14 ms·
Ross Ulbricht’s private journal shows Silk Road’s birth
- misiti3780 12y agoI never saw the number, what was DPR net worth when this all came to a crashing halt? I assume 10's of millions of dollars Also - was that money recovered by the FBI or could they not find his private keys?
- mikeyouse 12y agoI think the peak number in the spreadsheet for the value of SR was $104M -- I can't remember the source, but that figure stood out. edit for source: http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/wireStory/san-francisco-man-faces-ny-trial-tuesday-silk-28149351 http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/wireStory/san-francisco-man... The FBI had no problem finding his keys because he kept them in a folder called, "Keys" -- the kid was not an OpSec genius.. http://motherboard.vice.com/read/journal-and-chat-logs-from-ross-ulbrichts-laptop http://motherboard.vice.com/read/journal-and-chat-logs-from-...
- dghughes 12y agoIt sounds like a scene from that terrible TV show "What Would You Do?" I'd ignore it that's what I would do.
- hurin 12y agoIt all seems more amateurish with every additional piece of news coverage - why a single decryption key or even your day-to-day laptop as storage for that multitude of evidence! Surely you don't need 4 years of chat logs to run a site on a day to day basis.
- samteeeee 12y agoThis "diary" sounds like it was written by the FBI and planted on his computer...
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoI agree it does read that way. But the most reasonable explanation is that an arrogant narcissist (classic Dunning-Kruger) wrote it. The FBI did not write it.
- krapp 12y agoIt's surprising how much effort some on HN will go through to insist the case against Ulbricht must be completely invalid somehow. Several people in this thread have already assumed that because the FBI has his laptop, that must mean they stole it without a warrant. And now, if they found his diary, well, they must have planted it. You may have to come to terms with the possibility that the FBI actually has a case supported by evidence obtained through legal means.
- deciplex 12y agoDPR definitely broke the law, there's no question about that. A lot of us think it's an unjust law, but whatever. He may have also put out hits on people (though, curiously, he is not being charged for that). If that's the case then he's also a danger to society and really does belong in prison. But, it is immensely frustrating, even heartbreaking when you consider the cost in human lives, that given the choice between something like Silk Road and Mexican drug cartels, we as a society have apparently chosen Mexican drug cartels, and all the gut-wrenching bloodshed and destabilization they bring. I'm reserving judgement on Ulbricht the person, but what he did should not be illegal, for reasons ideological, practical, and humanitarian.
- krapp 12y agoI'm not entirely certain that black markets are the best way to facilitate a safe drug trade, but given a choice between Silk Road and more violent alternatives, Silk Road seems like the obvious better choice.
- deciplex 12y agoRight. Aside from, or in spite of, being a black market (by necessity), Silk Road was pretty benign compared to the alternatives. Surely Silk Road was taking some profits away from drug cartels. Probably not much, but a legal market would put them out of business. Now with Silk Road gone, all that trade is back under the umbrella of the cartels again, and the profits are theirs.
- ForHackernews 12y agoI feel like this applies here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hGo5bxWy21g#t=1m19s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hGo5bxWy21g#t=1m19s
- tall 12y agoThese are very intimate details of his life. The entries do not read like the entries of a psychopath, rather they paint a vivid picture of his life and the perfect basis for a movie.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoWhy would you have ever assumed that he was a psychopath?
- srdev 12y agoHe has been accused of putting out hits on people. That is at least somewhat psychopathic.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoIt's likely that when he was trying to put out the hit, as it appeared, he knew he was talking to the guy who was blackmailing him (who didn't know that he knew that) and he was trying to get him to believe that he was willing to kill to end the blackmailing. So he was never actually planning on killing anyone.
- srdev 12y agoThat is not likely at all. There is literally no evidence supporting that. It is simply an explanation that allows Ross's supporters to explain away the facts. The preponderance of evidence is that Ross is OK with murder.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoMaybe I want to believe too much. Regardless, I would say that there's a big difference between murdering someone who is blackmailing you and other kinds of murder, to the point that I wouldn't expect psychopathy from someone who was doing the former.
- 12y ago
- dchuk 12y agoI'm ignorant of the law here: This article starts off saying basically that the FBI agents distracted him long enough to steal his computer and image the hard drive...is that legal? I thought you needed a warrant or something for situations like this? Or is it illegal-but-it's-ok-it's-the-FBI-shhhh?
- gk1 12y agoFrom my understanding, they grabbed the computer just seconds before the arrest.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mgraczyk 12y agoAccording to the author, the FBI had a warrant for the laptop at the time.
- mattmanser 12y agoThey just mean they grabbed the laptop off the table before formally arresting him, i.e. they distracted him with a diversion of an argument, another agent grabbed the laptop from the table, and another agent physically detained him and arrested him. So he couldn't close the laptop and enact the encryption.
- reverend_gonzo 12y agoThey already had a warrant for his arrest, as well as for the computer. They just didn't want him to be able to turn off the computer, encrypt itself, and have it become inaccessible to them.
- heywire 12y agoImagine if you were the agent who grabbed the laptop, and you accidentally bumped the power button. Or if you were the forensic tech, and you accidentally triggered a reboot of some sort. No pressure!
- GCA10 12y ago
- ianamartin 12y agoThose journal entries don't really read like journal entries to me. The longer entries seem more like prepared and considered stories--stuff written for an audience other than yourself. I wonder if he was keeping those as notes for a book.
- creeble 12y agoA book he could never publish. Unless he got caught.
- gwern 12y agoPeople publish books about crimes all the time.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoWrite it and have it published when you die I suppose is the other solution.
- paulhebert 12y agoOr after the statute of limitations runs out, but I'm not sure how long that would be for the crimes he's accused of.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- denzquix 12y agoThe extracted quote at the top of the Forbes article here seems to indicate he was thinking along those lines: http://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahjeong/2015/01/22/the-dread-pirates-diary/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahjeong/2015/01/22/the-dread-... "I imagine that someday I may have a story written about my life, and it would be good to have a detailed account of it."
- jberryman 12y agoI think you'd expect that from someone on the spectrum of pathological narcissism or psychopathy, which is I think not unlikely given what we know about him.
- 666_howitzer 12y agoI think "Do things that don't scale" applies perfectly here, the part where Ross initially seeds the marketplace by selling magic mushrooms which he himself grew; may be this explain why new Darknet concepts failed to take off, not due to technological limitation or lack of market need. https://bitcoinmagazine.com/5285/torbroker-anonymous-finance-and-trust/ https://bitcoinmagazine.com/5285/torbroker-anonymous-finance... http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/11/18/meet-the-assassination-market-creator-whos-crowdfunding-murder-with-bitcoins/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/11/18/meet-th...
- tomphoolery 12y agoI just want to grab this kid and shake him while screaming "WHY WOULD YOU EVER WRITE THAT SHIT DOWN?!?" It's like he wanted to get caught...
- 300bps 12y agoIn a folder labeled "TorChat," Ulbricht's computer holds years' worth of chat logs. Felt the same way when reading this. Seriously - three years worth of chat logs? I don't think he wanted to get caught, he just felt that a clueless investigator could never decrypt his data, a clueless prosecutor could never understand let alone describe his operation and a clueless jury would never understand it. So far we know he underestimated the investigator and the prosecutor. We'll know soon if he misjudged his chances with a jury.
- krapp 12y agoNever assume you're the lone wolf in a world full of sheep....
- higherpurpose 12y agoSeriously, why would you do that? Hasn't he seen Boardwalk Empire? You get rid of the book and keep it all in your head! That, and it's also common sense.
- fizgig 12y ago
- oroup 12y agoThe snatching of the computer before you have a chance to lock it issue seems like something that could be solved with software. I'm imagining a "swatd" service that listens for loud noises (gunfire, flashbangs, shouting, etc) or observes the camera for sudden motion and locks the machine. I'm sure there'd be some false positives from movies and the like, but for guys like this, better safe than sorry.
- StoneTable 12y agoYou could use a laptop with some kind of sudden motion sensor and use that to lock the machine if the machine is moved.
- tacoman 12y agoThinkpads have this sensor that is meant to protect the hard drive from sudden shock. I bet it could be used for something like that. http://www.thinkwiki.org/wiki/Active_Protection_System http://www.thinkwiki.org/wiki/Active_Protection_System
- lsllc 12y agoA bit old, but Amit Singh did some interesting work with the sudden motion sensor on the Mac Powerbooks: http://osxbook.com/book/bonus/chapter10/sms/ http://osxbook.com/book/bonus/chapter10/sms/
- saboot 12y agoI think this could still be circumvented if this service was known. I guess you would intentionally not make this software available to anyone other than yourself. What about some sort of 5-10 minute prompt? You cant ask repeated questions due to surveillance, or you could be also requiring some hash value. Perhaps based on some permutation of the current time? It's weak but I can't think of something else you could consistently make a unique hash of using just your brain and some changing property of reality. Another idea, a heart rate or brain wave monitor connected via bluetooth. If it's disconnected, moved, or shifted it prompts a lock. If your heart rate increases or brain patterns are it also locks. The point is that it cant be removed from yourself, but others cannot stop you from locking it as well.
- Kenji 12y ago>"On that day, a male and female agent started an argument in San Francisco's Glen Park public library, to get Ulbricht's attention. As soon as Ulbricht was distracted, another agent grabbed the open computer" And that, ladies and gentlemen, is how you defeat crypto. How could you even defend yourself against such a thing? The only thing that comes to mind is never working in public on a computer.
- shittyanalogy 12y agoSomeone should invent a usb dongle that detects a nearby rfid chip that you keep on your keychain. As soon as that keychain is out of range, say 5 feet, the computer locks and encrypts itself. Integrate this into the computer and you wouldn't be able to tell who has one and who doesn't. Think you're being arrested with your computer open? Toss your keys.
- knodi123 12y agothat's called "security through obscurity". and sometimes it works great! Well, the first time. Of course, just like the shoe bomber changed airport security forever, an rfid keyfob like you suggested becoming commonplace, would just lead to the cops immediately tazing and tackling you, and treating every single motion of your arms as an attempt to destroy evidence.
- Pinatubo 12y agoTazing or tackling would probably take him out of RFID range.
- joezydeco 12y agoYou could be grabbed by agents and held there in your chair while another agent starts working on your files. My idea would be more of a proximity sensor that not only does the RFID-walkaway thing, but also locks the machine up if anyone additional to yourself approaches the device.
- chongli 12y ago
- alelefant 12y agoIn his diary regarding selling out of (illegal) mushrooms he writes: "...but at least now I was all digital, no physical risk anymore." Given the revelations from the last few years, how many of you would agree that carrying out an illegal plan like this is safer online?
- fdsary 12y agoReading this, and other recent events, gives me the realisation that we need the successor of UNIX. Nowadays, everything runs UNIX. My iPhone, Android, my Mac, my Ubuntu laptop, my Debian or BSD server, even my e-reader runs some Linux. On recent systems like iOS & Android applications run pretty isolated. You can't read and write the whole file system (afaik), and you need to have the user tap "yes" to use many system API's (like microphone, camera, etc). Using UNIX for a desktop computer, you don't really utilise the user system. Everything I run is either as my own user, or as root (when adding/remove packages or doing system updates). Otherwise, it's a singe user system. So any program I run can read all permanent data stored by other programs in my home directory. In effect, all programs have 100% access (except for changing system settings, but why would they care when there is only one user to own? When I encrypt my drive, I encrypt it all but also unlock it all when logging in. It's inherent to the system that my whole home dir is open when using (except for things I encrypt manually, like GPG mail or other user land things). Defaults matter. That's why Ross's documents were readable to the American government. I think we need a new OS to take over after UNIX. One that is built up of sandboxed modules. Where each program gets it's own file system, where they can do whatever they want. That file system is, if I wish, encrypted until I chose to open it. It could be encrypted with a public key system, so I can have many FS's opened with one key, or derive keys from a master key. These small systems could even be virtual machines, I can't say anything about the eventual overhead that would bring. In short, UNIX is bad because the file system is bound to my user, and anything my user runs has 100% access to everything else I run. The user system is nice, but not practical. If it was, Ross would be a free man.
- anonbanker 12y agoPosting as breadcrumbs so I can reference this post later.
- styles 12y agoIn theory LXC could do this. It needs to be tested more and clearly has security issues right now.