14 ms·
Strong Legs Associated with Healthy Brains in Twin Study
- xendo 11y agoTL;DR "muscle fitness (measured by leg power)" is correlated with cognitive ageing.
- enraged_camel 11y agoTime to do squats!
- mapleoin 11y agoinversely correlated I hope?
- xendo 11y agoCorrelated as in 'have a mutual relationship or connection'. I wrote it just because the title was suggesting that stronger legs lead to healthier brain. Whereas the study suggests that healthy lifestyle (better diet, more exercises) lead to healthier brain. Which is to be honest, nothing new.
- skj 11y agoThe term "inversely correlated" is a new one for me, since correlation is two-way, and, as they say, not necessarily causal.
- zeroxfe 11y ago"Inversely correlated" roughly means "correlated in opposite directions", e.g., when one variable goes up, the other goes down, i.e., the correlation factor is negative. It does not imply causation.
- staunch 11y agoWalking helps me think because my thighs pump my brain full of smart juice?
- barry-cotter 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brain-derived_neurotrophic_factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brain-derived_neurotrophic_fac... Certain types of physical exercise have been shown to markedly (threefold) increase BDNF synthesis in the human brain, a phenomenon which is partly responsible for exercise-induced neurogenesis and improvements in cognitive function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurobiological_effects_of_physical_exercise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurobiological_effects_of_phy... People who regularly participate in aerobic exercise have greater scores on neuropsychological function and performance tests. Examples of aerobic exercise that produce these changes are running, jogging, brisk walking, swimming, and cycling. Exercise intensity and duration are positively correlated with the release of neurotrophic factors and the magnitude of nearly all forms of exercise-induced behavioral and neural plasticity; consequently, more pronounced improvements in measures of neuropsychological performance are observed in endurance athletes as compared with recreational athletes or sedentary individuals. Aerobic exercise is also a potent long-term antidepressant and a short-term euphoriant; consequently, consistent exercise has also been shown to produce general improvements in mood and self-esteem in all individuals.
- shabbaa 11y agoInteresting, however i'd lean towards muscle mass in general having this effect rather than thighs in particular. Although being at the lower end of the body might be important in maintaining goid circulation.
- RobertoG 11y agoThe gluteus are the largest muscles. I imagine this is a factor, even if the development of all the muscles have proportionally the same effect.
- raverbashing 11y agoHere's the thing, you don't/can't "isolate" development of a muscle, especially a big one Working out has systemic (anabolic) effects
- makeset 11y ago> you don't/can't "isolate" development of a muscle This is not true at all. You may be confusing it with the assertion that you can't isolate individual heads of a particular muscle. Yes, training has some systemic effect through hormonal activity, but muscle anabolism is very highly specific to local stimulus. Otherwise we'd all be just doing curls and watch our legs grow. For a comically extreme example of localized functional muscle hypertrophy, search for the armwrestler Matthias "Hellboy" Schlitte :)
- raverbashing 11y agoYes, if you focus your training on one specific muscle, especially if it's a small one (arms basically) you will cause said muscle to be hypertrophied But you can bet Matthias Schilitte doesn't stand all day training only said muscles (also he has a genetic problem)
- esseti 11y agoJust started to read the book "Brain Rules: 12 Principles for Surviving and Thriving at Work, Home, and School". It basically starts with this "For starters, we are not used to sitting at a desk for eight hours a day. From an evolutionary perspective, our brains developed while working out, walking as many as 12 miles a day. The brain still craves that experience, especially in sedentary populations like our own. That’s why exercise boosts brain power (Brain Rule #1) in such populations. Exercisers outperform couch potatoes in long-term memory, reasoning, attention, and problem-solving tasks. I am convinced that integrating exercise into our eight hours at work or school would only be normal."
- LoSboccacc 11y agoThat'd be easy to check, since plenty school have a daily morning routine now, school scores aren't comparable, but I guess researchers can figure out a metric for brain fitness.
- tomp 11y ago> Exercisers outperform couch potatoes in long-term memory, reasoning, attention, and problem-solving tasks I'm pretty sure the cause/effect is reversed here. It's more likely that people who are smart and have better focus/are less impulsive are more likely to take care of their health and exercise.
- anon4 11y agoFrom my experience, there is no correllation between someone being smart and doing exercise.
- Kurtz79 11y agoI think it's misleading to take this kind of studies like they have a binary conclusion (exercisers=smart, couch potatoes=dumb). I guess there are many factors affecting intelligence and fitness, from cultural to genetic. It might not be the only factor, but it could well be one of many.
- 11y ago
- datashovel 11y agoI'd be interested to know more precisely whether the subjects were doing more aerobic or anaerobic exercises. My hunch, given my distant past life as an athlete, is that the correlation is with aerobic exercise and not anaerobic.
- darkr 11y agoWhy so? Surely, if the correlation is explicitly with leg power rather than endurance or general fitness, then anaerobic exercise (squats, deadlifts, lunges, leg-presses, as well as running/bike sprints etc) would be the a better driver for building that power rather than aerobic exercise?
- datashovel 11y agoThat's why I wish they were more explicit when defining the kind of exercise the subjects were engaged in. My comment was primarily from personal experience. When I did my anaerobic exercise when I used to train, it was heavily anaerobic, where I would do a lot of short bursts of heavy lifting. Later I transitioned to primarily focus on aerobic, where I did a lot of distance swimming. So I think I had a good amount of both extremes to at least provide some insights. Everyone's experience will likely be slightly different. My hunch, though, is a lot of people who do lifting still get aerobic benefits because they're not training as intensely. So I think I'm speaking more about the extremes of the two types of exercise and not a middle ground.
- ScottGillis 11y agoI agree with you. This is a very good question to ask. If this is from extremely intense workouts, then I would say very few would benefit.
- SebKba 11y agoYou can build aerobic power (at least to some extent) using anaerobic exercise like sprints / intervals. I would assume a combination of aerobic & anaerobic exercise is probably the healthiest because that way all energy pathways and muscle fibres get activated. I always think it's crazy to expect humans to function properly without exercise. We see the problems in all other animals when they become sedentary below the level that they would historically be expected to do. Yet somehow some people seem to think we are an exception to this rule.
- cheriot 11y agoThe study controls for genetics and upbringing. So somewhere among food, fitness, and the entire rest of the world is a contributor to brain health. How helpful is that?
- sevensor 11y agoThis is an appealing result. I like exercise and I want to think it's doing good things for my brain, but as with all studies on the mind-body link, it's going to take a great deal more evidence to make it convincing. It's especially premature to conclude anything about exercising the legs in particular.
- SebKba 11y agoThere is probably a correlation between overall health -> leg strength & overall health => brain health / power. Not as revolutionary as I would like it to be.
- plg 11y agoremember: "associated with" does NOT mean "causes" having a Mercedes in the driveway might be associated with higher grades in high school ... but you're not going to magically raise your kid's grade by parking a mercedes in the driveway
- reustle 11y agoWell, I guess it depends on how much money you donate to the university.
- Chris2048 11y agoWhat I'd like to know is how this boils down wrt work. If an increase in mental ability represent a greater work-done-per hour; But the cost is time spent exercising -> less time working (maybe somewhat compensated for other positive non-work benefits), Then what would be the perfect amount of exercise to boost productivity? i.e. would an hour spent exercising pay for itself in productivity boost?
- avar 11y agoYou run out of the ability to be able to do practical mental work long before you run out of the ability to do physical exercise, so I think you're making a false zero-sum comparison of the two.
- Chris2048 11y agoTrue, but for me I have other constraints on free time, where I have choice between one or the other; so I am doing other, low-mentally-and-low-physically-taxing tasks in between free-time.
- avar 11y agoIf you want my unsolicited advice I'd say that if you're truly so busy that you can't spare say 4 hours a week (3x a week in the gym) you have bigger things to worry about than how strong legs might impact the long-term health of your brain.
- Chris2048 11y agoI have more things I could do, than time to do them; prioritising is the issue. There's no such thing as 'spare' time in that context, all free time has things-to-do competing for it.
- vox_mollis 11y agoYou can get in a decent intense squat session in only 15 minutes. The really big time sinks associated with lifting include: - commute to/from gym - changing clothes - another shower If you don't live in cramped quarters such as SF/NYC, I recommend a small home/garage gym to address these.
- hsnewman 11y agoYeah, just ask Stephen Hawkings
- Retra 11y agoThat's really not how statistics work.
- DevX101 11y agoStrong legs are also associated with people who run a lot, which has been already shown to be associated with healthy brains. It's possible this study is a proxy for the common health advice of 'just do more cardio'
- pessimizer 11y agoOr just an overblown observation that smart people do more exercise. Similar to the massive bullshitstorm over the observation that people who are healthy sit less.
- hyperchase 11y agoOr weightlifting, squatting and deadlifting heavy on a regular basis will give you substantially stronger legs than any runner.
- DevX101 11y agoI'm not entirely convinced 'strong legs' are the causative factor in healthier brains. It is possible the researchers measured an artifact of people that do running cardio.
- nostrebored 11y agoParticularly damning is that the research participants were all female. Anyone who's set foot in a gym knows that women do cardio disproportionately, and that the cardio they do increases thigh musculature...
- kaitai 11y agoI have to disagree. Sure women do more cardio, but the cardio increasing thigh musculature? Not a chance. Squatting increases thigh musculature. Doing the elliptical for an hour a day does not. Running slowly or at a medium speed does not. Nor do either lead to any gain in strength anywhere.
- cronjobber 11y agoAnecdotal confirmation: Bill Gates, who is widely believed to have a very healthy brain, in more youthful years used to perform silly jumping feats, like jumping out of garbage cans.
- jinst8gmi 11y agoAnecdotal counter-example: my dog likes jumping into garbage cans but isn't very smart.
- bkmartin 11y agoMight apply to humans only... no canine trials have been studied yet. /s
- mattlutze 11y agoAnecdoesn't confirmation can be just as important in science as anecdotal.
- imgabe 11y agoSmart is not necessarily the same as healthy. Is your dog prone to bouts of depression?
- DrScump 11y agoor he is carefully hiding higher intelligence from you. To paraphrase Steve Martin, if you have $3000 worth of unexplained dog treats and chewy-toys show up at your doorstep, make sure you are shredding your credit card statements before putting them in said garbage can.
- gtpasqual 11y agoThis is slightly inappropriate for HN, but here is a video of Bill doing that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TCxE0bWQeQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TCxE0bWQeQ
- percept 11y agoPff, everybody knows he inherited his strong legs.
- omginternets 11y agoThis is actually a fairly old idea and hinges on the role of leg muscles in general circulation and brain irrigation. I don't have the other papers on hand, but I recall there being studies relating sitting time with cognitive performance, the idea being that there's a bit of hypoxia associated with immobility. Edit: An anecdote which I think will resonate with many. Very often I start getting drowsy in front of my computer and decide to get a cup of coffee. By the time I make it to the coffee machine, I'm no longer drowsy ...
- abledon 11y agoYup, one of the premises of this book: http://www.amazon.com/Spark-Revolutionary-Science-Exercise-Brain/dp/0316113514 http://www.amazon.com/Spark-Revolutionary-Science-Exercise-B... Its also humorous to note that the in many schools of Chinese Yoga (Qi-Gong) and Tai Chi, the first pose given is a horse stance. Where you simply stand and relax into the bone structure of your body, then continue for hours on end, (for sometimes many years with this single pose depending on the student).
- shas3 11y agoDo stronger muscles result in increased blood flow?
- Namrog84 11y agoI could be wrong but I thought I read. Increased exercise increases capillary size and in some cases can form new ones? In which relates the more you exercise. Stonger your muscles. The more blood flow there is.
- omginternets 11y agoI believe so, but take that with a grain of salt. As I remember, the leg muscles play a role in forcing blood back up towards the heart.
- pvaldes 11y agoMaybe but not always, kangaroos o frogs do not seem to be much smarter than deer or salamanders...
- padobson 11y agoI go to therapy to manage my depression. I don't have a severe case, but it's bad enough that it affects my productivity at times. Once a year or so I'll have a bout where I am almost completely unable to function. The tools I use to manage depression are (wait for it) diet, exercise and prayer (or meditation, if you want to keep it secular). Exercise is particularly useful. Depression affects the mind, so it's difficult to be self-aware about it. But I've found that when I start to have those thoughts of hopelessness, going out and running 1-3 miles at a pace that pushes my physical limits (I use a Nike Sportwatch for measurements) eradicates my depression. On a semi-daily basis, 30 minutes of prayer, 30 minutes exercise and at least one meal with ~90g of raw spinach seems to do the trick for me.
- andor 11y agoSpinach, that's interesting. Apparently, tryptophan + vitamin B6 + vitamin C converts to serotonin. https://thomasmcgregor.wordpress.com/2013/06/07/cure-depression-with-spinach/ https://thomasmcgregor.wordpress.com/2013/06/07/cure-depress...
- padobson 11y agoThanks for the link. I started on Spinach because my doctor suggested "leafy green vegetables". I tried kale first, but I prefer the taste of spinach. I most often eat it first thing in the morning as a shake: 90g spinach + 1 cup almond milk + half a frozen banana. According to the article, I may want to add some strawberries or oranges for more vitamin C.
- codebolt 11y agoJust like I always say, all a man needs to succeed in life is maths and squats.
- danielrm26 11y agoThe whole causation / correlation thing is a big part of this, I think. Many will likely read this and think that there's brain power in your legs, when in fact it's most likely saying that leg health -> physical activity in general -> brain health. I think the writing about the study should be more clear about this, as I'm sure the original work is.
- hellofunk 11y agoI wonder if this would be yet another advantage of using stand-up desks, which are now quite well-known to be stellar for cardiovascular health, but if they also improve leg muscles, could be a boost to one's thinking power? After a day of standing up at a desk, my legs are super tired, so obviously there is serious muscle development going on there.
- kaitai 11y agoFull article at https://www.karger.com/Article/FullText/441029 https://www.karger.com/Article/FullText/441029 Leg strength was tested by "Leg Extensor Power Rig," a custom-built instrument in one of these medical school labs (Nottingham Med School). It's important to remember that for all of these strength tests on average citizens you want an exercise that doesn't require coaching or good form, so no squats, sadly....
- DrScump 11y agoThat puts disproportional emphasis on quadriceps strength. I had hoped for a broader metric.
- askafriend 11y agoYou heard that HN? We all need to be doing heavy squats in the gym.
- davidw 11y agoI know getting out for a bike ride certainly activates my brain as long as I'm not going full-out.
- ALee 11y agoOliver Sacks once held the weightlifting record in California: http://www.mensjournal.com/health-fitness/collection/8-things-we-learn-from-oliver-s-sacks-memoir-on-the-move-20150501 http://www.mensjournal.com/health-fitness/collection/8-thing...