28 ms·
DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surveillance Powers
- higherpurpose 12y ago> For instance, the Court helpfully ruled that law enforcement's subjective reasons for pulling over a car don't matter so long as they can articulate some objective basis for the stop, like a traffic violation — even though the traffic violation is only a pretext. This has to be the Supreme Court's worst ruling in recent times since Citizens United. The cops can stop you based on an "objective" fake reason? What a ridiculous idea. "Oh, I thought your light was broken...well nevermind that, let's search you for drugs now!" In what world is that a "common sense" ruling? > The agent's declaration also disclosed that the DEA shut down the database in 2013 — after the Reuters story broke, in other words. They didn't "shut it down". They only "suspended" it in September 2013...and tried to put it back online by the end of the year. I imagine they'll keep trying. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/04/why-we-sued-dea-mass-surveillance-still-illegal https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/04/why-we-sued-dea-mass-s...
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoAt least in Australia the Supreme Court is willing to uphold a person's right to privacy. A case[1] in South Australia in February this year went to the Supreme Court (Court of Criminal Appeal) resulting in aquittal. A similar case (drug trafficking) in the South Australian District Court resulted in a nolle prosequi because the judge ruled the defect inspection of the vehicle illegal and struck the evidence. The ruling on that case hasn't been posted online yet. The police will, no doubt, continue to perform illegal searches where they believe they can get away with it. But you can win against them in court here in Australia. 1. http://www.courts.sa.gov.au/Judgments/Lists/Judgments/Attachments/1812/2015%20SASCFC%207.pdf http://www.courts.sa.gov.au/Judgments/Lists/Judgments/Attach...
- venomsnake 12y agoWe don't have security, we have security theater, we don't have democracy, we have democracy theater, we don't have rule of law, we have rule of law theater ...
- tomaskafka 12y agoIs that so because we vote according to who produces best theater?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 12y agoYou've got it backwards. Whren means that what matters is the objective circumstances, not what the officer is thinking. If Whren hadn't taken an illegal turn, the officer couldn't have offered some subjective reason for pulling him over.
- maxerickson 12y agoThat's an explanation of the legal theory, correct? The other side of the issue is the practical outcome. If typical defendants don't have the resources to examine whether the objective reasons given for stops are legitimate, then the distinction doesn't seem very comforting.
- rayiner 12y agoNo, that's an explanation of the practical outcome. It's much harder to force the typical defendant to argue about what the officer subjectively believed than to point to the objective facts.
- maxerickson 12y agoI read higherpurpose's concern as being about the use of secret surveillance information for targeting vehicles for searches. My understanding was that they saw that as, at least, a subversion of the way a just system ought to work. It looks like higherpurpose is over-reading "pretext" to be a false statement, but I think I agree with the sentiment that I don't really want police focusing their attention based on information that they later obscure (I would not be surprised if there are exceptions to this that I would agree with). So the question I was formulating was about the incentive this creates for the officers (to pull people of interest over for whatever the hell) and the differing ability of those people to challenge the stop. I guess on further thought that isn't a particularly interesting question (driving is easy enough to nitpick and find a legitimate pretext that will withstand scrutiny). Anyway, when I said 'legal theory', I meant that you were explaining the particulars of that decision more than you were addressing the concerns about targeting, and when I said 'practical outcome', I was thinking about how it would influence behavior of law enforcement more than how it would play out in court.
- dantheman 12y agoCitizens United was a great ruling, despite what you may have heard. People do not lose their rights just because they decide to act together. Remember what citizens united was about, it was about people releasing a film -- that's it; and the government saying that it was not ok to release X days before the election.
- nemo 12y ago"Remember what citizens united was about, it was about people releasing a film -- that's it" It was about a bit more than the pretext, the Justices' attempts at legal arguments to justify the ruling were absolutely horrifying, and the effects of the ruling have been disastrous given that it's effectively equated money with speech, permitting some citizens be more equal than others.
- dantheman 12y agoNo, it recognizes that people aren't equal. 1. Some are taller 2. Some are journalists 3. Some have lots of free time 4. Some are famous 5. Some own printing presses 6. Some are politicians 7. Some are beautiful 8. Some are rich 9. Some are retired ... Pretending that everyones voice is the same by removing money is wrong. It just increases the power of people with other advantages. Campaign finance laws are crazy.
- nemo 12y ago"Pretending that everyones voice is the same by removing money is wrong." I can't see how that's wrong at all. The wealthiest will always have more influence, but deliberately granting the wealthy more political influence is profoundly contrary to the principles of governance for a democratic society - it's naked plutocracy. The American way is political equality, regardless of other factors including wealth.
- LLWM 12y agoAs opposed to the entirety of legal history before 2010, when rich newspaper owners had just as much power to exercise free speech as scruffy-looking homeless people? If documentation doesn't match behavior, and you're not going to change the behavior, change the documentation.
- CamperBob2 12y agoIn what world is that a "common sense" ruling? A world where the John Robertses and Antonin Scalias don't have to worry about it happening to them.
- hackercurious 12y agoAs Milton Friedman once said, - “See, if you look at the drug war from a purely economic point of view, the role of the government is to protect the drug cartel." - this seems limitless in its effort and scope.
- zz1 12y ago> What do I mean by that? In an ordinary free market--let's take potatoes, beef, anything you want--there are thousands of importers and exporters. Anybody can go into the business. But it's very hard for a small person to go into the drug importing business because our interdiction efforts essentially make it enormously costly. So, the only people who can survive in that business are these large Medellin cartel kind of people who have enough money so they can have fleets of airplanes, so they can have sophisticated methods, and so on. In addition to which, by keeping goods out and by arresting, let's say, local marijuana growers, the government keeps the price of these products high. What more could a monopolist want? He's got a government who makes it very hard for all his competitors and who keeps the price of his products high. It's absolutely heaven. Source, in case someone is interested in reading more: http://www.druglibrary.org/schaffer/misc/friedm1.htm http://www.druglibrary.org/schaffer/misc/friedm1.htm
- benihana 12y ago>It's absolutely heaven. I'm pretty libertarian and everything Milty says makes sense. And I get what you're saying. But 'absolutely heaven' is a bit of a stretch, especially in that unregulated, illegal drug game where a dispute is solved with force. Search this page for deceased or captured to see what I mean http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Mexico%27s_37_most-wanted_drug_lords http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Mexico%27s_37_most-want...
- higherpurpose 12y agoObviously not heaven, but pretty close. The DEA helped the Sinaloa cartel own 80% of the drug market in Chicago by partnering with it to eliminate its competitors: http://www.businessinsider.com/the-us-government-and-the-sinaloa-cartel-2014-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/the-us-government-and-the-sin...
- stretchwithme 12y agoWouldn't you be shocked if they hadn't?
- tobltobs 12y agoYou would be shocked if the law enforcement would operate within the limits of the law?
- a3n 12y agoYes, after what we've seen in the last few years, I would be shocked if these kinds of things were not SOP, encouraged and rewarded. Sure, there are many opportunities for law enforcement to act ethically. Yup, I really was speeding, and I deserved that ticket. Those sorts of acts are probably the norm. But that doesn't mean that law enforcement is therefore ethical. The stain of one lie doesn't wash out. Lying to courts, suppressing stingrays, not spying "whittingly." As the post says, lying has been normalized.
- talmand 12y agoYears? More like centuries. History is rife with examples of abuse from people with power over those that have no power. It's something that has been fought, defended, tolerated, or the cause of revolutions since forever. This is just a new face to an old problem that has been a constant struggle for the human race.
- a3n 12y agoAbsolutely. Digital surveillance is a two-edged sword. As the abuse moves more toward digital, it becomes more possible for weak individual citizen-victimss to turn the spotlight/sword around. The government trump is they have guns and jails, and they police themselves.
- balabaster 12y agoGiven the number of cops I see driving with no seatbelts, not indicating when turning or changing lanes, speeding without their lights or siren activated, talking on their cellphones while driving, using their in vehicle computers at red lights. How is it any surprise at all to find them breaking virtually every other law under the sun? This infuriates me, at least if you're going to be enforcing the law, lead by good example.
- praptak 12y agoIn some countries it is illegal to provide false information to the court, especially so if you're a government agent. How is this "parallel but fake" evidence even legal?
- eloisius 12y agoProbably because the evidence is factually correct. What they are concealing is how they got it.
- talmand 12y agoWhich goes against any full disclosure laws that may exist in those jurisdictions.
- merpnderp 12y agoBecause being pulled over for an illegal lane change is acceptable to the courts. Knowing to follow someone down the highway until they make an illegal lane change, because you received intelligence from DEA/NSA electronic surveillance not approved by the courts, is not acceptable to the courts.
- LLWM 12y agoAnd that is only a problem because the enforcement capacity does not exist to pull over every person who makes an illegal lane change. The solution is, as always, more surveillance.
- unabridged 12y agoI don't think they are providing fake evidence as much as just not disclosing everything. "The DEA told me to watch for his car and pull him over for a traffic violation. I noticed the suspect change lanes without signal and I pulled him over." They just leave out the first sentence. The problem is when they don't disclose properly the worst case scenario (for the government) is just a mistrial or acquittal. In cases where the defense suspects parallel construction, they need to put the officers on the stand and ask them straight out "did you receive any information from a federal government agency about the defendant?". Make them either give it up or perjure themselves.
- barrkel 12y agoIf I'm not mistaken, this is just talking about parallel construction, right?
- fweespeech 12y agoYes. That and the fact they are using their international surveillance data to prosecute domestically...
- mooredinty 12y agoRemember this Pre-Snowden disinformation? 'US DEA upset it can't break Apple's iMessage encryption' http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/04/04/us-dea-upset-it-cant-break-apples-imessage-encryption http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/04/04/us-dea-upset-it-ca... I still can't believe so many people fell for that.
- andreyf 12y agoDid I miss something? Why do you think the DEA can break iMessage encryption?
- nitrogen 12y agoOne doesn't need to break any encryption if one has other means of accessing the plaintext. There's a difference between disinformation and misinformation. Even the truth, told selectively, can be disinformative.
- kylek 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_hangout https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_hangout
- andreyf 12y agoOne should be careful not to live in or spread in paranoia where everything is a plot to deceive. For anyone looking at the source material and judging reasonably, there was no deception. Perhaps some journalists got a little carried away, but I'd blame that on the pressures of their industry, not malice. The original DEA slide that was leaked says something very simple: traditional interception techniques do not work on end-to-end encrypted message services (e.g. iMessage). They can't just ask (or get a judge to ask) a law-enforcement-friendly cellular provider to tap the line and CC them on anything someone does. This is true for BBM and WebRTC and many other ways of communicating, as well.
- throwaway7767 12y agoThey can surely force by legal means Apple to give you the wrong key for a recipient, thereby defeating the end-to-end protection. This is the danger of the new wave of security tools that want to "solve" the hard problems (such as key verification) of secure messaging. The hard problems are still there, they're usually just bypassed by centralising trust, which creates a very tempting target for government legal pressure.
- cubano 12y agoYou expect the government to use secret surveillance and disinformation campaigns against a wartime enemy. You probably don't expect the government to use secret surveillance and disinformation campaigns in court against its own citizens. Why wouldn't you expect that? Just a cursory reading of the history of civilization shows that, along with warfare, those in power lying to and spying on others has always occurred. Please don't get me wrong, I am not agreeing with it, but at some point I think people need to just wake up and realize this is what they do. I really do not understand why people continue to act shocked or surprised about this.
- fit2rule 12y ago>I really do not understand why people continue to act shocked or surprised about this. Sheeple don't like to think about being fleeced, or turned into tomorrows lamb chop. The belief in the good of the world trumps the reality of dealing with evil.
- talmand 12y agoI would think the same history shows that people continue to be surprised as such revelations. No matter how many times it has happened before. Throughout history human beings have had a serious problem based on the sad idea that "it won't happen to me".
- maxerickson 12y agoThat's not entirely fair to modern forms of government, which to a large extent anticipate the problems. The Bill of Rights is a list of things that government power should not be used for. (Yes, I realize that it is easy to come up with abuses of the Bill of Rights, my point is that the Bill of Rights was not written based on the sad idea that you mention there, it was written for pretty much exactly the opposite reason)
- talmand 12y agoIt is entirely fair; it's fair to point out that without constant vigilance every form of government can slide into oppression of its people. Yes, the Bill of Rights was written to counter the abuses of the government it sought to replace. But over time these things tend to slip into oppression. It has nothing to do with those that attempt to make change, it's those that follow and squander the changes provided to them. Governments change, laws change.
- jstalin 12y agoOne thing law students learn in law school is that by far and away the most cases that chip away at constitutional protections are drug cases. The war on drugs has done more to eliminate constitutional privacy protections than any other government program. And now of course "the terrorists" seem to be the next justification for final, complete, mass surveillance.
- omgitstom 12y agoHow do you stop the mass surveillance machine once the gears are turning? This is a question I ask myself frequently, and I can't find the right path to get out of this vicious cycle.
- vijayr 12y agoI don't think it is possible. It is not just the gov, it is also private and public companies. Forget snooping for a second - let us just consider the public data. Once it is out there, who knows how many organizations have it? And even if we did, how are we going to force them to destroy it and not continue collecting more data? Most people give their data willingly either out of laziness or ignorance. If I have 15 different "store cards" in my wallet and let those stores happily track every single item I buy, willingly, who is to blame?
- kbenson 12y agoIf this is the natural progression of "information wants to be free", then it's probably worthwhile for us to figure out methods to live within this new reality. I'm not saying we shouldn't still fight it, but there should be a backup plan, in case it is futile.
- seanp2k2 12y agoThe backup plan is that we are not immortal, so however bad it gets, at least no one can force us to endure it forever.
- oafitupa 12y agoCheck out this obvious DEA astroturfer: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/30ydu0/cbs_federal_agents_accused_of_stealing_from/cpwy282 https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/30ydu0/cbs_federal...
- tveita 12y agoBesides being unrelated to the Popehat article, I don't see anything wrong in that post. What makes it an obvious DEA astroturfer?
- LLWM 12y agoBecause the DEA is so obviously wrong that anyone who takes their side must be an astroturfer. How could a real person agree with them? I mean, other than the real people who work at the DEA. Or work with them. And the policymakers they are following the orders of. And the people who voted for those policymakers.