36 ms·
Sorry to burst your bubble
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoThe notion that bubbles are not all equally bad, and that bubbles fueled primarily by debt tend to be the worst, seems reasonable on the surface, but it's not always so easy to separate bubbles into two camps: those fueled by exuberance and those fueled by debt. Margin debt, for instance, has increased significantly in China[1] and in the US, stock buybacks financed by debt offerings have been a prominent feature of the current bull market[2]. Central banks have taken so much unprecedented action since 2008 that it requires a lot of faith to rely on analyses of past bubbles to predict what will happen when the current ones burst. [1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-13/china-walks-264-billion-tightrope-as-margin-debt-powers-stocks http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-13/china-walk... [2] http://fortune.com/2015/02/11/stock-buyback-binge/ http://fortune.com/2015/02/11/stock-buyback-binge/
- danieltillett 11y agoYes we are in rather unchartered waters because of all the central bank buying. It is very hard to use build models based on past data when considering the actions of the worlds central banks over the last 8 years.
- themartorana 11y agoIsn't this talking about personal debt, though? When they talk about the wealth effect in a stock market crash, it's pushing down on personal assets that are made up of saved money. In contrast, the housing crisis of 2008 (from which we are still collectively suffering) was preceded by people taking on massive personal debt well beyond their ability to actually handle, and many times larger than actual savings. The following burst has a pile-on effect, in that those already debt burdened don't simply lower spending habits, but rather fall into bankruptcy, default on mortgages and other loans, and so on, which puts a years- if not decades-long drag on economic activity.
- lingben 11y ago> Margin debt, for instance, has increased significantly in China It is even more insidious than that. Chinese companies have pledged their stocks as collateral for loans so the whole thing is a pile of circular promises, one built on top of the other. This is the real reason why the Chinese authorities suspended so many shares from trading before they stabilized the market. If the shares had continued to go down, it would have resulted in a massive credit crisis since billions and billions in loans would go into default. For more details see: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-07-08/this-is-why-so-many-chinese-companies-are-suspended http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-07-08/this-is-wh...
- x3n0ph3n3 11y agoDoes anyone see an author attribution to this article? I can't find one anywhere.
- theseatoms 11y agoStandard practice for The Economist. Really hurts accountability...
- manachar 11y agoAlso prevents ad hominem attacks and can allow informed authors to speak without fear of retribution. The Economist has a pretty decent track record and clearly wants the company to take on the accountability of what's published.
- ghaff 11y agoThe idea is that the accountability is at the level of the magazine, not the individual author. It's not the norm today (outside of many newspaper editorials) but doesn't mean there's an inherent problem with it. I'd also observe that, in many/most cases, when organizations like analyst firms put out reports they're widely viewed as the opinion of the firm even if they're bylined. Which isn't unreasonable given that they're presumably peer-reviewed. In general, bylines have become standard practice because writers, etc. want it. Not because publications and other content producers prefer it that way.
- coffeecheque 11y agoIt's The Economist. Most authors are anonymous. http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/09/economist-explains-itself-1 http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/09/ec...
- icelancer 11y agoGuess I'll never know why... http://i.imgur.com/fkcBjSa.png http://i.imgur.com/fkcBjSa.png
- zitterbewegung 11y agoYou know it's bad when the Economist says debt is a problem :( . If Zero Hedge, Seeking Alpha, and the Economist start agreeing things start getting scary :(
- partiallypro 11y agoI think the biggest voice to say there is a debt problem, at least in high yield and junk bonds, is Carl Icahn. It seems that the biggest problem is that the underlying debt market is very illiquid and people are using ETFs and other financial instruments to create liquidity. This is why Icahn called BlackRock a dangerous company. Icahn is not a man I'd want to bet against. Though, this so called bubble could go on for years. I think the market will have a minor "taper tantrum" but I don't know if that will be the needle or not. As the housing market of 2001-2008 showed, this can go on for a lot longer than people expect. People were sounding the alarm in 2005, but it didn't take full fruition until late 2007. IMO, the bubble will pop in the private market before we even see it pop in the public markets.
- myth_buster 11y agoIt's truly the case that the bubbles will pop later than sooner as there incentive and ways to delay the inevitable. But when it does pop, you have ran out of options to catch the falling knife, so to speak. Like forest fires, recessions are natural to capitalistic market and any attempt to prevent it only adds kindling.
- Solanaceae 11y agoAt this point, I think it's pretty obvious that these cycles track with a subliminal fear of U.S. Presidencies that reach their term limits. There's this sort of instinctual dry-up, right before the eight-year mark on an incumbent president, sort of like geese flying south for the winter. No one says anything to one another, but the angle of the sun changes, the summer weather is gone, and all the birds hit the road at the same time. Regardless of the parties and there representation in whichever offices, and under whatever titles, everyone knows that different people will be sitting in different chairs when the dust settles, for some, there will be a new-car smell, and for others there will be painful hours stepping through a debugger, converting data from one format to another. Either you'll be comfortable while the bugs shake out, or you'll be in for a cold winter in a drafty house, but since the immediate future is up in the air, everyone stocks up for a harsh winter.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hartator 11y agoThey might need to focus a lot more on public debt that has been growing steadily for the past decade everywhere in the world. This might be the next bubble and it might be way worse than 2008...
- omarchowdhury 11y agoYeah, so what happens if a country like the US defaults?
- hartator 11y agoThey won't default, they will just print more USD. Anyway, that will be still bad for everyone.
- Suncho 11y agoWhy? As we produce more stuff, we also need to spend more to keep prices stable. Printing money and throwing it at the economy is one way to make that happen. As long as our rate of spending remains in line with our level of production, we shouldn't see inflation or deflation. Why do we need a balanced budget? If you're Greece and you can't issue your own currency, your national debt matters. But the U.S. can always issue new currency to cover its liabilities. I guess I have a hard time understanding why we should care about the amount of the U.S. national debt.
- seoguru 11y agoYes! If more people understood this, the world would be a better place. Reminds me of this post on "fiscal conservatives": http://itsthepeoplesmoney.blogspot.com/2014/11/confessions-of-former-fiscal.html http://itsthepeoplesmoney.blogspot.com/2014/11/confessions-o...
- Suncho 11y agoInteresting. I like what he says about debt-to-GDP, but I'm not sure I understand his leap to the conclusion that we should be striving for full employment. I understand why we'd want to scale production to meet the increased demand induced by consumers having more money. But if it would be efficient for us to scale up production without creating jobs, why should we create jobs? What is the value of full employment?
- kitcar 11y agoOn a related topic, can anyone point me to articles / research related to how bubbles continue to inflate during recessionary periods? From my uninformed/simplistic viewpoint it seems like the two are opposing concepts (i.e. popped bubbles lead to recession), other then the fact that governments use low interest rates to try and dig themselves out of recessions, and cheap money tend to fuel bubbles. The reason for my interest is this seems to be what is happening in Canada right now ( see http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canadian-house-prices-35-overvalued-economist-magazine-says-1.3040698 http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canadian-house-prices-35-ove... + http://www.leaderpost.com/business/Johnstone+Canada+recession+what/11223333/story.html http://www.leaderpost.com/business/Johnstone+Canada+recessio... )
- tpg 11y agoDuring a general recession, there are fewer attractive investment opportunities. However, investment funds still exist and need to be put somewhere. It's easy for a bubble to form when too much money goes into one particular sector, but the bubble then only makes it more attractive for investment. Housing is a traditionally safe, stable investment, and (at least in the US) large funds have been buying up homes at a huge scale for investment purposes. I'd be glad to speculate further, but that's all it is. I can't point you to any articles on the subject.
- marincounty 11y ago"Housing is a traditionally safe, stable investment, and (at least in the US) large funds have been buying up homes at a huge scale for investment purposes." Personally, I look at a house-- like I do food. It's a necessity. I don't feel large entities should be able to buy up large units of housing, and dole them out when the market suits their greed. Even for personal realestate speculation, I don't think anyone should be able to own more than 5 homes.(I just picked that number out of the air). In other words, I'm not a huge fan of realestate speculation, and whenever I hear about corporations buying up huge swaths of homes, I think about Gordon Gekko, 'Greed is good!', and my blood pressure rises. While I'm at it--what's up with letting foreigners buy our land, before they become citizens? As it stands now, it looks like pretty much anyone, from every country, can pick up the phone, and buy American realestate? We have a hell of a time buying property in other countries? What am I missing? And then letting the house sit empty? I know it's legal--it just doesn't seem right? I don't want to argue with anyone, I'm a nobody, and no expert. I'm not financially sophisticated. I just know if I had a lot of money, I wouldn't buy up all the orange juice concentrate, and keep it frozen tell the price skyrocketed; then and only then, sell it to the peons, and make a killing. I just could morally do it. Maybe that's why I'm broke? Furthermore, I couldn't imagine being a landlord these days. "Hay Joy, I see your daughter is going 1st grade next year? That's great! Hope she's making friends? I know how tough the move, and divorce has been on her. By the way, I need to increase your rent next month by $500. Have a good day! I'm off to the gym! See ya!" Went way of topic--sorry. Just tired of feeling so close to being homeless; I'm dusting off my camping equipment. I guess living in the Bay Area is skewing my view of the morality of realestate speculation? I now feel sick? I need to take a walk. Happy Sunday people!
- michaelochurch 11y agoI think that this article is basically right, but would add that bubbles are generally dangerous based on what they represent, financially and culturally. If Bitcoin hits $1,000 again, it's not innately dangerous (unlike housing, no one needs Bitcoins to live). It might represent a bad thing, like the collapse of a currency. We're still in a housing bubble (although not as much as one, and one with a sharper geographic profile) but what's propping it up now is industrial decline and extremely lopsided job availability. Much of the country is starved of economic activity while a few metropolitan areas (e.g. New York and the Bay Area) have healthy job markets but extreme real estate costs. All of that said, I have no way of predicting how that bubble will resolve or when it will crash. We could see it happen in 2 years or in 25, and it will probably vary with geography (just as Vegas and Florida got hit hard in the last one, but the Bay Area and Manhattan remained unscathed). Housing bubbles are weird because there's so much corruption (foreign money, NIMBY regulations) involved that makes them political and therefore unpredictable. The 2001 tech crash didn't do a lot of damage to the rest of the world (9/11 did far more). The 2008 crash is still being felt in Southern Europe. I can't predict how much of an effect the ~2017 VC-land crash will have. To be honest, the numbers don't look that bad; when Silicon Valley drops a turd like ZNGA on Wall Street, the Street usually reacts with proper skepticism. So I think that this one's going to be relatively limited in terms of its impact on the rest of the world. I don't like what it represents about our society, and what it may continue to represent, because that is corrosive. The truth about VC-funded startups in the Bay Area is that 98% of that stuff has nothing to do with creating new value, but with devising ways to profit from widespread organizational decline.
- omarchowdhury 11y agoGood comment.
- iambvk 11y agoWhat is ~2017 VC-land crash in your opinion? Specifically, who loses money? How would it effect common-man who is not involved in stock market directly?
- S4M 11y ago
- jkldotio 11y agoI have flagged this because it's paywalled. edit. unflagged, apparently that's against the rules (that I disgree with but will follow)
- dang 11y agoThat's not an ok reason to flag something on HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9717733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9717733 Paywalls are not banned on HN, especially when there are standard workarounds.
- jkldotio 11y agoI wasn't aware of that rule and I've been on here for many years, it should perhaps be made more prominent. I also genuinely think it's wrong, people should be able to flag things which are inaccessible for them. To expand on that, what's the point in sharing a link where you have to pay or sign up to get access on a public link sharing site? As you can see from my other reply all I get is a sales pitch from the Economist. If someone shares an article I will read it and maybe upvote it. If someone shares what seems to be an article which isn't, it's actually a sales pitch for the Economist under another headline, then it's worse than blogspam, in my book at least. I run a news aggregator and I know for a fact there are a great many free alternatives to "NYT, New Yorker, Economist, WSJ" for both news and opinion, and that's just for the USA let alone the huge number of non-US sources. I don't particularly see why they should get a free pass when a smaller site would get blasted for having a paywall. I also have university access to academic journals that aren't public. They frequently contain very interesting things but I wouldn't post anything from them here because a large number of people would just get a paywall asking them for $30 to download the pdf. Thankfully more and more academic publications are going open, but a great many remain closed and they wouldn't be appropriate to share. But, if that doesn't persuade you, I will not flag paywalled sites now I've been informed of the rules (rules published in a comment 34 days ago).
- dang 11y agoOh, we agree about journal articles that aren't readable without paying an exorbitant fee. But the Economist, NYT, WSJ, New Yorker, etc. are accessible with minor inconvenience—not the same thing at all.
- Retric 11y agoI don't know if the 1929 stock market crash was really the start of the great depression. It seems like the real issue was far more widespread and the stock market simply accurately reflected what was going on. Even just the timing is suspect as many indicators started to fall in the 1928 while the market was still going strong. IMO, if you want to point out just one thing it was probably waves of bank failures which created and sustained a deflationary spiral.
- kvcc01 11y agoI listened to Bernanke talk about this once. The academic view seems that things weren't that awful until 1931, when a large Austrian bank failed (Google Creditanstalt), which triggered a wave of global bank failures [1]. The resulting lack of credit was the cause that made the depression Great. When Creditanstalt went down, Dow was off ~50% from its 1929 high, which still happens every now and then. We went through a similar decline during the 2007-08 financial crisis and came out all right thanks to aggressive and globally organized central bank activity. Unfortunately such an organized response didn't happen in the 1930s so the economies kept contracting, and the Dow eventually ended up losing 90%. Check out the charts in that period, it is fascinating. [1] https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/docs/meltzer/bermac95.pdf https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/docs/meltzer/bermac95.pdf
- Gibbon1 11y agoI've heard other somewhat contrary things, one is the birthrate started falling well before the '29 crash indicating that working class and especially farming communities were actually not doing well economically. You can look up graphs if you want, but the birthrate drops relentlessly from 3.2 in 1920, to 2.2 by 1930. As the economy improves post 1935 the rate picks up again. My take on recessions and debt is to consider that when an entity (family, business, etc) pays off debt they are foregoing some consumption. Key thing. Now in normal times foregoing of consumption frees up economic output that is invested in the real economy. As I pay off my mortgage, the bank reinvests that money in building more houses. A virtuous cycle, depending how much you like concrete, sprawl and freeways. In a debt driven recession there is a problem, the economy isn't limited by available production. There is a lack of demand. Because as people frantically pay of debt they are foregoing consumption that doesn't free up more physical or labor resources for investment. It just creates a lack of demand. The money instead goes to correct balance sheets which is something that exists on paper (or in modern times le computer machine). That's the situation many parts of the developed world are in today. The solution is for the government to step in an manually rebalance consumer and commercial balance sheets. A political problem exists when the people in charge can't let go of the 'paper wealth'. And that's the current issue.
- derf_ 11y ago"According to two new papers, the crucial variable that separates relatively harmless frenzies from disastrous ones is debt." Also according to, like, Irving Fisher in 1933: https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/docs/meltzer/fisdeb33.pdf https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/docs/meltzer/fisdeb33.pdf "I venture the opinion, subject to correction on submission of future evidence, that, in the great booms and depressions, each of the above-named factors has played a subordinate rôle as compared with two dominant factors, namely over-indebtedness to start with and deflation following soon after; also that where any of the other factors do become conspicuous, they are often merely effects or symptoms of these two. In short, the big bad actors are debt disturbances and price-level disturbances."
- danieltillett 11y agoVery hard to have sustained deflation when you are using a fiat currency. The only example in history has been Japan and this only occurred because of a political decision. We really should stop looking to the GD as a lesson for today’s problems. We don’t use the 30 Years War as means of explaining religious conflict or the Crusades to explain the state of the middle east.
- arthurcolle 11y agoGreat deflation is your GD as opposed to Great depression? Since you are talking about Japan
- danieltillett 11y agoI meant the Great Depression :) While it is worth looking to the past to gain understanding we need to be really careful about doing so since the past really is a foreign land. Edit. If a country wants me to cure their deflation problem just give me control of their printing press for a few months. I can guarantee that by the time I am finished Zimbabwe will be held up as a paragon of financial rectitude compared to my handy work.
- 11y ago
- crimsonalucard 11y agoSo is the US in a bubble or not? If we are, why? If we aren't why not?
- adventured 11y agoI'd say no. The US is one of the few developed nations that has been busy paying down household debt for the last five years. It's in far better shape than its peers. [1] Most major economies have been taking on increasing amounts of household debt, or are already carrying too much. That includes: Norway, Sweden, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, Switzerland, the Netherlands, France, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Spain, Ireland, Portugal. Others like Italy have taken on more debt (30% more in ten years), but started from a relatively low base. Or Japan, which has a bit too much household debt but has been flat for 20 years. The US, Germany and the UK are among the few that have been actively reducing household debt. In the US assets are richly valued due to the former QE and low interest rates, but there isn't a bubble (yet anyway). If the US continues to reduce household debt, while boosting employment and wages (the US unemployment rate is half that of the Eurozone), that will only improve the situation. The US will very likely substantially outperform its peers over the next decade; the strong dollar has reclaimed a lot of lost purchasing power for the middle class, effectively giving Americans a 20% pay raise versus the rest of the world (and that's before interest rates climb). [1] http://i.imgur.com/718Coeb.png http://i.imgur.com/718Coeb.png
- adebtlawyer 11y ago> The US is one of the few developed nations that has been busy paying down household debt for the last five years. In the US, the people with the highest debt-to-income ratios have been briskly filing for bankruptcy over the last five years. I wish I had time to dig up another graph to match yours, volume of personal bankruptcy filings over the same period. It's correlated. It's also a much stronger effect than paying down, often someone with over 100% debt-to-income goes to 0% over a matter of months, with no change in income at all.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago
- api 11y agoTwo words: student loan.
- brock_r 11y agoFunny the 2008 housing bust wasn't specifically mentioned. I'm still walking funny from that.
- unethical_ban 11y ago> Five years after the bursting of a debt-laden housing bubble, the authors find, GDP per person is nearly 8% lower than after a “normal” recession (ie, one that is not accompanied by a financial crisis). I read that as the 2008 one specifically, but that was an assumption.
- somberi 11y agoThis hit a chord with me: "Be it tulips, land, housing, derivatives or shares, they find that the consequences of a bursting bubble depend less on the type of asset than on how it is financed. High leverage is the telltale sign of trouble..." I see this today not just in the Valley but elsewhere in the world too (witnessed it in India and Sub-Saharan Africa). When wealth sloths in a 1% interest rate economy, it gets restless to find better results, often with disastrous results.
- deevus 11y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but it seems as though Australia is in for a disaster when the current housing bubble bursts. Median house prices in Sydney are around $1M, which is shutting out the majority of people in the 25-44 age range from buying their first home. http://www.sbs.com.au/news/map/housing-affordability http://www.sbs.com.au/news/map/housing-affordability
- RussellDussel 11y agoSydneysider here, 24 years old and pretty-decent salary. Maybe if I save for several more years, and buy with a partner, we may be able to afford a 1 bedroom apartment, with some financial help from our parents, in the outskirts of Sydney.
- Cub3 11y agoIt's now more expensive to buy in Wollongong (Sydney outskirts) then in New York http://www.wsj.com/articles/worry-over-debt-as-australian-house-prices-rise-1430207189 http://www.wsj.com/articles/worry-over-debt-as-australian-ho...
- deevus 11y agoI know the feeling. I'm 30. My partner is 26, from the Sutherland Shire. If we are going to get a place near her family (which she wants so badly) I just don't know how we're going to afford it. Even if I make a 6 figure sum, adding her teaching salary probably won't be enough to afford the housing prices out there. Couple this with the fact that neither of our parents have the money to help us buy a house... I'm pretty sure we're doomed for now. I keep thinking to myself... save or invest a tonne of money and wait until the housing bubble bursts to buy a house. I'm not economically savvy really, so I don't know how good a plan that is.
- adventured 11y agoAustralia has the same problem Canada does. It's strapped to China on growth with a dependency on natural resources. Now that China's growth is over - they're about to become Japan due to extreme debt, bad demographics and the easy growth having filled out years ago - Australia needs to find a replacement engine for its economy. Canada has already realistically slid into a recession. They'll have a bad ten years, due to the perpetual oversupply of oil, weak China and strong dollar. Their households have taken on vast amounts of debt in the last decade. All of those things are likely to pop their real estate bubble, either directly or after low interest rates push the prices higher. A nice thing Australia has going for it, is that its net median wealth per adult is well over twice that of Canada (and the highest of any major nation). It can afford to lose some of its frothy real estate market without a disaster occurring. The bad part is, the household income to debt ratio is around 170%, on par with Canada, and nearly twice that of the US. As with Canada, a lot of that household debt is of course mortgage debt, and it'll continue to steal capital away from economic growth in the coming years. I think Australia will take a hit, have 10 to 15 bumpy years of low growth and falling asset prices (which will be confused for deflation when it occurs). It'll otherwise weather the storm well. Australians seem to tighten their economic belts when they need to. The focus will be directed at paying down debt and getting out from under the fallout of the former real estate boom.
- ilaksh 11y agoEconomics discussions are like a bunch of 1980s mechanics talking in a garage. Or nuns discussing their faith. The fundamental technology and premises are outdated. You can't just have one number to try to track everything while 'externalizing' all the stuff that matters, like human and environmental health. And in our high tech world, relying on lawyers and politicians rather than building automated systems is dumb.
- netcan 11y agoHere's something I don't understand. It's probably more relevant to a country Greece's size than the US: Why isn't consumer banking more international, like every other major industry? In Greece, interlocking government & bank failures have brought down the country and it's causing this seized up state. People are now afraid of leaving money in a bad banking system. So banks have no deposits, and can't provide financial services. But, if Greeks had easy access to large & stable foreign banks they wouldn't need to worry about the sorry state of Greece's own banks. I mean, if Greece's local canning industry had collapsed they would be buying foreign canned goods and everything (at least on the consumer side) could continue undisturbed. What is the big advantage of a local banking industry anyway?
- zo1 11y agoIt's not about advantage/better. It's all about regulation. I.e. You simply can't bank across a border due to all sorts of regulations and laws. And I think that applies to both sides of the fence, both on the Greece side, and on all the "foreign" countries that you think can provide a "global" service to the Greeks. The bank and the state are intertwined due to this, and any failure on one will most likely affect the other. This will be the case until a true free-market approach is taken by banks. Are there decent middle-grounds between regulation and free-market? Sure, things could chug along.
- rjtavares 11y agoThat's the whole point of having a single currency and a common market... I should be able to open an account in any Eurozone bank without much trouble.
- SturgeonsLaw 11y ago> You simply can't bank across a border due to all sorts of regulations and laws I wonder how many people told Travis Kalanick you simply can't start a taxi competitor due to all sorts of regulations and laws
- tim333 11y ago>You simply can't bank across a border In my experience that varies. I have bank accounts in the UK, US, and Spain and in terms of saving money and transferring it there's usually no problem. Where it is localised is borrowing money against property. If you want a mortgage against a Spanish flat you have to use a Spanish bank and so on. That kind of makes sense as if you run off and don't pay the mortgage then the bank is stuck with the property and it's easier to deal with one down the road where you know the laws and regulations than one in some random other country. Especially if evicting tenants and so on is involved, things get pretty complicated.
- bobbygoodlatte 11y agoAssuming one agrees that debt is the problem and we're on the brink of a crash, how would you protect your assets?
- acjohnson55 11y agoInterestingly, this reminds me a lot of the view espoused by Bill Janeway in Doing Capitalism in the Innovation Economy [1], which, among many other things, studies the history of business cycles. It's a great book. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Doing-Capitalism-Innovation-Economy-Speculation/dp/1107031257 http://www.amazon.com/Doing-Capitalism-Innovation-Economy-Sp...