20 ms·
Times Pulls Article Blaming Encryption in Paris Terror Attack
- interdrift 11y agoShame..that they wrote it in the first place.
- estefan 11y agoCare to elaborate?
- make3 11y agoEncryption existing is an important part of not being in a police state. It's the freedom to not have the gouvernment judge your every word, be it with an algorithm or by being able to look up your every word without a warrant in an investigation, without civil transparancy.
- okamiueru 11y agoAt the risk of putting words into other someone else's mouth, it's a shame that the level of education/awareness regarding the fundamentals of how society works is so lacking. Without encryption, internet doesn't work. Without internet, banking and e-commerce doesn't work. Really, not a single user-identifying service can function without encryption. Also, encryption is based on math and logic. You can't really prohibit people from using it, or having it in any sensible way. Meaning that if we live in a fantasy land where this became outlawed, you'd still have any two nodes using encryption should they wish to. I doubt terrorist have the necessary incentive to follow international laws. In fact, a mathematically unbreakable encryption is simply generating random data (aka. a one-time pad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-time_pad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-time_pad), and having a copy of this data at each end of the communication. Want to transfer sensitive data across the border? Just xor your data with the random data, and take the random data with you across the border. If the microSD card didn't leave your butt-crack at any point, you can merrily download the xor-ed data through NSA's mainframe, and they can't do jack about it, even with quantum computing, or any imaginable alien technology.
- ikeboy 11y agoTo play devil's advocate, saying "but you can never ban encryption anyway" sets up a false dichotomy. You're right, there are open source projects that will survive no matter what you do. But you can certainly force or convince companies like Apple and Google to prevent those apps from being available in their stores, and you can force large companies like Facebook to give you a backdoor. Sure, someone tech savvy can get around that, but not everyone. Just look at how many criminal cases end up finding emails explicitly talking about plans and crimes. So there are people nowadays not even using encryption when committing crimes. If you make encryption-by-default impossible, the amount of unencrypted messages will increase, and you'll have gained those. Now whether that's good or bad is a separate discussion; I tend to think it's bad, but that's a more nuanced argument than "you can't ban it, so don't do anything about it".
- nindalf 11y ago> someone tech savvy can get around that Or someone who has a strong incentive to keep their communication hidden - like a terrorist or a drug enforcer. This leads to a situation where law abiding citizens are punished when their right to privacy is denied, while criminals aren't hindered. "When you outlaw X, X will only be used by outlaws"
- ikeboy 11y agoMy claim is that "criminals aren't hindered" is false. Sure, there are people that will get around it, but as I mentioned, there are plenty of criminals that don't use encryption and have been caught with incriminating emails, so that makes me think that if encryption was made more difficult, some criminals who use encryption now would stop. Criminals aren't perfect.
- nindalf 11y agoYou are right, there would be many petty criminals who would be caught because they'd talk about their crimes in plaintext. There would be a reduction in petty crime, while leaving major crime pretty much untouched. That sounds like a good thing... except it might not be in society's interest to eliminate petty crime, as Snowden explains here [1]. [1] - http://nindalf.com/OverconfidentArowana http://nindalf.com/OverconfidentArowana
- interdrift 11y agoEncryption is a basic human right. The freedom to speak without being judged.
- gkwelding 11y agoSo is life, what do you do when 2 basic rights clash? It's definitely a tricky question, and I certainly don't have the answer.
- Kristine1975 11y agoBut do they clash in this case?
- geggam 11y agoEncryption or the use thereof doesn't threaten your life. Screwdrivers or the use thereof don't either, however if someone misuses the screwdriver and stabs you in the temple you will die. Does this mean we should outlaw the use of screwdrivers ?
- programmernews3 11y agoI agree and it is ironic as journalism depends upon free speech.
- donkeyd 11y agoEven without having encryption in main stream applications, like WhatsApp, it's child's play to communicate secretly. There are so many open source applications that allow you to do this, it wouldn't even be a speed bump for criminals. Targeting main stream applications only hurts main stream users. NYT should write an article about that.
- melling 11y agoYou seem to be overlooking the obvious argument that if a small group of people use encryption, then you greatly reduce the number of messages that you need to flag. Furthermore, if someone on a Watch List starts using encryption then perhaps you have an imminent problem. I'm not on the side of reading messages but you missed the real argument being made. Typical HN. How about someone answering the argument that will really be made by governments instead of the pointless one the NSA, etc have already answered. You can downvote me but you don't get a downvote in governments around the world when they outlaw real encryption.
- loceng 11y agoIf only the government(s) could be trusted to not pass along confidential business information from foreign companies (or even perhaps local) to help the companies in their own country.
- DickingAround 11y agoI have not seen them use that argument. If they used that it would be better than what they normally do; which is imply they don't understand what's going on. But even this argument is subject to the same problems; it implies they don't really know why we'd want/need encryption because it assumes that a government could create a back door only they could use.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- simonh 11y agoI work for a Bank and we use encrypted external email all the time. We have to for regulatory reasons. I'm sure it's the same for defence contractors, and it's a prudent precaution for governments and many other businesses and in many parts of the world.
- 034509034590 11y agoA link to the NYT article now redirects readers to a separate, general article on the attacks, which does not contain the word “encrypt.” The original piece can be found on the Internet Archive. https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/16/world/europe/paris-attackers-communicated-with-isis-officials-say.html https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http://www.nytime...
- josefresco 11y agoThe language seems pretty reasonable... "The attackers are believed to have communicated using encryption technology, according to European officials who had been briefed on the investigation but were not authorized to speak publicly. It was not clear whether the encryption was part of widely used communications tools, like WhatsApp, which the authorities have a hard time monitoring, or something more elaborate. Intelligence officials have been pressing for more leeway to counter the growing use of encryption."
- mtgx 11y agoSure, if you think unproven hearsay in NYT that we all ought to take for granted is "reasonable". If the authorities believe it was the encryption to blame, then they should come out and say it outright - with details, of course. They shouldn't hide under the "anonymous officials" tag which "believe" it was encryption the culprit that stopped them from learning about the attacks, and nothing else. It could've been just some random cop's opinion, who heard it from someone else, who was also wrong about it.
- hellbanner 11y agoSeriously, yes. "News" outlets for decades have printed "anonymous officials" and "inside government sources" with devastating opinions.. even worse is "So and so was CALLED XYZ by ... " this is like assigning a variable in programming, X=Y.. talk about programming the mass consciousness!
- golergka 11y ago
- jostmey 11y agoThe best encryption is simply to communicate the old fashioned way. Just because they had some playstations and access to "whatsapp" does not mean the terrorist trusted electronic devices.
- Zigurd 11y agoIf your favorite tool is the pervasive surveillance hammer, you try to make everything look like a nail.
- dfc 11y agoWhat is the deal with insidesources.com? Something feels a "little off" after browsing the rest of the site. It feels like a undercover PR machine for someone or some group. It also seems like they hate copy editors.
- xtyy 11y agoeditor of insidesources' twitter handle is @warroomalerts
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- madmulita 11y agoI blame prime numbers, even co-primes should be banned. Please contact your representative and help us free the world from evil math.
- huac 11y agoIt's worked before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Pi_Bill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Pi_Bill
- maxmax 11y agoSo irrational.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoNo, clearly it was rational. ᴨ = 3.2
- WildUtah 11y ago"So irrational" To me, it's transcendental.
- Kristine1975 11y agoThe question is whether it's normal.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AndyMcConachie 11y agoI blame it on unicode. Without unicode these terrorists would not be able to communicate with impunity.
- ceejayoz 11y agoIn fairness, character encoding is clearly the work of terrorists.
- zymhan 11y agoWow, I read this article on Sunday, and had I not seen this post I never would have realized the Times no longer stood by what they said.
- coldcode 11y agoYou could plan terrorist activity using postcards. Should we ban the Post Office? You could use phone calls from pay phones (where they still exist) and people used to do that all the time to plan crimes. You could go on vacation together and plan something. You could use voice or text chat in an online game to plan stuff. The people in charge of these organizations are not the suicide bombers; the head folks know full well what to use to avoid getting caught.
- eterm 11y agoYour post seems to miss the fact that the mail, phone calls and popular chat services are already logged, and asking for encryption back-doors is just wanting that process to continue.
- ceejayoz 11y agoMail may be logged, but they're certainly not opening most envelopes to read their contents.
- thomasjames 11y agoPostcard steganography. Would be downright devious.
- WildUtah 11y agoI have a friend who used to get erotic messages from her mathematician boyfriend steganographically encrypted on postcards. I had to show her how to decrypt them. It was pretty standard cryptanalysis once I guessed that the messages existed. Some of them were filthy.
- JshWright 11y agoStenographically encrypted in the printed image? How would that work?
- metalliqaz 11y ago
- raddad 11y agoWhat I found interesting is the method of communication was outlined in "Homeland" by Cory Doctorow (Or perhaps it was in "Little Brother"). I suppose we need to outlaw books now also.
- scotty79 11y ago> writing messages via in-game functions, like spelling words with dropped items or shooting walls I'm kinda ashamed I haven't thought of that.
- spacemanmatt 11y agoOh man. Writing banned words with object drops (or corpses) was classic humor back in the EQ days. Even better if your writing made the zone laggy.
- jcl 11y agoI think this may be the most important thing in the article. If the conspirators really were communicating via in-game ephemera, the communication probably wasn't encrypted at all. If so, the hurdle that the security forces faced is not that they couldn't access the communication, but that they couldn't interpret it. And that just shows how little a mandatory backdoor policy would help: being able to read something doesn't mean you can understand it. It's always possible for someone to come up with a communication scheme that you didn't anticipate or can't interpret, and you can't legislate away that capability. So a backdoor policy doesn't trade privacy for safety -- instead it trades privacy for a chance at safety, and pretty much just safety from careless, unprepared attackers.
- Malstrond 11y agoIt would not be the first time that obscurity is confused with security.
- paganel 11y agoIt reminded me of the "The Wire"'s Season 5 (I think), where Marlo Stanfield's guys were communicating with each other by sending photos of street maps, which would indicate meetup locations. It now seems easy to catch, but at that time (2008) it was still kind of a new thing to send data (like photos) instead of plain texts.
- ndm00 11y agoThis issue brings up a larger point that many in the tech world have ignored for awhile. Now that end to end encryption is easily accessible by everyone, how do the authorities figure out beforehand when a terrorist attack will take place? The answer is not banning encryption technologies or giving authorities a 'key' as the FBI director has proposed. But now authorities have a very difficult problem on their hands. Encryption can't be contained, and the authorities need to figure out how to still catch the bad guys.
- x1798DE 11y agoIt's not like they were particularly good at stopping terrorism before encryption became widespread. The problem is that they think they can stop all terrorist attacks, which is impossible.
- jrcii 11y agoThe right answer is intelligence gathering in the field, the old fashioned way. It's the only method that's compatible with freedom of expression and the 4th amendment.
- yAnonymous 11y agoYeah, remember 2003, when encryption wasn't mainstream. They did a much better job back then. You make it sound like there was a point when broad surveillance helped against terrorism, but it never did.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoThat's interesting, I don't remember the jobs of law enforcement and intelligence ever having supposed to been easy. In fact, we nominally have plenty of safeguards meant to make their job difficult. That's the point. If they don't feel like devoting effort to get past barriers, then the case is not worthwhile to pursue. Catching the bad guys is easier than ever, encryption or not.
- err4nt 11y agoIt takes what it has always taken: good police work. Encryption is like envelopes for the mail. They can be broken into with enough force, but their purpose it to shield the contents of the message from those handling it in transit. A post card offers no such protection. So suppose the banned encryption (envelopes). Im sure the government would still reauire envelopes. As would anybody dealing with health records. Or banking, financial stuff has a legitimate need for secrecy. So they ned envelopes. Pretty soon what you have is a class of people allowed to USE envelopes and a class of people not allowed it use them. Like envelopes, encryption is an idea, not an inplementation. They may block you from using this tool or that tool, just like a government could make selling pre-made envelopes illegal - but the IDEA of encryption is simple just like the idea of an envelope. Anybody with paper, scissors, and glue can fashion their own envelope. Encyption is the same, one person can dream up an build their own encoder and you can never ban or prevent that idea from being used.
- GrinningFool 11y agoIncreasingly we're seeing 'encryption' discussed in mainstream media as a tool that can only be used for nefarious ends. Kind of like how they talked about "cookies" in the late 90s and early 00s. It's unfortunate that there's no way [without a lot of money] to launch a campaign that highlights the fact that most sensitive online transactions rely on encryption - banking, purchasing, etc - to protect you from The Bad People who want to steal your critical financial information. That would also highlight that it's not just about keeping secrets from the government - in fact, that's the smallest fraction of it.
- fukusa 11y agoWe have to get rid of this narrative of bad versus good people while we're at it. It removes every bit of nuance from the discussion.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoUnfortunately this is a very widespread notion in culture and is helped by major religions.
- copperred 11y agoThat's the point. What the Paris attackers did makes them bad people. It's not up for debate.
- rlonstein 11y agoI read that unsubstantiated assertion in the print edition (I know, dinosaur. I like a morning paper) and called it out to my family. I'm saddened and amused at how the press is led around by the nose.
- post_break 11y agoCould it not be that what the article said was wrong, but that someone twisted their arm for correctly exposing how they were communicating?
- squozzer 11y agoTypical New Pravda SOP. Drop an unsubstantiated rumor blaming something the government doesn't like then retract it once e damage has been done.
- zamalek 11y ago> Dang it, guys. Encryption is now illegal for us to use, everyone uninstall PGP. Said no terrorist or criminal. Once the cat has been let out of the bag there is no getting it in again.
- privacy101 11y agoor ask Google, Apple, and Microsoft to automatically un-install the nefarious applications from all computers and phones... not sure what they would do about Linux ...
- cordite 11y agoI've started seeing this like locking down all coffee houses just because it is a convenient place to meet and discuss things and some people happen to plan terrible acts in these places.
- WildUtah 11y agoCountries fail to police immigration, promising us that it will go well and we'll all benefit. Then they demand our civil liberties so they can police the immigrants they invited. And our taxes have to rise to pay welfare to them. But don't worry; a few million more and we'll all be better off.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- laotzu 11y agoHowgh, my fellow native american or indigenous friend. I too grow weary of these pale face immigrants taking our land, genociding us, and telling us we'll all be better off.
- exabrial 11y agoI encourage open thought rather than mob attacks on unpopular opinions. Anyone have a link to the original article?
- ColinWright 11y agoA quick search of this thread reveals: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10580586 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10580586 https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/16/world/europe/paris-attackers-communicated-with-isis-officials-say.html https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http://www.nytime...
- exabrial 11y agoI don't really see anything too terrible about the article.
- unethical_ban 11y agoJim Bamford of Foreign Policy said encryption was part of the way this was done. On the Diane Rehm Show, when asked what we know, he said "not much, but that encryption or anonymizers, like Tor, might have been used to hide their communications". So they're already working to plant that narrative in listeners' heads.
- CWuestefeld 11y ago"was done" vs "might have been" - you're making a big jump. If you weren't aware, Bamford is actually one of the good guys in this debate. Don't make him say things he didn't say.
- rbcgerard 11y ago"One key premise here seems to be that prior to the Snowden reporting, The Terrorists helpfully and stupidly used telephones and unencrypted emails to plot, so Western governments were able to track their plotting and disrupt at least large-scale attacks. That would come as a massive surprise to the victims of the attacks of 2002 in Bali, 2004 in Madrid, 2005 in London, 2008 in Mumbai, and April 2013 at the Boston Marathon." https://theintercept.com/2015/11/15/exploiting-emotions-about-paris-to-blame-snowden-distract-from-actual-culprits-who-empowered-isis/ https://theintercept.com/2015/11/15/exploiting-emotions-abou...
- ewzimm 11y agoIt's even more absurd than that. The premise is that we can have a public worldwide debate that emphasizes how important encryption is to successfully carrying out terrorist attacks, convince the world to give up their privacy for the sake of safety, and after the majority of the protestors have been defeated by public awareness that encryption and terrorism go hand-in-hand, the terrorists will go back to using phone calls and unencrypted email.
- colund 11y agoIf (almost) everyone who is not a terrorist were to give up encryption, then it would be much easier to track down/narrow down the terrorists if they keep using it, no?
- mjmaher 11y agoI don't think so, as far as I know encrypted data doesn't really have a signature that can be easily spotted
- marcosdumay 11y agoIt does, it looks random (hight entropy). Yes, measured data and unmarked compressed data have this same property, as do actual random data. But is does not look like 9 nines of false positive rate are a concern to those people.
- strictfp 11y agoKind of like how they used guns!
- exelius 11y agoIn my mind, it comes down to what a society's priorities are. If the priorities are Freedom > all, then encryption is a necessary tool. If the priorities are Prosperity > Safety > Freedom > all, then society will run roughshod over freedom.
- shanemhansen 11y agoI've always viewed this as a false choice. If you give up your freedom you won't get anything in return. You won't be safer and you won't be more prosperous. <insert Ben Franklin quote here>.
- laotzu 11y ago>A politic minister will study to lull us into security, by granting us the full extent of our petitions. The warm sunshine of influence would melt down the virtue, which the violence of the storm rendered more firm and unyielding. In a state of tranquillity, wealth and luxury, our descendants would forget the arts of war, and the noble activity and zeal which made their ancestors invincible. Every art of corruption would be employed to loosen the bond of union which renders our assistance formidable. When the spirit of liberty which now animates our hearts and gives success to our arms is extinct, our numbers will accelerate our ruin, and render us easier victims to tyranny. Ye abandoned minions of an infatuated ministry, if peradventure any should yet remain among us!—remember that a Warren and Montgomery are numbered among the dead. Contemplate the mangled bodies of our countrymen, and then say, What should be the reward of such sacrifices ? Bid us and our posterity bow the knee, supplicate the friendship, and plough, and sow, and reap, to glut the avarice of the men who have let loose on us the dogs of war to riot in our blood, and hunt us from the face of the earth? If ye love wealth better than liberty, the tranquillity of servitude, than the animating contest of freedom—go from us in peace. We ask not your counsels or arms. Crouch down and lick the hands which feed you. May your chains set lightly upon you, and may posterity forget that ye were our countrymen. -Sam Adams, American Independence Speech, August 1, 1776. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/American_Independence https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/American_Independence
- ck2 11y agoWaiting for the day when it is insisted that only criminals/terrorists use end-to-end encryption. I'm not surprised by liberals who want this and think government is mother/father (to be clear I am progressive) but I am REALLY surprised by conservatives that now want government monitoring every part of their citizen's lives.
- hackuser 11y agoThe government and business have built a state of surveillance far beyond anything dreamt of a couple of decades ago, with massive continuing investment. Yet the tool of surveillance was unable to stop this attack. Now they want more surveillance, but maybe it's the wrong tool for this job. Surveillance seems to have reached that place on the technology adoption curve where people get a little over-enthusiastic and blindly think it solves every problem, and they haven't yet realized it's a tool which, like all tools, is good for for things but not for others. (That ignores the massive cost to individuals and to our societies of surveillance.)
- declan 11y agoIt's true that the NYT pulled (or dramatically rewrote, close enough) an article claiming: "The attackers are believed to have communicated using encryption technology..." You can see the original version here thanks to Archive.org: https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http:/www.nytimes.com/2015/11/16/world/europe/paris-attackers-communicated-with-isis-officials-say.html https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http:/www.nytimes... But then the NYT doubled down on the terrorists-and-encryption angle in a separate story here: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/17/world/europe/encrypted-messaging-apps-face-new-scrutiny-over-possible-role-in-paris-attacks.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/17/world/europe/encrypted-mes... Which says in the second sentence: "Obama administration officials say the Islamic State has used a range of encryption technologies over the past year and a half, many of which defy cracking by the National Security Agency..." HN discussion of that second story is here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10579201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10579201
- dboreham 11y agoThis is all covered pretty well in the latest Bond movie.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agohttp://www.newsdiffs.org/article-history/www.nytimes.com/2015/11/16/world/europe/paris-attackers-communicated-with-isis-officials-say.html http://www.newsdiffs.org/article-history/www.nytimes.com/201...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nab 11y agoThis link implies that the NYT is backtracking about a piece apparently "blaming encryption." The NYT article referenced did not at all focus on encryption, and it didn't go so far as to definitively blame encryption. The only paragraph discussing encryption is buried in the middle of the article. """ The attackers are believed to have communicated using encryption technology, according to European officials """ The lede did not mention encryption at all: "The attackers in Friday’s terrorist assault in Paris communicated at some point beforehand with known members of the Islamic State in Syria, officials on both sides of the Atlantic say." https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http:/www.nytimes.com/2015/11/16/world/europe/paris-attackers-communicated-with-isis-officials-say.html https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http:/www.nytimes...
- kohito 11y agoyou're saying its only possible the NYT "blamed encryption" if encryption was the article's main topic or the article's lede?
- azernik 11y agoSince there was so much other content there, the pulling of the article could have had nothing to do with that one sentence.
- davesque 11y agoNo, actually they're not saying that at all. They're saying that the article only barely mentions encryption and doesn't try to push an opinion on the matter.
- the_watcher 11y agoThe biggest problem with the "encryption is too good" crowd is that they simply refuse to recognize the simple fact that if there is a way in for them, there is a way in for others. If there is a back door, it's simply no longer effective encryption.
- davesque 11y agoHonestly, I don't doubt at all that intelligence officials would love to exploit FUD about this situation to further their agendas, but this article's claim that the NYT article was "blaming encryption" is kind of a stretch. Read the article linked on archive.org and decide for yourself: https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http:/www.nytimes.com/2015/11/16/world/europe/paris-attackers-communicated-with-isis-officials-say.html https://web.archive.org/web/20151115191248/http:/www.nytimes...
- compbio 11y ago> citing unidentified “European officials” That was the Belgium minister. > It was not clear whether the encryption was part of widely used communications tools, like WhatsApp, which the authorities have a hard time monitoring, or something more elaborate. "PlayStation 4 is even more difficult to keep track of than WhatsApp," Jambon [Belgium minister] said at a debate in Brussels. "The most difficult communication between these terrorists is via PlayStation 4," he said. "It’s very, very difficult for our services — not only Belgian services but international services — to decrypt the communication that is done via PlayStation 4." http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/video-games/playstation/11997952/paris-attacks-playstation-4.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/video-games/playstatio... So: It is less about encryption (PGP, Tor) than it is about companies running their own communication networks with encryption, and the intelligence agencies have increasingly more trouble tracking extremists using games or phone apps to plan their attacks. Is that Snowden's fault? No. Did Snowden's leaks contribute to companies making their networks harder to tap? Definitely. Another tidbit that is coming out is that nearly all terrorists were already on the radar of the intelligence services and had documents tracking their radicalization. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/16/french-and-belgian-intelligence-knew-paris-attackers-had-jihadi-backgrounds http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/16/french-and-belg... Apparently there was a failure to share and to make actionable sense of this information. Is that Snowden's fault? No. Did Snowden's broad indiscriminate leaks cause less willingness to share information between intelligence agencies? Definitely. This is, in my view, a side-effect of these revelations, but a real effect too. I don't want to weigh up these two on a scale, as that will be difficult and everyone will have different priorities anyway. BTW: This gaffe/Chinese whispers started with a Forbes article and New York Times fell for it: http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2015/11/14/why-the-paris-isis-terrorists-used-ps4-to-plan-attacks/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2015/11/14/why-the-pa... "Correction: It has not been confirmed, as originally written, that a console was found as a result of specific Belgian terror raids. Minister Jambon was speaking about tactics he knows ISIS to be using generally. "
- downandout 11y agoThis same narrative has been massaged into hundreds of stories on the attacks. These news outlets are doing surveillance-crazed politicians' bidding for them by creating the public perception that these people would still be alive were it not for encryption. Perhaps the Times realized how dangerously stupid this narrative is and is working to do something about it. We are told that if we stop going to the mall or sporting events out of fear, then the terrorists win. They also win if we lose our privacy rights in response to this or any other attack.
- halayli 11y agoIf the secret service is relying on snooped messages as the main affective method to catch criminals then it's doing it wrong. They're stuck in the WW2 mentality where they could listen on radio and decrypt codes. Back then it was very effective but that was 60 years ago. Secret services should consider decrypted communication as a nice to have, but they should be completely capable of being effective without decrypting communication channels and listening on private citizens.
- pbreit 11y agoMany are proposing a false dichotomy. Fact is, we can have privacy AND mitigate terrorist activity.
- Quanticles 11y ago> “’The most difficult communication between these terrorists is via PlayStation 4,’ the minister said, three days before the terrorist attacks in Paris. ‘It’s very, very difficult for our services — not only Belgian services but international services — to decrypt the communication that is done via PlayStation 4.'” The Onion is going to have a really hard time topping this.
- tripzilch 11y ago> The Times later posted a second article citing an anonymous “European counterterrorism official” who was quoted saying authorities’ “working assumption is that these guys were very security aware,” We should make laws against security awareness if it enables terrorists!
- tripzilch 11y agoI believe the conclusion of the article is the most important takeaway: (so, points for good writing, I guess :) ) > Former CIA Deputy Director Michael Morell said he suspects the Paris attacks will weigh heavily on the encryption fight ongoing. > “I think what we’re going to learn is that these guys are communicating via these encrypted apps, the commercial encryption, which is very difficult, if not impossible, for governments to break, and the producers of which don’t produce the keys necessary for law enforcement to read the encrypted messages,” Morell said on CBS’ “Face the Nation” Sunday. > “We need to have a public debate about this,” he continued. “We have in a sense had a public debate — that debate was defined by Edward Snowden, and the concern about privacy. I think we’re now going to have another debate about that — it’s going to be defined by what happened in Paris.” So, "They" want to misuse the attacks on Paris as an excuse to attract mind and screen-time for an alternative counter-debate about privacy and encryption. But Snowden got to "define the debate" because of the new information (as well as evidence for old information) he brought to the public, it's an entirely different thing if you're a politician grabbing screen-time and "define the debate" to a shocked audience over a terror-attack--which is exactly what the terrorists' want. Any freedoms or security taken away from us as a response to a terror-attack, is a win for the terrorists.
- wishiknew 11y agoI don't know why people are considering these terrorists to be so smart. They arrived at the Stade de France and were naively thinking they'd be able to come inside with explosives tied to them. In January, they didn't even know where the Charlie Hebdo meeting room was, they had to ask for directions and were even sent the wrong way (at first). Really, I'm far from worrying about their communication's encryption as much as I worry about the lax government.
- asift 11y ago> as much as I worry about the lax government You mean the same governments that are already collecting everyone's private communications and swabbing babies for bomb residue at airports under the guise of stopping these types of things? It's not a lack of effort or resources that should be concerning, it's the sheer incompetence.
- wishiknew 11y agoNo, the point I was trying to make has nothing to do with communication. Molenbeek has been known to host radicalized Islamists for twenty years, I've heard on French TV this weekend. Encrypted communication or not, as long as governments sleep on such facts, we will see further attacks.
- whatever_dude 11y agoAs someone said[1] the damage is already done. Now everyone thinks that the terror attacks were perpetrated by Syrian refugees that were communicating through the PS4 network using encryption, and that nothing of this would have happened if videogames didn't exist, encryption was forbidden, and they hadn't sheltered refugees. [1] https://openparachute.files.wordpress.com/2015/01/amount.jpg https://openparachute.files.wordpress.com/2015/01/amount.jpg
- damosneeze 11y agoOne of the main problems with the NSA programs is that it targeted _everyone_. That just makes no sense. If you have a lead or probable cause on someone, great, track them and hack their messages. Collecting everyone's information to catch a terrorist only dilutes your search.