12 ms·
Smartphones versus DSLRs versus film: A look at how far we've come
- quarterto 12y agoIt would be interesting to see this article today with the iPhone 6/6+'s improved camera: http://petapixel.com/2014/09/24/side-side-comparison-8-iphone-cameras-shows-6-dxomarks-new-king/ http://petapixel.com/2014/09/24/side-side-comparison-8-iphon...
- casca 12y agoTL;DR: "[T]he iPhone 5S currently sits 8-9 years behind the DLSRs in bright light, while the Nokia [Lumia 1020] trails by less than 6 years — probably nearer to 3." "Step into candlelight, [...] the iPhone trails the DSLRs by about 10 years, and the Nokia about 8. "
- higherpurpose 12y agoDespite major hardware drawbacks such as much smaller sensors and cheap lenses, I think computational photography will play a big role in shrinking the gap with current gen DSLR's too, over the next decade. We are slowly managing to put bigger and bigger sensor sizes in phones, too, without any compromises in design, as Sony has shown with its 1/2.3" sensors in the Xperia Z series [1]. Maybe in 2-3 years a 2/3" sensor will fit just as well, too. Again, I'm talking about no compromises in design. I know there are already 1" sensors in some smartphones such as the Panasonic Lumix DMC-CM1 [2], but despite myself being fine with buying such a phone, I assume most OEMs or smartphone customers have no interest in those. [1] - http://www.sonymobile.com/global-en/products/phones/xperia-z3/ http://www.sonymobile.com/global-en/products/phones/xperia-z... [2] - http://www.panasonic.com/de/consumer/foto-video/lumix-kompaktkameras/dmc-cm1.html http://www.panasonic.com/de/consumer/foto-video/lumix-kompak...
- CalRobert 12y agoNot sure if it's what you meant by computational, but some pocket cameras already apply software correction to known lens distortions. The Sony RX100, for instance, which is presumably how they can have a 1" sensor and very bright lens in a really small camera.
- jarek 12y ago> We are slowly managing to put bigger and bigger sensor sizes in phones, too, without any compromises in design It helps that the phones are getting bigger. The camera in my Nexus 5 is a ton better than in my old Blackberry Pearl, but the phone is also twice the horizontal size. The lens will be a bigger problem, though...
- vanderZwan 12y agoThere's two things I care about in a digital camera: low light performance, and dynamic range. I don't care about how much megapixels you can cram in there - if your lens is pixel-perfect, 6 is enough for most purposes anyway. The only reason I might want to upgrade from my Canon 40D is a drastically improved dynamic range, a compacter size and the ability to shoot movies. So far it's all not quite there yet to be worth it, from my point of view. Plus, I'm having more fun developing my pictures taken with my Nikon FM2 anyway. Ironically, recenty the Nokia approach with supersampling seems to have paid off most regarding low-light and dynamic range performance of phone cameras (especially dynamic range, which this article didn't address). I hope the others will catch up.
- higherpurpose 12y agoI doubt super-sampling beats Google's HDR+ [1] in either range or speed (the 1020 takes about 4 seconds per "normal" picture). The 1020 does have much better details and such, but that's most likely due to a 4x bigger sensor and higher quality lens. [1] - http://googleresearch.blogspot.com/2014/10/hdr-low-light-and-high-dynamic-range.html http://googleresearch.blogspot.com/2014/10/hdr-low-light-and...
- vanderZwan 12y agoThose 4 seconds are due to post-processing one sensor image. Google's HDR+ combines multiple images in a novel way to create a higher dynamic range. In theory you could use that with the Nokia camera as well. Of course, that would slow it down even further.
- ars 12y agoAnd shutter lag. There is nothing worse than missing every single shot (or having them all blurry) because the shutter took too long.
- CalRobert 12y agoIs this still an issue? I can't recall using a camera made in the last 6 years that didn't take the picture near-instantly so long as you did the normal half-press prefocus, or used manual focus.
- xyzzy123 12y agoWhile there is clearly a sensor gap, this actually sounds like a huge and valuable application problem. DSLRs are not conventionally software extensible, while phones are...
- DanBC 12y agoIsn't that because DSLR manufacturers don't want people with an entry level phone getting the same software as the pro-sumer phone, or the pro-sumers upgrading software to the pro version?
- alkonaut 12y agoThe processing of dslr photos usually takes place outside the camera (raw conversion etc.), so my requirements for in-camera processing are quite small for a dslr. For my smartphone on the other hand I need pictures usable directly (typically).
- antihero 12y agoThat said, it would be really nice if you could take RAW in Android/iOS. Is there even possibly a way with the current APIs/drivers?
- maaaats 12y agoLumia 1020, 1520 and some other Windows phones support RAW.
- andrewaylett 12y agoAndroid 5.0 introduces APIs that let camera apps get raw images, but the standard apps don't use those APIs yet.
- vibrolax 12y agoThe camera2 api in the just-release Android 5.0 contains support for RAW images. The current Nexus camera app doesn't use it yet. https://developer.android.com/reference/android/hardware/camera2/package-summary.html https://developer.android.com/reference/android/hardware/cam...
- alkonaut 12y agoSure the tiny sensors of gadgets have come a long way, but looking at it from the other perspective: what are the trends in enthusiast "big" cameras? Basically it's sensor growing. This is of course mainly driven by shrinking costs of manufacturing sensors, but there is still a huge cost in terms of bulk and weight to carry a camera with a 35mm sensor. Yet this is still something people want to do. Sadly photography is still very much a physics game, and while there is some room for improvement in sensor tech, and cheating e.g with multiple exposures, even a ten-fold increase in dynamic range and sensitivity wouldn't make large sensors obsolete.
- easytiger 12y agoSurely its more about the fact that lenses have to be a certain size.
- alkonaut 12y agoLenses have to be a certain size of the sensors and apertures are a certain size. And those sizes are fixed, for a given image (with a specific depth of field etc). So physics (the optics) is a thing. A breakthrough in optics that removed the need for heavy glass to bend light would be a revolution.
- custardcream 12y agoThis. to quote my father (who is actually a professional photographer): Pissy lens; pissy photo. You need chunks of glass at the moment regardless of sensor size. I carry a basic DSLR around with me (D3100) and a decent but cheap lens (AF-S DX 18-55) and a shit smartphone. They cost less than a good smartphone and the results are amazing.
- danieltillett 12y agoI was under the impression that there are basically not enough photons at the sizes that most smart phones sensors are. Once you get to low light levels a tiny sensor just can't be fed enough photons to give a good picture.
- pingec 12y agoSo where do cheaper (100-200$), non-DSLR compact digital cameras stand? Do they have any advantages left over those integrated in mobile phones or have they become obsolete?
- rickyc091 12y agoI think there's always a place for hardware dedicated for a particular task. Most of my relatives either don't have a smartphone or they still use the basic flip phones, so a simple compact camera simplifies things for them. I have friends that Instagram with their smartphones, but they still want a dedicated point and shoot for vacation purposes and events. While iPhone and Nokia may have a 6 year gap, the other mobile phones probably lag another 3 years behind them.
- hrktb 12y agoThey can still have additional features like waterproof and shockproof. Also the low price and single use means you'll use it in occasions you wouldn't bring your precious smartphone. it is becoming more and more a niche, but there is room to evolve.
- higherpurpose 12y agoIf you're comparing a $200 compact to a $200 phone, then chances are high that the compact is still better, keeping in mind that you're paying $200 for only the camera that you still have to take with you. If you're comparing a phone that has high-end specs in every way, plus a good camera, and costs $600, that camera should be better than most $200 compacts at this point. I think the game is over for compacts, even if all you can afford is a $200-$300 subsidized phone, and not a high-end one. My new Moto G 2014 takes quite good pictures with very little noise. Not only is the game over for compacts, but many people who perhaps before would've bought a sub-$1,000 DSLR to take vacation pictures, now don't feel the need to do tat anymore if they have a current-generation high-end phone that costs $600-$700, even if that $1,000 DSLR would be significantly better. The $600 phone cameras have become "good enough" for many people, except for those perhaps that have no trouble buying a $600 phone and a $1,000, or $2,000 or $3,000 DSLR to take with them in vacations. If I were the CEO of a camera company, I would've started focusing on the smartphone market 3+ years ago, from multiple angles: making my own "cameraphone" (such as Lumix CM1), selling "low-end" lenses for smartphones (that should still be significantly better than the ones others make for smartphones right now, that don't have experience in high-end cameras), and through other type of know-how/technology licensing that would help smartphone companies accelerate how good their phone cameras become - with my company cashing in on all of that. Out of Sony, Nikon, Canon, Panasonic, Samsung and so on, Sony is perhaps the best suited to do that. Not only are its smartphone sensors already highly popular, but it's also one of the top high-end camera makers. They also have their own smartphone company, so they have smartphone know-how, while others like Nikon or Panasonic don't. They could have so much synergy from that. Unfortunately, Sony's strategy in this is complete crap. The fact that their smartphone sensors are the most popular is probably mostly a coincidence, or inertia from bygone times, because none of the other strategies match it. Instead of making its own ultra-high-end cameraphone, Sony makes dumb camera accessories that nobody wants to use. Nokia received a lot of praise for its big bold 1020 camera, which had a halo effect on all of its other smartphones, too. Instead of trying to be recognized as having the best cameras, at least in the Android world, Sony rarely reaches top 3, because of bad software. And things are somewhat okay at the high-end, but all of their other phones have terrible cameras (both software and hardware). Sony is in a unique smartphone/camera intersection and they aren't anywhere near close to taking full advantage of it. Apple continuously beats them, even though Apple uses Sony's own sensors that are one or even two generations behind Sony's current smartphone sensors. To be honest, that's a complete disgrace. If I were Sony's CEO and I'd be in charge of such a disgrace for a few years already, I'd probably quit myself in shame - especially if I was Japanese (who, I think still care about honor and such things?) - and let someone better take charge.
- ghshephard 12y agoThe quality of your shot on a DSLR is, in many ways, a function of the glass you put on it. Do you have a stock 70-200 that you paid $500, or a fast-prime that you paid $2000 for? 99.99% of people don't put an external lens on their smartphone, so, that pretty much ends the conversation right there. And there are entire arenas of photography that aren't even possible on a smartphone - wildlife photography is pretty much the zone of the 800mm+ lenses. Really - so much of photography is about the lens, and honestly, except for low-light photography, the average $2k digital body from 2005 will get the job done today.
- pxndx 12y agoThat's the reason why the test included a cheap lens and a $1700 one.
- heartbreak 12y agoOne might claim that a $1,700 lens is a cheap lens. A fast prime for wildlife would be something along the lines of a 600mm f2.8. That's a $12,000 Canon lens.
- ghshephard 12y agoBut placing a cheap lens on a DSLR is basically crippling it. You might get some low-light advantages and a bit faster focus speed - but the entire purpose of a DSLR is to let you use the best lens for the situation. I read the review when it originally came out, and, while impressed with the hard work they put into it - It just felt like so much of an apples vs oranges comparison that I didn't get what they were trying to do.
- cookiecaper 12y agoI've found that a lot of DSLR owners end up just sticking with the stock lens. Lenses are really expensive and stock lenses are usually pretty adaptable. For this reason, I've begun to prefer high-end point-and-shoots like the Powershot G16; it has many more features and much better processing abilities than my old Digital Rebel, and since realistically I'm not going to lug around the DSLR and 5+ lenses for any situation that may arise, I've found P&S cameras to be much more convenient and very versatile. I would only use my DSLR if I knew I would need to photograph some circumstance that my P&S couldn't handle. I know this makes me a black sheep within the photography community and there are lots of people who like to make fun of me for it, but the reality is that unless you're trying to get a specific shot, a versatile, general-purpose lens is all you take with you on your DSLR anyway, and you're better off using the lighter, smaller, cheaper P&S.
- aruggirello 12y agoOne of the things that worry me, as I still enjoy shooting and am perfectly satisfied with my 6 megapixel DSLR camera, is programmed obsolescence. My camera, bought in 2006, is perfectly fine, the shutter still has a long way to go before hitting the 100 thousand actuations (it's just about halfway - and it may be repaired in the event it breaks), and I don't see the point why it may just stop functioning in a couple years. I also have a fancy new 24mp D5200, but I still find the old one useful - this thing is irritating. I noticed the infamous symbol (two arrows surrounding a friendly "10") on the bottom of most of the DSLR camera models currently on sale from major manufacturers (Nikon, Canon, Sony) - with the possible exception of Pentax.
- gambiting 12y agoI am not sure if I follow. What makes you think that your camera will stop working? And what is the symbol you mention about?
- aruggirello 12y agoThe reason is the 10 years - somewhere in the electronics of the camera, some components (like capacitors, etc.) employ some different materials/process so that it is more environment-friendly once disposed. This is good, except that it means they will quietly fail in about 10 years (of course, from manufacturing date, not from when I bought the camera). The net result is, the camera will soon stop working despite being in excellent condition and, after 10 years, will at least require servicing. A currently 25 years old SLR will still be perfectly working!!! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence
- yitchelle 12y agoI am not 100% sure you can classified this as planned obsolescence. It is the nature of the product. ie, the capacitors used only have a relative short life and will fail within 10 years. Just like the SLR will stop working, just much more later in time. It is just the way it is. Planned obsolescence would be if the camera manufacturer specifically design to product to stop working in a specific time frame. They might do this for commercial, legal or safety reasons.
- rdb 12y agoOne primary issue that we've seen with using smartphones as a primary camera is that you're forced to always shoot with a large depth of field, which means that you miss out on achieving that sought after bokeh for your close up or portrait shots. I've actually been working with a team of former post-doc researchers who've been using SIFT flow techniques to estimate depth information in an image and apply filters to emulate different depths of field - effectively allowing for an image captured with a smartphone to look like it was shot with a different lens (see https://www.dropbox.com/s/7qhfgnwl08vtk63/compare.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/7qhfgnwl08vtk63/compare.png?dl=0). We've got some pretty cool demos if anyone's interested.
- danielbln 12y agoIs that related to Google's lens blur that's now in most modern Android phones? http://googleresearch.blogspot.de/2014/04/lens-blur-in-new-google-camera-app.html http://googleresearch.blogspot.de/2014/04/lens-blur-in-new-g...
- rdb 12y agoGoogle's approach requires multiple images to be captured of the same subject from different angles in order to triangulate depth - our SIFT flow based approach can achieve similar performance using only a single image. This makes it as simple as capturing a normal image to capture one with an editable depth of field.
- jacquesm 12y agoI assume that only goes for those situations where you are reducing depth of field. As in, sharper backgrounds or foregrounds can become blurry but not the other way around.
- rdb 12y agoWe've only looked at reducing the depth of field as the narrow aperture on smartphone cameras leads to an extended depth of field (meaning that everything is usually in focus within the frame).
- qznc 12y agoWill Android 5's ability to shot in RAW format change that even more?
- barrkel 12y agoThis is the second time I've read this article. Or, gotten sucked into this article, more like. In bright light outside, I expected a fair fight between the phones and DSLRs. In dim light, I expected the DSLRs to eat the phones for breakfast. So, how do they compare? I thought I knew. It turned out that I was completely wrong. Read on to find the answers. In what way was he completely wrong? DSLRs eat the phones for breakfast in dim light, while they have a narrowish margin (against Lumia 1020) in bright light. The first page sets you up for a surprise, but it never comes. Of course, the lens you put on the DSLR makes as big a difference as you're willing to invest. That's why they'll never really be comparable.
- mod 12y ago> Of course, the lens you put on the DSLR makes as big a difference as you're willing to invest. That's why they'll never really be comparable. For a layperson, I don't think this is true. It takes a professional to extract the extra difference between say, a 50mm f/1.8 (~$100) and 50mm f/1.2 (~$1500). In fact, if I handed them both to a newbie, I'd expect them to do better with the 1.8. Myself included. That said, the f/1.8 is a bit exceptional, especially for its price.
- chrisduesing 12y ago50mm is an aberration, it is the only glass you can get <f/1.8 affordably (35mm are ok in this regard as well). Go check out the price of a <=f/2 100m+, which is much more suited to portrait, macro, etc. Then go look at <f/4 for 200m+ for wildlife and sports. Now you see why it is so damn expensive to be a professional photographer, and why the average person isnt posting stunning wildlife or safari shots to their facebook wall.
- annnnd 12y ago> The graph is misleading at first glance because the phones and the cameras sit on different scales... > Note that the scales for the DSLRs and the phones are different and not directly comparable... It looks like graph is misleading at second glance too. :) Author is comparing the steepness of the curves, which is closely related to scale. If you change the scale for phones you can make their progress much slower. Not saying the phones won't reach DSLRs in terms of image quality, just that this graph should not be interpreted in this way.
- thisjepisje 12y agoThe Sigma DP3M has a foveon sensor instead of a regular sensor with bayer filter array. It's based on different wavelengths of light penetrating silicon to different depths, which means that all 3 colours are stacked on top of each other, so you don't have to throw away 3/4 of your photons just because they happen to be a different colour than the dot they fall on. At low ISO the image quality is amazing, at high ISO it's very noisy. Also, the red channel is much noisier than the blue one. http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ab/Absorption-X3.png http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ab/Absorptio...
- Brian-Puccio 12y agoI'm curious why they didn't include any medium format cameras (let alone large format cameras with movements ... how much does a 4x5 digital back cost?). For under $2000, you can get a new 6x7 rangefinder with fixed lens and you'll pull tons more detail out of a slide or negative that large than you would out of a 35mm slide/neg. If you're willing to buy used (and why wouldn't you considering they're using digital cameras from 2003 in this review) you can get an awesome medium format or large format system for under $1000.
- foldr 12y agoI basically agree with you, but the price is a bit misleading if you don't include the cost of the scanner. I love shooting medium format, but on my $250 Epson the results are barely better (in terms of resolution) than I get from my iPhone 4S. Getting all the detail out of a negative usually works out pretty expensive. (Wet printing is cheap way to do it but it's really time consuming.)
- Brian-Puccio 12y agoI agree, scanning can be expensive (I've got a Coolscan for 35mm and I'm eyeing a v700 for 4x5). But if prints are the desired end result, it's still less than $10 to develop and print a roll of 35mm film. What's the price and cost of an inkjet, paper and ink carts? Then again, if all you're doing is taking quick snapshots to upload to instagram, just use whatever smartphone you have and don't bother buying an actual camera.
- foldr 12y agoYes, if you want prints then film is still an economical option. I think 120 film is kind of awkward for scanning because there are no affordable dedicated film scanners which handle it but it's still not quite big enough to get really good results from a flatbad. (It's tough to get more than 1200dpi of real resolution out of a flatbed and that only gives you 8MP for 6x6 negatives.)
- aphrax 12y agoI shot using Velvia 50 for many years (as mentioned in this article) and still yearn for that combination of grain/saturation - at least I think that's it, it's quite hard to put my finger on what was/is so fantastic about that particular film.
- mod 12y agoWhy is the most recent Canon in the examples from 2007?
- bsenftner 12y agoFor anyone working with or on computer vision applications, the difference is startling obvious: anything with a lens larger than the typical mobile phone/tablet slightly-larger-than-a-pinhole produces useful images, whereas mobile camera images are impressionistic blotchy messes. The reason they have such high megapixels is to hide that their pixel quality is piss-poor. I retain a consumer Canon A40 purchased in '98 for use with computer vision purposes; the highest resolution image it produces is 1024x768 - BUT EVERY SINGLE PIXEL IS STABLE AND CORRECTLY COLOR TONED. There is no blotchy pixel clumps revealed with a zoom. I also have access to a Nikon D7100, and my old Canon A40 produces more stable pixels and is better for computer vision.
- ajross 12y agoIndeed. It's almost like the intended use case of a phone in your pocket, piggy-backing on the same device you use to call your friends or tell the time, is something other than computer vision. I mean, I'm all for well-applied snobbery and picking the correct tools for the job. But, come on. A 30-second perusal of cute family photos on Facebook and a comparison to the photo album you used 15 years ago will tell you exactly what these devices are good for.
- knodi123 12y agoI'm just sad that I've still never had a cell phone conversation as quick and crisp as I had over a landline in the early 80s.
- foldr 12y agoI don't understand why these sorts of comparisons always contain wild exaggerations regarding differences in lens quality. For example, the author claims that the following pair of corner crops (which differ only in the lens used) illustrate a "dramatic" difference in sharpness: http://1.static.img-dpreview.com/files/p/TS250x0~cms_posts%2F5533410947%2FCanon-EOS-40D-1855-EV15jpeg.jpg?v=3009 http://1.static.img-dpreview.com/files/p/TS250x0~cms_posts%2... http://4.static.img-dpreview.com/files/p/TS250x0~cms_posts%2F5533410947%2FCanonEOS40D-1635-edgeEV15raw.jpg?v=3009 http://4.static.img-dpreview.com/files/p/TS250x0~cms_posts%2... In fact there is no actual detail that is visible in the one image but not the other (especially given the "smudging" from the noise reduction). The small difference in contrast (if this isn't just due to a change in lighting conditions) is easily fixed in Photoshop. All of this is to be expected given that both lenses are being used at f8 here, and any half-decent lens will give good sharpness across the whole image at that aperture.
- jff 12y agoI have a Pentax K-50 DSLR and a Pentax ME Super 35mm SLR. I love the pictures from the DSLR, but the size and feel of the film camera cannot be beat. It's about half the size of the K-50 and all the controls are quite simple. Developing film is fun too, kind of nerve-wracking because you're pouring in chemicals blind but then you open it up and pull out this lovely strip of negatives and you can see it all came out OK.