15 ms·
Fuck the Cloud (2009)
- cballard 11y agoThis seems unnecessarily angry. I suppose that this person wants to keep his data forever, but many people just don't care that much about their social media photos and the like. I'd love it if Facebook and Twitter had a rolling deletion period option - everything more than six months old is shredded forever, as far as the service is concerned. While people can obviously store shared photos and this wouldn't actually destroy them, I'd like that new contacts wouldn't be able to go back and look through someone's entire history. It's like a more social and longer-lived Snapchat.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> I suppose that this person wants to keep his data forever, but many people just don't care that much about their social media photos and the like. "This person" is Jason Scott, who works as the Internet Archive and also heads up Archive Team (the loose band of internet folks who race to archive sites about to go dark). He's a digital historian; his job is to save everything he can. https://twitter.com/textfiles https://twitter.com/textfiles https://archive.org/about/bios.php https://archive.org/about/bios.php http://archiveteam.org/index.php?title=Main_Page http://archiveteam.org/index.php?title=Main_Page
- mc32 11y agoThis seems to be more of a philosophical stance than an argument based on outcomes. It's also a call to think before knee-jerking "the cloud". And I do see the philosophical argument it has merit. But it does lack a business argument [for service consuming businesses] which will win out in most cases. In other words, in real world usage, the cloud is more dependable and flexible than internal IT infrastructure providers, for most businesses. That said, there is a good philosophical argument against the cloud.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> This seems to be more of a philosophical stance than an argument based on outcomes. I agree, but its fundamentally simple: Always be in control of your own data, because no one else is going to be looking out for it.
- skwirl 11y agoThis article doesn't really stand on its own; it comes across as a rambling diatribe by someone who is out of touch. If you have to know who the author of an article is to be persuaded by the argument given then it isn't very good. There are much better articles expressing this point of view.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoRespectfully disagree, although I appreciate the reply.
- coldtea 11y ago>This article doesn't really stand on its own; it comes across as a rambling diatribe by someone who is out of touch. Remember that next time you're red with rage because a cloud provider lost your data or a service you depended on is now bought/closed/gone.
- skwirl 11y agoMy point was more on the quality of the article. The article's point is a valid one, if you can find it. To constructively disagree, though: I keep backups. I have a Synology NAS device that I really like. But for your average person, I have to wonder - are their digital photos really safer on their laptop than they are on Facebook? Facebook is a fairly stable company. Laptops are lost, stolen, and damaged all the time. Files are accidentally deleted. People get viruses. People forget the password to their full drive encryption. When Facebook does bite the dust, it's hard to imagine that data just disappearing - it's incredibly valuable, and in the worst case, someone would buy it just to sell it back to people. Not ideal, but it isn't lost, and you had free storage for several years anyway.
- Domenic_S 11y agoThink about the future too though. Facebook strips exif and may have resized/recompressed your images. 20 years from now when we can do more super cool things with that data, the data won't exist in your FB photos. Tangentially related, this is why I shoot RAW. Not because it might give me better pictures today, but because it WILL give me better pictures in 5-10-20 years. You can take a RAW today that was shot 5 years ago and pull detail that was impossible to pull when it was shot, and that ability will only improve.
- bismark 11y ago> I'd love it if Facebook and Twitter had a rolling deletion period option - everything more than six months old is shredded forever, as far as the service is concerned. I really like this idea. The biggest benefit is that it stops people expecting these services to act like an archive. With the current system it's easy to think "Oh I can just look this photo up again on Facebook if I want to". Instead we should be treating these services as publishing platforms while we maintain separate archival versions of our data.
- mc32 11y agoOr alternatively roll them into inaccessible private space after X amount of time determined by user.
- rmc 11y agoAn approach of "delete all personal data over X days old" would actually solve a lot of those companies' data protection issues. It would also make them less likely to be hacked, since they would be less tempting targets. Why try to hack some celebrity's chat app if you know all nudie pics are deleted after X days?
- sbov 11y agoIn many ways the cloud is one step forward, two steps back. I look forward to the day when I can use my phone as my "cloud".
- swampthinker 11y agoJason's follow up post to this: http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/4352 http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/4352
- wanderingstan 11y agotl;dr Renting remote computational power is cool (AWS), but renting remote storage is not. I have a complete history of email archives since I started using gmail (ie cloud), but have lost years of archives from the years I managed email myself. It turns out that companies focused on data storage and retrieval do a better job than me. And that's fine. I pay someone to do my taxes and I don't build my own furniture. Specialization is a good thing.
- bingofuel 11y agoThe tax accountant analogy goes pretty well with this: The accountant is specialized in doing your taxes (aka serving up your data/files) but you still need to keep a copy of your tax records, receipts, and etc.
- derefr 11y agoAnd so, ideally, I want to be able to tell my accountant to store my archival tax records in my safe-deposit box, not in his office. Compute infrastructure is a commodity—doesn't matter who's paying for it—but all the services you depend on should rely on storage infrastructure you have an SLA agreement with. I don't care about the "distributed computation" promises of Diaspora or Sandstorm.io; I think they're wrongheaded. Anyone can do compute. But I really do hope that one day that my Facebook account can be canonically "stored on" a database instance I'm paying for, that Facebook's app servers will reach out and connect to and treat as the canonical source for "me", treating their own records as a secondary cache. This kind of setup would makes all sorts of things simpler and clearer and more secure; there would be a definite boundary where "my data" stops (the DB I own) and "Facebook's data" starts (the DBs they own.) And, to be clear, I'm not talking about everybody running their own infrastructure, or even everybody knowing what an IaaS provider is. Ideally, PaaS providers could get into the "consumer instances" game the way Dropbox is in the "consumer files" game. My "Facebook account database" above could be transparently launched into my own cute little private cloud by my PaaS provider when Facebook requests it through some OAuth-like pairing API. I wouldn't need to think of myself, as a user, as "owning cloud database instances." From my perspective, I'd get an abstract "Facebook account" (which is actually an app instance and attached DBs) sitting in my Heroku-for-consumers account. The important bit is that I'd be paying for the resources that "account" object consumes, that I'd have an SLA on those resources, and that the PaaS company would have every incentive to make it easy for other third-party services to interact with my "Facebook database" in a way Facebook themselves aren't. I, as a user, have no need to "manage" a cloud of my own; I just need to be considered to own it.
- bradleyankrom 11y agoThis article is a lot of fun with the Cloud To Butt Chrome plugin installed.
- roddds 11y ago>So please, take my advice, as I go into other concentrated endeavors. Fuck the Butt. Fuck it right in the ear.
- LinuxBender 11y agoThat is by far my favorite plugin. Just don't forget to turn it off before presenting in a meeting...
- dingo_bat 11y agoWhy would you be presenting Chrome in a meeting?
- tillinghast 11y ago… or before you make that quick-just-this-once edit to your site's templates via the CMS's wysiwyg editor. Turns out buttfront.net references don't resolve where you think they do.
- mikeash 11y agoOr editing Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Cloud_seeding#Vandalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Cloud_seeding#Vandalism
- rietta 11y agoWhile Jason Scott raises interesting points six years ago, the principles of data management remain the same as the days of dedicated servers with on premises systems. If you have only one copy of data and that machine goes down, then the data goes with it. In my experience in a business context 'the cloud' discussion is about the business' desire to expand capacity without the need for the capital expenditure needed to buy equipment and server admin salaries. By the numbers it is just better to rent instead of buy at the infrastructure level. The cloud is a murky, ambiguity-laden concept though. Both Netflix and my 92 year old grandmother on Facebook 'use the cloud', but the former is much more sophisticated in their network and data management practices. My grandmother just wants to see fun pictures of her family and great grandkids.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- FussyZeus 11y agoThat's what the author is getting at, "The Cloud" is sold as this awesome thing that will never die or break, and worse yet it's sold to people who often don't know any better. No one realizes that the Cloud is running on the same crap we've always had and is vulnerable to the same issues as everything else. MAYBE the company is better at data management, MAYBE the employees take pride in their job and do it properly, but that's all MAYBE MAYBE MAYBE, and could just as well be "no" and you're entrusting your data to people who really have nothing to lose if it goes into the garbage tomorrow.
- BookmarkSaver 11y agoEh... I think that the maybes you are using are a little bit misleading. When a company sells space in their "cloud", like maybe Microsoft or Amazon, there is a business guarantee that goes along with it. If Amazon were to randomly lose a big chuck of Netflix data, AWS's business would tank immediately. AWS is a giant system that uses its scale and number of customers to efficiently provide a more stable system at a lower cost than all of those individual customers could achieve by building and maintaining their own IT. I think it is sort of like a delivery system. If USPS or FedEx or USP started losing a massive number of packages (I know that they do lose some) then they would get abandoned, just like "Cloud" companies have an incentive to maintain a baseline level of quality. The alternative is that every business would have to create their own shipping services. I think it makes sense to assume that in most cases, unless the business is already massive enough to warrant it, that it is cheaper and more reliable to use the aggregate, dedicated ones for hire. The "Cloud" will be cheaper than individual implementations, and it won't be nearly as suspect to individual implementation errors because the identical system will have been proven by many other customers (otherwise it would be abandoned).
- bhz 11y agoThis is an old article and is almost entirely op-ed. No idea how this got to the top of page on HN. :/
- techdragon 11y agoBecause we all still harbour resentment toward frustrating situations such as the limitations of "the cloud"?
- coldtea 11y agoMaybe because opinions are also valid intellectually? Mere data driven conclusions get nowhere without a point of view and an end goal to accompany them.
- fixermark 11y agoThese statements are true, but may not be reflective of why this story gets top billing on Hacker News. See techdragon's extrapolation comment that's a sibling to this one. ;) Place smells more and more like Slashdot every month.
- r3bl 11y agoI'm definitely going to start renting my own server somewhere in Europe starting from January. I absolutely agree with everything he said and I really want to claim my own data again (run my own email server and things).
- nekopa 11y agoDo you have a write up on running your own email server?
- r3bl 11y agoThis was the article that convinced me to try: http://www.27months.com/2013/10/its-always-sunny-in-iceland-or-how-i-nsa-proofed-my-email/ http://www.27months.com/2013/10/its-always-sunny-in-iceland-... I read both that one and the one posted here like an hour before this one got posted on HN and they have convinced me to give running my own server a try. In the meantime, I have just downloaded a backup of all of my data from Twitter and Facebook (Facebook's archive was like 15x as big as the Twitter's archive even though I'm using Twitter way more) that I am going to save on my server, I have switched to POP instead of IMAP on my current email service and I am testing out ownCloud in a Docker container.
- tibbon 11y agoWhen everything was "moving to the cloud" a few years ago (around when Jason wrote this), I started to have similar feelings. It all felt like something marketers were over-hyping. "Your computer in the cloud" (ever had a shell account that was your main system? This isn't new), "your games in the cloud! Ever played Nethack using that shell account? I guess the only 'new' thing that I saw was the scaling capabilities based on capacity, but we've had time-sharing (albeit, slightly different) for many years.
- 83457 11y agoMy mom was a mainframe programmer and says the cloud it is just like what they had 50 years ago with timesharing but a different name. I just smile and nod. Is such a statement much different than saying PCs are just tiny mainframes with a screens attached?
- notalaser 11y agoYou aren't timesharing your tiny mainframe, so it is quite different, yes. The cloud is precisely what your mom had on a mainframe 50 years ago, including virtualization, on-the-fly scaling of resources (maybe a little more difficult because of the larger equipment), and even renting time on computers you didn't have in your offices, since not every institution could afford their own computer.
- geocar 11y agoProviding an employee with equipment (such as a laptop personal computer) to do their job is (legally) different than leasing equipment to a contractor, or transfer-pricing between departments in a corporation. Remember that a timeshare was very expensive and that those costs were accounted for carefully not only for the purposes of internal billing but also for benefit-analysis.
- throwawayaway 11y agoBoth statements are correct. Remember that it was a personal computing 'revolution'. It would be a great step backwards to accede power to cloud service providers. Computing at the whim of others aka timesharing. Smile and nod but your mother has seen a few cycles of the industry.
- Karunamon 11y agoOh, right, this is the guy that wrote the "facebook is the worst thing ever" screed.
- adityar 11y agoGetting resource limit reached error
- fixermark 11y agohttp://mxtoolbox.com/SuperTool.aspx?action=ptr%3a204.109.60.27&run=toolpage http://mxtoolbox.com/SuperTool.aspx?action=ptr%3a204.109.60.... I bet that wouldn't happen if he'd host his blog on a scaling cloud provider with a proven track record. I could think of a few that might be good candidates... ;)
- goodcall 11y agoDon't we keep our entire life's savings in companies aka banks that we don’t run, don’t control, don’t buy, don’t administrate, and don’t really understand.
- alphadevx 11y agoThey are much more tightly regulated (legally), and insured, often by governments.
- wanderingstan 11y agoThat's an excellent analogy I hadn't thought of. SLA's between companies is perhaps a proxy in the data world, but nothing for individual users. When data will become so important/politicized that there will be regulations about data retention?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThere are some regulations already - mostly on the side of keeping some of the data for tax/legal purposes. For decades. (Makes me wonder how all those fly-by-night cloud startups are handling that.)
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoThe reason they are is because of their intrinsic propensity to destabilization, vis-a-vis Minsky and the Financial Instability Hypothesis. Of course, how you structure your regulatory framework can have adverse consequences, as well (i.e. implicit guarantees by GSEs on mortgage-backed securities). It is further arguable whether or not fractional reserve exacerbates these effects.
- Spooky23 11y agoI was just talking to my pals at Digital Equipment Corporation and Sun Microsystems about how stable the technology industry is. Then, I read an article in Google Reader discussing how we don't even have to worry about arbitrary and capricious market behavior from our cloud partners, since we all have long term contracts and are protected against upward price swings from our cloud partners or material changes to the services they deliver. </s>
- jacquesm 11y agoWell, that's one way to break the ice :) I have a bit more of a nuanced view on this than Jason, but I totally understand where he's coming from and when the whole cloud gravy train started rolling our perspectives overlapped much more than they do today (and quite probably since then Jason's perspective has changed as well as perspectives do with the passing of time). There are use-cases where the cloud is absolutely and utterly the wrong way to go about it. When you're running a bank, a government institution (ever a lower government one) or something else that is mission critical and where total control of the data and maintaining end-user privacy is paramount then the cloud is probably not the right solution. There are also use-cases where the cloud is the right solution in principle but the wrong solution in practice because of cost. Above a certain scale bandwidth and storage costs of cloud operators will always command a premium over those you get from dedicated hosting providers. As for 'not owning the machines', plenty of companies lease their servers, so technically they don't own them anyway. The big problem with 'the cloud' as I see it is that companies tend to rely utterly on it and do not have a 'what if the cloud fails' line in their disaster recovery plans. Lose the cloud data and the company goes up in a puff of water vapor, which is what clouds are made of after all. So if your use case does match the cloud solutions well then make sure that whatever else you do, have at least a copy of your critical data, code and your configuration information outside of the cloud provider. And while you're at it, make sure that this is done in such a way that there is a separation of duties with respect to those that can administer the cloud portion and those that can access those just-in-case-the-shit-hits-the-fan backups. Just so you don't end up like codespaces did. Finally, the cloud is not so much an end-station as it is a step on a much wider scale from absolute control with certain administrative duties on one end and much less control but great convenience on the other. Where on that scale constraints indicated by your comfort level, your application and your fiduciary duties allow you to pick your solution is something that is likely different for every company (and likely for every person). Customers of companies would do well to research their service providers when it comes to how they are architected, just in case something goes drastically wrong so they don't end up holding the bag.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ninjakeyboard 11y agoThere is no alternative approach presented here. I can only assume that the author has never had to scale a piece of software to server hundreds of thousands of concurrent users.
- etjossem 11y agoThe implied alternative is "something you run, control, buy, administrate, and understand." Don't overthink this. You need it to scale to one (1) concurrent user. Go buy an external hard drive. Start saving important things locally, and also automate backups to the external drive. You now have two copies of everything you can't afford to lose.
- nsfyn55 11y ago>Don’t blow anything into the Cloud that you don’t have a personal copy of. I don't understand this logic. Amazon's S3 offers service level agreements with failure rates that at one point implied the statistical likelihood of losing an object to be once in "thousands of years". When dealing with any sort of stable storage this is simply something I cannot offer. I couldn't produce a set up locally with the resources I have for making guarantees on the decade level let alone millennia. With that said I keep personal copies, but the authoritative copy is what's in the cloud, because its a hell of a lot more stable. TL;DR I hear this argument all the time. The cloud isn't perfect but its a hell of a lot closer to anything I could achieve. "not invented here" syndrome won't save your data.
- jacquesm 11y agoUntil your control panel gets hacked and you lose all your data. See: codespaces.com (assuming it wasn't an inside job or a dumb mistake, but even then the same rules apply). So no, DON'T BLOW ANYTHING INTO THE CLOUD THAT YOU DON'T HAVE A COPY OF. It has nothing to do with 'not invented here', it has everything to do with your inability to outsource your responsibilities. The degree to which people rely on others to take care of their stuff is a huge blind-spot. Jason's advice is spot on in this respect, no matter what the up-time guarantees of the cloud solution you are using (and no matter what the redundancies), if you store all your data in the cloud without an off-line copy your company is 3 mouse clicks away from being history.
- nsfyn55 11y ago> Until your control panel gets hacked and you lose all your data This is just alarmism. If you really wanted to demonstrate your point you would show me some data. The data would demonstrate that over the millions and millions of users on a number of cloud platforms that their rates of data loss are significantly higher than your "home spun" storage. Then you would take out the outliers and show an honest distribution on the most stable vendors(since I'd expect the majority of data loss over all vendors to have some amount of locality within a specific vendor). The result of this will be the rate of data loss on the most reliable cloud platforms. You can then compare this against your own success rates. If you have ever(even once) lost even a single byte of data(for any reason), I do believe you will find yourself hopelessly outmatched.
- Touche 11y agoI think this gets to the heart of "what people value" and Jason is looking at it from a perspective of a collector. I'm also a collector so I feel much like him. I wonder if there's a relationship between collecting and being an introvert. I have no evidence but feel like there is. I think most people just don't value "things" the way our types do. What most people value is their social life. They post pictures to Facebook not to store the pictures but to get a reaction from their friends about the picture. That's what they value. The social interaction, not the thing.
- TheGRS 11y agoI really don't like to marginalize others by what type of personality they are. This is yet another way of putting people into buckets so that you can more easily go about your day without thinking about it much. Before facebook people would keep large collections of photo books so that when family and friends came over they could easily share them. It doesn't mean they valued those pictures any less because they were extroverted vs. introverted. People still keep hard copies of the pictures they cherish the most, like a wedding album. People value all sorts of things, but maybe they see cloud storage as perfectly secure, for the moment. Maybe personality plays into that, but I think its more about your approximate knowledge of the underlying technology that keeps people up at night.
- Touche 11y ago> I really don't like to marginalize others by what type of personality they are. Me either, I hope that's not what it sounded like. > Before facebook people would keep large collections of photo books so that when family and friends came over they could easily share them. It doesn't mean they valued those pictures any less because they were extroverted vs. introverted. People still keep hard copies of the pictures they cherish the most, like a wedding album. Yeah, absolutely, and I think people do still keep the photos they care most about today. I just think we overestimate how many of those photos exist. I think the overwhelming use of taking photos is for social conversation.
- swiley 11y agoHe acknowledges and supports that. He's not saying "don't use facebook" but "facebook is fun but temporary, like a party. Don't leave stuff there."
- voynich61 11y agoOldManYellsAtCloud.jpg
- rodionos 11y agoAWS customer since 2007. Just pulled the plug on our last EC2 instance this week having migrated our stuff to a provider offering root servers for the cost of m3.medium. Our requirements are simple and we have no need for high-load/high-end layers. We used to have 50-100 VMs depending on the time of the day, now less than 20 with the rest of the workloads migrated to Docker containers. P.S. Can't delete Glacier Vaults for now as AWS enforces a cooling period.
- peterwwillis 11y agoIf you use Snapchat a lot, you may notice how often you get updates from people or see their public story change. Do you ever stop to think about the old snaps, or miss them? No, because you have a constant stream of new ones. You can always make more memories. Nothing about the cloud is that different from what we had before. With shared hosting providers, you and 50 other users would fill up your disk quota on one or two hard drives on some dinky 1U server running Apache and ProFTPD. If the drives died, along with it went your data. Which is why you kept a copy on your own computer. Back then, nobody expected anyone to keep their data for them, so they just kept their own backups. The same was true for managed services and colo with the exception that you had to do more of the work yourself. Because the industry has gotten better about preventing data loss, we get complacent and stop saving our stuff as much. But why piss and moan over more reliable, more massive services for cheap or free? Because it isn't perfect, or innovative, or more transparent? The status quo of the industry is to reinvent the wheel, so it's hard to get mad at people for re-packaging the same solution in a different container. The obsession of holding onto all your old stuff just makes this look even more unnecessary.
- T3RMINATED 11y agoThe Cloud is a rip off - i Engineered AWS as a sub-contractor for Amazon.
- ksk 11y agoIt's rather interesting that HN mods allow posts with this kind of language but the moment you are even mildly critical of a comment or commenter, you get a warning about language. I guess the thinking is we look the other way as long as its not hosted on the ycombinator domain.
- nekopa 11y agoI think it's more he (the article) is saying fuck to an idea, not a flesh and blood person (as when responding to a comment). Also, it is possible to have civil debate around a profanity riddled article. That's what this site is trying to achieve.
- sneak 11y agoWhat the fuck are you talking about?
- cowardlydragon 11y agoIn enterprises, you either trust the cloud, or your local data center people. The local data center people will threaten and lord over you with their hardware powers unless you have the cloud alternative. And you're not entirely wrong about the cloud. So don't trust either. A modern business should have at least two external cloud providers and a local option.
- vvpan 11y agoI like the guy's writing style and use of English.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoI understand why people are upset about the word. It's misused. But I remember what it was like before "the cloud"... You had to provision machines one by one, often via email or phone. It took hours or days. Billing was usually done by the day. It sucked. Now you can just send a POST request to a machine and in a few seconds you have access to a new instance. You can send 1000 requests and get access to 1000 instances. And then you can send some more requests and only get charged for a few minutes of time. When this transition happened, we called it "the cloud" because it's a big undifferentiated mass of computers. We could've called it "the soup" but we didn't. That's what it has always meant to me. I don't understand why people want to eradicate the word just because it's misused. People misuse the word "internet" all the time, but I don't think we should strike it from our vocabulary.
- whichfawkes 11y agoAgreed. When I read the title, I was thinking "Oh, so you'd prefer to pay for dedicated servers? What a pain!". Though, I don't think the author is upset about the word. He's just warning against services that fall within his definition of "cloud" - which is pretty fair. Losing your stuff is no good, and there's always cruddy services out there.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoYeah, I guess you're right. Weirdly he's not talking about the cloud at all, he's just talking about storing things on someone else's servers. So I guess he's one of those people misusing the word cloud.
- Jedd 11y ago> That's what it has always meant to me. And that's my biggest problem with the word, and why I go to some lengths to avoid using it when talking to clients, despite a number of my employer's (and their partners') products including 'cloud' in their actual name. No two people actually agree on what the c-word actually means. For you it's elastic compute. For others it's cheap storage, or geographical diversity, or managed RAID, or an ersatz CDN, or their hosted email or wiki or some other application, or an accounting convenience (dipping into the opex, rather than the capex, bucket), or, of course, some combination of those and others. The biggest problems I've dealt with in IT over the years stem from people having even slightly different ideas of what words mean -- so a word that involves wildly different understandings is not a recipe for tranquillity.
- Turbots 11y agoAm I stupid for suggesting: JUST STORE YOUR DATA IN TWO TOTALLY UNRELATED CLOUD SERVICES = PROBLEM FUCKING SOLVED
- nsfyn55 11y agoReally a DOX bro? That company went under anyway(because it was financially unstable not because I chose to use S3 to host their site), but interestingly the page you've found has been continuously hosted (without even a minute of downtime) for almost 3 years. It also hasn't seen one minute of administration time since 2013. But seriously your tact shows you are a piece of shit.
- jacquesm 11y agoFirst off, I'm not your 'bro'. And what do you mean a DOX, you yourself wrote that on this very site. Or are you saying that you consider yourself anonymous from hereon in and therefore get to spout whatever nonsense you feel like and invite people to do dumb stuff 'because you said so' and we should ignore this in the context of your other postings? I'm responding to you the way I do because you run (or apparently, ran) an AWS hosted service. I'm a piece of shit because you disagree with me, but it just so happens that you've been all over this thread with a continuous stream of (hopefully) purposeful mis-understandings and/or downright trolling. If you want to do that from an anonymous account go ahead but don't do it from the same one that you use for 'Who is hiring' posts. Just like say if cperciva writes about online storage I interpret that in the context of his tarsnap business. People here are pretty open about the projects they're involved with and so are you, if you don't want that link to be made then I suggest you don't post about your company on HN or you create a separate account to share your 'pearls of wisdom' like you do in this thread. Oh, and your anecdote of how many years you were up and running holds zero water by your own standards. Attacking people and their professional reputations can get your own professional reputation called into question, get used to it.
- nsfyn55 11y agoBro was a pejorative friend. To be clear I never attacked you. Not once. I called your arguments into question, but that is what we are doing here. I believe your reasoning to be specious. >I'm a piece of shit because you disagree with me, but it just so happens that you've been all over this thread with a continuous stream of purposeful mis-understandings and/or downright trolling. This is just not true. I called you that because you tried to do just that to me. A quick re-read of all my comments and I'm sure you'll see I never made any personal reference to you. Now if you consider me telling you that you are incorrect an attack then I'm sorry this is something you'll need to get used to. In this case because you are wrong. I've offered you ample opportunity to proffer a statistical argument, but all you can give me is "if I didn't build its not safe" Sorry friend I just don't trust you. I've been doing this a long time and I don't trust myself. I never told someone to do something "cause I said so" but then again you never address the meat of my position. "Cloud providers have much lower failure rates than you historically I trust them more than I do you when building my understanding of the risks". Its trivial to undermine my position. Show you have lower failure rates than a prime time storage provider(bonus points if its amazon). Lets just a get a few non sequitars that you can't seem to get your head wrapped around. I never said don't have a back up. I said the back up in the cloud is the most durable one. I never said amazon couldn't fail. I just said the chances they fail vs. you are orders of magnitude lower. I never said you were bad at your job. I said you seem to have a shaky grasp on statistics and possible a fair amount of NIH syndrome. You are correct my anecdote doesn't prove my point, but it provides anecdotal evidence to corroborate my statistical position. I didn't say "don't be open or transparent" I said pulling a persons personal details into an internet argument crosses a very clear line. Get over yourself and remember not everyone that disagrees with you is trying to undermine your career. But you step over a line with you get personal and start pulling personal details into an internet conversation.
- nsfyn55 11y agoI don't think you are my bro. And I want to be clear your moded and nonsensical jabbering is not why you are a piece of shit. An attempt to call attention to my potential customers in a forum because you disagree with me is why you are a piece of shit. So its cleared up me "offering nothing but objective fact, statistical argument, and well formed conjecture" you "anecdotes, personal attacks, and general butt hurtiness because someone on the interwebs doesn't think you are right" exto facto you == piece of shit
- jacquesm 11y ago> And I want to be clear your moded and nonsensical jabbering is not why you are a piece of shit. Ah ok, that's what caused it. Well, that's fine but there is probably an aggregate several 100 years worth of experience in this thread that seems to be in violent agreement on you not really understanding the matter under consideration. > An attempt to call attention to my potential customers in a forum because you disagree with me is why you are a piece of shit. If you present yourself as a representative or founder of a company here then by extension you represent the views of that company unless otherwise noted. If you don't want that then you are free to make another account which is not in any way associated with your professional HN profile, it wasn't me that made the choice to join the two, you did (as do many other people here). But most of us are careful to speak in such a way that we do not bring our partners or employers trouble by drawing attention to either our lack of knowledge or ability or by making statements that would - when viewed in the light of our professional engagements - show our employers in a bad light. So, whether or not you agree with me is besides the point. If you feel like totally mis-interpreting Jasons writings and on top of that you call me 'alarmist' you are actively attacking our professional reputations, and what goes around comes around.
- nsfyn55 11y agoYou are misunderstanding me( I know sit seems to be a common pattern for you) whether I stand behind what I say is totally separate concept from your motivations and how they reflect on you as a person. The quality of my technical reputation is not in question here and my employer is welcome to read this thread. I didn't call you an "alarmist" I said worrying about whether amazon will stay in business, "get hacked", or if S3 is going to disappear without warning is "alarmism" They were responsible for 39% of all commercial internet transactions last year and store 2,000,000,000,000 objects. If they go under we are are all in a heap of trouble. A NAS device in some remote part of the netherlands isn't going to save us.
- CM30 11y agoThe points in this article also apply really nicely to websites and other services, many of which seem to make the mistake of outsourcing everything to other people's platforms. Oh sure, you may be using 'the cloud' to host your webmail, or your forums, or your chat, or anything else... but what if that goes missing? You're in an even worse situation than the individuals using these services to host their personal files. Remember what happened to IPBFree? They were shut down for some weird, unexplained reason (rumour has it as a raid for illegal activity), and literally everything on their servers was wiped out. Now imagine if the same sort of thing happened to one of these services, like Dropbox or the likes... Millions of people would lose most of their files overnight. Use such services for backups, sure. But don't rely on them too much, you don't know what might be going on behind the scenes at the other end of the line. You don't know their financials (usually), whether they're under investigation for something, whether an intelligence agency is spying on their servers, whether their security is up to par in every possible sense... And if they're offering it for free... well, they don't have much invested in keeping you as a customer when things get tough. Became unpopular recently, for saying something controversial or 'stupid' on social media? Made enemies in the political world? Then a lot of companies will be quite happy to shut down your account to avoid bad PR. By using these services, you provide a nice target for the social media mob the minute you do something that a lot of people don't like...
- superuser2 11y ago> like Dropbox or the likes... Millions of people would lose most of their files overnight. That's false. Files in Dropbox are also stored locally on all your Dropbox-enabled computers. They would simply stop syncing, and you'd plug in another syncing service. If Dropbox disappears, your Dropbox folder just becomes a regular folder.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoUnless they fuck up sync again and all your locally stored Dropbox folders get wiped clean. Happened once. I'm pretty sure Dropbox is more than cautious about it, but it's still a possibility with them, and more so with everyone else.
- nine_k 11y agoWell, it's seemingly trivially easy. Don't move to the cloud; copy to the cloud. Also applies to other storage media.
- textfiles 11y agoSalutations, ass-end of the Tech Elite. As someone who has generated a pretty hefty sandbag of verbiage over my decades online, it's always amusing to see what the Grand Eye of internet arbitration decides is an incredibly important and pertinent subject to discuss in my back catalog. Whether it's my work in guiding volunteers for in-browser emulation (http://archive.org/details/softwarelibrary http://archive.org/details/softwarelibrary), my delightful coterie of 1980s BBS textfiles (http://www.textfiles.com http://www.textfiles.com) or perhaps my documentaries on BBS culture (http://www.bbsdocumentary.com http://www.bbsdocumentary.com) Text Adventures (http://www.getlamp.com http://www.getlamp.com) or the DEFCON Hacker Conference (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVwaIe6CiHw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVwaIe6CiHw) ... or, as it is today, one of my many long-form written-down thoughts on all manner of this silly medium many of us have chosen to live our lives. Oh yes, also that my cat is on twitter and has a million followers. (http://www.twitter.com/sockington http://www.twitter.com/sockington) - Lots of people are loaded with knapsacks of opinion about that one as well. I have found that Hacker News (which is, be clear, an unexpectedly lively extension of Y Combinator) is composed of several diverse groups, all with variant approaches to a linked subject. A linked subject which, as some have pointed out, I wrote 6 years ago, deep in the mists of time. One group is literally in it for the Money, the gain, the ROI, the endless quest for the "Unicorn", and all their commentary is pungent with the bias and filter of either finding the precious gold coin at the bottom of the shitpile, or are rife with attempts to promote or play up subjects and links of great interest to their financial agenda. Be assured that I could not care less about the current status of the beating of your heart. Another group seems to be happy to drill down as deep as they can into the mathematics, algorithms, and code of a situation, thinking that if they napkin-blart out enough "facts", they will win some sort of day. I find these people tend to be unhappy about flowery language or effusive phrasing, simply because they've left-brain-dominated themselves into deep pits of nut-sorting and bolt-counting. They use "TL;DR" a lot, as well as, I assume, Adderall. Their heartbeat status is of greater interest to me, if only because I think they are coming from a good place, even if that place smells of Cheetos and sweat. And, of course, there are Opinion Tourists, my favorite, who might as well be equated with a loud and cantankerous pit of waving hands, waiting for the newly linked (if not newly written) event/opinion/image for their to raise in a mighty roar with a hastily cooked "hot take" on the item. Some of them even optimize the process to not even click on the provided link before the horn honking ensues. So, "Fuck the Cloud" was written in the deep miasma of when everyone used the term "Cloud" interchangeably with "Magic"; that it was an approach and glory that would lead the experience of computing to a new shangrila. Like any old-timers rife with memories of how we got into that world (and of the echoes of cloud-dom going back 50 years), I decided to write out some of my own thoughts, especially on this attempt to dumb down the populace and separate them from not just responsibility, but control and agency with their data. I have been entirely correct in the general theme - there is a divide within the technical community, of people with admin access and the ability to control any aspect of their work, and then a very large, almost overwhelming set of users who are, essentially, meat stock. And in the same way that meat stock has no particular seat at the table when negotiations of an agricultural nature are conducted, so in the same way are the "users" left out in the cold as a whole range of abilities and ersatz "rights" are stripped away, under the guise of "ease of use" and "leave it to us". All of this was written without the revelations of the deep, intense surveillance apparatus that is now in place, ensuring that any of this data you control or thought was within your own private space is actually destined to meet you again in an investigation, a courtroom, a warrantless intrusion or a physical SWAT attack. That wasn't even the point. The point was that user data, treated as something to abuse, monetize, and ultimately discard as a whim, was a complete betrayal of the early promises and experimentation of the Internet. To counteract this trend, I co-founded Archive Team (http://www.archiveteam.org http://www.archiveteam.org) and our delightful success in many areas would warrant a completely different essay itself - and it has, along with myriad speeches and presentations in the years hence. I'm sure it might be delightful entertainment for Hacker News to find this or that out on the net and go off, endlessly, in the loop of "This Needs Me" and "Fuck You For Thinking That", but ultimately, these are ridiculous showboat-dances of "what if" and "why not", and I've discovered in the years hence that truly, actions and achievement s speak louder, ever so louder, than words. Enjoy your day. And fuck "The Cloud".