7 ms·
WhatsApp and Snapchat could be banned under new surveillance plans
- api 12y agoWhatsApp being banned under these plans would be doubly hilarious, since its encryption is a joke. There's a single hard-coded AES key for everyone. I'm sure SnapChat isn't much better.
- xnyhps 12y agoThe static AES key is for local log storage. This is about encrypted communications. They are working together with Open WhisperSystems to bring the e2e-encrypted TextSecure protocol to Whatsapp: https://whispersystems.org/blog/whatsapp/ https://whispersystems.org/blog/whatsapp/
- higherpurpose 12y agoLet's start being very cautious about that. Because 1) Whatsapp has never said publicly they are doing that 2) Now they might backtrack and say they never intended to add E2E encryption 3) Without a privacy policy change as well, the encryption change may be meaningless, since they'd give themselves permission to modify it whenever they wish.
- blfr 12y agoPrivacy policy or some other ToS-like document should not matter to properly implemented technical security measures. That's the whole point.
- higherpurpose 12y agoAnd how would you know they didn't rip out the new system to replace it with the old one in one update? According to Moxie, the Android version already has the TextSecure built into it, yet I see absolutely no difference from the old Whatsapp.
- nickik 12y agoHave you actually listend to the network traffic? It used to be plaintext, so its easy to check, if there is some encryption going on. If there is encryption, then its likly its the one interduced by the TextSecure people. Why should it be diffrent? What did you expect to change? Thats the good thing about good crypto, the user does not even know its there. I mean sure, I would like to be able to validate the other persons fingerprint and discover as soon as we are communicating diffrently, but relasticlly, what whatsapp did is the biggest jump in crypto usage since https.
- soperj 12y agoI don't know why people wouldn't just use TextSecure instead? Then you actually know.
- scott_karana 12y agoLack of an iOS app, just maybe?
- nickik 12y agoIf thats the biggest barrior, im happy.
- woah 12y agonetwork effects? UX? Come on, how can you even ask that question?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Eye_of_Mordor 12y agoStopped reading after if he wins the next election
- chopin 12y agoI am all for Camerons plans. It will put a big red sign on everything: "The government is snooping on you!". Hopefully they ban SSL as well.
- yarper 12y agoPlease watch "Black Mirror" on channel 4. If you haven't seen it I think you'll probably enjoy it.
- yarper 12y agoFor anyone reading outside the UK, the chances of him winning the next election are slim to none at all.
- ubersync 12y agoCan you elaborate a little why do you think so?
- opless 12y agoWell technically he didn't even win the last election.
- robin_reala 12y agoTechnically a Prime Minister doesn’t win an election at all: people vote for a party.
- opless 12y agoWell done. I enjoy being out pedanted. Have an upvote.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Technically a Prime Minister doesn’t win an election at all: people vote for a party. In most parliamentary systems, the Head of State is compelled to invite the party with the largest representation in parliament to form a government, and that party then proposes a government which is then subject to a confirmation election in the parliament, which it must win in order to be the government. So, generally, Prime Ministers win an election among members of parliament, who are themselves elected by the public (whether or individually or by party name depends on the particular parliamentary electoral system -- the UK system, as I understand, uses first-past-the-post with candidate names and parties on the ballot, much like most US elections -- while some systems use party-list-proportional where seats are allocated proportionally to the number of votes cast for parties, and there are various hybrid and other systems in use, as well.) This is not entirely unlike US Presidents, who are also elected indirectly by presidential electors who are in turn elected by the public, however, it does differ in that the electors in the UK are also legislators rather than being elected solely as electors. Its kind of like if, in the US, members of Congress elected the President. (Which, in fact, can happen in the US system, but only if the Congressional count of the vote by the electors doesn't give a majority for any candidate.)
- fpp 12y agoIt is appalling what currently is happening in the aftermath of the crazy Paris attacks. Some of the biggest offenders of the Freedom of Press are now not battling for the protection of the press, but for being seen by the media as one of the mourners in the first row of the Paris events on the weekend (for a better overview of that see https://storify.com/tometty/staunch-defenders-of-free-press-attend-solidarity https://storify.com/tometty/staunch-defenders-of-free-press-...) Most of these providing their "condolences" have been constantly mocked by CH, have tried to criminalize the work of CH in the past (e.g. German politicians), and are now shamelessly exploiting media attention and believe again that there will be no better time to even further crush the rights of European citizens, some with measures (e.g. further extending telco data retention, dragnet snooping in the UK & Germany) that latest with the events in Paris should again been demonstrated as not effective to protect from such attacks (both measures were already in place and broadly used in France before the attacks). We can only hope that Cameron's statement in the article linked is solely a political one, fishing for voters in the far right & UKIP spectrum. Otherwise this might be another nail in the coffin of a growing and successful UK Internet industry. Some additional info: Noam Chomsky on the aftermath / events in Paris - http://www.telesurtv.net/english/opinion/We-Are-All---Fill-in-the-Blank-20150110-0021.html http://www.telesurtv.net/english/opinion/We-Are-All---Fill-i... Reporters sans Frontieres / Reporters without Borders: http://en.rsf.org/rwb-condemns-presence-of-predators-11-01-2015,47472.html http://en.rsf.org/rwb-condemns-presence-of-predators-11-01-2...
- nickik 12y agoThis is kind of funny, in a sad way. I mean in the USA the NSA is still saying that the never, never spy on private information, maybe sometimes, in rare cases, on non americans. While in england they are all like, "No more spying in secret, time to actually take your rights away". The english are hardcore, the NSA has more freedom in england than in the US. Sad, but funny.
- Fuxy 12y agoI'm not very involved in politics but it looks like I need to go voting to make sure he doesn't get in.
- remarkEon 12y ago[1] is probably the best analysis of the field. Last week on BBC Question Time, the folks on the panel and in the audience all seemed very hostile to limits on freedom of speech - though they noted that those rights are much more robust in the US. Perhaps this is Cameron's attempt to make sure that UKIP doesn't steal away some Conservative votes. UKIP seems most hostile to immigrants, from what I can tell. (I don't live in the UK, so perhaps someone can correct/expand). [1] http://may2015.com/ http://may2015.com/
- fidotron 12y agoThere appears to be absolutely no proof that such laws would help with their stated purpose. In the cases of Ottawa, Sydney, and now Paris, the perpetrators of their respective nonsense were already well known to authorities, yet this apparently presented no obstacle to them whatsoever.
- jryle70 12y agoAre you sure there have been no attempts that were disrupted because the communication was intercepted? those that haven't been disclosed to the public? Also, just because the suspects in the cases you mentioned were well known to the authority doesn't mean their communication was monitored 24/7. We simply don't know.
- lmm 12y ago> Are you sure there have been no attempts that were disrupted because the communication was intercepted? those that haven't been disclosed to the public? You think politicians would stay quiet about them if there were?
- idlemind 12y agoI think they are, foolishly, staying quiet on some recent victories. They've said as much. It could actually be to their benefit to release more about some of the cases where they don't reveal more about "methods" than the public already knows. But they probably won't, because it goes against their culture of secrecy, they'd rather pretend Snowden never happened.
- undersuit 12y agoTheir victories are few and far between when you weed out false flag and entrapment cases, and also look at all the attacks that actually happened at the same time. With all the press Snowden got, we in the US got no confirmation of any prevented terrorist attacks even though the media and security agencies kept alluding to the dozens they prevented in defense of their spying
- tomjen3 12y ago>The Prime Minister said today that he would stop the use of methods of communication that cannot be read by the security services even if they have a warrant. So now the British wants to outlaw math.
- dxbydt 12y agomaths[1], not math. [1] http://www.word-detective.com/2011/05/math-vs-maths/ http://www.word-detective.com/2011/05/math-vs-maths/
- rickjr85 12y agoThis is ridiculous, in the fact that, even if they ban well known encrypted chat apps. Terrorist and outlaws could just create their own? I have a phone, I am a developer, I can do whatever I want with it at that point, outlawing apps won't stop outlaws from writing illegal apps with encryption.
- AdeptusAquinas 12y agoThis is what I have never understood. Granted, my partner works in law enforcement and she says a good portion of criminals are quite dumb (willing to discuss smuggling plans in a public facebook profile, for example) but its not like creating a encrypted messaging system has a high barrier of entry. You could create such using C# Framework libraries in an afternoon! Hell, contract the work out anonymously on Elance for a $100 or so, and you'll be immune to the security services by the end of the day.
- DanBC 12y agoI'd love to see the cryptographic code that people get from elance for $100. I'd especiallu like to see a quick audit of that code.
- TillE 12y agoYou could do pretty well just by ripping off some C# RSA example code. Find a moderately competent programmer, pay them for 2-5 hours of work...sure, why not. Just stick to the high-level APIs and you should be fine. But realistically, nobody will be able to shut down the FOSS tools that already exist. Use Tor or VPNs if necessary in countries with internet censorship.
- AdeptusAquinas 12y agoYou would be surprised, I think. The RSA/AES stuff in C#'s System.Security.Cryptography library is pretty robust and easy to use. Copy/Pasting from MSDN will get you quite far.
- virtuabhi 12y agoUK is just getting worse for internet freedom each year. The country has already curtailed free speech with its libel laws [1,2], internet censorship [3], and newspaper targeting [4]. I wonder if people of UK are like frog in boiling water? Do they not realize that their rights are being removed with each passing law? I hope at least tech companies will move out of UK, prompting the UK government to ponder over its actions. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Chiropractic_Association_v_Singh http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Chiropractic_Associatio... [2] No one can make fun of Her Royal Majesty, and UK prime minister was on the parade showing solidarity with dead French satirists [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_the_United_Kingdom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_the_Unit... [4] http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/britain-targets-guardian-newspaper-over-intelligence-leaks-related-to-edward-snowden/2013/11/29/1ec3d9c0-581e-11e3-bdbf-097ab2a3dc2b_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/britain-targets-g...
- fpp 12y agoFriedrich Goltz's boiling frog experiment with the slow temperature increase to boiling only worked after he removed the brains of the frogs - all others actually jumped out above 25C+ - when you watch various UK TV shows one can certainly assume that at least some of the actors / watchers must have had their brains removed to be able to endure this. I'm not sure if that applies to the majority of the population (yet) ;-)
- Jimmed 12y ago> I'm not sure if that applies to the majority of the population (yet) Are we living in the same country?
- lotsofmangos 12y ago[2] You saying no-one makes fun of Liz? Our libel laws are hideous, but making fun of the queen or other royals is something that regularly occurs in UK media. And given the UK royals, to ban taking the piss out of them would be blatant entrapment.
- placebo 12y agoWhy stop there? I suggest making laws that will enforce strict curfews, limitations on areas of travel and also wearing mandatory unremovable collars that will enable security forces to immediately neutralise any citizen in case they turn out to be a terrorist. I could say something about how this is exactly how terrorism wins, but that's not really the case. This is just how we lose. These ideas of sweeping restrictions could be due to the same incompetent thinking that caused the problem in the first place, or might be a cynical leveraging of the situation to quench an unending thirst for more control and power, but whatever the reason, this is the kind of thinking that threatens the foundations on which free societies are built upon.
- AdeptusAquinas 12y agoI was thinking these sort of policies are more representative of how democracy and security services are constructed: Politicians just want to show they are doing something, so swipe at an easy target. Security services ask for more information gathering tools for the same reason corporations try to maximise their profit: its their job to do so. It's not going to change until people truly appreciate the trade-off of freedom vs. security, which probably wont happen until the majority really feel the pinch of losing the former.
- placebo 12y agoYou are right, but just that as a society we should stay vigilant in detecting and stopping companies that make profits using ways that are detrimental to society, the same should apply to politicians and security forces. There are checks and balances for that in a modern society, but they can't be watertight. One can only hope that society will feel the "pinch" (as you called it) early enough.
- AdeptusAquinas 12y agoI guess where my metaphor breaks down is that as you said Corporations are constrained from doing things detrimental to society (at least in theory), and the way we constrain them is via law. Security services and politicians are harder to fix, given they make the laws. The only true influence on their behaviour is public opinion.
- eterm 12y agoHe said: “In our country, do we want to allow a means of communication between people which […] we cannot read?” Yes, we do. It's awful that he can say we don't want something that would be protected in the US.
- idlemind 12y agoI can't tell whether this is hubris, technical naïveté or just an attempt to garner votes. Possibly all three. But let's assume they are proposing a ban on communications methods that cannot be lawfully intercepted (that's certainly how Cameron words it). Firstly, we know it's technically infeasible, secondly it would have a serious chilling effect on UK Internet companies and the digital economy, and thirdly it would actually take very popular apps and tools from young voters hands. So does he really think people will be panicked enough by the threat of terrorism to vote for it?
- 7952 12y agoIt is a wonderful distraction considering the massive budget cuts in the police force. The Met are facing 1.4bn budget cuts. The Border Agency had to cut its budget by 23%. The military are under constant pressure to cut staff and spend less money. Maybe he gives away civil liberties because it doesn't cost him anything.
- switch007 12y agoI'm so god damn sick of this. An attack happens, and politicians line up with pre-written, draconian and/or rushed and reactive legislation to further infringe upon our rights. It's been particularly noticeable since 2001. I'm so glad HN exists because I sometimes I feel I'm the only one who notices it.
- rurban 12y agoYou know that this is one of the oldest constitutional laws. Based on the french constitution, the 4th amendment in the US, and the Art. 10 Abs. 1 Grundgesetz in Germany, and everywhere else. And even if the UK has no written constitution, they signed the Human Rights Act 1998 incorporated the European Convention on Human Rights (the “Convention”) into UK law. Article 8(1) of the Convention provides that “everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home and his correspondence.” See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_in_English_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_in_English_law for more. Obama does not care a shit about his constitution anymore, and consequently his poodle in the UK neither. So they should just waive the Human Rights Act, and consequently leave the European Union. We pay enough for their cows anyway, and they are way above their tolerable abuses of civil freedom anyway.
- known 12y agoTechnology cannot solve Social imbalances.