8 ms·
US homes have gotten huge – offsetting the gains from energy efficiency
- jseliger 11y agoThis can be read effectively in tandem with "The Efficiency Dilemma: If our machines use less energy, will we just use them more?" at http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/12/20/the-efficiency-dilemma http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/12/20/the-efficiency-..., which is about the Jevons Paradox.
- nathancahill 11y agoInteresting. The same applies to CPU and memory resources too.
- foobarian 11y agoAnd low flush toilets.
- pasbesoin 11y agoI am generally for efficiency and conservation, but goodness, how I hate those things. I understand some models these days may have two flush modes of differing volumes -- I guess, for #1 and #2 respectively. Or for waif vs. lumberjack. Maybe those work better. But otherwise, those damned "low flow (volume)" toilets just end up too often taking extra flushes, none of which work very well, and keep one standing around as well as a plunger at the ready next to the unit. OR, you're the next person, after someone who doesn't take such care, and you find you have to hold it a bit longer while you deal with their lingering... "surprise".
- Rapzid 11y agoThe outflow in other countries is much bigger and you very infrequently end up with a clog. I knew a guy a ways back who moved from the UK and complained about the pipe sizes. Now I live in NZ and I can tell you, they are too small in the US!
- ars 11y ago> but goodness, how I hate those things I bought the TOTO CST743S from Amazon. It's low flow and works amazingly - much better than the full flow one it replaced.
- aedocw 11y agoI have toilets that use a pint (or less) per flush[1], and do not suffer from clogs or other issues. Part of the problem is the design of the toilet, where you need the water in the holding tank to "flush" everything past the elbow. [1]http://www.sun-mar.com/prod_flush_seal.html http://www.sun-mar.com/prod_flush_seal.html
- josephpmay 11y agoA great example of why looking at the data alone leads to false conclusions
- dogma1138 11y agoThat's a good thing (the size not the energy thing) people need space, Europe could use a wakeup and start making bigger living spaces a 2 bedroom flat in London is the size (or smaller than) of some studios in the us and most 1 bed apartments.
- kevinskii 11y agoLast year we moved from a huge house in the boonies to a shoebox in a prime location. We still don't miss having the extra space. We spend 99% of our time at home in the family room just like we did before, and the small house is much easier to maintain. Also, having a lot of living space makes it hard not to stealthily accumulate junk. I had always prided myself on not doing this, but when we moved we ended up filling an entire 8'x30' dumpster with crap we no longer had room for and didn't really need.
- dogma1138 11y agoWhat's a shoebox(my 2 bed flat in central London is 53 sq/m I've seen plenty of sutios in NYC that size (~500-550 sq/f))? There have been plenty of studies that show that small apartments lead to actual physical and mental health issues. While I can accept your anecdotal case that you are very happy with your "shoebox" size apartment it doesn't mean it's good, beneficial or something that should be acceptable. Smaller housing means smaller kitchens which makes home cooking less pleasant and likely, not to mention that small apartments might have a kitchen which isn't fitted with more than a microwave a small fridge and a hotplate or a tiny stove. This leads to people using takeaway or eating at restaurants which isn't good for you, even if you go to the fanciest place you can think off the chances off that the food there is just as caloric and "healthy" as your run of the mill fast food. A 2-3 course meal at a good restaurant tends to have 1.5-2 times the calories that a super-sized McDonlands meal has, you can easily eat up 2000-3000 kcal in a restaurant with that nice appetizer, big juicy steak, and desert. Home cooking on the other hand results in many cases in much smaller caloric intake, and the act of cooking it self has quite a few positive mental and physical effects on it's own. Smaller housing means less family/entertainment space which means you usually can't invite many people in, which means you do your socializing outside usually again in restaurants/bars which is while plenty of fun and pretty acceptable also has a negative impact. Smaller housing means you are more likely to deffer having children or decide to upgrade your relationship status, smaller housing also makes many people feel like they do not get enough privacy at home even if they are very intimate with their partners which adds to stress. Smaller housing means usually means poorer air-quality, less light (smaller windows, less of them etc.) and general feeling of claustrophobia which can lead to depression even if you do not feel that it does. And this is just the tip of the iceberg because there are many more factors why people need their space, that doesn't mean you need to live in a 7 room house, it just means that the rooms you have need to be of sufficient size, and the overall design of the apartment needs to be more open and brighter. I honestly can't fathom why people actually argue that it's fine to live in a small apartment, I've seen places in London that have a folding bed and if the fridge is open you can't open your "front door". This is 5th Element level of quarters and we are openly accepting it, yes that 20 sq/m flat in IKEA looks extremely cool if it was a hotel room, or a dormitory it would be more than acceptable but for people to live in such place for any length of time is not something we should approve off not to mention push towards.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bkjelden 11y agoAnecdotally, I have a hard time buying the stat that homes today are only 31% more efficient than they were in 1970. I lived in a fairly large, brand new home for a couple years, and my energy bills were way lower than my friends who lived in smaller, older homes. Some of this was a much better insulated and tighter sealed house, some of it was more efficient HVAC units. IIRC, the air conditioner installed with the house had roughly twice the SEER rating of my parents and parent-in-laws units from the late 90s. And this was in a fairly mild northern climate - you can get units with even higher ratings, and if you're in a locale such as Arizona, Nevada, Texas, etc, I think you'd be more or less priced into doing so.
- watmough 11y agoI completely agree and have a solid anecdote. Summer electricity bill in Texas for my previous 1600 sqft house, about $100-$150 month for cooling from Texas ambient to 74 F. For our new 3200 sq ft house, we cool to 73 F, for the same cost!!!! That is the difference between a late 70's house, and modern construction, which is foam-filled up the wazoo.
- nickbauman 11y agoSo, then, your anecdote completely exemplifies OP's thesis: a house double the size and much more efficient uses the same energy. Vive la différence? You also mention foam filling, and by proxy, sealing. Many high efficiency homes achieve their efficiency by becoming effectively Tupperware® containers. Which isn't good for the occupants (unless living in Mordor is a goal). Air exchangers are required, muting the gains on efficiency.
- roel_v 11y ago" Air exchangers are required, muting the gains on efficiency" God not this again. Active ventilation in 2015 (actually, in 2005) has heat exchangers that recoup most of the heat and do not nearly negate the efficiency advantages and improved comfort of a sufficiently air-tight house. Please review all the literature from the last 20 years which will tell you exactly this.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 13thLetter 11y agoThe fetishization of "energy efficiency" in this context is weird, like the old joke about a machine whose only specification is that it should run noiselessly. Houses don't exist to be energy efficient; they exist so that people can live in them. If those people want big houses and can pay for them -- as well as the additional energy they require to operate, of course -- why shouldn't they have them? If there's an argument here at all it's for having energy prices take into account whatever externality Vox is specifically concerned about, not for forcing people to live in smaller homes.
- Spooky23 11y agoI agree. Energy efficiency is a big scam -- I had the bad fortune of buying Maytag appliances in 2006. The company was going bankrupt, and their strategy to meet energy quotas was to undersize motors... Leading to dead appliances. Ditto with things like boilers who routine service requirements eat up most of the efficiency savings. Light bulbs are worse. Shopping for a bulb is like buying a car. And the focus on stupid efficiency gimmicks that save minimal resources (an efficient washing machine saves $30/year) distracts from more useful retrofits like insulation, windows, solar hot water, etc.
- DanBC 11y ago> Energy efficiency is a big scam It works both ways. Some vacuum cleaners had higher power rating labels to make buyers think the machines were more powerful. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-29021886 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-29021886 Disposable washing machines are definitely bad for the environment though.
- maxerickson 11y agoWhite goods are pretty well recycled in the US. I took a little refrigerator and dehumidifier, which both contained freon, to the scrap yard in a small town. They have their accepting set up so that they charge a recovery fee on the freon (which then they sell, but whatever). The scrap value of those appliances was less than the freon fees, but the paymaster worked it out so that I got 50 cents back or whatever. That doesn't explain what they will do with a washer, but it demonstrates that even a small operation is relatively sophisticated in what it is up to, and appliances are generally worth enough for them to deal with.
- ars 11y agoThe relationship between energy use and size of a home is hardly linear. The area goes up by the power of two compared to circumference (which is what matters for heating/cooling). > US homes have gotten huge — offsetting the gains from energy efficiency Quite the opposite, I actually see the data in reverse - energy usage per square foot goes down BECAUSE houses are larger! Since energy usage is pretty much constant (per family), if you increase the size of the home your ratio looks much better. They should actually measure energy per person to see if energy usage went down. I suppose a second refrigerator would consume more energy but I don't agree that a larger home and a second refrigerator necessarily go hand in hand.
- Retric 11y agoLighting would generally increase in a larger home fairly close to 1:1 per square foot. Water heating would more or less ignore home size, so it's fairly complex change.
- tw04 11y agoI can't speak for others, but I can tell you as someone with a larger home, who can afford a larger home, I've also replaced almost all of my lights with LEDs because I can also afford it and see the long-term benefits both from a power savings perspective, as well as a longevity perspective. I'd imagine my lights use less power than the average household.
- eitally 11y agoDitto, and replaced a tank water heater with a tankless.
- Retric 11y agoLed's are 15% more Efficent than florecent lights so they don't make that big of a difference. Also, exterior lighting tends to be far more common on large homes pluss decorative lighting like christmass lights. So, on average things do track closer to 1:1 than you might think.
- 11y ago
- DannyBee 11y agoErrr, the numbers on the graph don't match the headline, at all. This is partially because they compare two very different percentages, and expect them to cancel each other out, but they don't ;) Let's take https://cdn3.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/Nal5V8NG4BaEYnFL2lbcskLtaUE=/1600x0/filters:no_upscale()/cdn0.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/4251055/FT_15.11.04_residentialEnergyIntensity_310px2.png https://cdn3.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/Nal5V8NG4BaEYnFL2lbcskLtaUE... In 1970, we have 150 btu/sq ft and let's be generous and say 1500 sq ft. So we have a home using 225000 BTU. Now, we have 101.8 btu/sq ft, and 1864 sq ft. That's 188264 BTU. 17% is not nothing, nor is it "offsetting the gains". Note, you can't use the 101.8 number for the new housing graph, since it's an average over all homes. (In fact, you can't really just multiply any of these numbers and have sensible results, but hey, it's a news story!) You'd have to find an average new housing btu/sq ft, which they don't provide. Also note: Greater energy efficiency is entirely possible. You can easily halve the heating energy requirement, for example, by using ground source heat pumps in most places (my GSHP was a 46 SEER , 5.3 COP unit). But this has high monetary cost to retrofit (When done during construction, and factored into the price of a house, it basically costs "not a lot more"). Or you could use per-room mini-splits, or whatever. It's just that people don't care, and so the only thing that forces higher energy efficiency in most cases is building code changes, not consumer demand.
- monochromatic 11y agoAlso no mention of the fact that larger homes tend to be multiple stories, and thus they have less surface area per square foot. So insulation efficiency tends to go up as home size increases.
- iofj 11y agoIt's a fun example of Jevon's paradox though. The more efficient the insulation ... the more heat is needed to warm houses (because people don't consider the cost of heating anymore is the reason usually given). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zurn 11y agoIn comparison to other first world countries the housing square footage is very high but peanuts compared to residential energy consumption. For example USA has 77 residential m2/capita and Germany has 55 m2/capita (50% more), but USA electricty consumption is 4.5 MWh/a/capita vs Germany's 1.7 MWh/a/capita (165% more). http://shrinkthatfootprint.com/average-household-electricity-consumption http://shrinkthatfootprint.com/average-household-electricity... vs http://shrinkthatfootprint.com/how-big-is-a-house http://shrinkthatfootprint.com/how-big-is-a-house
- ilaksh 11y agoHere is my idea for a radical way to reverse that trend: https://runvnc.github.io/tinyvillage/ https://runvnc.github.io/tinyvillage/