4 ms·
Microsoft CEO says women need not ask for raise, should trust system
- rdl 12y agoIs he quoted out of context, or trolling? I'm confused, because most Microsoft people I know speak really highly of him, but the system is shitty for promoting even white guys in tech, let alone anyone else -- people get promoted by moving jobs every 12-24 months, not through being recognized and rewarded for contributions at companies. "Karma" makes me think he's trolling, or was quoted out of context. (The snarky response here is "he's clearly speaking from his extensive experience as a woman in technology...", but I'd rather take the high road.)
- ryanburk 12y agohttp://readwrite.com/2014/10/09/nadella-women-dont-ask-for-raise http://readwrite.com/2014/10/09/nadella-women-dont-ask-for-r... has a better write up, in my opinion. this was at the annual grace hopper celebration of women in computing and was not out of context / said ironically.
- dominotw 12y ago>> Twenty-nine percent of the general Microsoft workforce is female, and in the U.S., almost 61% is white. Can someone give me an american perspective on why Americans find 61% white to be an unacceptable thing considering 60-70% of american population identifies as white and America still predominantly is a white country.
- istorical 12y agoIt's the same as any other agenda-driven statistics. It's based on the interpretation the author/speaker is looking for, not any sort of greater context or meaning. Critical thinking is hard for everyone. And escaping own's own biases is difficult even when you are aware of those you hold.
- jacalata 12y agoI think they usually mean "much lower black and hispanic representation than demographics would suggest". The population of the USA is 13% black and 17% hispanic [0] - Microsoft employees are 4% black and 5% hispanic. [1] The coincidentally similar percentage of white people in the two groups is because MS has a far higher representation of Asians than the general population. [0] - http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/00000.html http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/00000.html [1] - http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/diversity/inside-microsoft/default.aspx#fbid=vsbjSFeQWq1?epgDivFocusArea http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/diversity/inside-microsoft/de...
- rokhinip 12y agoIt's true. I was at the conference when he said that and he has not been quoted out of context. If he was trolling, he chose to do it at a bad location given that he's at a conference aimed at promoting women in the tech industry
- istorical 12y agoI think the likeliest case is that he is a poor negotiator himself and has left potential raises on the table without realizing it due to a lack of initiative. The personality types that are more common in the software field are often the personality types that would avoid risk and conflict - two fears that prevent labor from negotiating for better wages. I really don't understand why this is being made into a gendered issue. My first instinct is to just assume that if he'd instead been asked "How should software developers ask their bosses for raises?" he would have had the same answer, an answer that reflects his own insecurity and fear of negotiating - not one that reveals some deep-seated prejudice.
- jacalata 12y agoIn the software field? Maybe. In the billion dollar software company CEO field? No, really not the case.
- tdicola 12y agoNo its not out of context, a better article here has more details: http://readwrite.com/2014/10/09/nadella-women-dont-ask-for-raise http://readwrite.com/2014/10/09/nadella-women-dont-ask-for-r... For what its worth he walked back the statement on twitter, "Was inarticulate re how women should ask for raise. Our industry must close gender pay gap so a raise is not needed because of a bias #GHC14"
- clubhi 12y agoI don't think roles deserve certain salaries. Different people are worth different amounts for the same role. As a corollary, I don't think women should have salary expectations because of a role.
- comrh 12y ago"Different people are worth different amounts for the same role." But are not worth different amounts because of their sex.
- clubhi 12y agoIt's impossible to infer what a female is worth because you can't even infer what a male is worth.
- ossreality 12y agoI don't think that came across the way you meant it...
- kmonsen 12y agoNot asking for raise is "good karma". Why would anyone want to work for Microsoft at this point if they have options?
- adamio 12y agoApparently he also said "That's good karma. It will come back," Nadella said. "That's the kind of person that I want to trust, that I want to give more responsibility to." http://www.theverge.com/2014/10/9/6953697/microsoft-ceo-satya-nadella-women-raises http://www.theverge.com/2014/10/9/6953697/microsoft-ceo-saty...
- rjknight 12y agoThis reminds me of David Graeber's bullshit jobs[1] thesis, that those doing more "real work" tend to get paid less because real work is enjoyable. It sounds awfully like Nadella is saying that "more responsibility" might be a substitute for better pay, and that people should be happy with that. [1] http://strikemag.org/bullshit-jobs/ http://strikemag.org/bullshit-jobs/
- pacaro 12y agoMy experience at MS was that the only way to get promoted was to have a good relationship with your manager, and for them to have a good relationship with their manager, and so on (the higher level you are the more layers need to be persuaded). So if you are in that position you don't need to ask. What to do to get your next promotion, and whether you are on track, is just something that gets discussed in 1:1s from time to time. If you are not in that position, then no amount of asking is going to make any difference, coming into work with an offer from Google/Amazon/Facebook/etc. will maybe get you escorted from the building, maybe get you a counter offer. So, while I don't have an opinion on the karmic consequences of asking for a raise, I do believe that it will not achieve anything other than friction, either your boss knows you need a raise and is working with you to get it, or you should look for another job
- matthewcford 12y agowhat a load of bullshit, if the women in MS found out that they are being underpaid and asked for a raise, then their wage bill would raise. Very self serving.
- kirinan 12y agoI think it is out of context and isn't what he means. I think he means to say that women should be able to trust the system to give them a raise if they have earned it, not that they can trust the current system or should trust the current system. I think he is talking about an ideal system and not the one we are currently in. I'm going to assume best intentions here.
- gajeam 12y agoTwo things: First of all, ironically this was at the Grace Hopper Celebration, named for one of the foremost pioneers of women in technology. Second of all, he's already essentially retracted the statement on Twitter. https://twitter.com/satyanadella/status/520311425726566400 https://twitter.com/satyanadella/status/520311425726566400
- yzzxy 12y agoHis response to the response: "Was inarticulate re how women should ask for raise. Our industry must close gender pay gap so a raise is not needed because of a bias #GHC14" https://twitter.com/satyanadella/status/520311425726566400 https://twitter.com/satyanadella/status/520311425726566400
- nickbauman 12y agoWhich implies that the solution to the problem is to LOWER the pay of men to match the pay of women. I think the term "unintended consequences" can be writ large here by now.
- anigbrowl 12y agoIt implies no such thing.
- nickbauman 12y agoJust so I understand: what DOES the statement imply? Think of me as mentally deficient here and explain it like you'd explain it to an 8 year old.
- Im_Mr_Manager 12y agoHe is saying that there should be no pay gap based on gender and if that were the case women would not need to ask for a raise to bring their salary up to the same as what a male in the same position would make.
- anigbrowl 12y agoIt implies only that he wants to see men and women paid equally for equal performance. There's no particular reason to think that he would achieve this by lowering the salaries of better-paid employees (where better pay was not correlated with superior performance) rather than by increasing the salary of worse-paid employees (likewise). If he's smart, he'd engage an outside auditor to measure employee productivity and how well it correlates with salaries, then raise the pay of any group that wturned out to be systematically disadvantaged.
- ttronicm 12y agoWhat a terrible human being! That's probably being too kind.
- jnem 12y agoThat's a very reactionary statement based on precious little information.
- rjknight 12y agoIs this surprising? CEOs of 120,000-employee corporations are not exactly well-known for their belief that those employees all deserve a raise. It might be stupid for Nadella to want to nickel-and-dime MS employees, especially female ones, but as someone who is judged by the short-term profitability of the company, he has some pretty strong incentives to do so.
- comrh 12y agoThis entire panel seemed out of touch. What were they trying to offer?
- saltcookie 12y agoan individual lacking a penise does not mean it owns a salary raise. Only merit can get u a raise.
- gojomo 12y agoI haven't seen the full context, but I believe the statements may have been offered with an implicit, "in an ideal, properly functioning system". That is, less "don't ask for a raise", more "you shouldn't have to ask, pick a place that does it automatically [my goal for Microsoft]". Of course, there are still problems with that approach: the salary incentives are never fully aligned, and even if you achieved that harmony of salaries-and-value for a short while, it would drift out of alignment. Workers demanding raises or managers cutting the overpaid would then both be required. But I can see why a large-company CEO like Nadella would hold out the ideal of smooth, regular, equitable, no-exceptional-requests salary adjustments. That's something big companies can systematize much more easily than little ones.
- neilellis 12y agoThe essential problem here is that we're still talking about men telling women what they need to do. Because, hey it's their problem. Let's just get it clear, it is all about what we (men) need to do. Slavery wasn't an African person's fault. Xenophobia isn't a problem for foreigners to sort out. There is nothing wrong with realising that we have a privilege over another group in society and making efforts to become aware of that and to work against it as best we can. What is wrong is assuming it's something that the people we have privilege over need to combat themselves. One last analogy: Hey poor person, work harder and then you can inherit money like I did. PS: Can someone explain the downvote? (PPS: it would be nice for reasons to be given for downvotes, because as a frequent user, commenter and submitter it feels pretty rubbish being down-voted without knowing why)
- neilellis 12y agoPPPS: Thanks for those who voted back up. Would be nice to know the reasons for down votes still. Wouldn't it be quite easy to prompt a down voter for a reason and display that reason. Thus encouraging responsible downvoting?
- neilellis 12y agoAnd would you believe it, that comment was downvoted :-) oh the irony!
- daeken 12y agoComments about downvoting are [almost always nearly] content-free. The way to battle bad downvoting is just to upvote content that deserves to be promoted.
- georgemcbay 12y agoI kind of wish there were a link you could click on each post to see a list of the people who downvoted it. I don't expect that to ever be added and I can imagine many ways in which it would backfire, but nothing annoys me more than silent downvotes (downvotes but no responses) to posts that are perfectly reasonable if maybe mildly controversial. If you disagree with a post (that isn't just obviously a troll or otherwise clearly meant to be offensive) enough to downvote, respond with why, it is much more useful for everyone that way.
- smokinjoe 12y agoPersonally speaking, I worked 2+ years at a company where I slowly realized that I was worth more than what I was being paid. I didn't push for a raise very hard, but the more responsibilities I acquired, the more products I built, the more customers I interacted with, I thought it would be more than fair to increase my compensation. Every single request was met with a "we'll speak about this at a better time." I would just smile, nod and go back to work. It made me feel bad about myself from the standpoint that maybe I wasn't worth that. Then of course come the friends and family that ask whether I've gotten that raise yet (always a fun conversation..). I learned that if you want something, you need to go out and get it. If you sit there waiting for a raise, you will never receive one. So I left the company and found a new job with better pay. It sucks because not everyone has that option (I'm a stupid, young, single person) and it shouldn't come down to that - but it is a reality of the business world. The fact that the CEO of Microsoft so naively believes that this is how things work is somewhat unsettling.
- diogenescynic 12y agoThis thread, in about half a second, dropped from the 2nd post from the top to the 28th post. C'mon mods, quit suppressing discussion.
- nickbauman 12y agoAnswer the following question for yourself: Why do managers not want you sharing your compensation information with your co workers? The answer is the reason why CEO answered the way he did, especially the "good karma" comment.
- zxcvvcxz 12y agoIsn't the problem that they don't ask for raises and negotiate as much or as hard as men do? I wonder what would help women with this. Everyone needs to look out for their own best interests in "the real world", no magic fairy is going to wave a wand and give people doing the same job the same money. There's no economic incentive to do so without pressure. And that pressure must come from the employees.
- jacalata 12y agoPartly. The other problem is that when they do negotiate the way men do, they tend to get far more negative reactions (like having the job offer withdrawn). http://www.cfa.harvard.edu/cfawis/bowles.pdf http://www.cfa.harvard.edu/cfawis/bowles.pdf
- zxcvvcxz 12y agoWell there's a market solution for that too - keep looking for better work if you believe you're worth more. Eventually smart employers will see the ridiculousness of what's happening, and hire all the otherwise competent workers who are being discriminated against for no good reason.
- jasonisalive 12y agoThis is the right answer, unfortunately most people are unfamiliar with or unwilling to trust this sort of logic, and so we end up with efforts to actively fight the problem with prescriptive regulation, which just make things worse. Society would be a lot better if more people could reason like you!
- jacalata 12y agoIn theory, sure. In practice, this isn't a conscious behaviour practiced only by some crazy sexist get-back-in-the-kitchen minority, this is a pretty widespread unconscious reaction from the vast majority of american society.
- blergh123 12y agoI'm actually surprised at how many people in the comments want to immediately defend or explain away his comments. It's pretty clear he meant what he said, and is now on the back foot attempting to undo the damage he did. Why does this kind of behavior need to be excused as 'out of context' or 'trolling'?
- adventured 12y agoBest guess here, is that it's because a lot of people like Satya and have been optimistic about what he might do at Microsoft. If a bigger jerk said the same thing, you wouldn't see as many people seeking to explain it away. I think people naturally prefer to give a much greater benefit of the doubt to someone they think is nice. Also, as a new CEO in a very difficult job with high levels of 24/7 scrutiny, there's likely to be an inclination to not light the guy on fire over his first misstep or three (even if it's offensive).
- neilellis 12y agoThat sounds reasonable, the problem is as ever that we human's have a problem separating the comment/action/thought from the person. It's why we can't understand that Hitler was a vegetarian or Thomas Jefferson had slaves. In reality we're a massively complex mismash of conflicting thoughts and emotions. Just like any country. Yet we expect a consistency from the aggregate! Personally speaking I can believe that he's a pretty decent person (probably more than I) and that he may well for all I know be trying to do his level best for gender equality. I only disagree with the statement, not the person. But the statement is very important when it comes from the head of one of the world's largest companies.
- ChristopherM 12y agoThis is horrible advice, men and women both must push for a raise, companies will absolutely under no circumstances just give away raises because "it's the right thing to do". Case in point, I am a white male. When I started working at a company over a decade ago I also started at the same time as another white male. I started at $55k, he started at $52k I negotiated for an additional $3k from the start. The first year I assumed they would give me a good raise since I was hired at entry level wages, I got a $2k raise. I was livid. The next year I made a huge deal about the tiny raise, I ended up getting $5k, now up to $62k. Year after $3k, again not happy. During that year there was a "salary freeze", I told my boss that was unacceptable, if I didn't get a promotion I would be leaving. So I got another $5k during the salary freeze. The next year still not happy, I made the same ultimatum, This time $10k. Up to $80k, I ended up leaving a couple of months later for a management position. In contrast that other software engineer? He got $2k per year, except for the salary freeze year, they made it up the year after. He left after 5 years making $62k Me -> $55k, $57k, $62k, $65k, $70k, $80k Him -> $52k, $54k, $56k, $58k, $58k, $62k So, apparently by being the squeaky wheel I ended up making an additional $18k a year by the time we both left. Plus all the additional money I made the preceding years. Lesson here? Make yourself very valuable to the company, and then make them pay. They won't do it of their own free will. Look at it from their perspective, if you don't say anything why would they do anything? Obviously you are happy if you are not complaining. The problem for women is that, in general, they don't speak up, they don't negotiate for salary increases they just accept what is offered. What we really need to do is to teach women how to understand what they are really worth, and to negotiate from a position of strength.
- rescendent 12y agoIt was a snippet from a very long interview where almost all of what he said was good. However, in this answer, I can see why the CEO of a 120k employee company is not going to say "get pushy with your salary" else he's have a pay rise revolt with people's justification being "your boss', boss', boss' boss told me to"
- waterhouse 12y agoI'm curious what you think of Ben Horowitz's "How to Minimize Politics in Your Company"[1]. He gives the specific example of an employee asking for a raise; he argues that responding by giving them a raise, even if it's reasonable, rewards behavior that has little to do with their job performance, which has undesirable secondary consequences. He says that the right way to deal with it is to have a good, regular, and standard process for evaluating employees and adjusting their compensation accordingly. To a person who works at a company that doesn't have such a process, I'm sure your lesson applies. But I wonder what you think about what the company should do. Take the company you worked at as an example: should they have had some process by which they would have measured your performance and come to you (and perhaps your co-worker) with a raise? (More regular and performance-dependant than "+$2k/yr each year if you haven't been fired".) Regarding the main topic of this thread: Perhaps Satya Nadella believes that Microsoft has such a process, and believes that no one should ask for a raise, and gave his advice as though all companies were like Microsoft. (Or perhaps someone has information contradicting this hypothesis.) pacaro's comment below suggests that, whatever else you might say about Microsoft's process, it doesn't reward asking for raises. [1] http://www.bhorowitz.com/how_to_minimize_politics_in_your_company http://www.bhorowitz.com/how_to_minimize_politics_in_your_co...
- general_failure 12y agoIs there a complete transcript somewhere? Why are we all jumping to conclusions with no data? All this discussion seems pointless without enough information.
- jacalata 12y agoBecause some of us watched it? There is a full video here [0] and a transcript of the specific question and answer here [1] [0] http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/10/09/microsofts-nadella-backtracks-from-comment-about-women/?module=BlogPost-Title&version=Blog%20Main&contentCollection=Policy&action=Click&pgtype=Blogs®ion=Body http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/10/09/microsofts-nadella-... and [1] http://techcrunch.com/2014/10/09/microsoft-ceo-opens-mouth-inserts-foot-on-gender-pay-gap/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/10/09/microsoft-ceo-opens-mouth-i...
- amaks 12y agoQuartz: Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella, here’s the real definition of karma. http://google.com/newsstand/s/CBIwh9iU1ho http://google.com/newsstand/s/CBIwh9iU1ho
- neilellis 12y agoFantastic, indeed Karma (or Kamma in the Pali) just means action. The fruit of any action is of the same quality as the action itself. So indeed this infers that asking to have the same pay as a male colleague, or any colleague is in itself greed and that the fruit born from it would be of a similar type. The Buddha I believe recommended that you never talk about the Kamma of another as it is usually just a way to hide a value judgement of someone else. Instead we should focus on what Kamma we take and therefore the type of fruits we'll experience in the future. If this interests anybody - this is an excellent book on the subject: https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CCEQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.saraniya.com%2Fbooks%2Fmeditation%2FPaul_R_Fleischman-Karma_and_Chaos.pdf&ei=KTM3VNOJO9PXaqGkgZgO&usg=AFQjCNFVDCReY64GRXGS-n0FVEKB6ZxZ2A https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web...
- Mikeb85 12y agoDear god, everyone should ask for a raise. You can't trust that your employer will give you one out of kindness or something...