6 ms·
Travel in the USA Requires ID
- anonbanker 12y agoI often use my family bible when going across borders. it's always worked as proper identification, and is always accepted.
- recursive 12y agoBikes are at least as practical as horses. And buses are at least as practical as that.
- URSpider94 12y agoIn TFA, the author says that bus passengers are subjected to random ID checks. It sounds like it's a statistical thing, not a 100% screen, but nonetheless if you are dead-set on not carrying/showing ID, it's going to be an issue.
- santaclaus 12y agoIs the MTA in NYC still subject to random ID checks?
- rmxt 12y agoNot sure if this is the latest legal practice, but it seems that the NYCLU has fought against this and won: http://www.nyclu.org/news/nyclu-victory-preserves-right-walk-around-without-id-take-photos-nyc-subway http://www.nyclu.org/news/nyclu-victory-preserves-right-walk... That's to say nothing of the 'license plate reader-like' identification that is feasible through MetroCard tracking. Unfortunately, your stuff is still subject to "random" searches. https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/1dm5fu/what_are_my_rights_regarding_random_subway_bag/c9rmqap https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/1dm5fu/what_are_my_rig... http://www.aele.org/law/2006LRSEP/macwade-kelly.html http://www.aele.org/law/2006LRSEP/macwade-kelly.html
- untog 12y agoI've never had my ID checked. Bag, yes. ID, no.
- iak8god 12y agoIf it is (or was), I'm curious what happens if a person doesn't have an ID. As someone well above the legal drinking age who does not own a car, I often go about my day without carrying my Driver's License or other state-issued ID.
- Zikes 12y agoNot to mention the random checkpoints various states can set up in the name of immigration or DUIs.
- fapjacks 12y agoRecently there has been an interesting method of getting around this, which at least is interesting: http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/01/03/see-this-guy-get-through-a-dui-checkpoint-without-saying-a-word-thanks-to-what-he-hung-out-his-car-window/ http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/01/03/see-this-guy-get-...
- jameshart 12y ago"We have literally reached a point where the only way to travel long distances anonymously is to use a horse." Sure about that? Brief Googling on regulations around moving horses between states indicates that "under ... federal regulations, horses moving interstate must be identified and accompanied by an Interstate Certificate of Veterinary Inspection (ICVI)."
- beeworker 12y agoThere's always personal BigDog robots...
- lwhalen 12y agountil those have to be licensed, with appropriately-displayed plates.
- CWuestefeld 12y agoLet's not get started on having to buy dog licenses every year in most of the country.
- schoen 12y agoThere's a site about this issue from the Identity Project, which documents campaigns against ID requirements for travel. http://www.papersplease.org/ http://www.papersplease.org/
- gohrt 12y agohttp://papersplease.org/ http://papersplease.org/
- IgorPartola 12y agoI am fairly confused by this site. Best I can find is the page that says that I should deny showing my ID (in all cases? In some cases?), and ask to see the law that requires me to show my ID and "see what happens". For a site that says that one of their core missions is education, I don't exactly feel educated. Their other activities seem more productive, such as investigating what information the TSA and DHS keep on your travels, but which problem is it at the core here? The fact that the TSA asks to see my passport when I fly, or that the store that info along with my departure/arrival locations?
- nulltype 12y agohttp://papersplea.se/ http://papersplea.se/
- MBCook 12y ago> We used to make fun of the Soviet Union for its lack of freedom of travel ("papers please"). You only need ID not pre-authorization. You don't have to get Idaho to authorize your vacation and Nebraska to allow you transit.
- eternalban 12y agoA journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step ...
- andrewguenther 12y agoAnd then you slide down the slippery slope?
- eternalban 12y agoHere is how one such journey ended. [1] That handsome devil is the person quoted in GP. [1]: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6a/ForbiddenCity_MaoZedongPortrait_(pixinn.net).jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6a/Forbidden...
- dragonwriter 12y ago> You only need ID not pre-authorization. To the extent the federal government requires valid state-issued ID for travel but neither mandates states to issue ID nor prohibits states from rescinding IDs that they have issued, you in effect do need pre-authorization, even if the actual pre-authorization regime is fairly light touch, granted by default for long terms without specific travel plans, and rarely revoked.
- eli 12y agoI've heard of states revoking your ability to drive, but not your ability to have a State ID. What's an example of that? (That said, I agree that if IDs are going to be required for voting, travel, etc then they should be free to acquire.)
- 12y ago
- dmix 12y agoOther ways to travel without ID: by taxi paid for with cash also greyhound buses (paid for with cash). It seems cash is the only means of travelling without IDing yourself. The destruction of privacy via credit cards/debit cards hasn't been given enough credit.
- MichaelGG 12y agoThe article points out long-haul buses and links to this article: http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2011/06/tsa-swarms-8000-bus-stations-public-transit-systems-yearly http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2011/06/tsa-swarms-8000-bus-...
- kirsebaer 12y agoGreyhound and other inter-state buses require ID.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 12y ago> If it weren't in the Constitution even travel by horse would require a license and be a privilege. Travel by horse isn't in the Constitution.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- baddox 12y agoAnd it probably does require a license.
- geggam 12y agoThe constitution defines govt rights. It does not define citizen rights. Check the 10th amendment
- dragonwriter 12y agoThe Constitution defines both government powers (governments do not have rights) and individual (not just "citizen") rights. In principle, it defines the maximum boundary of the former and the minimum boundary of the latter.
- Datsundere 12y agomost underrated comment ever.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rhino369 12y agoComparing an ID with "travel papers" is silly. An ID is an identification device given to everyone who wants one. "Travel papers" are licenses to travel. IDs are a tiny restriction on your freedom. Travel papers are a major restriction on your freedom. The stupid airfare taxes are a much bigger restriction on our freedom, IMO.
- imglorp 12y agoThree words: No Fly List. There is no transparency to that process, no way to find out if you're on it, no appeal, no recourse. That's tantamount to license to travel if not worse.
- yasth 12y agoThere is an appeal process, and just recently you are now generally notified if you are on it. http://www.usnews.com/news/politics/articles/2015/04/14/us-to-tell-certain-travelers-if-on-no-fly-list http://www.usnews.com/news/politics/articles/2015/04/14/us-t... That doesn't mean it is perfect (far from it), but things have gotten (slowly) better.
- IgorPartola 12y agoSo you are saying that the current no fly list is as bad as having to apply for a license to travel every time you intend to? They are different things. When the government says "you must apply for a license before you do X" it means you are denied until permitted. The current implementation of the no fly list seems to be "permitted until denied". That isn't to say the process of getting on/off the list is good, just that it's not nearly as bad as being denied by default.
- rhino369 12y agoI don't really want to argue in support of the no-fly list because I think it is definitely unconstitutional (in current form), but it is still not a license to travel. It's a black list compared to a white list (travel papers). This makes a huge difference as the default is that you are allowed to travel. Instead of having to convince some bureaucrat that you should be allowed to travel, the government just blocks a relatively small number of people from traveling. Only 500 Americans are on the list. So 1.5 x10^-4 percent of Americans are limited by it. Also, no fly list only applies to one method of travel. You can still drive, train, or walk anywhere you want.
- hbbio 12y agoReading this should particularly echo to the French-crowd here, as our government is about to pass one of worst anti-privacy law in history, all in the sake of fighting "terrorism" of course. Side note: The author is also the author of Differential Synchronization, a key alternative to Operational Transform. If you happen to read this, congratulations for your work!
- pmontra 12y agoThanks for the reference to Differential Synchronization, very interesting! https://neil.fraser.name/writing/sync/ https://neil.fraser.name/writing/sync/
- mangeletti 12y agohttp://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:SQCXxa8INWoJ:https://neil.fraser.name/news/2014/12/25/ http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:SQCXxa8...
- Havoc 12y ago>the only way to travel long distances anonymously is to use a horse. Pretty sure that'll get your name in plenty of papers, so not so sure about the anonymous part...
- xigency 12y agoI've never had my ID checked to ride on a Greyhound bus.
- Hemospectrum 12y agoThat's because drivers are sloppy about enforcing it, even though it's been company policy for however many years.
- mherdeg 12y agoI think you can still travel long distances anonymously using a bicycle. Stephen King treats bikes as the canonical post-apocalyptic transit method — roads are too crowded with abandoned cars for automobile travel to be effective, and motorcycle travel is very dangerous (there is no ambulance if you have a high-speed accident). But you can do a hundred miles in a day on a bike. That's not bad. I've also never been asked for ID when using an Amtrak ticket, although my sample size is low (15 journeys) and I always use a credit card at point of purchase (either online or at a ticket counter).
- JoshTriplett 12y agoMotorcycles also need gas.
- varikin 12y agoAnd motorcycles need constant maintenance.
- jff 12y agoBut the maintenance is really pretty simple, the biggest problem with any gas-burning vehicle would be that all modern gas will be more or less useless after a year or so.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoElectrics would have similar problems, though at least they can be charged from either generators or the electrical grid.
- jff 12y agoA diesel motorcycle would probably be the best bet, since diesel engines can be made to run on a variety of other fuels. The US Marines have one, the M103M1 (http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/24/automobiles/24KAWASAKI.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/24/automobiles/24KAWASAKI.htm...) but they're not really available to the public.
- jasonpeacock 12y agoThere's a lot of FUD in the article. Most (all?) states have no requirement to carry or present ID to officers - you only have to give your name, and sometimes your address depending on the state. There's no Federal requirement to carry ID. To operate a motor vehicle you need a driver's licence...but your passengers don't. What about riding the bus? You can get on the local Metro, Bolt bus, or Greyhound w/o an ID. Hitchhiking doesn't require an ID. Bicycling doesn't require an ID. Nor does walking. You don't need a pilot's license to fly an experimental aircraft (but I'm sure there are other requirements for operating from an airport). Hangliding/parasailing doesn't require an ID. So...only through a commercial airline (private jets don't require IDs) requires proof of identify.
- mikeash 12y agoJust to nitpick, you absolutely need a pilot's license to fly an experimental aircraft. You don't need one to fly an ultralight, but that's quite a different thing. (An experimental aircraft is just one that's registered in a certain way. It could be anything from something you constructed in your garage to an ex-Soviet MiG that you've restored to flying condition. An ultralight is anything under a certain low weight.)
- eli 12y agoAs the blog states, you actually don't need an ID to fly, you just need to prove your identity (and be ready for a huge hassle).
- chucksmash 12y agoIt's been eight years, but in 2007 I was able to fly from Columbia, SC to Atlanta, GA without any personally identifying documents whatsoever - I showed up at the airport without a ticket, without a wallet, without anything. I was flying home for a funeral and as such was fairly distraught, so perhaps they cut me some slack on that account. I don't remember any specific hassles though.
- frandroid 12y ago
- papi_bichhu 12y agokk
- noonespecial 12y agoI think this is simply an extension of the fact that its really no longer possible to live an anonymous life in the USA. The government makes the case that they need to know who and where everyone is so that they can figure out who is "dangerous". This seems perfectly reasonable to an awful lot of people. The problem is that the people's idea of what "dangerous" means is wildly divergent from the government's.
- saint_fiasco 12y agoThe author of the article implies that he used to be proud of not having to do so because it differentiates his country from the Soviet Union. How will having to carry ID turn a country into an authoritarian dystopia? Is it just an American thing? I ask because I live in a country with an authoritarian past and we still have to carry ID everywhere and people just don't see anything wrong with that. Should I try to persuade them otherwise?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoRequiring papers to travel means convincing your government. Not requiring papers/ID means the government can't withold them. Personal freedom, which is paramount in American public discourse.
- saint_fiasco 12y agoIn my country everyone has a right to an ID card and not even the police can confiscate them. I agree that withholding an essential ID document is evil.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoBut, do you see that checking even your ID means the police can deny travel based on who you are? The 'travel papers' are then in the government computer. No, its essential you do not even present ID to travel, for personal freedom to be ensured.
- saint_fiasco 12y agoIf you have a warrant for your arrest, they will detain you. Or if you are under house arrest or something. They can't stop you on mere suspicion, though. I don't mean to say "if you did nothing wrong you have nothing to fear". It's more like "if you weren't literally convicted of a crime, don't worry".
- 12y ago
- pseudon 12y agoYou do not need ID to fly intrastate within the US: http://www.papersplease.org/wp/2015/04/09/why-did-the-tsa-prevent-these-people-from-flying/ http://www.papersplease.org/wp/2015/04/09/why-did-the-tsa-pr... However, you do need explicit pre-approval from the US DHS to fly, through the Pre-Crime surveillance and control regime of Secure Flight: http://papersplease.org/wp/2014/09/22/gao-audit-confirms-tsa-shift-to-pre-crime-profiling-of-all-air-travelers/ http://papersplease.org/wp/2014/09/22/gao-audit-confirms-tsa...
- dublinclontarf 12y ago> Pre-Crime Nice.
- joshavant 12y agoIn the article, there's a link to a TSA Blog article that assures readers you don't need an ID to pass through security. And, at the bottom of that article, there's a link to another TSA site, which lists acceptable IDs ('You can find a list of acceptable IDs here.', emphasis mine). Hilariously, the first line of that page is: 'Adult passengers 18 and over must show valid identification at the airport checkpoint in order to travel.' Mixed signals, TSA.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoThis makes me wonder: do you need ID to take a train within the Schengen area? I'd imagine not.
- thesimon 12y agoNo. You also don't need a ID for flying inside Schengen or going by bus.
- noedig 12y agoI wonder if we will need to have a license to operate a self-driving car. Certainly we will need a driver's license in the short-term, but after some time when people trust that self-driving cars work, will we decide that it is no longer necessary for the person using the car to know how to drive? If so, then that seems like it would open up a pretty anonymous way to travel. Of course, the vehicle will probably be licensed, but if you rent it from a company, then they company will know who is using the car, but the government will not. Will the government require rental companies to check ID's and provide them with the information? Maybe, but they already do that, and the government would need a warrant to get the information.
- binarymax 12y agoForget being checked for ID. If you travel with a phone you constantly broadcast where you are.