12 ms·
Alibaba begins drone delivery trials in China
- aioprisan 12y agoI wonder if China's more lax regulations aren't a big win for Alibaba and improves their ability to go to market faster than Amazon will with drove delivery.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoDoesn't Amazon also do business in China? Couldn't they do the same thing, under the same regulations? (Unless what I'm hearing is true, and being a non-Chinese company is a big hindrance.)
- Phlarp 12y agoBeing a non-chinese company is a big hindrance.
- chriskanan 12y agoThat's probably correct, and it is similar to what Amazon is threatening to do because they are blocked from doing more drone delivery research outside in the US by the FAA: http://www.theverge.com/2014/12/9/7359409/amazon-slams-FAA-for-restrictive-drone-laws http://www.theverge.com/2014/12/9/7359409/amazon-slams-FAA-f...
- houshuang 12y agoThey have more lax regulations about some things, but apparently civil aviation is extremely tightly regulated, with most of the country set aside for military aviation (James Fallows has written about this). I'm sure they'd be wary of all their civilians runnings drones, filming things that shouldn't be seen, etc as well.
- howlingfantods 12y agoChinese airspace is highly regulated, especially in the cities mentioned. Theoretically, every single drone flight has to be reported and registered with multiple military and civil agencies. Enforcement is a different story.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoHow is the communist regime's governance in China "lax?" There's probably significant worry on the part of the CCP to keep drones controlled as they may see and record things that are politically inconvenient for this autocratic regime like political prisoners being abused or heavy-handed riot police action. Chinese aerospace laws, from a casual googling, seem to be very strict as well, and geared towards favoritism for their military. If drones take off anywhere, I imagine it will be in the most transparent countries, like the ultra-liberal Scandinavian democracies. I doubt drones are autocrat friendly for obvious reasons. I also imagine there's a nice middle ground between planes and rc hobbyists with defined paths and lots of rules that will eventually shake-out in many countries. Drone delivery just makes a lot of sense ,perhaps not so much with toothpaste, but with, say blood or organ delivery where a proper helicopter costs many times more and an accident is lethal. A drone accident is just a lost resource.
- CmonDev 12y agoReminds of me of this (copying service/product before "original" gets released): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LG_Prada#iPhone_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LG_Prada#iPhone_controversy
- zirkonit 12y agoA big win for BABA. I wonder what is the difference in efficiency between drone delivery and the old-fashioned truck logistics, taking into account speed, carbon emissions, human factor etc – I wouldn't be surprised if 5x or 10x is the factor.
- 6stringmerc 12y agoAre they using auto pilot or stick and yoke? Just curious, as the article mentions in the conclusion this isn't addressed. Recent regional news would indicate this may be a valid concern...well, at least from a cold-blooded investor standpoint (liability vs. profitability).
- kleer001 12y agoGreat question, fundamental really. If it's auto pilot what's to stop some malicious hacker from diverting the drones. If it's manual how much are the pilots getting paid and are they bonded? Seems like a huge can of worms to me.
- gatehouse 12y agoMy guess is that they are using human operators, and they probably have a retrieval squad on standby in case they lose contact. The regulatory issues I couldn't begin to guess. The goal at this stage would be to validate the business model and to collect flight data and get a sense of the operational requirements. If it works and they want to develop an autopilot, they will then have all the flight data, landing zone choices and issues, and trained operators to consult.
- 6stringmerc 12y agoNicely put; especially with respect to the business model. It almost seems that being competitive with traditional methods (bicycle, scooter, truck) almost will require more investment than can be expected as a return on capital. If human capital is very cheap in the markets for delivery (assumption) then establishing a break-even / profit point is genuinely of concern. Also, I can't help but recall seeing pictures of some cities with smog so bad I wonder if drone pilots would even be able to see at certain altitudes. Limited scenario, I know, but seems to correspond with population density. Dense population seems kind of the ideal market, so, yeah, just a thought.
- 6stringmerc 12y agoYeah, while normal aircraft seem to have plenty of regulations and training involved, the nature of the 'piloting' is of worthwhile concern. As was just the case over in Washington DC, even a weather event can have drastically unwanted consequences. It's one thing to say "Oops I crashed my drone on the White House lawn" and quite different when it comes to "Oops I crashed your X/Y/Z product into a group of children playing outside."
- forkandwait 12y agoNot to be a downer, but I think the whole drone delivery thing, at least for now, nothing but a media show. Worked great for Amazon, .... (Maybe the technology will evolve enough later to be cost effective, and tests are important on that path.)
- joshkpeterson 12y agoAgreed. We will see self driving car deliveries before we see drone deliveries.
- 6stringmerc 12y agoI'd be willing to bet we see self driving "moped/scooter" deliveries before self driving car deliveries simply because of the physics / liability implications. If reliable car systems can be developed, scaling down makes a lot of sense. Economically, it would be much easier to insure a moped than a car/truck, IMO.
- lucaspiller 12y agoHow does the delivery get from the moped on the street to my front door on the 5th floor? Maybe a Segway type thing would work better, it just needs to be able to press the lift buttons.
- jonathantm 12y ago[whyNotBoth.jpg](http://i.imgur.com/cpl3U.jpg http://i.imgur.com/cpl3U.jpg)
- marcosdumay 12y agoImagine a few of those things taking off from a self-driving car, doing the delivery, and getting back to it a hundred meters further. The cars have a problem, that they can't get the products to their final destination.
- esMazer 12y ago
- dharma1 12y agoFirst thoughts.. wonder what flight controller they're using? Ardupilot? And those props look pretty small for lifting much!
- muxxa 12y agoI've an efficiency fantasy of them piggybacking on the roofs of trucks going in the right direction in order to save fuel, then hopping off when the truck starts to head in a different direction. Techno parasitism.
- psb217 12y agoThis is actually how (some) couriers worked in Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash. They latched on to the back of passing cars/trucks with magnetic harpoons and hitched a free ride until they needed to head another way.
- pyre 12y agoIn a very "Back to the Future meets Cyberpunk" fashion.
- thisjepisje 12y agoDonald Duck also did this once.
- Nicholas_C 12y agoDammit, I hear about that book just about every week. I think I might finally cave and read it.
- neumann 12y agoThat's how I used to hitch lifts with trucks when doing bike messenger runs that took me down at the docks. Dumb and foolish I was.
- Derpdiherp 12y agoI'm still not convinced by delivery by drone. There's many problems that have yet to be solved, some have obvious solutions that are still none trivial to implement - others at least in my mind are very much an issue. So far as none trivial but solvable problems - there's going to have to be communication with all vendors operating delivery drones. Each drone will have to be aware of other drones by other companies and their flight-paths in the area and avoid collisions. The biggest problem that I can see is the customer and public themselves. What is to stop someone stealing drones? Or plain vandalism of them? Follow it in a car to it's destination and you know it's going to have to come low enough down for a quick grab. Otherwise if there's some controlled drop off point, air rifles or crossbows or other publicly available small projectile weapons.
- gutnor 12y agoThe cost of operating those is also questionable, especially in China. It is profitable to have pizza hand-delivered in the US/Europe where labor cost is high. In China, I wonder how that is even possible.
- lucaspiller 12y agoEverything is relative. If the salaries are 1/4 what they are in the US (as an example), then the cost of pizza will be relatively the same too. The percentage of that pizza that goes towards paying for the delivery is pretty much the same.
- puranjay 12y agoChinese cities are notoriously expensive. Cheap labor is limited to rural areas and smaller towns where most of the huge factories are located. The wages in a city like Shanghai, while obviously not comparable to a city like NYC, are high enough to warrant a drone solution.
- josu 12y ago>What is to stop someone stealing drones? Or plain vandalism of them? Cameras on drones and laws. Stealing a motorbike is relativelly simple, and it doesn't happen that often. Eventually the cops will start using drones, and the rest has already been told by South Park.
- auganov 12y agoThe drone in this stunt is operated by YuanTong, a parcel delivery company, not Alibaba. Also Alibaba does not (generally?) maintain distribution centers or hold inventory. So from a strategic perspective drones don't mean to Alibaba what they could to Amazon.
- pagnotta 12y agoYou are right, Alibaba doesn't even sell anything, they are like e-bay, just connect the buyer to the seller. As far as I know Alibaba also doesn't have a delivery service, ShungFeng Express is the most used delivery company. The chinese Amazon is YiHaoDian(360buy), they sell their own things and they have their own delivery operation.
- billconan 12y agoAlibaba owns http://www.tmall.com/ http://www.tmall.com/, which is amazon-like.
- mephi5t0 12y agoChinese started to stock up on heavy duty slingshots...
- web007 12y agoIt feels like Alibaba fell for Amazon's joke. I wonder how often this happens for companies, where a PR stunt or vaporware press release from company A convinces company B to expend resources to "beat them to market".
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThat's how we got StarCraft, and thus modern RTS games. Someone created a fake rendered demo at E3 conference and Blizzard fell for the trick; they believed the awesome thing they saw is real, and they worked their butts off to beat it.
- adrianpike 12y agoGot any citations on that? Warcraft, Dune II, etc. all came out way before Starcraft, and I'm pretty sure Blizzard was building SC pretty quick on the heels of WC2.
- mercer 12y agoI think it was a Gamasutra article, but I remember that it wasn't so much that they made Starcraft because of the demo, but rather that they made it a lot better after seeing this fake demo.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoNot Gamasutra, it came directly from one of StarCraft's developers blog. Per [0], StarCraft was supposed to be the "Warcraft in Space" it didn't turn out to be, and it was meant as a quick project to fill the publishing gap. [1] Explains the fake demo thing and its influence on StarCraft development in lenghth. A key quote: "At some point I talked with Mark and Patrick about how Dominion Storm knocked us on our heels, and they let us in on Ion Storm’s dirty little secret: the entire demo was a pre-rendered movie, and the people who showed the “demo” were just pretending to play the game! It would be an understatement to say that we were gobsmacked; we had been duped into a rebooting StarCraft, which ultimately led it to be considered “the defining game of its genre. It is the standard by which all real-time strategy games are judged” (GameSpot)." [0] - http://www.codeofhonor.com/blog/tough-times-on-the-road-to-starcraft http://www.codeofhonor.com/blog/tough-times-on-the-road-to-s... [1] - http://www.codeofhonor.com/blog/starcraft-orcs-in-space-go-down-in-flames http://www.codeofhonor.com/blog/starcraft-orcs-in-space-go-d...
- sly010 12y agoWhenever I see drone delivery, I always see quadrocopters. Aren't octocopters more safe (they can still fly with 7 rotors)? Intuitively they can also carry more load. It should be a very simple decision considering that the main objection against drones is safety.
- aroman 12y agoOne word: cost.
- Phlarp 12y agoQuads are an MVP in this sense-- I imagine commercial fleets of any type will be primarily 8 or 16 rotor machines. With just 4 rotors you are pretty much toast if any single component fails, with a well built and properly programmed 16 rotor craft you could theoretically stay up, or at least do a somewhat controlled landing on just 4, assuming opposing pairs.
- Nicholas_C 12y agoI thought quadcopter battery life was a prohibitive factor as well. From what I've read casually most have a battery life of 5 to 10 minutes.
- mod 12y agoHere's one over an hour and a half: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ScZ8zDsVvk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ScZ8zDsVvk It's definitely an issue, especially with payloads, but it's feasible to work around it. I think you can keep strapping on batteries for quite a while, too--the lift of some of these machines is incredible.
- thalesmello 12y agoHow big is Alibaba inside China? Just like Amazon in the USA, the go-to place for people to buy stuff online? Disclaimer: I live in Brazil, and I use Alibaba only to buy inexpensive stuff, so that's the picture I have of the company.
- officialjunk 12y agobigger. plus it does way more than just online retail: http://qz.com/206283/all-the-western-companies-youd-have-to-combine-to-get-something-like-alibaba/ http://qz.com/206283/all-the-western-companies-youd-have-to-...
- pagnotta 12y agoAlibaba is like MercadoLivre, they don't sell anything. They pretty dominant, in China they have TaoBao, an e-bay like, TianMao, also like e-bay, but more selected, more expensive to open a shop in it, and more brand-oriented than TaoBao, and finally they have Alibaba China, that is a B2B site, it means real wholesale. Oh, there is also Alipay, huge, it is the Paypal in China, people here use it even to pay 10 bucks to a friend when sharing a restaurant bill, a guy just taps his mobile phone and send the 10 bucks to his friend that is sitting just across from him, it's funny. There is also Alimama, advertising market. The thing is that in Brazil (I'm a brazilian too!) the e-commerce is still far from the level it has reached in China. My wife (chinese) buys everything in the internet, even noodles, milk, oil, soap,her clothes, her Lenovo laptop, her Iphone6, everything from the internet. She can't spent a day without buying at least a pair of socks from the internet. Brazil lacked a good payment system, but now with PagSeguro i guess things will improve. But there is also the expensive delivery in Brazil, in China it's ridiculously cheap, like you pay 30 Reais to send a 5 kilos pack 2000 Kilometer away to the other side of the country within 24 hours!!
- engendered 12y agoOne inevitable business area is in anti-drone system, particularly in drone-capture systems (e.g. intercept and actually "capture" the drone and its cargo for forensics, etc). If you made such a system right now, you'd immediately have orders from the White House, other high security locations, and eventually the wealthy, etc. And of course, stealing from delivery drones is going to become a thing.
- kailuowang 12y agoThe vast majority of the Chinese population with meaningful consumption power live in hire rise apartment buildings in the cities. So if you can't drop the package in a yard, how do you deliver by drone?
- zorked 12y agoWell, keep the windows open :)
- hyperion2010 12y agoThat lets the smog in.
- WillPostForFood 12y agoBalcony? Delivery box on the roof?
- harisamin 12y agoguess they beat Amazon to it :)
- iamleppert 12y agoIt's......really weird. Solving a problem that doesn't exist. Tea? Really? Asian cultures as so different and seem weird to me with this kind of technology related announcements.
- Panoramix 12y agoTea is an obvious choice to start with this. Huge demand, extremely lightweight, reasonably priced. Nothing "weird" about it.
- IanDrake 12y agoJust wait until the drone bumps into someone... https://www.google.com/search?q=quadcopter+injuries&num=50&espv=2&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=R4_SVJyCA5D9oAShroGICw&ved=0CAgQ_AUoAQ&biw=1280&bih=939 https://www.google.com/search?q=quadcopter+injuries&num=50&e...