17 ms·
Is This Justice? Charging an Eighth Grader with a Felony for “Hacking”
- VikingCoder 12y ago"Ribbit." At the start of my accounting class, we had to pass around a bootable floppy disk that had the software on it. The teacher would talk to us about the day, while we passed the disk, student to student. "Ribbit." Then, one day, the computers all started to make frog noises. Turns out, someone put a TSR (Terminate and Stay Resident) program on the disk, and we had all just run it on our computers. "Ribbit ribbit!" The frequency of the noises kept increasing, both as more computers came online, and as the program increased the rate. "Ribbit ribbit ribbit!" Today, would the kid who did it be thrown in jail? I think we need a lot more "Kids will be kids" and a lot less "Tough on crime" with this stuff. "Ribbit ribbit ribbit ribbit!"
- ColinWright 12y agoLengthy discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9362307 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9362307 Other submissions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9356172 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9356172 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9362307 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9362307 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9368317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9368317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9376847 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9376847 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9393700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9393700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9395514 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9395514
- dantheman 12y agoNo this is not justice, this and every other zero tolerance policy removes discretion and reasonableness from justice. It's a way not to be held accountable for your actions - It's a variation of "just following orders"
- HarryHirsch 12y agoThis isn't following orders, it's much much worse. All the "zero tolerance" nonsense has been instituted because of a widespread perception of corruption - when there was discretion the popular kids used to get let off lightly, and the unpopular ones would have the book thrown at them. That doesn't look anything like justice or equitable, can't have that. Nowadays, with zero-tolerance, do you really think the book is thrown at everyone? You'd think anything the "good kids" do is completely swept under the rug. The fact that the fellow who put up the dick pics on the teacher's computer was suspended last year for a few days confirms the theory.
- spott 12y agoThis isn't a zero tolerance problem. The charging was under the discretion of the cops, which means discretion was applied and abused.
- tickthokk 12y agoI was a sophomore in 99. I was suspended for 3 days for "hacking" our keyboarding software. It was an old blue-screen'd DOS application. My friend and I figured out that F10 (or something) created a new folder. I made at least two, named "school grades" and "top porn stars" (Hey, I was a teenager). My friend did the same on his, but I think his was just "school grades" and "porn". They claimed that we were trying to alter our grades with those folders. We were A/B students, so that didn't really pan out. Getting in trouble for it wasn't really a deterrent, but then again, I wasn't arrested. It probably would have stopped me from ever fiddling with a machine if I had been.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoI was in high school some time after you. I guess the change had already taken place because when I figured out how to get into the school's internal file structure I decided the risk wasn't worth exploring. I already had to fight the school admin to take an AP class as an underclassman (it is shameful that this was something that had to be fought over).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- snarfy 12y agoWe have trespass laws, but somehow when you trespass on someone's computer you can get thrown in prison for decades. This attitude towards computer crime vs any other crime will not change unless we the tech community do something about. Now back to my upvoting...
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>unless we the tech community do something about // Do you think there's anything that can be done? You can petition your representative (I'm in the UK, so that's an MP) but the chance of computer crime ever being an issue that's relevant to them are practically non-existent. It's not an issue that will win/lose votes significantly. This seems to be a problem with representative democracy that only the major areas of focus can ever really get representation - do you vote for the party that's moving in the right direction on health and gets computer crime wrong?
- marcosdumay 12y agoThat's a problem caused by voting on people, instead of voting on issues.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoOK, but that's how representative democracy works isn't it. How do we overhaul that, main parties aren't going to move towards an issue based democratic process because that's ceding power to the demos.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> OK, but that's how representative democracy works isn't it. No, representative democracy is largely issue-based and less personality-based in many regimes, particularly parliamentary systems with electoral systems which produce roughly proportional results while supporting multiple ( significantly more than 2) viable parties. The US combination of a presidential (or, for states, gubernatorial, which amounts to the same thing) rather than parliamentary system and an electoral system which has poor proportionality and strongly favors duopoly (the latter more significantly than the former, though both are factors) creates a weak party system with weak issue focus on elections based on personalities and identity politics more than issues at both state and federal levels. Because of the federal nature of the US system and the distribution of much power over even federal elections to the individual states, and the fact that many states feature citizen initiative processes, this could be radically changed for state government in many states without direct support from existing elected politicians, and could also be changed to a limited extent for federal elections without elected politician involvement.
- manyxcxi 12y agoLeave it to Florida...
- NietTim 12y agoNational organisation/institution?
- lectrick 12y agoBeen to Florida many times. It has always failed to impress overall. Art deco in Miami Beach is cool though, as is NASA/Cape Canaveral. Fondness for EPCOT center. And Key West. OK Florida isn't that terrible. Some of the people, though...
- meric 12y ago"Even though some might say this is just a teenage prank, who knows what this teenager might have done..." Who knows what students in cooking class holding butcher knives might do? Who knows what police might do when entering people's houses. Shoot dogs that bark. Who knows what the dog might do? https://news.vice.com/article/san-diego-police-shoot-mans-service-dog-dead-after-responding-to-domestic-violence-call https://news.vice.com/article/san-diego-police-shoot-mans-se... Who knows what police might do when chasing down a homeless person. Shoot them forty-six times. Who knows what an homeless might do? http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/footage-shows-homeless-black-man-milton-hall-being-shot-at-46-times-by-police-in-the-us-9826453.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/footage-sho... Who knows what police might do when they see your children pranking each other in Walmart with a fake gun? Shoot them. http://www.msnbc.com/msnbc/cops-shoot-and-kill-man-holding-toy-gun-walmart http://www.msnbc.com/msnbc/cops-shoot-and-kill-man-holding-t...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 12y agoI don't like what this Florida Police Officer is doing. But focusing on a single poorly spoken sentence is absurd. I understand that police sheriffs are politicians, so this is generally considered "fair game" in American Politics. But this is an obviously bad, off-the-cuff remark that Chris Nocco shouldn't have said. But the amount of focus that has been given to this absurd statement is ridiculous. It is a demonstration of our short-attention span and love of "gotcha" catchphrases that are destroying American Politics. Lets do this rationally. Lets start by looking for a written official statement from this Officer before making fun of his views. --------------------------- Here's a better quote from this officer. "I think, unfortunately, when the story's being told in other (publications), they're not talking about the fact that he committed this crime previously," Nocco said Monday. "We enforce the law. And if we don't enforce the law, nobody else will." Knowing that this guy is a repeat offender changes the calculus significantly. I think everyone can get a free pass once. The 2nd pass, maybe the officer is just showing the kid that he really has the power to prosecute him (without necessarily going forward with the intent on actually doing so). The kid's lawyer likely contacted the eff / press to make the officer back off a bit. In the end, the kid is going to get off with a slap on the wrist and a bit of disdain for the officers of this country.
- balabaster 12y ago"Who knows what this teenager might have done" So you're going to charge teenagers with crimes based on "what they might have done" now? A bit minority report, don't ya think? This statement standing alone is a huge concern for civil liberties. Arresting someone and charging them for one crime based on your opinion of "what they might have done" seems remarkably heavy handed. But who knows what this kid is like, perhaps he was a little hellion making this teacher's life a nightmare [was the teacher gay? homophobic? I don't know the back story here] and this was just the straw that broke the camels back? Eventually we all snap when pushed and kids know how to push your buttons better than anyone. Perhaps he needed be kept in check and have his boundaries enforced to reset his notion of what is and isn't acceptable conduct. But equally... a felony for a [hopefully harmless] prank that is common practice in I.T. environments around the world, that's a bit weak. At least he's only a kid and it'll be sealed on his 18th birthday. However, it'll be attached to his school record and follow him around like a bad smell until he leaves academia. So I guess he'll learn his lesson... all be it a bitter consequence to what amounted to something largely harmless.
- pyre 12y ago> "Who knows what this teenager might have done" > So you're going to charge teenagers with crimes based on "what they might have done" now? A bit minority report, don't ya think? They are throwing the book at him for a crime that he has admitted to committed (unauthorized access of a computer system). This a crime regardless of "what he may have done." The fact that no one is stopping to say, "Let's rethink this guys," is an indictment the police / prosecutors involved in this case. This is a bit like charging a child with Breaking & Entering because he snuck into his friend's house through a window to play a prank on him, and the cops "aren't sure what he really did while in the house." Edit: Fixed formatting
- dragontamer 12y agoIMO, its more about the proliferation of Prosecutors who aren't taking advantage of prosecutorial discretion. I think any judge / jury will agree that giving a felony to a kid who has only changed a wallpaper is absurd. But that isn't the point, the point is that the prosecutor wants to appear "tough on crime" and jack up the numbers on the "number of cases prosecuted". The problem here isn't the law. The problem is the widespread culture of prosecutors. EDIT: I found a better quote from the officer. It looks like this kid was a repeat offender. That's a big no-no actually... hmm....
- vowelless 12y agoForgive my ignorance about American law but what does "charging" mean in the context of "justice" in America? Isn't charging just the act of acknowledging the complaint of one of the parties involved? Is justice even relevant here? Are the police allowed to act on charges and arrest individuals? Or is this just a complaint?
- tvanantwerp 12y agoBeing charged with a crime is a formal accusation from the government, and you will be arrested. You may then post bail as set by a judge, if they allow it, and remain free for the duration of your trial. If you can't post bail, you stay in jail through the trial. If found guilty, you go to prison.
- watson 12y agoBased on the way you wrote this I get the understanding that the US system differentiates between jail and prison? In that case what's the difference?
- mapt 12y agoThere are a lot of individual circumstances, but generally: Prison is where people who are convicted of felonies (crimes worthy of >1 year in custodial sentence) are sent. Jails are where people awaiting trial, or convicted of misdemeanors (crimes worthy of <1 year in custodial sentence) are sent.
- 286c8cb04bda 12y agoJails are run by counties or cities, and are for persons awaiting trial (i.e. not been convicted) or persons found guilty and serving short sentences. Prisons are run by a state or by the Federal government, and are for holding persons who have been convicted of a crime and sentanced to a longer term.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 12y ago
- upofadown 12y agoThis strikes me more as extra judicial punishment. The stupid statements from the Sheriff are because the people involved got caught at it. The charges will undoubtedly be thrown out once the punishment is complete.
- skywhopper 12y agoHad this been the method of dealing with such pranks when I was in school, I would have a very long rap sheet. Generally my teachers were fine with it because they knew I had done it and they knew I could fix it. They often asked me to troubleshoot computer problems for them anyway. The worst reaction I ever elicited was when walked into my history teacher's unlocked classroom during my study hall period and changed the DOS prompt on her floppy-boot-only PS/2 model 25 to read "Please command me, oh benevolent [teachername]!" rather than "A>". Generally she was pretty even keeled about what I considered equivalent pranks that didn't involve a computer, such as writing a silly message on the whiteboard behind a drawn-down map or something. So I was very surprised when she totally freaked out and all the teachers stopped letting students screw around on their PCs during slow class periods. Oooops, no more Scorched Earth during Calculus...
- stegosaurus 12y agoThe basic issue here is that computer crime laws are terminally broken. What would be the punishment had the teenager placed a magazine on his teacher's desk? This is an identical scenario, but with computers. The 'access' argument is bunk. He could have opened drawers on the desk, he could have photocopied everything in those drawers. But he did not. The same problems crop up all over. Copyright infringement carrying harsher punishment than actual theft of a physical object, for example.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- stegosaurus 12y agoThe basic issue here is that computer crime laws are terminally broken. What would be the punishment had the teenager placed a magazine on his teacher's desk? This is an identical scenario, but with computers. The 'access' argument is bunk. He could have opened drawers on the desk, he could have photocopied everything in those drawers. But he did not. The same problems crop up all over. Copyright infringement carrying harsher punishment than actual theft of a physical object, for example.
- moron4hire 12y agoThis makes me fear that we are going to make a generation of people too afraid to screw around on computers.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoThis is absolutely crazy. A common 'prank' in my high school was going around the computer labs changing all of the desktop background or renaming folders/changing their icons to mess with people. Immature: very. Criminal: obviously not. I guess it's the password part that constitutes the hacking here but if the password was widely known and therefore he didn't 'brute force' it via guessing (it's unclear from the article) is it still hacking? I guess it depends how he came into 'possession' of the password. If someone gives you a key to their house and you use it I wouldn't classify it as breaking in, but if they key it left outside the door and you use it to enter without permission that would be. Either way these are just technicalities and the fact that a school even got law enforcement involved in this is utterly ridiculous.
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>Criminal: obviously not. // vs. >but if they [left a key] outside the door and you use it to enter without permission that would be [breaking in]. // Why is trespass itself not harm in the first case but is harmful in the second? [Incidentally if you use a key you don't 'break in']. As the law stands in UK I gather the first is a tort (unless you add in damage or intimidation or something else) and the second is a crime (under the Computer Misuse Act 1990). They are similar. On discovering both there is a real cost involved, change password/lock and in the first case pay for the time needed to sanitise, revert any changes.
- cwisecarver 12y agoIsn't this akin to charging a teen with murder that entered a teachers house and swapped out framed family photographs with men kissing using a key known to be hidden under a planter? It's probably not even that ridiculous since the computer was, I assume, school property and not personal property.
- hurin 12y agoThe most amazing thing is that no one along the chain of escalation this must have passed (e.g. the teacher, the vice principal, the superintendent, the officer that arrived for the call, the sheriff, the prosecutor) - took a minute to stop and think: "wait is this really the right way to go about handling this?"
- ColinWright 12y agoRarely is that done - everyone in the chain thinks "It's probably not serious, but I'd better pass it up to the next level just in case." No one is willing to take that responsibility for making the decision, so it gets escalated. Some thing happened in the UK with the "Twitter Joke Trial": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Joke_Trial http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Joke_Trial
- amateurpolymath 12y agoGood to see Florida is determined to remain a national joke.
- noir_lord 12y agoYes because no other state in the US has ever had police or sheriffs do crazy shit. It's just Florida..and next time it'll just be Colorado and the time after that just Montana.
- skywhopper 12y agoAnother way to look at this is as a reveal on just how shoddy IT security is in our schools. I'm guessing that well-known password would have also gotten the kid halfway or more to changing grades in the Student Information System. This is an opportunity to improve policy and procedures to protect actually sensitive data. They ought to be thanking the kid.
- throwaway9324 12y agoI've always thought that the biggest unfairness in US computer law is that you're judged for what you could have done and not what you did. I think it's largely because those who made these laws where told how dangerous computers are and they couldn't imagine, as a factor of their age, why anyone would do something like this out of curiosity. So you ended up with every computer system being protected and a derogation of freedom at a scale unimaginable in the physical world. The double standard of course becomes very apparent when there's no equal punishment for the keeper of the computer system if a third-party has their data compromised as a result of mismanagement.
- lallysingh 12y agoThis is one of the reasons I'm considering private school for my kid: parents are customers and (hopefully) get treated better than this.
- jebblue 12y agoThey need to have a computer forensics investigator check the teacher's computer. If there really is no evidence of tampering beyond prank level then either that's all the student did or they knew how to cover their tracks; in either case, no evidence should translate to leniency in the charge IMHO.
- sarciszewski 12y agoWhen I was in the 7th grade, I actually hacked a bunch of websites and never got caught. It's been long enough now for the statute of limitations to shield me from prosecution on this point, but I won't go into specifics. I would like to caution people from implying that an eight grader is incapable of causing havoc on a computer system. The old WinXP at.exe privilege escalation vulnerability gave me SYSTEM access on every computer I visited at school. One of my friends in high school, I recently learned, hacked the domain controller and read the Principal's emails. Schools are known for their terrible security. Mildly intelligent kids can and will outsmart the system. In high school, one of my close friends went to a trade school where everything was locked down with a product called Deep Freeze which reset every computer after hours to a snapshot of the OS. The teacher was kind of laid back and said, "I don't care what you do, just don't break Deep Freeze." My friend broke Deep Freeze so he could change the desktop for one student he disliked to tubgirl every morning. Nothing ever happened to him. He was never even reported for disciplinary action. Then he put a piece of scotch tape on the bottom of another student's mouse, as a prank, and got expelled for vandalism. This case with the middle schooler reminds me of what happened to my friend: A wholly inappropriate response to basic juvenile mischief. It also reminds me of what happened to me: I was forced to pay over $9000 in restitution to a security company that had been neglecting to do its job for years, because I forced them to do their job for once. They called it "damages". This kid does not need to face a felony. Anyone with an ounce of human compassion can see that.
- coldpie 12y agoBreaking Deep Freeze was how I spent most of my time in computer classes in high school. I guess I should consider myself lucky that I'm now I'm a productive member of society instead of rotting in a prison.
- sarciszewski 12y agoSo too is my friend. I think the majority of people who would have hacked the planet in their youth become productive members of society in absence of law enforcement intervention. At least, based on the people I know. :)
- 12y ago
- waterflame 12y ago1- accessing someone's computer is like accessing someone's home - checked 2- unauthorized access of a computer system is a crime - checked 3- the kid should be taught a lesson - checked But... do u have to destroy his future for it? A 14 years old kid should drag a fellony with him till he graduates from university, because he decided to prank his teacher? That if he's allowed access to a university with such a record. I thought law and punishment's roles are to reform and teach. (slapping myself... wake up!)
- mapt 12y agoUntil he graduates from university? Universities often exclude felons (or at least, most felons) from admittance. The negotiating position of the applicant is one of appealing their standard policy of exclusion on special grounds, rather than competing with other entrants.
- Bahamut 12y agoI remember friends and I doing similar pranks while in high school ~15 years ago - it annoyed the computer administrators, but it was generally regarded as benign. We were considered some of the best behaved kids in the school district too (didn't get in trouble, went to class, did our schoolwork, etc.) - charging a kid a felony for this harmless act is ridiculous, there is no reason to punish the kid for something like this period.
- istvan__ 12y agoWelcome to the USA. "The test of the morality of a society is what it does for its children." ~Dietrich Bonhoeffer
- wes-k 12y agoCan't this student just text the prosecutors naked pictures of themselves and get them charged as sex offenders? Honestly I say if you're going to go down for some stupid law, might as well abuse the stupid laws in your favor.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Can't this student just text the prosecutors naked pictures of themselves and get them charged as sex offenders? No. Criminal charges aren't things that happen automatically based on external facts (even if the proposed action includes facts which in some cases might be parallel to those that have supported charges against the recipients), they are things that human beings -- specifically, prosecutors -- initiate. Doing the suggested act might result in criminal charges, but almost certainly those would be additional charges for the student, not charges against the prosecutors. > Honestly I say if you're going to go down for some stupid law, might as well abuse the stupid laws in your favor. The nature of criminal law is that there are a narrow category of people whose active participation is required for any use/abuse of it, stupid or not.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- graycat 12y agoSo, the boy got into the teacher's computer. Hmm .... Time to send the cops after all of the NSA, right? Or, since the NSA has shown all the world that no computers are private, the boy didn't get into anything private and did hundreds of millions of times less than the NSA has been doing for a long time.
- vjdhama 12y agoThey be like : "Let's get'em young. Don't want no trouble in future".
- Fando 12y agoLunatics! These people need help.
- graycat 12y agoThe school and the cops should just have refused to make what the boy did a police or legal matter.
- graycat 12y agoLet's have a US information technology venture partner with their "deep domain knowledge" take up my bet on finding the typo in my paper! Come on VCs! Good information technology entrepreneurs are eager for VCs who can actually understand the work and play a constructive role in the future of the company! So, "deep domain knowledge" VCs: Show us what you've got! Let's see your "deep" abilities in information technology!
- peterwwillis 12y agoWhen I was in school, the network administrator framed me for "slowing down the Mac network" using "AOL punters and Visual Basic proggies", because I had a personal website that linked to said Windows AOL tools. He got me kicked out and had "hacking" put as the reason on my permanent record. When I went to subsequent schools, they would hold me accountable for any computer problems or suspicious activity as I had been "guilty of hacking" at a prior school. My attempts to clean their systems of 0-day computer viruses and fix broken proxy settings on browsers got me banned from the school's libraries. Teenagers are not adults, and don't understand the monumentally irrational fears and corrupt politics that drive adults - especially in academia. They also have no way to defend themselves and are often victimized by adults, and often have no idea that adults can literally throw the book at them for no reason whatsoever (I certainly had no idea that kind of thing could/would happen). Hopefully somebody steps up and forces the government to do the humane thing here and not fuck a poor kid's life over to gain political points and 'send a message'.
- gambiting 12y agoQuestion - when I was 15, I did an arp poisoning attack on our schools network, redirecting all traffic through mine(borrowed) laptop. I've started my own SSL server and redirected all traffic to and from Ebay through it, decrypting it - I knew my IT teacher was on Ebay 99% of the time, so soon enough I got his password. Then I went to him and explained what I have done - he actually gave me a highest grade for the effort and was seriously impressed(also muttered to himself that he shouldn't have accepted that invalid SSL cert...). What would have happened to me if I did this in US? Guantanamo?
- alain94040 12y agoIt's sad to see HN, one of the most educated communities online, fall for an obviously link-bait article. If what you read makes you wonder how a multitude of people could possibly behave in a moronic way, instead of grabbing your pitch fork, ask yourself if there could be another side to the story (which there seems to be, if you read a few decent comments in that thread). As much as I love the EFF, they have changed their communication style a few months ago, to the point where I find them no better than spam. Sad. I hope they stop eventually and revert to being reliable and trustworthy again.
- thieving_magpie 12y agoWhere is this thread that has "decent comments" justifying the police response? Trying to remain objective here but you're not exactly convincing me that some internet comments change the story's narrative in any way.
- jasonsync 12y agoBoth sides are spinning the story, but it does seem like the EFF is fighting the good fight here: "The computer in question also had encrypted 2014 FCAT questions stored on it" Of course, this is not relevant as the files were not tampered with (also mentioned in the article), however it trumps up the perceived seriousness of the so-called "cybercrime". It's link-bait from the Sherrif's department. "Green had previously received a three-day suspension for accessing the system inappropriately." More link bait as other students got in trouble as well. The students frequently used the same administrative account to screen-share with their friends. More alarming is that the school didn't do anything about this the first time around. Eg. move the encrypted files to a different account / network, or lock things down. But again, this had nothing to do with encrypted files. "Green was released on Wednesday from Land O'Lakes Detention Center into the custody of his mother. He'll likely be granted pretrial intervention by a judge, sheriff's detective Anthony Bossone said." So they don't have a case (changing a desktop background is not gonna fly as a cybercrime with a jury, no matter how many times you do it), or have decided that they've wasted enough taxpayer dollars trying to scare future "hackers" straight. It's ridiculous we're even talking about this - that it got this far. The teens mother probably offers the most level heaved observation of the situation: "The teen's mother, Eileen Foster, said she understands her son did something wrong, but doesn't think he needed to be arrested. Also, she said, it shouldn't have been so easy for students to access the system."
- jeffmould 12y agoThis case reminds me of a similar case that took place two years ago in Florida in the county right next to where this incident took place. We have removed "common sense" from society and replaced it with zero tolerance laws. http://www.msnbc.com/all-in/florida-teen-faces-felony-charges-science http://www.msnbc.com/all-in/florida-teen-faces-felony-charge...
- mcguire 12y ago"Additionally, it has been reported that the school had terrible operational security where weak passwords, teachers entering passwords in front of students, and students regularly using teacher credentials, was prevalent." Irrelevant. The only important question here is whether the consequences of a felony match the crime committed. On the face of it, they do not, but there is not enough information presented to evaluate that. (Would the EFF's answer change if the student were part of a group committing long-term sexual harassment? (Maybe not. I dunno.))
- rayiner 12y agoObviously the prosecution of this kid is ridiculous. That said, I don't get all the victim-blaming around hacking. One of the basic bits of consensus in our justice system is that victims don't have an obligation to make it difficult for criminals to perpetuate their crimes. Whether the school's security here was weak or strong is irrelevant.
- jostmey 12y agoA teenager picks up a gun. Could they be arrested for assault because "who knows what this teenager might have done"?
- neonbat 12y agoEven though the kid probably won't get a felony it is absurd that the government can even use that bargaining chip in this scenario to gain leverage. This is the same kind of garbage they used against Swartz.
- UUMMUU 12y agoIt sounds more like they're doubling down trying to make this "hacker" seem more malicious than he was to draw attention away from the fact that their security measures are pretty atrocious.
- twobits 12y agoThe usa is realizing the sad pov that people are robots. It is becoming the first, past-human society. There are "entities". Powerful entities. And some other things, we don't care about. It is the first to realize in a social context, the halting problem. That imperfect rules imposed on an extremely huge social canvas, are not Turing complete. The limits of discreet rules. Which in a social canvas, has also to include in the description, "harsh", "absolute", "cold blooded", etc. In societies where you still have humans running the show, you don't kill -9 kids. Yes, "I" (for some values of "I"), am the most important thing in the world ever, "I" am the law, and "I" am a powerful entity, but show some "dignity", "humanity", "judgment", and "honesty" about what we have been in the past ourselves.
- nske 12y agoMost comments focus on whether that should be illegal, what the legal consequences should be, etc. These deserve a big discussion, all right, but I think it should be a different discussion. Because law should not be a replacement for better/friendlier/flexible channels of conduct, rather than a last resort when we do not think we have an other way to protect ourselves. I don't see how this could have been the case with the teacher. - He could discipline the student in many different ways, using his own authority - He could have treated the prank indifferently, thus showing that it failed its purpose to impress him and provoke a reaction - He could silently take practical measures to protect the privacy of the data on the laptop, which, in the very end, was all that mattered Getting Justice involved is a real ass move imo.