24 ms·
Why I Quit Ordering from Uber-For-Food Startups
- jvm 11y agoThis is nearly incoherent… He doesn't order from Sprig because it's too efficient? I mean you are welcome to value whatever you want, but if you're against efficiency you will probably have a problem with nearly every for-profit business; all his complaints are at least as true of any restaurant that hires full time employees. > In the hypothetical future we can label Full Josephine, many people don’t cook, but some people cook a lot more, and better, than ever before, and all of us, cooks and non-cooks, derive pleasure from that." Minus rhetorical flourishes, this is identical to the Sprig future, with the difference that in the case of Sprig the cooks are compensated with full-time employment rather than the joy of cooking. It sounds like the author doesn't really value that, but I bet a lot of Sprig employees do! The actual future: Some people cook for Josephine, some work for Sprig, some work for traditional restaurants, some people eat the above food, lots of people still make their own food.
- adminprof 11y agoI think his point is that Josephine has a sense of community, that the people behind the cooking are fully visible, whereas in Sprig the people are just cogs in a system.
- e_modad 11y agoBut are they just cogs in a machine? The author betrays his own thoughts on the subject by discussing it that way. I order delivery all the time and have never though of the cooks and delivery people as "cogs in a machine." They're people with jobs, with their own complex lives. It's not my responsibility to worry if the delivery boy who's a Sophomore is having trouble doing his homework because he's working part time for Sprig. I tip well and always smile and don't feel guilty that it's convenient.
- protomyth 11y agoThe author isn't against efficiency. The author wants a human touch and doesn't believe Sprig provides that. This is a "oh, the humanity" article.
- rhizome 11y agoIn the service industries, a human touch costs extra.
- jacinda 11y agoI thought his point was that Sprig promotes a more "megacorp" future where if you enjoy cooking and want to do it for a living you must work for Sprig or a similar megacorp as an employee, with little agency in your cooking or career. On the other hand, he thinks Josephine's model promotes a future where telecommunications helps connect people who are more akin to small-business owners than employees with customers. These people then have more agency in their cooking (in addition to the human connection with customers). I personally think that eventually AIs will be able to master cooking as well so we won't have human cooks involved at all except as a fashion statement.
- AJ007 11y agoThis is very relevant http://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2015/08/31/436377616/the-restaurant-with-no-visible-workers http://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2015/08/31/436... I have been starting to think, what if in the future we have all of these platforms - like Uber - and the just suck? Honestly the mediocre UberX drivers now are considerably worse than the average cab driver (city specific.) Some combination of IP law and marketplace-platform dominance may enable fairly mediocre exchange platforms to exist at scale for a really long time and be difficult for anyone to disrupt. Craigslist, eBay, aren't that great and in some cases are downright horrible, but once all of the buyers congregate there, its hard for innovation to exist in either the classifieds or auction space. What if IP law, patents, trademarks, made it really hard to even offer specific types of services? Contrarian thinking, and quite negative, but seeing Uber go from incredible and high quality to fair made me realize that maybe at scale some of this stuff won't be as joyful.
- hobs 11y agoI think you are very likely close to the mark, and that is because the switching cost for these types of services (due to networking effects) means that the shoddy but working service will last a LONG time.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoWe may get a wild west of crappy deregulated services, and then through many decades of blood and tears we'll regulate them back into order. We've done that once, little over a century ago.
- gozo 11y agoI think his "objection" is similar to mine in that technology supposedly promises that everyone can be a producer, but instead we are getting even more centralization. We see the same thing in technology, were instead of open standards we get e.g. Facebook. Or in startups were the prospects of actually competing with one of the larger players is almost theoretical at this point. A lot of people are fine with living for the moment hoping they can make it rich before opportunities shift. Others think more about what future they want to see.
- mc32 11y agoTechnology never promises anything. People may have presumptions, projections, etc. But technology itself never makes promises. Some individuals may make some claims, but you can get all kids of claims from all kinds of people.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vonklaus 11y agoI agree that there is something off putting about these companies in that, as a cynic, I think they are simply putting a nice whitelabel wrapper on someone else's work. That being said, it is hard to make the case that this is centralization and I have concluded that I believe these businesses are good because: * Everyone is a private contractor, they are free to make their own choices and work (or not work) for a company. * They can be flexible service providers and they can create their own reputation. * Companies like airbnb/uber/sprig simply provide a platform . It is likely that many platforms will arise as for some of these businesses the barriers to entry are pretty low. The workers and producers can be on all platforms or go completely independent but Uber without driver's isn't a 50b company. * If your options are make some money in the "sharing economy" or make no money in the "real economy" I think you would choose to hop in. i see this as the new websearch model. Companies provide the best results and ratings, while offering ancillary support to users and charge them instead of showing adverts. the problem is if one gets really good, really powerful and effectively controls a lions share of virtually all of the search results routing all queries and related services through a single provider. lets hope that if that were to happen that not only would they not be evil but that they would good.
- wonnage 11y ago> A harried courier extracts your meal from a fat insulated bag; you say “thank you,” close the door, and feel bad for a moment about the differences between your lives. People have been delivering food since before tech startups ~~~disrupted~~~ delivery, but enjoy that self-congratulatory pity
- minikomi 11y agoI enjoyed delivery driving while at university. If it suits your personality, and you enjoy listening to music, it's really not a bad part-time job at all. You get really good at priority balancing too!
- zyxley 11y ago> People have been delivering food since For the urbanites among the ancient Romans, food vendors (and even things like grab-and-go street vendors and fast food restaurants) were a normal part of life, since their apartments generally didn't have personal kitchens. I can't find a source for it, but I have to imagine they had at least some personal food delivery services.
- pjmlp 11y agoPompei had lots of small street restaurants, from what one can tell from the ruins. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/history/pompeii/9850077/Pompeii-exhibition-the-food-and-drink-of-the-ancient-Roman-cities.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/history/pompeii/9850077/Pompeii-e... So I imagine it is possible many would do some kind of deliveries as well.
- brc 11y agoThe wood fired pizza (and oven design) dates to roman times.
- virtualritz 11y agoNo, that was just flat bred, aka focaccia. Pizza only came to be much later, when the tomato got introduced to Europe, from South America. And when people eventually found out that many varieties of tomatoes are not only not poisonous but also well tasting. :)
- protomyth 11y agoSadly, I'm guessing Josephine is illegal (well, the home cook part) in many cities in the US. It's in the same grouping as paid dinner parties.
- martingordon 11y agoThat was my first thought when I read about Josephine. It appears as though selling home-made food recently became legal in California[1] (after the cook has passed an online course). I imagine most other states won't be so amenable to passing legislation that lowers food safety standards. New York, for example, allows home production of only a few category of foods and explicitly prohibits direct internet sales[2]. [1]: http://www.forbes.com/sites/instituteforjustice/2014/01/29/california-legalized-selling-food-made-at-home-and-created-over-a-thousand-local-businesses/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/instituteforjustice/2014/01/29/c... [2]: http://www.agriculture.ny.gov/fs/consumer/processor.html http://www.agriculture.ny.gov/fs/consumer/processor.html
- sithadmin 11y agoI'd venture to guess that it's illegal in most cities in the US. Legal codes requiring certain minimum standards exist for good reasons. Home-scale kitchens are impossible to scale to commercial levels of quality and service without cutting corners that can make food dangerous.
- venomsnake 11y ago> Legal codes requiring certain minimum standards exist for good reasons. And sometimes for bad reasons. Couple of examples - cooking meat to 160 F / 71 C, Nycity inventing dangers of sous vide. The whole zone thing. Food codes sometimes grossly misinterpret or twist science. Or are made towards large scale operation - you will almost certainly have contamination when cracking 1 000 000 eggs. But with basic chance of even having salmonella in the egg 1/20000 even very sloppily prepared breakfast will be safe.
- zeroonetwothree 11y ago
- alaskamiller 11y agoTrying way, way too hard. On demand food businesses are just catering companies. Catering companies have always existed. Bolt on pizza delivery magic, paired with remote-button access from your little black mirror that constantly tracks your coordinates/altitude and now it's a daily faustian dilemma weighing too heavy? Do you want another app to help you with that too? From the article the author's main point is this: Sprig-type operations drain agency and expertise out of the world. They centralize, aiming to build huge hubs with small spokes; their innermost mechanisms are hidden. They depend on humans behaving as interchangeable units of labor. He just doesn't like that a store exists to cater to his demand. How gauche to have to interact with a store that's not a store! He then wax romantically about some weird hippie future where it's much more fun to have your neighbors cooking for each other like one big timeless block party. That's called a marketplace. An unregulated, cottage protected, open marketplace! That must be better better than a store but as lovely as that sounds to mingle with a range of people to get a bowl of pho or some sandwich one has to face the fact that every marketplace ends up centralized. Every one. An open marketplace is a winners take all video game. Look at eBay and its class of power-sellers that dropship or flip their Alibaba account. Look at Fiverr and its class of power-users that end up dominating the search results. You just end up dealing with the most polished store for the sake of what being a store brings to the table. The consistency, quality, and ease. So wait, really what's the point here? What are we really trying to discover and realize about ourselves today? That treating people as interchangeable economic units is bad but this hippie fuzzy feeling way is less bad? As opposed to just cooking yourself or going to a restaurant? Maybe this is just a promoted native post. Who knows. But it notches up another line about how frustrating annoying Berkeley and its residents are. For extra credit contrast this piece to another post today by New York Times on the culture of GoFundMe community and a response by nostrademons Per https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10526447 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10526447 On the whole, I think this is a good trend - it makes the economy more efficient, it encourages people to celebrate diversity instead of shunning it, and it's how the upper classes have operated for a long time, which is the source of a major power imbalance where corporations & rich people feel entitled to ask for anything and then working-class people feel ashamed to refuse. I hope you take that, stuff it in your pipe and smoke it, guy.
- deleted 11y ago
- mastermojo 11y agoI see a future where a much smaller percentage of people cook. Roughly equivalent in percentage and frequency as adults that would play a musical instrument or tend to a garden. Right now a lot of people cook meals not just because they enjoy to do so, but because having someone else cook healthy meals for you all the time is too expensive. A "Full Sprig" society can hopefully leverage specialization and economies of scale the same way that people no longer keep hens for eggs. Yes, the feel-good-local-farm(kitchen)-to-table aspect is lost, but most people don't care about that.
- debaserab2 11y agoI very much doubt that. Cooking is a part of every culture. It's more than just being about a healthy meal. For many people it defines who you are. The on-demand technophiles are not representative of the majority.
- cooper12 11y agoSeriously. This is coming from a forum that believes that Soylent is the way of the future.
- hellbanner 11y agoA programmer told me that after 2 months on Soylent, he "Missed the feeling of eating" and returned to eating regularly. Evolution took a long time to evolve our DNA. It doesn't change easily.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI tried Joylent (a version of Soylent made in EU) for few weeks and I too "missed the feeling of eating" a little, but I recognized it as just a habit. The same kind of habit browsing HN is, with similar procrastination values.
- hellbanner 11y ago
- orthoganol 11y agoIn case anyone associated with Sprig reads this, I had written you guys off a while ago because I can't stand landing pages that do weird/ annoying scrolling. I just checked and it's still like that... please just make it a natural-scrolling page and I promise I'll give you a shot (instead of SpoonRocket which also does healthy).
- adminprof 11y agoAgreed. Please leave scrolling alone. It's the one constant we have in the world of unpredictable interfaces.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoIt's a sign of the upcoming Hipster Apocalypse. They take $50 million in VC money and come up with that POS website. And they they think they're "winning".
- halayli 11y agoHe has no proof what's going on behind the scenes, and jumped into conclusion and project a holier than thou attitude just because. People that write such articles should realize that they can cause a lot of damage to businesses. If you don't have significant evidence that people working for such companies are not treated well and are unhappy then go do your homework first, otherwise it's just unethical and irresponsible to publish your intuitions and project them as facts.
- woah 11y agoI don't think that reporters should feel that they are responsible for the companies they write about having a good PR day.
- drumdance 11y agoNo, but they should at least gather basic facts.
- meowface 11y agoAgreed, he seems highly critical of it based more on slippery slope fears than actual evidence of mistreatment or unethical behavior.
- e_modad 11y agoExactly. "Dystopian"? Hyperbole much? This person is just ordering delivery, leaving a nice tip and then making a huge assumption about the lives of the cooks and delivery people. It's not like the restaurants have child labor camps making you dim sum for Christ's sake.
- reedk 11y agoIt's important to note that this is not a news article and the writer, Robin Sloan, is not a journalist. This is an opinion piece by a (very good!) novelist. He is free to articulate his opinion without "significant evidence" and you are free to think his opinion is baseless.
- brc 11y ago
- datapolitical 11y agoThere's another option in between Sprig and Josephine that's both a bit slower and far more "human" in the way the author wants. Doordash brings you food from local restaurants (the same ones you eat at when you go out with your friends). It costs a little more than sprig, and it takes a couple more minutes. But the food is individualized and made to order. It's familiar, made by the human beings you can go talk to the next time you're in there during a night out. In short, it's the perfect in-between. And given the tone of the article, not all that surprising the author totally ignored it.
- Splines 11y agoPersonally I can never get behind any of these food startups, just because I find that they offer extremely little value. Sort of like grocery home-delivery, after awhile you realize the premium you're paying for something you can easily do yourself. I feel like this class of startups are needlessly attempting to add services on top of existing things that people can do themselves for much cheaper.
- zedadex 11y ago> We don’t know. We don’t get to know. We’re just here to press the button. I mean, I'm sure you could find out.
- aaronmhatch 11y agoIs it just me, or was that one difficult article to read? It's almost like he was told by the Atlantic to make this a long-form piece just because it's the Atlantic, so he tried to write an unnecessarily long and patch-worked narrative.
- gdubs 11y agoTangentially, Mark Bittman's food posts on the New York Times, like 'The Minimalist' - as well as his books - changed my life. His philosophy is that we do have time in our lives to cook, and that there can be great value in doing so. Personally, I find it to be a nice balance to being so heavily involved with technology all day.
- prezjordan 11y agoI've been looking for something like this in my life, but what's a good place to start learning how to cook? I'm a young single dude in his 20s, and the most I can do is boil some pasta. I work from home so time is not really a huge issue, I just don't know where to start. Any tips?
- jfim 11y agoLearn basic techniques (how to make an omelette, how to saute food, etc.) and extrapolate from there. You can also just look up recipes and read them beforehand to see if they're too complicated. Lots of delicious things are actually pretty simple to make. For example, you can take some chicken thighs, pour some olive oil, salt, pepper and lemon juice on top and stick them in an oven at 425F and you have a meal in about half an hour or so.
- HillRat 11y agoHarold McGee's "On Food and Cooking" is a great book to read (it kicked off the popularization of food science), and Alton Brown's "Good Eats" was a fantastic cooking show full of great kitchen geekery. I've also heard that "The Four-Hour Chef" (yes, God help us, same guy) is actually a good starter book. Also, "Cookwise" and "Bakewise." Great books. More personally, let me say that the best way to learn how to cook is to go to the market, find some stuff that looks interesting, and then figure out what to do with them. Pretty soon you'll have an intuitive idea of techniques to use with almost anything you can find, which is when the fun stuff really starts. Don't get intimidated! If you can cook pasta without ruining it, you have it in you to make duck-egg carbonara with house-cured bacon and Swiss chard over homemade fettuccine. Oh, and get some good knives and keep them sharp. Trust me.
- salimmadjd 11y agoOT I would NOT recommend any investors from investing in the uber-for-food space. Mainly because these businesses will ultimately parallel the competitiveness of the restaurant business. So at the end, you're ultimately investing in a restaurant chain business and not an Uber-like business.
- frozenport 11y agoAnother way to think of it is like a racket, if you don't join you suffer. Once everybody joins the customer base is the same. In this way, it makes for a good although distasteful(maybe) investment.
- xivzgrev 11y agoHe paints full Josephine in great color, but that's exactly what Airbnb is - connecting visitors with people want to host people in their homes. Airbnb doesn't dictate the experience beyond some guidelines, they don't hire hosts, etc. But We see Airbnb enabling bad actors on its platform, refusing to take action against them, posting ads all over san Francisco to sink prop f - acting like a mega Corp. Josephine is not mega Corp, yet. But imagine if it became huge. I bet it'd look more like sprig, and all the other mega corps, than the author would like. Pretty much the only wildly successful company I can think of that has not ended up acting like a mega Corp is craigslist.
- mreiland 11y agoI believe the owner of craigslist got sued over his refusal to maximize profit.
- thwarted 11y agoYou got a reference for that?, because since Craiglist is private, there doesn't seem to be much chance of a traditional "maximizing profit" in-the-shareholds-best-interst lawsuit going anywhere.
- maxerickson 11y agoHuffPo, but Ebay (a part owner at the time, haven't checked if they still are) sued Craig Newmark (and another individual at Craigslist): http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/09/10/craigslist-ebay-lawsuit-e_n_711795.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/09/10/craigslist-ebay-law... But it was not about profit maximization, Ebay argued that actions they took were harmful to the stake Ebay owned in the company. So it was just a more typical shareholder lawsuit. (It's unlikely that Craigslist has overtly stated that the purpose of the company is to maximize profit, so as long as Newmark controls a huge chunk of the company a lawsuit along those lines is going to be a tough hill to climb)
- thwarted 11y ago
- thejerz 11y agoLet me stand up for Sprig. They have, in my opinion, found the holy grail of McDonalds meets Whole Foods. They are serving organic food from local farms, made by local chefs, with the lowest carbon footprint of anyone -- all in a form factor that people will actually use. That's why I favor their future over that of Pizza Hut, Postmates, Uber Eats, and even Josephine. Instead of looking for faults, I think they deserve a round of applause.
- tequila_shot 11y agoAny experiences with Postmates? I keep ordering with them everyday and things are great so far.
- lightcatcher 11y agoI'm surprised HN is so against this article. I'm unhappy with the idea of "full Sprig" or "full Josephine". Furthermore, a "full Sprig" or "full Josephine" society is impossible with their current business models as I highly doubt their contractors have enough money to use their own services, especially if they get sick and have to deal with their uninsured medical costs. The lack of regulations around these services is just a way for the company to transfer more liabilities onto their contractors (cough employees) and reduce costs for themselves and their customers. I think all of these startups are "solving all the problems of being twenty years old, with cash on hand"[0] and do so by taking advantage (and perpetuating) massive income inequality. [0] http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/05/27/change-the-world http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/05/27/change-the-worl...
- TulliusCicero 11y ago> "solving all the problems of being twenty years old, with cash on hand"[0] Yeah, it's not like people with kids ever get take-out or delivery, right? Maybe this kind of issue is more relevant to affluent young people, but it's hardly irrevelant to others. There's nothing wrong with targeting a luxury market. Even middle class people can afford some luxuries.
- galago 11y agoI cook all my own food. I think it takes longer to deal with ordering it and having it delivered than it does to prepare--if you just want basic healthy dishes. A lot of the HN crew came from upper-middle class families, so they didn't learn this from their parents.
- aianus 11y agoMy mom cooked all of our meals growing up -- you could probably count on two hands the number of times I even set foot in a restaurant before leaving for college. But I could tell even as a child that spending an hour and a half cooking and cleaning every day doesn't make any sense when you're earning $40/h each and takeout for three costs $20 and requires no clean-up.
- Angostura 11y agoReally? I do the majority of my cooking and making a really nice chicken dhansak from scratch takes a lot longer that ordering from the local curry house
- kamilszybalski 11y agoI absolutely love this idea! I thought to myself - "cooked by people for people" as a good tag line
- tracker1 11y agoI really like the Josephine concept... mainly because I like "home cooking" I like to cook too. That said, I think that delivery services for food itself will probably become more common too. If restaurants could just make food, and ping an uber-like service for a driver to do the pickup/delivery it could work out better. Some restaurants aren't busy every day, being able to combine nearby pickups and deliveries for multiple restaurants could be a huge success. I do think it would take more than the combined infrastructure of grubhub + uber though. Simply because orchestration on grubhub is usually limited/partial menus, and the deliveries themselves can go from simple to complicated... living in a gated apartment (where there's a separate gate to the walk-up entrance, etc) makes deliveries difficult for someone who hasn't been there. I'd love to see restaurants able to share delivery drivers... and delivery drivers able to stay active, when a single location isn't busy, another may be, and to top that, it would allow more places to offer local delivery.
- bencollier49 11y agoThis is fascinating. I am waiting to read with interest what happens when these startups engage with UK catering hygeine laws.
- malandrew 11y agoFWIW the restaurants behind these actually do a lot better. Imagine you own a restaurant. You serve lunch and dinner. You kitchen is utilized from 11 to 2 for lunch and from 6 to 10 for dinner. With these apps your kitchen now is utilized before 11 prepping food for delivery for lunch and again from 2 to 6, prepping food for dinner. You're now making more on your capital investments and your kitchen staff is getting more hours. The people cooking the food are the same as if you went to a restaurant and the people delivering are the same that would be wait staff. If you didn't feel bad for these people before why would you feel bad for them now because there is an app in front?
- duncanawoods 11y agoI'd like to believe that but long-term, I expect the app is just a rent-seeking gatekeeper between the restaurant and their customers. We can expect the gatekeeper to turn the screw and make margins barely survivable eliminating quality leaving only a few low cost supply chain optimisers. We see the same pattern again and again. Small businesses should fight like hell to keep a direct relationship with their customers.
- jmonegro 11y agoGood use case for http://openbazaar.org http://openbazaar.org
- edoloughlin 11y ago> just a rent-seeking gatekeeper between the restaurant and their customers Couldn't agree more. I think this central to any discussion about the 'sharing economy'. Uber et al claim to be disrupting established monopolies and their marketing seeks to establish themselves as champions the free market. In reality, they are seeking to build a new monopoly, where they control the information about relationships in a system. Memory fails me at the moment, but I remember hearing a piece on a podcast recently (it might have been Radiolab) where they discussed how the 'live' view presented by Uber was a prediction coming from their algorithms and that no actual location data was available to the app on your phone until you booked a ride. I thought it was ironic that the new darlings of the free market were operating what was essentially a soviet-style central planning system, albiet with a very modern gloss.
- GrinningFool 11y agoI'm thinking maybe the author should get his thoughts in order and try again. That read like a collection of partially conceived ideas - it was a difficult read.
- scottmcdot 11y agoIs there a Josephine-equivalent in Melbourne?
- tsudot 11y agoDon't you need a license to sell cooked food? How do FDA regulations work on such kind of things?
- bambax 11y agoSo the author doesn't like Uber-for-food but loves Airbnb-for-food: is that so much different? Why does he not learn to cook instead, and meet people on the market where he would go buy ingredients?
- patio11 11y agoThere's something utterly perverse with the logic that "Some people are getting left-behind by the current economy; definitely definitely don't find them new, value-creating jobs because that will spirit-murder them."
- throwaway2048 11y agoThere is also something utterly preverse in pretending exploitative "sharing economy" companies create the kind of "value" that should be encouraged, especially as it displaces less exploitative companies. Which of course is a propagation of the very thing you claim they so nobly rescue these lost souls from!
- aianus 11y ago> especially as it displaces less exploitative companies. You're joking, right? Taxi drivers are practically indentured servants who begin each shift $100+ in the hole to some asshole rent-seeking capitalist who happened to buy the medallion at the right time 40 years ago.
- throwaway2048 11y agoThere is no doubt taxi cab arrangements are often exploitive, but this article is not about Uber. The "especially as" portion of my statement was in reference to circumstances where this model isn't just pushing out equally exploitative relationships. But even that being so in Uber's case, why are people championing the replacement of one abusive relationship with another?
- aianus 11y agoWhat's abusive about Uber? You drive whenever you want and their commission structure means their interests are aligned with yours and you can never lose money on a shift (at least not to Uber).
- lmartel 11y agoIt's clear that the author wants me to dislike Sprig and like Josephine, but after reading the entire article I honestly can't articulate a single reason why other than an abstract feeling of wholesomeness. This reads like satire.
- mbrock 11y agoAll this fetishizing of authentic human connections is making my misanthropy flare up.
- sgryzko 11y agoThis reminds me of a recent interview with Pete Trainor: https://soundcloud.com/uxpodcast/112-steve-portigal-pete-trainor-anjan-chatterjee#t=19:52 https://soundcloud.com/uxpodcast/112-steve-portigal-pete-tra... "...things should be possibly be made more complex or more complicated for people to make them smarter and to make them happier... it's flying in the face of quite a lot of the wisdom that we've been building up for the last 15-20 years in usability." I think one of the author's points is that he appreciates that Josephine actually satisfies a higher level of Maslow's hierarchy than Sprig not in spite of its lower level of convenience, but because of it. 1) Uber For Food: Immediate satisfaction of fatty, salty food. 2) Sprig: Higher-level satisfaction of food better for long-term health. 3) Josephine: Slower, more conscious choice; face-to-face connection with your neighbors.
- cbr 11y agoSprig-type operations drain agency and expertise out of the world. They centralize, aiming to build huge hubs with small spokes; their innermost mechanisms are hidden. They depend on humans behaving as interchangeable units of labor. Seems like you could make the same criticism of grocery stores.
- jonnathanson 11y agoCan we please stop describing mildly unsettling thoughts about technology as "dystopian?" You are gaining convenience at the theoretical expense of small businesses at some point in the future. This is hardly the stuff of Orwellian nightmares. [In fairness, I assume the "dystopian" subheading was chosen by an editor, and not by the writer himself (his own phrase: 'hardly utopian').]
- sbilstein 11y agoI think a lot of these SF-based food startups are filling a need that exists because of SF's fairly bad model of urbanization. Things are kinda dense, but not really, and it's very hard to get around. If SF was a more spread out city like Sacramento or Houston, driving to a grocery store or a Chipotle or an inexpensive eatery would be trivial to get your food. If it was much more dense (and easy to get around) like Manhattan or Bangkok or Tokyo, it would be trivial to get prepared food at any price since restaurants and street side cooks of all kinds can effectively get to dense districts to sell food.
- Reedx 11y agoYeah, that's true. Parking is really a pain for most restaurants. Basically... good luck. But grocery stores (at least Safeway / Trader Joes / Whole Foods) generally have attached parking and aren't too bad to park at. Though I still try to go during off-peak hours.
- peterhartree 11y ago> They depend on humans behaving as interchangeable units of labor. This isn’t a new problem... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q030WNZvXrA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q030WNZvXrA (Clock scene from Fritz Lang's Metropolis (1927))
- OJFord 11y agoSounds like the most hyperbolic article ever. "Sprig" as I see it isn't likely to replace/centralise all of cooking. It's nothing more than an easier 'takeaway', a 'cometo' if you will. This sort of thing's been around for years in the UK: HungryHouse, JustEat, precursors to Deliveroo, etc. - I was shocked recently in the US when I couldn't find an equivalent (I guess I didn't search long enough to find Sprig, or it's not yet widespread enough). For me at least, but I'm pretty sure for most people, HH or JE is like the 'one stop' place you can go to choose a takeaway. I don't have to think "I want Chinese food, let me find a Chinese place that delivers", or "I want pizza today, let me find a pizza takeaway site" - it's all in one place. But that certainly doesn't mean that all my food comes from a "centralised" place, and I never cook...
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y ago> This sort of thing's been around for years in the UK: HungryHouse, JustEat, precursors to Deliveroo, etc. You are correct, and those services just wrap what's been around for even longer - the local curry house that keeps a couple of moped drivers and a telephone operator on staff. It's a fairly old-fashioned business model.
- keithpeter 11y agoGlasgow, 1980s was my first introduction to delivered fast food - people I was staying with phoned (POTS) local pizza/chippy for pizzas salad and chips. Came in 15 mins. Paid (cash) at bottom of the close.
- OJFord 11y agoNo - because the local curry house won't accept my order for a different local curry house, or the local pizza place, or the local kebab shop, or the chippy, ...
- stupidcar 11y agoFor anyone who can't be bothered reading the self-indulgent, meandering rubbish before he actually provides the explanation: "I stopped ordering from Sprig back in the spring, because ... they sent me a truly sub-par chicken sandwich."
- wfo 11y agoFor anyone who can't be bothered reading the self-indulgent, concise rubbish since he doesn't actually provide the explanation: "I will dismiss out of hand any article suggesting that the sharing economy can be about connecting people with others instead of separating them, and I will post something snarky and condescending instead of engaging with an interesting point"
- paxtonab 11y agoI thought it was more about the fact that the sharing economy can either create positive, meaningful interactions that connect neighbors and neighborhoods, or it can turn your neighbors into faceless drones that you only interact with via the touch of an app button. I admit that the dystopian future the author sets out seems a little drastic, but it does remind me of Jobs' "below the API" argument.
- cwp 11y agoFor anyone wondering if that ellipses is at all misleading, here's the full quote: "We make these choices, bit by bit. I stopped ordering from Sprig back in the spring, because (a) I don’t like that future and (b) they sent me a truly sub-par chicken sandwich." FWIW, I found the article to be really well written.
- Aqueous 11y agoThis is ridiculous. In what macroeconomic transformation have we ever landed on just one mechanism of production or distribution? There exists room for both Sprig and Josephine - much like there exists room for both fast casual and fine dining, and for both Uber and taxis, and brick-and-mortar book stores and Amazon (who just opened a brick-and-mortar book store). There is often displacement and pressure to compete, but most of the time we don't collectively make a singular choice, eradicating the other choice totally. There are over 300 million people in this country who all have to eat every day (leaving aside whether they do or don't). What are the chances that all of them are going to land on the same way to buy or prepare food? Zero, just like it is right now.
- amelius 11y agoFunny thing is, I'd rather have an API for cooking me meals than an API for driving me home (Uber/Google car). Because in the latter case, when I come out of the office, I still need to spend X minutes in a car, then spend Y minutes in the kitchen. Whereas in the former case, my dinner is being cooked while I'm driving home, so I'll need to spend only X.