8 ms·
Rise of the Machines: The Future Has Lots of Robots, Few Jobs for Humans
- mark_l_watson 12y agoI posted this article. I have been an AI practioner since about 1982 and whenever a non-tech friend asks about AI I usually talk about the challenges to society in dealing with a world where only a small number of people need to work to produce enough for everyone. I think that social challenges will be even greater than the technical challenges.
- mc32 12y agoThe robotists will be the new capitalists. The robotists will not only amass wealth but also disproportionate power. It'll be up to the people to decide how this unnerving issue is resolved. Will the power of robotics be devolved into the community and be community commons type property or will it remain in private hands thus ensuring a widening gulf between robotists and the rest. It was back in the seventies with Nixon in power when the specter of a widening wealth gap led to serious consideration of reverse income taxes (the old basic income), we'll have to revisit those ideas. I also wonder what a more leisure driven lifestyle will lead to. With more time to think, meditate and reflect, will people feel more depressed, will people impact the environment more when it's cheaper, easier a d you have the time to travel anywhere? Will such amenities be rationed so as to minimize impact on ecology? On the other hand, more time for " mobilization" and such time consuming social engineering schemes.
- neals 12y agoAnd what do you think of the social benefits? Is there anything positive to say about AI? If we fully subject ourselves to the machine, will we be happy?
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoI think it rather depends which machine, but I can certainly think of some useful things to do with highly sophisticated software that would make me, for one, a bunch happier. For instance, if we finally achieved the End of (Wage) Work, I could, ahahaha, finally get some work done. That is, me and everyone else in the research sector could finally focus on actually accomplishing things rather than scrambling for funding. And on a more personal note, I could probably spend a while going to practically every nerdy-hobby convention in sight. I could probably get through about three before desperately wanting something serious to do. Of course, then I could spend a lot of time on exercise, or lying around on the beach.
- taimurkhaliq 12y agoI totally agree with you. What do you think is the prospect of software engineers?
- LordKano 12y agoMaybe The Terminator and Robocop had a deeper effect on my young psyche than I recognize but what I find truly terrifying is the day when first world nations can completely automate military and law enforcement. A human being can have internal dialog, "Yes, I know that no one is supposed to be here but I'm not blowing up a building full of toddlers." or "Yes, I know that it's a crime but I'm not going to use deadly force to apprehend someone who was stealing apples to survive." and obviously, machines won't care.
- marcosdumay 12y agoMachine warfare is something so anti-intuitive that my head spins. How said that watever should be a crime, and why? (Those are much deeper questions than it looks like.) Also, machines can avoid deadly force much better than humans, and apply it better too. I think after enough casualities we'll settle on some superb law enforcement. More "human" than anything we can imagine today. But the path through there is complicated.
- Navarr 12y agoCGPGrey on this same topic: http://www.cgpgrey.com/blog/humans-need-not-apply http://www.cgpgrey.com/blog/humans-need-not-apply
- confluence 12y agoGood riddance to jobs.
- VLM 12y ago‘Well if I drop out I’m still going to get the same income as everyone else.’ We can observe an experiment we're running in poor areas without jobs, inner city, deep south, appalachia, and around half the students will eventually graduate even if there's no vocational reward for anyone, grads or not.
- swalsh 12y ago"Then I believe that a guaranteed income would actually result in more entrepreneurship." In a future where finding easy problems is hard, and everyone is trying to start a business... you'll going to see a lot of "sit-com" start ups.
- phreeza 12y agoWhat is a sit-com startup?
- ryanSrich 12y ago> Why do so many founders build things no one wants? Because they begin by trying to think of startup ideas. That m.o. is doubly dangerous: it doesn't merely yield few good ideas; it yields bad ideas that sound plausible enough to fool you into working on them. At YC we call these "made-up" or "sitcom" startup ideas. Imagine one of the characters on a TV show was starting a startup. The writers would have to invent something for it to do. But coming up with good startup ideas is hard. It's not something you can do for the asking. So (unless they got amazingly lucky) the writers would come up with an idea that sounded plausible, but was actually bad. [1] http://paulgraham.com/startupideas.html http://paulgraham.com/startupideas.html
- CardenB 12y agoIs this really a bad thing when capital is cheap?
- TheGRS 12y agoOnly if you just want people to tackle easy, meaningless problems.
- jdreaver 12y agoIndeed, it would be unfortunate to lose your job to a machine, but oftentimes people fail to see the upside: if a robot can do a job more cheaply than a human, then whatever that robot produces is then cheaper for everyone else to buy! If most of the economy were efficiently automated, then you would barely need an income to survive or thrive. Machines do not decrease your productivity. Just because a machine can make a shoe faster than you doesn't mean you can't make a shoe. If a machine can make houses in a day, that doesn't make your house will spontaneously combust because you made it inefficiently. Labor-saving machines only add to the productivity of society. People have been losing jobs to tech since the dawn of civilization. It does suck if your job is automated out, but the overall good to society can't be denied.
- s73v3r 12y ago"if a robot can do a job more cheaply than a human, then whatever that robot produces is then cheaper for everyone else to buy!" Why do I give a shit that some rich bastard can now buy a cheaper Kia when I'm on the street cause I can't pay rent? "If most of the economy were efficiently automated, then you would barely need an income to survive or thrive." Really? If most of the economy were automated, what are the rest of us going to do for income? "It does suck if your job is automated out, but the overall good to society can't be denied." Neither can the overall negatives to society. The utopian dream of everyone having time for their own pursuits is awesome, and I hope it happens. But, there is also the long period in between where people are still required to have jobs and income to survive, yet there are extremely few jobs available.
- jellicle 12y ago> If most of the economy were efficiently automated, then you would barely need an income to survive or thrive. $prices = ($prices * 0.9) $income = ($income * 0.0) If most of the benefits from robots flow to the 0.1% who own them, and most of the costs of robots fall on the rest of the population who work for a living, they can be accounted for as a net good to society while being disastrous in practice.
- jdreaver 12y ago
- fiatpandas 12y agoStill waiting on machines to free humanity from the shackles of manual labor.
- ThomPete 12y agoHis first book "The lights in the tunnel" is a great book too.
- wehadfun 12y agoSo from an energy prospective are robots better? Would generating all that power to run all those robots cause problems in natural resources?
- woodchuck64 12y agoIt isn't the physical ability of the robot that matters much to jobs, it's the intelligence. How about a future where each person is given a computing wattage allowance for an artificially intelligent workforce at AmaGoogleBaiduSoft. That way, each person can advance in intelligence and productivity in tandem with technology.
- M8 12y agoSounds like coal-powered space ships and flying cars to be honest. If AI is possible then you will soon enough have computational allowance for rather running yourself in the cloud, unless you really love original imperfect organic bodies and hate mind back-ups.
- woodchuck64 12y agoIt is unlikely AI will itself accelerate Moore's law for decades, so that means we have decades to plan, use, and benefit from steadily improving AI at Moore's law rates. AI is not a threshold, it's a continuum.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- M8 12y agoSorry, I thought you meant strong human-level AI.
- ryanSrich 12y agoSo the article points out that within a half decade we'll see a lot of repetitive jobs being replaced by machines. I get that and certainly agree. Later in the article it suggests that we'll see even more jobs being replaced and eventually all human employment will be obsolete (it doesn't say this directly). Then the author of the book points out that this may be a catalyst for people becoming more entrepreneurial. To counter the second point; if there exists a point where AI can be applied to essentially any job (doctors, therapists, CEOs, etc.) then why would the job of an entrepreneur exist? What makes that job more special than any of the other highly intellectual jobs out there that are supposedly on the chopping block? I mean if we're really talking about true AI, one that can medically treat patients, mobilize and palpate, then that same "being" would easily have the mental capacity to start a business. Point being, it seems contradictory to say all human jobs will be replaced by machines except for this one thing.
- brianpetro_ 12y agoSure, robots can run a franchise since there are limited inputs/outputs. But, can a robot innovate?
- njharman 12y agoIs machine learning innovation? Are most companies that innovative, really? Most are replicating proven patterns, retail, restaurants, construction, etc. Startups seem to be mix and matching existing concepts and 1 in a 100 end up being something that sticks.
- jdreaver 12y agoPeople argue that the owners of the robots will amass wealth and then sit on it like Scrooge McDuck, leaving everyone else to starve and live in poverty. Not that I agree with them :)
- kokey 12y agoThat brings some interesting questions. Like, will they use this power to use humans to do the jobs of robots, for fun? What will they use this wealth for? It can't be to pay for things because you wouldn't have to pay people to produce and deliver those things for you.
- themgt 12y ago"Sponsor Content" - so, HN is linking to a paid advertisement
- cwyers 12y agoIt's promotional material for a book, yeah. If the content is any good, I don't know why that makes it unsuitable for discussion on HN.
- anthonyarroyo 12y agoIf, as this guy contends, the future economy won't adapt to automation as it has in the past, it will lead to massive unemployment and social instability. When threatened with massive social instability, smart countries will regulate automation. Countries that fail to regulate will face rising social instability and eventually eat themselves alive, being taken over by countries that are more stable. Political elites will regulate automation purely out of the interest of keeping their jobs. All of these technofatalist arguments (the technology is coming, so why fight it?) fail to take into account that Angloamerican laissez-faire politics are not a global inevitability.
- marcosdumay 12y agoAny country that regulates the robots is doomed. But regulating energy, land usage and other natural resources can be a way to make it work.
- tomjen3 12y agoCountries that regulate automation will be eaten alive by countries that don't. Unless you embrace industrialization/automation then the other people will have the maxim gun and you will not. Ask the Zulus what happens then.
- nicholasdrake 12y agohttp://lao8n.com/2015/04/05/if-technology-growth-does-lead-to-mass-unemployment-what-then/ http://lao8n.com/2015/04/05/if-technology-growth-does-lead-t... the flaw in your reasoning i think is that there will be zero-sum fight to have the limited number of companies in your country so that you can tax those companies and support the massive number of unemployed people. there will be a race to the bottom in the automation regulation that you describe because companies will just move if they are not allowed to lower costs through more automation... thus i think the result is that some countries will have very high employment rates because all the high-skilled, unautomatable jobs are located there (e.g. the US) and some countries (e.g. spain?) will have really high unemployment... this will lead to extreme tensions internationally followed by god knows what..
- 12y ago
- paulhauggis 12y ago"When you have a safety net in place, people will take more risks. That probably is true of the economic arena as well." I think the difference is that the same company that is going to take the risk will also be restricted when it comes to income they are earning (more taxes), and any other rules that are in place that will directly effect growth. Look at countries like Sweden and Denmark: large safety nets and you would think everyone would start a company, but it's just not the case. The requirements for employees make it so you need lots of money to even manage HR (hiring and firing is a court case). Many safety nets also create a culture where risk is seen as a bad thing and less people will want start companies. This can also be seen in places like Sweden and Denmark. "People say that having a guaranteed income will turn everyone into a slacker and destroy the economy" Will it turn everyone into a slacker? no. However, I know so many people that went on unemployment and had no motivation to even be bothered to look for a job. If this happened in my small, circle of friends, I can just imagine the effects of essentially free money at a much larger scale. All of these predictions are looking at what's happening now. We need to predict what will happen when 2 or 3 generations of people have access to this basic income. When more and more people are getting basic income and less people are working (which I predict will happen over time as more people figure out the system), where does the money come from to support everyone?
- marcosdumay 12y ago> The requirements for employees make it so you need lots of money to even manage HR (hiring and firing is a court case). Yet, the best feature about universal income is that it's simple and has low overhead. If you are successfull you'll get taxed -> taxes go to the people, equaly distributed. No extra administration staff, no means investigation, no extra court cases. > However, I know so many people that went on unemployment and had no motivation to even be bothered to look for a job. How much of this was because those people had a living income, and how much is because they'd lose money if they got a job?
- prostoalex 12y ago> Look at countries like Sweden and Denmark: large safety nets and you would think everyone would start a company, but it's just not the case. Precisely, Alaska for years had payouts from its oil fund going to the residents. Combined with cheap housing the residents are quite content with the status quo http://www.gallup.com/poll/181547/alaska-leads-states-first-time.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/181547/alaska-leads-states-first-... Still waiting for that wave of innovation to come out of Alaska and hit the world.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoThese kinds of things ignore the premiumization of things. Sure you can roboticize and 3D print cheap crap, but someone will make a slightly higher quality version with slightly better materials and charge more for it. People will flock to the better version for their own reasons. Capitalism fits in very nicely with our own vanities and desires. Robots won't change that. Does everyone reading this drive the cheapest Kia or Hyundai? If not, why not? With premium goods you will need marketing staff, support staff, etc. Jobs will continue to be created. We'll just lose manufcaturing entirely, which seems to be a net good considering how horrible those jobs are. New jobs will take up the slack, or if it not, we'll see a trivial uncheck in welfare and less work hours for workers. Not exactly end of the world scenarios here. These robot scare pieces really are out there. We've had industrialization for 100+ years. Its no different than what we're doing now. If anything, advanced and cheap robotics and replication will help with a lot of inefficiencies in the market. Why does it take a $90/hr guy to do some basic plumbing in my house or to replace a door? This kind of blue collar stuff should be automated/roboticized. Or why is Chicago on the hook for billions in pensions for meter maids, janitors, bus drivers and other low effort/easily roboticized jobs? We're paying millions per person in pensions for a mere 20-25 years of labor. Robots will solve the inefficiencies that need to be solved. They'll make things better via lower tax loads and better outcomes. We need more robot optimistism here. I'm ready for the low work, low tax, low hassle leisure society.
- niche 12y agoAre AI scares cyclical as well? Much like market adjustments
- PopsiclePete 12y agoWhy is a job a good thing??? I don't need a job. I need income. The two don't have to be necessarily connected. If robots doing all manual/farm labor replace humans, that's a good thing - it frees us up to pursue more interesting pursuits. Now, all of this wealth that will be generated, if it's concentrated in the hands of the top 0.5%, then yes, we're screwed. But some form of basic guaranteed income would go a long way to make sure we're not turned into serfs. I love programming. But if I could focus on the projects I wanted to write instead of what I'm forced to write, why is that horrible?
- Spooky23 12y agoPeople need a purpose. Work gives people that purpose.
- polymatter 12y agoWork does not imply job. Jobs are where people are financially rewarded for work. Work that is not financially rewarded still exists. See topic: Hobbies, Charities, Volunteering.
- s73v3r 12y ago"If robots doing all manual/farm labor replace humans, that's a good thing - it frees us up to pursue more interesting pursuits." Like participating in dystopian future death games for the amusement of the upper class because we don't have any food?
- PopsiclePete 12y agoWe could call them.....the Hunger Games!
- mc32 12y agoThe problem I see with this is that's your attitude towards free time now because you are used to the notion of work. Whether it be purely for an exchange of money or for personal enrichment (non monetary) In a society where work is not the norm, people may not seek out to be productive, but rather passive consumers of things and services. A nice docile population used to some modicum of comfort but with little desire.
- kokey 12y agoI think this will be great in industries where we like to interact with people. If robots cook the food and mix the cocktails, it will free up people to provide a better experience at the bar and table, with better food for cheaper, or less pressure to get people to clear the tables.
- pdiddy 12y agoI imagine The Second Machine Age is old news on HN, but I highly recommend it for a discussion of these topics. It's a very readable book and discusses these social shifts in an intelligent manner without descending into pessimism or making exaggerated claims.
- borgia 12y agoAutomation en masse of low skilled labour is going to present an absolutely huge challenge to society. I cannot see how low-skilled jobs such as: - driving jobs (taxis, haulage, etc) - store work (stacking shelves, stock ordering, cashing out purchases, solving basic customer queries such as where in the store is product X, etc.) - retail banking - fast food or convenience store services - etc. will not be replaced by automation in the next decade or so. We're already seeing it as self-driving vehicles are rapidly developing, stock picking bots at Amazon and similar are coming along rapidly, self-service checkouts at stores are becoming very much mainstream and highly used, online banking and ATM machines offering a wider range of services, etc. Those jobs listed above represent an enormous amount of employment throughout the western world as it is. If we accept that not everyone can do every type of job, that IQ does separate people in their abilities to do or even learn to do a job, etc. then that means we will see mass displacement of the workforce when the only jobs available to many are one's that are out of their educational or intellectual reach. This is just the beginning, by the way, as AI and automation gets better then the skills and jobs it can replace will grow and increasingly sap up jobs requiring higher levels of intellect or education. So while low-skilled job replacement is the primary short-term challenge, overall job replacement is a medium-longer term challenge. This challenge has been on my mind quite a lot recently, as have the challenges posed by the development of AGI/AI which are pretty well linked, although AGI has its own challenges in terms of what it might mean for humanity as a whole. If we accept the above then we accept that not just large scale unemployment, but large scale human redundancy, is inevitable then we have very large questions to ask, and thus very large answers or solutions to provide, regarding how we structure society. If the low skilled jobs are the first to go, which are tended to by people of lower IQ / intellect or who aren't strong academically, then not only will we have large scale unemployment/human redundancy but I believe it would be coupled with comparatively low entrepreneurship. That's not to say that people of lower intellect can't be entrepreneurs, but it is becoming increasingly difficult to find easy problems to solve and will only become more so. It would also be significantly more difficult for such people to, for example, open a franchise of a chain due to the financial and experience backgrounds levied by most franchise owners. The conclusion I've come to is that socialism is inevitable in the medium-long term whereby the machines do the work and the ownership/profits of the methods of production are shared by everyone. I'm not a proponent of socialism, I will say, but I've come to the conclusion that it's inevitable given the technologies and changes that are coming our way. On solutions: - Without changing the ownership of that which produces, a basic living income for all would come at a very high cost to those who still have jobs in the form of higher taxes. - If the current situation remains, whereby few people control the vast bulk of the production in the economy, and large scale unemployment comes around, even with a basic living income we will see unparalleled inequality. Even if ALL jobs were replaced by machines, if the ownership of these machines and the decisions regarding their profit remains in the hands of few, there will not only be unparalleled inequality but a system of inequality more sustainable than ever before. - Regardless of how a solution is implemented, it will be gradual as automation takes time to take up increasingly more intelligent work, which will place an enormous burden on those intelligent enough to do the work. It will inherently become even more less unequal, as those who "cannot" do the work will not work but would be supported by those who can, those who can will do so and pay large taxes while doing so, and those who own that which produces can further relax. - We live in a society that is increasingly "no man left behind" in terms of resources. The obvious solution to an issue whereby society shifts toward more intelligent work and automation of less skilled work would be to produce more intelligent babies. -- Eugenics will never be looked upon kindly, so the only other solution is to make embryonic selection for intelligence en vogue. -- Despite grand increases in intelligence and knowledge, many of the population are still highly religious. I don't believe this will fare well for embryonic selection in the short term. -- Therefore in the short term we would see more of what we currently see - higher reproduction rates in the unemployed or those doing low skilled work, increasingly lower rates amongst those in higher skilled work as having a child becomes even more expensive/stressful due to higher taxes. -- This makes all the above challenges even more difficult than they already are. So the solution lies in something like: - Changing the ownership of production - Putting in place support systems to support the lives of those whose jobs are replaced and who have not the skills or intelligence to take higher skilled work - Putting in place support systems to enable those in higher skilled work/higher education/etc. to have as many children as they want. Free childcare for working parents is one of the most important parts of that. - Increasing emphasis on education for all. Make it available to all for the same cost and make the various colleges entrance based on merit alone. - Continue developing and finding a way to make embryonic selection for intelligence popular and accepted. There are large barriers to the above, namely ourselves in our reluctance to put more funding into social/educational/etc. programs, and the elite who control that which produces certainly not wanting to give up their position any time soon. I'm interested in people's thoughts on this. It seems to be something that is largely ignored but yet appears to be staring us down head on as something that will happen and will begin happening soon.