11 ms·
Dropbox Is Struggling and Competitors Are Catching Up
- shedletsky 11y agoThe problem with Dropbox is that it is not locally encrypted. This means it will only ever be used for sharing excel spreadsheets at work. Dropbox has a team of people whose only job it is to write AI software against the data being saved there. They have software agents rummaging through everything you upload (which is maybe not surprising, but also not a service I want to pay for). I think if someone could combine the sharing aspects of DropBox with some of the more secure cloud backup products (like CrashPlan) they would have a winning business model. The secret sauce would be figuring out how to do this without becoming a pure infrastructure provider, where the margins are a race to the bottom.
- jayess 11y agoI work at a very large enterprise and we've been in need of a cloud storage solution for the enterprise. Not where everyone shares the folder and all files are stored locally, but server-based cloud storage, so multiple servers can synchronize their folders for sharing in the local office. With A/D integration. And granular permissions. We looked at all the usual suspects: Dropbox, box.net, google, amazon, etc. For some strange reason, no one seems to offer this service except for some niche companies that have immature products. I don't get why these companies aren't aggressively pursuing enterprise services.
- khnd 11y agohave you guys checked out aerofs?
- wbond 11y agoNot sure if it ticks all of the boxes you need, but take a look at Nasuni.
- jacoblane 11y agoegnyte might also be worth a look.
- berntb 11y ago<cough> sshfs... :-) (I know, I'm hellbanned.)
- delecti 11y agoMaybe I'm misunderstanding your needs, but have you considered sharepoint?
- yurisagalov 11y agoHi jayess, Not sure if you're still reading this thread or not, but I'd love to chat with you more and see if we may be able to help you (or you can just sign up at aerofs.com -- we keep it free for up to 30 employees, so you can try us right out). Shoot me an email if you'd like, yuri@aerofs.com
- cjjoseph 11y agoDefinitely worth taking a look at the hybrid solution from Egnyte. Can leverage cloud and on-prem for scaling, performance, etc.
- puttergi 11y agoThanks for the shoutout cjjoseph. I'm a product manager here at Egnyte. The OP's use case is right in Egnyte's sweet spot. Our storage sync technology allows you to synchronize files among multiple on-premises storage servers and the Egnyte cloud. We support granular sub folder permissions and easy AD integration. Your Egnyte account will scale easily to thousands of users and many millions of files/folders. If anyone on this thread has further questions about Egnyte I'd be more than happy to answer them here.
- objectivefs 11y agoHave you checked out ObjectiveFS? It gives you a regular POSIX shared filesystem for your servers. Would be curious to know what you think.
- sblom 11y agoPart of their problem must be that they haven't done DropQuest in years. https://www.quora.com/What-happened-to-Dropquest-2013-2014-and-2015 https://www.quora.com/What-happened-to-Dropquest-2013-2014-a...
- shampine 11y agoAlways one of my favorite days.
- wooderson 11y agoDropbox has the most brilliant engineering team in the Valley. But they've hired fairly weakly on the business side.
- joosters 11y agoAfter reading about all of the product's faults in these comments, I hope they don't have the most brilliant engineering team in the valley...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mehrdada 11y ago> Dropbox has the most brilliant engineering team in the Valley. That's definitely been my impression having observed the company for years from outside and from interviewing there just a little while ago. Given their engineering talent, I can't imagine they'd lose the game entirely, but they might indeed struggle on the business side. I was really impressed with the sample of Dropboxers I saw and turning them down was a difficult decision.
- ljk 11y agoThey even poached Guido Van Rossum(guy who invented Python) from google
- dmix 11y agoThis was about the time I stopped using Dropbox: https://imgur.com/uoShTDo https://imgur.com/uoShTDo Syncthing has been an excellent replacement in team environments. As well as Tarsnap for more technical set ups.
- AceJohnny2 11y agoYou really think any other US-jurisdiction-based provider is safer?
- pekk 11y agoIn terms of this one concern, more obscure services probably are safer than one which is so overwhelmingly popular, and it makes a difference if the service does not have your data in plaintext. Of course it's easy to give up other kinds of security in exchange for reduced profile to NSA, that's a whole other issue.
- lfam 11y agoAre Syncthing or Tarsnap US-based? No. And Syncthing is just a tool that does multi-way sync across devices you own. If a company wanted to replace Dropbox with Syncthing, they would have to run one or more servers to provide the "always on" feature that their employees' "sometimes on" laptops sync to.
- cperciva 11y agoLeaving aside the fact that Tarsnap is based in Canada (since really, I doubt CSIS has any more qualms about asking for data than the NSA does), the whole point of Tarsnap is that I can't reveal customer data because -- unlike Dropbox -- data stored using Tarsnap is encrypted using keys which only the customer holds.
- jen729w 11y agoFWIW, I really don't like the new Mac client. It may be partially Apple's fault - changing the way they have to integrate with Finder - but it's just not as robust as it historically was. Have you tried creating and moving a bunch of folders? Something about the sync causes them to jump around, you get leftover "untitled folders" all over the place, it's just not a pleasant experience. If you move folders (full of folders), the web interface reports that you "Deleted 4118 items" (!) then you "Added 4118 items" (aaah). Stupid. I've been a Dropbox user forever and only recently have I lost faith that it "just works". [Edit: stated that I "hated" the new Mac client. Realised that was perhaps too strong an emotion for a bit of software.]
- WalterSear 11y agoJust be glad that you have't had days and days of pegged cpus. :( I'm actively looking for an alternative.
- jen729w 11y agoYeah I get a fair bit of high CPU usage, I hear the fans on my old MBA and quit/relaunch the process. Doesn't happen too often, only about once a week. :-/
- xenadu02 11y agoI think it's doing something crazy with fsfilters because I notice the DropBox process kick up CPU usage when I'm copying files in a completely unrelated directory (or even at the terminal). I think it is trying to observe all file changes on the filesystem.
- chrisfosterelli 11y agoI think Dropbox lost a reasonably large share of its market when the crowd that is both technical and privacy-conscious starting moving to more secure alternatives. I love Dropbox and still have an account, as it has a great user interface and always worked on Linux, however I won't use it for anything that I don't consider "shareable" anymore. I prefer Spideroak [1] for actually saving my important documents. Sure, it may not look as nice, but for zero-knowledge guarantee I'm OK with that. [1] https://spideroak.com/ https://spideroak.com/
- simplexion 11y agoSpideroak is great and I was lucky enough to get in on their unlimited storage they offered a while back. I still only use around 200GB so far, but with the amount of photos my wife takes of the kids it is rapidly expanding.
- TD-Linux 11y ago>but for zero-knowledge guarantee I'm OK with that. How can you guarantee that when the client isn't open source?
- click170 11y agoYou don't. Which is so disappointing because for a moment there they were getting my hopes up about Spideroak, but I can't get behind that in light of their proprietary client. Not even interested in trying it, its a non-starter in my books.
- chrisfosterelli 11y agoI can't. However, unless you built literally your entire system from source code and all of the programs that run on it and analysed that source code yourself personally, you can't guarentee that about anything. It's a matter of degree of trust. This is what Spideroak's business is built on. Sure, I'd like it if their client would be open source, however in the mean time they're still a better option than Dropbox for security conscious people and they have been working for a while to make as much as possible open source. [0] [0] https://github.com/SpiderOak https://github.com/SpiderOak
- simplexion 11y agoMy main issue with Dropbox is their deceptive practices of the past. I can't trust a company that behaves like that. http://boingboing.net/2011/04/21/dropboxs-new-securit.html http://boingboing.net/2011/04/21/dropboxs-new-securit.html
- farslan 11y agoThey have products like Carousel, which is not even capable of sharing photo albums with others with a direct URL, which was the number one core feature Dropbox had since one day. Meanwhile the competitors all support it (Flickr, Google Photos, etc..). I'm clueless why they neglect it but it's just silly not to do. When you think of how everyone is trying to get the Photos scene right.
- gcr 11y agoCarousel has always supported that. Select some photos, "Share", then "Get Link". The recipient doesn't need an account. They can also download as a .zip file. (The recipient learns your full name though, so I don't want to give you an example link... But this has always worked great for me.)
- farslan 11y agoUnfortunately this is not true. There is no way you can download a .zip file from an Album shared from Carousel. Here is even a support case with users complaining: https://www.dropboxforum.com/hc/communities/public/questions/202143075-How-do-I-share-an-Album-in-Carousel-via-a-link- https://www.dropboxforum.com/hc/communities/public/questions... I've discovered this when I shared an Album with my friend with over 300 photos. He was not able to download them all, I've just stopped using it at that step. Because they imho want users to sign up and include the photos in their accounts. So they value new user signup more than user experience.
- rogerbinns 11y agoMy experience is that Dropbox is currently "lucky" that they support (and work well) on Linux, while none of the competitors do. That at least means everyone can use it together, without requiring multiple solutions. Their "business accounts" implementation is incredibly poor for people who already use Dropbox (ie the people to best please and most likely to spread the good word). For some bizarre reason they decide on this weird merge of one business account and one personal account. If you have more than one of either then tough luck. If you don't want your personal stuff and your business stuff co-mingled then tough luck too. If you want exceptionally confusing web pages with hostile flows, then they have you covered. (Yes, I just set up another one today and it was beyond painful.) What they should have done is how Google etc handle it. You login with multiple accounts, have a selector between them and everything just works.
- chralieboy 11y agoThis was my experience as well. I had to destroy my personal account once I left the company because they couldn't unmerge them and transfer to a new account. This was like 3 months ago and I was shocked that they still didn't have this fixed. Now we use Google Drive and it just works, figures out accounts, has great permissions stuff for teams, etc.
- eru 11y agoAlas, Google Drive (used to?) suck on Linux.
- sciurus 11y agoThere's still no official google drive client you can install on linux. WHich is bizarre, considering chromebooks run linux and obviously sync with drive.
- r00fus 11y agoThat is not bizarre at all - it'd be like complaining about OSX apps not working on Mach BSD even though that's what OSX is built on top of. When companies build on open source, they generally don't make it easy for you to use the base product without their extensions. So for all intents and purposes in terms of a platform, OSX != BSD and ChromeOS != Linux.
- kelukelugames 11y agoI hope the DropBox employees still have enough money left to reserver soccer fields. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=awPVY1DcupE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=awPVY1DcupE
- akoumjian 11y agoThe real challenge is how to compete with a storage platform when online storage is turning into a sort of commodity. Companies like Google and Amazon are racing to the bottom on cloud storage pricing, so competing in this space completely depends on the value you are adding on top of storage.
- clemmer56 11y agoIt boils down to this: You'd have to be dumb to store important stuff on Dropbox. So you only share non-important things on it. And for that, it's not worth paying. You might as well us the many free alternatives. Storage is free now. Dropbox is doomed for these simple reasons.
- mayneack 11y agoWhich free things alternatives are better suited for important things and why?
- abcdefghijkl 11y agoI saw that they're opening new offices and was interested in applying there, do you think db won't exist in, let's say, 5-10 years?
- sjonnz 11y agoI have a hard time associating Condoleezza Rice with leading the charge on personal privacy. As long as Dropbox chooses to continue working with her, I will continue to steer my coworkers and friends to use one of the many, many other competitors. Even though there is no other evidence that others are better, selecting Ms. Rice shows poor judgement by Dropbox.
- LekisS 11y agoThat's also why I decided to stop using Dropbox (for personal and professional use) and I keep on telling my friends and co-workers to use a more secure and encrypted one. When everyone begins to care about personal privacy, how could they chose to associate with Condoleezza Rice ? Is there even a worse choice ? Edit: I'm using Hubic now, hosted by OVH (very very bad desktop app right now, but they're making progress, and it's cheap, 50€ for 10TB / year)
- curyous 11y agoWhat struck me about bringing Condoleezza Rice on is that it's an indicator that they don't have the customer's best interests at heart. I now avoid using DropBox whenever I can, replacing it with OneDrive and Google Drive.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pserwylo 11y agoGenuine question, as I am not well versed in valuations: How can a company be "valued at $10 billion" when it is sharing the "$904 million global market for business file-sharing"? Is it because of the term "business" file-sharing, whereas there are non-business customers who are also paying for these services that make it worth substantially more than $904m? Or is there something else about valuations like this that I am missing?
- raldi 11y agoThe investors believe that the market will grow at least 10x, and that Dropbox will capture a great deal of that market. Also, when people speak of a market, they're speaking annually.
- softdev12 11y agoThere can be several logical reasons for this. 1, investors expect the company to merge to other verticals (outside of business file-sharing). 2, their current business is already outside business sharing (with consumers). 3, the number is just for a time period (like $904 million per year) and their valuation is over a much longer period (e.g. decades). Any many other reasons...
- pserwylo 11y ago> 3, the number is just for a time period (like $904 million per year) and their valuation is over a much longer period (e.g. decades) Okay, so this along with your sister the comment from raldi points at what I probably missed: The duration for which the valuation is made is unspecified, at least in this article. Thanks for pointing this out.
- SoftwareMaven 11y agoValuations are instantaneous. It is, roughly speaking, how much a buyer would have to pay to buy the company right now. That's easy to do with public companies because it is just "trading price * number of shares". Venture-backed companies typically use their last investment round for valuation, where, if they had $100M invested in the company for a 1% stake, you multiply that by 100 to get the $10B valuation. It is likely an inflated number, but it's hard to tell because it isn't in an open market. It could be $1M or it could be $100B.
- jmuguy 11y agoOne thing that's almost made me switch is how they handle sharing links now. Putting whatever you're sharing behind a (imo deceptive) sign-up/sign-in pop-up. So I've gone from something really clean looking when I share a file with someone to something that looks like I'm asking them to sign-up for Dropbox. Does the paid version get rid of this?
- Tehnix 11y agoUnfortunately, the paid version does not get rid of this. It's quite annoying actually, I even had one of my friends ask "Why are you sending me a Dropbox signup link?"...
- sanderjd 11y agoI'm confused – when I click Share, copy the link, and open it in an incognito window, it doesn't seem to be behind a sign-up/sign-in pop-up.
- mayneack 11y agosame https://www.dropbox.com/s/ze9fhjs8y4miobo/Screenshot%202015-06-24%2020.46.03.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/ze9fhjs8y4miobo/Screenshot%202015-...
- greyboy 11y agoMy account has the same "problem" as jmuguy. It's really unfortunate as I often need to share files with non-technical/older people, and it creates unnecessary confusion. As well as anyone that shares files with me, I see the same pop-up (icognito window or not).
- lubos 11y agoDoes anybody know how many of their 400 million "registered users" are still active?
- FrankenPC 11y agoI know I have a junk account I use only once or twice a year.
- joeblau 11y ago> While Dropbox led the $904 million global market for business file-sharing last year with... > craft a more detailed business plan that could turn a company with more than $400 million in annualized revenue into one that makes billions Based on these quotes, Dropbox would me they have to expand beyond file-sharing right? Edit: Seems like others know arithmetic as well.
- delecti 11y agoOr they're expected to expand the file-sharing market, either to entirely new customers, or by converting customers who were using non "file-sharing" storage options.
- macjohnmcc 11y agoThe only thing holding me back from subscribing is the cost for entry (beyond free). I have plenty of storage space between the different services that I don't feel the need for as much space as they offer at the starting price.
- loopdoend 11y agoNext time don't put Condoleezza Rice on your board of directors.
- doctorpangloss 11y agoMy mind is blown that so many people report poor experiences. Perhaps this is the wrong audience. I exclusively recommend Dropbox for file sharing. It solves problems for families and small businesses, especially at its free tier. Even on a strictly philosophical level it excels. It's not that it solves problems (all the competitors do), but HOW: with folders. Everyone knows folders. People working together really ought to keep it simple and share a folder. It really idiot proofs what is otherwise a nightmarishly IT-esque process you get from Google Drive and Box. Like where do your Google Drive files live? Do they live in Drive? Do they live in Docs and Sheets? Why is it called Sheets now? Am I emailing a copy of the document, a link to the document, did I share it with this person? What does "anyone with a link" mean? Why are there forty ways to do the same thing? I think so many of us are missing the point on usability. I've only seen one poor experience with Dropbox: When a mom tried to install it by Googling, and somehow ended up in some kind of keywordspam site and installed some other garbage. Then there are the features that are great not because competitors lack them but because they're easy to explain. "View previous versions" and "Show deleted files" have saved the people I "IT" for. More importantly, it's trivial for me to explain, "Right click on the file and click, Show Previous Versions." But explaining to people how to interact with the hilariously multi-modal UI that's constantly changing on Google Drive? Sure it works, but it's so difficult to explain. I'm not disagreeing that on a whole, Google Drive is a more useful thing. But I'm not talking at some crazy high level of abstraction. People who don't "thing" but write essays, make movies, plan trips, send links, share tax info, share music, do research... It's a one-author-at-a-time each-person-is-a-stage-in-the-pipeline workflow. Dropbox really augmented what people already know how to do without opinions like Material Design, use Android phones, popups that suggest to use this non-built-in browser and non-built-in maps tool. Dropbox steps around all of Microsoft, Google and Apple's synergistic and collaboration-hostile bullshit. Google Drive makes a ton of sense for an organization like Google or Microsoft, where the prevailing reality of work is: A bunch of people work together to make a report for their manager's consumption and need to toggle on-and-off permissions across a variety of stakeholders. But jeez guys, can't we see that the giant-corporation nightmare isn't the reality of how things are done for the vast majority of normal and productive people? It would be shame if Dropbox allowed the enterprise mentality to creep in. IT is a horrible thing and I wouldn't want to inflict it upon anyone.
- habosa 11y agoIs it just me or is this a totally uninteresting article? There's no evidence stated for how Dropbox's competitors are "catching up" or how Dropbox might be "struggling" other than maybe some troubles scaling sales. I feel like this thread is just general discussion of things people don't like aboit Dropbox as a response to the headline, rather than a discussion of Dropbox.
- wj 11y agoFrom the first paragraph of the article: While Dropbox led the $904 million global market for business file-sharing last year with about a 24 percent share, No. 2 Box and No. 3 Microsoft each took about 21 percent and doubled their slice of the pie, growing almost twice as fast, according to researcher IDC.
- pwnna 11y agoI'm surprised no one here mentioned Seafile as a competitor. They are completely open source => from client to server. I host my own for myself and my family for like a year now and it's super smooth[1]. I have the system setup with an actual certificate. It also allows you to enable client side encryption[2]. [1]: the deployment process is incompatible with how i manage my servers, so that was a pain, but mostly figured out. [2]: encryption may leak some information, but it is better than nothing.
- Aloha 11y agoIs there a good replacement for dropbox, for the purpose of filesync between machines?
- chrisper 11y agoIf you want to use your own server, look at aerofs. It is free for up to 30 clients.
- robg 11y agoFUD
- partiallypro 11y agoSurprised many people here seem to think Google Drive is the defining competitor. When the real money is made in enterprise, which I would say Microsoft dominates with OneDrive. Microsoft's bundling of Office 365 with OneDrive and internal sharing is something only Google could compete with (but can't because at least for large corporations, Google Docs does not suffice.) I have found that Google has the best for collaboration, but the money is made in enterprise and OneDrive is making in-roads because of what it is bundled with.
- ams6110 11y agoGoogle Drive and Office/OneDrive are outcompeting because they do both storage and cloud apps with collaborative editing that is feels natural and works well. Dropbox is just storage with some nice sync capability.
- holychiz 11y agoWe have OneDrive but I'm not aware of anybody in our large company using it. Instead our team spend extra money on Dropbox, and Box. OneDrive is clunky, hard to use. It does not even integrate well with Office365, let alone other apps. In terms of UX, OneDrive is a disaster. Google Drive has a fatal flaw that kills its enterprise growth: you have to register your primary domain, no sub-domains allowed. This is fine for start-ups, but in enterprise, if one team sign up for Google Drive, no other teams can sign up separately! In a large company, it's next to impossible for our team to find that original team to pair up for Google services, if they're willing to share the services at all, budget issues and all that.
- veidr 11y agoI think the key to this story is that Dropbox has been a good product for individuals, but Dropbox for Business has been and remains absolutely terrible. We trialled it for several months at work, and it failed in all sorts of ways. Not enough admin control, confusing to add employees, and -- worst of all -- sync failures where some employees sharing the same set of folders would just randomly not sync a bunch of the files. This led to things like Alice telling Bob to look in the shared folder for a file, Bob telling Alice it wasn't there, Alice telling Bob yes it was, Bob telling Alice no really it isn't, Alice coming over to Bob's PC to see that hey it really isn't there, and then finally just emailing the file to Bob. I myself got to deal with their business support a few times, regarding a bug that corrupts some PDF documents shared via Dropbox if they contain Japanese text. The "within 12 hours" response the website promised never happened -- it took days/weeks. They don't have any mechanism for me, as the customer, to follow or get updates pertaining to our support ticket for this issue (and it was kind of a show-stopper, since I work for a Japanese company). Finally, the fact that they have this type of a bug at all -- can't display international text? what decade is this? -- and that it goes un-fixed for 8+ months, didn't give us confidence in Dropbox. If our experience is typical, I don't think Dropbox is going to do nearly as well in the business space as they've done in the consumer market.
- adamconroy 11y agoI agree totally. I almost fell over laughing recently when I saw a new headline about Dropbox and business customers. It might have changed, but the one thing that summed up how useless it is for business is that you can't effectively run it on a server.
- defen 11y ago> a bug that corrupts some PDF documents shared via Dropbox if they contain Japanese text That's really disturbing. Is Dropbox not just moving bytes around? Why are "PDF" or "Japanese" even relevant?
- veidr 11y agoSorry, I should have been more clear -- that sounds worse than it is (although it is still bad). The original file data in the Dropbox is not corrupted; it is only the PDF presented in the web browser (to the user with whom you shared the data) that is corrupted. What happens is, when you share a PDF file via link, instead of presenting the actual PDF file in the browser (which would work fine) Dropbox instead presents its own PDF viewer inside the web browser and shows the file. This "PDF view" has problems with many PDF documents containing Japanese text, and either doesn't render the Japanese, or renders bogus data instead. Depending on the contents of the document, this can result in it looking like gibberish, but it can also result in a document that looks correct to the recipient but is actually totally wrong. For instance, one real-world case was a document with a long list of work items for a project. The items happened to be in English, and in Japanese many of them said 'CANCELED' (中止)in the right-hand column. The Dropbox PDF viewer failed to render only the Japanese in the right hand column, so to the recipient it looked like e.g. a list of 100 work items, when in fact the point of the document was to communicate that 60 of the 100 items had been cancelled. In this case, there was no hint at all to the recipient that there was anything amiss. It's a bad bug, and dramatically reduced the utility of Dropbox for our company. But, to be clear, the original data stored in Dropbox was not corrupted.
- edpichler 11y agoDropbox is one of the best software/services I ever used. Think on this: they competitors are Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Pen drives, FTP, etc, and they succeed! This seems really difficult to me, to build a huge service on a very hostil business. They are more alive than ever, and it's not because they are lucky, it's because these guys are really really competent. I really admire this company.
- restalis 11y ago"competitors are Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Pen drives, FTP, etc" Pen drives are not comparable with data sharing services (which is one of the Dropbox's usage). FTP is not secure and if FTPS were available sooner then Dropbox would have been a much tougher sell now!
- codesushi42 11y agoThey should have sold to Apple when they had the chance. It's funny that they didn't have enough foresight to see that large players like Google would amass the infrastructure to easily out compete them. And that infrastructure came for free from Google scaling out other efforts. Online storage is such a commodity now. They've got nowhere to go but down, unless they can offer a really innovative solution that offers more than file storage. Otherwise their interface just seems really dated now and their mobile apps are terrible.
- pen2l 11y agoWait, Apple made an offer to acquire them? I was not aware of that. Anyway, I'm also surprised by the series of very bad moves of all sorts by the Dropbox crew. They're focusing on various areas these days which to my understanding just spells dead end, like being a place for photo storage (competing with Flickr), etc. They lost any good will they had built by having Rice on board, and then sticking with that decision even after seeing the bad reception. It's surprising because I thought Drew Houston et al. were very strategically smart folks who couldn't make these types of mistakes.
- codesushi42 11y agohttp://techcrunch.com/2011/10/18/dropbox-said-no-to-nine-digits-acquisition-offer-from-apple-steve-jobs/ http://techcrunch.com/2011/10/18/dropbox-said-no-to-nine-dig...
- bane 11y agoJust think about this: Google (within the scope of photos) has given every person unlimited photo storage. That's how much cloud storage is worth...nothing.
- j_s 11y agoAlso worth mentioning Amazon Prime Photos here, even though it requires a Prime membership.
- bane 11y agoI've been a long time DB user. The company has always given me some weird feelings, but the execution of the syncing and clients has been better than anybody else up till now. I have to say though, if I had as easy to use a set of multiplatform clients that let me just use the storage I have on my home network I'd drop them in a hot minute. And I think that's part of DB's problem. That's really all they do. Sure there's some oddball photosyncing or whatever. But after all these years DB has yet to figure out really anything other than being a "cloud bucket" for people to dump things into. It's a platform at best without a real killer app. Really obvious extensions of DB have yet to materialize: like file hosting, or web-site hosting right out of your DB. I'm a (very) amateur musician, how awesome would it be if I could distribute/sell my music right out of my db -- as simply as just copying up another song file -- and having a store automatically update with the new inventory (and DB gets a cut)? Or let me host a hobby site where I distro my new open-source cat sharing software? DB's strength to me has always been the ability to get stuff up and on the internet quickly and simply without fussing with ftp/scp/sftp/etc. clients and servers, hunting down hosting providers, building web servers etc. But the execution of sharing off of that space in the cloud has been fussy, changes all the time and DB severely caps external transfers. What if the DB client was a P2P client also, so when I go to download the latest Mitch Murder album (which he's hosting out of his dropbox and will revenue split with DB), DB doesn't have to swallow all the bandwidth of the download because all the free DB users are helping split the load and making themselves more valuable than the leeches they all are? Or how about if paying customers could set up several paying accounts on a system and easily switch between them instead of the mess for multiple user accounts right now (under the excuse it prevents free users from leeching). Why is a company with 1200 employees worth $10billion unable to come up with these easy ideas and instead get caught up in an enterprise cloud storage provider battle with a dozen other companies? Why are the clients slowly getting worse? What the hell are people doing there except admiring the fake antler mounts? [1] 1 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAfIDUTPJJM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAfIDUTPJJM
- hughc 11y agoIf your only value metric is about personal storage, then you might see Dropbox as 'doomed' by its more-space-for-less-cost competitors. I've worked with Dropbox and OneDrive and despite many people having access to a nominal TB of OneDrive storage via Office365 subscriptions, the creaky, Sharepoint underpinnings of the latter still make it a poor alternative to Dropbox for simple collaboration and sync. You can't just drop a bunch of files into the relevant folder on your HD and have them shared and synced; things like file name limitations will crop up, stalling the process indefinitely, and users don't see why it's their responsibility to work around those sort of things. As far as collaboration is concerned, the ubiquity of Dropbox across platforms will keep it in front for some time to come.
- overgard 11y agoSo I'm still a dropbox customer, but I haven't really used it in months. The problem is the "just one folder" thing is really limiting. I really really need the ability to map it to different places on my hard drive. A lot of programs are finicky about folder layout, and dropbox does not work well with them. I ended up just buying a VPS with git support and using that. It's obviously a very technical thing that most people won't do, but it's way more flexible. I think the problem with dropbox is it's very easy to get started with them, but the advanced use cases are not only not considered, it's clear they just have no interest in those uses.
- nemothekid 11y agoI've never really found it all that limiting, and I'd argue I prefer it that way. The solution I've come up with is putting a symlink in the dropbox folder to the folder that needs to be synced. That way dropbox "sees" all your files, but your programs can just continue like normal. (I'm guessing you are on OSX/Linux).
- overgard 11y agoI'm a weirdo that still uses windows (on my mac, of all things), because its graphics drivers are better for graphics programming and visual studio is way nicer than xcode. I use OSX too, but I can't really depend on symlinks existing across my machines.
- sapek 11y agohttps://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc753194.aspx https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc753194.aspx Or does Dropbox not support symlinks on Windows?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- anotherevan 11y agoSpiderOak will let you handle assigning different folders.
- rokhayakebe 11y ago300M users, Does one think it would be just easier to charge everyone $1/mo for unlimited storage and be done with this?
- dools 11y agoI used Dropbox for ages, until it came time to get serious about team accounts. Of course I had problems all the time with outsourced contractors using their personal Dropboxes for files. Stuff went missing etc. Team accounts are the solution -- however when your team involves up to 35 people (including software testers, VAs, project managers etc.) the per user cost is utterly insane monthly. Also you can't share folders that are sub-folders of shared folders which is a stupid restriction. The only reason I was using Dropbox and not Google Drive in the first place was because a) the web interface for Google Drive sucked 4 years ago and b) they didn't have a good link sharing feature. Now Google Drive kicks Dropbox's ass not only in terms of their web interface, but also with more flexible link sharing, better permissions control (ability to share sub-folders of a shared folder) AND no per user cost. And you can pay them $1.99/month for 100GB storage. OneDrive is a fucking debacle. I can't believe even one person uses Microsoft's cloud services, but it's all part of the cascading requirements that start with Excel and end with $5,000 servers being used to run archaic business management software written in VB ... so Microsoft may have a fair bit of the market, but it's by default. Their products stink to high heaven. Google Drive is the only logical choice for cloud storage now, they've already eaten Dropbox's lunch, we just have to wait for everyone to realise it.
- gregpilling 11y agoWe also gave up on Dropbox and went to Google with the unlimited apps plan. It seemed easier, solved the problems, and reduced by one the number of systems we needed to understand. $120 per year per employee is easier to deal with, if it includes all the other Google Apps integration.
- _pmf_ 11y agoJust pray you will never need any kind of support.
- com2kid 11y agoI may be biased, I work at MS, but I've always loved OneDrive. It just works everywhere. On my laptops, tablets, and across both Windows Phone and Android. Google keeps doing UX things with photos and Google Drive that confuses my #1 usage scenario (finding photos). It also has some strange integration with Google Docs. It all sorta works but, again, the UX changes pretty damn frequently. OneDrive has reliably stuck with "here are a bunch of files."
- colinbartlett 11y agoIt frustrates me that the comments here on articles like these consistently devolve into nothing more than a list of anecdotes for or against. I'd appreciate more reaction and comments on the actual article content instead.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoYou see, there is this: "Its total 2014 revenue was about 60 percent of Dropbox’s, according to IDC, but its market value is now only one-fifth of Dropbox’s private valuation." So if you're measuring your net worth in Dropbox shares, be very very careful. Now I happen to like Dropbox, but I'm not a business user, just a personal user. And having recently been exposed[1] to some of the sorts of things a large enterprise player wants in a shared storage solution I can see that there are a lot of missing pieces relative to that market. [1] By virtue of being acquired by one.
- roymurdock 11y agoDropbox entered the market first and thus had a first-mover advantage. They also did well to give away space for free and with referrals. I have 20gb of free space because I would refer all my friends in college to Dropbox whenever we had to work on a group project. It has been ~2 years since I've referred anyone to dropbox. Now we use google drive for any collaborative projects. The functionality of docs, sheets, and slides is unparalleled. The service they provide is extremely homogenous. Data storage is a commodity. The only way to differentiate is through the UX/UI/link sharing features. Dropbox hasn't really done anything in this space since I first started using it. They added a feature that automatically syncs my photos from my phone to my box. Great, get me to hit the data cap, I get it - you want my money. The people who work at Dropbox are very competent. I spoke to a few recent hires from Ivy Leagues on the phone while I was looking at job prospects. They decided to take positions as glorified customer support reps because they wanted to work at a prestigious company with other folks of their caliber. One guy told me that he had no illusions that dropbox was changing the world, but that he would be well set-up for whatever his next job would be in San Francisco. If I were Dropbox right now, I would be looking to be acquired by Microsoft or Amazon to migrate users (Dropbox's only valuable asset at this point, which is rapidly declining) and dig in for the battle with Google Drive.
- dagw 11y agoDropbox entered the market first and thus had a first-mover advantage. Dropbox wasn't first. There where and handful of other companies doing more or less the same thing at the time. Dropbox just offered a much better product and showed everybody how it was supposed to be done.
- junto 11y agoMy experience is this. It works well. It does the job but the bottom line is I don't trust them not to be pumping every file upload (and everybody else's files) to the NSA. The old Condi Rice appointment was a huge red flag. I'm itching to leave. I'm currently trailing Spideroak and it seems OK so far.
- _pmf_ 11y agoI tried Microsoft OneDrive and managed to get the first file I uploaded (a 150 MB ZIP archive) to be stuck in some partially uploaded state so that it cannot be deleted or reuploaded). This was with the original OneDrive client that comes preinstalled with Windows 8.1.
- scurvy 11y agoI'm really surprised that no one has mentioned Bittorrent Sync as a Dropbox competitor. We all have several TB's of extra storage lying around between our work computer, laptop, home machine, phones, etc. Why not sync stuff directly between all of your machines and skip the cloud middleman (and the chance that all your files are belong to someone else)? Remember that day or two when anyone could log in to someone else's Dropbox account?
- sdalfakj 11y ago> Bittorrent Sync Because it is still closed source AND requires all your computers to be online for syncing to work. I went with SpiderOak. Happy user.
- scurvy 11y agoNot all must be online, just 2. Also, Dropbox isn't open source, nor Box, Google, Microsoft. I don't think that's really a requirement for success in this space.
- letstryagain 11y agoOnly one computer needs to be online for the sync to work. This is a good thing because your files never go to a third party. You don't have to trust Dropbox or anyone else with your data. Plop it on a couple of servers and you're good to go.
- NoGravitas 11y agoOr Syncthing, which does very much the same thing as BTSync -- multi-way sync of one or more directories between several computers you own/control. Syncthing is free software, and offers better security guarantees than BTSync, but as a result it's slightly harder to set up a folder on each client. Or there's also OwnCloud, which gives you a very simple user experience; you just need to have a centralized storage server set up.
- silverlake 11y agoDropbox supports LAN sync, which is like BT Sync. I'm surprised this isn't a killer feature for companies. If I upload 100MB to a shared folder, other sync tools will download a copy for every user. That could be a huge amount of traffic. BTSync and Dropbox solve that problem.
- charleswitt 11y agoGiven the Condi Rice appointment it would be silly to put important files on DropBox. I only use it for non important files. And in that case I might as well use the free competitors. So DropBox has a very weak business case, at least for consumers.
- thanatropism 11y agoClickbaity title sez > Dropbox is struggling Article clarifies > Dropbox’s revenue grew more than 50 percent last year. Storage isn't a network-externality heavy business as, say, social networking or, hell, desktop software. Your use of SpiderOak doesn't alter my utility function between SpiderOak/Dropbox/Google Drive/etc. Unless, of course, storage starts building the application layer in, as Google is wont to do... At any rate, it's a big potential market still.