6 ms·
Reaction to the Sony Hack Is 'Beyond the Realm of Stupid'
- oplint 12y ago"Terrorist" is probably the most destructive word in modern American vernacular. It means both anything and nothing; its only purpose is to (ironically) evoke fear in the listener and handwave away people and ideas you don't like with no evidence and no grounds for further discussion. Forget motives and social constructs. Forget thinking about real solutions. Are they "cyberterrorists"? Are we being "terrorized"? The answer to the latter question is of course yes, but not by the "terrorists" but by sensationalist articles like this.
- scintill76 12y agoI also "love" how the only thing scarier than a terrorist, is a cyberterrorist.
- Dylan16807 12y agoA terrorist is someone who threatens/harms bystanders for a political goal, more or less. Hacking Sony is not an act of terrorism, threatening theaters with violence is.
- nishonia 12y agoThat is far too broad a definition - and still not completely correct. Terrorism falls within the spectrum of warfare, it isn't as simple as "Well I feel terrorized, so my tormentor must be a terrorist!" Also, the emotional state of terror - the word has been severely corrupted. The British were unquestionably terrorized by the German dive bombers, fitted with signature sirens, in WWII. That was clearly a terror campaign, because intent was expressed and capability demonstrated. This whole movie thing, not so much.
- Dylan16807 12y agoDepends on what exactly the threats were here. If you make a credible bomb threat against taking particular actions that can be terrorism. Yes the definition is a bit broad. I thought about excluding nation states but that's not quite right either. Perhaps I could argue that the British were not bystanders in your example.
- nishonia 12y agoOk, so what makes a threat credible enough to instill terror? Seriously, terror. I'm not talking about a level of concern that causes people to modify their behavior around media consumption, I'm talking about the level of terror that breaks your enemy's will to fight. Again, terrorism falls within the spectrum of warfare - not criminal behavior. I'd argue that the identity and reputation of the aggressor needs to be established for a bomb threat to be considered terroristic. Even the CIA, an entity that would benefit from a loose definition of terrorist, refuses to classify a group as "terrorist" unless they have expressed intent and demonstrated capability. It wouldn't make any sense to exempt states from the list of potential terrorist actors - because the state invented terrorism. As I said, spectrum of warfare. Now intelligent people can disagree about the ability of individuals to declare war... but then terrorism is restricted to the state. I hope you've misunderstood my WWII example, because otherwise you've just argued that civilian children, elderly and infirm were somehow not bystanders while huddled in bomb shelters. My history isn't super strong, but I don't think anybody has ever argued that the British engaged in total war - which would be necessary for children to be classified as anything but bystanders.
- Dylan16807 12y agoI guess you and I have completely different definitions of terrorism. I wouldn't say that actual terror is necessary. Just fear. And I have exactly the opposite reaction about warfare. I think that the terror of proper war is on an entirely different level, in most ways worse, in fewer ways not as bad. Someone being attacked in a war can't give in to a political threat and make the danger go away. It's entirely different. A state can perform terrorism but it's not by dropping bombs on every city they can reach. Civilians in a time of war aren't exactly targets but they're not 100% innocent either. It's complicated. Children don't make choices but they are affected by the choices of their guardians. It would be nice to say that any civilian casualties in war are unacceptable but that's clearly not how humans work.
- gtremper 12y ago"terrorist" seems to be the modern equivalent of "communist" during the cold war.
- leeoniya 12y agoAs noted elsewhere, Sony is a Japanese corp. The release - in any country - under their watch can cause retaliation against Japan and sour already touchy relations between them and North Korea, not to mention the physical proximity, smaller country size, etc.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoEh. This misses a couple of things. One, the FBI told the theater chains that if they screen the movie, they could be targets for the hackers. I'm pretty doubtful that theater chains have good security, and they probably know it. They also don't want their internal emails spread all over the media and their business disrupted. As no company does. So I can't blame them once the FBI has scaremongered them. Two, once the theaters said they won't screen it, Sony would lose money releasing it. It's not free to send out prints and continue advertising. If they have no hope to make money, why lose more money? And why piss off the hackers further? Where's the win? It's nice to sit back and say Sony should release it, but honestly, what's in it for them at this point?
- djrogers 12y agoIt was still initially Sony's call to let the theaters out of their contractural obligation to air it. Once they all took them up on the free pass, yes - canceling the release may have been the sensible move.
- spinlock 12y agoIs there an obligation to show a movie on the theaters part? I always assumed they paid for the right to show a film but were independent in their opperations.
- CaptainZapp 12y agoI think that's where bundling comes in. You want to show the new Hunger Games movie in your theaters? Then you also have to show those duds for so and so long.
- gojomo 12y agoThis interviewee's criticism is not narrowly focused against Sony, but the entire reaction: theater chains, Sony, media, the American psyche, a "lose our shit" mentality. It would take a wider cultural consensus to respond in solidarity: theaters don't cave, studios don't cave, moviegoers don't cave, media doesn't feed panics, the legal system doesn't require cowering as a liability issue. We're not there yet... but maybe we can get there, with discussion and experience.
- pakled_engineer 12y agoIndia and Pakistan when various groups threaten to bomb theatres they delay the film release a few months then show it anyway. Sony is going to do the same, then shill it as a must watch in order thwart glorious victory of comrade jong-un.
- nemothekid 12y agoNot sure I take the reductionist view point of calling the hacking "just a Bond script release". Allegedly the hackers stole over 300TB of data, and we have already seen them mountains of private information such as SSNs. If those SSNs were then sold/used for fraud (causing even more damage), and that revenue used to by weapons, could we call it a terrorist act then?
- arghnoname 12y agoNo. If I rob a bank it is not a terrorist act. If I use the money to make a dirty bomb and commit a terrorist act with said bomb, that's a terrorist act, not the initial robbery.
- paulhauggis 12y agoIt's a terrorist act to threaten movie theaters with 9/11 style attacks for showing a movie and this is exactly what the hackers are doing.
- yourad_io 12y agoA terrorist threat and a terrorist act are easily distinguished: "Did shit blow up? Then It was an act." Threats are not acts, despite what any legal framework may say.
- connie_lingus 12y agosony should just release the damned thing on christmas day on netflix and let the whole world deal with it at the same time.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- skuhn 12y agoIt continues to baffle me that so many people are assigning substantial blame to Sony. Yes, their executives were uncouth in their private e-mails. However, these e-mails were literally stolen from them and made available publicly in a campaign designed to embarrass them after they refused to cave to initial blackmail demands. There is no Pentagon Papers conspiracy here that the press needed to expose for the public good -- they're just airing dirty laundry and furthering the ends of criminals. Yes, Sony had lax computer security and they made it a lot easier than it should have been to abscond with internal data. However, it is so much harder to protect against a targeted attack and (I don't believe) the method of the attack has been disclosed, if it is even completely understood yet. They should be ashamed and apologetic about their security practices, but that doesn't mean they as much as published this information themselves. Yes, The Interview doesn't look particularly great, and I didn't plan to see it. Yet it should absolutely be allowed to exist and to be publicly released. It is a comedy. It is not "an act of war" as Sony's attackers claim. The existence of this film did not harm real people, that is entirely a result of the extreme overreaction by the people behind these attacks. I absolutely think that Sony is being blamed for their victimization, and I don't agree with it. It would be terrible to be in their position, and I don't think any company who operates within the laws of their country should be subject to any of: 1. A loss of over $40 million 2. A smear campaign using their own stolen, private correspondence 3. Release or misuse of all manner of employee personal information, SSNs, etc. 4. And all of the other things they're dealing with right now If you place value in free speech, privacy rights and the arts I don't see how you can side against Sony here. I don't care if it's "terrorism" or not, the people involved in these attacks are certainly criminals.
- joeyh 12y ago"operates within the laws of their country" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_rootkit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_rootkit Doesn't excuse others illegal activities, but it certianly makes it easier to feel a certian level of schadenfreude in this case.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat was a decade ago, they paid out several million to settle the matter, and the actual impact of it was virtually nil. The endless harping on this transgression has reached the point of being posturing rather than substantive criticism.
- byerley 12y agoThe North Korea link really confuses me. How is a small country like North Korea capable of mounting such a sophisticated attack when they aren't even teaching their computer students about the Internet? - http://cnnpressroom.blogs.cnn.com/2014/12/07/suki-kims-experience-in-north-korea-its-the-most-horrific-place-to-me-in-the-world/ http://cnnpressroom.blogs.cnn.com/2014/12/07/suki-kims-exper... Even if they specifically trained a hacking group, the talent pool would be tiny.
- downandout 12y agoThis is pretty ridiculous. Want to clear out an entire NFL playoff game in a few weeks? Tweet out a vague threat against the game about 24 hours prior. Want several million dollars? Send emails to about 20,000 bars and restaurants demanding $5K in Bitcoins or their business will be blown to bits. The problem isn't that Sony capitulated to a threat. It's that they capitulated to a nonsensical threat. They gave credence to every threat. Earlier in the day I was somewhat neutral on this, but now that I've had a chance to consider it I think that Sony is actually endangering our national security with this move. This is the first time in recent memory that America has been seen as caving to terrorist demands, and it can only create more disasters.
- dalek_cannes 12y agoSony is Japanese.
- ssalazar 12y agoSony Pictures Entertainment, who produced and marketed this movie, is based in the US (Hollywood) and run by Americans. In all likelihood this decision comes from them.
- rjvir 12y agoIt's not an empty threat. They completely compromised Sony's servers. Who knows what they haven't leaked yet, or what they are capable of. The movie theaters decided to not show the movie because they couldn't implement a nationwide security system in every one of their theaters in 2 weeks. Since there is 0 security at movie theaters, I as a moviegoer would be extremely scared to go to watch this movie in it's opening week.
- tdicola 12y ago> I as a moviegoer would be extremely scared to go to watch this movie in it's opening week. Sadly, that's exactly the fear the hackers want you to have. You have much higher odds being hurt or killed in a car accident on the drive to the theater than from some potential terrorist act.
- zaroth 12y agoI wonder if in refusing to show the movie, are the theaters really concerned about the physical threat, or the cyber threat? The physical threat is certainly the headline, and provides an easy out for theaters who might actually be more concerned about their networks. The cyber threat is certainly the more credible of the two. Hackers who owned Sony so completely could now turn their focus to AMC, Regal, Cinemark, and Carmike. Aside from looting data stores, they could potentially shutdown ticketing systems, hack customer databases, steal credit cards... We know a well-funded persistent targeted attack is guaranteed to succeed against these kinds of targets. I'm not really sure what's even holding back the tides of cyber-warfare beyond perhaps governments' inefficiency at organizing the necessary task forces. Fear of enforcement or retaliation certainly isn't the gating factor on the teams who are perpetrating these hacks. The whole thing seems beyond absurd from one angle, and at the same time portends an escalating cyberwar which will not be nearly as fun to watch as The Interview.
- marcosdumay 12y ago> I wonder if in refusing to show the movie, are the theaters really concerned about the physical threat, or the cyber threat? More likely, they are concerned about the economic threat. It's a great excuse to not lose exibition rooms empty with a bad movie, and yet evade any kind punishment by Sony.
- pdkl95 12y agohttp://www.poetryloverspage.com/poets/kipling/dane_geld.html http://www.poetryloverspage.com/poets/kipling/dane_geld.html It is always a temptation to an armed and agile nation To call upon a neighbour and to say: -- "We invaded you last night--we are quite prepared to fight, Unless you pay us cash to go away." [...] "We never pay any-one Dane-geld, No matter how trifling the cost; For the end of that game is oppression and shame, And the nation that pays it is lost!"
- afarrell 12y agoKipling may be an imperialist, but he is an honest one, and certainly correct about some fundamental ugly truths of international relations.
- efnx 12y agoI want to watch this movie more now so I hope I can at least find the version that these hackers have released. I'd rather pay and sit in th theater but one way or another.
- gojomo 12y agoI've not yet seen any clear, convincing reporting of why anyone would believe that the theater-threat comes from the same person/persons who compromised Sony's servers/network. The NYT mentioned an email sent to multiple media outlets – but did that email somehow prove inside knowledge of the hacks? Perhaps, by revealing fresh info or using a cryptographic signature associated with earlier releases or messages left behind on Sony's machine's? If so, no reports have said so. Another site mentioned a Pastebin source for the threat, which was accompanied with links to other Sony emails. But were those new, unique emails that could have only come from the hacker(s)? And which was the first threat source – an email or a Pastebin? These are basic questions of apparent provenance that should be answered in any coverage of internet-delivered threats.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sandstrom 12y agoNow and then I discover apparently longer-running threads in the news that I've completely missed. Sometimes I feel embarrassed that I've missed them, but mostly I'm just happy that I have. This one seems like the latter. This essay is good (although I don't feel as strongly about it as the author). http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/hatethenews http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/hatethenews (I still like journalists and news, I just wish it would be more long-term, less 'real-time')
- scelerat 12y agoSony hasn't capitulated. This is PR gold. Just wait for them to change their minds on down the line. The pent-up demand will drive sales far beyond anything that would have happened had they ignored the "threat."
- Animats 12y agoBruce Schneier: "Someone killed 12 people and shot another 70 people at the opening night of Batman: The Dark Knight [Rises]. They kept that movie in the theaters." But that Batman movie was a good movie. (OK, not the best of the franchise, but still OK). The plot of The Interview is "a celebrity journalist and his producer land an interview with Kim Jong-un and are instructed by the CIA to assassinate him." That sounds like a good action-adventure movie. But it was made as a comedy. Dumb. Then the plan was to release it on Christmas Day, usually a day for take-the-kids movies. Dumber. Sony may be using this as an excuse to escape from a turkey of a movie. Of course, now we all have to see it. Probably on Netflix; it's not worth a trip to a theater. This whole affair is in the realm of stupid, on all sides.
- btbuildem 12y agoYeah pretty much the only way for Sony to salvage the situation is to release this p.o.s. as a torrent..
- joshstrange 12y agoPlease remind me again why we spend BILLIONS on Intel, let them trample our rights, and operate in complete darkness? Oh yeah it's to prevent... Oh, well, uh.... What use is the FBI/CIA/NSA/etc good for if the same attacks happen regardless of how much money we funnel their way? I couldn't care less about this movie, I might have watched it when it came out on DVD but pulling it from theatres because of threats from an unknown entity? Even if it's from NK that's an even bigger reason to ignore it. This is a dangerous precedent we are setting when a threat can stop a movie from getting released. We are caving to terrorism (this is probably one of the first times ever "we are letting the terrorists win" actually fits the situation) of an unknown entity.
- S_A_P 12y agoThe terrorists(or fake terrorists) won here, plain and simple. I honestly cant believe we are even having this conversation, or that pulling the plug was even an option here. However, to play devils advocate, I wonder what would happen if say, China were to make a movie about assassinating the president of the US, what sort of reaction our government would have. Just because North Korea is a small country with few means to really get at us doesn't make it a good idea to write a film with a plot about killing their leader. That said knowing Seth Rogen movies, Im sure it ended up with them smoking weed with KJU and having a party out of it, so he shouldn't be that upset...
- talmand 12y agoIf China made such a movie, I would expect the government reaction to be a sternly written statement saying something. "Death of a President" is movie about solving the assassination of George W. Bush with British production companies, so it's been done. I don't recall going to war over it or anything. Personally, if I were President and a foreign country made a raunchy comedy about assassinating me, I'd give it a try before condemning it with a low review score.
- justanother 12y agoThe situation as analyzed in this article highlights the misgivings I have always harbored about the term 'terrorism'. Once we classify a particular set of criminal behavior as being so much more heinous than ordinary crime, we pretty much invite everything, over a long enough time scale, to slide down the slippery slope into this new classification. When I was much younger, this word referred to organized groups whose sole aim was murder and destruction. Now it is applied to children who point fingers at each other and say "bang!" as well as whistleblowers and (apparently) people who hack movie studios. Is it time to retire 'terrorism' yet?
- personZ 12y agoThis is a pandering article where someone acts outraged to pander to an audience. Firstly, "cyberterrorism" has forever been defined as attacks on computer resources, not attacks on people. If a nation state crippled a business to coerce their actions, that is pretty much spot on with the definition of cyberterrorism. Secondly, who ever said that such a theater attack would have to simultaneously hit 18,000 theaters? The threat seemed to be that any theater could be at risk. I mean, is ten theater attacks okay? Five? Two? One? Sony and theaters are not the US military or the government. They're a risk abatement private enterprise. This is a terribly weak article. He redefines existing terminology and then strikes down absurd strawmen to get the cheering crowd to nod along.