11 ms·
Teacher spends two days as a student and is shocked at what she learns
- rootlocus 12y agoAren't teachers supposed to go through college / university before they become teachers? Why are their own experiences irrelevant?
- pyre 12y agoWasn't there a previous discussion/article on this (or at least something very similar)?
- mhartl 12y agoYes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8442067 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8442067
- misuba 12y ago...does she learn how to write clickbait headlines?
- joelrunyon 12y agoThe only thing worse than "clickbait" headlines are comments complaining about clickbait headlines. If you don't like the article - don't read it.
- lozf 12y agoI stopped reading the article after the missing "the" in the third sentence.
- mwfunk 12y agoThe headline must have changed since the link was posted to HN- it's currently "Teacher spends two days as a student and is shocked at what she learns", which is about as matter-of-fact and non-clickbaity as it gets. It's just a literal description of the article contents. What was it originally that was so sensationalistic?
- akerl_ 12y ago"$person does $thing and is shocked by what they find/learn/discover" is definitely in the first chapter of the Blogger's Guide To Clickbait Titles.
- pher 12y agoIt's the word shocked. You're not wrong, there is nothing wrong with the post title in itself. But the internet has caused a lot of people to falsely attribute some form of grandeur to innocuous content in order to get you to click on the article. It's the crossroads of intellectualism with capitalism. The point is we're all striving for the most clicks because clicks translate to dollars, either directly in the form of advertising, or a personal brand. But on HN, it's considered gauche to acquire links in this nature. You should be getting the clicks because the content is worthy, not the title.
- otikik 12y ago... you will be amazed at what he learns!
- swartkrans 12y agoI flagged this and didn't read it just because of the title.
- folz 12y agoSaved you a click (from the top comment the last time this was posted): The three points from the article: > [1] Students sit all day, and sitting is exhausting. > [2] High School students are sitting passively and listening during approximately 90% of their classes. > [3] You feel a little bit like a nuisance all day long. People wonder why high school aged students are unruly, unpleasant, and filled with deep negative emotions (anger, disdain, need-to-rebel). I look at this list (especially [2] and the lack of autonomy that follows) and the reason seems really clear. The basic model seems broken. Previous discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8442067 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8442067 Original source of the story here: http://grantwiggins.wordpress.com/2014/10/10/a-veteran-teacher-turned-coach-shadows-2-students-for-2-days-a-sobering-lesson-learned/ http://grantwiggins.wordpress.com/2014/10/10/a-veteran-teach...
- vacri 12y agoPeople wonder why high school aged students are unruly, unpleasant, and filled with deep negative emotions (anger, disdain, need-to-rebel) They don't wonder it at all; it's not some mystery solved by sitting in a classroom. Adolescents, as a demographic, have always been known to be raging pits of hormones with mood swings and strong passions. Items 1 and 3 are common in the working world, and there's a few jobs out there as a 2 as well (particularly if you focus on the 'lack of autonomy' part), yet we don't see the same kinds of behaviour from those workers. Adolescence is a time where you're finally becoming an adult, finding where the boundaries are, and putting your own flavour on life. There's a certain amount of experimentation with that, and it's entirely normal to have more unruliness amongst adolescents.
- nilkn 12y agoI do sit a lot during my day job, but I can tell you that my sitting conditions are vastly more preferable than those of the typical high school student. I sit in an $800+ chair, with a desk with more space than I need, next to a huge window. I can get up anytime I want and go for a walk or break. In high school, I sat in chairs that often felt like they were going to fall apart, and my butt was numb or in pain half the time and sometimes my back too. The desk rarely was big enough to accommodate even just a book and a sheet of paper side by side, which was incredibly infuriating to me. Classrooms were typically horrifyingly dreary. And just getting up to stretch or walk around often wasn't an option.
- derekp7 12y agoWhy is this so surprising? Wasn't every teacher a high school student at some point? Is the experience so traumatic that they completely forget what the schedule was like once they become teachers themselves?
- inclemnet 12y agoYou don't need trauma to just forget things. You've experienced many hours of continuous stimulation every day for years, and most of that is naturally thrown away, including the mental impact of experiences that seem at the time like they will always stay with you. Plus, it seems reasonable that doing the same tasks from the point of view of actually being the teacher, now having a lot more life experience and other things to think about, should make previously normal parts of the experience stand out. If you think this should be unnecessary, and 'obvious' just from thinking back to your own school days, I think you are either highly abnormal or simply wrong.
- derekp7 12y ago::I think you are either highly abnormal or simply wrong. Is it really that abnormal to remember the stresses of a bad situation, especially when you transitioned to a better one? I can see people not thinking anything is wrong while they are going through the experience, but I really can't find anyone that I know, at least, who thinks high school was a worthwhile experience. And who hasn't had that feeling of relief at the beginning of summer break, and that sick feeling in the pit of their stomach when summer was over? Or recognized immediately on the first day of college that a student actually can be treated like a person, not an inmate? I recall sitting in a college class that had a recent high school graduate in it, and he raised his hand asking if he could use the washroom. The instructor just looked at him and told him that he is in the real world now, and doesn't need to get permission for a normal bodily function. Of course, you might be right, in that I probably spend too much time reflecting on something from 25 years ago. It is the main reason that I don't put up with BS from people I work with -- had enough of that from school teachers. But it is possible that it affected me bad enough that I could probably use some counseling about it, if it is considered normal to just forget about what high school (and junior high, to an extent) was like.
- cmdrfred 12y agoHow can someone who has been teaching for 14 years pass themselves off as a 16 year old?
- scoot 12y agoOFFS, RTFA.
- cmdrfred 12y agoThe question stands, She isn't experiencing what a student experiences she is experiencing what a student experiences when there is another adult in the room. Two very different things.
- vacri 12y agoAre you taking the position that she can gain no useful insight at all from the activity?
- cmdrfred 12y agoNo but the problem with the schools isn't that kids don't get to play basketball a minute before class. My history teacher sent me to the office for saying columbus was a slaver, my computer teacher wrote me up for proving he wrote insecure code (sql injection), my science teacher chewed me out for stating that every legitimate scientific body acknowledges evolution is a fact. The problem is the education system isn't about education it's about control.
- prawn 12y agoYour question was about passing off rather than experiencing.
- intopieces 12y agoI do wish that my school had had the block scheduling this school seems to have. We had 8 periods in a day (school was a half period) and they were all ~50 minutes. This is barely enough time to accomplish anything, and days where the classes were shorter (teachers' meetings) then each class was worthless.
- bcaine 12y agoThe problem is that it's near impossible for a student to pay attention during longer classes. I think you're trying to measure accomplishing things by the amount of material you work through during a given class, instead of by the amount of information the student actually absorbs during that time. That seemed to be one of the main points in the article, just getting through material was a terrible way to look at classroom learning.
- intopieces 12y ago>The problem is that it's near impossible for a student to pay attention during longer classes. Impossible seems a bit harsh. The situation could certainly be improved, and it might certainly be improved if the instructor has more time to engage in students as individuals, which can't be done much in a short period system (this was my main complaint with HS and why I never took a huge lecture course). I do agree that the current method of engagement, overall, is not ideal.
- wmt 12y agoThe problem is not the engagement as much as trying to sit and pay attention for 90 minutes. You will way better results by having a 5-15 minute break every 45 minutes.
- bzbarsky 12y agoIt really depends on the class. Lectures of any sort longer than an hour are pretty painful. Science lab classes shorter than an hour are likewise pretty painful. Designing a schedule that can accommodate both is not easy and people typically don't even try (though they should!).
- Sambdala 12y agoI remember high school. During class I hid whatever book I actually wanted to read at the time inside the class book and drowned out the teacher. If homework was worth >10% of the total grade for the class (so that you couldn't get an A from tests/quizzes alone), I would copy the homework from someone else the period before. Tests & quizzes are so gameable it's a complete joke. Standardized tests even more so. Without any actual learning from the class itself, you can generally come close to ace'ing most high school tests by being moderately intelligent. There was one class where I got busted for copying the homework and actually had to apply myself for the rest of the semester to avoid being failed, and this was only because the teacher felt I could rise to my potential if challenged to do so. Thankfully, that was actually one of the more interesting classes I had to attend. I was warned constantly that college was going to tear me apart if I didn't instill good study habits, but it was mostly more of the same. It actually required even less work because most classes relied more heavily on quiz & test scores than High School did. After my freshman year, I went to class about 2 hours a week (out of ~18) and still kept above a 3.5 GPA. At the two corporate jobs I've held so far, the same formula still seems to apply where you can avoid applying yourself 98% of the time as long as you can shine during the corporate equivalent of "tests." To date, it's the hardest thing in the world for me to garner the self control to apply myself to a task if I'm not passionate about it (even forcing myself to pay bills is a challenge), and I think a large part of that is due to the fact that I've been able to coast through every "challenge" quite easily, and everything has seemed to work itself out so far. This next month I'm actually striking out on my own, thankfully on something I'm passionate about (and have been working on for the past six months on the side), and I'm scared to death I won't be able to actually follow through on the hard work required to be successful as an entrepreneur.
- zrail 12y agoI've experienced similar, to a lesser extent (I never cheated, I just didn't do the homework). I also recently struck out on my own and so far I've been successful. In your case, you may want to just farm out all of the non-passion-inducing work. Accountants, book keepers, virtual assistance, all of these are there to help you succeed.
- 12y ago
- aarohmankad 12y agoThis is one of the reasons I like my school. Points 1 and 3 in the article are pretty close to nonexistent. [1]: We operate on a 4x4 schedule (4 classes August - December, 4 classes January - June). So we sit in one class for 90 minutes, a good time to focus on a task and get it done. [2]: Issue 2 is a problem with every school I've been in and seen. I can't think of any school that has managed time in a way that will cover curriculum and capture student's attention. [3]: I'm lucky that my school is only 3 years old, extremely new for my district. I can easily form personal connections with my teachers and administration. My teachers know my extracurriculars and understand if I didn't complete my homework that day (I turn it in later, but I do have to finish it). Overall, this article was a reflective experience and made me even more thankful of my school.
- jschwartzi 12y agoMy experience with a 4x4 schedule was that I would lose focus about 15 to 20 minutes in, start trying to work whatever homework the teacher had assigned, realize I didn't understand it, refocus on the lecture, and realize that I had missed half of it. The only reason I graduated High School on time was because one of my math teachers gave out D's. This was really only an issue in Math classes, where we were expected to passively absorb information. The classes I did really well in were Honors English, AP English, and History/Social Studies courses where the teachers asked us to think about what they were telling us. Looking back, the only reason that I was able to go to college, get a degree, and end up working in Engineering is that my parents were willing to support me monetarily while I replaced my shitty High School record with a good Community College record.
- aarohmankad 12y agoYour math teacher sounds like a bad teacher. My calc teacher is very much the same, but he heavily focuses on being able to teach us how to learn on our own (i.e. looking up new concepts on khanacademy/other resources, looking for practical applications to theorems we learn, etc.)
- Rapzid 12y agoI recall one of my best math class grades was pre-cal my Junior year. I would normally fall into the trap you did, and completely failed Algebra 2 but somehow didn't swing back on it.. Anyway, the teacher, the girls soccer couch, actually gave us a good amount of time after the lecturing to work on our homework. And often he would start the class about 10-15 minutes late and I knew it was to give us a chance to polish off the homework. I recall being in a class of mostly Seniors, and a group of us always ended up working together.. The baseball teams pitcher, who was actually quite sharp, his friend, and a girl I don't quite remember that well. The teacher encouraged us to move our desks together as needed. This arrangement worked out fantastically. We would often divide and conquer the homework, or race through the problems individually. Both had advantages; somebody(me or the pitcher) would almost always have a particular problem figured out if the rest were stuck. It created this interaction that was part competitive and part cooperative/supportive. I suspect we all had fun, learned a lot, and did great on the tests and grades(I did). I had three main takeaways from this: 1.)The lectures were focused, dense, and did not take up the entire 90 minutes. 2.)We had plenty of time to practice the problems and help each other/get help during the period 3.)I now just recall that this was our lunch period as well, which we took the 2nd to last slot, so we had a break before the last bit of the period. This was quite nice. As an aside, three of the coaches I had for academic classes are probably in my top 5 list. Their classes were very engaging.. I find this interesting.
- j2kun 12y agoIt would be easier for teachers to notice these things if their schedules included some time for reflection and preparation instead of packing as many classes as possible into an eight hour day.
- analog31 12y agoFrom now on I'll be more tolerant when someone plays with their cellphone during one of my presentations.
- 1a2a3a4a 12y agoInteresting analysis, but as a current student I would find the things she wanted to change to be annoying in high school. It probably depends a lot on the student, but I really just wanted to listen to the teacher teach. My best teachers really knew their stuff and assigned interesting work for homework. The ones that tried to get us to hop around were not appreciated. I'm there because I want to learn, not do jumping jacks.
- kirsebaer 12y agoSeriously, it was so annoying when the teacher would have us get up and "move", for instance to demonstrate a math concept. She doesn't seem to get it that physically commanding students like that is demeaning, treating them like a dog.
- WalterBright 12y agoIt's true in any profession that one learns a lot by spending a day in your customers' shoes.
- markbnj 12y agoI think to some extent she underestimated the differences in her own body after 15 years. I recall being bored and fidgety in school, but I was never so physically drained just from sitting in the way that she describes. That's probably something an increasingly inflexible adult experiences more than a child does.
- alexgrist 12y agoMaybe you just become more accustomed to long periods of sitting and listening for hours while you're frequently having to. First day back after a break always seemed more exhausting possibly because you weren't having to do it all week.
- grimman 12y agoI personally was constantly fiddling with something, be it drilling holes in erasers or doodling or whatever, but I was always doing something. Had I not been able to do something (allowed... now that's a different story ;)) I would never have passed a single subject! Just tiny tasks to keep myself busy while I was listening. Even to this day, a couple of decades later, I can't really concentrate on one task. That said, people learn differently. Some people can just put their mind to it and grind through material, others, like me, aren't quite so fortunate. If only there was a way to gauge the learning method most suitable for a child, and put that child in an appropriate class... I believe things in education would look a lot brighter.
- saalweachter 12y agoIt's really funny, later in life, to be in a meeting full of people who have similar coping mechanisms. A dozen grown-ass adults spinning pens, playing with badges, anything but sitting still.
- bennesvig 12y agoI remember being tired every day in Jr. High and High School, struggling to not fall asleep. Once the school day was over, I'd suddenly get a huge boost of energy.
- pbreit 12y agoWow, 7:45 sounds awfully early. And out at 2:35?
- bane 12y agoI lived in a rural area during this time in my life. School started at 7:30am, the school bus picked us up at 6:30am, which meant I had to be up at 5:30-6:00 to eat breakfast, shower and get ready for the day. This meant a 9:30 bed-time. This also meant that I got home by about 3:30-4:00 depending on traffic. An hour for dinner gave me 4.5 hours to study. Let's be honest, I also took an hour for free-time otherwise I wouldn't have any. So 3.5 hours to study every day. In college at least, when you plan your schedule, you should plan 2-3 hours of study-time per week for every hour of class time. As you can see I really only had time to study 1 subject a day, maybe 2 if I didn't give myself free time by that standard. Recipe for success? Ha!
- stevewilhelm 12y agoLAHS, heart of the Silicon Valley, has "zero period" start at 7:15am [1]. Not all kids take a zero period class, mostly kids taking PE or an extra curricular like band. [1] http://www.mvla.net/LAHS/Department/110-About-LAHS/Portal/Bell-Schedule http://www.mvla.net/LAHS/Department/110-About-LAHS/Portal/Be...
- VLM 12y agoThe district my kids are in is even earlier, we're at a very high latitude, and on paper the reasoning is so that even in the darkest days of mid December the kindergartners travel time at the start and end of the day will be in sunlight. The same bus that carries a high school kid between 6am and 7am carries a grade school kid from 8am to 9am (roughly). Its actually even more complicated because we stagger grade school, middle school, and high school, so there's a middle school run from 7am to 8am in between. Rather than three times as many buses and drivers each only working two hours a day, they all put in pretty much an 8 hour working day split shifts. Unofficially its all about high school sports and away games travel time, also somewhat optimistically getting in a practice or maybe even a game/meet before a "normal-ish" dinner time.
- bane 12y agoI found this interesting. I worked for a few years teaching technical subjects to mid-career adults and ended up adopting an educational theory not too dissimilar to the author, but for mostly different reasons. Previous discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8251569 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8251569 I remember high school very well, and it was a pretty torturous experience. If you could design an educational program that was almost guaranteed not to be a conducive learning environment with poor mastery outcomes, the public k-12 system in the U.S. would probably be it. Even worse, when they measure educational outcomes, the place systems like South Korea's at the top, a system that's absolutely optimized and excels at the lowest possible form of learning, rote memorization. In the previous discussion, I point out that I believe students need to "complete the circuit", go from input/reception to output/production to say they've learned a topic. In today's school environment, if this happens at all, it happens by accident: 1) The teacher gives a lecture, information is shoved in 2) The students do homework and tests, okay, the students "produce" what they've learned, usually a brain dump of what they've memorized, but let's be honest, not a demonstration of learning or mastery. 3) The homework and tests get an impersonal grade, the "feedback loop" necessary to complete the circuit. But if the student got it wrong? Too bad, the lesson is moving on anyways. There's no time really spent in education to have the student go back with this new course correction and see if they got it now. And out of schedule help in most schools is woeful. Because of this systematic failure, by the time many students are involved in "advanced" topics in high school, their foundational knowledge is so flimsy and filled with holes that new topics are like turning a strong fan on in a room with a house of cards. Yet the professional educational establishment seems unable to figure this out and correct it. Keep in mind, without even a template of any kind, we're all fluently able to learn a complex language, a mass of complex social rules so complex that libraries are full of books describing them and how to sanitarily complete a digestion cycle on our own (everybody poops) before we even show up for day 1 of 1st grade. Keep in mind that we spent the first two of those 6-7 years not even being able to talk - so we did all that in about the same time it takes to get through high school. If we learned as much in our 4 years of high school, we'd all be leaving with the equivalent of advanced degrees in physics. Children can learn at phenomenal paces, yet it takes years before students accumulate any worthwhile new skills in this kind of environment -- skills that should take them weeks or months. School is doing it wrong.
- jqm 12y agoI found her description of being tired in an icky way very good. I remember feeling exactly that way at the end of the day in high school. I also agree with her suggestions. Short bursts of information, plenty of chances for physical motion, participation rather than passive listening. I believe all of this would have greatly improved what I got out of high school. Oh, and also cutting out a significant portion of the bullshit and indoctrination which was passed off as eduction but which was not. That's a different topic though I guess.
- vorg 12y agoI recently spent a year as a full-time language student in a college (in China, so more like US high school in many ways) after teaching English for 10 yrs, and also unexpectedly discovered point no. 1, i.e. how tiring it is to sit down all day, and almost never did so as a teacher. Even after 1 year I was still often yawning after 2 or 3 hrs of near continuous sitting, and always got up to walk around outside for 5 or 15 minutes during breaks. Most other students were much younger, usually 20-ish, and often stayed sitting in class during breaks. I don't know how they do it, but maybe it's just their age, or maybe they haven't done a job where they're on their feet all day for 10 yrs.
- pdonis 12y agoThe money quote to me is this one: "I was struck by this takeaway [#2] in particular because it made me realize how little autonomy students have, how little of their learning they are directing or choosing." What strikes me about this is how none of the solutions the author offers fix this problem. In fact, it's unfixable with our current concept of what a school is. No amount of monkeying with how classes are taught will change the fact that the kids are there because they have to be there, not because they chose to be there.
- kirsebaer 12y agoExactly, school is a prison. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d_DJAZ-ByV0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d_DJAZ-ByV0 It would be nice to see more attention on unschooling-style homeschooling and also on non-coercive schools where children are free to play and explore for themselves, so-called "democratic free schools" like Sudbury Valley School in MA. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=awOAmTaZ4XI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=awOAmTaZ4XI
- ufmace 12y agoI've been thinking more like that lately, and came here to say pretty much that. School is an inherently coercive institution. I think it's designed to snuff out independence and creativity and churn out people who blindly follow orders, who will be good corporate peons, Army privates, or something similar for their masters, and outcomes other than that are achieved more in spite of it than because of any attempts at positive change in the system. I don't know exactly what removing it would look like. I tend to think it needs to be less of a top-down organized system. More people doing whatever feels interesting to them at the time and getting as much help and support at it as we can practically provide, whether that's building cars, writing computer programs, reading about history, playing sports, or just screwing around for a while. I think that people inherently want to learn and do stuff, and you'll get much better results just letting them go do what they want to as great of an extent as possible than by ordering them around and restricting their options as much as possible.
- Meekro 12y agoThis is reminiscent of a book called My Freshman Year, by a college professor who actually enrolled as a student at the same school. She writes about numerous discoveries that she found shocking, despite having taught at the same school for many years. It's a great read.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mithras 12y agoMost (continental) European countries have a similar system.
- sjg007 12y agoThis is actually terrible. Kids peak at all different times and mostly learn from peers who are more accomplished than they are. And to avoid the cache-22, the most advanced kids of course might learn from a teacher or kid of a more advanced year.
- Freeboots 12y agoThis article actually made me angry, to the point of pacing and muttering, that these points are not commonly understood and addressed. How can these be new concepts? how can this be news? Students are bored because they have no autonomy, are force to sit and be talked down to all day, are not empowered to be involved in their own learning. WOW! AMAZING! How out of touch do educators have to be for this to be considered innovative thinking?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- reledi 12y agoOne of the best high school teachers I had used to teach Dutch to adult immigrants before becoming a Dutch high school teacher. She treated her previous students with respect and expected them to do the same. She taught us with the same approach and had thoughtful discussions with us, and it made a world of difference.
- marco1 12y ago"Offer brief, blitzkrieg-like mini-lessons with engaging, assessment-for-learning-type activities [...]" Is that normal usage of "blitzkrieg"? Do you use it in everyday language?
- mschuster91 12y agoiirc either McDonalds or BK has rumors of an internal rule that even the uppermost layers of management have to spend at least one full day each year standing behind the cash register and selling burgers. It would be nice if a) this was more than an urban legend and b) if more companies embraced variations of this rule. I believe it to be a good way to catch problems (e.g. unrealistic expectations of workers) before shit hits the fan like in a Mannheim (Germany) hospital where medical instruments were not disinfected properly due to too few workers and time - and reports to upper levels vanished in bureaucracy.
- glenra 12y agoThere's a reality tv show based on this premise called "Undercover Boss".
- ARothfusz 12y agoWhy were they only taking 4 classes per day? They are 30 minutes longer than my high school classes were, but we had 7+ different classes per day. I'm pretty sure our day lasted till 3:30 or 4pm. We had 5 minutes to get to the next class, and on a big campus, that could result in some pretty good cardio workouts. So maybe inadvertently we were getting those stretches recommended by the author.
- bzbarsky 12y agoThe article covers this: (Note: we have a block schedule; not all classes meet each day) The reality is that in a typical 1-hour class with 5 minute breaks between classes on a big campus you lose the first 5 minutes of class to people arriving late and the last 5 minutes to everyone packing up their books so they can rush our the door. So you get 50-minute classes, or about 5/6 of your nominal instruction time. And if you have to do a lab or something, you either have to do double-period classes or stick to labs that can be effectively completed in 40-45 minutes (because you need time to set up and clean up too). So enter block scheduling: the idea is to lengthen the classes to 90 minutes or so and alternate days when they meet. You still lose 10 minutes of each class, but that's 8/9 of your nominal instruction time, not 5/6. And teachers get a bit more flexibility in terms of what things can be done with a class. The drawback is that if you lecture for the full 80 minutes, the outcome is typically not so great: it takes an exceptional lecturer, or an exceptional student, or for some sorts of material both, to pull off someone still being able to absorb information in a lecture that's longer than an hour.
- sopooneo 12y agoWhen I was a student teacher I asked permission to do this and, without exception, was met with baffled looks. What specifically are you hoping find out? I was asked. Why would you want to that? my mentor teacher wanted to know. It's not that anyone had objections, they just couldn't fathom why an adult would want to do it. My biggest take away was how out of control and unpleasant lunch period was. Also, how much the kids got yelled at during class transitions.