11 ms·
Maybe it's just me but I don't really like the tendency to treat pedophiles as if they are the devils themselves. Let there be no doubt. I have two kids and th
by ThomPete 11y ago
Maybe it's just me but I don't really like the tendency to treat pedophiles as if they are the devils themselves.
Let there be no doubt. I have two kids and there is probably no limit to what I would do to someone who did anything to my kids. But it's not as simply as just condemning pedophiles for being that and I ultimately think there is something morally or ethically questionable about this approach.
It's fairly well established that many pedophiles where in fact victims of pedophilia in their childhood themselves and so I would like to see a less hysteric and more balanced response to the issue.
Just because he is helping catching the bad guys does not give him the moral upper hand as he seem to think he has. Too bad such a complex issue gets treated with such brushing generalizations.
Maybe I am reading too much into what he writes, but these honeypots to hit random people just feels wrong to me. Like snooping on someone else life.
- allendoerfer 11y ago> It's fairly well established that many pedophiles where in fact victims of pedophilia in their childhood themselves … Wouldn't that mean, that he is not only trying to catch pedophiles but actively curing pedophilia? I think what is going on in the US with the public shaming of offenders in databases is wrong, but I am fine with honeypots to catch them. Legally he is in no position to do so, of course.
- ThomPete 11y agoMaybe a few but he is also hurting someone who might just be watching and could destroy their lives completely. As I said it's not that simple. I find it all disgusting but these people need help not traps. They are humans not animals despite what we think of some of their actions.
- allendoerfer 11y agoThere is no "just be watching". If you watch a child getting raped, you are committing a crime and better have a very convincing argument why you had to do it. It is in fact that simple. Of course they need help, too. We need both prosecution and prevention.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou will get quite a different punishment for watching child porn than from raping a kid. So yes there is "just watching" That doesn't make it less disgusting but it's not the same.
- ikeboy 11y ago>You will get quite a different punishment for watching child porn than from raping a kid. Source? The handful of cases I've heard of don't seem to match that claim.
- edison_carter 11y agoYou might be surprised. I'd say that child pornography is often punished more harshly than child rape. The justice system weights the crime of consuming child pornography by the number of images the defendent is in "possession" of. I guess laws vary, but at least in my jurisdiciton, you can be sentenced to years in prison per image. It would be easy for a single wank session to result in -- potentially -- life in prison. The issue is confounded by widespread lack of techical acumen among judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys, and even the forensic "experts" who investigate and testify (on both sides). For example, would you consider it reasonable to charge someone with a separate crime for every copy of the exact same digial file present on a hard disk? For both an image file and an automatically-generated thumbnail image of that same file? Do you meaningfully posess a file in your browsers temporary cache? How about a file deleted from the filesystem, but still present in residual form on the disk? Some of the issues are nuanced, and it's difficult to even have an intelligent conversation about the evidence. [source: computer nerd supporting attorneys]
- wstrange 11y agoIf watching a crime is a criminal offence, you better lock up the viewers of CNN, Fox News, and the BBC. I do think their ought to be laws against the distribution of this kind of material (there probably are?), and there is no question that producing it is a criminal offence, and should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> It's fairly well established that many pedophiles where in fact victims of pedophilia in their childhood themselves This point is oftentimes overlooked. Also, the word "pedophile" is oftentimes conflated with "child molester", which makes it impossible to distinguish the individuals who are pedophiles but have not (and have no intentions to) act on those desires. I found this article to be a worthwhile read on the latter situation: https://medium.com/matter/youre-16-youre-a-pedophile-you-dont-want-to-hurt-anyone-what-do-you-do-now-e11ce4b88bdb https://medium.com/matter/youre-16-youre-a-pedophile-you-don...
- ThomPete 11y agoExactly. Most people never actually distinguish between: Desiring, watching, touching and actual penetration.
- pluma 11y agoNot all pedophiles are child molesters, yes. But more importantly, not all child molesters are pedophiles. Just like any other form of rape, a significant portion of cases has more to do with power than with attraction. Sexual abuse is abuse first. The problem with child porn (in the strict sense of "pornography involving real children") is that all child porn is child abuse. So someone had to be abused to produce it and they depict actual victims in the act of being victimised. This is why possession is illegal, just as possessing other pictures of victims being victimised without the victim's consent is illegal (in countries with real privacy laws anyway) -- with the obvious addition that children can't give consent in the first place. Of course the (understandable) moral panic doesn't help. While it's obvious why actual child porn should be illegal by default, it's not as obvious why the same goes for non-pornographic material (unless your definition of pornographic is simply "what someone could masturbate to", in which case you might as well extend it to everything). An intuitive argument is that the proliferation of "child porn substitutes" (e.g. drawings, "naturalist" photography, etc) increases the risk that pedophiles might act on their drives. But considering that pedophilia is neither sufficient nor necessary for child abuse, that doesn't seem as clear cut. Also the numbers seem to indicate that for "normal" pornography, proliferation actually results in a decrease of sexual assaults (i.e. the "release valve" counter-argument). Legalizing it all is obviously wrong. Banning it all (as in those parts of the world where you might become a registered sex offender just because a shop clerk finds out you took a photograph of your own child in an entirely non-sexual setting) is obviously wrong, too. But I don't think we can have a reasonable discussion about this issue as a society before we've learned to accept that morality isn't defined by arbitrary commandments and every human is different.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoThe war on drugs didn't work out as intended. The war on pedophilia seems much safer. Except of course for teenage sexting. Where the legal system has ruined lives for no reason. Or the weird edge cases it introduces. Such as a theoretical case where someone wearing Go Pro comes across a pedophile actively abusing a child out in the wild. The good samaritan Go Pro wearer is now guilty of both production and possession of child pornography. The laws do not leave any room. Oh well!
- chimeracoder 11y ago> The war on drugs didn't work out as intended. The war on pedophilia seems much safer. We don't have a war on pedophilia. We have a war on "child pornography". I put "child pornography" in scare quotes because it's abundantly clear that many of the laws that aim to target child pornography really only use it as a bogeyman to obscure some other agenda. Also, as for "safer", whatever we're doing now is clearly putting children at risk. In many countries (including the US), pedophilia is exempt from typical confidentiality laws regarding mental illnesses[0]. This makes pedophiles less likely to seek professional help, and I can only imagine that this means that they are more likely to harm or abuse a child. [0] https://medium.com/matter/youre-16-youre-a-pedophile-you-dont-want-to-hurt-anyone-what-do-you-do-now-e11ce4b88bdb https://medium.com/matter/youre-16-youre-a-pedophile-you-don...
- dools 11y agoYes this has long been my concern. Is pedophilia something that can be rehabilitated? Is it mental illness? A sexual orientation? By providing people with no choices are we creating underground networks? To me there are echoes of drug prohibition here. I go fucking crazy thinking about my kids getting taken. When I watched true detective i was seriously ready to throw up. Particularly chilling was the last line: "we'll never get them all". Since law enforcement can never possibly eradicate a problem, and since we provide no way for someone to get help without being incriminated, aren't we just leaving the opportunity wide open for this to fester under the surface?
- 11y ago
- api 11y agoI disagree, and I think the problem is the framing. Call it rape porn, because it is. What would you think of someone trading files like "REAL video of ISIS soldiers gang raping and beheading girl!" Child porn, especially the "hard core" sort alluded to here, is in the same category. I do dislike the OP's guilt by association and vigilantism though. There's a reason we have a proper justice system. Imagine if someone like this was mistaken about one of those email addresses. You could sue him to hell but the damage might be done.
- ThomPete 11y agoThere is a world of difference between desiring, watching, touching and actual penetration. We might find the people watching child porn disgusting but they are after all only watching and not necessarily doing anything resembling rape porn.
- nkurz 11y agoWhat do you feel is the important distinction between "touching" and "actual penetration"? I'd think they both would fall under the same category of "child molestation".
- ThomPete 11y agoA kid touching a mans penis maybe barely aware that the man is getting aroused vs. a man penetrating a little kid. They both fall under the same category but they are two very different things. Also don't forget that a big part of the issue with pedophilia is actually society which because of the tabu and inability to distinguish between the different types of them ends up making the experience even worse and further adding to the problem. And again I am not in any way defending this behavior, I have kids myself. I just believe that the very thorny subject requires more careful thinking than just calling evil.
- ikeboy 11y agoThe obvious counterpoint is that beheading videos are legal to watch. The last time this came up on HN that I remember, someone linked to these posts by Rick Falkvinge: https://falkvinge.net/2012/09/07/three-reasons-child-porn-must-be-re-legalized-in-the-coming-decade/ https://falkvinge.net/2012/09/07/three-reasons-child-porn-mu... https://falkvinge.net/2012/09/11/child-porn-laws-arent-as-bad-as-you-think-theyre-much-much-worse/ https://falkvinge.net/2012/09/11/child-porn-laws-arent-as-ba...
- tdy721 11y agoI am normally a pretty level dude, but in this case I really do believe we are dealing with something supernaturally evil. This isn't snooping on randoms, it's exposing demons for what they are. (Atheist, but science just doesn't have the words for this.)
- argumentum 11y agoA a fellow atheist, I agree that evil is a real thing, but I still don't see the need to call it "supernatural". Evil is the opposite of good, so if we agree that actions to promote life, liberty and happiness are good, then actions that promote death, slavery and misery are evil. Simple as that. So there's plenty of evil in nature.
- richmarr 11y agoSo, lions are evil?
- Loque 11y agoRecently I noticed that most people I would consider evil, are actually people doing what they think is right but with the wrong information - as well as people giving into basic animal instincts that as a society we aim to rise above. Saying that, I have definitely met people with malicious intentions, who are definitely 'evil' (or lacking a severe amount of empathy for their fellow beings). I am not sure people with challenged sexual instincts are these people, however I am sure there are people with a combination of both behavioural traits.
- soylentcola 11y agoI consider a modern, secular definition of "real" evil to be based in the malicious or intentional "taking" of something from someone else for your own gain. That could be stealing for profit or taking life for non-defensive reasons or it could be forcible rape or other coercion that takes away someone's right to control what is done to their person. Not a complete or concise definition but the general theme I notice when I think about what I personally consider "evil" is the elevation of your own desires over the safety or well-being of others. In a way, evil (for me) is based on what helps humanity/society or hurts it. It's based in our natural instincts for empathy and the ignoring of those "higher" motives in favor of more primitive drives to take, hurt, kill, rape, or enslave. For me, good versus evil is not so much about religious or Hollywood ideas of light vs. dark or god vs. devil but the more familiar battle between our "animal" side and our "human" side.
- Lorento 11y agoI agree. I think people hate pedophiles in much the same way they hate(d) gays. Because it's disgusting and perverted, not because it harms people. The fact that some children do actually get harmed and that many people have children themselves that they feel very protective of fuels the emotion of labeling all pedophiles as "evil". If viewing an image of child abuse is wrong. Isn't viewing an image of ISIS beheading someone also wrong? In both cases the crimes were committed and the images produced to satisfy an audience. But one is illegal because it's perverted while the other is legal because presumably far more people have blood-lust than a minority sexuality. In Australia it's especially bad, with somebody being convicted for possessing hand-drawn Simpsons porn. There might be a copyright case there, but it's hard to make the connection between that activity and actual harm to any children. The defense argued that they weren't humans because they had 4 fingers and misshapen faces. This kind of case is what happens when the "evil pedophile" mindset overwhelms people. http://www.smh.com.au/national/simpsons-cartoon-ripoff-is-child-porn-judge-20081208-6tmk.html http://www.smh.com.au/national/simpsons-cartoon-ripoff-is-ch... You could go a step further and ask what's the difference between a parent taking photos of their naked child playing in the bath, and somebody doing the same thing but then having a wank with the photo later? I think the difference is that one is "normal" and the other is "perverted", so we make one legal and the other illegal. I probably appear in some baby bath photos and I certainly wasn't scarred by it. If they got onto the internet and people got some pleasure from them, is that really going to scar me for life, assuming I even know about it?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Ntrails 11y agoI've posited that the only law required is prevention of child abuse. Viewing/possession of an image as a crime seems inherently misguided - especially if criminality is going to be defined by assumed intent. However I have never been able to avoid the counter argument that by allowing (implied consent) a market for cp imagery you may increase demand which will increase the incidence of child abuse in order to satisfy. The bath photo is simply one end of a spectrum.
- Sideloader 11y agoI agree. Pedophilia is a sexual preference for pre-pubescent children, not an act. The vast majority of pedophiles are likely sad and lonely people condemned by a freak of nature to live with the burden of a sexual preference that in Western society carries the ultimate stigma. Even discussing pedophilia calmly and reasonably opens one to the charge of being a pedophile or a "pedophile apologist." Taboos can reveal a lot about a society but I'll leave that discussion for another time. I don't completely trust the motives of guys like the author of the linked article. Others have already pointed out technical errors in the article and questioned the soundness of his methodology. His irrationally labeling Tor as "the devil" is a bit odd too (and highly illogical), to say the least. He even admits he has an irrational hate-on for pedophiles. What is this guy actually achieving with his "honeypot" other than wrestling with his own demons (more on this later)? He set out to entrap ostensible pedophiles and gather their IP addresses etc. Not child abusers or child pornographers but people that clicked on his link offering a "community of like minded individuals." He explains in detail the technical aspects of his operation and what he learned about the people he interacted with and draws some very dubious conclusions. (Such as "Many visitors to the site were active pedophile predators." Maybe this is the case, but he offers no compelling evidence other than a few lines of a chat room transcript. Not once does he mention even contemplating contacting the FBI or his local PD or any other LEA. Rather, this seems to be mostly about him. There have been a few high-profile cases over the years where crusaders dedicated to fighting things they found morally reprehensible (e.g. prostitution, narcotics, pornography, homosexuality, child pornography) were outed as being voracious consumers and/or practitioners of that which they vehemently opposed in public at every opportunity. One of them was a DA who made a name for himself with his aggressive prosecution of alleged prostitutes and child pornographers. There is a term for this in psychology which I can't recall at the moment. Basically, there are some people who deal with the cognitive dissonance and the associated shame and guilt of being attracted to something society or their religion condemns morally by venting against it publicly while indulging in it privately. A guy who has an anti-porn website, say, and publishes anti-porn literature for distribution in schools who travels the country speaking out against porn and attending and organizing anti-porn conferences while fapping himself raw to internet porn every night after work. I am *not saying I think the guy in the article is a pedophile or harms children. I am saying that I don't think his prime motive for doing this project is empathy or compassion for victims of child abusers and predators. He sets up a "honeypot" that serves no practical purpose. No suspected child abusers were investigated, no children saved from harm, police and LE don't even get a mention. Nothing new and useful was brought the table. Yet based on his two-week escapade "Tor is the devil." That seems like a very odd statement, especially coming from an engineer. Is his computer the devil's sidekick? He does admit that he is motivated by personal reasons and it very much shows. After reading his piece I don't know what the take away is supposed to be. Pedophiles use the internet? Tor is used for illegal activities? Anyway, it's late and this is going in circles. I mean no disrespect to the author but I am left feeling very puzzled.
- DanBC 11y ago> Maybe it's just me but I don't really like the tendency to treat pedophiles as if they are the devils themselves. People don't know what the prevalence of paedophilia is, or the ratios of paedophiles that never act on that vs paedophiles who do act on it. If someone commits multiple offences it's easier to catch them, so the statistics of convicted offenders are probably skewed towards frequent offenders. That may make paedophile offenders appear to be riskier. It's important to remember that child abuse does cause very real, often severe life-limiting, harm. We've come a long way from the 1970s thinking of "making a fuss is what causes the harm" to recognising that it's the abuse that causes most of the harm.
- asanagi 11y ago[citation needed]
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoIt's another of those causes like clean water or treating people equally. Who wants dirty water? Who wants to create second-class citizens? Who likes pedophilia? As humans we love these issues where you'd be either an idiot or extremely asocial to oppose. We like slogans. We like to feel superior. We do not like nuance, or having to think a lot about things.
- facepalm 11y agoJust as heterosexuals don't rape people all the time, most pedophiles probably don't either. I think an estimated 2% of the population are pedophiles. I feel sorry for them. However, if they prove to be a danger to the kids, they have to be locked away or something. It's just because we don't know a better way to treat the issue.
- geek_slop 11y agoAh, but I believe that they do often act on their impulses. Mayo reported that more than 3/4 of persons who were arrested for child pornography were found to have molested a child. A federal prison study actually estimated even more.
- outworlder 11y agoWhat's interesting is that most people these days would agree that sexual orientation is not a choice. This is fine when we are talking about equal rights for homosexuals, but for some reason is abhorrent when we are talking about a orientation that is undesirable for society. (And thus classified as a mental disorder). Even if there is no crime involved, and there won't ever be. I blame the media for misusing the word "pedophile" to mean child molester.
- johanneskanybal 11y agoCould you yield that the potential for one party getting abused is alot higher if it's a 10 year old and a 50 year old vs two 50 year olds? Seems pretty obvious to me but trying to be specific for the sake of argument.