9 ms·
US Has More Solar Workers Than Coal Miners
- tedunangst 12y ago> counted 142,698 employees There are about three times that many people employed growing corn, however. So should we switch all our power plants to corn based ethanol?
- ChrisGaudreau 12y agoExcept that corn is used for more than just ethanol.
- tedunangst 12y agoAbout one third of all corn turns into ethanol, meaning the worker count is actually equal.
- TallGuyShort 12y agoI don't think this is significant. They're counting the entire solar industry against one very specific role in a specific fossil fuel industry. What about all the people working on coal plants and the related infrastructure? What about all the people working in oil & gas? Given how such a small percentage of US energy is solar, if it required more man power than coal plants I'd take it as a sign that we're doing something seriously unsustainable in the way we do solar. edit: good points in the responses
- heydenberk 12y agoIt's natural for a mature industry (coal) to require less labor than an immature industry (solar) which is in a phase of rapid growth.
- adventured 12y agoI don't think that's inherently true at all, it depends on the nature of the industry or company and how they're structured. Most of the fastest growth tech companies required very little labor compared to their early extreme growth - most such companies only got bloated at the tail end of their growth, and their labor to sales ratios fell dramatically (eg Microsoft, Intel, Dell, Cisco, eBay, Google, etc). Amazon requires less jobs per dollar of revenue generated, than Walmart (~75% less) or Target (~66% less). Amazon will likely push this to an extreme over time as they heavily automate their warehouses with robotics, doing away with at least half of their theoretically expected human labor growth. Advertising and look-up systems online require vastly less jobs than old-fashioned white / yellow pages. e-brokers require a lot less human labor than the old brokers used to, where you needed a human to process every trade. Craigslist butchered the classifieds industry, drastically optimizing it. eBay was famous for generating massive sales per employee in the first X years of existence, far beyond anything established big auction houses managed. Microsoft practically invented the software company, and required a lot less labor per dollar of sales than just about any other company you could have compared it to at the time. They also had extreme growth. In 1980 they had the inflation adjusted equivalent of perhaps $40 million in sales with just 40 employees. This list keeps going.
- cleverjake 12y agoA common argument against renewable energy pushes is how it hurts the coal jobs - at least in areas like pennsylvania, kentucky, and west virginia. A "they're tryna take er jerbs" argument is a good way to get voters out against it when most people are in the industry, or have parents, siblings, inlaws, or relatives that would loose a job if that happened.
- firebones 12y agoInteresting. None of those states would seem high on the list of states with great potential for renewables (too dense for wind, not enough sun or open space for solar). But if you could hack that--for instance, offer clean, less-dangerous aboveground jobs at comparable or better wages--wouldn't the workers flock to them? The deep-pocketed, lobbying mine owners on the other hand... Maybe the hack is for those states to get the mine owners established in the manufacturing supporting renewables. Smooth transition, ready workforce.
- dredmorbius 12y agoThere's opportunity for solar in pretty much all states, and if not solar, then other forms of renewable energy, conservation measures, or activity. I would expect to see large concentrated solar installations in sunbelt states though.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> Maybe the hack is for those states to get the mine owners established in the manufacturing supporting renewables. Smooth transition, ready workforce. Those states will bend over backwards to accommodate the coal industry, but they're not going to put any programs together for the actual workers. You would need either a non-profit or a renewables industrialist (Elon?) to put a program together to train and/or relocate these workers to better jobs.
- firebones 12y agoYeah, I don't expect the typical OSHA-ignoring mine owner to adapt to a new economy, and they probably have achieved enough regulatory capture to keep out competing tech, but state lines are porous, and labor is relatively mobile, so if opportunity beckons across state lines, economic rationality may prevail. So states bordering coal states--the ball is in your court! I see plenty of wind farms and rigs on the interstate transporting large turbines to Iowa and Kansas, so maybe the labor will reallocate.
- dredmorbius 12y agoIf anything, that would make the argument stronger that solar requires (or promotes) more jobs. The argument is that solar kills jobs. It doesn't. My concern is that the per-worker productivity is vastly lower than what we've been used to for fossil-fuel generation. Mind: I also think we can't get off of coal fast enough.
- fennecfoxen 12y agoThe real mechanism whereby solar kills jobs is by making electricity more expensive, thus making manufacturing unprofitable (sending the jobs overseas) or making the costs of manufactured goods higher (so people who need them will take money from other parts of their budget, like entertainment expenses or savings.) It'd be a fine thing if solar really did mean fewer jobs overall: having fewer people spending time and effort making intermediate products is great for the economy.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>The real mechanism whereby solar kills jobs is by making electricity more expensive Except it does the exact opposite. The spot price of electricity in Europe and Australia has even managed to turn negative a few times thanks mostly to solar. Did coal ever do that? The recent oil price plunge orchestrated by the Saudis was also in part recognition of this fact (as well as an attempt to punish US Shale oil producers/Iran). Competition never drove prices up but it sure does make the dinosaurs with disrupted business models whinge very loudly in the media and lobby furiously. P.S. Did you know that solar kills birds? Also there are unconfirmed reports that wind turbines cause health problems.
- fleitz 12y agoIt's a moot point because negative electricity prices reflect producing more than is necessary, the reason why it's negatively priced is because it's being generated at the wrong time (which is the stupidity of solar, it works best when there's less load) It's easy to make negative priced electricity with coal, simply shove a tonne of coal in the burner and then try to find someone to take the load before your generators / boilers blow up. I'm not saying coal is the future, merely that arguments about negatively priced electricity are stupid, which is why companies try to focus on baseload generation because that's where most of the generating capacity needs to be.
- maerF0x0 12y agoKeep in mind that solar, kind of like electric cars, has much of its costs front loaded. Roughly speaking, you spend $20k more on an electric car, and then save $15k on fuel because its cheaper to run off electricity than gasoline. But that $20K is today and the $15k savings is over 15 years. Similarly w/ solar panels. Return of investment is a few years. whereas marginal coal is probably very profitable, that is coal from an existing operating mine.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoVery true. Getting solar panels for your home is like making a one time payment on a car and getting free gas for years.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- crdoconnor 12y ago>Given how such a small percentage of US energy is solar, if it required more man power than coal plants I'd take it as a sign that we're doing something seriously unsustainable in the way we do solar. Solar is very capital intensive - making the panels & deploying them - but operationally very, very cheap (all you have to do is give the panels a wipedown every so often). By the time solar is a large percentage of US energy it will probably still employ a similar number of workers. It's kind of like writing code in that respect.
- vacri 12y agoThat's a subtle reframing you've done there. "Solar" is an entity unto itself, but "coal" is a submember of "fossil fuels". Apparently "solar" doesn't get the same consideration, despite being a member of the "renewable energy" industry. What about all the people working on coal plants and the related infrastructure? The article said "coal mining jobs", not "coal miners" specifically. Coal mining includes jobs like truck driving and the other items you're asking about. You've basically done a double-whammy reframing: solar jobs are "generic-anything in an entire industry"; coal jobs are only the literal miners themselves, in a 'narrowed-down' field from a wider industry.
- gooseyard 12y agoalso, it is easy to forget that the steel industry is a major consumer of metallurgical coal (commonly called met coal), not as an energy source but as a raw material (coke). Producers of high quality, low sulphur coal might sell the same product to energy producers as "steam coal" or "thermal coal" as well as to steel producers. When prices for steam coal dip, it often stimulates steel production. I have experience in coal mining, but I don't know much about the coking process, other than that the coal is partially burned. Presumably as long as we're manufacturing virgin steel some of the coal carbon is released anyhow.
- dredmorbius 12y agoCoking coal can be replaced by other carbon sources, though coal itself was used to replace charcoal, derived from wood. The World Coal Association states "721 million tonnes of coking coal was used in the production of steel" in 2010. http://www.worldcoal.org/coal/uses-of-coal/coal-steel/ http://www.worldcoal.org/coal/uses-of-coal/coal-steel/ Total global coal extraction in 2010 was 3547.8 Mtoe, or ~5,068 tons of coal (BP 2014 annual energy review). Coking coal is 14% of that total.
- mmphosis 12y agoWhat about all the people working in oil & gas? There are actually fewer people with jobs in oil & gas compared to other industries. http://credbc.ca/role-energy-sector-bcs-economy/ http://credbc.ca/role-energy-sector-bcs-economy/
- spacecowboy_lon 12y agoand do you count the unskilled subcontractors from the building trades - when we had our roof instalation done recently a couple of guys came a few days before and put up the scafolding - are they part of the "solar industry"
- tptacek 12y agoUnfortunately, the solar workers are not as effective a voting bloc as the coal workers, who are concentrated geographically.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoAnd solar workers have a higher injury rate, so attrition.
- civilian 12y agoThan coal workers? [citation needed]
- antr 12y agoLet me call bullshit on your comment: http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-de...
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat story seems to add the deaths attributable to coal consumption (through people dying from breathing polluted air) rather than the deaths from coal extraction vs. solar installation, which is what the poster above was talking about before getting flagged (perhaps due to the failure to back the statement up with any data). Pollution externalities are as or more important than deaths on the production side, but they are different and we shouldn't minimize the latter even if we approve of solar more than coal - it's just easy ammo to the coal lobby, and might be giving a free pass to employers who take a cavalier approach to safety.
- antr 12y agoYes, it includes externalities. Still, the order of deaths is the same if externalities are removed: http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/191326/deaths-nuclear-energy-compared-other-causes http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/191326/deaths-nuc...
- api 12y agoWhile I'm generally pro-solar, more workers is not an inherent good with an energy source... quite the opposite. The idea of energy is to require as few workers as possible so that human attention and labor can be spent on other things. This is likely directly related to the fact that coal has a higher EROEI than solar (neglecting long-term externalities of course).
- dredmorbius 12y agoHigher EROEI and much more concentrated capital. For every square meter of PV deployed, you start with 1 kW of incident sunlight, reduced by the panel efficiency (~15%), capacity factor (~25%), the shading/spacing factor (~55%), and inverter efficiency (~90%). Your panels have a nominal life of 20 years after which they must be replaced. On a square-meter basis, the raw output of a coal-fired plant is vastly higher. That footprint is extended by mining operations, fuel transport (mostly railroad), and tailings and ash disposal. It's still pretty high. That said, I'd prefer to see approaches to increasing solar worker efficiency rather than prolonging use of coal.
- gizmo686 12y agoSolar panals also use their land area much less invasivly. You can stick them on the roofs of building which would otherwise be unused space. Coal power plants do not share space nearly as well. Of course, coal mining may actually make more usable space but I would prefer to keep such space in its natural state until we actually want to use it.
- dredmorbius 12y agoRight. That's a concern for land use which I address in another follow-up on this thread. What I'm focusing on though are the costs of plant capital involved in energy production, and the relative productivity of that capital. Coal plants approach 500x the energy intensity of solar power.
- reportingsjr 12y agoI don't see why a power output per square meter metric would be worth comparing. The amount of space solar takes up shouldn't really matter that much. I do believe that solar farms are a pretty bad idea and panels should be put on roof tops more than anywhere else. Roof top solar solves more problems than farms. It helps keep roofs cooler during summer which can help reduce the heat island effect. It also doesn't take up space that is becoming more precious all of the time.
- MisterBastahrd 12y agoThis is apples and oranges. They're comparing coal miners to people who are primarily engaged in building or installing solar panels. If you want a true comparison along those lines, you'd need to account for every person working at a coal-fired power plant or working on a coal-based power source (like antique trains).
- dredmorbius 12y agoOn the positive side: it appears that solar energy is highly effective as an employment generator. On the negative side: the fraction of electricity generation provided by solar vs. coal is a very small fraction, meaning that you're looking at far more workers per GWh of actual energy production. The 8 month total generation for 2012 includes 12,346 GWh of solar PV, vs. 1,105,161 GWh for coal generation. http://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/monthly/pdf/sec7_5.pdf http://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/monthly/pdf/sec7_5.pdf This means that a solar worker is responsible for 0.087 GWh of generation. A coal miner is responsible for 8.968 GWh of electricity generation. At this rate, we'd require 32.11 million workers in solar to replace existing coal generation capacity. While that would be a strongly effective employment program, it would also be devoting a vastly larger portion of the United States' labor force to the task of energy provisioning. That's a significant chunk of the 147.3 million total civilian workforce as of October, 2014, at 22%. http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.a.htm http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.a.htm
- sfall 12y agowe are comparing solar industry vs coal miners. so the development of solar technology is included in the total #
- anigbrowl 12y agoIsn't the largest labor input for solar in manufacturing and installation, rather than maintenance? Using your example of 12,346 GWh of solar PV for 2012, wouldn't those solar installations have produced the same amount of power (or close to it) in 2013 without any additional labor input, plus whatever new capacity was installed in 2013, resulting a higher GWh:worker ratio?
- dredmorbius 12y agoI don't know. I haven't seen a good breakdown of labor requirements for solar over time. I suspect many of the jobs are in sales and marketing as well, which may well get optimized out.
- Animats 12y ago
- tn13 12y agoThis seems like bad news. Given the ratio of Solar:Coal as source of power generation in US, ideally we would expect the Solar workers to be far less. This is a scaling problem.
- diafygi 12y agoI have a startup in solar, and the thing I don't think people are understanding here is the unbelievable amount of growth that is starting to happen in solar. We're talking 400x growth in the next 40 years[1]. So far, the solar industry has reached grid parity (i.e. unsubsidized costs <= retail cost from the grid) in a few U.S. states and several countries[2]. When it has reached grid parity in these locations, you see a huge inflow of investment capital since there's little regulatory risk[3]. This trend will not change. Solar will only get cheaper, and fossil fuels will only get more expensive. So what happens in 10-20 years when solar is at or below grid parity in most of the world? Mix that financial advantage with a huge political movement to fight climate change (e.g. stop Colorado from burning down every other year), and you have the formula for another whale oil-style shift in energy. I'm originally a chemical engineer from Texas, and I have a standing $100 bet with two of my friends who work in the petroleum industry that they will not retire in an oil job. Anyone else want to take that bet? Finally, we're hiring[4]. [1]: http://www.pvsolarreport.com/the-next-internet/ http://www.pvsolarreport.com/the-next-internet/ [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_parity#Rapid_uptake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_parity#Rapid_uptake [3]: http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/01/16/solar-yield-idUSL4N0JE2NU20140116 http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/01/16/solar-yield-idUSL4... [4]: https://angel.co/utilityapi/jobs/44943-software-engineer https://angel.co/utilityapi/jobs/44943-software-engineer
- cstavish 12y agoI'd like to know your thoughts on today's cheap oil prices-- assuming oil stays around $70-80 a barrel for the next few years, do you see that slowing down solar development/investment? In other words, do people keep their "eyes on the prize" so to speak, or are they dissuaded by temporarily cheap oil prices?
- diafygi 12y agoIt's actually kind of interesting. I think it might be helpful globally for clean energy. Cheap oil means people won't feel as much pain if a carbon tax is put in place to compensate for the externalities of using fossil fuels. So this is an opportunity for political movements in countries to push through a carbon tax now. Then when the price of oil goes back up (i.e. after OPEC has driven out the frackers and hurt Russia sufficiently), the carbon tax will make clean energy more competitive. I personally think that OPEC is shooting themselves in the foot over the long term with this move.