17 ms·
Amazon details its plan for how drones can fly safely over U.S. skies
- larrys 11y ago"Kimchi also laid out his thinking on how autonomous drones could safely fly in the same locations as helicopters. Helicopters are much more problematic than planes for drones because of low-altitude flying." I wonder what size drones they are envisioning. For example with a typical prosumer drone out there now, it would be completely obliterated by a large helicopter when coming in contact with the moving blades or hitting the windshield or other parts. Likewise the downdraft of the heli would force down anything of that size in it's path. After all if a drone is such a threat to a heli then what kind of threat is it to a person that it comes into contact with by accident?
- nkassis 11y agoFalling parts could still be a huge danger even if they are small. So it doesn't have to be a danger to the helicopter to be a danger to someone.
- electricblue 11y agoSeems like they would need to be much larger than prosumer drones in order to carry anything bigger than a blu-ray. If a drone the size of the one in the 60 minutes demo hit helicopter blades you'd probably be looking at fatalities.
- falcolas 11y agoWatching the latest Mythbuster episode is enlightening, particularly if you take the weights of the crafts they're testing into account. THe TL;DR of the episode is - carbon fiber blades directly connected to motors (likely the setup for commercial UAVs) is capable of slicing deeply enough to hit your jugular, others are not (unless the motor is being held solidly and used as a form of saw). I'm more concerned with UAVs and payloads in excess of 10 lbs falling from 400 feet up onto my head because a wiring connection came loose and cut power to the UAV (happened to me recently, minus the head). In short, don't fly UAVs around people, or in no-fly zones.
- larrys 11y agoOf interest: http://blogs.wsj.com/metropolis/2013/09/05/remote-control-helicopter-kills-man-in-brooklyn/ http://blogs.wsj.com/metropolis/2013/09/05/remote-control-he... "A 19-year-old model helicopter enthusiast was killed Thursday when a toy helicopter he was flying struck him in the head, a law-enforcement official said."
- artmageddon 11y ago> Likewise the downdraft of the heli would force down anything of that size in it's path. I imagine even the downdraft coming off of a helicopter would be enough to ruin and take out any drones that got within a certain level of it.
- kejaed 11y agoIf Amazon is going to be using these aircraft to deliver packages they are going to have to be a fair bit larger than the prosumer drones out there now to have any sort of useful payload capacity.
- jessaustin 11y agoLikewise the downdraft of the heli would force down anything of that size in it's path. Downdraft wouldn't help safety: presumably there are locations above the helicopter from which a drone would be pulled into the rotor.
- digitalsushi 11y agoIt will be interesting to watch how over the next decade the airspace is forced to get split up and reassigned. We're on chapter:fairy tale and we will eventually get to chapter:mundane. The tech exists, the money exists, the demand exists. There are clearly some huge obstacles, the same magnitude plaguing self driving cars. Both fascinating worlds unfurling before us.
- nostromo 11y agoI'm surprised the Washington Post doesn't include any disclaimers regarding their ownership by Bezos in their coverage of Amazon.
- readymade 11y agoFirst thing that came to my mind as well.
- anotherangrydev 11y agoWell, they are not suppossed to do so...
- CameronBanga 11y agoAgree, seems like a pretty big disclaimer.
- lemevi 11y agoI don't really understand this process of declaring conflicts of interests. The declaration of a conflict of interest seems like at best a bare minimum requirement and one that is abused. I see posts sometimes where they write about how great X is and then have a disclaimer of (we're owned by creators of X) as if that was good enough. I just think if you have a conflict of interest, unless the value of the news is significant, writing about X should be avoided altogether especially if it's heavy on speculation, analysis or opinion.
- skybrian 11y agoThat's excluding a lot of people from the conversation who might have something interesting to say. For example, are you going to exclude pilots from a conversation about aviation because they have an obvious conflict of interest? If you're an expert in a certain area, it's quite likely that it's because it's part of your job. There aren't that many people who are both impartial and knowledgeable.
- lemevi 11y agoTo be more specific, I am talking about journalists who work at private publishers owned by people or a company with a financial conflict of interest in a topic.
- CPLX 11y agoThis is uncompelling. Just having layers of airspace like that doesn't really address the main issue, which is that in order to get to any layer you have to transit the layer below. Even giant commercial flights end up below 500 feet all the time of course, well at least twice for every flight. It also has some real issues in that it's glossing over the challenges of steep terrain and obstacles. Most of our air navigation takes place by reference to MSL altitude (i.e. relative to sea level), but this is exclusively based on AGL (i.e. relative to ground level). Not an insurmountable challenge of course but it seems like they are skipping a lot of important parts. Same impression of the "real time data" plan, which sounds extremely complex in the context of aviation. The overall impression is that nobody has really thought this through particularly, that this is more of a conversation starter at best. (Relevant: I have a pilot's license)
- Tuxer 11y agoThe no flight under 500 ft over anything other than sparsely populated areas is in AGL, not MSL. I assume they would also need to stay out of class D/C/B areas. My main concern is that this doesn't take care of helicopter traffic that doesn't have this 500ft AGL rule. Having ADS/B or a variant of it for the drones would take care of that issue, as in 2020 every aircraft will require ADS/B.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoADS-B also solves the tracking issue for Amazon, as each drone wouldn't need to use a separate communications channel to notify its controller of where its is; Amazon could simply tap into existing ADS-B data streams.
- CPLX 11y agoThe positional accuracy of ADS-B as currently implemented is often measured in hundreds of meters, and GPS has never been particularly good at accurate estimations of altitude. Are drones to have ground based radar ranging? Altimeters based on barometric pressure? Updated to current altimeter settings via what means? Anyone touting ADS-B as a realistic solution for avoiding mid-air drone collisions in congested areas is severely naive in my opinion, at least based on current technology. My assumption is that those advocating for it in this context aren't actually familiar with its specs and how it works. In aviation, separation between flying objects is usually measured in miles horizontally, and a thousand feet or more vertically, and the systems are based on that reality for the most part.
- legohead 11y agocan't wait to see hundreds of drones flying around the city. the future is...loud
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoSince there will be so many flying at once you're going to have the occasional failure. That's going to make walking around in the city interesting for sure.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoIt should be straightforward to design corridors for drones where, if they were to fail, they land on structures instead of people. Amazon could design this as an additional OpenStreetMap layer, using existing satellite mapping data to create areas to avoid where people are likely to be. Avoid roads and sidewalks.
- rpcope1 11y agoYou know even if they don't land on people, I sure don't want an Amazon drone falling on my house, or out in my pasture, or on top of my shop. Will Amazon pay up in full if it punches a hole in my barn, harms livestock, or destroys a car I have sitting outside? If they're going to have a non-zero number of these drop from the sky, they better know they're not getting that drone back, for starters.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoFirst, its no different then an aircraft. You know what happens if a piece of an aircraft lands on your house? The airline's insurance company pays for it. You know how much say you have over airspace above your home? Zero. > If they're going to have a non-zero number of these drop from the sky, they better know they're not getting that drone back, for starters. While you may think property rights don't exist solely because of the word "drone", you'd be mistaken. I have serious doubts you're going to see significant drone traffic in the area where you live (based on your profile info).
- rpedela 11y agoHas there been much discussion about hundreds or thousands of drones filling the sky and how much of an eyesore that would likely be to many people, then the political fight that is likely to ensue?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- stevecalifornia 11y agoI still don't understand how an autonomous delivery drone is better than an autonomous delivery car. I feel like a delivery drone is the absolute most complicated way to solve this problem other than somehow involving rockets. Drone limitations: - Needs great weather. - Package size and weight exceptionally confined. - Exceptionally limited range. - How to actually get package from drone to human? Drop? - Night flight? Yes / no? Probably not. Car limitations: - Traffic.
- rifung 11y agoUsing delivery cars would cause a lot of traffic in densely populated areas. Cars are presumably also more expensive than drones. On the other hand, I suppose a car could do more than one delivery at a time whereas a drone would be more limited in what it could carry.
- VLM 11y agoThis summarizes a big problem with the congestion argument. Our economy is not big enough to cause "serious" delivery congestion when confined to 2-d road vehicles, yet its assumed if you open up to smaller 3-d capable vehicles massive congestion will result. Why? Where I live it is not an issue, but it is theoretically possible that there might be a location on the planet right now where Fedex trucks crash into UPS trucks, and Dominos pizza cars are running Chinese delivery cars off the road, on a daily basis. However that weird situation existing would still be a workable system for perhaps 99.9% of the worlds surface. There are also practical scaling issues. The local pizza delivery joint cannot produce fast enough to saturate a 2-D delivery system during the superbowl, just can't pump out pies fast enough. Naturally going to 3-D delivery with maybe 100x the delivery capacity because of 3-D isn't going to alter their delivery rate, the skies will be pretty empty. Even if you drive there to pick up, there will be a 2-hr wait for pizza. Drones and trucks are expensive and the finance guys would prefer the absolute minimum be owned and deliveries be made 24x7. That would imply we're not going to get drone congestion until we have deliveries at 3am. I'm just not seeing people order enough raw "stuff" to keep delivery services busy enough.
- 11y ago
- sandworm101 11y ago> Amazon Prime Air engineers have largely kept a low profile as they test their technology overseas. Canada, specifically British Columbia, is hardly "overseas". http://www.thecanadianpress.com/english/online/OnlineFullStory.aspx?filename=DOR-MNN-CP.c756149ac89240cead9200c597688014.CPKEY2008111303&newsitemid=32503812&languageid=1 http://www.thecanadianpress.com/english/online/OnlineFullSto...
- giaour 11y agoWell, you might have to cross a tiny bit of ocean water if it's on Vancouver Island.
- comrh 11y agoNo plans on if they fall out of their special zone and onto my roof or my head though?
- CodeSheikh 11y ago“Imagine the Internet without HTTP and TCP/IP” That's quite an absurd analogy to push forward Amazon's drone program. Even though I am quite fascinated by the innovation of this idea, not so much about the practicality of it. I believe it is good for rural areas where highway system is not streamlined and major shipping carriers don't encourage frequent routes.
- mercurialshark 11y agoI like the idea of rivers serving as a natural drone highway. They weave through most cities/towns, provide insulation from populations on the ground and relatively easy recoverability (as opposed to being destroyed on impact).
- VLM 11y agoAlso consider railroad tracks, at least normally you'd only have one property owner making claims (the railroad), and the local residents are already used to 9000 HP worth of coal train rumbling thru at 3am so a tiny little quiet drone is no real issue. Also in an accident, I think its pretty obvious who "wins" when a ten million pound train hits a ten pound drone, so other than glass and paint claims I think you're pretty safe. I don't envision a drone ever causing a coal train to derail, LOL.
- godgod 11y agoThis is going to end in an air disaster. Our reliance on drones and computers will come to a head soon.
- ck2 11y agohttp://i.imgur.com/SLZeCmS.png http://i.imgur.com/SLZeCmS.png
- bra-ket 11y agoIt looks like a surveillance network.
- josu 11y ago>While the Supreme Court hasn't explicitly accepted that as the upper limit of property ownership, it's a useful guideline in trespass cases. Therefore, unless you own some very tall buildings, your private airspace probably ends somewhere between 80 and 500 feet above the ground. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2013/07/photographer_george_steinmetz_arrest_how_much_airspace_do_you_own.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20...
- sarwechshar 11y agoIt would be interesting how they plan on detecting smaller moving objects like birds, which would be more of a challenge than a helicopter or a construction crane. Perhaps lasers and radar similar to how Google's driverless cars detect potential hazards?
- caskance 11y agoI wonder if detecting them is even really a problem. They move, emit heat, and most are naturally inclined to avoid drones already. I'm really curious about whether birds of prey might start hunting drones.
- jordanthoms 11y agoIt's a possibility if the drones are delivering food for Amazon Fresh... That would be so awesome!
- andygates 11y agoMore fun will be in optimizing stopping birds going for drones. My little photo quad has been attacked by mobs of both seagulls and crows. Wasp-coloured paint and ultrasound squeakers?
- Johnny555 11y agoThey didn't address the other part of safety -- some percentage of those hundreds (or thousands) of 15+ kg drones flying over a city are going to have an unavoidable collision or a catastrophic hardware failure and come crashing down to the ground, which could easily be deadly if it lands on someone, or cause a car accident if it lands on a car or on the road. At the very least it's going to cause property damage - who do I call when one punches a hole through my roof or I see one hanging in my tree? Has anyone done an analysis of the crash rate for large drones and likely casualty rate on the ground?
- sandworm101 11y agoWell, you could always take anything onboard the drone as salvage. Or what about all those people who will not want to let the drone retrieval squads onto their land? I'm waiting for the ability to transmit "bird alerts" to chase away the drones I don't like.
- function_seven 11y agoYou're right that they need to address those concerns. I'd like to see that analysis also include any possible reduced injury/death from fewer delivery truck miles and fewer consumer car trips to the local store. I have no idea if it will offset or not, but I could see—even with a few thousand drones crashing every year—that a net benefit could still be realized because people are not driving to the store for some of their shopping.
- Johnny555 11y agoSure, using drones instead of trucks could be a net win in safety if it means less drivers on the road, but this seems unlikely -- one driver in a UPS truck can deliver hundreds of packages on his route, but since the drone has such limited payload capacity, it might need to make a round trip per package so it would take hundreds of drone trips to replace one driver with a truck. And, since heavy packages aren't realistic for a drone, the truck is still going to drive much of his delivery route to deliver the heavy packages.
- 11y ago
- zkhalique 11y agoThe trouble with drones, even more than self-driving cars, is that soon, lots of manufacturers will be able to make them. When no-name unaccountable manufacturers make drones for people who buy and fly them anonymously, we won't be able to prevent the havoc that occurs, with laws. Previously, this was hardly a problem, because very few machines operated autonomously outside of a building. Cars had occupants. Helicopters and planes had occupants. Now, many won't. If a rogue drone with mounted guns starts shooting up a public square, we won't know who launched it unless the manufacturer played by the rules. That's a serious problem for our society that's coming up. Terrorism has always been a problem of technology, and we're about to make more technology available to the masses, where some fraction of a percent of wackos is going to use it for nefarious purposes. The trouble with unmanned robots which are easily manufactured is that we can't trace who made it, sold it, or launched it. And therefore can't enforce the law on everybody. I am more concerned about this than governments using the technology.
- skybrian 11y agoIt doesn't seem all that different from the market for any other regulated product. The FCC approval process for electronics more or less works, not because it's impossible to get around it, but because most people don't go shopping for stuff that's not FCC-approved and most businesses don't want to risk selling it. Of course there are always black markets, but their scale depends on how much unmet demand there is that can't be satisfied by regular markets.
- zkhalique 11y agoThe difference is that we will have self-directed autonomous technology running rampant outside confined areas, and you only need 0.1% of it to go rogue to cause serious damage.
- trhway 11y ago>If a rogue drone with mounted guns starts shooting up a public square, we won't know who launched it unless the manufacturer played by the rules. a bomb hidden in a thrash bin or a stolen car parked on the public square. A bullet from sniper rifle from a mile away. No drones necessary. And just imagine what kind of, including chemical or nuclear, havoc can any engineer wreck with tech available today. >Terrorism has always been a problem of technology. centuries ago Church tried to outlaw crossbows: http://militaryhistorynow.com/2012/05/23/the-crossbow-a-medieval-wmd/ http://militaryhistorynow.com/2012/05/23/the-crossbow-a-medi... Safety through obscurity works only for very cutting edge technologies and only for the very short time.
- nd1 11y agoI've always seen these Amazon drone delivery stories as an elaborate PR stunt (I'd say an extremely successful one if it is...). But every time the story comes up on here everyone seems to take it very seriously. Am I just being really cynical or do we actually think this is going to happen in the next 5-10 years?
- caskance 11y agoIt doesn't have to be imminent to be taken seriously. I take my retirement savings seriously.
- nandhp 11y agoIt's not a question of drone deliveries coming in 5-10 years, it's already happening in some places: for example, DHL has a drone in service (albeit as a research project) shuttling urgent pharmacy orders to an island 10 km off the German coast. http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/sep/25/german-dhl-launches-first-commercial-drone-delivery-service http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/sep/25/german-dhl... http://www.dhl.com/en/press/releases/releases_2014/group/dhl_parcelcopter_launches_initial_operations_for_research_purposes.html http://www.dhl.com/en/press/releases/releases_2014/group/dhl... The question for the next 5-10 years really if the economics and regulations can change or have changed to make it practical to do this on an ongoing basis for small and larger payloads.
- _rpd 11y agoInternally, Amazon is completely serious about drone delivery.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- clumsysmurf 11y agoI am not looking forward to all the noise pollution flying drones will contribute.
- crocal 11y agoThanks for that comment. I felt I was the only one thinking that these drones in the sky constitute a major pollution and visual agression. In my case, it triggers the exact same revulsion I have when I discover a big spider walking on my ceiling. Yuck. At least with trains, roads and airports, we can move away from the source of pollution. With drones, great, nowhere to hide. Pollution comes to you. Not to mention that I am sure soon we will have ads displayed on the side of the said drones. Did I hear "Blade Runner"?
- icebraining 11y agoAt least with trains, roads and airports, we can move away from the source of pollution. With drones, great, nowhere to hide. Pollution comes to you. Not to mention that I am sure soon we will have ads displayed on the side of the said drones. So, just like cars?
- crocal 11y agoWorst than cars. Cars don't drive over your garden...
- mo1ok 11y agoFor all the negativity in this thread, you've pointed out (in my opinion) the one actual problem with this. It's going to be like living next to a highway in any urban area. Not any noisier than an apartment in new york, I suppose, but disruptive to quieter cities.
- elchief 11y agoI saw some kids on your lawn by the way. You should tell them to get off of it.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y agoCan other companies do this or just Amazon?
- golemotron 11y agoI want a rule that limits drones to flying over roads when they fly in non-rural areas.
- lucb1e 11y agoWhy?
- golemotron 11y agoBecause there are fewer exposed heads on roadways.
- fredland 11y agojust want to point out the obvious here: the VP of Amazon Prime Air's name is Gur Kimchi. Godspeed, brother. Korean-Americanly yours, F
- mo1ok 11y agoThere's a lot of negativity in this thread. I'm really excited about this. Even on an aesthetic level, it will be amazing to look at the city sky and see hundreds of lights buzzing about, blade-runner style.
- 88e282102ae2e5b 11y agoI would love to see how they plan to address theft. Surely it would be super easy to steal the drones and harvest them for parts.
- MichaelGG 11y agoI'd guess it simply won't be that big an issue. They'll know where they are all the time, and they'll file theft reports and get police involved. They could add video, too, if they felt the need. In the US, it doesn't seem like organised bands are going to risk criminally attacking autonomous devices to steal parts.
- CodingGuy 11y agoI would love to shoot one of them, if they ever fly over my house. :)
- andygates 11y agoHonest Bob's Cheap Drone Parts, refurbished Amazon-spec drone motors and controllers from, er, our friends in Shenzen, honest. I've got the receipts here, officer...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- analog31 11y agoIn my view, if industry wants such a lavish public gift as the privileged use of airspace, it should come with plenty of strings attached. Drones should be licensed and carry liability insurance. They should emit an ID signal that includes their GPS coordinates. They should respond to a "scram" signal that clears an area for things like rescue helicopters and firefighting aircraft. They should not carry advertising banners or emit noise pollution. There are already analogous rules for cars in most of these areas. There's also a laundry list of items regarding data privacy that should apply to drones.
- dspillett 11y ago> They should respond to a "scram" signal that clears an area for things like rescue helicopters and firefighting aircraft. This is a massive thing. An issue I see though it whether everyone will play by such safety rules. Yes Amazon and the like will, but once the site of a delivery drone is commonplace other drones will be around either for publicised purposes (such as event recording, or people like Google updating their aerial maps) or "hiding in plain site" (i.e. those recording without permission or delivering less legal cargo). Who will be able to regulate those to make sure that they confirm to such safety standards (quick answer: nobody). Also the scram signal itself could be open to abuse.
- sudhirj 11y agoA lot of these problems already apply to people walking around, cars, helicopters and private aircraft.
- dspillett 11y agoYes, but a drone can cause some forms of damage that a person walking around can't (in places inaccessible to a person just walking around), and the barriers for entry (which to a large extent will come down to costs) is (or will soon be) a lot lower than that for the other things you mention.
- rockyleal 11y agoEveryone should remember that the Washington Post is owned by Jeff Bezos while reading this article. Even the title is propagandistic in style "...can fly safely over U.S. skies"
- Retra 11y agoThat's a good point, but if you left 'safely' out of the title, the meaning changes significantly.
- ridgeguy 11y agoAnd that - a single word change - is why editorial control matters.
- cpeterso 11y agoAnd what does it mean to "fly over US skies"? The drones are flying over cities, not skies. The article might get different response if it read "Amazon details its plan for how drones can fly safely over your children's school!" :)
- dantillberg 11y agoThe whole article seems like it was written by Amazon PR. In addition to that not really counting as journalism, there really ought to be a disclaimer disclosing to the casual reader that the owner of the Washington Post also owns 19% of Amazon and is its CEO/Founder/Chairman/President.
- arde 11y agoCue pirate drones stealing cargo.
- ams6110 11y agoI think a very real problem with package-delivering drones will be thieves or bored kids shooting them down.
- 2anon4this1 11y agoThis is all wrong. Small underground tunnels covering entire cities with autonomous delivery bots on wheels which automatically take the fastest route from any given A to B with a generic size/shaped payload are the real solution to this issue. Horizontal drilling technologies mean that we can bore a 30 metre long tunnel while only digging up the first 3 metres. Imagine all the industries this would revolutionise. All shopping and food ordering would become completely price and quality-driven, as realestate prices and premium spots are no longer relevant. last 10 mile package delivery would cost tens of cents. Automated subterranean transport is the REAL future of automated delivery.
- madaxe_again 11y agoYou say this, but plenty of cities (Chicago, London) have small gauge underground railroads which used to be used variously for mail and coal - they're all now abandoned.
- andygates 11y agoThis idea assumes that there aren't already a maze of tunnels under cities: there are. It thinks they're cheap, which they absolutely are not. It thinks they're reasonable to get permission to dig, which is, er, nope. And it absolutely won't work outside dense cities. The "van + drones" model scales out.
- tomohawk 11y agoCurrent law holds that flying within 500 feet of someone's land is trespassing. I'd be happy to lease my property for each use by a drone operator for a modest fee. Perhaps they could credit my Prime account for each use. Also, since sound dissipates by the inverse square of the distance, the difference in sound between a drone flying at 100 feet vs 500 feet is quite a lot. I'd expect any fee charged by me to use the space above my property to vary by that formula. However, it looks like they're going to try to take my property rights away from me by paying off some people in Washington. This would have the convenient effect of nullifying my ability to seek redress for noise and other polution, or loss of use of my property.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoSomeone here must be working on domestic anti-drone self-targeting weapons as we type? Surely firing potatoes/beanbags above your own property is legal, if a drone just happened to be passing and got hit then wouldn't that be a shame. Or perhaps we'll have patrolling sentry drones that physically tackle and enforce domestic airspace? Will be interesting to see how sophisticated lawmakers get in pre-empting such actions.