14 ms·
Lego Universe's Dong Detection Problem
- sosuke 11y agoI'm surprised that there isn't a parental agreement requirement possible to absolve lawsuits against player created content. This is similar to the Call of Duty dong and offensive content problem in user created emblems.
- vinceguidry 11y agoWouldn't fix the problem, which is damage to the brand. If word got around to parents that their new lego game isn't kid friendly cuz of dongs, that's far worse than any number of lawsuits. Lots of them would never buy another lego game again.
- apendleton 11y agoThe big concern is COPPA compliance; COPPA violations don't give the parents grounds to sue, they give the FTC grounds to initiate an enforcement action. Parents aren't parties, so they have no rights to waive in an parental agreement.
- dylancollins 11y agoActually this wouldn't be a COPPA issue. COPPA is about data privacy, not content.
- __z 11y agoRead the text of COPPA - http://www.coppa.org/coppa.htm http://www.coppa.org/coppa.htm Its all about collecting personal information from a child, not allowing them to see lego dongs.
- striking 11y agoIt just goes to show you that no matter the capabilities of the medium of the day, people will do anything to expose their genitalia. From Pompeii[1] to LEGO Universe. Gosh. Although I have to admit that I've been puzzling about this kind of problem in my spare time because it is a very difficult problem to solve with plain algorithms. Which makes me ask, why don't they just separate the kids who draw dongs into a separate pile and only let them interact with each other? Or something like that. Something like GTA V's "cheater pool" [2] or HN's hellbanning. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erotic_art_in_Pompeii_and_Herculaneum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erotic_art_in_Pompeii_and_Herc... [2]: http://www.gta5tv.com/gta-v-cheaters-pool-details/ http://www.gta5tv.com/gta-v-cheaters-pool-details/
- tempestn 11y ago> why don't they just separate the kids who draw dongs into a separate pile and only let them interact with each other? Ha, I can't imagine any issues with that from a PR perspective at all.
- joshuapants 11y agoYeah, in a kids game you'll probably get an awful lot of complaints from parents when they find out that their child is suddenly only capable of entering games with dongs as the primary focus.
- cmdrfred 11y agopoor kid makes a rocket ship ends up in dong world.
- doktrin 11y agoThis may be the most entertaining thread I've ever seen on HN.
- empressplay 11y agoor on the planet Porno...
- sehugg 11y agoRemember Second Life? http://m.theregister.co.uk/2006/12/20/sadville_flyers/ http://m.theregister.co.uk/2006/12/20/sadville_flyers/
- thrownaway2424 11y agoSL is still a thing. I was once paid to write a robot that wandered around SL classifying the goings-on into perversions/other. If you've ever seen SL you know that ratio.
- TrevorJ 11y ago99:1
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> SL is still a thing. It still exists, yes, but it is almost dead. It is a shadow of its former self and it is a crying shame.
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoGiven that my legitimate, above board enterprises never went anywhere because 98% of the population was on adult islands getting frisky, I don't know about crying shame. That game was a depressing look at people. I don't mean this to sound like I am not a fan of sex, but Christ, there are other pleasures in life and that game seemed like a single track mind.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoYou seem a bit too bitter. I wonder if SL's sex obsession is just because it's one of the few things that works well in its world.
- yellowapple 11y agoA few months ago I got a haircut from a middle-aged lady with a subtle Mid-Northern U.S. (Minnessotan? Dakotan? Yooper?) accent who - in response to my responding to her "So what do you do for a living?" question with "computer programming and repair" - spent the entirety of our time together talking about how much she loved to go on Second Life and hang out with people, interspersed with various remarks about SL clients infecting her computer with viruses and being unsure how she could better protect her computer from said malware.
- elchief 11y agoRecent nipple detection post from reddit:http://m.imgur.com/a/6KUEu http://m.imgur.com/a/6KUEu
- bsilvereagle 11y ago*NSFW
- elchief 11y agoOh, ya, NSFW...Oops Here's the original thread too: http://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/33n77s/android_app_nipple_detection_using_convolutional/ http://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/33n77s/andr...
- nilsbunger 11y agoPutin has a third nipple?
- Nexxxeh 11y agoI can say with a 95% confidence, yes. Putin has a third nipple.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThose "humans" are weird. There is quite clearly another nipple there.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoCan confirm. Putin is Scaramanga.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's totally meaningless without a control that shows how it did on a set of images without nipples and how it did on a mixed set of images both with and without (after all, these could simply be selected to show 'good' cases). Detecting nipples when you know they are present is relatively easy.
- giancarlostoro 11y agoWhat are they doing to stop kids from making Lego dongs in real life? But on a serious note: I've always wanted a "minecraft" legitimate Lego game. It's just something I would play even if it were only Single Player, but had several modes like a story mode, and then obviously a creative mode. I enjoyed Lego City Undercover, still haven't beaten it, it's quite fun to run around exploring the depths of the game.
- na85 11y ago>What are they doing to stop kids from making Lego dongs in real life? Nothing, obviously. Nobody sues the company if their kid builds a dick out of real, physical blocks.
- yellowapple 11y agoWhat if someone else's kid builds a dong out of Legos and shows it to his/her friends? We'd then be ina situation more similar to the one prompting Lego's anti-dong work.
- k__ 11y ago> What are they doing to stop kids from making Lego dongs in real life? If I understand it correctly, the problem is that someone else builds a penis and another persons kid sees it.
- gcb0 11y agomicrosoft probably just put a "online interation not rated, mature only" and everyone clicks "agree"
- brentm 11y agoCOPPA is the real deal. A friend ran a ticketing company that was fined in the 7 figures over an issue regarding email collection and a tween pop star's ticket sales.
- dylancollins 11y agoCOPPA is definitely the real deal (and the equivalent is currently being rolled out in the EU). However the reference to COPPA by @glassbottommeg actually isn't correct. COPPA is about data collection on kids without parental permission (e.g ad tracking etc.), not about content restrictions. Otherwise it would be called COPPPA (Children's Online Privacy, Protection and Penis Act).
- mjfisher 11y agoThat said, COPPA concerns will almost certainly come into consideration here. It's not just data storage, but ways that Personally Identifying Information (PII) might be shared through a product, and whether that sharing is approved by a responsible adult, etc. User generated content is almost always a candidate for PII leakage; for example in a block building game, you might reasonably expect a player to proudly build their full name in huge letters for all the world to see. If other players in game can see it, and a legal guardian hasn't approved that kind of behaviour (and been unambiguously informed that their child can do that) then you've got a COPPA violation. And COPPA violations are routinely prosecuted, so you need to pay attention when making a product explicitly targeted at under 13s. It makes it remarkably hard to design games for kids that are both creative and social. It feels very bureaucratic, but despite that I still very much believe it's worth having legal safeguards like COPPA; we're still in an era where society is changing drastically in response to the internet and I wouldn't want to see the more vulnerable members of it open to exploitation.
- mike_hearn 11y ago> It feels very bureaucratic, but despite that I still very much believe it's worth having legal safeguards like COPPA; we're still in an era where society is changing drastically in response to the internet Surely that's an argument for not having COPPA? Social standards are changing but laws, once enacted, almost never do - they tend to freeze an arbitrary set of moral judgements in place and prevent people exploring any alternatives. As you note, would Minecraft exist in Notch had lived in the USA and a friend had helpfully informed him about COPPA early on? Perhaps the risk of letting people build anything with no age verification would have seemed too risky, yet the cost and overhead of age verification + subsequent retarded user based growth would have seemed to make the project not worthwhile. I've yet to see any real evidence based studies that show COPPA solves any real problem. It appears to be a classic case of "something must be done, this is something, therefore it must be done".
- mintplant 11y ago> This is a roundabout way of saying "never build an online game for kids / I have no idea how Minecraft hasn't been sued over this yet" Exclusively player-operated servers. This let Minecraft's online scene take off while saving Mojang from most of the overhead.
- ef4 11y agoExactly. Even now that they offer official paid servers hosted by Mojang, you're still paying for your own server, and you control who's invited to it. Parent can rest easy knowing that all the penises on their server were definitely created by their own kid and his friends.
- kpil 11y ago:-) Yup, makes all the difference!
- vl 11y agoThis point in the article is really strange though. Isn't Roblox, for example, operating massive building online universe for kids and somehow solves this problem without godzillion of moderators? If Lego can't do it themselves - just, you know, acquire Roblox.
- mike_hearn 11y agoPut in a more general way: decentralised systems sometimes avoid hidden costs that more centralised systems can suffer from. Minecraft is decentralised and Lego Universe is not. (the reverse is of course also true)
- tzs 11y agoInteresting typo of "defamation" as "defamatio" in there. Accident, or subconscious influence from all the dong talk?
- chc 11y agoWhat does "defamatio" have to do with dongs?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- alan_cx 11y agoIt rhymes with......
- ColinWright 11y ago$ grep ^[a-z]..*atio$ /usr/share/dict/american-english Tom Lehrer had the line: "What with president Johnson practicing escalatio on the Vietnamese ... "
- lazugod 11y agoApparently it makes other people here think of the word "fellatio".
- nkozyra 11y agoWhile an interesting story, my takeaway from this (and I guess, exquisitetweets?) is that coercing long-form stories into Twitter is just really obnoxious.
- eru 11y agoIt's only long-form by twitter standards.
- Rolpa 11y ago>dong detection software Screw the next Twitter. Whoever successfully writes such a piece of software will make billions.
- prezjordan 11y agoI thought Chatroulette was working on this problem years ago? Maybe just a rumor.
- teraflop 11y agoThey were certainly funding research into it. http://wan.poly.edu/KDD2012/docs/p552.pdf http://wan.poly.edu/KDD2012/docs/p552.pdf > For instance, our observation on a typical weekend (summer 2011) from a representative online video chat website (Omegle) indicates that 35% of the videos broadcast by this website have nudity in them. ... In this paper, we present a new approach to misbehavior detection in online video chat systems that significantly improves upon the state of the art in terms of its increased scalability while also achieving higher accuracy. > This work is supported in part by the unrestricted gift funds from Chatroulette and the US National Science Foundation (NSF) through grant number CiC 1048298.
- draugadrotten 11y ago> Whoever successfully writes such a piece of software will make billions. And have fun at work!
- qq66 11y agoThis is the answer to the oft-asked question, "Why didn't Lego build Minecraft?" Because big companies necessarily focus on risks to what they already have, while small companies focus on untapped opportunities.
- refurb 11y agoThis is a great point. I used to work for a large biotech firm and we agonized over decisions that small companies wouldn't even bat an eye at. When you already have several billion in sales, you worry about jeopardizing them. When you have nothing, what is there to risk?
- qq66 11y agoPhrased more poetically by Kris Kristofferson: "Freedom's just another word for nothing left to lose." :)
- karmajunkie 11y agoHuh... i started to post that it was Janis Joplin, then decided to fact-check myself before I go all 386[1] on it. Humility FTW[2]! [1] https://xkcd.com/386/ https://xkcd.com/386/ [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Me_and_Bobby_McGee http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Me_and_Bobby_McGee
- archgoon 11y agoHere the concern was that Lego would jeopardize it's brand, but they also wanted to leverage their brand to increase appeal. Were the issues you were dealing with similar, or of a different nature? Can you give any examples? I know little of the biotech buisiness, and I'm sure it'd be interesting.
- satori99 11y ago"It really comes down to the brick, the core brick," is what Lego concluded. How though could the company's teams put this on a screen? Obviously, Gram says, they were inspired by Minecraft and knew that they could learn from it. "Minecraft is digital Lego," he says. "We only wish we had invented it." - David Gram. Lego Marketing Director http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2014-08/20/lego-fusion http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2014-08/20/lego-fusion
- monochromatic 11y agoCould there possibly be a worse format than Twitter for something this long?
- fpgaminer 11y agoCall me crazy, but are there any studies that show exposure to genitalia during childhood leads to psychological damage of any kind? I suspect there isn't, and that this social taboo is, to some degree, absurd. Seems like this social taboo leads to a lot of damage and cost, while likely being unwarranted. I mean, I suspect people in general don't want to see dongs in Lego Universe or really any non-sexual game, so efforts should be taken to prevent it. But it shouldn't need to go beyond normal moderation. The only reason Lego feels the need to go beyond that is because of the social taboo. In what I imagine a "normal" society to be, dongs in LU would just be laughed off as a joke, and the builder banned for breaking the rules. Nothing more.
- catshirt 11y agothis is really not my area of expertise but you pose a great question that I'm trying to justify for myself: perhaps Lego has legal responsibilities? you know, the same way I have legal responsibilities not to expose kids to genetalia. for instance, if user of age shows a pornographic picture to a minor in minecraft, what are the legal implications? edit: another comment suggests minecraft handles exactly this by not running their own servers. let's say for the sake of argument they didn't.
- facepalm 11y agoI am trying to think of an age where kids would not be exposed to genitalia. When they are little, we let them run around naked anyway. When they are older, they might take up some sports and be exposed in the changing room. What I mean is: I doubt there is a legal responsibility to prevent kids from seeing genitalia. Porn is something different.
- DanBC 11y agoHave a look at the English legislation for an idea of how this is handled by criminal law. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/section/12 http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/section/12 If you are over 18 and if you show an image of sexual activity to a child (someone under 16 that you don't believe is over 16; or someone under 13) then you've committed an offence. Running a server in which other people show children images of sexual activity doesn't count. It's unlikely that Minecraft dong-towers would count. I'm also a bit wary of removing parental responsibility. Depending on the age and maturity of the child you should probably be monitoring their first interactions and giving calm safety advice. Suggesting that the providing company takes all that responsibility is odd.
- jay_kyburz 11y agoCan I just say this is an abuse of Twitter. Seriously, if you want to use more that 140 characters, use something else.
- thefreeman 11y agoWhile we're at it. How about company's stop linking fucking screen shots of their press releases on twitter which are impossible to reflow or read properly on a mobile device.
- drivingmenuts 11y agoIt's a better use of Twitter than celebrity updates, so there's that.
- stormbrew 11y agoThere has never been a twitter post that wasn't an 'abuse of twitter' to someone.
- yzzxy 11y agoYeah, just like abuse of photocopiers. They're meant for letter size documents only! http://www.artnet.com/magazineus/news/artmarketwatch/warhol-photostat-3-30-12.asp http://www.artnet.com/magazineus/news/artmarketwatch/warhol-... Nobody is required to use a given medium in a way that others find "proper" just because they annoy some people. I personally enjoy the stream-of-consciousness feel of this style of self-referential twitter threads for certain types of storytelling or reporting.
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoI'm not sure how I feel about comparing a Twitter conversation to Warhol.
- hyperbovine 11y agoBecause Warhol was such a stickler for tradition.
- 11y ago
- ghshephard 11y agoGiven the number of kids walking around all the naked people at burning man, and not paying the slightest attention (well, after the first day), I doubt a replica of a penis in Lego would have any impact, negative or otherwise. Total waste of money policing that sort of stuff.
- DaveSapien 11y agoInteresting to see how MicroSoft handles this in MineCraft 2...
- frik 11y agoCertainly an exclusive game for XBoxTwo with HoloLens.
- frik 11y ago> MMO too expensive for Lego Lego World is the upcoming Lego Minecraft-clone: http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=109880 http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=109880
- mtsmithhn 11y agoAaaaand there's a dong in their own screenshot. Brilliant.
- Kiro 11y ago> I have no idea how Minecraft hasn't been sued over this yet Is Minecraft explicitly aimed at kids though? I mean, what exactly do you have to do to get sued if you have dongers in your game? A childish graphical profile?
- curiously 11y agoShintoism openly celebrates male genitalia. Manga has a lot of sexual content but it's not creating demons Americans are so afraid of.
- shiggerino 11y agoOh, but they have a thin black band covering the frenulum. That's clearly the part that's causing the psychological harm. But Americans needn't worry, because they already carve that part off of the infant's penises, along with the foreskin.
- curiously 11y agoI know what you mean but I often find those black band censorship in adult manga. If you've seen Dragonball Z comic books, there are scenes where Goku's penis is uncensored and emerges in his early days or Bulma showing her boobs (vagina is erased) or flipping the bird before a major fight, and other adult themes can be found (dirty magazines, sexual innuendos). No kid complained. I mean it made the comic book so much more worthwhile to read. Like little cherry topping on top of a great storyline and characters. This sort of 'teasing' is so prevalent in kids and teens comic books. I mean there were even more crazy ones like Ranma we watched as kids. When I read the same comic book in English, all those 'no no not in America' type of scenes were removed or have gone thorough de-perversion.
- Confusion 11y agoI have no idea how Minecraft hasn't been sued over this yet By not acting like it could possibly be a problem. Not being created by a US citizen/company probably helps.
- jordanbaucke 11y agoTyler Durden https://youtu.be/ru4glg0RJxA https://youtu.be/ru4glg0RJxA
- robogimp 11y agoI cant understand why I haven't built a massive dong tower in mine-craft yet?
- DanBC 11y agohttp://imgur.com/a/0LWnW http://imgur.com/a/0LWnW http://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/37l02h/the_two_wizard_towers_i_made_on_my_survival_server/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/37l02h/the_two_wi...
- dools 11y ago"in the night kitchen" by maurice sendak is the only children's book i've seen with a penis in it.
- tormeh 11y ago>People saying "well just allow dicks" - LEGO's brand is utterly trusted by parents. We had to uphold that trust. Which meant zero tolerance. This is the saddest thing. Lego permits violence in its products, but a penis built out of bricks is a problem.
- Lorento 11y agoA real life example of this type of trick happened with a large public sculpture in New Zealand recently. It looks innocent except from the right angle. http://www.stuff.co.nz/oddstuff/65855907/Cloud-or-phallus-Sculpture-an-eye-opener-for-Aucklanders http://www.stuff.co.nz/oddstuff/65855907/Cloud-or-phallus-Sc...
- hownottowrite 11y agoIn other news, Exquisite Tweets is pretty nifty. http://www.exquisitetweets.com http://www.exquisitetweets.com
- copsarebastards 11y agoI'm torn. On the one hand, parents who are worried about their kids seeing a Lego penis are crazy. A kid isn't going to recognize a Lego penis and if they ask about it, it's a learning opportunity. On the other hand, Legos were a huge part of my childhood. I recently went into a Lego store and bought a big Lego kit, the $160 kind my parents couldn't afford when I was young. The security guard at the entrance laughed because I had such a giant grin on my face walking out. I'd really hate to see Lego become inaccessible to the next generation because their parents are too puritanical.
- GhotiFish 11y agoWell, ok, but you would have to be powerfully insane to conclude "Someone made a penis out of these generic construction blocks online, clearly these generic construction blocks are unsavory."
- copsarebastards 11y agoNo argument there, but unfortunately that's a powerful insanity that infects enough people to be a financial concern for Lego.
- stegosaurus 11y agoHmm. So, I can vividly remember being young. 13, probably back to 10 or so. I did all this stuff. Looked for porn, played online games, chatted on IRC with 'old people'. Etc. There never was an issue. The weird fears people seem to have like video chat with pedophiles didn't happen because, well, it was just as odd to me then as it would be now. This was with little guidance from parents... in the early days of the Internet I think they just didn't know how to use it as well as I did. I have the vague sense that barring some sort of learning disability, the idea of 'protecting' kids from most stuff is silly. Sure, I look at a 13 year old now, and see their immaturity, but part of me feels as if that's mostly just that they don't have the pressures adults do to be respectable, to act in predictable ways, to not burn money and so on. I acted out on purpose then because society was broken for me; it still is, but as an adult we must conform to not starve and die. Am I just weird and special or do other people feel this way too? I have the same attitude about e.g. violent video games... it doesn't really matter how much I played them when I was younger. I am not violent because a) it's not ethical and b) it has negative EV.
- ohitsdom 11y agoAre you a parent? Not trying to dismiss your opinion, just want to make a counterpoint. Sure, pedophile interactions mostly never happen. But as a parent, I agonize over the awful (although rare) events that my kids could go through. So I'm going to setup age appropriate restrictions, but I also realize I can't protect my kids from everything so ultimately need to keep talking with my kids about issues and have good lines of communication.
- stegosaurus 11y agoI'm not, but I'm not talking about parenting here, really. I am asking whether it is unusual for me to remember my youth. If it is, then my story is just an anecdote. If not, then I would be interested in knowing whether others had reasonable thought processes. The basic idea that a 10+ year old needs to be protected from themselves or they'll just develop neuroses/be abducted/whatever seems weird to me based on my own experience of being that age. I was just as rational as I am now - with different data points to draw from, but not self damaging. I guess I would compare it to funerals. They are not for the benefit of the deceased. Whether or not individuals continue to do these things is kind of a different debate.
- creamofthecrud 11y agoInteresting there's not a lot of talk about Japan / Korea here. Just a lot of talk about America.
- iconreforged 11y agoSounds like a great Kaggle competition to me.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoDo you mean Kra__Gl_e?
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoOK, the game sounds good, where can I buy it? Lego.com don't appear to have heard of it?? Google results liknk to http://www.lego.com/en-gb/games?domainredir=universe.lego.com http://www.lego.com/en-gb/games?domainredir=universe.lego.co... but that page doesn't mention it ...
- teddyh 11y agoThis is not a new phenomenon: http://habitatchronicles.com/2007/03/the-untold-history-of-toontowns-speedchat-or-blockchattm-from-disney-finally-arrives/ http://habitatchronicles.com/2007/03/the-untold-history-of-t... “I want to stick my long-necked Giraffe up your fluffy white bunny.”
- pvaldes 11y agoSoft scandal is just another form of marketing, and a very common one. Most Disney new films have been acused to sex jokes hidden on it: http://www.geeknative.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/sex-tangled.jpg http://www.geeknative.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/sex-tan... http://usercontent1.hubimg.com/8320082_f260.jpg http://usercontent1.hubimg.com/8320082_f260.jpg I didn't surprise if it was a deliberate move to making people talk about your product. Animated films for children are plenty of sexual innuendos destined to parents and nobody raise a brow. Children love the idea to break rules and boast with friends about how they discover and understand the sex innuendos, even if they don't really understand the joke at all. It takes a lot of effort by the marketing department to show everybody those 'hidden codes' that nobody will noticed otherwise.
- msie 11y agoLego Universe will never be as successful as Minecraft. Look at Little Big Planet and how they crushed people building trademark-infringing levels. How can you be that restrictive and hope people will flock to your platform?