7 ms·
This whole refugee crisis is hard for me to accept. My whole family ended up in the West in an earlier crisis, and they tell us about how they rented crappy bo
by lordnacho 11y ago
This whole refugee crisis is hard for me to accept.
My whole family ended up in the West in an earlier crisis, and they tell us about how they rented crappy boats, almost died, almost got pirated, etc, trying to get across the water.
They also talk about the generosity they met once they got to their respective countries. There's stories about various strangers who volunteered to put up entire families in their own houses, helped them with the language, getting a job, studying, childcare, and so on.
A few weeks ago I was driving through Calais, and there were so many migrants on the road they spilled onto the opposite lane. There's stories about people getting killed clinging on to the bottoms of trucks, people dying of asphyxiation in containers, people getting run over by the train. People dying in overfilled boats.
-How did attitudes change so much that we can no longer accept that someone would like to change an accident of birth?
-Why do we hide behind refugee status (and there are real refugess from war these days, esp in Turkey) when we know that people did not choose to be born in an economic hellhole?
-Are we really happy to let capital move freely but keep the labor stuck where it is cheapest?
EDIT:
So, before I got attacked for not feeding, housing, and educating thousands of migrants on my own, I was going to add this:
- Why is there such reluctance to spread the burden? The numbers arriving in Italy and Greece are orders of magnitude higher that those living in the shanty in Calais, hoping to come to the UK. It was 140K crossing the Med according to the BBC in 2014. There's 350M people in Europe, and several of the rich states are actually shrinking.
- venomsnake 11y ago> A few weeks ago I was driving through Calais, and there were so many migrants on the road they spilled onto the opposite lane. Did you stop to help any of them? If the answer is no - that answers all of your question. On a longer note - observant Muslims just rub the Europeans the wrong way. Because they pit against each other 2 strongly held beliefs - religious freedom and women are totally equal - politically, sexually and everything else to men. Until Islam reforms in Europe - it will only become worse. We tamed the Christian Church - but right now it seems that secularism is under attack. You will see how better will be received (lets hope it does not get to it) refugees from Ukraine or Armenia or Georgia. Let the downvotes begin ...
- kshatrea 11y agoI upvoted you. I live in Sweden and used to live in Denmark. In both places the rise of right wing parties (Danske Folkeparti and Sverige Demokraterna) is precisely due to the conflicts between these two groups. It isn't Islam that is the problem though. There are several Muslims, especially in Sweden that have integrated quite well. I can't put my finger on what it is that is a problem though. Indians by all means(I am one) don't integrate that well either (in clothes or social and religious habits) but they don't seem to receive that much vitriol. I feel the inequality of women is one reason for the negative reputation of Muslim residents(I can't find precise stats online right now but the percentage of non-working Muslim women is much higher than in other religious groups) and the amount of children they have per family is more leading to more welfare[0]. [0] I don't have stats right now so I can't prove this but I can anecdotally prove it based on conversations with many Swedes and Danes.
- tomjen3 11y agoAs a Dane I don't know much about Indians, but the Chinese haven't integrated much, but they work hard and aren't trouble so why should we hate them? Roma (or gysis) on the other hand - tons of criminals, so very unpopular. Muslims are a mixed bag. Lots of them own small businesses, if you buy a pizza chances are you will be served by a muslim. On the other hand if you get raped by a stranger it is also most likely a muslim, despite the fact that they are not a large part of the population. Add to that Denmark has really short sentences _and_ we generally don't deport people even if they are gang leaders and you can see why there are lots of people who don't like muslims. Anyway much of this could be avoided if we were tougher on crime, or much more discriminating in who we let in.
- kshatrea 11y agoAbsolutely, and the tougher on crime motif is one of the things that makes DF very popular. In Gothenburg, Sweden for instance the Roma are everywhere, outside most large stores and have a bustling begging operation and there is plenty of theft which make them highly unpopular. You're right that crime (especially in Scandinavia which is highly peaceable) is one reason why certain communities are despised. But I feel that refugees also have certain other problems - they've never been to school in many cases and therefore their children have disadvantages in such high tech nations, which causes inequality to rise and so on and so forth. This topic is going to lead to many PhDs in the future, but in the mean time lets see what happens...
- adventured 11y agoThe attitude issue is based on fear. I think people in the first world prefer to be generous, and that fear of losing what they have is what causes the friction. Whether we're talking about jobs, pensions, welfare benefits, etc. In many European countries (it's in no way exclusively an European concern mind you) a fear of losing cultural identity is also an extremely common issue. It plays into the fear of change. Modern welfare states are extraordinarily expensive, and require careful fiscal management. You can have a mostly well functioning one like Germany or Sweden, or you can have a disaster like numerous other examples. The fear (emphasis that that isn't to say it's the reality of the situation necessarily) is ending up in the disaster category, that the system will get overwhelmed and cuts will be required, lowering the standard of living for everyone.
- tomjen3 11y agoI don't really mind letting a lot of people in who are willing and able to work. I mind letting people in who are going to receive the very generous welfare payments Denmark gives out, and which are part of the social contract since they never payed into the system. I absolutely hate those who come here and turn to crime - want to come and work? Fine, show that you have a job and you can stay. Want to come and start a business? Excellent. Show that your are making money, you can stay. Want to come and contribute to the fact that Denmark has the highest rate of burglaries in the EU? You can stay out.
- leaveyou 11y agoThis wave of immigrants comes in a very unfortunate moment when there is a high unemployment in lots of EU countries and lots of economic immigration inside EU. This makes the new immigrants perfect candidates for welfare or criminality, because lots of low skill jobs are already occupied by previous immigrants (from eastern Europe for example).
- lordnacho 11y ago>I don't really mind letting a lot of people in who are willing and able to work. I mind letting people in who are going to receive the very generous welfare payments Denmark gives out, and which are part of the social contract since they never payed into the system. Quite a lot of locals have a negative balance vs the system. Doesn't it seem a bit arbitrary to leave it that way? How about a probation system... learn the language, get a job, limit the money you can take, and don't commit any crimes.
- venomsnake 11y ago> Doesn't it seem a bit arbitrary to leave it that way? It is not arbitrary. A country has obligations fundamentally only to its citizens. The whole sovereignty thing.
- lordnacho 11y agoThe whole notion of sovereignty in its current form is an accident of European history. The borders of the world can't be said to be much other than arbitrary, for huge pieces of it. Seen another way, you could remove the citizenship of people who went negative. Then you'd be rid of your obligations. If it sounds absurd, that's because it is.
- tacone 11y agoWell, before the refugee crisis, people from many of same countries used to get to Europe by plane. The above sentence does not apply to all them of course, but still one should ask himself why do they get here by boat now.
- atmosx 11y agoThis is the (new) Europe[1]. Unfortunately. Funny thing is that especially Poland, should know better, after the 2nd WW about 2.5 million Polaks emigrated for Germany (mainly) and other EU nations. [1] http://carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/?fa=60574 http://carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/?fa=60574
- evilhaskeller 11y agoMy family also emigrated to the West in the 90s, fleeing war and misery. I empathize with the refugees, but I do not think that Europe should let such a steady flow of people into its territory. Far right is rising all over Europe, for a reason. A significant number of Europeans do not recognize the country they have been growing up in. The cultural/demographic pressure is a real issue that is fueling far-right politicians' anti-migrants rhetoric. In 2014, France alone has welcomed as many new immigrants on its territory as Canada. It is just not sustainable, and the longer we wait to face this sad reality the harsher the far right burst will be. Politicians need to listen to their citizens before they actually start to feel helpless/pissed off and vote for populist freaks.
- lumberjack 11y ago>-How did attitudes change so much that we can no longer accept that someone would like to change an accident of birth? Citizenship is valuable. It is wealth in the form of economic opportunities, security, stability and all other amnesties afforded to citizens of developed countries. That wealth was built over centuries by the ancestors of the current citizens. Are you proposing that we should start handing citizenship away for free? That would essentially amount to theft from the current citizens. The current migrant situation is unfortunate but simply eliminating borders or doing away with citizenship is not the answer. And I really disagree with the "accident of birth" bit. First of all it was not really an accident. The parents did make a conscious choice however irresponsible it might have been. Secondly all property is pretty much a matter of an "accident of birth" and citizenship is no less valuable than the seven digit inheritance that your parents might leave you.
- mjn 11y agoReactions vary. From what I've read, Greeks on the islands that are seeing a big influx of immigrants coming by boat from the Turkish coast have generally been treating immigrants well, or at least as well as limited resources allow. I gather that immigrants in Athens are not treated as well. An article about the islands: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jul/08/greek-island-refugee-crisis-local-people-and-tourists-rally-round-migrants http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jul/08/greek-island-re...