11 ms·
Costa Rica Is Now Running on 100% Renewable Electricity
- vidyesh 12y agoThis article misses a vital point. Its now been more than 85 straight days without using fossil fuel for power.[1] [1]http://www.sciencealert.com/costa-rica-powered-with-100-renewable-energy-for-75-days http://www.sciencealert.com/costa-rica-powered-with-100-rene...
- boulos 12y agoIt also doesn't do as good of a job as this Guardian article: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/mar/30/truth-behind-costa-rica-renewable-energy-reservoirs-climate-change http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/mar/30/truth-b... at pointing out that this is a temporary blip caused by record rainfall following a record drought.
- vidyesh 12y agoI couldn't find the original article so linked the one I found quickly. But here[1], this article is quite well with enough info and pitches in a few more things than just Costa Rica. [1]http://qz.com/367985/costa-rica-is-now-running-completely-on-renewable-energy/ http://qz.com/367985/costa-rica-is-now-running-completely-on...
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoWorth noting that this is a "comment is free" article, which is basically the Guardian's sanctioned area for trolling their right-on readership. "Green energy is only possible for tiny countries that suffer from global warming and even then not really" is a fine bit of trolling and I salute the author's skill in this game.
- InspecteurConan 12y agoYou got it all :)
- amelius 12y ago(I'm still waiting for the W3C spec and full browser support that will allow me to comment on just any url.)
- lkbm 12y agoThe W3C has Annotea, but they never got widespread browser support. I know I actually downloaded Amaya at one point, presumably in hopes of trying Annotea.
- polshaw 12y agoFossil fuel for electricity. Transport is a comparable energy consumer and overwhelmingly fossil fuel based. In cooler climates the same is true for space heating.
- barking 12y agoAlways wondered how Costa Rica seems able to do so well in a region that seems otherwise to be stuck in never-ending poverty, environmental degradation and conflict.
- boulos 12y agoPart of the usual explanation is that they abolished their military after their civil war in the 40s: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_Costa_Rica http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_Costa_Rica
- melling 12y agoThey got rid of their military: http://articles.latimes.com/2013/dec/15/opinion/la-oe-barash-costa-rica-demilitarization-20131208 http://articles.latimes.com/2013/dec/15/opinion/la-oe-barash...
- rodgerd 12y agoExactly. Having armed forces ready to stage a coup any time their friends in the State Department or CIA encourage them leads you down the route of Honduras, Chile, and so on.
- digi_owl 12y agoExcept that they could abolish the army because USA has underwritten their security. So in essence they have gone one further than Chile.
- rodgerd 12y agoCharacterising the situation of Central American states as having "the US underwrite their security" seems willfully at odds with actual history.
- _nedR 12y agoWow. That is truly amazing. What is almost as shocking to me is that I have never heard of this before. I have heard that Costa rica was a model for its healthcare sytem but i never heard that it didn't have a military. This story should be told more often and Costa rica should be a model for the world in this regard.
- riffraff 12y agofor the record, Norway has had something like 98% of it's energy from renewables for a long time.
- boulos 12y agoAnd iceland (which the article points out is a leader in geothermal energy production)
- vidyesh 12y agoIIRC, it is somewhere between 80-90% of houses using geothermal energy to heat up their houses.
- rosser 12y agoAnd Costa Rica doesn't have a nearly trillion-dollar sovereign wealth fund. It's not a very fair comparison.
- digi_owl 12y agoMost of the renewables was built before the oil.
- zurn 12y agoIf this is said about Europe's largest oil producer (between Nigeria and Kuwait in world stats), there's something wrong with energy production accounting.
- Dylan16807 12y agoWhy do you say that? Shouldn't the burden go on the consumer?
- zurn 12y agoNo, placing the burden on the individual consumers doesn't work. "Tragedy of the commons" type problems are generally solvable only by organized collective decisionmaking. Irrespective of that, discounting oil production from "share of renewables in energy production" is just nonsensical.
- dirtyaura 12y agoIt should be noted that this is mostly hydro power. If I recall right, hydro is up to 90% of the electricity generation in Costa Rica and if there is a drought in the country, they will burn coal to support their base load power generation. Nevertheless, great achievement.
- jn1234 12y agoExcept hydro isn't really that great of a power source, when the environmental impacts are taken into account. In the US, the most recent trend has been toward removals. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dam_removal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dam_removal
- toomuchtodo 12y agoA breakdown of the generation capacity is available here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/3042kb/costa_rica_provides_record_75_days_of_power/cppa1oj https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/3042kb/costa_ri...
- johnchristopher 12y agoIt popped up in my Facebook stream yesterday and one comment caught my attention: "Okay, but what about the hectares of forest (with actual indigenous people, animals and plants) and farm lands they are destroying every year with dams ?".
- 1971genocide 12y agoThe damage caused by hydro-electrical plants is always blown out of proportion. Dams create huge reservoir of water, which flood a lot of land upstream, causing the river lines to expand. however people forget to mention that gravity is a zero-sum game. every area that is being rendered unusable upstream results in creation of new area downstream. More often than not these areas are near large cities which are usually located downstream. Also it opens up new fertile river bed for agriculture. Now coming back to your question. Sometimes government do not properly compensate the people that are being displaced or take care of the animals etc. But that is a fault of the government and not the science behind hydro-electrical.
- fetbaffe 12y agoHowever fish that needs to travel upstream have a hard time. It can be solved to some extent.
- sjwright 12y agoWith cannons. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kICS32kady4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kICS32kady4
- hueving 12y ago>however people forget to mention that gravity is a zero-sum game. every area that is being rendered unusable upstream results in creation of new area downstream. That's not right. Once the lake is created, nearly the same amount of water will be flowing downstream.
- 12y ago
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoIt is worth noting that "Running on 100% Renewable Electricity" most likely only addresses grid electricity, not other form of fossil fuel use, such as cars, truck, boats and trains. 100% Renewable Electricity in the grid is a great milestone, but it's not 100% of energy use as the title might suggest.
- static_noise 12y agoGrid electricity is only about a third of primary energy consumption. Renewables and nuclear power only make up about 10% and 6% of primary energy consumption worldwide [1]. In the coming years we have to ramp those fractions up globally A LOT in order to become CO2-neutral. Also from the low fraction of 6% we can see that nuclear could be switched off today without making a big difference for CO2 output, renewables already generate more power. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_energy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_energy
- brrt 12y agoThen it is also worth noting that electricity generation is the biggest single source of carbon emissions globally :-). And that transport is actually a relatively tiny part of global carbon emissions: http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/global.html http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/global.html In other words, this is a bigger deal than your post seems to suggest.
- de_Selby 12y agoI did a summer internship project with our national electricity supplier here in Ireland when I was a student - the aim was to asses he environmental impact of their fleet of vehicles. The management weren't terribly happy with the presentation I gave at the end of the summer where using a few simple models I showed that even their smallest power station was polluting on a scale that was orders of magnitude greater than the impact of their entire fleet. We have mostly coal and peat powered plants here. Nuclear is completely off the table for political reasons, but there is a huge untapped wind energy resource. This really is great news for Costa Rica. I think we should also be exploring Nuclear energy more to bridge the gap in most other countries though.
- jussij 12y ago> So to prepare for drier weather that's likely to come with climate change. I don't understand why do so many people equate climate change and global warming with drought? If only it was only that simple? One of the most noticeable, measurable effects of climate change is the warming of the oceans. That warming adds energy to the oceans and that energy then causes big changes to barometric pressure, resulting in wind directional changes. The warming oceans warm the air above them and that causing the air to rise. That rising warm air sucks in colder surrounding air. That air movement changes the prevailing wind patterns. It is those changes to local wind patterns that cause the changes to local weather. If suddenly you’re country is seeing more onshore winds, you’ll be seeing more drought. But if you’re seeing more offshore winds you’ll see more flooding. The climate models are so complex it’s impossible to predict how these changes will pan out at a local level. But as someone living here in Oz, it's clear that over the last few years the local wind patterns have changed and those changes have caused changes to local weather. Some areas are seeing warming, others are seeing cooling, some areas are in drought, others are in constant flooding, but in the end it just depends on how the the prevailing winds have changed.
- lars512 12y agoThe models may well have changed, but a quick Google for "climate change impact Costa Rica" brought up a 2008 study, saying: > Regional climate models predict that the area will become warmer and drier as climate change accelerates. Give them the benefit of the doubt. Perhaps they are talking specifically about the best current models for Costa Rica, instead of suggesting every place will have drought. Although the models are complex and may change, there's no reason not to run with the best current models, changing your plans only when these long-term forecasts change.
- DennisP 12y agoHere's a 2013 study in Nature on the subject[1]. Drought has increased over many land areas since 1950, pretty well matching their model, which predicts increasingly severe drought over the next 30-90 years. For much more on the subject, a great book is Six Degrees by Mark Lynas, who reviewed about 3000 papers on the projected effects of climate change (and referenced them extensively). I don't remember all the details, but one issue is that more heat brings more evaporation, drying out the soil. Rainfall tends to be less frequent and harder, which washes away the dried-out topsoil. Another issue is that rain clouds tend to form over the warmer ocean, instead of drifting over land. Rain falling in the Indian Ocean is expected to cause severe drought in Africa (and that's already been seen to some extent). [1] http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v3/n1/full/nclimate1633.html http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v3/n1/full/nclimate16...
- samstav 12y agoA UT geosciences professor made a fantastic and enlightening documentary on global energy called Switch that is certainly worth a watch if you're interested in this topic. From wikipedia: "... he asks the central question of the film: what will the energy transition look like for the rest of us? ...travels the world to find out. The expertise of the interviewees and the access to restricted energy sites is unparalleled in other energy films. After his journey, he assembles his findings to map out the likely energy future. While coal and oil will continue to play a large role especially in developing countries, a global transition to where their alternatives become dominant will happen in about 50 years. Renewables see by far the largest growth rate, while natural gas makes up the largest portion of the replacement, with nuclear approximately equal in share to renewables." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switch_%282012_film%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switch_%282012_film%29 http://www.switchenergyproject.com/ http://www.switchenergyproject.com/
- primroot 12y agoForget about the rights of indigenous people, agricultural productivity, water evaporation, environmental impact, the subsidies, the malls, Jevons paradox, Plan Puebla Panamá, etc. Let's talk about greenhouse gases. http://www.un.org/esa/sustdev/sdissues/energy/op/hydro_tremblaypaper.pdf http://www.un.org/esa/sustdev/sdissues/energy/op/hydro_tremb...
- christudor 12y agoElectricity supply has to exactly match electricity demand at all times, which is why (in my opinion) 100% renewable energy doesn't make sense. There has to be /some/ source of electricity that a country can turn to if the wind stops blowing, the sun goes behind a cloud, or - indeed - demand for electricity suddenly spikes. The only way you could do this with renewable energy is if you had a way of 'storing' electricity, which could be used to meet demand if there was a shortfall in supply -- and this becomes incredibly expensive very quickly. The most efficient approach to the electricty supply is to have a base-load of electricity being supplied by something which is 'always on', e.g. fossil fuels or nuclear energy, and then having renewables top up the rest. [All this is just my opinion, by the way, but didn't want to litter the whole post with "in my opinion..."! You get the idea!]
- DennisP 12y agoThat's why all the articles about countries doing so well on renewables are always on countries with lots of hydro and/or geothermal. There really should one word for those sources, which provide energy pretty much on demand but aren't available everywhere, and a different word for wind/solar which have the opposite characteristics. Using the same word for both tends to make people overoptimistic about wind/solar.
- throwaway344 12y agoSome renewables are "baseload" sources of power. Things both proven, like geothermal and hydro, or more experimental like OTEC. They can work 24/7/365.
- ptaipale 12y agoHydro is sort of wasted as "baseload" source, because it's so readily adjustable, i.e. it is good as "dispatchable" source. Nuclear is the typical baseload source, as adjusting output is not that fast. But of course, if your hydro is really plentiful, then it doesn't matter. Take the case of Norway and Denmark: Denmark has wind energy, which is very erratic. Norway has lots of hydro power which is perfectly dispatchable. When there's wind and not much consumption, Norway can buy wind electricity cheaply from Denmark (in fact the price may be negative because the excess production has to be sunk somewhere). The hydro plants are stopped. When there's no wind and there's a lot of consumption, Norway can sell electricity at a very good price to Denmark. So, capacity is not the only thing that matters, dispatchability is important, and Norway clearly has the upper hand here because its wattage capacity is of a better kind.
- dataker 12y agoI'm not convinced renewable energy is always a good idea. Many times, people wanna save the environment at the cost of the poorest. In Brazil, a lot has been discussed about Belo Monte Dam(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belo_Monte_Dam#Social_effects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belo_Monte_Dam#Social_effects) as it's bringing serious social and economical issues to native residents.
- primroot 12y ago> Many times, people wanna save the environment at the cost of the poorest. Not quite, they want to keep/increase "their" wealth at the expense of the poorest. So old story here.
- mikeash 12y agoThe costs of environmental problems are disproportionately borne by the poorest as well.
- primroot 12y agoI completely agree. My point is that this is part of a bigger pattern of "power dynamics." For example the urban middle class engages in a kind of self-congratulatory mode by observing such rituals as Earth Hour, while at the same time condemning the intransigence of poor communities who refuse to be displaced for the sake of the country, the planet, etc. No one dare even suggest that the economic rewards of cheaper energy be allocated in further promotion of environmental protection measures, or God forbid, compensation for the displaced, instead of fueling an imminent manifestation of Jevons Paradox, which would obliterate the thinly argued benefits of e.g. a hydropower project. As we say in Spanish "la cadena se rompe por el eslabón más débil." [1] The case of environmental problems is filled with nasty expressions of this saying [2]. David Graeber is one who has written about this pattern beyond this case. [1] The chain breaks on the weakest link. [2] Take the case of the WWF http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/wwf-helps-industry-more-than-environment-a-835712.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/wwf-helps-industry... . Or this case of a hydropower project in my country Panama https://intercontinentalcry.org/un-registered-barro-blanco-hydroelectric-dam-temporarily-suspended-non-compliance-environmental-impact-assessment/ https://intercontinentalcry.org/un-registered-barro-blanco-h... which our local breed of "pragmatic environmentalists" dared not to object.
- webXL 12y ago> And the country's economy relies on tourism and agriculture, not energy-sucking industries like manufacturing. As it relates to the topic, it should say "not electricity-sucking industries". This is an important point however. The U.S. uses 7.3x as much electricity per capita.[1] It would be extremely difficult and costly to build the renewable infrastructure to replace what we have now. Sure, if you're in a warm climate and not used to consuming so much electricity, then renewables are great, but insisting that all developing economies use renewables, or imposing that cost on workers who haven't seen much wage growth in a while, you're asking for trouble. Solve the nuclear waste issue and we can really improve living conditions all over the world, while helping to prevent CAGW. 1) http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.USE.ELEC.KH.PC?order=wbapi_data_value_2011+wbapi_data_value+wbapi_data_value-last&sort=desc http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.USE.ELEC.KH.PC?order=...
- phkahler 12y agoMost of it comes from hydro which is considered environmentally unfriendly. Its still very interesting even if the "greenness" is somewhat debatable.
- pluckytree 12y agoWhen a country accomplishes something really great, it’s not because they are small and the US is big. It’s because they are smart and we are dumb. We hear this all the time. Portugal legalized drugs and it worked, but they’re small. Iceland forged their own path after the banking collapse, but they’re small. The Nordic countries have great education systems that cost less, but they’re small. Always a great excuse when you really don’t want to learn from others.
- NittLion78 12y agoMaybe we're dumb because we're big. More people = more odds of an ignoramus group having critical mass.
- pc2g4d 12y agoMore people = greater diversity of opinions and interest groups, thus greater difficulty achieving consensus (or even majority).
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoIf that were true China would be the most diverse nation on the planet, and the hardest to manage. The problem in the US is the opposite - national policy is almost exclusively influenced by interest groups with very limited intellectual and cultural diversity. There could easily have been a crash space-race type of program of renewables development at any time from the mid-70s onwards. If that had happened, it's likely there would have been astounding developments in collection efficiency and energy storage. But the Jurassic energy cos were never going the loss of face, I mean loss of profits, that would have led to. So - here we are now.
- lkbm 12y agoYou start out implying that China _isn't_ diverse, an dthen seem to argue that the US's problem is that we're more diverse. But you got it right the first time: China, especially in terms of leadership, doesn't listen to a bunch of diverse groups. They centrally control it without much concern for the whining of the luggage industry, or the furniture industry, or the cotton farmers. In the US, we listen to special interests because 1. we listen to those who talk and 2. special interests are very interested in a small thing that the general public doesn't care about. A very small luggage industry can demand absurd luggage protectionism because people in that industry care a lot, and people outside of it are barely even aware that it's a thing. I won't change my vote based on whether you put massive tariffs on foreign-made suitcases, but people whose jobs depend on it will. China avoids this by not caring about what people say.