9 ms·
Study: Doubling Saturated Fat in the Diet Does Not Increase It in Blood
- buzz27 12y agoWell, the sample is quite small, and just because a measure of fats in blood did not increase, it is probably not justified to conclude that a high intake is safe.
- vixen99 12y agoHigh anything is probably not wise. However a somewhat different story from that to which we're accustomed, is emerging. Am J Clin Nutr. 2010 Mar;91(3):535-46. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.2009.27725. Epub 2010 Jan 13. Meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies evaluating the association of saturated fat with cardiovascular disease. CONCLUSIONS: "A meta-analysis of prospective epidemiologic studies showed that there is no significant evidence for concluding that dietary saturated fat is associated with an increased risk of CHD or CVD. More data are needed to elucidate whether CVD risks are likely to be influenced by the specific nutrients used to replace saturated fat."
- Dewie 12y ago> Well, the sample is quite small, Regards, Peanut gallery on every article on some research
- dang 12y agoYes, it's time we stop reflexively dismissing every study with a small sample size as if that made it worthless. This is the latest meme in a sequence that includes "correlation is not causation" and "the plural of anecdote is not data". It's a generic dismissal and has a de-interesting effect on discussion. It has more in common with internet reflexes like "First" and "Betteridge" than with reflective thought. One way to catch oneself before doing this is to ask if you're tacitly assuming that the people doing the work are idiots. The odds—and the Principle of Charity [1]—suggest they're not. Comments that imply this generically are usually low-quality. If the people doing the work really are dumb, then it almost certainly has more specific flaws (e.g. "this way of measuring glucose isn't reliable", to make something totally up) that it would be far more helpful to point out. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity
- icebraining 12y agoIt's not just a meme. There have been multiple articles and papers the last few years on how a great number of clinical trials are statistically underpowered and therefore suspect; this includes a 2005 paper entitled "Why Most Published Research Findings Are False", which analyzes "49 of the most highly regarded research findings in medicine over the previous 13 years" and finds that a worrying number of them hasn't stand replication. And when people talk about underpowered studies, it's mentioned less than 100 individuals, not less than 20.
- dang 12y agoOh I know. You're preaching to the choir, believe me! But that's not the meme. The meme is invoking it to dismiss a study with no further thought and no specific content. Small samples get overinterpreted, many published findings are false, etc.—it's all true and the community here is well aware. But it's a gross overreaction to dismiss small-sample experiments wholesale. Even a few seconds' reflection is enough to see that. For example, assuming this experiment was rigorous, it didn't need more than 16 subjects to find that greater saturated fat in diet doesn't automatically cause greater fat in blood. Additional resources might be better spent on future samples (i.e. replicating the finding by other researchers) than on a larger single sample, which is probably a game of rapidly diminishing returns. And so on. The point is that HN wants reflective discussions, not reflexive ones. It takes no work and no real thought to pick out one detail that people are currently primed to fuss over and make a post of it. That's not reflection, it's habit, and its payload is not learning, but reinforcement. Reflection requires engaging with the material—this specific material. There are two ways to do that. One is to dig in and learn the material, think about it, and report your findings to HN. The other is to happen to know something about it in the first place. The first takes work, the second luck. Comments based on neither work nor knowledge are likely not to be substantive. That's why want to avoid generic dismissals as opposed to specific ones.
- joosters 12y agoThey only analysed 49 research findings? Pah! Far too few to draw any real conclusions :)
- 12y ago
- 17425170 12y agoWe've been running some basic experiments that suggest the opposite to these findings: http://hema.vu/1vA0sHR http://hema.vu/1vA0sHR . But again, this is hardly conclusive (our sample size is much smaller).
- volker48 12y agoYour experiment doesn't really look like the same thing at all. From your link, it doesn't look like you are controlling carbohydrates and your participants are just eating lots of fast food. The study started with low carb high saturated fat. I would argue that fast food is high carb and high fat. Interesting research though either way.
- doctorcomputer 12y agoAre you controlling for blood sugar?
- GIFtheory 12y agoI'd like to point out that the linked article links to its own blog about 20 times, but not once to the actual study, which is here: http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0113605 http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjourna.... Epic.
- dang 12y agoThat url (http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/285915.php http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/285915.php) also appeared to rip content from the original popular article, which we found by googling one of the quotes from the study author. There is a class of poor-quality science blogs that mostly lift content from elsewhere. We mostly don't ban them, because occasionally they do end up being the best popular article on a study. We do, however, penalize them.
- joelthelion 12y ago... in 16 adults.
- bluecalm 12y ago16 adults is quite good. If you polled them well (that is randomly) and you obtained some result in all of them then it's significant evidence that that the result is true for very significant part of the population. Sure, you can't show that it's true for everybody but having a result like: "only 0.1% chance that it occurred by random if 2/3 of the population reacts this way and way less if it's half of the population" is very nice result to have. If something occurs for 16 randomly chosen people (or even 15/16 or 14/16) you are virtually certain it occurs for very significant part of the population which is often the goal of the study - to justify further research.
- icebraining 12y agoIf you polled them well (that is randomly) It's not random. They were "sixteen overweight/obese men and women 30-66 years old, with a BMI between 27–50 kg/m2".
- DanBC 12y agoHow important is it that this study had no control (and thus no randomisation or blinding) and had a small sample size, and that some of the authors have written books about this diet?
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoNutrition studies will often use people as their own controls because of the significant variability between people. Nobody is willing to fund nutrition research with "perfect" studies, so researchers do what they can (especially when they are known to have hypotheses counter to the orthodox view). On their books, I think that would be a ridiculous thing to reject people's findings for. Almost every academic has written a book at some time. Instead, we need to recognize the possibility of a bias inherent in every researcher and look to the study design, execution, and conclusions to see if they hold. Phinney and Volek are in a different class when it comes to their books and their ideas than is, say, Robert Lustig.
- mipapage 12y agoTwo of the authors, Phinny and Volek, have some interesting books out on living in a low carb lifestyle.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoWe've known for a while the risk factor for heart disease is serum SFA levels, not necessarily SFA consumption. What has never been shown is that consuming SFA raises serum SFA; instead, it's been an understood truism held in place by policy and demagoguery. This study is small, but evidence convicting saturated fats was extremely weak to begin with, and we are now seeing positive evidence exonerating it. If you are interested in learning more about the history of nutrition, I highly recommend Nina Teicholz book The Big Fat Surprise. As others have mentioned, Phinney and Volek's books are a great overview off the science as of a few years ago. Phinney has been doing research on this for 40 years, quite an accomplishment, given how hard it has been to get funding for research that contradicts the policy line of "carbs are critical to survival and fat must be avoided".
- deepsun 12y agoWell, originally thought was valid. If we eat something, there must be more of it in body. Of course, now we see that body is more complicated in case of SFA, but generally assumption works for other cases. If a cat entered a house, you generally might expect that cat should be inside the house. The reality, as we see, is more complex than that, but generally assumption works, and worked for most of the cases. I just want to say that please don't blame scientists and policy makers. Everyone's smart after the fact.
- DanBC 12y ago> Well, originally thought was valid. If we eat something, there must be more of it in body. Sadly we replaced saturated fats (eg butter) with trans-fats (eg margerine). We know that trans-fats are terrible. That possibly caused some confusion. We knew people we still having heart attacks, we just thought that they were the group still eating saturated fats.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoAnd now we may have gotten worse: instead of trans fats (really bad!), we now get highly oxidized poly-unsaturated fats as restaurants have moved to seed oils for frying, which don't handle the temperatures nor the time in use very well. Oxidized fats do nasty things in the body, perhaps worse than trans fats. Bring back the stable saturated fats like coconut oil, palm oil (if sustainably produced), lard and tallow.
- apetresc 12y agoWhatever, I give it at most two years before some other study directly contradicts this one (just as this one directly contradicts conventional wisdom based on other studies which themselves contradicted the generally-accepted status quo before them). Nutritional science is just insane.
- claudiusd 12y agoYou basically nailed the problem: the generally-accepted status quo is based on flimsy evidence. Our metabolism is complicated and it will likely take decades before we fully understand it, not to mention that different people process calories differently. Luckily, it's very easy to detect when your diet is having a negative impact on your health and you have time to make changes before heart disease or type 2 diabetes strikes. There's no excuse for not keeping track of your weight and not getting regular blood work to look for risk factors. When these risk factors emerge, very simple changes like eating more vegetables and spending more time walking can be enough to reverse them. Easier said than done of course, but we do have reliable science that shows this.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoI would take that bet. Phinney and Volek have a long history of doing pretty good science. I haven't seen any of their work directly contradicted over Phinney's 35+ year career[0]. Also, there is scant evidence that this is actually showing a different result than other studies. The diet-heart hypothesis never had good, controlled studies[1] to back it up; we are just now seeing the good science testing it, and it's not holding up well. I will agree that nutrition science has been, and, in many cases, continues to be, lacking. It is getting better, though. We are moving past epidemiology being the be-all-end-all and starting to see well controlled trials asking interesting questions. Unfortunately, those are really expensive and hard to do. 0. I could be wrong here; I've read a lot but not everything. Still, they've had enough detractors that I'm sure people would have trumpeted it. 1. Lots of epidemiological studies, but causation shouldn't have ever been inferred from them. Unlike with smoking, risk factors were never 20x, more like 1.2x.
- elsewhen 12y agonot that this negates the finding of the article, but i think it is important to highlight that: "This work was supported by the Dairy Research Institute, the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association and the Egg Nutrition Center."
- justin66 12y agoOne interesting thing to note is that the title Doubling Saturated Fat in the Diet Does Not Increase Saturated Fat in Blood does not logically contradict the notion that radically reducing saturated fat in the diet decreases saturated fat in blood. It's possible that once you reach a certain consumption point you're doing as much as you can do. I'd want to read the study in detail before commenting further. I'm a little surprised they started with people with metabolic syndrome, which could mean a lot of things and lead to a lot of craziness.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoUnfortunately, it's probably not too much of a stretch to think metabolically disordered people may outnumber those who aren't, if not now, then soon. But, realistically, it was probably necessary to target sick people to get the grant.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MrQuincle 12y agoIt would be quite surprising. I concur with @elsewhen that the people funding this research must have been quite pleasantly surprised: "This work was funded by a grant from Dairy Research Institute, The Beef Checkoff, the Egg Nutrition Center, and the Robert C. And Veronica Atkins Foundation." I've been reading through it on http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0113605 http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjourna... and I don't understand several things: * Which SFAs (Saturated Fatty Acids) have been gone up in plasma by a carbohydrate diet? Only palmitoleic acid, or also other ones? And what's the percentage of these acids compared to all SFAs? * If you only check people with metabolic syndrome are the results not typical of a metabolism which is screwed up? Don't you at least wanna know what it does in healthy people? * If there is momentarily plasma palmitoleic acid response on dietary intake of carbohydrates, are those SFAs there so the body can get rid of them? What's the mechanism here? If you want to loose fat, it will need to go through the plasma at some time...
- hachiya 12y agoI would be very careful about taking anything in this study at face value. Be sure to look at available responses before taking advice from the Atkins, Inc. folks. e.g. http://carbsanity.blogspot.com/2014/11/that-new-volek-phinney-study-part-i.html http://carbsanity.blogspot.com/2014/11/that-new-volek-phinne... Palmitoleic acid is a MUFA and while it may be true that it can act as a biomarker, there is an insanely huge amount of research against there being any direct deleterious mechanism of action for this fatty acid. To the contrary, palmitoleic acid is often shown to have protective, insulin sensitizing effects. More on that later, but come on. How can you write that when even perusing Wikipedia should cause pause! But let me ask you this. When was the last time you heard that saturated fat caused an increase in the saturated fat circulating in your blood and that THIS was the cause of heart disease? Answer: Never!