5 ms·
Barf bags on airplanes: Are rates of airsickness declining?
- Yizahi 12y agoThe only reason I see for declining of actual motion sickness cases is widespread availability of super effective drugs that block all symptoms. When you know that you suffer motion sickness you'll just carry some pills in travel and never even look like a person susceptible to it.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "super effective drugs" Any recommendations? I've 'grown out' of most of my motion sickness over the years but boats still get me bad. I can just about make 60 mins without being sick and then I feel awful for the next several hours. I've tried lots of stuff but most of it doesn't seem to help.
- Scoundreller 12y agoThis is not a recommendation on my part, just quoting some evidence for scopolamine patches: "TTS-S has proved to be significantly superior to placebo in reducing the incidence and severity of motion sickness by 60-80%. It was more effective than oral meclizine or cinnarizine, similar to oral scopolamine 0.6 mg or promethazine plus ephedrine, and the same as or superior to dimenhydrinate." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16719539 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16719539
- k-mcgrady 12y agoThanks. Pretty sure oral meclizine is what I would normally take so I'll have to check out scopolamine patches.
- ghaff 12y agoMaybe. Dimenhydrinate (Dramamine) has been around forever and is still one of the more effective things you can take. I sometimes use it in boats and it works pretty well though it makes me really drowsy. (I've never tried the patches.) You definitely don't see the bags as much as you used to. I've noticed their absence myself. I suspect it has to do with generally bigger and more stable jets and better routing around turbulence. I do wonder though how much also had to do with the bags being one of the things airlines just stuck in the seatbacks out of long habit going back to the days when there were more props and small jets. Many airlines have cut back on a lot of stuff they used to routinely pass out like blankets and pillows.
- Renaud 12y agoI don't have proof to back this up, but I strongly suspect that the fact that all flights are now exclusively non-smoking has had a big influence on that decline. I remember as a child how the smell of cigarette, coupled with the decrease sense of equilibrium that you can experience in a plane, would easily cause nausea.
- gojomo 12y agoSecondhand smoke also upsets my stomach, so I'd agree this could be a major factor. It's amazing to think smoking used to be so common in the confined plane cabin: every plane like those glass-encased "smoking areas" remaining in many airports! Moderated drinking habits probably also play a role: when flying was rarer, and a rougher ride, throwing back excessive drinks before/during/between flights may have been a bigger part of the adventure – then also boosting airsickness rates.
- micheljansen 12y agoGood point, apparently this is the case [1]. I had horrible car sickness as a child, on both trains and cars and I always thought I just grew out of it as I got older. A few weeks ago I was in the passenger seat of a heavy smoker's car and felt as sick as ever. Never realised the link. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/21036110/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/21036110/
- pm90 12y agoInteresting. By the time I was born, all flights were non-smoking, so I've never ever seen anyone smoke on flights.
- joezydeco 12y agoMy wife has flown overseas every year to Europe (since she was a newborn) to visit family. She got violently airsick every single flight and nobody could figure out why. Then when the international flights went non-smoking, the nausea stopped. She's 100% convinced it was the smoke. Even sitting in the "non-smoking area" got a constant wave of second-hand smoke that wafted around.
- lordbusiness 12y ago
- droidist2 12y agoA lot depends on the type of plane. A little DC-9 would have made more people sick than a 767. As we're flying more we ride more in larger aircraft and on direct flights so there are less rides in little puddle jumpers.
- liberty53 12y agoMuch better (more stable) auto pilots and flight management systems?
- raverbashing 12y agoProbably both, but autopilot can't "shake off" turbulence However, it can fly more direct routes and do smoother curves. I remember the last time I felt really bad was in an AA Super-80, doing a lot of curves to reach an airport. Bigger planes (737s/A320) were not so bad
- cafard 12y agoIndeed. The heaviest demand for bags I've ever seen was on a puddle jumper between Philadelphia and Washington, on a windy spring day.
- jackcarter 12y agoHa, perfect timing. Yesterday the guy next to me threw up in his hands on takeoff. He hadn't looked for a bag; I expect he thought he could ride it out. I handed him mine. I can't imagine the bags are a significant cost to airlines -- everyone's heard of the 'American Airline olive,' but those were actually being consumed every flight. Compare that to the PR from customers smelling vomit for hours because there was no bag.
- digital-rubber 12y agoI can't imagine that either. What i can imagine is that time spend on cleaning a single barf spot probably exceeds the costs of paper bags. Then again, who says everybody managed to put everything neatly in the bags and no cleaning afterwards is required. Need some proper stats to calculate this i guess.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoI hadn't heard of the "AA olive" - https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-American-Airlines-saved-40-000-in-1987-by-eliminating-one-olive-from-each-salad-served-in-first-class https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-American-Airlines-save... gives the gist.
- chiph 12y agoAsk me in a couple of days. Going to be taking a small regional jet through the east coast thunderstorms. Not looking forward to this.