11 ms·
Costco to Pay Almost Zero to Accept Credit Cards
- needusername 12y agoI read the article but didn't understand what the deal actually was. Do they pay no interchange on Citigroup issued Visa cards branded as Costco? Do they pay no interchange on Citigroup issued Visa cards? Do they pay no interchange on Visa cards? Do they pay no scheme fee on Visa cards? Do they pay no fee to their acquirer?
- nickadam 12y agoNow AmEx is going to start hemorrhaging discounts and incentives as they lose valuation. Could this be the blockbuster of credit cards? That was a fun two years. So many "free" games and movies.
- comrade1 12y agoThere's been articles the past few months about Costco's relationship with Amex, with the conclusion being that the Costco Amex cash-back card will be cancelled in 2016.
- narcissus 12y agoPossibly interesting to someone: Costco in Canada no longer has that Amex relationship. Instead, they are associated with Capital One and their Mastercard. There's a page on the costco.ca site with a heading of "Credit Cards Accepted at the Warehouse" that says: The following cards are accepted in our Canadian warehouse locations and at our gas stations: MasterCard Debit cards Costco Cash Cards I didn't even think to try last time I was at Costco, but this does seem to imply we can use our normal Mastercard credit card there now?
- speg 12y agoThey will try and sell you theirs, but you can use any MasterCard.
- ajdlinux 12y agoThere are stores that accept only one type of card? Is this kind of thing common in the US?
- jrochkind1 12y agoIt is not common in the US, no. Most retailers accept VISA and MasterCard, the two largest credit card networks. It is more common _not_ to accept American Express -- because American Express typically charges _higher_ interchange fees than the other networks, traditionally their business model was to charge higher interchange fees and use them to fund higher 'reward' programs for the card holders. That Costco accepts only one network is unusual. That Costco formerly chose AmEx as their exclusive network is surprising, since AmEx ordinarily charges higher fees than the others, they must have had a special deal before, but they found they could get a better special deal from VISA, apparently. All of these things are interesting in being unusual, rather than typical, in the US market. And perhaps pointing the way to changes in the market driven by mega-retailers like Costco, at least changes in the market that mega-retainers operate in, with unclear effects on smaller retailers if it sets a precedent.
- _delirium 12y agoI agree it's fairly atypical, but it's not only Costco. Sam's Club, their most direct competitor, only took Discover for many years, which is an even more unusual choice of card (they now take MasterCard). There's also a significant AmEx-only niche in Manhattan restaurants. Not sure what's going on with that one, and it's not something I've seen with restaurants in other cities.
- cookiecaper 12y agoAmEx is seen as the card for the well-off. They usually have stricter qualification requirements and are well-known to never issue another card to someone that discharges their AmEx in a bankruptcy. They have perks and reward programs that are attractive to the people who can qualify. They're seen as more exclusive, so restaurants that are trying to pander specifically to richer people may see it as an opportunity to bolster the impression that only other rich people eat there ("The clientele is so upscale here they don't even have to accept VISA!").
- amelius 12y agoIf both customers and retailers want a different method of payment, but can't get it, there seems to be something broken. Also credit cards are supposed to be expensive because of their insurance function. But who needs insurance on their groceries?
- maxerickson 12y agoThis story is about a retailer getting a great deal. (at their volumes it is quite likely that this deal is cheaper than accepting cash)
- kasey_junk 12y agoWhere is the overwhelming evidence that customers want a different method of payment?
- amelius 12y agoThey will want it when they find out that they are paying a hidden fee that is being passed on by the retailer.
- kissickas 12y agoI would bet that at least 90% of Costco shoppers know about that "hidden" fee - the higher AmEx fee is the reason those cards aren't accepted at a lot of other, especially smaller, businesses. Beyond that, plenty of businesses are cash-only. It's not because they can't afford the machine.
- lambdaelite 12y agoThat fee covers insurance and other benefits on the card, and with the benefits, you can break even (e.g, I get 2.2% cash back, which offsets the increase the retailer adds to cover interchange). Are you suggesting people don't want the benefits? Also, re your OP, Costco sells far more than just groceries.
- amelius 12y ago
- adventured 12y agoCostco has extraordinarily thin margins, so this is a very big deal for them. Operating profit margin: 0.0285% Net income margin: 0.0182%
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pmorici 12y agoI wonder if the fact that you need a membership card to even get into a costco store has anything to do with this. I'm guessing it is a lot harder to commit credit card fraud which is what the justification for a lot of the fees the credit card processors charge is.
- narrowrail 12y agoThese cards can be used outside of Costco, where membership cards are not required. The reason they were able to negotiate such low fees is that Citi/Visa wanted access to this customer base. The Amex CEO was quoted saying something like 'the math of Costco's proposed deal didn't make sense.'
- pmorici 12y agoIt doesn't matter what people do outside costco if I know that I will have significanty lower instances of fraud on transactions that happen at costco then it makes sense to offer them extremely low processing fees if their clientele is a customer base you want to attract.
- Terretta 12y ago> The Amex CEO was quoted saying something like 'the math of Costco's proposed deal didn't make sense.' According to the 4th paragraph of the article: “The numbers didn’t add up,” AmEx Chief Executive Officer Kenneth I. Chenault told investors last month. “We couldn’t accept their financial terms nor their contract terms, some of which would have meant taking on more risk than we were comfortable with.”
- pkfrank 12y agoDo Costco shoppers have a higher percentage of "loan activity" on their cards? The type of activity that is more lucrative for credit card companies. I would think that a possibility, given that many small businesses stock their shelves with products bought directly from Costco.
- kasey_junk 12y agoThat is a large part of the American Express business model. They can offer larger incentives for use (to make up for the lower acceptance rate) because they get more in interest from the card as many small businesses use Amex as their operating line of credit.
- teej 12y agoI thought the gap was bridged by the fact that Amex charges 2x per transaction of the other CC companies.
- free2rhyme214 12y agoMy guess is someone in management wanted to leave AmEx a long time ago.