15 ms·
Elon Musk’s Space Dream Almost Killed Tesla
- toxican 12y agoThis is a really great article. As a casual observer of SpaceX, it seemed to me that they just came out of nowhere a few years ago. It's really great to see a story about their origins.
- sumedh 12y agoIf anyone is interested to hear Justin Musk's viewpoint http://www.quora.com/How-can-I-be-as-great-as-Bill-Gates-Steve-Jobs-Elon-Musk-and-Richard-Branson http://www.quora.com/How-can-I-be-as-great-as-Bill-Gates-Ste...
- js2 12y agoThanks for the link, but I thouught the third answer from James Altucher about Richard Branson was the real gold on that page.
- vidarh 12y agoAltucher writes well, but I find it hard to overlook the relatively large inaccuracies in the bits I do know about, and keep wondering what else is equally inaccurate. E.g. he seems to think "Virgin Air" (the actual airlines are Virgin Atlantic Airways and Virgin America) is Bransons main business, but Virgin Group consists of a huge number of companies, and Virgin Atlantic revenue only accounts for about 10% of the groups aggregate revenue (Virgin Atlantic revenue is about 20% of Virgin Group revenue, but Virgin Group only owns about half of Virgin Atlantic) EDIT: The story about how Branson supposedly got the idea also sounds apocryphal. In 1984 Branson was rich already - in fact Virgin Atlantic became profitable in large part because Virgin Records was doing well enough that Branson could use Virgin Records to finance lease of a secondhand plane for the company to start out with.. What was to become Virgin Atlantic was started by Randolph Fields and Alan Hellary before Branson got involved. It's not impossible Branson was thinking of setting up an airline before that, but he didn't start Virgin Atlantic until after he'd been approached by Fields.
- mirceal 12y agomaybe true, but it wouldn't not be such a great story if it was framed as you put it :)
- paublyrne 12y agoBranson tells that story in his autobiography, Losing My Virginity. It's probably not fanciful to think that it happened given the crazy things he has done in his life. The stories about how he got off his earlier enterprises - Student and Virgin Records - are possibly more inspirational because as you say he had already success to back up the air venture, but that success had really been built out of nothing.
- vidarh 12y agoIt's quite possible he did something like that, but I think the connection to Virgin Atlantic at most would be that it may have been what made him willing to fund it. It's a matter of court records that he did not start Virgin Atlantic alone - it took a court case before he paid Fields, who had already started and operated an airline, the dividend payments he was due. I agree you with you regarding his earlier ventures. There's the famous quote of his (not sure whether it's real or not) as an answer to a question of how to become a millionaire: Become a billionaire and start an airline. With respect to his earlier ventures, I particularly like the story of how he at one point needed additional finance for Virgin Records and contrary to what most would do dressed down more than usual for his visit with one of the most stiff-upper-lip banks in London - his reasoning apparently that if he'd shown up in a suit, they'd know he was in trouble, so he went out of his way to appear like couldn't care less if they gave him the loan.
- ska 12y agos/Justin/Justine/ ?
- soneca 12y agoAlso applies to other kinds of uber achievers outside of entrepreneurship. Like Mandela and Gandhi, both struggled with normal expectations a person has regarding the family. Hard to be a present parent/spouse when you are committing your life and mind to a country.
- loco5niner 12y agoJustine
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- parennoob 12y agoFrom the article: > Downey appreciated that Musk was not a foul-smelling, fidgety, coder whack job. Always good to know how the rest of us "coders" are looked upon by Bloomberg, and presumably the average person while they are busy singing Elon Musk's praises.
- dfgray 12y ago> by Bloomberg I got the impression that was Downey's expectation, not Bloomberg's. People don't smell or fidget in Hollywood..
- ende 12y agoNot after being doused in makeup and qualudes, at least.
- smacktoward 12y agoOr rather, when they do, they at least have the decency to call it "art."
- bpicolo 12y agoThis was an incredible article. Just awesome.
- jonknee 12y agoCan't wait for the book version next week.
- appden 12y ago> In late October 2001, Elon Musk went to Moscow to buy an intercontinental ballistic missile. Has there ever been a better introductory sentence?
- agumonkey 12y agoIt all reads like a wonderful technological suspense thriller.
- kposehn 12y agoNo.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoI don't have a link to further into that story, but after being screwed by the Russians on the price (they did a bait and switch, increasing the price four fold when he arrived), he asked on the plane ride home "How hard can it be to build a rocket?". EDIT: To add to this, the US government created sanctions against Russia, causing the Russian Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Rogozin to say "Use a trampoline to get to the ISS then" [1], which prompted Elon to unveil the Dragon Mk2 crew capsule: "Sounds like this might be a good time to unveil the new Dragon Mk 2 spaceship that @SpaceX has been working on w @NASA. No trampoline needed" [2]. I would not want to be on Elon's bad side. [1] http://space.io9.com/russia-to-nasa-try-jumping-to-iss-on-a-trampoline-1570387515 http://space.io9.com/russia-to-nasa-try-jumping-to-iss-on-a-... [2] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/461279062837968897 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/461279062837968897
- solarexplorer 12y agoI remember reading it here: http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a16681/elon-musk-interview-1212/ http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a16681/elon-musk-interv...
- toomuchtodo 12y agoAhh! That's it! Thank you!
- mrt0mat0 12y agothe man is pure inspiration. 10 years ago, i was asked who i admired, and couldn't think of a single answer. Maybe that's sad on my part, but when asked now, he's at the top of my list.
- baby 12y agoDefinitely one of the most inspiring man when it comes to success. For research I would say Stephen Hawking For education I would say Neil deGrasse Tyson ( I would put Neil in the inspiring "anti-racism" category as well https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQLtPWPqsjA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQLtPWPqsjA )
- ValG 12y agoDon't forget Bill Gates. While many may (rightly) fault his business ethics and tactics, he is doing more for the bottom 20% of humanity than most others.
- seiji 12y agoBut, he set back all of computing 10 to 20 years (1995-2010 "dark ages" approximately) just for the sake of greed, dominance, and profit. Was it worth it?
- cdelsolar 12y agoreally?
- DougMerritt 12y agoTrue. But he has successfully edited his reputation by using philanthropy, so you got a downvote. Which I reversed because you're right (taking "all of computing" to be mild hyperbole).
- Joeri 12y agoI used to think this myself, but reading up on computing history I've somewhat changed my mind. If Bill Gates hadn't been born and Microsoft hadn't existed, what might have happened instead? IBM would have still made the PC, only using another CP/M clone as OS, and would have owned that market because the other vendor wouldn't have written as clever a deal as Gates did. Two possible outcomes of that: either IBM would have replaced microsoft as center stone of the PC market and been no better and probably worse than microsoft (they were considered pretty evil in their day), or more likely IBM would have failed to create the PC platform (because that was really Microsoft's doing), and the personal computing market would have remained deeply fragmented on both hardware and software levels, tools for gamers and tinkerers but not business computing. In either case, OS/2 wouldn't have happened in the way that it did (especially since microsoft was a key developer behind that). Linux would have had a significantly tougher time happening, either because of IBM's control of the PC market (including the hardware), or in the fragmentation scenario because the lack of a hardware standard would have made it more difficult to build a community of OS enthusiasts. Apple would have probably gone bankrupt during Jobs' wilderness years. Without ms office propping it up as the only desktop alternative to DOS/windows it wouldn't have stood a chance given how incompetent apple's management was at the time. So, maybe microsoft slowed down the personal computing market, or maybe they sped it up, or maybe they didn't change the timeline at all. I reckon there's no way to tell unless you have a time machine. I wonder if Gates feels guilty though. His current efforts are laudable, but it always seems like he's compensating for something.
- cspags 12y agoHere's the video of the first Falcon 1 launch that reaches orbit. The series of cheers at each milestone, as the article mentions, is pretty awesome. https://youtu.be/8FQhtMrUQlE?t=18m34s https://youtu.be/8FQhtMrUQlE?t=18m34s
- ljk 12y agobloomberg video documentary on Musk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mh45igK4Esw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mh45igK4Esw
- alexqgb 12y agoIf we're doing a round-up of great Musk pieces, the interview Ross Andersen did for Aeon should not be missed. http://aeon.co/magazine/technology/the-elon-musk-interview-on-mars/ http://aeon.co/magazine/technology/the-elon-musk-interview-o...
- m52go 12y agoHas anyone else experienced slow scrolling and no visible scrollbar? I'm on Chrome on a Nexus 6. I fear it's a ploy to keep my eyeballs on the site for as long as possible. Not a fan of this at all.
- MBCook 12y agoSame thing on my iPhone. I gave up trying to read the article because of it. Even safaris built-in reader mode didn't work, it wouldn't look past the first section of the article. I'm guessing they're playing games with the DOM using JavaScript or something like that. Doesn't really matter, it completely broke to usability of reading the article. I sent them a comment about it, I hope they listen. I really dislike this new trend of websites implementing their own custom scrolling behavior. I've yet to see one that improved on the default behavior in iOS.
- seanwessmith 12y agoWhat was the moldy Russian book on rockets that Elon Musk was reading???
- methodover 12y agoWhat an absolutely riveting, brilliant article. The title doesn't give it justice -- this article is about a dream, and about a man's relentless pursuit of that dream. Incredible. I wonder what SpaceX's long term goals are. Much of the article suggests that it's Mars. But SpaceX probably wants to do something that's profitable, right? Missions to Mars won't be profitable for probably a very long time, if ever. I wonder about something like a mining operation on the Moon or other near-Earth objects? Right now, it's hard to imagine anything more profitable than deploying satellites.
- run4yourlives2 12y agoI thought it was the other way around: SpaceX wants to go to Mars and will find profitable things to do to achieve this. Similar to Tesla selling a nice car so it is in a position to build a battery factory, no?
- jbooth 12y agoYeah, and as always, it comes down to energy -- there's an established way to turn CO2 and H20 into Methane and Oxygen, given enough energy for input. And SpaceX has put some research into methane-fueled rockets already. So some people are theorizing that the play is to plunk an unmanned nuclear reactor and electrolysis equipment on the surface of mars, let it crank out a trickle of fuel for a couple years, and we've got the infrastructure to send a there-and-back mission to mars with on-site refueling. No big deal, right?
- derekp7 12y agoThe only thing that bugs me about this strategy -- whenever you look at a rocket launch, there is a lot of infrastructure and people running about doing stuff prior to the launch. So how is this going to happen on Mars? The only way the Moon return missions were possible was because of the low gravity and no atmosphere on the moon. I just can't see a rocket launch from Mars happening with on-site manufactured fuel and automated facilities.
- kzhahou 12y agoI applaud Elon, but I gotta say I'm uncomfortable with the extreme adulation. His company merged into Paypal -- he did not invent that payment solution. He was an investor in Tesla before taking it over -- the original idea and company were not his. The press paints him otherwise on both counts. That's undoubtedly a better story (and perhaps we're at a point where we need to believe in a hero-inventor), but I don't think inaccuracy actually serves us well.
- Roritharr 12y agoI see him more as an outrageously lucky person that does the very best with the insane amount of fortune that he got. That image alone is inspiring enough, for most of us are proportionally fortunate aswell and should aspire to do as much with our gifts.
- zeidrich 12y agoHe's a really smart guy, but there are lots of really smart guys out there. He's a really lucky guy, but there are lots of really lucky guys out there. There aren't many really smart, really lucky guys out there. One of the challenges is when we see really smart, really lucky guys, we tend to think of them as unbelievably smart and kind of lucky. One of the bigger challenges is when they start to see themselves that way.
- fraserharris 12y ago"The harder I work, the luckier I get" - Samuel Goldwyn
- marze 12y agoWhy is this somewhat pointless comment voted so highly, everyone jealous? You could certainly argue that Musk was quite fortunate at certain key points, but really, who else has accomplished anything remotely similar?
- agumonkey 12y agoOne thing for sure is that after going through all this, he must be pretty zen now. He has talent(s), funding, market, trust, ...
- BrandonMarc 12y agoGreat article. Even without mention Elon's drunk-tweeting about Catherine the Great. http://www.parabolicarc.com/2011/12/30/elon-musk-tweets-on-chinese-space-ambitions-catherine-the-greats-horse/ http://www.parabolicarc.com/2011/12/30/elon-musk-tweets-on-c...
- DigitalSea 12y agoWow, reading through this story and you can't help but notice some comparative traits to the late Steve Jobs. The incredibly high work ethic, not taking no for an answer and being highly optimistic in the face of bankruptcy. Those familiar with Steve Jobs and the story of Apple will know that Apple found themselves in this exact situation, a man with a vision burning through cash and not really making any ground - only for them to become a highly profitable company. After all is said and done, SpaceX is not only profitable, but Musk somehow remains its largest stakeholder, even though he went through a desperate period of trying to raise more capital. Seems taking on debt helped Musk retain SpaceX's majority stakeholder (a brilliant move if you know you're going to succeed). This is probably one of the most inspiring things I have read in a very long time. A very well-written article that doesn't skip on the details. Absolutely riveting, I was supposed to be working and I could not stop reading this. We need more opportunistic thinkers like Musk, everyone thought he was mental or was having a breakdown, but he proved his detractors wrong by not giving up (even when it looked like bankruptcy was the likely option).
- tbabb 12y agoI get two things out of this article: 1) Elon's tremendous luck. He took huge gambles, repeatedly, and they all turned up heads. They were all very worthy ambitions, but nine times out of ten, they would not have worked out. I don't condemn him for taking those risks at all (in fact I applaud it), but: There are probably plenty of entrepreneurs out there with comparable intelligence or ambition, but when they fall on their faces, we just shake our heads at them and say "well, that's what you get". But each of them simply wasn't lucky enough to have an Elon story. We should keep this in mind either while heaping adoration on Musk or while rationalizing someone else's failure. 2) Elon almost didn't succeed on more than one occasion because somebody else was actively trying to screw him over. And that (human shittiness) is one of the stochastic forces that made his success so unlikely. The world would have been a worse place and civilization would have been set back, all by the selfish behavior of some VC company. It is reprehensible that lollipop-yanking and sandcastle-stomping is not only actively impeding our society's progress, but despite this, it is actually tolerated or even revered.
- titanomachy 12y agoTrue. If NASA had awarded the contract to someone else and SpaceX had folded, we wouldn't be saying "look at that brilliant guy who got dealt a bad hand", we'd be saying "look at that asshole who earned a fortune and then blew it all on an idea that everyone warned him was nuts"... or more likely "who? never heard of him".
- eellpp 12y agoThere are lots of point of views around the thoughts: - He did not invent anything - He had privileged background, education and luck - He takes extreme risk but has background to fall upon etc etc ... So he is not great or a hero. The fact of matter is that he has a personality and attitude for getting things done. He dreams of something, faces extreme challenges but still pursues it and gets it done. What matters is this attitude of never giving up. The extreme odds against which the person fights, makes him stand apart. But people with similar attitude, fighting against extreme odds can be found in all walks of life. Whether we find that narrative interesting or not depends on "our" background/interest etc. Example could be someone with no means for basic education and learns on his own to become a great mathematician(or a architect who turns desert into greenfield) or someone who becomes a great artist/sportsman/writer(basically excellence in anything) against extreme odds. I bet people with this kind of attitude don't care whether you find them heroic or not. The may even not care to read things like this. Fighting on this (whether its heroic or not) is just silly. Some people will find the story of single mother, working multiple jobs to provide for her family more heroic. But then that's good for them and does not steal the fact that Elon musk is hero for lot of us.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- anon4this1 12y agoLuck? You can become a millionaire or even a billionaire by luck. Risking an entire 9 figure fortune in order to run both 1) a business that most at the time thought was impossible (mass produced electric cars) 2) a space company that most at the time thought was impossible to do without being a nation state and managing to against the odds make both of them succeed and become 11 figure companies is not luck. it is immeasurable slog, vision and competence. there are tens of thousands of people worth hundreds of millions and ~1500 billionaires on earth, can you name a single one taking anything like the risks and producing the results elon is producing?
- tempestn 12y agoWhile both side are impressive, I think the risk is really the big story. Of those people worth at least tens of millions, how many would be willing to risk their entire fortune on a venture that, in their honest assessment, would probably fail? (There's a quote somewhere, where Musk actually says he expected SpaceX to fail, but did it anyway because of how great it could be if it succeeded.) I bet the number is pretty damn small. A big part of how he got to this point is simply the fact that almost no one else would have been willing to try. Beyond that, he must have been extremely skillful and lucky to actually succeed.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tbabb 12y agoLuck, like dedication and talent, is necessary but not sufficient.
- lloeki 12y ago> Luck? > immeasurable slog, vision and competence. In many ways I find luck is to competence what magic is to technology: indistinguishable for the uninitiated.
- redmaverick 12y agoWhen I was going through the article, these two quotes came to my mind. “There are some people who just get what they want in the world. If you want to start a startup you have to be one of those people. You can’t be passive and wishy-washy,” – Paul Graham "A formidable person is one who seems like they'll get what they want, regardless of whatever obstacles are in the way."- pg
- bshanks 12y ago"they were in the process of finalizing the paperwork for the funding round when Musk noticed a problem. VantagePoint Capital Partners had signed all of the paperwork except for one crucial page...Musk believed that Salzman’s tactics were part of a mission to bankrupt Tesla. Musk feared that VantagePoint would oust him as CEO, recapitalize Tesla, and emerge as the major owner of the carmaker." From other sources it seems that VantagePoint may have owned less than 10% of the company. I am surprised that a minority shareholder could legally have the power to block an additional funding round; couldn't the other shareholders have brought it to a vote and overrule VantagePoint? Was the reason this wasn't done just the lack of time, or could VantagePoint really have had some procedural right to block this?