7 ms·
Why I might buy an Echo: - it's a speaker with extra features. At about the same price as a bluetooth speaker, and I need a better one of those, the extra fe
by bryanlarsen 12y ago
Why I might buy an Echo:
- it's a speaker with extra features. At about the same price as a bluetooth speaker, and I need a better one of those, the extra features are basically free as long as the audio quality is good.
- it can answer questions at the dinner table. My wife and I both have the annoying habit of pulling out our phones to answer questions that come up during conversation. Asking "Alexa" instead would be much more socially pleasant.
- it can stream music without the hassle of bluetooth. Bluetooth streaming becomes less convenient when you don't know which of the many computers, phones or tablets were used to start the music, or where it is...
- my three year old can probably figure out how to use it
Thought I'd throw those out there, and start a "positive" thread. This discussion is overwhelmingly negative. Lots of good points being made in the negative comments, but there are some nice positives, too.
- dave1619 12y agoI definitely agree. I'd use it mostly for a bluetooth music streaming speaker. And for $99 (since I'm a prime member) it's a good price. All the other features are extra and I don't know which ones I'd end up actually using on a regular basis. But it would be cool to try out.
- taternuts 12y agoThis was my train of thought as well, but it ended in me researching mini bluetooth speakers and buying one of those instead. The features enabled by Echo are kind of cool and all, but I don't think I'd use them at all and the security stuff is obviously enough of a concern to make me think twice. It wonder why they didn't try to add a wifi kill-switch kind of thing for the paranoid who would just use it for a blue-tooth speaker
- lurkingperson 12y agothere's a button on top to turn the listening feature off
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoWhich actually activates the stream-to-NSA feature /paranoia.
- readerrrr 12y agoYou are trading your so far rarely touched privacy for solving minor first world annoyances.
- freehunter 12y ago>You are trading your so far rarely touched privacy Prove it. Seriously, don't speculate like this until it's proven one way or the other. Prove that it violates my privacy and then we will talk.
- readerrrr 12y agoYou must be joking. Why don't you "prove" that all the metadata is not used for commercial purposes, and that metadata isn't available to government agencies.
- discipline 12y agoNo, you must be joking. The burden of proof in an argument has to be borne by the one making the claim. If you claim you saw a UFO, the burden of proof is on you. The burden of proof does not fall on everyone else to prove that what you saw could NOT, in any way, shape, or form, possibly be a UFO.
- orbifold 12y agoIt is established by now that various government agencies all over the world routinely monitor web traffic, tap phones and install trojans on computers. There is no doubt in my mind that an internet connected listening device would be exploited.
- runeks 12y agoSo smartphone, tablets, laptops are also exploited? They all have a microphone and they're never off. I fail to see how this is any more a possible privacy breach than my iPhone that's laying right next to me right now.
- stronglikedan 12y agoWhile we're being positive, I absolutely do not think Amazon would be stupid enough to shoot themselves in the foot sending all recorded data up to the cloud. I'm certain that within a few hours of release, someone will have a network monitor hooked up. Their findings will be widely known almost immediately, and this thing would be dead in the water if they were sending everything up. They know this already.
- antsar 12y agoSmartTV and other home-automation-with-voice-recognition device manufacturers would like a word with you.
- atmosx 12y agoActually it's the other way around. We (as consumers) should have a word with them.
- cmicali 12y agoThis very likely uses network speech recognition, so most things (except for the wake-up word) are being streamed up and recognized in Amazon's data center (Siri, SVoice, etc all do this also)
- stronglikedan 12y agoExactly. Casual conversation won't be sent up; only commands.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gisely 12y agoDoesn't mean the NSA or Chinese equivalent won't figure out how to hack Echo to plant a little piece of stealthware on it that records all conversations of suspects in "terrorism related" investigations. Such stealthware might get detected once or twice (though not often-- it won't be ubiquitous), but such detections will easily covered up by forcing Amazon to announce a rare and obscure firmware bug backstory. Actually, come to think of it, with proper contextual targeting, such stealthware wouldn't even need to send full conversations. Just wait for detection of "the meeting" or "the rally" and boom spend off all the info you need to effectively disrupt pro-democracy rallies in Hong Kong.
- jameshart 12y agoYour three year old probably can't use it. Current voice recognition - Siri, kinect, et al - all seem to struggle with child voices. Maybe something they've expressly worked on for this 'home assistant' scenario, but I don't hold out much hope. It's a general pattern that early releases of human-interaction tech tend to optimize for 50th percentile western males.
- LockeWatts 12y agoWhy wouldn't they? If they're being released in the west, they're optimizing for their largest target demographic.
- duskwuff 12y agoChildren generally don't enunciate as clearly as adults. Their speech is more difficult for a computer (or a human who doesn't know the language well!) to understand.
- famousactress 12y agoSiri literally said "You're a baby!" to my 1.5 year old daughter the other day when she tried to talk to it.
- swalsh 12y agoAs a person, I struggle with 3 year old voices... I think its just that they are still learning how to properly form words.
- aidenn0 12y agoWhen one of my daughters was 3 someone handed an iphone with one of those apps with an animal that repeats things back. She said something with the word "color" in it, but it came out "cala." It repeated it back (incorrectly) and then she got stuck in a loop of saying "not cala, cala!" and it repeating it back, getting more frustrated each time.
- flanbiscuit 12y ago> - it can answer questions at the dinner table... that would be my biggest use for it, well that and as a speaker I guess. I really hope that I can swap out "Alexa" for the word "Computer" so I could feel like I'm one step closer to Star Trek
- mamikonyana 12y agofrom the video: "..it only hears you when you use the wake word we chose..", so you can definitely chose "Computer" as your wake word
- jarin 12y agoNow they just need a Paul Bettany voice pack.
- joemi 12y agoThat's pretty good, but it's second place to my desire for a Majel Barrett voice pack.
- pdaddyo 12y agoFunnily enough, Google Now's voice search was originally called "Project Majel" for that reason - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Now#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Now#History
- delecti 12y agoThat doesn't necessarily mean that any word is an option, just that your set of options is larger than 1.
- Tyrannosaurs 12y agoIsn't this patently false? If it's not listening how can it hear the wake word?
- 12y ago
- greedo 12y agoThe idea of this sitting on my dining room table while eating with my family is horrifying.
- richardwhiuk 12y agoI hope you don't put your phone on the table while eating with your family, or have it in your pocket at that time.
- greedo 12y agoNope. We have a family rule that dinner time is an electronics free zone.
- richardwhiuk 12y agoOr in your pocket for that matter - yes, the acoustics are pretty much good enough to pick up everything you say.
- daturkel 12y agoEdit: I missed this: "Plus, Echo is Bluetooth-enabled so you can stream your favorite music services like Spotify, iTunes, and Pandora from your phone or tablet," which obsoletes some of the below. The point on monophonic audio still stands. Out of curiosity, are you already embedded in the amazon cloud music ecosystem? I'm one of those luddites who still has a library of mp3s—I don't want to have to figure out what I can or can't get on some compatible streaming service here. That would be a lovely feature—if it had an aux-in port or bluetooth compatibility so I could still use it as a dumb speaker. Smart TV's still have inputs, e.g. Additionally, if I'm not mistaken, it's monophone? Dual-driver, but only one "360-degree" channel of some sort?
- smellf 12y agoI am also a "library of mp3 luddites", and to me it sounds as though the Echo can do any Bluetooth audio, like a modern head unit. So you might say, "Computer, play Bluetooth audio", or "Computer, skip this track," and it would work just like pressing play and skip in your car. This may just be wishful thinking on my part, however.
- samshih 12y ago> it's a speaker with extra features. This is so true! Nice speaker with add-on capabilities, definitely a plus and will probably buy!
- zan2434 12y agoactually, it doesn't have a battery, so it won't replace an ordinary bluetooth speaker. I was optimistic too :(
- Fuzzwah 12y agoI attempted to start a positive comments thread earlier, yours seems to have done far better so I'm going to repost my thoughts here too: I've requested an invite. I see it as a replacement for the ditigal photoframe pc I built a few years back out of an old laptop and have in my kitchen. Its running XP with a heap of autoIT scripts I hacked together, controlled by an MCE remote. I use it every day to listen to news headlines and check the weather while making my morning coffee and for streaming jazz while cooking dinner. I think I'd prefer asking Echo to play these things than going through the hassle of upgrading the photoframe pc from XP. I'd gain some functions such as easier music streaming, shopping list stuff, etc. I'd lose a few functions; I occassionally use VNC on the photoframe pc to display a recipe or twitch stream. I can do the recipe on my phone and put the twitch stream on my TV and turn it so I can see it from the kitchen.