24 ms·
The Rise of Renting in the U.S
- ck2 11y agoThink of renting as "housing as a service". Ha. Except for one problem, landlords. Most are not good people. Would rather be my own landlord.
- hkmurakami 11y agoidk, I'd give most the benefit of the doubt that they are "good people", but may not necessarily show that side to you the tenant for a variety of reasons, such as fear and greed, especially when they are dealing with an asset that represents a large portion of their net worth. Good people can behave poorly.
- derekp7 11y agoYou also have landlords that hold a large number of units (often times a corporate entity, with management outsourced), then you have individuals who are renting out their old house after they moved (either because they can't sell for what they owe, or other reasons). And often times the people renting behave pretty bad (not intentionally, but there is often more than the "normal" wear and tear).
- jonesb6 11y agoAlso you never talk to your landlord for good things. It's almost entirely for bad things like late rent, etc.
- kylec 11y agoI don't own, but if I did I'd love a "landlord as a service" where I could just call or email someone about a problem and have them fix it.
- brianwawok 11y agoPlenty of handymen out there, I suspect you could find one who would be happy to take care of anything. Don't really need an app for it, just call a few and ask around..
- Avshalom 11y agoThis I think is important because I sure as hell have never rented anywhere where a landlord was some one to call if you needed to fix a problem.
- jdmichal 11y agoWhere I live, if the landlord doesn't fix the problem within a reasonable amount of time, you can fix it yourself and deduct the repairs from your rent payment. You should educate yourself on your local laws surrounding rentals if you haven't already; there are likely similar terms where you live.
- Avshalom 11y agoand then what lose more money taking time off work to go to court when the landlord tries to evict you for not paying rent in full?
- jdmichal 11y agoYou would resolve it the same as any other contract dispute. If resolution fails, then you go to the courts. If they sue first, you counter-sue and tack on malicious prosecution as well.
- Vraxx 11y agoThey won't try to evict you assuming you're abiding by your local renting laws, because I'd bet they've read them as well considering it's part of their job. A lot of landlords will take advantage of the fact that tenants often are not aware of these rules to get away with not abiding by them, but if you demonstrate that you know the laws they aren't going to mess around when you can sue them in small claims court and win handily. Not to mention, oftentimes if you do suffer some opportunity cost as a result of their actions, that cost can be included in the damages.
- herbst 11y agoMost are business oriented people. I never met anyone particulary not nice.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoRenters are by far worse than landlords. As long as we're generalizing.
- tomg 11y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calculator.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calc...
- sosuke 11y agoI love it, but it doesn't include the rent being raised every year like clockwork. Right now it's $1500, next year $1575 etc
- theseatoms 11y agoBuy a basket of REITs (with geographic exposures of your choosing) to hedge against changes in land value.
- erhrsdjsdrjtrj 11y agoIt does. "Rent growth rate" is an option.
- dsp1234 11y agoThe option to change the rental growth rate is located under the section titled "What Does the Future Hold?" with a title of "rent growth rate" and a default value of 2.5% (with a range of -5% to 15%)
- rayiner 11y agoI don't think I'd have any interest in every buying a house if it weren't for the insane tax deductions for mortgage interest. Why be stuck in one house when your living situation changes over time (new kids, kids get bigger, kids move away, job changes).
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThe tax deduction is baked into the price.
- rayiner 11y agoMaybe, maybe not: http://taxvox.taxpolicycenter.org/2013/06/05/what-changes-in-the-mortgage-deduction-would-mean-for-home-prices http://taxvox.taxpolicycenter.org/2013/06/05/what-changes-in.... This article estimates that eliminating the mortgage interest deduction would reduce home prices by ~12%. But if you're in the highest tax bracket, the tax benefit from deducting mortgage interest is around a 28% reduction in your effective payment. So at least at first, you'd lose more to the elimination of the deduction than you would gain in reduced payments.
- sokoloff 11y agoThere's also a phase out in deductibility of mortgage interest at some income level, so it's not at all linear.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> This article estimates that eliminating the mortgage interest deduction would reduce home prices by ~12%. But if you're in the highest tax bracket, the tax benefit from deducting mortgage interest is around a 28% reduction in your effective payment. You're assuming that the average impact on home prices is the same as the impact on prices of homes bought by people irrespective of income. People of different incomes tend to buy different kinds of homes (or the same kinds of homes in different locations), so one would expect that removing (or adding) a subsidy that is income sensitive would have differential impacts on the homes typically bought by different income levels, not consistent impacts across all homes.
- ErikAugust 11y agoHas anyone released a halfway-decent 'Rate My Landlord' site? Asking for a friend.
- leesalminen 11y agoI haven't, but I think it would be very useful here in Boulder, CO where landlords are acting quite cocky.
- steve-howard 11y agoThey'd need to address the powerful incentive to create fake reviews.
- AndrewUnmuted 11y agoWhile true, I think the bigger issue is that no landlord would, in their right mind, agree to be represented on a website that is almost certainly going to contain nothing but negative reviews. If one stops to ponder what would make an individual want to rate their landlord on a "RateMyLandlord" kind of site, then the answer is pretty simple: hatred. The biggest reason for people to write such a review is to complain. Usually, the complaints people write stem from issues related to their inability / lack of desire to pay their rent on time. Landlords hate not getting paid. Especially in major cities, where regulations basically annihilate their ability to operate in an honest and competitive way without significant impact on their financials. Getting their monthly rent on time is really the only way they can turn any kind of profit on their business. My income is higher than it has to be for the place I rent here in Brooklyn. But I get charged far below market rents. Why? Because I pay my rent every month on time without hassle. Because I don't wreck my apartment, don't need many repairs, and don't bother my neighbors. So even though I could afford to pay the market rate, I am a 'good' tenant, so I pay the so-called "preferential" rent, which is almost $400 per month cheaper than the rent cap instituted by NYC's horrid rent control laws. That's right. My landlord could actually charge me more, but he doesn't, because I'm not a shithead. What am I supposed to write in my RateMyLandlord review? That I am a good tenant and get charged lower rent than everyone else? There goes all of my reward for being a decent person. I don't see any way for such a site to work without damaging reputations or ruining nice arrangements tenants already have with their landlords.
- chishaku 11y agoWhy are mortgage debtors referred to as home owners? Edit: I was being a bit facetious. With liar loans, no down payment mortgages, deferred interest, "prices only go up," etc, it's been too easy to sell home "ownership" to people without their requisite understanding of the risks involved and the constantly changing market realities. I'm all for personal responsibility but the use of language is powerful.
- brianwawok 11y agoWhy are people getting closer to death every day called living instead of dying?
- recursive 11y agoThey're doing both. It's not a contradiction, like between "owning" and "not owning".
- brianwawok 11y agoExcept in the example above they are doing both. They both "Own "but not "Fully Own" their house. They are "Partial Owners".
- dragonwriter 11y agoBecause the (home) mortgage debt is a liability assumed against a home that the debtor owns (either to fund purchase of the home or afterwards), and therefore being a home owner is a necessary (but not sufficient, as one can own a home free and clear of mortgage debt) condition to being a (home) mortgage debtor.
- jdmichal 11y agoExactly. Mortgages work differently than, say, car loans. Car loans typically have the bank listed on the title until the loan is satisfied, then the title is rewritten to be in the buyer's name. This is why a car can be repossessed without a court order; the bank is quite literally the owner and you only have the right to use the car. A mortgage, on the other hand, is only secured by the property. The buyer is the owner, period; pulling up my house in the county property records shows my name. This is why banks must go through the courts in a foreclosure process in order to take ownership of the property, and cannot simply repossess it.
- api 11y agoAs a side effect of historically cheap money, house prices have risen so high that entire younger generations are locked out of home ownership in quite a few areas. There are a few outliers but in general it's good jobs, affordable housing, pick one.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> As a side effect of historically cheap money, house prices have risen so high that entire younger generations are locked out of home ownership in quite a few areas. If it is a side effect of cheap money, how is it pricing people out of the market? The rising sticker price of the property should be offset by the lower price of money which is driving it, so that the actual total real cost of the purchase (including the financing cost) is the same. Only if something other than the general price of money (an increasing spread between the price of money for favored debtors and disfavored ones, presumably including the young people priced out of the market) is driving real estate prices should someone be priced out of the market.
- randomgyatwork 11y agoI live in Toronto, 10 years ago a house in the suburbs may have been affordable for someone like me, now they are hugely over priced. I could make a 5% downpayment and have a mortgage till the day I die, but that doesn't seem reasonable to me. Maybe rational buyers have been priced out of the market?
- dragonwriter 11y agoI'm not saying that people aren't priced out of the market, I'm saying that decreases to the general price of money cannot explain people being priced out of the market. > I could make a 5% downpayment and have a mortgage till the day I die, but that doesn't seem reasonable to me. Right, but if the only price increase was attributable to the lower price of money, you'd have a mortgage just as long and with just as much burden now as before the decrease in the price of money -- you'd just pay a higher nominal purchase price on the house, and lower interest and fees associated with the loan. If, instead, you've been priced out of the market, that means something other than a general decrease in the price of money is involved, because the increase in the prices is out of line with the decrease in the price you would pay for financing. If it is cheaper money driving the price, its money that has gotten cheaper for some other class of potential buyers than it has for you.
- prostoalex 11y agoFinancing for real estate projects dried up after 2008, and single-family construction is not an industry that can deliver overnight when demand has risen. For more analytical view of the real estate market, check out UBS' report (which is bullish) http://files.ctctcdn.com/f0054e99301/0f155366-4016-4c0f-ade0-8fbc6a479acf.pdf http://files.ctctcdn.com/f0054e99301/0f155366-4016-4c0f-ade0... Looking at current buy-vs-rent ratios is not very useful, as we don't have much insight into the reasons for renting. Some prefer personal mobility that comes with renting, but some are just waiting on more affordable/accessible/convenient ownership options to pop up, and will be buying in a few years.
- kilbuz 11y agoThe statistic that went most against my intuition is that San Francisco has the one of the lowest 'rent burdens' in the US. That is, rent as a percentage of income is on the low end and equivalent with many Midwestern cities. I'm guessing that the typical SF renter paying 25% of income on rent may be dealing with a lot less space (and more roommates) compared to someone in Pittsburgh or Minneapolis.
- alexchantavy 11y agoThe lower burden might also be because SF incomes are a lot higher than in the Midwest.
- eldavido 11y agoThis is true, but I wonder why. Are SF employees simply that much more productive than elsewhere? (Serious question, it might be that for certain types of work, you really do need the talent base here, but a company is certainly paying a premium for it these days.)
- onlyrealcuzzo 11y agoYes, they're some of the most educated people in the world.
- acchow 11y agoIncomes in SF are much higher.
- entee 11y agoI think it's also that SF has fairly high income inequality, which means that their statistics for rental burden a prone to being misleading.
- rconti 11y agoWhich means you're able to put a simply massive amount of money away if you so desire. I notice in many of these kinds of comment threads, people talk about dropping out of the rat race and getting rid of their "luxury townhome" and luxury cars and so on. Orrrr you could just participate in the rat race in a much more modest and realistic way.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoThe article doesn't really touch on two very key facts. 1 - When I grew up in the 90's all I heard from my rich business owners were to buy real estate. The value always goes up and its a good investment. This isn't true anymore with the crash and younger people don't see real estate as a worthwhile, long term investment. As such, they're not looking at paying for something for so long and not getting anything out of it. Same thing for the "equity" part of this argument. Those same business owners pounded into my head the idea that my money when I was paying rent wasn't going towards anything and I would never have any value in a rental like I would a house or town home that I owned. 2 - The transient nature of the younger generations. When I was growing up, your life arc was pretty well established. Go to college, get a nice job in your career field, get married, buy a house, have some kids. This just isn't the same plan most younger kids have. My nephew is 21 and has been "couch surfing" for years. He has no aspiration to get married, or buy a house. He pretty much lives day-to-day and gets by with help from his friends. His friends are the same way. They change apartments about every 6 months. Different parts of the city, in order to get closer to where the "action" is they say. With a far more transient, younger population, it makes sense their not going to buy houses and settle down. We've spent decades talking about how we want to have everything available wherever we are, we WANT to be a mobile society and culture. This younger generation has simply taken it to its logical conclusion. No need for a house when I can just crash with my homies. No need for a tv, house, car since we've developed an entire culture to handle that and give it you on your phone, tablet, laptop wherever you are. Car? We have Uber and Lyft. No house? We have AirBNB, This makes sense on a bunch of different levels tbh.
- 2muchcoffeeman 11y agoAre leases so short there that they can just move every few months?
- at-fates-hands 11y agoCloser to 6 months, but yes. They put an ad on craigslist or some of the other smaller publications like the kind you see at bars. They pool their money, get a small ad that talks about taking over a lease near some hip part of town. My nephew said within a week or so they're flooded with responses, They work out the paperwork with the landlord and they're on to the next place.
- drawkbox 11y agoThe American Dream is looking more like a middle level marketing organization with false advertising for most. The problem is we just keep stripping away the middle class and lower class consumer power[1][2] and the solution is getting wages up to fix these issues. People wonder what happens in a consumer driven economy after stagnant wages since 2001, well this. It leads to Great Recessions, a sideways investment market and a few generations worse off with the US heading in the wrong direction. The country has been Enron'd and drained of cash. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/01/25/upshot/shrinking-middle-class.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/01/25/upshot/shrinki... [2] http://money.cnn.com/2015/12/09/news/economy/middle-class/ http://money.cnn.com/2015/12/09/news/economy/middle-class/ EDIT: Multi-level marketing, was caught up on middle class, thanks for correction.
- sokoloff 11y agoMLM is multi level marketing, not middle.
- mineshaftgap 11y agoThe middle class is shrinking, but not because they are moving down but moving up, but that doesn't fit the doom narrative that whiney millenials love.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoIt's been more correctly Bained. See what happened to Guitar Center for details. Enron was a real company doing real work. Bain, not so much. Sure, the traders at Enron were completely out of control and the management team was out to lunch, but please remember that MCI was even part of Enron. But YEP! drained of cash and loaded up with debt. The small details don't really matter than much.
- ecnal 11y agoThose articles (and the data behind them) suggest the opposite of your point: the middle class is shrinking, yes, but it's shrinking because incomes are increasing and people who were previously in the middle class are moving into the upper class.
- agentgt 11y agoMy wife and I bought a 2-family (we live in the other unit) a couple of years ago and so many people told us how it was a bad idea. People said we would have horrible tenets and that finding renters would be hard and that selling rental property is a nightmare. Eight years later and I can tell you it was one of the smarter investments I have made. Had wonderful tenets. And after some refi magic the house is not far from being paid off.
- bluedino 11y agoI'd have to save up almost a years pre-tax salary to buy a home. Well, one that I would want. I could save up half a years pre-tax salary and buy my not-ideal house. Nice/modern home, good location/schools, or large size. It seems like you can only pick 2 without spending a ton of $. Until then, I rent.
- cpursley 11y agoWow, in my area you can almost buy a (albeit - modest) home outright on a years mid+ level tech salary.
- leetNightshade 11y agoWhere do you live and what kind of salary are you talking about?
- cpursley 11y agoAtlanta area. Average Ruby web dev salary for region and experience level. You can buy a McMansion (if that's your thing) for less than the price of a closet in the worst parts of the Bay Area. Poke around on zillow.com.
- leetNightshade 11y agoI don't live in the Bay Area, but I live in L.A.. Cost of living wise it feels like I do. I can't believe how much money goes to rent, and paying for lots of gas for commuting. The urban sprawl with lack of a good efficient means of public transportation, is pretty disgusting.
- cylinder 11y agoDo you think it used to be different? You buy a starter home, and move your way up. Why do you expect young people to immediately be able to buy their perfect dream home?
- lowglow 11y agoI've sorta turned my back on the standard american dream. Racing to new areas of growth, working to build someone else's dream, getting paid well immediately for performance, paying high rent, etc to afford the image of success, and making friends that participate in this same high ambition culture. Instead of making markets, markets start making you. All the rules, and "norms" we've collected around ourselves to participate are just foolish. I ended up just buying and crashing in a van, exiting that mode of being, and am much happier because of it. Now I get to save money, research and build what I want when I want, and generally am very much less stressed. I'm no longer beholden to a landlord, or feel like I must participate in activities that just serve to entertain but not enlighten. I can spend the day at the beach just reading if I wish. You start to look at time as something that you can control again, and you start seeing how much life truly is a gift, and that life itself should be nurtured and cherished. There is also a sense of independence and DIY that comes along with the lifestyle that feels like I'm leveling up in good ways. Will this mode change for me? Sure. Change is inevitable. But for now I've found more peace and focus than I have in a long time. I'm now able to concentrate on longer stretches of time that hold bigger ideas, and then asking myself how I might use that time to start refocusing my energy making new markets.
- seivan 11y agoHow does it work with having a companion. It might be easier to find someone with the same outlook. But if you're already in a relationship it's going to be an uphill battle.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI might be able to answer that. My wife and I are early 30s. I spent my 20s in the rat race, working 60-80 hour weeks for material possesions (nice vehicle, luxury townhouse, etc). At some point, I got tired of it and said, "Can we try something different?" I switched to a fully remote job. We disposed of the townhouse (no equity in it). We downsized our lives (1 car! I ride a bicycle everywhere! You would not imaging how much better shape I'm in) and began to live more frugally with a short-term plan of moving onto a sailboat and living on the ocean for a few years. We save 50%+ of my income (we live in a low cost of living area), we should be able to retire comfortably around age 45. We'll be moving onto our sailboat in the next few months, learning to sail together, and then starting a long circumnavigation around the world (~5 years). My wife didn't require any convincing. More quality time together for getting rid of things we shouldn't have cared about in the first place? It was an easy sell. If anything, she sold me. Rule 1: Pick the right partner.
- cryoshon 11y agoJust one more symptom of runaway economic inequality... The consumer has less and less real ownership/power. In good areas, the landlords have realized that year over year rent increases won't prevent units from being rented... and so, people are drained further unless they want to move away from where the jobs are.
- jpmattia 11y agoI'm a little surprised that there hasn't been a populist rebellion over interest rates. Low rates have inflated pretty much every asset class. This is especially so in housing: The Fed needed to reinflate housing prices in order to make many systemically important players (banks, AIG) solvent again. I have to wonder though: In re-inflating house prices, have we just off-loaded the bad investment to non-systemic institutions? ie, avg people?
- mwsherman 11y agoYes. It’s opposite of what one would do to make housing affordable. Unaffordable housing, especially in cities, is a huge and regressive drag on the economy.
- jseliger 11y agoUnaffordable housing, especially in cities, is a huge and regressive drag on the economy. Housing is unaffordable primarily due to parochial land-use restrictions, as Matt Yglesias explains in The Rent Is Too Damn High (http://www.amazon.com/TheRent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957 http://www.amazon.com/TheRent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp...) and I explain here: http://jakeseliger.com/2015/09/24/do-millennials-have-a-future-in-seattle-do-millennials-have-a-future-in-any-superstar-cities/ http://jakeseliger.com/2015/09/24/do-millennials-have-a-futu.... If we want cheaper housing, all we have to do is legalizing the building of it.
- switch007 11y agoSorry, my eyes are tired so I didn't read your post, but there's a 3,000+ house development happening in my town — a HUGE development for the area — and the starting prices are $600,000, in a country where the average salary is $39,750 (the region's average is $43,000). There are similar developments of 100s of houses, which equally ridiculous prices. I only see the existing house prices going up, not down.
- maxsilver 11y ago
- kazinator 11y agoThis article is full of "no kidding" like, oh: > In fact, metros with greater shares of renters have higher wages, higher productivity (measured as economic output per capita), and greater concentrations of high-tech firms, according to Mellander’s basic correlation analysis. People are attracted to where the jobs are, and so everything gets bought up and inflated, and the late comers have to rent. In related news, you never see rental apartment buildings among rural grain elevators. Gee, why is that? Correlation analysis? Yeah, we wouldn't want to jump to any premature conclusions like that the jobs and presence of industry leads to renting; there is a glimmer of hope that we might be able to prove that renting actually causes higher wages, higher productivity and the presence of high-tech. It could be that people come to the city just for the privilege of participating in expensive rent. Then when their bank accounts drain dangerously low, they realize they need high wages, and so they create companies and give themselves salaries. Fact is that renting is not some way of the future or a shift. Even if 99% of the people rent, it will be because they have to, and all will continue to foster the dream of owning a home, and continue to envy the squirrels in the park that de facto own their own space in the hollow tree, or the birds that have their own nest, and don't pay a fucking thing to anyone.
- awakeasleep 11y agoProperty taxes should basically kill the dream of "and don't pay a fucking thing to anyone" for anyone that lives in the US. Especially city dwellers. I was surprised to see tax for properties I could technically afford cost more per year than I had been paying in rent.
- ap3 11y agoYes. Because renters don't pay property taxes /s
- AjithAntony 11y agoOf course they do. It's part of the rent. edit: oh that was saarcasm
- 11y ago
- shmerl 11y agoWith prices soaring into crazy heights, buying simply becomes harder and harder. The problem is - renting is becoming harder as well!
- Gratsby 11y agoA decade ago, I lived in an area where people lost houses left and right. One neighborhood had a 50% foreclosure rate. Those people all lost whatever equity they had and home prices have gone up significantly since. Of course more people are renting. If they have managed to save the down payment required, they have to question whether they could really afford that property again. Most haven't because rents are higher than their mortgages used to be. Who can save $100K+ in that situation? And if they could, where is that $500K house that you can buy with 20% down? Probably not in the same area where you have a job that allows you to save $100k. The government is propping up the banks which are propping up the housing market. We'll see a little pop in the next 24 months, but it will be a quick one because it will release some of the hold backs that are in place today.
- Animats 11y agoCheerleading for higher house prices used to be widespread, and was a big part of the problem. It's inflation, people. It's still the same house, for more money. The median house historically costs about 2.2x the median income. That number hit 4x nationally in 2007, and 10x in California. It's not that high this time, but it's still very high by historical standards.[1] San Francisco hit 10.5x in 2007, and now it's around 9x. In the 1950s, rent in NYC was typically 10% of income. It may be time to look at applying antitrust laws to rental real estate. Where there are a small number of large landlords, that's likely to push rents up. This is more of a small-city problem than a big-city one; the biggest commercial landlord in NYC has 5% of the rentable commercial space.[2] There are medium-sized cities with one or two big landlords. [1] http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2015/11/daily-chart-0 http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2015/11/daily-c... [2] https://commercialobserver.com/2015/04/nycs-top-10-biggest-landlords/ https://commercialobserver.com/2015/04/nycs-top-10-biggest-l...
- rhapsodic 11y ago> It may be time to look at applying antitrust laws to rental real estate. Or better yet, look at repealing or modifying the laws that keep the supply of housing from rising along with the demand.
- billions 11y agoThis is the better solution. California charges $160,000 in taxes per home before it's built. Not to mention extremely restrictive zoning laws.
- enjo 11y agoZoning laws are actually by and large a relatively modern idea, with the oldest zoning regulations in America in place for only 100 years, with the aggressive zoning codes we have in place today generally only stretching back to the 70's and 80's. Aggressive zoning, by my estimation, is a bad influence on housing costs. It's restrictive (by it's nature) and generally serves one and only one purpose : keeping neighborhoods from becoming more dense. As our population continues to grow people have to live somewhere, and we have to recognize that the only way to organize our cities for that growth involves density levels that are in many cases double or even triple what they are today. Until then housing costs will continue to soar.
- d4rkph1b3r 11y ago> In broad strokes, this makes them good for the poor and bad for the rich The stupidity in this comment hurts my soul. Let me ask you this, out of the poor and the rich, which one is more heavily leveraged into assets (using debt).
- hueving 11y agoPoor, because poor people are the only ones to be entirely in debt. Also everyone with a good income that has huge student loans. I think you've become very disconnected from what the lower middle class is like if you think high interest will help them. The average savings account in the US is well under 10k.
- d4rkph1b3r 11y agoOk, I guess we're doing this. I'll explain the basics of money to start. Money is a representation of your buying power relative to everyone else. So if everyone's money doubled, no one got richer. It's only when the percentage of buying power changes that anyone is really more or less poor relative to before. Ok, back to the argument... >Poor, because poor people are the only ones to be entirely in debt. Wrong answer. You missed the part where I said leveraged into assets. If you are 50,000 in debt, and I have 50,000 in cash, if the amount of money doubled out there... I'm the same amount rich, but you're less poor than you were! So if that was the end of the story, you'd be right. Poor people get helped out more than the rich. But that's not the end of the story... Now, let's say that 50k in cash went towards the down payment on a house worth 250k (20%). Again, to make it easier, we're imagining the amount of money out there doubles. Guess what? My asset just went up to 500k. I was leveraged into the growth. I just made out like a bandit. Are you less poor? Yes, but relative to all of us who bought houses, you just got fucked. (Because of inflation).
- hueving 11y ago>Ok, I guess we're doing this. I'll explain the basics of money to start. Don't behave like a child. It doesn't add anything to your argument. Also, you seem to be confused about the difference between interest rates and inflation. The value of money being cut in half is what's referred to as 'inflation' and it's not what is being discussed.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoTo anyone who noticed one of the cities with high rates of homeownership, that can work remote, withstand rough winters, and accept that their football team will never win the Super Bowl, MOVE TO BUFFALO! Buffalo used to be a very wealthy city. It was the first American city with widespread electricity (thanks, Niagara Falls!), and because it's had some hard times, you can literally buy a mansion at (relatively) bargain prices and rent it out to half a dozen people, and you still get to keep the master bed and bath for yourself. And there's the added bonus of living in a proud, blue collar city, where people care about who you are, and not what you're paid.
- toast_coder 11y agoI think this articular is giving off some bad interpretations. First and foremost this guy's data all starts at 2006. Well, do a quick GIS for a chart on home ownership in America. 2006 was basically the peak for at least the past 40 years, and probably longer than that. Drawing conclusions about how America is changing based on changing home ownership since a huge bubble which peaked when he started calculating his data is downright poor science.
- jkyle 11y agoRent is a tax on the poor by the rich.
- Mikeb85 11y agoNot a big surprise. Whether or not people want to admit it, economists like Piketty, and many others (even Marx) have predicted this. And the trend isn't going to stop. The future is looking more and more like Elysium than Star Trek...
- GirlProgrammer 11y agoWhy is owning a house the "American Dream" in the first place? Why should our primary investments be houses?
- lkrubner 11y agoThe ratio of median wage to median rent peaked in 1958 at 22% (or rather, 4.54). That was also the peak of the Baby Boom. Which makes sense, really, because the ratio of wage to rent is one of the fundamental determinants of male sexuality, especially back then, when it was less common for women to work. It was much easier for an 18 year old to afford their own apartment and start their own family. People often point out that the median male wage in the USA has been declining since 1973, but what is rarely pointed out is that for men under the age of 25, its been falling since 1958. The loss of high paying low skill jobs means the only high paying jobs are high skill jobs. That has forced two adjustments on us: one, people start their adult lives later than they used to, and two, some people never get there, as they never acquire the skills to get there.
- jensen123 11y agoI find it interesting that many people look at governments differently than they look at say grocery stores or auto mechanics. If a grocery store or auto mechanic is charging too much or providing poor service, I would go to another one. Why don't people do that with governments? Obviously, because they're kinda "stuck". Moving can be a serious pain in the rear. So how to make moving easier? If you're renting a home, then it's certainly easier to move than if you're owning. However, it's still a major pain if you own a lot of physical stuff. But as far as I can tell, owning lots of physical stuff is becoming less and less necessary. You no longer need a huge amount of music records, paper books, VHS movies, billiard table, pinball machine etc., since you can fit all those things into a tiny computer. Also, online shopping makes finding/buying any item easy, so keeping things just in case you might need them someday makes less sense now than it used to. I currently own a home, but I'm tempted to become a renter.
- ontheinternets 11y agoWhat is the correct ownership rate? and why do we care about the change from 2006? The data from 1956 to the present makes this whole article kid of boring. https://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/histtabs.html https://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/histtabs.html