6 ms·
The article deftly steps around the real issue: Fuel Cells are entirely an petroleum industry promotion. The goal is to provide a seemingly credible (but in re
by r00fus 12y ago
The article deftly steps around the real issue: Fuel Cells are entirely an petroleum industry promotion.
The goal is to provide a seemingly credible (but in reality completely unworkable) clean alternative so politicians, car companies and oil companies together can work "towards a clean future" while deep down knowing that it's a stalling tactic to keep the petroleum infrastructure in place.
Any fuel cell funding sucks the oxygen from the real threats to the industry: Industrial/Consumer solar and BEV (battery electric vehicles).
It's analogous to "clean coal": http://www.coal-is-dirty.com/top-5-clean-coal-myths http://www.coal-is-dirty.com/top-5-clean-coal-myths
- soperj 12y agoI really don't understand the whole cars are in league with big oil. What on earth do the car companies have to get out of it? The big name in the 90s, Ballard, had buy in from a couple of car companies and no oil companies.
- hackuser 12y ago> I really don't understand the whole cars are in league with big oil. I'd guess car manufacturers have two economic interests: 1) The less energy for automobiles costs, the more people will use them, and 2) the less economic harm there is from climate change, the more people will use cars. I could see #1 motivating auto manufacturers to support the oil industry, and #2 motivating them to support clean energy.
- IanCal 12y ago> #1 motivating auto manufacturers to support the oil industry Are the energy costs for electric cars higher than those for traditional cars? I thought they were significantly lower.
- rational-future 12y agoThe conspiracy hypothesis is that the oil people have long ago acquired controlling interest in the auto corporations. Via foundations, funds, banks, etc.
- rsync 12y ago"I really don't understand the whole cars are in league with big oil." I don't know if car manufacturers are in league with big oil per se, but I have heard it argued convincingly that the repair and maintenance costs that are implied by the IC engine and its infrastructure in the car are a huge source of revenue for the entire auto ecosystem, and they just cannot give that up.
- frankosaurus 12y agoAuto companies and oil do have some common enemies. For example, mass transit is a threat to both.
- krschultz 12y agoDon't picture a bunch of oil tycoons with monocles sitting in back rooms smoking cigars with Ford execs laughing about how they are going to crush Tesla. It's much more subtle than that. I grew up around cars. My dad races them as his hobby. We restored a few, and spent plenty of time wrenching on a car together. It was one of the highlights of my childhood. It's still one of the things we often talk about when we see each other. I'm sure it's the reason I got a mechanical engineering degree. When I think back to those times, a bunch of fragments of memories pop up. The sound a racing motor makes the first time you fire it up. The smell of gasoline vs diesel vs oil vs brake fluid vs transmission fluid. The grease on your hands. Knowing all the components under the hood, how they go together. How to start a cold engine with a flakey carb. How to fix a flooded engine. There is real nostalgia around cars, and that means gasoline/diesel engines. I can barely enjoy modern cars with their plastic engine fairings and electronic controls, much less an electric car with just batteries and motors. I love building robots, and I'm a professional programmer now, but electric cars just don't excite me from the perspective of working on them. (Driving a Tesla is a different story). Layer on top of that nostalgia, which I believe most of the people that work in the auto industry have, is the reality of 100+ years of IC engine expertise. If electric cars are the future, how much advantage does Ford have over a startup? Certainly some, but not nearly as much as they do in gasoline engines. Every bit of the drive train is completely different in an electric car. Not only are you throwing out the expertise in engines, but transmissions and differentials as well. I can imagine that makes their position less defendable.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>I can imagine that makes their position less defendable. What you've written I agree with, but it's a long way off from the OP's conspiracy. Cars have been around a long time, so the affinity is natural result all that history. It will change. I'm also a "car guy". I recently entered into four-year lease on a new vehicle, and on the drive home I told my significant other it's probable that this will be the last ICE we ever buy (and perhaps the last car that we actually drive off the lot ourselves). It's funny to think about.
- sliverstorm 12y agoThere is real nostalgia around cars, and that means gasoline/diesel engines. Sure. And as a petrolhead, I will miss IC engines when they go. But it's a long leap from "implicit affection for IC engines" to "strategically presenting a build-to-fail engine technology to discredit alternative fuel".
- taeric 12y agoI would think it is more with leveraging existing infrastructure. It isn't so much that these companies are "in league" with big oil. More that a large portion of the infrastructure they have right now benefits from not needing to be retooled. Consider the costs that companies such as (solely as) Tesla are having to front to get a refueling infrastructure in place to make their cars considerable.
- greglindahl 12y agoAlmost all Tesla car charging occurs in owners' garages, where Tesla doesn't have to front anything. Tesla's supercharger network is funded by a $2,000 addition to each luxury car that they sell. Both kinds of chargers use a lot of pre-existing electricity infrastructure.
- taeric 12y agoRight... And they are trying to get things placed in locations such as shopping malls and eating locations so that for trips one could step inside while it charges. This is a large portion of why families can't really get one of these vehicles. If I can't take this thing on a family trip, there is no point in even trying to get one.
- higherpurpose 12y agoFor one, because they see Tesla as "winning" this "paradigm shift in cars", which could be (will be, in my opinion) just as disruptive as Apple's touchscreen was to the former cellphone industry. In such a situation having the paradigm shift happen in the first place is bad news for you, especially if you're a leader of the old paradigm. Microsoft, RIM and Nokia were all laughing off the iPhone in the first few years, so people would stay away from them and keep buying their "old stuff". So yeah, I can very much see how companies like Toyota and whoever else is promoting the totally unworkable fuel cell car "revolution" would be in bed with the oil industry. They'd rather push for something that barely changes the status quo, but at the same time is seen as "revolutionary" in the media, than go into electric cars.
- marcosdumay 12y agoNot signing for a conspiracy. But the car companies actions look a lot like they believe that both: 1 - Nobody will buy alternative fueled cars 2 - They must appear to support ecologically friendly energy sources
- api 12y ago"I really don't understand the whole cars are in league with big oil." Yeah, nobody would ever "conspire" when trillions upon trillions of dollars in economic activity, millions of entrenched (and often unionized) jobs, hundreds of billions of dollars of sunk cost in infrastructure, the economies of entire nations and regions of nations, and generations of established thinking are at stake. That never happens. The parent poster is just one of those conspiracy nuts. Sorry for the combative tone, but I'm a bit tired of seeing this kind of naivete. Of course people will conspire and engage in stalling and other underhanded political tactics to stop things that are a threat to huge industries and entrenched ways of doing things. They'll do that and more. They will lie, cheat, kill, undermine democracy and foster political corruption, start wars, you name it. A lawyer friend of mine explained it to me this way (we were discussing shady behavior in the startup world): "There are people who will beat you up or kill you for a smart phone or the contents of your wallet. What will people do for a million bucks?" I sort of got it. Answer is that people will do everything they'll do for your cell phone or wallet and then some, but they'll do it with far more sophistication and cunning. The higher the stakes the more cunning and otherwise sophisticated the crimes. BTW, the mention of unionized jobs above highlights that it's not just oil companies and car companies we're talking about here. We are also talking about a massive infrastructure for making, selling, and servicing oil-burner cars that employs minimally tens of millions of people in the US alone. All of that is threatened by simpler, more reliable, grid-connected battery EVs. EVs are downright apocalyptic for entire sectors of the economy. Hundreds of thousands of businesses will die, and millions will find their entire skill sets completely obsolete. It'd be like if suddenly there were computers faster and cheaper in every way than silicon-based ones but that are programmable through some utterly alien abstraction that has almost nothing in common with present-day programming languages. All your skills are now obsolete. Google is done. Microsoft is done. Etc...
- SilasX 12y agoIIUIC, the GP was objecting that car companies have conflicting interests with oil companies on this matter, not that such large conspiracies can't happen given the stakes. That is, car companies would love to be able to sell cars that don't need oil, and so would not (by themselves) hinder such technologies.
- koffiezet 12y agoThe problem isn't necessarily that they are in the same league, for the same reasons. Oil companies don't like electric cars for obvious reasons. Car companies on the other hand have a different reasons: electric cars hardly require maintenance, and a large part of the money car companies make is by selling replacement parts. Car makers were perfectly happy with the current situation, and the new-one threatens part of their business model, and nobody likes to switch from a working proven business model to a new-one. However, the difference between car companies and the oil industry is that the latter cannot adapt to this new situation. Car makers could just postpone introducing pure electric cars, or introduce even more complex 'hybrid' solutions under the pretense of being environmentally-friendly, while selling even more replacement parts and maintenance - which in my opinion was always silly. They could hold the boat off as long as nobody else tried to make a real production-ready electric car. So it's no surprise that it was a new-comer to the market that made it first. Suddenly, a lot of car manufacturers jumped the electric train: Renault, Nissan, BMW, Mercedes, ... You really think none of them thought of making an electric car before? GM did, just check out the "who killed the electric car" documentary. I don't believe for a second not every single car maker saw what was inevitably coming, but why kill the goose that lays golden eggs? It would be really hard to explain that to shareholders at a time when the industry is going through a very harsh period.
- alephnil 12y agoHe does not raise that topic, but as I see it, that's a strength of the article. It questions the utility of fuel cell hydrogen cars entirely on technical grounds, providing good arguments for why that is not a good technology to bet on in the future, from someone that has participated in developing said technology. This gives much more weight to his arguments than if he had started to discuss how this is some plot to keep the petroleum infrastructure in place. Instead the article gives solid arguments for technical minded people, that can be used in political discussions elsewhere
- redthrow 12y agoElon Musk famously calls them "fool cells": http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-06-25/toyota-to-offer-69-000-car-as-musk-pans-fool-cells- http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-06-25/toyota-to-... “As people probably know, I’m not the biggest fan of fuel cells -- I usually call them ‘‘fool cells,’” Musk said this month at Palo Alto, California-based Tesla’s annual meeting. In a speech to employees and enthusiasts at a service center in Germany last year, he called fuel cells “a load of rubbish.”
- schiffern 12y agoHere's the dirty little secret of the "hydrogen economy": it's a fossil fuel bait-and-switch. Renewable hydrogen from water is 2-3x as expensive as making it from natural gas†. It simply can't compete at the pump. People won't pay $9/gal equivalent when $3/gal is available right across the street (or across town, for that matter). † releasing just as much CO2 and fugitive methane, and still being wholly unsustainable
- kylebrown 12y agoThe question isn't, "what's the cheapest fuel at the moment?" The question is what's the cheapest carbon-neutral power source that could scale up to meet future global demand? Daniel Nocera has been arguing for years that using solar energy to split water into hydrogen (ie. the "artifical leaf") is the best strategy. Not even nuclear can scale to meet global demand[1]. But solar devices can be mass manufactured and distributed to the point-of-use (leap-frogging the need for massive infrastructure investment).[2] 1. http://web.mit.edu/professional/pdf/DGN_Daedalus.pdf http://web.mit.edu/professional/pdf/DGN_Daedalus.pdf > "Delivering this TW-value with nuclear energy would take the construction of eight thousand new nuclear-power plants. In other words, over the next forty-five years, we would have to construct one new nuclear-power plant every two days." 2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=12VPW-wS8yc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=12VPW-wS8yc
- darkmighty 12y agoIf a 'artificial leaf -> fuel cell -> power' is less efficient than 'photovoltaic cell -> battery -> power' and the cost is comparable, I don't see how your point is valid. Yes, we'll need a lot of energy, but note that that figure is for the whole world. I think it's doable. Hell, it's the best alternative so 'doability' doesn't really matter, but I guess we'll see how close we'll get (with nuclear+solar). Note that china alone has 200 nuclear plants in project right now [1]. [1] http://nextbigfuture.com/2015/02/china-could-build-200-nuclear-reactors.html http://nextbigfuture.com/2015/02/china-could-build-200-nucle...
- baddox 12y ago
- demultiplexer 12y ago(writer of the blog here): Eh... hm.... I really don't want to get into conspiracy theories here. To be honest, during the whole Formula Zero championship we got absolutely zero interest from any fossil fuel companies. I haven't posted a good picture of our kart yet, but our biggest sponsors? - Greenchoice (a grid energy provider with a focus on renewables) - DSM (plastics manufacturer, mostly because of our innovative use of composite body parts) - University of Delft - A whole bunch of mechanical suppliers (Rodac, Swagelok) - A whole bunch of electronics suppliers (Chroma, Cyner, Betronic) - A logistics company (van Kaathoven) Even the organization of Formula Zero, who had a pretty strong foothold in the fossil business through their renewables programmes, didn't get any attention from fossil fuel anything. And this barely changed when the competition dissolved into Formula Student. Even though this is one of the biggest student competitions in the world, it doesn't get nearly as much sponsorship from big oil as e.g. the Shell Ecomarathon. If they were really interested in getting enthusiastic, almost evangelistic people on the case to promote hydrogen as the next big thing, they would sponsor Formula Student.