12 ms·
Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms
- personjerry 11y agoHow can a government have jurisdiction over this? It's their system. If they decide to only give you an account on their system if you've verified your name (i.e. through driver's license) then why can you demand otherwise? They can just refuse you service, can't they?
- nugget 11y agoFor better or for worse, once services become monopolies the government has much more authority to regulate them.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoFacebook is not monopoly. The real definition of a monopoly is the sole provider of a good or service, which has apparently been forgotten. FB is not the only social network, nor will it ever be. Who does have the ability to use force to create artificial monopolies though?
- creshal 11y agoIt's not fully clear whether the German government has jurisdiction here, with Facebook nominally residing in Ireland. A case has just been filed by the Hamburg state government, but that can easily take years to go through courts. > How can a government have jurisdiction over this? Because the government can decide that demanding a driver's license is illegal because it is an unreasonable burden on users, simple as that. German law states it must be possible to use a service anonymously or pseudonymously "if it is technically possible and reasonable". Whether it is reasonable in this particular case is for the courts to decide. (cf. Telemediengesetz, http://www.cgerli.org/index.php?id=51&tx_vmdocumentsearch_pi2[docID]=1438 http://www.cgerli.org/index.php?id=51&tx_vmdocumentsearch_pi... )
- personjerry 11y agoThat makes sense, thank you for explaining the particular details.
- _ak 11y agoFacebook is operating in Germany, among other countries. If they want to earn money in Germany, they need to obey to German laws and regulations, obviously.
- creshal 11y agoWith the internet being the poorly regulated series of tubes it is, they argue they're operating and earning money solely in Ireland, not Germany. Whether the judge will be amused by this, we'll see.
- _ak 11y agoThey operate offices in Hamburg and Berlin. They specifically target German advertisers. They won't be that stupid to even attempt that argument.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mseebach 11y agoThey can decide all that, but that doesn't give them clear jurisdiction to actually enforce it. They can penalise users doing it, possibly by making it a breach of the terms of carrying a drivers license to use it for this purpose, although it's not clear how they'd prove such usage. Alternatively, they can try to hit Facebook's ad sales in Germany, but that's likely to run into common market rules around trade barriers. Anyway, does Facebook actually enforce this? I have never shown any ID to Facebook, and I see plenty of people not using their real names (typically they use derivatives or add a screenname as a middle name, rather than being totally pseudonymous).
- return0 11y agoNot when politicians and governments use it. Facebook and twitter are utilities now.
- philippnagel 11y agoGoing with that logic, everything these entities use becomes a utility.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- madez 11y agoHow can a government have jurisdiction over this? By the existence of a law proclaiming so. Also, in this case it was not the government but another organ of the state, unless you refer with ´government´ to any organization of public law. In many jurisdiction there are restrictions and rules for businesses in place. For example, often you can't restrict purchases of your product based on the customers skin colour. In Germany privacy is fundamentally more valued and protected than in the US of central-north America. For example, under german law you have the right to get virtually all information a organization is keeping about you, why they are keeping it, where it is from, how they use it and who they share it with. The organization is obligued to comply without financial compensation [1]. Furthermore, there are broad cases where the deletion of the stored information can be demanded [2]. Information about people may not be stored without the technical necessity for the service or without the explicit consent from the affected persons. As soon as the consent is withdrawn or the data is not any more needed to offer the service, it must be deleted. Facebook collects and keeps data about people who do not have an active account. That is not allowed in Germany. To put it blunt; in its current form, Facebooks practices are illegal under german law. Germans don't want anybody to collect data about them, and made laws against it. Ironically, they still use Google. I guess most simply don't understand the implications or don't see practical alternatives. I hope this elaboration makes the situation more understandable. [1] http://dejure.org/gesetze/BDSG/34.html http://dejure.org/gesetze/BDSG/34.html [2] http://dejure.org/gesetze/BDSG/35.html http://dejure.org/gesetze/BDSG/35.html
- icebraining 11y agoAs a side note, those data protection laws are widespread across the EU, thanks to Directive 95/46/EC.
- madez 11y agoThank you for this information. Indeed, in Section II, Article 7 rules are laid down [1] which Facebook is violating, for example with shadowprofiles. [1] http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:31995L0046:EN:HTML http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:...
- 11y ago
- detaro 11y agoIf you offer information services in Germany you have to allow pseudonymous access if it is reasonable to do so, as part of privacy rules (principle of "Datensparsamkeit" = "data economicalness" - requiring as few pieces of information as absolutely necessary). It is an interesting question if Facebook requires your real name to function properly and if this decision would hold in court, but it is in principle covered by law and I imagine the fact that facebook and other social networks have worked without these rules before might work against facebook here.
- JulianMorrison 11y agoThey can't "out" you. Because privacy. IMO this ought to be a global rule. It's completely unacceptable to have a private company arrogating to itself the ability to "out" you at its convenience. Fuck contracts. It's wrong.
- dempseye 11y ago[insert angry libertarian response]
- mseebach 11y agoWho's talking about outing anyone? Denying service to pseudonymous users isn't outing anyone. Just don't give Facebook your real name, then they can't tell anyone your real name. They might deny you service, but they can't 'out' you.
- pjc50 11y agoTheir system is subject to EU data protection and privacy law. They probably could actually just refuse her service, that would be a different case. Although if they started banning transgender people, or foreigners with strange names, on that basis it would collide with equalities law. And it sounds like German privacy law prevents requesting identity documents (which are, after all, government issue) when not actually required for fraud prevention. Theoretically US law has a similar rule about social security numbers but it's not well enforced.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoA while back the UK clamped down on misuse of NI (the equivalent for ss numbers). I was working for BT at the time and the briefing we got on use of NI numbers was very clear that break these rules and your ass is fired - it was stronger worded than the don't look up the queens private telephone numbers one we had.
- davidgerard 11y agoIf they do business in Germany, e.g. selling ads, they get to obey local law.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sillygeese 11y ago> How can a government have jurisdiction over this? Or more broadly, how can a government have jurisdiction over anything, or anyone? The answer is fundamentally: by force. For example, if I point a gun at you, I've just established the same kind of "jurisdiction" over your wallet. Because otherwise you'd just refrain from giving it to me. But isn't it great that a "privacy watchdog" is limiting the privacy invasions Facebook can inflict on us, while surveilling us themselves, and funding their operations with money that's forcefully taken from us? It's like, heart-warming! (They've established "jurisdiction" over our incomes!)
- jon-wood 11y agoYou talk like these organisations are one coherent whole having meetings to plot how to best exploit German citizens. It's entirely possible, and probably desirable, to have a government containing on group trying to protect citizen's privacy while another has reasons not to - where those roles overlap you should at least in theory have debate within government as to who takes precedence. In this non-ideal world that may not happen, but its better than not even making that possible.
- sillygeese 11y agoDo you think that's a satisfactory situation though? Suppose that there actually is a group within the government that's genuinely trying to protect us. Even so, the organization they'd be protecting us from is the exact same one they're part of. How does that make sense? It's like there's a pack of wolves next to a herd of sheep, and one of the wolves is like: "Guys? Guyyys? Can we just not eat them please?" In reality, governments are hell-bent on monitoring everything we do, because that's a great way to cement their power over us. Dictators don't arrange elections, and the most productive slave is one who thinks he's free. That's a large part of why the whole world isn't under complete tyranny right now. Try protesting anything any government does though, and the response will be tear gas and batons. That shows exactly how many fucks they give about our well-being or wishes. (Recent examples: Hong Kong, Brazil, Venezuela etc)
- Oletros 11y ago
- MereInterest 11y agoWhy wouldn't a government have jurisdiction here? A government exists to protect, enforce, and guarantee the rights of the individual. If, in one country, the people have decided that those rights include the right to privacy, then of course the government can require that any businesses operating there will respect those rights. It's their country, not Facebook's.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoIf an individual desires privacy, perhaps being on Facebook is not wise.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoThe modern corporation only exists because of the jurisdiction of governments.
- xwintermutex 11y ago"Facebook changed the profile to her real name against her will ..." How did they know her real name?
- madez 11y agoThis doesn't suprise me at all. Big data-hungry companies like Facebook or Google know A LOT about you. I'd say they even know a lot of things about their used that their used don't even know about.
- on_and_off 11y agoOne explanation is that Facebook collects its users contact lists. That way, it can create 'shadow-accounts' for people that don't have yet a Facebook account. So when/if that person finally creates a Facebook account with some data tying him/her to a shadow-account, Facebook can directly propose relevant contacts and already knows a lot about that person, including his/her real name.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 11y agoI'd be very surprised if Facebook didn't know my parents' names, my kids names, my shoe size and any other piece of information I haven't provided explicitly. Just assume that anything that you entered on any website, or that you mentioned directly or indirectly to anyone on Facebook is available to Facebook. In the creepiest of worlds I imagine this: on a non FB website with a FB "share" button on it, I congratulated a friend on her birthday five years ago. When she gets a FB account for the first time tomorrow, Facebook already has her shadow account with good Guesses of her details, including the birthday and real name.
- grkvlt 11y agoThe most likely explanation is they sent her a message saying pseudonyms are not allowed, and asking for her real name. She replies something like 'My real name is XYZ, here is ID to prove I am a real person, but I do NOT wish to use that name, please continue to call me ABC on the site' but Facebook simply went ahead and changed her name from ABC to XYZ against her wishes. No secret data mining, information collection or machine learning required.
- raverbashing 11y agoA lot of users in Germany already, from my experience, 'use pseudonyms' (you just put a real-enough sounding name that's fake) and be done with it. Facebook should really not try to make the same mistakes as G+ in that sense
- notahacker 11y agoThat was my first thought when reading the headline: I thought Germans already were pretty confident they had legal protection. I don't think any of the German Facebook friends I have use their full real name, and some of the pseudonyms aren't even that real-enough sounding to German-speakers.
- zaidf 11y agoReal identities have been core to the Facebook experience since the day it launched; just as fake usernames have been core to YouTube since its launch. For either to go back on a core part of who they are would be a mistake. Facebook would be making the same mistake as Google if it did allow pseudonyms.
- DanBC 11y agoShould Facebook not allow "Robert Galbraith" (JK Rowling) to have a page? How about "JK Rowling" (Joanne Rowling)? Should she be forced to use her full forename? In England you can use whatever name you like, as long as you don't have the intent to deceive. (This is tricky with doctors and banks). So, legally, I could be "Bob Smith" and "Ann Jones" at the same time. Why does Facebook get to tell me that I only have one name when my government is fine with me having multiple names?
- zaidf 11y agoWhy does Facebook get to tell me that I only have one name when my government is fine with me having multiple names? Because Facebook isn't your government. It is a non-government entity with a very specific vision. If it finds that the use of fake names hinders the experience of other users and there by Facebook Corp., it should be allowed to require real names.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nxb 11y agoFacebook does the same with birthdays. I input my age as 90 when creating my account. They changed it to my real birthday somehow. AND then they expose it publicly to anyone who looks up my profile, even when they aren't my friends. AND this is all after me having disabled the "show birthday on timeline" and enabling every other privacy setting there was. If there's one company using AI and data collection for evil, it's Facebook. Not to mention the years of silently disabling previously set privacy settings without getting the user's permission - e.g. the "show profile in search". Insane. Facebook should be slammed hard by the courts.
- abluecloud 11y agoHow is that possible for them to know your real age, logically? (I don't mean you're lying, but only you can work out the link with other services and facebook that might be leaking this information).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nxb 11y ago- Deducing based on my median friends' ages. - Easily deducing my approximate age from my Linkedin profile. - Any of the numerous other private people data sources they have access to or have bought over the years. I'm sure my birthday and basic details are in some of those. It's impossible to get those all deleted once the information is out. - Day and month are easy, because everyone wishes me happy birthday in the messages and wall posts. All that's remaining is the year, which could be easily deduced from Linkedin and other third party data sources. - Which I've mostly cleaned up now, until Facebook exposed it all again. - I had a profile for a few months in 2005 before deleting it. Used a different computer, different location, different email and everything for this new one a decade later, but probably they've connected the identities. Looks like if you ever tell Facebook some private information, it's non-revokably theirs to expose to the world forever. Facebook invests very heavily in machine learning / AI, and uses it heavily through out their platform. They collect and buy tons of data both on the site and from third parties. This deduction is trivial for them. The bad part is not so much that they deduced these details about me though, it's that I specifically made it clear that I didn't want any age public, let alone the real age, and they exposed me anyway.
- glomph 11y agoMany of my friends already use pseudonyms on Facebook. They just use ones that look like a real name. Their reason is just that they want to be able to tell new friends something to search and still be invisible when they look for jobs etc.
- return0 11y agoFacebook and twitter will soon become the primary medium for a government to communicate with its citizens. It's the new press, so governments have to make sure their citizens have access to that information, regardless of whether they want to use their real names or not. The freedom of the press cuts both ways, and forces a number of responsibilities on these companies, due to their peculiar and de-facto monopoly state, and the sheer amount of attention time they occupy. The press was not completely unregulated in any well-functioning democracy, and i don't see the reason why the new (increasingly old actually) media should not be.
- docspace 11y agoHamburg Regulator == Hamburger Helper?