9 ms·
The economics of in-flight Wi-Fi
- akhilcacharya 11y agoJetBlue's WiFi is still free? When is that supposed to change? I read about their Ka band transition, but thought the free connections were for a limited time.
- chrismartin 11y agoAll of this seems predicated on the assumption that no work or fun happens without continuous internet service. Why not download and queue up your work/entertainment ahead of the flight? I look forward to digging deeply into something for a few hours without the notification hail and temptation to browse the web aimlessly. Also, it bears repeating that Gogo issues fake SSL certificates to intercept their users' encrypted traffic. http://www.symantec.com/connect/blogs/gogo-inflight-internet-intentionally-issuing-fake-ssl-certificates http://www.symantec.com/connect/blogs/gogo-inflight-internet...
- reagency 11y agoBecause our Android devices and web apps are really bad at proper offline sync.
- 0x0 11y agoIf you pay up for a given amount of megabytes of transfer, what is the risk that someone else can wireshark up your MAC, clone it and overrun your quota?
- colinbartlett 11y agoI know of two cost-saving measures for Gogo: 1.) Buy your pass on the ground first and it can be half the price. 2.) Some Delta flights offer free video streaming to devices via a Gogo app. Simply click the link that says "I need to download the app" and the internet switches on so it can redirect you to the AppStore. Switch back to a browser and it still works....
- newy 11y agoI find the $20-35 well worth it. I look forward to the day when wifi becomes standard on all flights. In the meantime, as a quick protip, you receive complimentary Gogo (at least on AA) with a business Amex Platinum. See http://ir.gogoair.com/phoenix.zhtml?c=251827&p=irol-newsArticle&id=1999486 http://ir.gogoair.com/phoenix.zhtml?c=251827&p=irol-newsArti...
- jordigh 11y agoSounds like you're the article's model customer -- the person who doesn't mind paying exorbitant prices because they own a business credit card.
- ubernostrum 11y agoWell, it's always been the case that people who are seen to be wealthy/"big spenders" actually don't have to spend so much because they get things comped. Higher-tier credit cards have a history of these kinds of perks, with airline-partner deals on those cards covering everything from lounge membership to in-flight wifi to refunding the application fees for trusted-traveller programs like Global Entry. And if you're getting that stuff comped, why would you complain about how much it costs someone who doesn't get it free?
- kchoudhu 11y agoI have no business and have three business credit cards. What's your point?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWorks for personal platinum Amex as well. Between my $200 in airline credit yearly, comp' Boingo/Gogo wifi, airport lounged, etc, its worth the $450/year annual fee.
- manacit 11y agoDo you have a source regarding Gogo wifi w/ a personal Amex Platinum? I'm fairly certain that only exist on Biz Plat, unlike Boingo.
- bjelkeman-again 11y agoHere is what seems a recent list of airline which provide inflight wifi. http://blog.edreams.com/in-flight-wifi/ http://blog.edreams.com/in-flight-wifi/
- sleepyhead 11y agoPaying for wifi: So airlines in America is giving not giving great customer service. What else is new? Meanwhile in Europe low-cost carriers like Norwegian offers free wifi on most flights.
- mirithekiwi 11y agoMeanwhile in Europe low-cost carries like Ryanair charge fees for not checking in online or not printing your boarding pass at home. I really don't think this is a Europe-vs-America issue.
- sleepyhead 11y ago1) I don't think anyone else than Ryanair does that. I do agree they suck though. 2) It is an American issue. Have you been on any airline from Europe, Middle East or Asia? If you generalise the offerings and compare the level of service then you will find that American airlines offers much lower service. Most European airlines are quite good, and most big carriers from Asia and Middle East are much better.
- idlewords 11y agoNorwegian makes you pay for water.
- icebraining 11y agoSeems fine by me, since I can bring my own water but not my own WiFi :)
- mcescalante 11y agoThis is why JetBlue won best customer service in 2014 and it doesn't seem like they really have serious competition; they actually make an attempt to make customers happy. I book JetBlue every single time I can (even when it's more) because I can actually use WiFi without spending more than my (already expensive) ticket cost, and I get more than a single miniature water bottle.
- ubernostrum 11y agoExcept JetBlue is switching to low-cost-carrier style fare tiers, charging for checked luggage and other ancillaries, etc., largely at the behest of their shareholders who feel that being indistinguishable from the other budget airlines would be more profitable.
- jrockway 11y agoThey're not quite the same as other LCCs, they do have "mint" service on transcons which is quite competitively priced. I stick to the legacy carriers because I tend to buy fares without all the usual bullshit included, and because I like the mileage program. (You can't redeem JetBlue miles for a first-class ticket to Hong Kong.)
- reagency 11y agoYou'll pay extra for Jet Blue, to avoid paying $10 for WiFi??
- dopeboy 11y agoOn a recent American Airlines flight, a 30 minute pass cost me $10. On a not so recent AA flight, an all day pass cost me $35. Depending on the cost differential in a JB ticket, it might be worth it. Sidenote - the prices on their pricing page [0] are significantly different than what I paid which makes me think the airlines are getting a significant enough cut to keep the status quo. [0] - http://www.gogoair.com/gogo/listAllProducts.do http://www.gogoair.com/gogo/listAllProducts.do
- tw04 11y ago
- aurelianito 11y agoThe economics of airplane wifi remind me of the economics of the hotels wifi. Go to a 5-star hotel and you will pay 15 extra dollars for the priviledge of having a lousy internet access. Go to a small hostel and you will get good internet access for free.
- bane 11y agoIt tends to also be location based. I find wi-fi at hotels in big cities almost universally bad, while the same hotels outside the cities to be generally good.
- sgnelson 11y agoYou have to take advantage of that business traveler who is expensing everything has "has to have internet access for work."
- delecti 11y agoMy understanding (though I don't have any sources and it could just as easily be hearsay) is that nicer hotels jumped onto the new business model and signed long-lasting contracts with providers of internet service when things were just getting established. So it's less that nicer hotels are necessarily trying to milk you, and more that the nicer hotels jumped onto the bandwagon when it was still a bad financial decision, and are passing their bad luck onto you. Of course, I wouldn't at all be surprised if your suggestion is right, and they're just trying to milk the more well off clients.
- jessaustin 11y agoI'd be surprised to learn that any of these hotels had e.g. twelve-year linens contracts. For that reason it's really difficult to learn they signed an exclusive wifi service contract for that long. How did they know wifi would still exist now?
- nly 11y agoMarriott are throwing in wifi these days, but you have to pay for premium access if you want to stream some Netflix
- contingencies 11y agoI was hoping for an explanation of how airlines globally price customer internet access out from a business perspective; instead I got a hodge-podge of quick reviews from a customer perspective of airlines in the US only. Typical... a better title might be 'In-flight wifi by carrier (US only)'
- yishanl 11y agoDoes anyone really expect anything of airline flights anymore? At least those of us in commercial/economy class? Years ago great customer service was defined as giving someone the can and some free peanuts. Now it's touch screen "entertainment in-flight systems." Not like any of those things have made the flying experience any better. So I just pick the cheapest flights available. Sure, Wi-Fi is a plus, but the environment in economy isn't exactly ideal for work. I've primed myself to fall asleep as soon as I get into my seat before takeoff, regardless of time of flight.
- Gustomaximus 11y agoCheapest is the main variable but when it's a reasonable difference (probably under 10%) I'll choose based on flight experience expectations - planes,food, entertainment, wifi, FF program etc. Personally I wouldn't write off the customer value of these add-on segments.
- joezydeco 11y agoNow it's touch screen "entertainment in-flight systems"... Enjoy that while it lasts. United is moving to a BYOD system where you use your own phone or tablet to watch in-flight entertainment. The new cabins have removed all screens and armrest audio systems (oh yeah, and headphones too) http://www.united.com/web/en-US/content/travel/inflight/entertainment/personal-device-entertainment.aspx http://www.united.com/web/en-US/content/travel/inflight/ente...
- delecti 11y agoHonestly, I prefer that anyway. I've got no shortage of devices with plenty of my own media, and now I don't have to be stuck 12" from a screen I can't reliably turn off, that will be shining advertisements and redundant safety lessons in my face when I'm trying to sleep.
- reagency 11y agoYeah the screens suck, but BYOD with no in-Seat USB charger sucks.
- obblekk 11y agoFrom an earlier HN post, apparently when Gogo invented their tech, basically every airline signed long term contracts at ridiculous rates. Even if they want to compete, their locked into a cost structure using outdated technology. I bet in a couple years the contract cycle will churn and all of a sudden, we'll get a EDGE/3G level performance at reasonable prices.
- Titanous 11y agoGoGo is quite aggressive about variable pricing. An all-day pass is $16 if you buy it ahead of time, but if you buy it on the plane it can cost up to $50. They also do split testing of their prices and discriminate based on the user agent.
- joshfraser 11y agoThey charge lower prices for mobile devices, so an easy cost-saving hack is to spoof your user agent to look like an iphone or android device.
- tehwebguy 11y agoAlso, if you have an AMEX Platinum you get 10 GoGo passes (per year, I think)
- colinbartlett 11y agoThat's only the corporate card, not the consumer one.
- oostevo 11y agoThe consumer one does have Boingo access, though, which can come in handy.
- reagency 11y agoIs Gogo vs Boingo basically business vs consumer? Or..? I just realized I never realized they were different, since the name is so similar.
- zifnab06 11y agoI believe so. Boingo is also used on the Washington state ferries. Its horrible - looking at $16 for internet for a (up to) 30 minute ferry ride.
- 11y ago
- JesperRavn 11y agoAlthough I don't work remotely, I can get most of my work done from my laptop even with very low bandwidth wifi. So even $35 for a 6 hour flight is a good deal for the company considering I'm getting hundreds of dollars worth of work done. I even pay out of my own pocket when I'm not traveling for work, since if I'm not doing anything else I might as well do work.
- craigds 11y agoNever pay for wifi. This isn't primarily a budget concern, it's just that it's almost always far worse quality than free wifi. And hotel wifi is always worse than hostel wifi
- mooreds 11y agoIt seems claer that the main customers are businesses (or employees). Even if I am footing the bill myself because I am a contractor, rather than expensing it, it still makes economic sense. By having Internet on the plane and working, I am making productive use of dead time. And exchanging even $40 when I can bill 3x that or more is a no brainer. Don't get me started on the benefits of the internet on flights when travelling with kids.