6 ms·
EFF Outlines Plan to Fix the Broken Patent System
- zanny 12y agoThe solution to the patent system is to abolish it. The whole thing. Seek compensation for the act of coming up with innovative ideas instead of trying to apply artificial state granted monopolies to them after the fact. It would be so much healthier to have money pumped into the R&D of common utility goods for the sake of the innovation than to continue to perpetuate patent warfare while trying to attach a flawed profit motive to intellectualism.
- rogerbinns 12y agoThe usual retort to that is "so you don't want to cure cancer then". The pharmaceutical industry very strongly depends on patents, and would easily be able to convince government through money and "cancer" not to abolish it. The practical thing then is to come up with a solution for pharma, and then abolish the patent system.
- gavanwoolery 12y agoKilling software patents would be a good start IMO.
- themartorana 12y agoI think this is the right way to go. Short of the argument against patenting math, I think you're hard-pressed to find anything that parallels pharma or hard-goods patents in software. But with software should go business-process patents, which suffer from the same "patent a way of doing things" problems. Patents do well to cover the result of a process, and shouldn't cover the process itself. In software, you can have two patents end up with the same result, as long as they arrive there by different paths. With hard goods, you invent inline skates. Someone can't declare another patent arriving at the same result but using a different manufacturing process to create inline skates.
- higherpurpose 12y agoEven if we keep patents for Big Pharma alone, they need a serious overhaul because right now they are grossly abusing them, too. It's not just tech companies doing it. http://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/patents-against-people-how-drug-companies-price-patients-out-of-survival http://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/patents-against-peopl... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-sachs/the-drug-that-is-bankrupt_b_6692340.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-sachs/the-drug-that-is... http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2014/03/31/how-big-pharma-is-slowing-cancer-research/ http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2014/03/31/how-big-pha... (there are many more such examples)
- rhino369 12y agoPharma is just the best example. But any industry that involves R&D would be heavily affected. Why would Qualcomm bother making new designs if some other company will just rip off their design. All it would do is further weaken the engineers role in society and favor the banker. Without IP, the only thing that matters is capital to build production facilities.
- wbillingsley 12y agoThe patent system is very badly designed for pharma. The cost in pharma is in the clinical trials, but the patent is awarded for creating the drug -- long before the trials. Rather than being a reward for brining an innovation to market, the monopoly (patent) is awarded long before the bulk of the work has been done. No reward is offered in the patent system for doing the hard and expensive part -- proving efficacy and safety. But the patent means that even if you choose not to spend the money to bring it to market, nobody else is allowed to. Something like 95% of pharmaceuticals fail to be effective and safe. In other words, 95% of pharmaceutical patents are for inventions that ultimately don't work. "A patent for something that does not work" ought not be allowed -- the pharmaceutical patent should only be awarded after efficacy and safety has been proved (incentivising the hard part).
- suvelx 12y agoWhat's to stop the FDA enforcing 'patents' and market exclusivity in their approval process? I.e. Instead of approving Chemical-X, approve only DrugCorp brand Chemical-X? Possibly with some stipulation that the first company to submit and pass approval gets a N-year exclusivity.
- nitrogen 12y agoThe practical thing then is to come up with a solution for pharma, and then abolish the patent system. Could pharma companies pay an R&D tax into a shared pool issued as research grants by the NIH, with a quasi-market for allocating research funds? That way non-researching manufacturers of generics still contribute to new drug research -- no freeloading.
- amelius 12y agoWe don't need patents to justify everything. Think of space exploration. No patents are necessary for the government to invest billions of dollars into that industry. Furthermore, pharmaceutical companies have no incentive to find a real cure for anything if they can make more money fighting symptoms.
- kanzure 12y ago> The solution to the patent system is to abolish it. The whole thing. Here is my proposal for that sort of strategy: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/openmanufacturing/vS4ju1VqXb0/jD_TZ8U47b4J https://groups.google.com/d/msg/openmanufacturing/vS4ju1VqXb... Basically the idea is that there are extremely entrenched interests, so it is unlikely that they will just roll over and die. Instead, there should be a plan for deprecating the patent system.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoHow do other countries patent systems compare with the US'? Can inspiration for changes be drawn from them or are they just as bad/worse? I ask because I only ever hear of trolling in the US system.
- transfire 12y agoI know of one important distinction between the US and India with regards to medicine patents. In India you can only patent the means of making a medicine, not the medicine itself. So if you can come up with a substantially different way of making the same thing you have equal rights to it.
- rayiner 12y agoThis is a good law for India, because they have the capability to manufacture medicine, while lacking the capability to invent them. It's one of the many ways the world freeloads on U.S. medical R&D spending.
- rofl1234 12y ago> lacking the capability to invent citation needed
- rayiner 12y agoNew drug development in India is in its infancy: http://www.rsc.org/chemistryworld/2014/09/piramal-exits-drug-discovery-india http://www.rsc.org/chemistryworld/2014/09/piramal-exits-drug... ("This admission reflects the view that Indian drug companies are finding it difficult to develop successful new molecules. Discovering new drugs requires huge investment, and has not been favourably looked upon by risk-averse Indian investors. Several Indian molecules have failed in the clinic, including Piramal’s head and neck cancer candidate P276 in 2012. Even the antimalarial Synriam (arterolane and piperaquine), which Ranbaxy hailed as India’s first domestically developed drug, was originally discovered elsewhere.")
- higherpurpose 12y agoI hope that after the Alice vs CLS Supreme Court ruling EFF & Co reintroduce the abolishing of "business method" patents, which Microsoft and IBM fought so hard to take out of the previous bill. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/11/20/software-patent-reform-just-died-in-the-house-thanks-to-ibm-and-microsoft/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/11/20...
- omgitstom 12y agoMan - this guy might have the best title I've seen in a while: Daniel Nazer Staff Attorney and the Mark Cuban Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents Electronic Frontier Foundation daniel@eff.org
- tzs 12y agoIs that usage correct? Shouldn't he be described as the holder of the Mark Cuban Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents, rather than being described as the Mark Cuban Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents? Also, every time I read about the Mark Cuban Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents I have a mysterious urge to watch "Zoolander".
- schoen 12y agoThe usage "is the ____ Chair" as opposed to "holds the ____ Chair" isn't that uncommon in the academic world (treating the Chair as a unique title, rather than only a position). A few random examples from Google: https://www.design.upenn.edu/city-regional-planning/graduate/people/eugenie-l-birch https://www.design.upenn.edu/city-regional-planning/graduate... Professor Birch is the Lawrence C. Nussdorf Chair of Urban Research and Education. http://www.thelancet.com/lanres/advisory-board http://www.thelancet.com/lanres/advisory-board Professor Klugman is the William H Foege Chair of Global Health at Emory University, Atlanta, GA, USA. http://www.bahaipeacechair.umd.edu/events/apr29-2015 http://www.bahaipeacechair.umd.edu/events/apr29-2015 Professor AMITAV ACHARYA is the UNESCO Chair in Transnational Challenges and Governance and is Professor of International Relations at the School of International Service, American University, Washington, D.C. https://www.law.louisville.edu/faculty/interdisciplinary-circle https://www.law.louisville.edu/faculty/interdisciplinary-cir... Professor Tony Arnold is the Boehl Chair in Property and Land Use. https://www.american.edu/provost/human-rights/Faculty-SIS.cfm https://www.american.edu/provost/human-rights/Faculty-SIS.cf... Professor Ahmed is the Ibn Khaldun Chair of Islamic Studies who studies American society through the experiences of the Muslim community.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI too thought that the 'Mark Cuban Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents' sounded like it was situated in the 'Derek Zoolander School for Kids Who Can't Read Good.' I had to skip the rest of the press release and go straight to the White Paper.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- frederickf 12y agoThis might be naive on my part but it seems like we could help the situation quite a bit, at least for software patents, by just reducing the amount of time for which new software patents are valid. It's simple, easy to understand and implement, more consistent with the speed at which the software market evolves, would reduce the perceived value of bogus patents making trolling less likely, free up technology sooner for everybody to benefit and still offer some protection to innovators. Right now they're good for between 14 to 20 years (1) which seems too long to me. I'm not sure what the right number is, maybe between 5 - 10? Even that seems long, but then again I don't have anything innovations to patent so I'm probably biased. (1) http://patents.stackexchange.com/questions/312/how-long-are-patents-valid http://patents.stackexchange.com/questions/312/how-long-are-...
- transfire 12y agoIt's not a good idea. Ideally rights should be for as long as the life of the inventor. Instead of a cut-off time, I've heard people espouse a system of valuation and, in some cases, taxation, so that over time a patent becomes increasingly affordable for others to buy out and put into the public domain.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoWhat is the basis for your "should" here?
- rhino369 12y ago>Ideally rights should be for as long as the life of the inventor. I'm fairly pro patent, but I disagree. Unlike copyright where there is an almost unlimited amount of expression available, some inventions are just something people would independently come up with. Nobody would organically and independently come up with Mickey Mouse or Sherlock Holmes. But different teams would have invented the BJT transistor if Bardeen, et al. never existed. Patents length acknowledges that by not giving exclusive rights forever. It's more of a challenge prize than a pure ownership of the idea indefinitely.
- gombotzd 12y ago
- transfire 12y agoThis doesn't really go far enough. It's doesn't address the more basic problems of a for-profit patent office (the USPO has been required to be self-sustaining since Bush), nor does it address unfair practices of high upfront and ongoing renewal costs and worse, the inherently unfair practice of being able to buy expedited service. It is also counter productive to shorten the time span of patents b/c it means all the money required to develop it has to be recouped very quickly. Better to have longer periods, but with clearer and stricter requirements for what is actually patentable.
- rayiner 12y agoMost of these are really excellent, such as the suggestion to require example code for claims implemented in software, to allow the regional courts of appeal to decide patent cases, and to defer most discovery until after claim construction. On the other hand, some of the suggestions simply beg the question. What is a "software patent" or a "patent troll?" Software is eating the world--mechanisms that would have in the 1990s been implemented in ASICs are implemented in microcontrollers. What people think of "software" they think of typical application code that mostly moves bits from point A to point B or react to user input. Software where each individual line of code is straightforward and requires little thought. An R&D project might spend millions of dollars to write a bunch of code that will be thrown away--and can still be considered successful if it yields useful algorithms. These are qualitatively different kinds of software, but it's devilishly difficult to draw the line. Of course the easy solution is to eliminate software patents. I'm not convinced that's a good thing long-term. I look at the tech industry, and see one where product companies rather than hard R&D companies make all the money. The folks at SRI who invented Siri get a small license fee, while Apple makes billions by wrapping it with a candy shell. It's an industry where there is tremendous pressure to vertically integrate, because you can only justify R&D on basic technologies if you also control the product that gets sold to end-users.
- rhino369 12y agoIn my opinion, software elements in a claim should be treated as means-plus-function claims. I'm not sold on ending the Federal Circuit. It would just lead to forum shopping and arbitraging circuit splits. That would only increase litigation due to uncertainty. I'll have to read the EFFs white paper to see why they feel this way. But IMO the Fed circuit + SCOTUS keeping them honest really works.
- btilly 12y agoDefine "really works". I also question how much the SCOTUS keeps them honest when they blatently ignore SCOTUS decisions, and SCOTUS does not have the bandwidth to continuously overturn them.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago
- cletus 12y agoI'm disappointed by the EFF's stance here: it simply isn't strong enough. I'm in the camp that believes there shouldn't be software patents period. Simple as that. As for ending the exclusive jurisdiction of the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals on patent case appeals, I assume this is because that court has frequently been overly friendly to patent plaintiff claims. Some might argue it's gone so far as regulatory capture. What's more, the court has repeatedly been overturned by the SCOTUS. That's a fair argument but what they're forgetting was that the USCoAftFC was introduced to solve a problem. We have the problem now that there is inconsistent treatment of patent cases in Federal district courts, leading plaintiffs to file cases in "friendly" jurisdictions, most notably East Texas. Prior to 1982, you had the same problem at the appeals level and you had a rush to file appeals in friendly jurisdictions. This court was certainly intended to provide consistent treatment of patent cases and--ideally--allow for experts in patent law to handle such cases. But the fact that this court has really had trouble finding a patent they didn't like is a sideshow: the real problem here is software patents. You can't patent a mathematical formula and as anyone with any kind of Computer Science education could tell you, an algorithm is essentially indistinguishable from a mathematical function. The fact that the US courts have ignored this or simply been unable to comprehend it is at the root of the problem.
- xroche 12y agoThis is what is supposed to be true in Europe: software "as such" can not be patented. The issue we have is that corrupted patent organizations such as the EPO twisted the "as such" so much that they managed to reverse the original meaning (ie. you can not patent a software "as such", but patenting its use inside of a computer is legit - I love lawyers)
- Animats 12y agoLet's look at the EFF's proposals: 1. The patent term should be shorter for software patents. It should last no more than five years from the application date. Software doesn't move that fast. The Internet is now over 30 years old. It's been 61 years since the first FORTRAN compiler. At various times in the past, aircraft technology and radio technology advanced at least as fast as computer technology. Computing is not special; it's just a currently active area. 2. If the patent is invalid or there’s no infringement, patent trolls should have to pay the winning party’s legal fees. This provides a way for big companies to intimidate patent holders. A small patent holder can be threatened with huge legal bills. The odds of winning a patent infringement lawsuit are about 40-50%, and even if you have a strong patent, it's common to lose. 3. Patent applicants should be required to provide an example of running software code for each claim in the patent. The USPTO has the right to demand a working model if they are not convinced the patented concept would work. At one time, they did. (Patent models are cute collectables now.) Current USPTO policy is to demand a working model only for things such as antigravity machines or perpetual motion machines. Unworkable patents do not seem to be a problem in the software area. 4. Infringers should avoid liability if they independently arrive at the patented invention. Absolutely not. Infringers will routinely lie about that, claiming independent invention, and it's really tough to prove intent. There's a provision in current law which allows for a defense of independent invention for, I think, one year after patent issue. That's sufficient. 5. Patents and licenses should be public upon filing. Patent owners should be required to keep their public ownership records up-to-date. Patent applications are already published at the 18 month mark. 6. The law should do more to limit damages so that a patent owner can’t collect millions if the patent represented only a tiny fraction of a defendant’s product. A patent is the right to say "no, you can't do that". Infringers aren't entitled to practice the patent at all and then just pay damages if they lose. 7. Congress should commission a study and hold hearings to examine whether software patents actually benefit our economy at all. The purpose of the patent system isn't to "benefit the economy". It's to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts", according to the Constitution. As for "patent trolls", according to the EFF's own database[1], there are only a few real "patent trolls", with one firm in Texas being the big generator of threatening letters. The top firm has 15 letters in the EFF's database. (They've sent more.) There are a very small number of patents being "trolled". The EFF was arguing for this in the previous session of Congress. Once it came out how weak their case was, the legislation was dropped. [1] https://trollingeffects.org/lawfirms https://trollingeffects.org/lawfirms
- yazaddaruvala 12y agoHonestly, I think the best way to get rid of this nonsense, keeping everyone happy, is to allow patents but to enforce a "profit cap". Basically, if an entity has invested $X into RND for patent Y, then patent Y should be valid until some $(Z*X) has been earned by the entity. Where Z is some constant; or stepped like tax brackets. Example: A company develops some new software: it cost $500,000 of Engineering effort. They are awarded a patent. The patent should be valid until that company has earned $5 million (Z=10; ie 1000% ROI). Example: A company develops some new drug: it cost $5,000,000,000 for RND. They are awarded a patent. The patent should be valid until that company has earned $50 Billion (Z=10; ie 1000% ROI). I agree it may be hard to prove "amount spent on patent" or "profit earned from patent". However, at least to me, it seems as hard as the IRS auditing a company's taxes, or as hard as auditing a public companies quarterly financial disclosures.
- eCa 12y agoI think any such scheme should be based on revenue rather than profit, or else Hollywood accounting[1] might be encouraged. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
- yazaddaruvala 12y agoHonestly, I think the best way to get rid of this nonsense, keeping everyone happy, is to allow patents but to enforce a "profit cap". Basically, if an entity has invested $X into RND for patent Y, then patent Y should be valid until some $(Z*X) has been earned by the entity. Where Z is some constant; or stepped like tax brackets. Example: A company develops some new software: it cost $500,000 of Engineering effort. They are awarded a patent. The patent should be valid until that company has earned $5 million (Z=10; ie 1000% ROI). Example: A company develops some new drug: it cost $5,000,000,000 for RND. They are awarded a patent. The patent should be valid until that company has earned $50 Billion (Z=10; ie 1000% ROI). I agree it may be hard to prove "amount spent on patent" or "profit earned from patent". However, at least to me, it seems as hard as the IRS auditing a company's taxes, or as hard as auditing a public companies quarterly financial disclosures.
- Singletoned 12y agoI've often thought that a simple change would be to require you to prove that it is in the public interest for your patent to be enforced. Patents only exist for public benefit anyway. I don't think that a patent troll, for example, could prove that the world would be a better place by them enforcing their patents. If they could, then we'd be better off letting them do it (by definition).
- aercolino 12y agoThe PDF document lacks the last endnotes. 189 is the last one on page 28, but the endnotes list stops in the middle of 167.
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>If the patent is invalid or there’s no infringement, patent trolls should have to pay the winning party’s legal fees. // Wow, I can't believe award of costs isn't standard in such cases already. Incredible.