6 ms·
The [non-]money quote: "The next test flight is not expected until 2018 because of limited NASA budgets, and Orion will not carry astronauts until 2021 at the
by lisper 12y ago
The [non-]money quote:
"The next test flight is not expected until 2018 because of limited NASA budgets, and Orion will not carry astronauts until 2021 at the earliest."
So while I don't want to downplay the technical achievement, it is politics, not technology, that remains the limiting factor at NASA. :-(
- smackfu 12y agoIt's also technology. "But the project suffered a series of technical issues last year that pushed the service module preliminary design review back by about 10 months." http://aviationweek.com/blog/nasa-slips-orion-em1-flight-2018-0 http://aviationweek.com/blog/nasa-slips-orion-em1-flight-201... It's someone doing good PR that gets it boiled down to "limited NASA budgets."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kbenson 12y agoI can't help but think part of the technology problem is also caused by budget constraints. Less budget means less actual testing and experimentation and more theoretical planning, work and design. I imagine more real world experience with tests and experiments for those involved would help these problems get solved sooner, possibly before they even come about.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoIt is not clear that more budget would make things go faster. 9 women can't make a baby in 9 months, for example. It really depends on how well the project could utilize the extra funding (they probably could do with more, but at some point progress/dollar would have to fall). It is just like software, actually.
- DigitalJack 12y agoWell in this case it would have. The sub contractors went through multiple stop-work start-work iterations and there is always a loss of efficiency with that as the engineers get shuffled. The ones on the program when it starts frequently aren't the same people as when it was stopped.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoGood point: consistency in funding is pretty important, and to manage projects for the long term...also in industry. It would be tough not to know what your budget would be for 5 years on a 5 year project.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoGood point: consistency in funding is pretty important, and to manage projects for the long term...also in industry. It would be tough not to know what your budget would be for 5 years on a 5 year project.
- OvidNaso 12y ago"9 women can't make a baby in 9 months, for example." Very true. However, 9 women and 1 man are more likely to give you a baby in 9 months that 1 women and 1 man.
- ericd 12y agoDon't mean to be pedantic, but I think it's "9 women can't make a baby in 1 month", but they can make 9 babies in 9 months. Bandwidth vs. latency. I'm sure NASA could speed up the overall project if they had more resources by doing lots of things in parallel. NASA went from having unmanned ICBMs to putting a man on the moon in under a decade when they were given enormous funding.
- nhaehnle 12y agoThe Apollo project is historical precedent that shows that precisely this type of project can go much faster, given the required budget and focus. The second part here is also important, of course. Just pouring more money onto a problem isn't necessarily going to help if e.g. there is more focus on political turf wars than there is on the actual technical challenge.
- anovikov 12y agoThat's also politics, they have been bouncing service module work between NASA and ESA.
- TallGuyShort 12y agoPeople at my company also always list budget and headcount restraints as the reason they couldn't have been more successful. It's almost like it's universal politics at play or something.
- ghaff 12y agoOr it's like pretty much no one ever thinks there's enough money or people for whatever project they're driving. Maybe that's what you mean by "politics" but pretty much no organization ever--there are probably a few cases that come close to exceptions like the Manhattan Project, but not many--can get as much funding or staffing as they would like.
- meowface 12y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the Manhattan Project was considered to be understaffed and underfunded as well. I don't know a lot about it, but my understanding is that at the time, leaders really had no idea if it was going to work or if it was worth all the effort.
- ghaff 12y agoI imagine you're right :-) I was just throwing out the name of a 1 in a million project that may have potentially had all the resources it wanted given to it. But I'm sure even that project saw phone calls arguing for more support staff or whatever.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoThey threw a lot of people and funding at the Manhattan project, it was a national priority at the time and not a really a good example of a project that was starved at all for resources (it was probably like: we need X; ok, you get X).
- anigbrowl 12y agoThe next test flight is not expected until 2018 ಠ_ರೃ In the meantime, please consider supporting Buzz Aldrin's ShareSpace science education foundation by purchasing one of his #GETYOURASSTOMARS t-shirts: http://web.sharespace.org/ http://web.sharespace.org/
- InclinedPlane 12y agoCertainly, but I wouldn't fall into the trap of thinking naively that things would be better if only NASA had much more money. Orion is a multi-billion dollar project. SLS (which will eventually be the launcher for Orion, should they ever plan a full design for a mission that uses it) is also a multi-billion dollar project. Orion has a budget of about $1 billion per year, SLS nearly $2 billion. So we're spending a crapton of money on these projects. But because of they way they are being managed and run they are hugely expensive compared to the work involved. Sadly, NASA manned spaceflight is mostly a jobs program now, and has been for a long time. The unmanned spaceflight part of NASA is still capable of executing on ambitious projects, the manned part more or less just sort of stumbles in the general direction of a goal with the hope that a lot of money will fall out of congress along the way (which it usually does).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ArtDev 12y agoThe Iraq war cost $1 billion per DAY. Imagine if a even small amount of money was shifted from the military to NASA. I recall when NASA needed to fix the Hubble telescope and the Air Force had TWO extra space telescopes in storage!
- danielweber 12y agoImagine if a even small amount of money was shifted from the military to NASA. Imagine if all the money in a Monopoly box were real.
- InclinedPlane 12y agoThe Air Force had two optical assemblies in storage, that's actually one of the cheapest parts of the entire system, though a very important part. Even if we could launch those "space telescopes" for free they'd be useless, they aren't complete units. And sure, it'd be nice if we spent more money on space, but that doesn't excuse the huge problems at NASA et al. There is a gap of perhaps an order of magnitude in capabilities between what we are doing and what would be possible if we gave space exploration a higher priority in terms of expenditures. But there is a gap of perhaps 1 to 2 orders of magnitude in capabilities between what NASA is doing and what would be possible if NASA manned spaceflight were run better and smarter. As an example, the Shuttle program spent around $5 billion a year consistently for nearly 30 years. In that time the major achievement of all that work was to put up the ISS. The ISS is nice now that the expense to put it up is just a sunk cost, but it was in no way worth how much it cost, nor was anything the Shuttle did worth the cost of the program. Ultimately every Shuttle launch ended up costing about as much as a Saturn V launch (and that's a Saturn V launch back at the start of the program, more likely later launches would have become cheaper due to various economies of scale and process improvements). So we had 30 years of operating a hugely expensive low Earth orbit spacecraft instead of 30 years and over 100 launches of a heavy lift rocket capable of sending payloads beyond Earth orbit. We could have had hundreds of people living and working in orbit, on the moon, or on Mars by now, but instead we got the Shuttle and ISS. Some of the fault there comes is due to congress, but there's no excusing the people at NASA from making and committing to these decisions.
- otoolep 12y agoNo astronauts for 7 years, at least? I don't know whether to laugh or cry.
- mikerichards 12y agoYes, we all understand that resources are limited