5 ms·
Pentagon’s $55B mystery plane is secret, but debate on cost is appearing
- venomsnake 12y agoIsn't the future in 3d printed automated drones, with absurdly low cost, that can saturate any defense.
- ojbyrne 12y ago"Absurdly low cost" won't work with the giant welfare system that is the DoD.
- venomsnake 12y agoThere are nations that have the outdated ideas of winning wars and not stimulating the economy ... for them the ideas of mass produced drones built at BOM, with some stolen IP from US are tempting.
- hessenwolf 12y agoWasn't war always about stealing people's stuff or preventing your stuff from being stolen? I mean, my country had independence wars every generation for 800 years, but they were all about not getting our potatoes robbed.
- sitkack 12y agoThe OP is referring to real vs perceived (manufactured) threats, but you know that.
- adventured 12y agoThe problem with such drones, is distance. Let's say Iran decides to take that approach. Then the question is: how far can they push those armed drones out from their operating bases. The answer is: not very far. So no, drones saturating defenses isn't a serious threat to nations or regional strength, only to very specific targets that are nearby (eg an aircraft carrier & crew dumb enough to park off the coast of Iran, after they acquire such drone technology, and assuming the US has developed no defense for such).
- venomsnake 12y agoThe problems with such drones is not distance. When you remove the whole wetware, and the systems to keep it alive you can reduce the weight of the aircraft substantially. Also it is threat for exactly the regional powers. Iran does not care about US, it cares for Iraq, Israel, Saudy Arabia, Egypt and Syria.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoNot only you can reduce the mass of your aircraft, removing wetware also gives you ability to push it further in terms of speed and maneuverability. Current fighters are constrained by what pilot's body is capable of handling.
- desdiv 12y agoNorthrop Grumman seriously paid for a Super Bowl ad? Oh sure, next time I'm out shopping for a long range stealth bomber maybe I'll subconsciously remember the ad and choose a Northrop Grumman one. I've been a long time Boeing-Lockheed customer but the powerful imagery from that ad left quite the impression on me. I get that defense officials and congressmen watch the Super Bowl, but there must be more cost effective methods of reaching them than buying the most expensive airtime on the planet.
- tree_of_item 12y agoDon't forget the signaling value: Northrop Grumman is not a small shop, and wants to show these officials and congressman that they're the real deal and have plenty of money to spend on flashy and super expensive things like Super Bowl ads.
- c-slice 12y agoI think this is completely PR - they want to create buzz and excitement in the public for the "hot new spy plane" such that its politically impossible for congress to cancel the program/cut the budget.
- enraged_camel 12y agoI doubt it. There is a ton of war-weariness these days, and expensive military projects aren't very popular. Especially considering the utter fiasco that is the F-35 program, I really doubt the public is in the mental or emotional state to support another pricey project.
- bhayden 12y agoYou say that like the public opinion matters at all.
- frabcus 12y agoMy guess is it's political - they want the public to also be excited about the mysterious new plane, and approve the budget.
- ricardobeat 12y agoDid I seriously just read a cry for "disrupting the combat aircraft market"? How about disrupting the tobacco business? Disrupting human traffic? Exaggerations aside, not everything is about making (or saving) money. I sure as hell don't want military weapons to become the latest startup trend.
- _yosefk 12y agoI can see how we'd be better off without human trafficking and, to a smaller extent, without the tobacco business. I'm not sure we'd be better off without weapons. In fact, if the club became world's most advanced weapon tomorrow, it would, among other things, likely boost human trafficking.
- venomsnake 12y agoWe cannot be without weapons. Ever. A smart person could weaponize everything. That is the whole point of the brain evolving. It is in our DNA.
- tormeh 12y agoThere are, of course, defense startups. This one is pretty futuristic/terrifying: http://www.proxdynamics.com/home http://www.proxdynamics.com/home
- rprospero 12y agoI have no love for the military. I turned down a guaranteed job offer that pays twice what I'm currently making simply because I don't want to work on things that kill people. That said, I can also see the other side of this. According to Wikipedia, the US government spent $66 billion dollars on the F22. I'm naive, so I think that we could save $66 billion on that by just not having an F22, but congress disagrees with me and I'm not sure that I'll ever win that fight. However, imagine that start-ups could do the job 10% more efficiently. That's six billion dollars that you just saved. Now, imagine an entire government agency, like the Peace Corp, but purely dedicated to fighting human trafficking. You could fund that agency for fifteen years on that six billion dollars. If the startup is 20% cheaper, then you could have a second agency of similar size that is dedicated to helping people stop smoking. If the startup managed to be a full 30% cheaper, you can throw in thirty thousand four-year, full-ride college scholarships. Again, I'd love to have all of that $66 billion spent on other projects, but even funnelling part of that into a different area could markedly improve the world. I'd never work for a start-up that worked on air combat, but I'd be thrilled to free up some of the air combat budget.
- smhinsey 12y agoSo what happens if we find ourselves in a war of attrition again? Most/all of the potential opponents in such a war are nuclear powers so it's theoretically not a possibility but history is littered with theoretical impossibilities made real. It seems like we have all of these incredibly dominant and expensive weapons but only a relatively tiny supply, no timely and cost-effective way to replace losses, and not many options if they run out. I didn't attend a service academy so maybe I'm missing something, but what if the initial battle is not decisive and after 6 months of somehow-only-conventional war there are no more LRSBs or F-22s or whatevers?
- adventured 12y agoThe other major nuclear powers are no more capable of fighting a war of attrition than the US is. Further, the US is highly unlikely to be dumb enough to fight a war in China or Russia. That would require ten million soldiers just to get started anyway. It simply isn't going to happen, any more than Russia or China are going to cross the Pacific or Atlantic and invade the US. China has very little capability to project outside its borders, and is in the process of modernizing its military and shrinking its forces. Russia has zero capability of projecting serious conventional might outside of its borders, or those extremely close by. So what war of attrition is likely to occur? Whatever that is, it'll be fought closer to the enemy's backyard, than the US backyard. The US has military bases all around the planet, nobody else does. So the US can strike, perpetually, at foreign targets via force projection, while limiting damage to its domestic manufacturing capabilities. Said manufacturing capabilities would be, much like WW2, ramped up to meet demand. The US has a massive labor pool, and if desperately needed, could grant citizenship to tens of millions from Latin America in exchange for building armaments in factories. Unlike China, the US is capable of 100% domestic commodity supply, and if pressed can also fulfill all of its own manufacturing and technology needs (which China can as well, but they don't have the domestic commodities the US possesses). To win a war of attrition, in a conventional war, the US could simply spam the construction of new B-52s and bombs, and then leverage its global bases, pressing an unrelenting bombing campaign taking out all of the enemy's manufacturing capabilities. No present or likely future enemies of the US could strike back at the US domestically for any sustained period of time. Now, if we're talking China in 30 years, will they be able to project across the Pacific all the way to Hawaii and California? Interesting question, it's going to depend on whether their economy melts down due to the hyper debt accumulation they're undergoing now, and whether they end up in perpetual debt stagnation like Japan (while their demographics melt simultaneously, and the demand for entitlements to take care of the elderly soars, sapping their financial capabilities even further).
- ponyous 12y agoWTF US, why do you need/want to build this? Do people support this?
- zo1 12y agoThis may be an overall drop in the budget. But could we all agree that this money could have been spent for better causes? You know, the concrete stuff people expect of a government. Things such as homelessness, poverty, health, retirement, crime.
- madaxe_again 12y agoAw, c'mon, nobody has mentioned Aurora yet? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aurora_%28aircraft%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aurora_%28aircraft%29
- johnnyyousef 12y ago"Aw, c'mon, nobody has mentioned Aurora yet?" What on earth does that? "nobody has mentioned Aurora yet?" you've obviously checked nobody mentioned it, so why not just give us the link and say how it's relevant. "Aw, c'mon" what the hell is that? Who talks like that? What does "aw" mean? You're disappointed nobody has mentioned something is relevant? Why does that upset you? Why shorten "c'mon" from "come on" like that? Why post this nonsense? Just give us the link and why it's relevant.
- madaxe_again 12y agoWhat died up your arse? The link is right there. Would you like me to click it for you?
- johnnyyousef 12y agoI don't have a problem with the link or reading it myself. I have a problem with 'Aw, c'mon, nobody has mentioned Aurora yet?'. What do you mean by 'Aw, c'mon'? That's an illiterate sentence. And why say 'nobody has mentioned it yet?' Why ask that question? Why not check for yourself if anyone has mentioned it yet? What you probably meant was 'This may be related to the Aurora project [link]'.
- madaxe_again 12y agoYet you start a sentence with "And", use single quotes inappropriately, and add absolutely nothing to the discussion, whereas I, colloquialisms notwithstanding, did. Go and do something productive with your time - this isn't, and I'd bet it's just annoying both of us.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoI think the key question for space and aviation enthusiasts is whether or not the Pentagon is building a hypersonic suborbital manned bomber. If they are -- and it's a big "if" -- then that means the technology for civilian use is just a couple/few decades away. I haven't seen the numbers, but in my mind the market for suborbital commercial flights, say, New York to Sydney in an hour or two, is already there. It's a place on the road to reducing cost-to-orbit where the money's already there. Somebody just has to go get it. Plus DoD will end up solving most of the problems by being the first mover.
- Pxtl 12y agoI don't know, I don't think the market for any kind of supersonic passenger vehicle is there. Look at the Concord.
- vvpan 12y agoThe best defence is probably not bombing the hell out of nations on the other side of the world to start with.
- babby 12y agoThe title is a bit misleading. Pentagon's $55B mystery plane is secret... Yet the planes only cost half a billion each: ... The service estimates it will cost $55 billion to build as many as 100 of what it calls the Long Range Strike Bomber ... Here I was thinking they built the most reckless single aircraft ever.