9 ms·
Silicon Valley's Soft Landing
- api 11y agoEquity crowdfunding is now "live," or getting there. This will bring more money in at the seed stage. I wonder how this will affect the larger ecosystem? Seems like we might see a shift away from a few "unicorns" to an ecosystem with more smaller to medium sized companies trying more things. That's probably good, and is probably more likely to produce more Googles and Facebooks than betting the entire farm on a few dozen over-inflated ventures. Of course the future is also likely to be more geographically diverse. Silicon Valley might no longer just be in Silicon Valley. That's also a good thing.
- randycupertino 11y ago" Silicon Valley might no longer just be in Silicon Valley. That's also a good thing." Maybe we'll no longer have to pay $3000/mo for a 1br.
- azinman2 11y agoIf only. i think it's actually higher Than that.
- Apocryphon 11y agoA Turkish coworker told me, upon receiving representatives of a tech incubator from Istanbul: "In 2000, everyone wanted to be in Silicon Valley. Today, everyone wants to be Silicon Valley." That's not true yet, not by a long shot, but I hope we get there soon.
- axis967 11y agoI do not. People who do not work in tech are being priced out of the area left and right. I'd like to see more startups sprout up in places like Austin, Chicago or better yet Charlotte. Better yet, start a company with remote working being the default from day 1 - makes recruiting the right talent much more straight-forward.
- codesushi42 11y agoAs much as I'd like it to work, there's really no replacement for working with colleagues face-to-face. And that's not likely to change. But maybe the hubs can. Perhaps SV can pass the torch to Seattle? ducks
- DarthMader 11y agoPersonally think a decent chunk of SV is not worth emulating. Hoping to see a new city blaze their own trail w/o the drawbacks of SV (gentrification, 0 work-life balance, ratio of men/women, same people talking about the same topics (e.g. "oh you work in tech, too?! How unique")
- phamilton 11y agoI'm always intrigued when I hear about 0 work-life balance in SV. Maybe I've gotten lucky, but I've worked at a small startup (first 10 hires), a medium sized startup (150 people), and a big tech company (10k people) and at all of them I was able to be home by 6pm every day, even with an hour commute, to spend evenings with my family.
- hueving 11y agoThe work life balance thing seems to be a made up justification to not be in the valley by people who live outside of it.
- Apocryphon 11y agoThat's what the quote means, though. He saying, that people from many cities are trying to build their own version of Silicon Valley there, with local startup environments.
- timr 11y agoThere's an elephant in the room: nobody really knows how many valley companies exist solely because of revenues that are diversions of this river of money. Startup-servicing startups. Hosting. Metrics. Food delivery. Recruiting. Hell...there are hundreds (if not thousands) of companies just doing advertising services, alone. Everyone fixates on the unicorns that are doing big revenue numbers, but the regional effects of those redwoods are tiny in comparison to the "robust ecosystem" of mushrooms that grows in their shadow. I often wonder how much of Facebook's revenue (for example) consists of valley startups trying to micro-target indifferent consumers. Pretty much any time I look into a VC-funded consumer company, I find that they're spending money on Facebook ads, Google ads, mobile ads...you name it. When that money dries up, the "ecosystem" of ad services takes a huge hit. I'm sure there are consumer companies that have organic growth, but it's hard to tell when there's so much money sloshing around. One King's Lane, for example...they were buying ads like crazy. At their peak, they had big, unicorn-y revenue. They're probably going to sell for a fraction of their total investment, and have never been profitable [1]. Meanwhile, the theoretical market cap of all current private-market unicorns ($300-$500Bn, depending on the source) is something like 10-20x the market cap of every IPO issued in 2015 (~$30Bn) [2]. It's pretty clear that the economic status of San Francisco is at least correlated to the huge influx of VC money since 2012, and that a lot of the resulting value is creative storytelling. I don't see why people are so confident in a soft landing if that same money goes away. [1] http://recode.net/2016/01/06/one-kings-lane-once-valued-at-900-million-is-likely-to-sell-for-fraction-of-that/ http://recode.net/2016/01/06/one-kings-lane-once-valued-at-9... [2] http://wolfstreet.com/2015/12/22/ipo-window-suddenly-closes-worst-year-since-2009-worst-december-since-2008/ http://wolfstreet.com/2015/12/22/ipo-window-suddenly-closes-...
- w1ntermute 11y ago> Hell...there are hundreds (if not thousands) of companies just doing advertising services, alone. http://idlewords.com/2015/11/the_advertising_bubble.htm http://idlewords.com/2015/11/the_advertising_bubble.htm > I often wonder how much of Facebook's revenue (for example) consists of valley startups trying to micro-target indifferent consumers. During the dot-com boom, a large fraction of Yahoo's revenue was coming from startups, who were using their VC money to pay exorbitant amounts for partnerships with Yahoo. You can guess what happened at Yahoo when the party ended in 2000 and the money men went back to NYC.
- tymekpavel 11y agoThe infographic and analysis are slightly misleading. If you look at the YoY analysis, funding is basically flat. One could argue that Q2/Q3 2015 were outliers and that while investment didn't grow in 2015, it didn't shrink either.
- jusben1369 11y agoGood technology is a terrible company to inject into this conversation. They've been around for a decade or more and were always an also ran in their space. They hardly match the desired narrative that the NYTimes, or anyone else wants to use, of a 3 - 5 year rocketship/unicorn who is suddenly engulfed in flames. When I first saw that article a couple of weeks back I was like "What? That company was still even around?" And why would the author assume, based on one quarter worth of data, that any sort of landing of any kind has occurred? Surely you'd want to let the change of direction play out a little longer before making any type of claims about whether there's a meaningful change and at what speed it's happening.
- nazca 11y agoHow much did Uber raise in Q3 and Q4? Seems like it would be material to the trend over the past few quarters, and is at this point a different animal.
- Animats 11y agoThe value of a company is the present value of future dividends. Investors, collectively, will not do better than that. However, it may be possible to find investors who will overpay for an overvalued company and lose money. The "unicorn" business requires a large supply of such suckers. "It is in the nature of markets to move money from the many to the few."
- avn2109 11y agoGoogled that quote and can't find a source; who is it?
- rasz_pl 11y agosounds like Karl Marx
- Nihilartikel 11y agoJust because his economic theories tend to have historically been executed exceedingly poorly by mendacious totalitarian thugs doesn't mean that he couldn't have actually been correct about a thing or two, here and there.
- Animats 11y agoAs a general comment, Marx wrote in a period when 1) productivity was much lower and the big problem was still making enough stuff, and 2) most labor was direct labor, so there was a direct relationship between labor inputs and product outputs. Neither of those apply to the developed world today. Many of the developed world's economic problems come from the fact that we no longer need many people to make the stuff and provide the services. US employment in manufacturing, mining, construction, and agriculture is now about 14% of the US workforce. In Marx's day, 80-90%. Marx wrote in an era when capital for enterprises was hard to accumulate. Now we have a capital glut, but a demand shortage. Economic policy-making hasn't caught up to this yet.
- 11y ago
- carsongross 11y agoThe whistling past the graveyard is hilarious. We are going into a 2008-style financial crisis, with the Fed already zero bound and China heading into a deflationary collapse. The banks, at least, have better balance sheets on paper this time around, but the carnage is going to be breathtaking. How many cycles of "things are amazing -> a new, permanent plateau -> I see no evidence of a bubble -> soft landing for sure -> no one could have seen this coming" do we have to go through, folks?
- oldmanjay 11y agoWhat's nice about doomsaying is when you're wrong no one cares and when you're right that one time, you get that useless fleeting feeling of self-satisfaction
- ra1n85 11y agoIs it really doomsaying when it's occurring at somewhat regular intervals? 1990, 2000, 2007...
- oldmanjay 11y agoYes. The human tendency to find patterns where none exist makes the whole thing feel more compelling than it is
- adventured 11y agoThere is an obvious pattern. The Fed is intentionally inflating asset bubbles to fake economic recoveries. Those asset bubbles inevitably must implode because they're not supported by fundamentals (such as the extremely slow GDP growth the prior six years). They did it in response to the 2001 recession, and they did it again in response to the 2009 recession. They openly admitted they were attempting to inflate assets this time around.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoThe business cycle is a thing. Everyone knows the business cycle is a thing. Half the people on Hacker News have been calling bubble for the past 2-3 years. The business cycle remains a thing.
- code4tee 11y agoI don't think we will see a .com bubble style 'crash' but it seems increasingly certain that the screws are going to get turned on startups that can't sustain themselves without constant injections of cash from investors. There is a knock on effect too in where the risks aren't entirely understood. For example think about mobile/web analytics companies. Tons of their revenue comes from other unprofitable companies that are propped up by VC cash. Even if the web analytics company is doing well in their own right there is a huge hidden risk with the business model of such companies since a big chunk of their revenue comes startups propped up elsewhere with VC cash and that cash is about about to start drying up really quickly. In other words a lot of companies that think they are doing well are in reality just also propped up with VC cash indirectly. In short, the tide is going out and we're about to see who's been swimming naked.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoThink of the role that an "Advance Man" played for traveling circuses in days gone by...they were on the road keeping a couple of towns ahead of the circus' itinerary and drummed up interest with posters, flyers, and sales puffing, so that the circus would be profitable once it arrived... Spending VC money on "advertising", or attempting to generate the same "buzz" for free on social media probably amounts to about the same thing... Is the "circus" (startup) being advertised to investors the "real deal"...ah, the risk of the bet...will it scale, or will it fail...? It seems that the savvy are becoming a bit wary of relying on the hype of an Advance Man (advertising)...when marketing is required to establish a product as opposed to the product establishing itself, through proven utility, the ground is certainly shaky...
- hkmurakami 11y agoNow that I think about it, it feels a bit "off" to me that we refer to both behemoth, money printing companies like GOOG and AAPL and smaller, money hemorrhaging, ultra-growth phase Series A and B companies as "Silicon Valley" in the press. They're really whole different worlds, perhaps best separated as private vs public companies, and it's strange that we haven't clearly made a verbal distinction between the two.
- sangnoir 11y agoI suspect the VC ecosystem encourages/condones the lumping of mature, money-earners with the money-burners as "Silicone Valley". It serves them (and founders) well/if in people's minds, startups are nascent Googles and Apples
- codesushi42 11y agoThis article basically reads: "What, me worry?" It's way too early in the impending downturn to draw conclusions like this.
- peter303 11y agoA friend just got laid off at Twitter after a few months there. I thought he was a top tier programmer. I heard they released a fair amount of office space too.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kspaans 11y agoRegardless of your friend's skill, it's possible he simply didn't have enough seniority-capital to dodge the axe. Juniors, as in newer-hires, are sometimes the first ones cut during a lay-off.
- headgasket 11y agoThis thread has justified the time wasted on hn. I had recently felt the signal to noise has been dropping consistently here; The smarts catalyzed here justifies keeping HN in my list. The signal is still strong. I feel an awakening. Cheers! PS: that idlewords blogpost linked by w1ntermute http://idlewords.com/2015/11/the_advertising_bubble.htm http://idlewords.com/2015/11/the_advertising_bubble.htm is exactly what I've been thinking for years now, great blog too.
- headgasket 11y agoThis thread has justified the time wasted on hn. I had recently felt the signal to noise had been dropping consistently here; The smarts catalyzed here justifies keeping HN in my list. The signal is still strong. Cheers! PS: that idlewords blogpost linked by w1ntermute http://idlewords.com/2015/11/the_advertising_bubble.htm http://idlewords.com/2015/11/the_advertising_bubble.htm is exactly what I've been thinking for years now, great blog too.
- kimberleyhansen 11y agoTo give just one example, on-demand ride startup Lyft recently sold a batch of stock that increased the company's implied value to $5.5 billion. The amount is eye-popping for a not quite 4-year-old company that is spending far more money that it generates, and reported a relatively slim $47 million in revenue for the first six months of 2015, my colleagues Eric Newcomer and Alex Barinka have reported. To show how outlandish Lyft’s valuation is, consider that on a roughly similar basis Apple would have a stock market value of more than $12 trillion, about two-thirds of the annual gross domestic product of the U.S. Can someone ELI5 what a "roughly similar basis" might be? How did they arrive at this number?