7 ms·
Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for clean transportation
- dmfdmf 11y agoThis isn't a tax on oil companies it is a tax on everyone.
- refurb 11y agoExactly. The oil companies will just pass that tax right along.
- Dylan16807 11y agoFor the sake of comparison, do you feel that oil companies pass along the current tax breaks they get?
- adventured 11y agoOil companies pay extremely high tax rates compared to the small tax breaks they get. And in fact, most of the tax breaks they get are made up of routine corporate deductions that all corporations qualify for and aren't special to the industry: https://www.aei.org/publication/the-truth-about-all-those-subsidies-for-big-oil/ https://www.aei.org/publication/the-truth-about-all-those-su... Exxon and Chevron, as two examples, have been paying essentially the highest corporate tax rates on earth for a long time.
- megablast 11y agoGood. As they are supposed to. How do you imagine this is supposed to work, if not making gas more expensive?
- eggy 11y agoThe price of the oil drums costs more than the price of oil per drum, although they are reused. A tax on oil will certainly be passed on to the consumer. If the end game is to discourage oil use, not to keep the planet clean, it still will not work. Look at the high price of tobacco even in the face of the risk to health issues. People will continue to use oil in the same quantities unless the price goes up by an order of magnitude. The government wins both ways: higher tax revenue, or they can claim they saved the planet.
- ams6110 11y agoYou do realize that wholesale oil is not literally packaged in individual drums? "Barrel" is a unit of measure.
- jedrek 11y agoExcept that smoking rates have dropped to one third of their 1965 levels. If this tax gets those kinds of results, I think the pro alternative energy community would be ecstatic
- jbooth 11y ago1) That's half-true. Or 60% or 40% true. Econ 101 says some % comes out of profits, some % comes out as higher prices. 2) Externalities. Also Econ 101. We've got a basket of reasons, from environmentalism to national security, to limit our dependence on oil. Kicking in taxes while the prices are low can prevent markets from forgetting all the things they started to build in during $120/barrel oil, continuing to limit our future dependence, with the bonus that we now have a relief valve we can ease up on if things get really tough with oil prices. It's actually the most market-based way to attack the myriad problems the oil economy creates for us.
- randyrand 11y agoIn a perfectly competitive market corporate profits are zero and it all comes out of the consumer. Now oil is not perfectly competitive and you are right. But it is rather close. So you can still expect the majority to come from the consumer.
- gohrt 11y agoIf oil is close to perfectly competitive, how does OPEC control prices by adjusting supply?
- morgante 11y ago> In a perfectly competitive market corporate profits are zero and it all comes out of the consumer. No, the determinant of tax incidence is price elasticity, which is orthogonal to competitiveness of a market. [1] Oil is interesting because it is somewhat price inelastic both for demand and supply. People's ability to stop driving is limited in the medium term, but also many suppliers of oil aren't capable of completely exiting the oil business. In practice, I suspect the incidence is in fact roughly 50/50 if applied in a huge country like the United States (the incidence would be much on consumers in smaller markets). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence
- jessriedel 11y agoNo, you're missing the part where corporate profits are zero in a perfectly competitive market. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition#Profit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition#Profit If corporations always operate at revenues=expenditures, then the entire tax must fall on the buyer in the long run. The price inelasticities you're talking about are only in the short run.
- matwood 11y agoBut it sounds better as a tax on those evil corporations.
- donatj 11y agoYep, economy is finally getting back on track because the gas price is becoming reasonable again, and now they want to do this. The price of gas affects everything. The more expensive it is to ship things, the more expensive everything is. Simple economics.
- stepanhruda 11y agoIt's a tax based on the elasticity of the demand and supply. The demand for oil is hardly inelastic (people definitely buy less gas if it's more expensive). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence
- dlg 11y agoIn the economics world, tax incidence is a matter of serious study. There has been a decent amount of work on who actually pays oil taxes. Hal Varian (who later became Chief Economist at Google) wrote a good piece[1] summarizing the basics in 2000 for the New York Times. The summary: "A gasoline tax in a small country falls mostly on the residents of that country. The world price of oil is essentially independent of the taxing policies of most countries, since most countries consume only a small fraction of the amount of oil sold. "But the United States consumes a lot of oil -- almost a quarter of the world's production. That means it has considerable market power: its tax policies have a major impact on the world price of oil, and economic analysis suggests that in the long run, a significant part of a gasoline tax increase would end up being paid by the producers of oil, not the consumers." [1] http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~hal/people/hal/NYTimes/2000-10-19.html http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~hal/people/hal/NYTimes/2...
- rokhayakebe 11y agoEvery single tax is ultimately a tax on workers and consumers.
- AndyMcConachie 11y agoGas should be more expensive in the USA. Sounds like a good idea.
- donatj 11y agoThe price of gas is linked to the price of everything through shipping and transport. The lower the price of gas, the stronger your buying power. There's no upside to a high price of gasoline.
- tptacek 11y agoExcept for decreased usage of gasoline and thus a decrease in the externalities of using gasoline.
- sosuke 11y agoNo one stopped buying gas at $4 a gallon but they did stop spending money elsewhere to make up for it.
- raldi 11y agoThat's not true! I specifically remember reading, back when gas broke $4 a gallon, that we had finally discovered the price at which drivers change their habits. Below $4, rising prices just made them complain. But above that price, we started seeing statistically-significant changes in demand.
- sosuke 11y agoI think you're right there is a tipping point. I do feel that there is a flex point where drivers change recreational driving but they will still need to get to work and the grocery store. They won't go on fun trips though.
- Sanddancer 11y agoVehicle miles driven went down during that time period. Additionally, there was an increase in the sale of more efficient vehicles, so people indeed did buy less gas.
- douche 11y agoYep. Let's implement possibly the most regressive tax possible on working-class people. Because every penny of that tax is going to come out of our pockets at the pump or at the grocery store.
- randyrand 11y agoIsn't that a flat tax? And definitely not regressive if you assume rich people buy more gas.
- GigabyteCoin 11y agoRich people may buy more gas, but gas eats up a considerably larger portion of the poor's wallets.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- SeoxyS 11y agoI think it's regressive because people with less income spend a larger proportion of their income on gas. I disagree with him; for the record. Just trying to see his viewpoint. Personally—I think this tax is a great idea. I think the government has two jobs: (1) to build and maintain effective infrastructure for the common good (roads, firefighters, etc.), and (2) to apply pressure to rectify forces where the tragedy of the commons would otherwise apply (global warming, etc.). This is an example of the latter.
- oh_sigh 11y agoOil is 31 USD/bbl now. It was 41 USD/bbl in Jan 2015. Would you notice the difference?
- douche 11y agoFor somebody who is closer to the edge, that bump in fuel prices is going to trickle into everything they consume, and when the transit costs of the product are a bigger proportion of the total cost of the item, that's got real impact on their buying power. Plus, it's never just gasoline that goes up. Gasoline, you could just cut back on non-essential miles. But gas goes up, and heating oil follows - and you can't stop paying the oil bill when it's 0 F outside, unless you want to freeze yourself, and your plumbing. Then your electricity rates go up because the fuel oil for the oil-burning plants that backstop your eco-friendly, weather-dependent renewable electric energy when the sun isn't shining and the wind's not blowing, goes up. And you can bet your bippy that once they jack the tax up, it won't come back down easily. Seems like a stupid move when the Saudis are trying to hurt our domestic oil production in a price war.
- randyrand 11y agoAt what point is our ROI on clean energy negative?
- paulsutter 11y agoOil just dropped in price by more than $70 a barrel, a $10 tax isn't going to cause economic trouble. It's the perfect time to enact a carbon tax, even if it is limited to oil. This will boost the ROI of new energy technology and open up more private investment dollars. One way to get bipartisan support may be to put the tax on imported (not domestic) oil.
- danieltillett 11y agoIsn't the USA basically an net exporter these days? If congress can't increase the gas tax to support the highways how are they ever going to support something like a tax on oil to support clean transport?
- paulsutter 11y agoNew energy technology will benefit from an increased price of oil. Freeing up private investment dollars is the key. As for the government, considering the deficits I don't imagine such a tax would really free up much budget. Whether such a law can be passed is an entirely separate question from whether it's a good idea. And it is a good idea.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes it is a good idea - a better one would be to stop subsiding fossil fuels. Neither have much chance of getting through congress.
- greeneggs 11y agoIn 2014, the US imported 9 million barrels of petroleum per day, and exported 4 million barrels per day. Net imports accounted for 27% of US petroleum consumption. [1] While that is from 2014, this table suggests that imports didn't change significantly, up or down, in 2015 through November [2]. [1] http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=727&t=6 http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=727&t=6 [2] https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=pet&s=mcrimus2&f=m https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=pet&s=m...
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThis'll go over like a lead ballon - now oil companies are not only feeling pressure from clean energy; they're being asked to actually pay for it?
- wtallis 11y agoAre you decrying a lack of sympathy for oil companies in a measure that has the ultimate goal of killing them? Or just pointing out that oil companies will be opposed to anything that threatens them, be it natural market pressure or regulators?
- nostrademons 11y agoIt's a "fuck you" to the oil industry, but the oil industry isn't exactly filled with Obama supporters anyway, and besides, he's never seeking election again. It'd be pretty hard to get it through Congress, but it could potentially work, given that both the tech & financial industries have made some pretty big investments in renewable energy and their power is rising while the oil industry's power is declining.
- adventured 11y agoIt would in fact be impossible to get through the Republican Congress presently. Not an exaggeration, it will not happen under any scenario so long as the Senate and House are both Republican held. This is nothing but a political stunt on the part of Obama, he gets to say that the effort was made and it appeals to the base.
- danieltillett 11y agoWhat is point of Obama at this point proposing anything unless it can be implement by executive order. Congress won't pass anything he suggests.
- Raphael 11y agoI would guess that Biden wrote this bill and wanted to propose it one last time.
- ghouse 11y agoCan we just institute a revenue-neutral carbon tax ($15-35/ton) and let the market figure out the solutions?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zardo 11y agoTry running for office on that platform.
- bkjelden 11y agoMy biggest reservation with oil/gas taxes is that consumption taxes tend to be very regressive. Car ownership is already a tremendous burden for the poor in the US that isn't present in other countries - in all but a handful of US cities a car is pretty much required to hold down a job. So while I like the idea of raising money for clean energy, I would be more supportive of a policy where the burden isn't disproportionately shouldered by the poor.
- hackerboos 11y agoWhen I read about sales taxes and arbitrary taxes on commodities I think just like you have said. If he wants a tax that doesn't hit consumers he should just raise federal corporate taxes. In fact, removing subsidies would be a good start.
- mozumder 11y agoA tax on consumers is fine if it's used to guide people away from consumption of that product. We do that for Tobacco, for example. The less oil the world uses, the better.
- hackerboos 11y agoYou don't need cigarettes. You do need energy.
- ant6n 11y agooil !=== energy
- marcoperaza 11y agoCorporate tax is a political sham, a sleight of hand by politicians to make taxes more palatable to voters. There is no such thing as a tax on corporations that's not a tax on people. Corporate income is either paid out as salaries or dividends, or spent on purchasing goods from other firms (so eventually only dividends and salaries). Taxing corporations means reducing salaries and reducing dividends. The corporate tax also benefits big firms with overseas offices and armies of tax accountants and lawyers, at the expense of small and medium sized businesses that can't afford to play the tax avoidance game. We should eliminate the corporate tax. Make it revenue neutral with equivalent small bumps in the income tax. But it actually doesn't generate much revenue to begin with, more evidence that it's not worth the trouble.
- tommoor 11y agoI wonder if you could just place a tax on premium gas, the type that fancy cars take - so that it minimises any potential affect on low-income households.
- Sanddancer 11y agoThat would be counterproductive. A lot of the more efficient engines require premium too because they use the higher compression to get decent performance out of a smaller package. So it would end up discouraging people to get more environmentally friendly engines.
- gnarbarian 11y agoholy shit. that's a 30% tax at current prices. We have recently seen 110/barrel so consumers could easily deal with it. But given the elasticity of demand for something like oil, this will negatively affect the oil glut recovery by slowing demand. Speaking as an Alaskan where our entire economy is driven by oil, our government is running a HUGE multi billion dollar defecit due to revenue shortfalls stemming from oil prices. We would like to see increased demand for oil to burn through the supply glut quickly to get prices back to at least $70 per barrel. Regardless of Obama's plan it's going to take years and years to get back there if ever. The real issue is our state government can't afford to operate without levying any new taxes on the general population. The cost of living here is already astronomically high, plus we've been in a recession since 2012, and a tax like this is not going to help our situation at all. give it a few years and alaska may look like a ghost town. The fact that I am a programmer who works on federal stuff, my position is not really in jeopardy but the majority of my friends are engineers who depend on oil and gas. Worst case scenario I can take a remote job and probably get a raise for doing so. Maybe then I'll be able to afford a house up here haha. Bottom line is the USA now produces as much oil as Saudi Arabia (albeit with more than double the operating costs). We are much larger than they are and far more diversified, so as a nation we are able to withstand this sort of thing but if you examine places like Texas, Alaska, North Dakota, Oklahoma etc this oil price situation is going to financially destroy hundreds of thousands of people and dramatically affect millions of us. Gas prices also are somewhat less elastic when sliding left on the supply demand graph. so even though prices are 1/4 what they were, we're only seeing gas prices at 1/2 the rate they were. This means there is not as much of a benefit to consumers as you would think from these prices. Worth it? who knows. No matter what alaska is in a world of shit.
- mozumder 11y agoYah Alaska really needs to figure out an economy that's not based on selling things they find in the ground. They need to learn from California and New York and other places where people have figures out how to make money off of ideas. You need smart people for that, though.
- douche 11y ago