7 ms·
Somebody’s Already Using Verizon’s ID to Track Users
- phkahler 12y agoAnother argument for Net Neutrality. Just pass the data through please.
- RexRollman 12y agoThat's disappointing. So in the end, Twitter is no better than Google or Facebook when it comes to user tracking. We are the product, indeed.
- ams6110 12y agoOf course you are. Are you paying for Twitter?
- RexRollman 12y agoNo, but I am also not a Twitter user.
- icebraining 12y agoPeople are paying for Verizon, though.
- meepmorp 12y agoThat you're the product if you're not the customer does not imply that you're not the product if you are the customer. Companies sell personal data all the time, cause they can make extra money off their customer base.
- jakejake 12y agoI don't really blame twitter, they're just using information that is being sent to them. The carriers who add these headers are to blame.
- RexRollman 12y agoBut no one is making them use it. Furthermore, they could have warned people.
- MAGZine 12y agoThis is so wrong. An ISP is not meant to interject information into a client's request, build profiles of their subscribers, help "provide targeted content," or any such activity. Apparently ISPs are making so little money by providing services they were originally born to provide, they need to go and do totally unwanted activity like this. They're internet service providers, not customer profiling service providers. It's clear that these companies do not have their customer's best interests at heart, though I'm not sure that they ever have.
- ams6110 12y agoFurthermore the notion that the addition of an HTTP header to the request would be a patentable invention is absurd. The protocol explicitly supports it. Nothing was invented here.
- hackuser 12y ago> They're internet service providers, not customer profiling service providers. Google is a search engine and application provider, not a customer profiling service provider. Similar things could be said of Facebook, cable/satellite TV, automobiles, retail stores, government agencies. But all are focusing on collecting information and building profiles.
- zer0defex 12y agoTextbook example of escalation. Start with relatively easy to remove cookies. Savvy people clear their caches, the criminals move to automatic localstorage weapons. The savvy people start wearing AdBlock armor and rejoice. The criminals move up to armor piercing injection bullets. The everyday mom and pop don't stand a chance. 1984, yeah right man, orwell is today.
- cheezit 12y agowww.runads.com is doing the same for their mobile advertising campaigns. The ad-tech industry is targeting mobile advertising as the Next Big Thing, and they're right to do so. Anyone not tracking and optimizing ads toward the permacookie will be left behind.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 0x0 12y agoHas anyone done any research on how robust their MITMing HTTP handling is?
- gnud 12y agoWill the ISPs overwrite this header if already present? If so, isn't that a kind of huge problem? If not, can't someone make a mobile browser that sets these headers to some random value?
- gorhill 12y agoYes, it will be overwritten. Someone tried it: https://github.com/lightswitch05/Bogus_X-UIDH#update-verizon-overwrites-the-x-uidh-if-it-is-already-set-so-this-is-not-a-valid-solution- https://github.com/lightswitch05/Bogus_X-UIDH#update-verizon...
- philo23 12y agoWhat if it had a different case? Eg x-uidh: I remember for a while the only way to change the User Agent header for iOS UIWebViews was to set the user agent header in lowercase, as long as it's after the actual header, PHP will uppercase both and the later one will win (for $_SERVER atleast, obviously this is PHP specific.)
- MichaelGG 12y agoYes, the fun is to figure out what they're using and exploit it. HTTP is a terrible format to parse, with lots of idiotic extra features that have no legitimate usage. But it'd be fairly easy for them to harden things, just abort if they run into anything weird. Which may be a way around this. Run a local proxy that does stuff like use line folding, comments in headers, and other things to make their parse code abort. Of course, you then run the risk of breaking compatibility with actual HTTP servers (with good reason-those are bad features and such messages are probably an attack). And of course the ISP can always fix their code.
- MichaelGG 12y agoYes, the fun is to figure out what they're using and exploit it. HTTP is a terrible format to parse, with lots of idiotic extra features that have no legitimate usage. But it'd be fairly easy for them to harden things, just abort if they run into anything weird. Which may be a way around this. Run a local proxy that does stuff like use line folding, comments in headers, and other things to make their parse code abort. Of course, you then run the risk of breaking compatibility with actual HTTP servers (with good reason-those are bad features and such messages are probably an attack). And of course the ISP can always fix their code.
- atmosx 12y agoApparently you check your mobile connection here: http://lessonslearned.org/sniff http://lessonslearned.org/sniff
- ams1 12y agoProPublica reporter/developer here.. There's a tool embedded in the article to see if your carrier is setting a tracking header. We also published a follow-up about how AT&T has said they will stop using the header: http://www.propublica.org/article/att-stops-using-undeletable-phone-tracking-ids http://www.propublica.org/article/att-stops-using-undeletabl...
- analog31 12y agoMy provider, TracFone, appears to be sending beacons. This is a low cost pay-as-you-go service that buys airtime from the big carriers. My particular phone uses the Verizon network. Is there a way to opt out of this?
- trvz 12y agoWhen I've read the first part of the first sentence, "Twitter's mobile advertising arm enables its clients to use a hidden...", I've thought "I'm a client, but never heard of ... oh, nevermind.".
- biafra 12y agoIt should be possible to counter this by running a proxy somewhere and use that. Privoxy would work for this and while you're at it you can make it remove the ads too.
- gorhill 12y agoYour proxy would need to be after your ISP.
- ben1040 12y agoFor what it's worth, this article is 2 weeks old and it seems Verizon may have either stopped this or is now respecting opt-outs. I'm curious if others are seeing this. While I was definitely getting that header added to my outbound traffic two weeks ago, it is not happening to me now. I noticed that a day or two ago, and it still seems to be the case now.
- sehugg 12y agoNope, they haven't stopped. Reduced a bit, maybe. I'm seeing maybe 5-6% of our HTTP traffic with the X-UIDH header instead of 10% two weeks ago. AT&T's x-acr header, though, seems to be gone, as others have reported. They were about 0.5% of our traffic.
- yclept 12y agoMy phone is still sending this stalking header.
- joshu 12y agoJust checked, I am still transmitting the X-Uidh header.
- gojomo 12y agoSometimes the X-UIDH header goes away, but then returns a day or two later – so don't trust any one all-clear check as resolving the issue.
- lvs 12y agoFor what it's worth, I am no longer seeing the dox header in requests. Something has clearly changed without much fanfare.
- lvs 12y agoFor what it's worth, I am no longer seeing the dox header in requests any longer. Something has clearly changed without much fanfare.
- mschuster91 12y agoAre you f..ing kidding me? If I pay for Internet access, I demand best-effort of the provider to transfer the data packets unmodified (except, for IPv4, NAT usage), shortest way, to the target IP address. I do not pay and then want to get tracked so that the provider or some other dickheads can data-mine me and make even more money. If I want this, I can choose a free plan (e.g. unlimited 3G, but with tracking). About time everyone switches over to HTTPS with HSTS (so that no provider can perform a SSL MITM attack using its own trusted certs).
- ams6110 12y agoYep it's time to just stop using plain HTTP. Unfortunately I think that the number of people who care enough about this to suffer the pain are not enough to change ISP behavior.
- mschuster91 12y agoThe people who care enough will begin to use VPNs anyway. A pity that enabling VPN on mobile equals massive battery drain :'(
- techrat 12y agoAnd breaks custom HOSTS configurations.
- revelation 12y agoI continue to be baffled at this. It seems like we are just all ok with a communications provider manipulating data? I was expecting the feds to bust their doors in. This is US Postal opening every package and rewrapping it to insert advertisements.
- wyager 12y ago> This is US Postal opening every package and rewrapping it to insert advertisements. No, because ISPs aren't common carriers. It's a pretty common political position (among those who care) that ISPs should be common carriers.
- Rizz 12y agoI wonder in how many states doing this is an illegal form of tampering with electronic communications. It seems to me interfering with communications would be illegal unless it is necessary for network operations, which advertising trackers obviously are not.
- gergles 12y agoI still don't understand why I appear to be the only Verizon customer on the Internet that doesn't have this header injected. There is nothing special about my account (other than its age, perhaps, I have only been a Verizon customer since the iPhone 6 release,) but it just doesn't show up for me.
- colordrops 12y agoDid you enable Do Not Track in your browser settings?
- gergles 12y agoAmusingly, yes, but other people reported doing the same and still seeing the header be sent.
- stock_toaster 12y agoDumb question, but are you actually using the cellular network while you test it, and not accidentally using some associated wifi network?
- ohazi 12y agoFWIW, I'm an old Verizon customer (had a grandfathered unlimited plan until about half a year ago), and I also don't see it. Galaxy S4. Edit: apparently this is old and they may have stopped for the moment?
- gojomo 12y agoWhich site are you using to test? Are you sure you're not using any proxies, VPNs, or local wifi? I have seen the header disappear for a brief period, only to return a day later. I've seen another user reporting that the header disappeared after they used all web-based opt-outs, and complained by phone... but then reappeared after traveling to a different region. So there does appear to be some volatility and inconsistency in what Verizon is doing. Also, reportedly, government and some business accounts may be immune. So keep checking, especially after travel: even if you haven't seen it so far, you might someday.
- 12y ago
- guelo 12y ago> Google has proposed a new Internet protocol called SPDY that would prevent these types of header injections – much to the dismay of many telecom companies who are lobbying against it Wow, I was pretty ambivalent about SPDY/HTTP2 before but now I really hope it catches on.
- mschuster91 12y agoActually a binary format (designed to be machine-friendly) is better for MITM injections as it's easier to parse and manipulate... the only benefit of HTTP2/SPDY is that iirc it requires TLS. I'm waiting for the first carrier to perform SSL MITM.
- guelo 12y agoHTTP2 doesn't require encryption but it does compress the headers. I'm guessing compression makes it too CPU-intensive for telecoms to manipulate the headers on the fly.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoI wish they'd require encryption. Perhaps make http:// http:// be TLS but without certificate verification.
- kaoD 12y agoThen the telecoms would MITM it anyways.
- nitrogen 12y agoCertificate pinning and web-of-trust verification would make that difficult to maintain for long.
- kaoD 12y agoIt's unlikely they'll ever get mass usage because both are uncomfortable to work with. If a certificate is compromised, changing it means all pinned clients will get a huge warning. Either the user ignores the warning (in which case pinning is useless) or he doesn't and the site is harmed. Keeping a compromised certificate is even worse. For WoT you first need a web of trusted individuals. Unfortunately key distribution over insecure channels is still an unsolved problem.
- bcl 12y agoA solution to this is to setup openvpn on a VM someplace and route all your phone's data traffic through that. I've done this using the Fedora open vpn guide (https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Openvpn https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Openvpn). To get it working on the iPhone I also had to add this to the server config: push "redirect-gateway" push "dhcp-option DNS 8.8.8.8"
- packetslave 12y agoThe problem with doing this is that now all your web traffic is associated with the IP of the VM, which is presumably even easier to track back to you. You'd have to do something exceedingly clever like have the VM automatically route VPN traffic into Tor.
- bcl 12y agoWell, it depends on your goal. In this case it is to avoid Verizon adding stuff to my http traffic.
- MichaelGG 12y ago"took steps to secure these Device IDs, and began allowing their users to delete them, in the same way they could delete cookies in their desktop Web browser." That's a joke. Android's permission model encourages users to freely give out their device serial number. The permission to read device ID is hidden behind the permission that allows an app to determine if you're on a call. A totally innocuous permission (which should not be a permission) smuggles in a very intrusive one. Oh, and for a kicker, device ID permission also gives apps access to the number of who you call or calls you. So even security conscious users that check permissions can easily get tricked. "Sure, I want this flashlight app to turn off if I get a call so I don't blind myself trying to answer" - bam, you just gave away your permanent ID and call logs. This could be a negligent incompetent mistake on Google's part, but it seems unlikely because it's so nonsensical and they've done nothing to rectify it in years.
- higherpurpose 12y agoI'm also starting to believe that Android's extremely vague permissions are not that vague because of their engineers' incompetence, but because it was done this way on purpose. Google promised at I/O that a permission system with more fine-grain control would come in Lollipop, but it's still nowhere to be seen.
- userbinator 12y agoAgree with this, especially after their fine-grain control App Ops, which received a very positive response, was completely removed, and the reason they gave for doing so quite nonsensical: "it can break apps" - obviously, that's why people want to use it - to prevent apps from "breaking" their personal privacy. (My Android's ID/serial number is 0123456789ABCDEF, the same as tens of millions others out there, so I'm not so worried about it. One of the perks of owning an unbranded generic Chinese device, along with a new random MAC address whenever I reset the WiFi...)
- MichaelGG 12y agoIt's unlikely your IMEI is non unique though.
- r0m4n0 12y agoVerizon has been pushing their "Smart Rewards" program on me for months (http://www.verizonwireless.com/wcms/myverizon/smart-rewards.html http://www.verizonwireless.com/wcms/myverizon/smart-rewards....). After reading the fine print, you are actually consenting to monitoring of all traffic through your account that will be shared to third parties. I respect the fact they have some sort of opt in that has some return... Inho they are swindling the typical oblivious consumer trolling for a free Jamba Juice gift card
- userbinator 12y agoIt's a little amusing and rather sad that the word "smart" now seems to be used to describe products and services that act against their users and often perform surveillance on them, implying that it's somehow a "smart" thing to let this happen.
- gallerytungsten 12y agoIt appears that there is a huge business opportunity for someone to find a way to defeat this type of tracking. Of course, it would probably need to be a subscription type of service, which bodes well for steady recurring revenue.
- MichaelGG 12y agoJust add some mobile-specific marketing to a VPN service.
- tomphoolery 12y agoI suppose...but couldn't they just track you by IP address anyway?
- atesti 12y agoIt would be possible for Verizon to implement this really bad system without anybody noticing and even if Speedy/HTTP 2 or HTTPS is used: Currently they inject the header with an ID which changes e.g. daily and charge third parties to associate the ID with a profile. They can only inject in HTTP. If instead the third party (e.g. an adserver) contacts a Verizon server with the IP (and port number in case of carrier grade NAT) on every request and that server gives back the profile and Verizon charges the adserver for this, then nobody would ever know and there would be not much protection against it (without a third party proxy or vpn to hide the IP).