type of experience I have no idea
- nlh 11y agoI think the implication of the article is that pure fashion (i.e. clothes) tend to lead to adaption, and over time we feel less-happy about them. But plastic surgery seems to provide longer-lasting satisfaction (perhaps because in our heads, a change to our actual bodies is deeper and more satisfying than a new pair of shoes.)
- minikites 11y agoThe part about plastic surgery recipients is interesting and the article isn't that long, everyone interested should just read the article.
- lisper 11y agoI didn't notice the plastic surgery part. I think the article may not have completely loaded the first time.
- tonyedgecombe 11y agoI think that meme is a bit overdone, in particular by people trying to sell you "experiences".
- nommm-nommm 11y agoExperiences are often the simple things in life that costs very little.
- nitrogen 11y agoI usually value "things I can use to produce experiences" over "experiences". Seems to be working so far. Memories are fleeting, but things, tools, home improvements, etc. can last for years.
- prawn 11y agoI don't find memories to be fleeting. Shared experiences and reminiscing about them with friends and family bring me a lot more joy than almost all of the junk I'm surrounded by.
- drjesusphd 11y ago... or plastic surgery.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- J-dawg 11y agoI've increasingly tried to adopt the Mr. Money Mustache approach to this idea [0]: >> Slightly higher on the consumer thrills ladder is the new slogan of, “Don’t buy things, buy experiences! Travel! Take Cruises! Go to all the happy hours!” >> It’s a nice idea, and it does work to a certain degree: experiences are more memorable than things. After all, your favorite trip still glows warmly in your memory, even while that iPad2 you purchased just a few years ago is hopelessly outdated now and sitting in a storage bin under the shipping boxes from your iPad3 and iPad4. >> In the mainstream media, the analysis ends there. Spending on experiences is better than spending on stuff, so just spend all your money on experiences and you’re set. >> But there’s an even more satisfying thing you can do with money, which is rarely mentioned: not spending it. I don't make a lot of money, and I'm a long way from retiring early like MMM. However I've started to realise that the idea of being completely financially independent (if not 'retired', then at least able to live without working for long periods) is even more satisfying than the thought of exotic holidays. Of course, there's no right answer to this. If I'm hit by a bus tomorrow, I'm sure I'll be lying in the road wishing I'd taken that trip to California. [0] http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2014/04/14/how-to-make-money-buy-happiness/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2014/04/14/how-to-make-money-...
- jib 11y agoI don't think I would enjoy not working. Sure there is 20% crap or so, but 80% of the time I am doing moderately enjoyable things, or at least neutral things. I think that it is certainly true for some people that they would be happier retired early, and doing volunteer work or so, or working with random things (I think MMM does carpenting or something? On top of running a blog). I also think there are plenty of people for whom that is not true. I like knowing that I COULD quit. Actually quitting work wouldn't make me happier though, I think. Someone is actually giving me pretty good money for doing things that I enjoy. That seems better than not getting money for doing things that I enjoy, or getting low amounts of money from it. Sure, it does come with those crappy days when I truly dont enjoy what I do, but they are certainly less common than the days when things are nice.
- cpfohl 11y ago
- dilemma 11y agoMaybe that's what the article says, but I think it's far better to use your money to create things.
- Kiro 11y agoThat's a bad TL;DR considering most of the articles address a completely different loophole: plastic surgery.
- lqdc13 11y agoLots of contradictory stadies on this subject: Money buys happiness until you have $75,000 (the one they are citing): https://www.princeton.edu/~deaton/downloads/deaton_kahneman_high_income_improves_evaluation_August2010.pdf https://www.princeton.edu/~deaton/downloads/deaton_kahneman_... Money always buys happiness - no limit: http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2013/04/subjective%20well%20being%20income/subjective%20well%20being%20income.pdf http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2013/... However, it seems to not matter that much as money only explains 1.8% of the variance in subjective well being: http://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1010079728426 http://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1010079728426
- J-dawg 11y agoThe one I always find a little unsettling is the idea that relative wealth has a greater impact on happiness than absolute wealth. The inference that happiness is a zero-sum game doesn't sit well with me. In South American countries for example, it certainly seems to be true that middle class professionals have a pretty nice lifestyle partially as a result of inequality in society. (For example, it's pretty normal to have a live-in housekeeper to clean and cook for you)
- AlexandrB 11y ago> The one I always find a little unsettling is the idea that relative wealth has a greater impact on happiness than absolute wealth. The inference that happiness is a zero-sum game doesn't sit well with me. It's important to remember that this kind of finding describes a default or average psychological outlook of a population. There's no reason that an individual can't alter his own perception of the world and his place within it through meditation, psychotherapy, CBT, or some other means. Basically, relative wealth will affect your happiness if you allow yourself to believe that relative wealth is important. Capitalist society is built on this belief (it's foundational to aspirational advertising) but that doesn't make it true.
- vanderZwan 11y ago> The inference that happiness is a zero-sum game doesn't sit well with me. Note that that inference is limited to material wealth.
- JacobAldridge 11y agoReminds me also of the aphorism "The only things you will regret are the things you didn't do" (my emphasis). Those who decided to have plastic surgery are 'happier' than those who thought about it but decided not to go ahead. Would be interesting to see if a similar effect shows up in other large decisions - eg, people who decided not to buy a house v those who took on the debt; people who decided not to move overseas v those who took the plunge. In other words, this may have nothing to do with plastic surgery and may reflect a deeper underlying source of (un)happiness. Me personally, I have just one regret in life: that I didn't rob a bank when I had the chance. [EDIT TO ADD] When I was fifteen, I headed in to my local bank to withdraw some cash. Troublingly, my 'local' branch was close to where I was at boarding school, some 100 miles from the branch where my account was established - and it transpired that the signature on my account was still my mother. We'd not updated it since the account was opened nearly ten years earlier. Maybe they felt sorry for the poor boarding school kid with no money. I suspect I hammed that up a little. Because rather than referring me back to the original branch, the customer service representative headed out the back to see what she could do. For a LONG time. About fifteen minutes in to the wait, I leant over her desk and noticed, in among the paperclips, a 20 cent piece (this is Australia). I looked around - cameras, probably, but nobody watching. And so my brain starts ticking - surely I could casually reach out, grab that coin, and pocket it without being noticed. Surely she wouldn't notice on her return - if she even knew the 20c was there. It was a risk ... but for the rest of my life, I'd be able to tell people I robbed a bank! I probably spent another fifteen minutes pondering the decision. Which was too long - she returned, and the opportunity was lost. For what it's worth, I was able to withdraw funds legally. She'd had a great conversation with a teller at the originating branch, who it turned out knew my father (everybody does). Based on descriptions of my father, and comparisons to me, my rep felt confident I was indeed who I said I was and changed the signature on the account from my mother to myself. Now THAT'S a great customer service story as well. Or a tale of social engineering being the weakest link in any security plans. But for me, nearly twenty years later, it's just the story about the day I could've robbed a bank ... and didn't.
- J-dawg 11y agoI recently had some counselling, and one thing the therapist spent a long time talking about was self-agency. It was something of a revelation for me. I realised I had essentially been drifting along in life for a long time, allowing decisions to be made for me and avoiding conflict wherever possible. He described self-agency as like a muscle that needs to be exercised, even in small day-to-day ways. A sense of self-agency seems to be fundamental to good mental health. >> Me personally, I have just one regret in life: that I didn't rob a bank when I had the chance. Oh come on, you can't just leave that hanging there. Hope you can share the story without incriminating yourself! EDIT: Great story, and for what it's worth I think you probably made the right decision. It could easily have ended up being the story of how a bright kid had his prospects ruined over the theft of 20 cents, because of the bank's "we always prosecute" policy and an over-zealous legal system.
- hashkb 11y agoI think the most remarkable bit here is that the way we feel about how we look our is the strongest predictor of happiness and self esteem. I think money vs happiness is less interesting (and we've covered it on HN weekly) than pretty vs happiness. My 2c: duh. If you draw confidence and security just from looking at yourself, you have an advantage.
- noobie 11y agoI am debating whether I should subscribe for Nautilus or not, do Prime subscribers get access to contnet regular users do not?
- reddytowns 11y agoGood to know
- josinalvo 11y agoNope (as far as I can tell) http://nautil.us/primeuser http://nautil.us/primeuser But you get absolution from ad-blocking, and it is only 1-2 bucks a month (also, curious about people downvoting you... Why are you guys downvoting parent?)
- Swizec 11y agoBollocks. Nothing brings me as much happiness and bliss than looking at my bank account balance and seeing that I have 6 months worth of fuck you money. That no matter what happens, I can bankroll my life for 6 months before I have to fix the cashflow situation. Anyone who says money doesn't bring happiness has either never gone without, given up, or has so much that they can't conceivably spend it. Experiences are great. So is plastic surgery. If you can afford them.
- pdpi 11y agoCan't recall the source, but there was an article here a long while ago that basically said that basically unhappiness is not just negative happiness, it's a separate metric altogether, and that your overall mood is the combination of your happiness and unhappiness. Under that model, money is rarely good at buying happiness, but it's great at getting rid of unhappiness. Not sure how you'd describe it, but the "fuck you money" fund to me is more about peace of mind and not feeling pressured into stuff I don't want to do than it is something that makes me actively happy.
- agumonkey 11y agoI wanted to say something similar. Money can relieve from one kind of pain, the substrate (shelter, heat, food) not the existential pain (passion, love, independence, etc etc). Now the question, is it better to have one without the other.
- rpgmaker 11y ago> Nothing brings me as much happiness and bliss than looking at my bank account balance and seeing that I have 6 months worth of fuck you money. How about having 2 years of fuck you money? You missed the point of the article. It's not that money doesn't make you "happy", just that there are other things you can buy with money that give you more lasting happiness.
- Swizec 11y ago> just that there are other things you can buy with money that give you more lasting happiness. That makes sense. But I wouldn't prioritize having those experiences above having money. If having an amazing experience put me under my comfort level with money-in-bank, then on the mid-term, they'd make me pretty unhappy. On the very long term, I might remember them as great. Or I might remember them as dumb because I wasted money and opportunity cost. But it's possible that I am permanently biased because I grew up with a very everpresent lack of money.
- nxzero 11y agoGenerally speaking, use of this model is useful, but it has limits within the bonds of a given person's reality; both real and constructed. The real loop whole is the realization that life is uncertain and happiness is a construct that's self defined, which is to say, if you're happy, you're happy.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- empressplay 11y agoSide projects also improve happiness once you have enough money to buy a cart-full of groceries without thinking about it. Writing, coding, performance -- it's all good!
- return0 11y agoI would like to emphasize that. Building something that some people find useful is satisfying and motivational.
- frankus 11y agoI would expand that to helping people in general. There's definitely a diminishing marginal utility effect to income once you get to a certain point, but you can sidestep that by using your resources to help someone who's on a much steeper part of that curve.
- barrkel 11y agoBuy a motorcycle. It's a thing, but it gives you experiences.
- danparsonson 11y agoAmen to that! I think you've hit on an important nuance there - buying things in the pursuit of experiences: good, buying things strictly for their own sake: not so good. As long as the pleasure of owning the thing is secondary to the pleasure of using the thing, then all is well :-)
- RyanMcGreal 11y agoBuy a bicycle. It's a thing, but it costs a lot less, is a lot cleaner and safer, and still gives you experiences.
- maehwasu 11y agoI've done both a lot, and there's no way you can compare riding a bike to going 250mpg on a motorcycle. Of course, like many awesomely fun things, it's quite dangerous, which is why I won't start riding again until I'm 55 or so.
- brianwawok 11y agoEver go 50 MPH down a hill on a bicycle in TT position? If all you want is scary, I think this would meet your needs ;)
- frgewut 11y agoHe was talking about mpg (miles per gallon). He seems to be a hypermiler.
- collyw 11y agoI am sure downhill mountain biking is both safer and more exciting than riding a motorbike fast on a fairly flat piece of road.
- ljw1001 11y agoThe idea that you can buy happiness is the great fairy tale of capitalism. Of course, other things equal, you are better off with more money. The problem is that if you choose to maximize income, other things aren't equal anymore. Sure, more and better experiences can make you happier, but do you have to pay a lot for them for that to be true? Searching for loopholes is not going to be as fruitful in the long run as choosing to play a different game.
- marcofloriano 11y agoI don't think everything is a fairy tale. Lots of our true happiness comes from basic things like security, eating well, education and good heath. In the current system, money can grantee you most of that. An advanced capitalist country probably offers a good system for individuals to work and get those very important things. Without them, there's no happiness. But, off course, we want more, much more. And after a certain point, it does start look like a fairy tale.
- geodel 11y agoWell that's the point of hedonic treadmill that one has to keep earning more-spending more cycle going to be happy.
- Artistry121 11y agoCapitalism is not the idea that you buy happiness. It's the idea that you freely trade with others to get items you need. It creates abundance - even overabundance for some - and then one can choose what level of consumption they want. Less buying = higher savings = more capital or leisure time so capitalism can actually encourage savings.
- llamataboot 11y agoCapitalism as a philosophical idea of free trade is far different than how corporate capitalism has actually looked in practice though. Not only in terms of power and information disparities and massive externalities making a mockery of the idea of "pure capitalism" (much as crushing and brutal authoritarianism made a mockery of "pure Communism") but also because advertising is a mind control weapon. I know its popular for smart people to think that advertising doesn't affect them but I can assure you that it is VERY hard to choose what level of consumption you want to live it while you are swimming in a sea of advertisements designed to make you feel unconsciously dissatisfied with what you have. The only experiment I could think of to counter this would be to live mostly off the grid or deep in an "undeveloped" country for a year or two and watch how your consciousness shifts. Otherwise it is like the fish that is looking for the water.
- amelius 11y agoSpeaking about physical changes to the self, there are probably lots of loopholes still to be discovered by the neurosciences, perhaps even on a molecular/chemical level.
- scotch_drinker 11y agoAnother loophole is to always treasure what you have. I bought a 2009 Hyundai Santa Fe in 2009 because I really enjoyed the car I test drove. I still drive that car today with 135K miles on it. At least once a week, when I get in, I try to think "I really like this car." Even though it's now 7 years old, starting to get creaky and long ago lost the new car smell, I try to remember what it was like to really enjoy the car. By doing this regularly, I have been able to prevent some of the effects of hedonic accustomization. Reading Stoic philosophy helps too. A Guide to the Good Life is a good place to start.
- jpsierens 11y agoYeah, I agree with you that you can get joy out of old material possessions such as your car, I do so myself. But I wonder if you're applying the Stoic philosophy in the correct way? I also read a part of the book so when you say you try to think "I really like this car", shouldn't the thought be "Boy imagine I'd lose this car today, or maybe it gets robbed, I better enjoy it before that happens" instead? At least that's what I got out of the book, to excercise "negative visualization regularly.
- cooperpellaton 11y agoI think you're most certainly right that the negative visualization is a central part of Stoic philosophy as it's applicable today but I don't think you're example is correct in this scenario. Instead, in this case, I think it's appropriate to not drive the car and/or to remember that no matter how old the car is, it is still far-far better than the worst possible reality such as that where the OP doesn't own a car, or has one in significantly worse shape. I like to practice this own philosophy in my life to remind myself that no matter how frustrated I am with my possessions or with my work that I could be in a much worse place than I am currently. It also helps, a lot, to be a minimalist because it makes you all that much more appreciative of the few things you have (especially when you own good ones!).
- scotch_drinker 11y agoI also apply negative visualization but people don't like to hear about that. :-) I try to do without things, I fast regularly to know what hunger is about (plus it's probably good for me) and at least mentally think about what it would be like to have nothing.
- s3arch 11y agoI feel people who work on to fill the void of their inner core, will always tend to stay happy. Here subjects who carried a void of low self esteem, by changing their looks coupled with how they viewed themselves and the world later on, had a powerful effect. The same could be achieved if you had a good bank balance, and spent it on the matters, which yields good experiences, and in turn changes the way you view yourself and the world. Most of the time, it requires you to stay humble. But usually people don't prefer this. :)
- mark_l_watson 11y agoI enjoyed the article right up to the end, when it started to sound like an infomercial for plastic surgery. I believe that the foundations of happiness are simple: truly love many people, feel gratitude for life, and enjoy experiences like travel.
- josinalvo 11y agoBelieve what you will. This is SCIENCE! :P ---- Just joking, but I find the result somewhat intuitive. I've seen first hand how many people (esp. woman - this my anecdote, don't read too much into it) see their value through beauty. So I think the research reflects a statistical reality - even if it does not apply to you.
- petra 11y agoWe also know that media experiences(movies/games/music) are less susceptible to the hedonic treadmill than objects. But i'm curious, how close does virtual reality(VR) experiences get to real-life experiences on that aspect?
- chadgeidel 11y agoAs a data point, I enjoy driving cars on the racetrack. I'm not a professional - just an enthusiast. Simulations are getting better and better but IMHO still not as good as "the real thing". The highest-level sims (with motion controls) are pretty good. I think this is the best comparison today (~$50K simrig vs $25k car): https://youtu.be/hzAIVzAMNg0 https://youtu.be/hzAIVzAMNg0 There's the added benefit of not worrying about crashing a $500K race car. :-D [Edit] The simulation upgrade cycle is its own hedonic treadmill though - gamepad > wheel > full wheel/pedal/seat setup > 3 monitors > VR > motion rig > ???
- petra 11y agoThat's a great example. But what's missing ? just the feeling you're at real risk(you say it's a benefit, but it might be an appeal of real driving) ? or something more ? And with regards to remembering the experience, reliving it in your imagination later , do you feel any difference between real/sim ?
- sokoloff 11y agoCan't answer for racing sims, but can for airplane/airline sims. I've done some simulator training (many things are too dangerous to practice in actual airplanes) and I believe I can recall the circumstances of every single crash during sim rides. Every single one, even ones from 15 years ago. I can't recall the details of every single successful sim ride, but neither can I recall the details from every single "real" flight either. Fortunately, my fourth box (crashes of real airplanes) is empty.
- chadgeidel 11y agoI think the "missing element" probably is risk - even though I never personally feel like I'm in danger. The real, tractable elements that are difficult to simulate are G-forces, the "inertia" of the car throwing you around, the "wind in hair", and sounds/smells. Surprisingly - car simulators really "phone it in" with the sounds. In terms of remembering the experience - I have much fonder memories of my slow laptimes and small improvements on a trackday than "relatively quick" laptimes on a simulated track. I've thought about it a LOT (as I've recently had to sell my fun car) and I can't say there's one element that I can put my finger on.