9 ms·
When Women Stopped Coding
- nathan_long 12y agoThis story makes a compelling case that women stopped programming because - 1. Computers started being sold as consumer products - 2. They were marketed almost exclusively to boys - 3. Boys played with computers and learned about them, while girls were made to feel that computers weren't for them - 3. Men showed up to college with more computer experience - 4. Women felt they must not be "naturally good" at computers, based on how men already knew more While I think people sometimes exaggerate how much of gender differences come from society, advertising, etc, the facts of women's history in programming are clear, and I think the cause is well-argued here. We need to fix the perception that women aren't welcome to program. We're missing out on talented developers.
- jiggy2011 12y agoWhen I studied CS , only a small minority arrived with programming skills, a much larger number came with knowledge of gaming and by extension computer building because it was much easier to afford a PC required for the newest games if you could build it yourself.
- orionhenry 12y agoGaming has been a hell of a gateway drug for programming.
- aalvarado 12y agoWhat do you mean?
- jamesaguilar 12y agoMany people who get into programming, do so because they either want to make games, or like computers because of games. This was widely true among my CS class at WashU, and also many of the professionals I currently work with.
- filereaper 12y agoI concur. I got into programming because I couldn't complete a level in a game, and I resorted to cheat-codes and hacks. First it was the missing-no hack in Pokemon, then getting the console for "sv_cheats 1/god/impulse 101/noclip" for Half-Life and then rules.ini for the Red Alert series. Hand hacking rules.ini for Red-Alert made a massive impression, any of the game's dynamics could be altered, you could spew out units for $1, bolt a tesla-coil on a tank etc... Cheats and trainers got me to look into the workings of a computer program, plus the midi music from trainers is addictive :)
- simplemath 12y agoUsing ResourceFork to give my tiny shuttle Class 6 Plasma Cannons in Escape Velocity...
- rmckayfleming 12y agoI spent an inordinate amount of time as a kid using ResEdit to make cheat plugins for EV:Override.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> I got into programming because I couldn't complete a level in a game, and I resorted to cheat-codes and hacks. While I programmed long before then, that's certainly the reason I started poking at hex editors, and why I remember off the top of my head that 0x63 is 99 and 0x64 is 100.
- panic 12y agoUNIX itself started because Ken Thompson wanted to port his game Space Travel to the PDP-7: http://cm.bell-labs.com/who/dmr/spacetravel.html http://cm.bell-labs.com/who/dmr/spacetravel.html
- Dewie 12y agoIf I wanted to get involved with making games, it would probably be in order to design games. Not coding per se.
- brandonmenc 12y agoUp until the mid 90s, designing games generally required that you also program them. In the 80s, even the musicians had to hack assembler (Martin Galway, for example)
- TeMPOraL 12y agoYup. I started programming at 13 because I wanted to make my own better (obviously) StarCraft. Poking around in existing games and trying to make my own during my teens is the sole reason I work as a programmer today.
- 3rd3 12y agoThis seems to miss an explanation for why the marketing was directed at boys in the first place.
- kasey_junk 12y agoThe segment mentions that most "tool toys" are marketed at boys. Specifically mentioned Tonka Trucks but think plastic saws, hammers, etc. They couldn't find any data one way or another about if that marketing made sense.
- bhaumik 12y agoMy younger sister would've been more likely to enter tech if there was less barbie and more this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IIGyVa5Xftw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IIGyVa5Xftw
- spion 12y agoMy take on that missing piece: once computers went personal / homebrew / RadioShack they switched categories. The new category was "tinkering with electronics", which has a long established cultural perception of being a male activity (and those personal computers were therefore marketed to males)
- 3rd3 12y agoBut why is tinkering almost exclusively for men?
- spion 12y agoThat, I don't know. We'd probably need to go much further back to find an answer.
- aragot 12y agoI know I'll get banned and cursed for years for that but here you go: Oh stop it, those are gender differences and girls also enjoy their differences, even if they're unfortunately imprinted by culture. They're untouchable, they are given what they ask (which is: often dolls), they're social. And the few that are in IT, they don't show up at the Java User Group, even if it's their job, even if it's free, even if it's at the same time as for boys. They do show up more often at higher-class networking parties where they may make connections with product managers and be promoted, rather than stay programmers like us for a bit longer. Of course there will be counter-examples, but I see girls in IT getting promoted MUCH faster than boys. In my 14-people office? 4 women-project-managers, 1 woman-architect (who doesn't know GIT), 1 female programmer (with 2 years of experience) and 8 male programmers. Yes, I'm making this observation about my team to imply that women have better jobs, sooner than boys, and it does imply that males don't get promoted as easily as women, at least in the world around me, and I'm saying an IT career is an excellent path for a girl. Before anyone says "Women get promoted quicker because they're just better at their job", I'd note they turn over this exact argument when it's directed to boys, by suggesting they didn't get the education, incentive, support or opportunity. It's not about anyone being better. It's about how we reach fairness. I do see that some of the world is different for girls, but unfairness is reported more often than advantages. Edit: "Why are there less girls at the JUG, is it because they're uncomfortable with 95% men?" > Or that they aren't involved much and reserve their evening time for their social life. The only way to be sure would be to ask them, and they'll probably remark they'll be promoted whether or not they attend the JUG, if you've followed the story of my team.
- grimtrigger 12y agoI find this explanation extremely hollow. Most programmers didn't start programming when they were kids. They started when they realized it was a good paycheck.
- dominotw 12y agoYep I didn't actually see a computer till I was in my early 20's.
- cortesoft 12y agoAny data on that? I tried searching for info on when the average programmer started, but couldn't find anything. I always figured most programmers started young, but that might just be because so many in my group started really young.
- grimtrigger 12y agoNo data, just anecdotes
- MattGrommes 12y agoAmong my friends I always thought I was the odd one out because I _didn't_ start programming as a child.
- wuliwong 12y agoI'm another that didn't start programming until one of my required courses as a physics undergraduate student. We did have an 8th grade programming class but everyone took that and obviously it didn't spur me into any interest in programming.
- HillRat 12y agoBut the "gendering" of computers affects everyone, regardless of how or when they get to the table. I've known many women who found themselves regularly condescended to and even verbally abused by their CS professors, and many of them just dropped out entirely rather than face an academic discipline that quite vocally didn't want them involved. (Is this the norm? I hope not. Is it common? I fear so.) And once they get into the industry, they continue to face scorn and opprobrium, although some sub-disciplines (particularly database administration, ETL and data modeling) seem to fare better than others. Not distinct to the comp-sci field, as any female executive or high-grade salesperson will attest, but I'd like to think we're better than them.
- intortus 12y agoIt seems like a lot of CS programs focus more on filtering than teaching, which just intensifies the trend.
- brannon 12y agoI completely agree. I had never programmed before my first college course, and while I had a lot of fun in intro programming courses, I always felt way behind everyone else and didn't do particularly well. Those first couple of classes filtered me out of any chance at getting into the CS major, and I ended up transferring schools to study it.
- guard-of-terra 12y agoIn the Eastern Bloc countries nobody bothered to market computers, for many reasons including closed off markets and economical disasters. They also valued gender equality a lot. But the end result was absolute the same - massive male domination in everything computer-related. So i's not marketing.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agoCould it be the operating systems or the UI? There are fewer choices nowadays you know. At least one person I know completely lost interest in the field because of the switch from DOS to Win 3.1.
- guard-of-terra 12y agoGUI lived alongside with keyboard-based text UIs for most of 90-s here. Actually it was women who stick to Norton Commander lookalikes for many years. I still don't think it made any gender-balance difference.
- pXMzR2A 12y ago> So i[t]'s not marketing. The article seems to agree, since the underlying reason is attributed to institutionalized sexism in the mainstream culture.
- byEngineer 12y agoGrew up with Atari 800xl in 1980s in communistic Poland and confirm the same. It is quite obvious what happened but first what I really don't like about the article: Object ovation of women. You have "agents" who decide for themselves -- men -- and objects who need to be told/encouraged or have stuff explained as otherwise they will apparently not understand why they should study CS. Or have mammography ( when was the last time you seen an ad explaining men to have prostate checked? ), participate in politics, etc? You don't tell agents what to do. Agents take action by the definition of being an agent. Objects on the other hand need to be told. Feminism is objectifying women this way. And explanation of why not these many women are in the CS percentage wise today as in 1984? Easy. As CS became very popular instead of being highly scientific niche subordinate to mathematics department, it just became as any other engineering department - overflown with men. Btw, I studied English language for my Masters. Hihhly recommended : male/female ratio 1 to 7. 😉 And no, there are no articles encouraging men to take foreign languages as their University Major. As we are not objectifying them as feminists are objectifying women. We know that advising agents would be inappropriate. But if you want to spend 4 or 5 years with chicks around you -- go study foreign language. And you can still pick up programming after partying with them for five years 😉
- crusso 12y ago"They were marketed almost exclusively to boys" Back before anyone was really marketing computers in any mainstream way, I remember gathering around the few that were available in the school library or in a math teacher's classroom. The only people interested EVER were boys. It had nothing to do with marketing.
- nether 12y agoWhich came first, tool-toy companies interested in boys, or boys interested in them?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoMaybe it doesn't matter. Once a group becomes predominantly one culture, it rapidly slides to that corner of the culture space. Lots of reasons - people hire people they feel comfortable with. People value people they understand more, regarding them as more intelligent or harder working.
- onewaystreet 12y agoYou say "ever" but the early history of computing was filled with women. Something caused a change.
- tsotha 12y agoThe field was too small at the time to draw any useful conclusions.
- kaitai 12y agoI was interested in high school but felt like I wasn't allowed in the computer room. It was full of boys who knew the teacher, and I didn't know the teacher and wasn't a boy, and just didn't really want to deal with the social discomfort given that I had a computer at home and could use that for an hour in the evening. Instead I skipped class in a computer-less room with the IB coordinator's blessing. That hour or two a day of skipping class or eating lunch would have had a different effect if I'd spent all the time playing with computers. I started making up for it in college as a CS class was required, I couldn't afford my own computer & so discovered the trash and Linux, and there was a badass female sysadmin who demonstrated perfect ease in owning the computer lab.
- nostromo 12y ago"They were marketed almost exclusively to boys" You mean exactly like chemistry sets? Yet chemistry is the most equal major in terms of gender of graduates. I like Planet Money, but this story is unconvincing.
- pjc50 12y agoChemistry sets went the other way and have almost entirely gone out of fashion due to health and safety issues.
- cheez 12y agoYeah, the new chemistry sets are much safer. Bleh.
- onewaystreet 12y agoA shift happened where computing was seen as something girls didn't do. If not marketing then what caused it? (IMO it started when computing became synonymous with math, if people thought girls couldn't do math then they also couldn't be good with computers).
- mbil 12y agoI don't have data on this, but I'd imagine the popularity of computers in the home in the 1980s was outshining that of chemistry sets. In the NPR piece they talk about how computers were marketed to boys for playing games. And chemistry is also taught in high schools, so both male and female students interested in it would've had some experience before attending college. The same is not true for computing.
- vorg 12y agoI would add: 6. Males are far more likely to enter jobs they're not suitable for Of all the "programmers" without any aptitude that seem to plague corporate IT departments, virtually none of the ones I've come across have been female. If you take out these frauds when counting programmers, then the gender balance in many IT departments becomes more like the early 1980's. Added: When programming became a perceived status job, the frauds turned up to cheat aptitude tests, lie on their CV about experience and studies, and what not.
- Dewie 12y agoFucking men, man. What an egotistical, useless bunch. /s
- makeset 12y agoI've met more than a few women who majored in computer science and were then diversity-hired into corporate positions involving programming, with no skills or aptitude for it beyond sophomore-level class projects. They tend to get shuffled around to less technical positions eventually.
- smegel 12y ago> We're missing out on talented developers. As a sought after developer in a niche area I appreciate the lack of competition. But then again I am a selfish, cynical bastard.
- jjindev 12y agoI was one of those boys who bought a TRS-80. The thing is, I don't remember it as a peer accepted pursuit for me either. This was before anyone noticed, let alone Hollywood recast it as their version of Revenge of the Nerds. This was when being a nerd was not nice. While I did get some quasi support from people who thought it might help in a career someday, the much more common response in those days was "who needs a home computer?" Update: I agree that we should encourage everyone with an aptitude now to go into higher ROI fields (of which CS is one), I do think it is a bit reconstructed history to make TRS-80s actually "cool" and "non-cool kids excluded." Indeed, the TRS-80 was not even a game machine. PCs as game machines came a bit later, and as price effective ones, much later.
- brandonmenc 12y ago> And these toys were marketed almost entirely to men and boys. They give two piddly links to commercials aimed at boys. Explain these ads, then: http://minotaurproject.co.uk/blog/?p=342 http://minotaurproject.co.uk/blog/?p=342 Or Commodore ads like this one: http://assets.sbnation.com/assets/1325832/commodore-765.jpg http://assets.sbnation.com/assets/1325832/commodore-765.jpg In the 80s, computers were marketed to the whole family, boys and girls included.
- guyzero 12y agoWere you there? I was. Computers were marketed to boys and families for whatever reason reinforced this as well. It may not explain everything, but it explains the genesis of the situation.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- guyzero 12y agoEdit: uh, something happened with comment parenting, but anyway, yes, not every ad was mono-gendered, but in practice boys monopolized the C64s and TI-99/4As of the world. It's chicken and egg situation - it was perceived as a "boy thing" so was marketed at boys. The 80's in the US & Canada weren't exactly Saudi Arabia, but toys were as gendered if not more so than they are today. And people marketing computers had no social agenda, they just took the path of least resistance. It is, on some level, similar to the tragedy of the commons. Everyone made a decision that worked well for them and in the end the net effect was one that had a lot of negative impact.
- brandonmenc 12y agoI was born in the 1970s so yeah, I was there. The article implies that, in the 80s, home computers were considered nothing more than glorified pong machines and girls were never seen in any of the ads, which is simply incorrect. There are countless ads featuring Commodores, Apples, and Trash 80s displaying spreadsheets, and quite a few with girls at the keyboard. Is there an exhaustive study of computer marketing from that time? I ask in all seriousness, because two links and hazy memories from NPR isn't very convincing.
- rayiner 12y agoThe "women just aren't as interested in programming" trope rings hollow when the participation of women in CS majors is about half of what it was in 1985, a time when, by all accounts, programmers were far less socially mainstream than they are today.
- istorical 12y agoWhy? Don't really follow your logic. My hypothesis is that women (specifically teenage girls) just aren't interested in the field / profession so they decide not to study it in school or search for jobs in the field. Perhaps this is because they are discouraged from trying it by their teachers or media, perhaps its because they don't have the confidence to believe they'll succeed, perhaps they think it's not cool, perhaps they don't think it'll be a fun job. But I guess, I see "women aren't as interested in programming" as a very likely cause for the disparity. And I don't think that's a sexist observation. I believe if we can find ways to get more girls interested we should pursue them, and indeed I root for organizations like Black Girls Code. We live in too politically correct a world if we think it's bad to suggest that maybe girls _aren't_ interested in the field. I'm not sure that it's the biggest contributing factor, but if it could be part of the story, why are we so afraid to admit that possibility? Because it's not something we'd like to believe?
- kasey_junk 12y agoThe "aren't interested" hypothesis would also need to explain why the physical sciences haven't had the same decline in involvement as computer science nor why there is a specific decline in participation in computer science but not in the other categories. I don't think anyone is afraid to suggest that girls aren't interested in the field, it's just that it is a very unsatisfying answer and it doesn't really make sense to generalize about more than half the population.
- istorical 12y agoThat makes sense, thanks. I agree that it is strange that the drop isn't as large as it is for women in STEM in general, but I don't think it disqualifies the hypothesis. I guess from my perspective if you only have a handful of women even entering a CS department in university in the first place, then the first and most important problem to solve is why they don't seek to study the major, or participate in high school programming classes. I believe if you can answer that question and remove that factor, it will be the biggest first step. Disclaimer: Was a CS major, dated a CS major woman who coached me through Calculus and who I collaborated with in software classes. I'm biased.
- freshflowers 12y agoMaybe just a total coincidence, but the mid-80's is also the time when media and authorities started their witch hunt against hackers and the word "hacker" became equal to "criminal". Basically, in the mid-80's the predominant media image of computer engineers was either social outcast of criminal. Gee, wonder why women weren't attracted to that.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoWhy should the "not attracted to that" factor be specifically gendered?
- inclemnet 12y agoThis argument seems to rest on the assumption that women are fundamentally more susceptible to decisions based on stereotypes than men are. Do you have any evidence both that this is the case, and that any measurable difference (if there is one) is significant enough to blame for this effect?
- waterlesscloud 12y agoNo, it suggests that men and women both are both susceptible to media stereotypes. He's just suggesting that the "outsider outlaw" is more appealing to men than to women.
- johansch 12y agohttp://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/evolution/9005552/Men-twice-as-likely-to-take-risks.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/evolution/9005552/Men-twi...
- Frozenlock 12y agoNot necessarily based on stereotypes, but rather what's more accepted by society. Men are usually the outliers. (See % of male prisoners) Note that he also said "Maybe just a total coincidence".
- waterlesscloud 12y agoYou know, this might have more to do with it than the actual marketing of the time. As shown in another post here, home computer makers tried to market to the whole family. And why wouldn't they? Computers were relatively expensive and esoteric, why not aim at their uses for everyone in the family? And they did. But WARGAMES and that whole media portrayal that followed of the computer hacker/enthusiast was definitely male and outsider. Interesting point.
- cheez 12y agoInteresting link in the comments: http://cs.stanford.edu/people/eroberts/cs181/projects/women-in-cs/graphs/csbachelors.jpg http://cs.stanford.edu/people/eroberts/cs181/projects/women-... This graph shows that the drop off was nearly identical for men. Maybe the initial bump was just people getting overexcited for this computer thing and then hearing from their friends that it's kind of nerdy. Edit Another interesting link seems to show that women receive degrees at a significantly higher rate than men, and that the gap is widening: http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=72 http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=72 Why is this?
- cscheid 12y agoRead the graph again. The dropoff for women is much larger. $ python >>> 20000.0 / 17000.0 1.1764705882352942 >>> 12500.0 / 7000.0 1.7857142857142858 CS enrollment for women in 1984 was 78% larger than in 1996; For men, it was 17%.
- cheez 12y agoI'm not sure where you're picking these numbers off and from which graph. The graph I linked has the following values(ish): * Men: 27,500 - 17,500 -> 1.57 ~ 36% drop * Women: 15,000 - 7,500 -> 2 ~ 50% drop So yes, you're right that women did seem to drop off more but not as much as you say.
- cscheid 12y agoThe graph you linked to. I'm comparing the 1984 numbers to latest available, since 1984 is what the linked piece talks about (and which I mentioned in the original comment) > drop off was nearly identical for men > women did seem to drop off more These two statements cannot be both true at the same time.
- cheez 12y agoIn this case, a drop off needs to be compared to a peak value which 1984 is not. 1984 is before the 1986 peak. I'm not saying they're exactly identical but it's clear that there are similar patterns. Perhaps not "nearly" identical, but similar enough.
- maybe_maybe1 12y agoMaybe, just maybe, they got out because they could see far ahead at the mess coding would become in the future. They were there at a time when the computer staff were more respected members of an organisation, rather than just a cost centre to be minimised and offshored. Maybe, just maybe, they could foresee a horrendous time when technology was chosen as it was the flavour of the month, regardless of how good the technology actually was (see: Ruby on Rails, and about every single JS framework to date). Mostly though, they could probably see the fact that most coding work was going to be mundane, bug fixing, and working in an industry that never seems to learn, but throws away knowledge and experience, and focuses solely on the new shiny, and keeps thinking it has invented something new, when it is really just a poor rehash of something earlier, something that was probably more solid and more robust. Maybe.
- zxcv731 12y agoThis same graph used in the article was extensively discussed on reddit 3 days ago. [1] I want to quote some of the comments, which I think is extremely important to this discussion. " The far simpler answer is that the 1970's "explosion" of women into the (purported) field of "computer science" was largely women obtaining degrees in (what were then "computer science" courses) the subfields of "Data Processing" and later on "Word Processing". (Edit: see the Google Ngram on the transition of terminology from "Data Processing" to "Computer Science"[2] ). With the ending of punch cards, and the increasing decentralization via personal computers (and networks of them) and subsequent later software improvements (spreadsheets, advanced databases, WYSWYG word processing), those functions ceased to be viable degrees and lost their status as "computer science" related functions... everyone became (in one form or another) involved in data-entry and/or word processing. The plain truth of the matter is that women were NEVER highly represented in the true "computer science" fields of programming (and later network & database administration). " Although I believe the comment author can use a better tone, I think these facts are extremely important to this discussion. There were more people echoing that their grandmum got a CS degree in data entry[3] Edit: Data processing are indeed counted towards computer science. Although there is no data on the relative weight [4] http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/pdf/tabb1.pdf http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/pdf/tabb1.pdf [1]http://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/2joexk/what_happened_to_women_in_computer_science_of/cldob83 http://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/2joexk/what... [2]https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=data+processing%2Ccomputer+science&case_insensitive=on&year_start=1940&year_end=2000&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t4%3B%2Cdata%20processing%3B%2Cc0%3B%2Cs0%3B%3Bdata%20processing%3B%2Cc0%3B%3BData%20Processing%3B%2Cc0%3B%3BData%20processing%3B%2Cc0%3B%3BDATA%20PROCESSING%3B%2Cc0%3B.t4%3B%2Ccomputer%20science%3B%2Cc0%3B%2Cs0%3B%3BComputer%20Science%3B%2Cc0%3B%3Bcomputer%20science%3B%2Cc0%3B%3BComputer%20science%3B%2Cc0%3B%3BCOMPUTER%20SCIENCE%3B%2Cc0 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=data+processin... [3]http://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/2joexk/what_happened_to_women_in_computer_science_of/cldqkih http://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/2joexk/what...
- 3rd3 12y agoSigh, not this comment again.
- colomon 12y agoI think the graph here -- http://www.randalolson.com/2014/06/14/percentage-of-bachelors-degrees-conferred-to-women-by-major-1970-2012/ http://www.randalolson.com/2014/06/14/percentage-of-bachelor... -- provides an interesting contrast. Seems like what has happened is the percentage of women in CS was tracking along with that in architecture or the physical sciences, and whatever happened in the 80s caused it to gradually move down towards (but so far always above) the percentage of women in engineering.
- seanflyon 12y agoI think that when CS was a newer field it was treated more like Math and less like engineering.
- bane 12y agoThat's an interesting graph. The article makes the claim that this was an effect of computers basically being sold as toys (which are almost always gender targeted in their marketing). But this graph also makes me think about the huge and longstanding push to align software development with traditional engineering practices...that may also have been a contributing factor.
- inmygarage 12y agoI am a female born in 1983 and have always been deeply interested in computers, but have nonetheless felt inexplicably out of place for it. I was in advanced math classes my entire life and placed out of calculus in college. I took a summer programming class at a different university in 2000 and fell in love with programming. But when I got back to school, I took another CS class that was exactly as described in this article. I can't quite articulate the feelings of isolation and frustration I felt in that class, but they were strong enough to drive me away from CS and engineering for a long time. I have a History degree.
- ElComradio 12y agoThat's too bad. I wish things were easy for you, like they were for me, when my peers were cheering me on to learn how to program and I was super popular because of it. Everything was a cake walk, and I learned that if society is in the slightest way against what you are doing, it's impossible to accomplish, so I'm really glad I wasn't driven out of the field that interested me.
- ritchiea 12y agoThat's a pretty rude and condescending response. Feeling excluded from a particular culture is very different from expecting a task or learning a skill to be easy. Imagine trying to learn a new skill and finding that your peers & superiors in the field are hostile to you but friendly to each other. This is the experience many women report and I've witnessed it myself.
- ElComradio 12y agoYes. There are obstacles, we agree. If you wanted to learn something, say, plumbing, and found that fellow plumbers viewed you as an effete nerd, would you just lay down your wrench, or would you resolve to be the best plumber possible and soldier on? Which course of action do you think would be the most rewarding?
- 12y ago
- Dewie 12y ago> Movies like Weird Science, Revenge of the Nerds, and War Games all came out in the '80s. And the plot summaries are almost interchangeable: awkward geek boy genius uses tech savvy to triumph over adversity and win the girl. Movies like Revenge of the Nerds are not about nerds triumphing over adversity and getting the girls because they are nerds... it's about triumphing over adversity and getting the girls in spite of being nerds. Or, if the key to their success was really their brains, they used it to overcome an adversity that was caused by being nerds. If they weren't being nerdy and brainy, there would be no adversial story to begin with. To implicitly suggest that movies like that are supposed to inspire people to become and continue to be nerds is asinine. It's a role reversal concept; not something that people believe happens in real life. The whole point is them being unlikely heroes and winners. > Ordóñez got through the class but earned the first C in her life. I guess this is supposed to evoke some "hitting a low" sentiment? The sheer horror of getting a grade that is technically right in the middle? Long live grade inflation, I give it an A+++.
- daveloyall 12y ago[...] when personal computers started showing up in U.S. homes [...] Doesn't anecdotal evidence suggest that children quickly exceed their mentors (parents) when exposed to 1980s consumer hardware? (That hardware was deterministic--same key sequence means same result every time. You know, like video games from the same era.) Being exceeded by your child can be a dramatic emotional event. Are the feelings that a father or mother experience different when the child is a little girl vs. a little boy? </speculation>
- cortesoft 12y agoI am pretty sure all computer hardware is deterministic? (unless we are talking about quantum computers?)
- daveloyall 12y agoThe deterministic nature of computer hardware used to be apparent during interaction with the computer. Novices would quickly learn to carry out common actions 'blind'. You could memorize a sequence of keystrokes and experiment with changing parts, or leaving out parts, to develop variations, or shorter but equivalent sequences. The user interfaces of older computers were also orders of magnitude faster. If you were to time travel back to the 1980s and try to show off a smart phone to 8-bit hobbyists, I predict that they'd frequently attempt to remove the battery: "It seems to be stuck in a loop!" Some might blame multi-threading, some might blame storage and communication latency... I blame planned obsolescence and the 'Halloween Documents' come to mind. Most users were not introduced to real computers. They were introduced to products, products engineered to optimize for profitability.
- tonyplee 12y agoI have 15 year old daughter and would love to get her more interested in computer science. She is doing good in school getting A in math/science, etc. Any suggestions from HN on how best to guide her interests? Extra project? incentive? For now, her interests are typical teenage - school clubs, facebook, youtube, tumblr, etc.
- DanBC 12y agohttps://www.madewithcode.com/ https://www.madewithcode.com/
- arjie 12y agoArduino-based stuff is fun because you can tie it in to what you're already doing, and there are derivative platforms for other uses, e.g. Lilypad. Obviously suggest, not force.
- rimantas 12y agoWhy not just let her to pursue her interests, not yours?
- Jare 12y agoEncourage her to build and create things. If she chooses the computer as her tool, all the better, but provide her with as many avenues of creation as possible (paper, sound, words, images, code, wood, ideas, etc) and she will find the one that's right for her. She is a teenager, I believe you are not her guide anymore, but you can (and should) be an amazing facilitator and her #1 fan.
- nojvek 12y agoI know one of top female coders in Google who worked on Maps. She said her dad taught her a few things in java when she was young. Her dad would give her some sort of reward of every little school problem she could solve with java. Before she even grew boobs, she made a word problem solver based on the STUDENT paper http://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/5922/AIM-066.pdf?sequence=2 http://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/5922/AIM-066.p...
- arh68 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 001sky 12y ago"This idea that computers are for boys became a narrative. It became the story we told ourselves about the computing revolution. It helped define who geeks were and it created techie culture." The facts seem to (rather) be that computers were no longer just toys, they were becoming serious tools. As such, "tool geeks" gravitated to computers. This hypothesis would explain the inevitable sexist outcome of the field with a simple explanation. It can also be verified objectively and orthogonally by looking at other "tool" drivem occuplations that seem to share a heavy gender bias. See, eg http://www.catalyst.org/knowledge/women-male-dominated-industries-and-occupations-us-and-canada http://www.catalyst.org/knowledge/women-male-dominated-indus... Playing with tools and machines is not so much sexist as it is anti-social more broadly speaking. It's not clear the both genders share similar preferences in thus regard. If you look at more "social" industries (or business functions) like in Media/publishing/advertising you tend to find a significant number of very successful/world class etc women in very high powered jobs. The bigger question is when did coding become so anti-social? And is/was this anti-social nature somehow necessary or functional?
- Dewie 12y ago> Playing with tools and machines is not so much sexist as it is anti-social more broadly speaking. Asocial is a better term. Unless you're talking about the "mad scientist" (mad engineer is a better term...) that builds machines in order to take over the world.
- jgrahamc 12y agoI did Mathematics and Computation at Oxford starting in 1986. There were four women on the course (something like a total intake of 30). Three of the four switched to mathematics at the end of the first year. I don't have any real explanation why.
- crazy1van 12y agoThis seems like a feedback loop without a clear beginning or cause. Marketing affects behavior. Behavior affects marketing. Repeat. Does Hasbro market GI Joes to boys because boys tend to like GI Joes or do boys like GI Joes because Hasbro markets them to boys? I'm not so sure how useful wondering about finding the "Cause" of this. It isn't that simple.
- omonra 12y agoI have a 2yo who has been obsessed with cars from the time he could crawl. We never encouraged it (don't own a car or a tv, no siblings) - actually got him a few dolls to try and balance it out. I think that once you have kids and observe them do gender-specific things from a very early age, you dismiss all the talk of 'marketing is responsible for it'.
- wuliwong 12y agoI'm don't know that any real explanation is gonna be much more than speculation but it certainly is an interesting graph. I'm actually really surprised by the percentage of women in the physical sciences. I studied physics and sadly, I'm afraid that if you split out physics from the other branches it would be significantly lower than the other physical sciences. My own anecdotal experience (undergraduate and graduate school) would put it at 10%. But that is just two snapshots in time at two schools. I would guess the average HAS to be higher, but still below 40%.
- Mandatum 12y agoWasn't the early-mid-80's when programming/computers held much of a social stigma (ie nerd, geek, etc were insults). The market followed that trend and instead of offering a computer as a consumer gender un-biased product, it was marketed at men.. But even then, if you look at ads from around that time for computers.. It's a computer. It's not something that you can assign a gender to in advertising very effectively. It's the social aspect surrounding computers that does that. Also I disagree with what nathan_long said regarding "Women felt they must not be "naturally good" at computers, based on how men already knew more". To me that is absurd to assume that woman would think that "men know more than us, so why try"? His third point would be nullified by the associated social stigma during their teen years.
- shamimj 12y agoI had a very similar experience when I entered one of the best universities of Iran in 2000. Although the number of female students were almost as much as males, every professor assumed that students should at least know one programming language and be familiar with all the basic concepts of computers. and many students, especially female ones did not have that knowledge prior to university which was a great turn off as they realised they would be easily judged by their lack of knowledge. The sad thing is that all of these students were great in their high school in order to get in in the first place.
- lnanek2 12y agoRomantic story telling for a line graph, but really it is more like the profession of computer operators, originally drawn from the largely female secretary pool, disappeared as computers evolved from big buildings where you submitted decks of punched cards to their modern form. Nowadays we have IT, EE, CS, etc. but these are really different professions than what was originally mostly women. The first crop of nearest equivalent computer scientists usually majored in mechanical engineering, simply because there were no computer majors yet and the computers were much more mechanical, and had the same gender imbalance we see today.
- staticelf 12y agoI don't think girls ever completely stopped to program, but for sure there are less girls in those kinds of subjects at higher education levels. But from my view, it all comes down to interest and I have no real explaination to why girls are less interested in computer science. However, I can tell my story on how I got intersted and why I do not think girls at that age would have any issues having the same story. I can only answer for my experience, but here it goes: When I were younger (I'm still in my 20s) I started with computers and mainly to play computer games which I quickly realized was a lot of fun. Later on, and surely labeled as a "nerd" by my fellow classmates (girls and boys) I started to take interest in cheating in games and wondered how the hell to do it. That made me walk out on the internet learning about how programs work in the first place and I discovered modding. I understood that I can change the game data which was saved on my local hard drive in order to gain powers in the game. Cheating quickly became boring so I wanted to know how to mod a game so bosses would spawn more powerful to meet my newly crafted gear that could beat anything. So I started to mod the client with programs that were available on the net. At this point, I barely understood all the english grammar that was used but the interest in learning on how the stuff works eventually led me to learning to program and awoken an interest I didn't even know existed. Previously to this, I had no idea how computers really worked like I had no idea how a car engine worked. I didn't examine this until I really wanted something done. I am sure my story is like many stories in the early 00's of people who eventually learned to program. I don't think any girl that did the same during this period would have any specific attention except good ones. Maybe the girls in my school did not learn to program because they were less interested in games, maybe something else. But what I am totally conviced of, is that there were no sexism hindering these girls to learn if they wanted to. Actually, I would think that most boys would not care as much if a girl was as interested as me. I were labeled a nerd (and had really no problems with it) but I do not think that a girl would be labeled the same. Of course there were girls labeled as nerds but not because they were interested in computers, but because they did "too much homework" or "took school too seriously". The funny thing is that I were not labeled as a nerd because of my interest in computers, I am pretty convinced that it was only because that I had a nerdy look and sat a lot in front of computers. In fact, most of them when I showed some tricks were actually impressed and had no issues with that. Children can't hate on something they do not understand and in my experience a kid always goes on the visual things or very basic information that they do understand (i.e. do too much homework / sit a lot in front of computers). I am sure there are some sexism out there still, but in my experience the sexism has been reversed. I have always felt "second picked" or less important because of my gender. I don't understand why girls need "extra attention" regarding computer interest anymore and I actually think it's damaging for several reasons. My question remains the same, why can't we just try to treat everyone equally?
- rverghes 12y agoMathematically, isn't this a guaranteed result? The article said that the share of women in other programs kept rising. So doesn't the share of women in different programs need fall to balance? If more women become lawyers, aren't there fewer women left for other programs? I really wish these types of articles would show absolute numbers. Percentages can be so misleading.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- waterlesscloud 12y agoAbsolute numbers here - http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/ http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/
- waterlesscloud 12y agoThe National Science Foundation study that this is all based on has the raw numbers, as it were, for each degree (at each level Bachelor, Masters, PhD), for each year. If you want to do some digging on your own, it's in XLS and PDF formats here- http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/ http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoThis story just isn't convincing. If anything, the legal field has always been more hostile to women, and now it is becoming dominated by women. The same was true of advertising, PR work, sales, and any number of other fields previously dominated by men, and now slowly being taken over by women. More than 50% of my law school class (top ten law school) were women. In law school the know-it-all assholes were still mostly men. And that didn't seem to dissuade the women one bit from pursuing a career in law. In my first legal job, more than 50% of the first year associates were women. In my wife's firm, 70% of the first year associates were women. When I was an undergrad (early 90s) there were about 40-50% women in the CS introductory classes, but by the 200 level classes, there were only about 10-15% women. I was pre-med for a time. Pre-med classes were just as hard ... the attrition did not change the sex ratio in the pre-med classes. Why do people insist on making up all kinds of just-so stories to explain the discrepancy in numbers of women and men programmers. Isn't it possible that women might not be interested in programming in the same numbers as men. Even within the male population, those genuinely interested in programming seem to be a pretty small number. Most of my classmates in the CS program did not stay programmers. Many of them went to work for places like Goldman, McKinsey, etc. In fact, those were the preferred jobs in those days. Only a very small number of us wanted to actually program for a living.
- jonny_eh 12y agoThen why the drop off in the 80s? Did the female genome change at some point?
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoI don't know, but here are some possibilities: 1) Change in competition in classes that were graded on a curve. If CS became more popular, it could have become more difficult to be an A student. 2) Change in curriculum. CS could have gone through a change in subject matter. At my alma mater in the early nineties, CS included a huge amount of math. The Math and Physics majors also had the same kind of ratio distortion as CS. There were no advertisements to boost male enrollment in Math and Physics. 3) A few new majors were created (like Operations Research and Industrial Engineering) that offered admission into lucrative jobs like banking and consulting, while being much lighter on the algorithms and math. A large number of people from CS went into those majors (both male and female). There were certainly a lot more women in Operations Research. People used to comment on how OR had all the women, and CS had all the immigrants from Asia.
- ps4fanboy 12y agoIt always amazes me when groups post stats but never post the source statistics? Where did they get the data, etc. Also why is it by Major and not by Degree?
- waterlesscloud 12y agoData source here - http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/ http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/
- balls187 12y agoI'm curious to know: * Rates of women in Computer Science jobs. * The number (not just %) of women studying computer science. Did those numbers fall, or stay the same? Was it just that more men entered the field of Computer Science? My hunch (clearly not backed by any data) is that prior to the mid 80's, Computer Science was a niche field, so there weren't many people who went into CS. As CS jobs became more mainstream (given the advent of the personal computer) more men went into Studying CS, instead of other fields they had been in. With more men studying CS, more men ended up in CS jobs, and eventually you end up with male dominance. I would love to compare these rates, with what were the top engineering/science jobs in those times, and see of there is a correlation between the decrease in manufacturing/engineering, and the increase in Computer Science jobs. Perhaps it's also cause and effect. There were more medical and legal jobs, so women entered those professions, and were able to fight to get equality. Since CS was relatively new, the barriers that women face hadn't been knocked down. As time goes on, there were more female doctors and lawyers for girls to have as role models, leading to more women studying in those fields.
- kazinator 12y agoNote that Autism and Asperger's Syndrome are "male dominated". Something like 4:1. If you have a field toward which nerds gravitate, it will become male-dominated. What happened around 1984? Yes, home computers were becoming much more common as the article aptly notes. But what else? It was becoming obvious that the people who flocked to these things most, who outright related to these computers, were nerds. Popular culture latched on to this instantly! What was on the big screen and on TV? - War Games (1983) - Superman III (1983) - Major character is a computer nerd played by Richard Pryor (August "Gus" Gorman). - Riptide TV Series (1983) [1] - Major character Murray "Boz" Bozinsky is an utter nerd - Whiz Kids TV Series (1983) [2] When 1984 rolled around the trend went all out: - Revenge of the Nerds (1984) Nerd stereotypes were in the spotlight, as well as the connection between nerds and technology, especially computers. And that of course is going to have some effect on enrollment in fields of study having to do with computers. Young people respond to stereotypes in mass culture. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riptide_%28TV_series%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riptide_%28TV_series%29 [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiz_Kids_%28TV_series%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiz_Kids_%28TV_series%29
- bane 12y agoI think it's also important to note that the timing. Some of the first real mainstream home computers started selling around the time people who were graduating college in '83 and '84 were in middle school or starting high school, ripe time to start monkeying around with a computer. The Atari 8-bits were released in '79 The TRS-80 Model 1 - '77 VIC-20 - '80 TI-99/4 - '79
- colomon 12y agoAutism gender ratio is 5:1, actually. Presumably (given current definitions) that includes Asperger's as well.
- SiVal 12y agoIf unequal access to home computers in the 1980s was the main cause of loss of interest in CS degrees, why is it that every improvement in access equality has been accompanied by more loss of interest in CS? I suspect that the article might be right about the sharp turn in the 1980s being the result of personal (as opposed to corporate) computing, but we've now collected thirty years of data that suggest that access isn't the issue. Instead, I think it's the inherent lack of appeal of the activity itself. Only a small percentage of boys can maintain any interest in programming after the novelty wears off, and it's only the fact that even fewer girls stay interested that accounts for the gender imbalance.
- adventured 12y agoHas anyone considered that programming in the 1970s and 1980s was in fact less hostile and more open than many other fields for women in terms of being merit based? Emphasis on that being a relative scale (less hostile than many other fields at the time). And that during the 1960s through the 1980s, fields such as law or advertising were the opposite: openly hostile to women. With there being a critical difference being between aggressive and passive hostility. As women gradually found it easier to move into fields such as law, they chose not to pursue computer science. That shift pulled women from pursuing computer science, perhaps because women found those other jobs more fulfilling for any number of reasons. Nerds are typically not as aggressive in any sense, as the guys that would have worked in advertising or law, circa 1985 would have been.