12 ms·
How Memorizing “$19.05” Can Help You Outsmart the MTA
- mirkules 12y agoIf they really wanted to fix this, the text would read "How many rides would you like to purchase ($2.50 per ride)". Of course, this only works if every ride is $2.50.
- uptown 12y agoWith a few exceptions (i.e. the Express Buss which costs $6), every ride is $2.50. http://web.mta.info/nyct/fare/FaresatAGlance.htm#info http://web.mta.info/nyct/fare/FaresatAGlance.htm#info
- colinbartlett 12y agoI think the whole point is that they don't want to fix this. It's probably specifically designed this way.
- ovi256 12y agoSounds a lot like a dark pattern! If not dark, at least gray.
- embolalia 12y agoNYC Subway fares are always $2.50. Really, as confusing fares go, this is nothing compared to DC's Metro. At the top of the machine, above the head of anyone who can actually fit in the train, there's a massive listing of fares to each other station in the system (on and off peak, which are different). In order to fill your card perfectly, you need to know exactly which stations you'll be using and when. Granted, most tourists will be traveling within the distances that get the minimum fare, and off-peak, so they could just go by that minimum fare. There's just no actual indication of that fact. Oh, and if you want a plastic RFID card rather than magnetic paper that will fall apart within 3 trips, you need to spend $10 for $8 of fare. (EDIT: And another commenter mentioned something I'd forgotten: those paper farecards also come with a $1 surcharge per trip.)
- munin 12y agoeach ride with the magnetic paper also costs $1 extra, to incentivize using the RFID, but the RFID cards stop working after a month and when they do you have no way to get the balance off of it the way you do with a paper card. yay!
- mikeash 12y agoOdd, my wife and I have both had ours for many years and they still work fine.
- tedks 12y agoI've had DC Smarttrip cards last years. Actually, I've only ever owned two since they were introduced. They definitely don't stop working after a month.
- JosephHatfield 12y agoI was one of the first people in DC to get the Smart Card. That original card lasted for more than ten years. The first (much thinner) replacement card failed after two months. The second failed after three months. I complained to WMATA and they completely denied any change in the card design. I've been back on paper fare cards ever since.
- palidanx 12y agoI was just in DC and I noticed that on the buses some times you have to swipe 3-4 times just to get it to work? Is it just a weird software glitch or my bad luck?
- pikewood 12y agoThe original SmarTrip cards came from a company that went out of business, but used proprietary technology. WMATA eventually found another company to create the cards, and I believe this came about the time when new SmarTrip cards reduced in price from $5 to $2. So perhaps not a change in the design, but definitely a change in the manufacturing. http://wamu.org/news/10/10/15/metro_board_replacing_smartrip_will_be_difficult http://wamu.org/news/10/10/15/metro_board_replacing_smartrip...
- zokier 12y agoI presume this does not matter if you are a regular user of the system because over time presumably the remainders would accumulate?
- krschultz 12y agoYes. If you are a daily commuter, you should be buying the unlimited card anyway. If you live in NYC and just the subways frequently (as I do), then you just refill when you run out. Whether there is $2.45 or $0.00 when I run out and need to refill doesn't matter to me. No matter what I'm cursing at the train that invariably pulls in at the moment I run out of money and hustling to the nearest machine to refill hopefully before the train pulls away. Which is why I would never waste the time to enter a specific amount.
- SippinLean 12y agoBetter still, just get the card that links to your bank account and automatically refills when it gets low.
- gav 12y agoIf you are a regular commuter, but don't ride enough to make the unlimited card work, there's an EasyPay MetroCard[1]. It refills automatically via credit card (and you get the 5% bonus) so you never have to use the machines. [1] http://web.mta.info/metrocard/EasyPayXpress.htm http://web.mta.info/metrocard/EasyPayXpress.htm
- patmcguire 12y agoI remember a similar thing when I lived in a building with it's own laundry card system. You could only put on money in increments of $5, and every wash or dry cost $1.70. The math there meant that you had to do an exact multiple of 50 loads over the lifetime of the card, or else you would wind up orphaning money.
- harmonicon 12y agoI always thought "turnstyle" and its variants ("turn-style" in this post) are misspellings of the word turnstile. However I have seen it quite a lot online in different articles. Is "turnstyle" actually a different spelling for turnstile?
- lstamour 12y agoNot that I know of. The article also said "ween" instead of "seen", so maybe it just needs a couple quick edits.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- moron4hire 12y agoNeither of those are "Americanisms". They are just ignorant.
- unclebunkers 12y agoWe really don't see either here, so I'm going to have to disagree with you on that.
- teddyh 12y agoOr intense porpoises: http://www.wastedtalent.ca/comic/phocoena-intensus http://www.wastedtalent.ca/comic/phocoena-intensus
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nodata 12y agoMTA doesn't mean sendmail/Postfix for anyone wondering. MTA = Metropolitan Transportation Authority in NYC
- gdg92989 12y agoI guess this makes sense if you're visiting NY and you're only going to use the subway a few times. If you live in the city though you're probably just refilling the same card over and over. Then the logic of filling the card up doesn't hold up. you should go for the largest "bonus" you can get and try not to lose that card!
- otoburb 12y agoThis makes sense on the surface, but the confounding factor is that the NYC MTA cards are rather flimsy. Bend these cards just a little bit and they sometimes don't scan as smoothly. The trivial inconvenience of social pressure while attempting to swipe an inconsistent card with a bunch of other people behind you waiting to push through the turnstiles is enough to cause me to consider purchasing a new card. Yes, most of the time we're just refilling the same card over and over, but these cards also have an expiry date of 1 year. This is still a good hack to keep in mind.
- zavulon 12y agoIf your card expired with balance still remaining, you can exchange it at the window for a new card, transferring the balance and not losing anything. Or you can do it by mail.
- otoburb 12y agoProvided the magnetic strip can be read. Usually the card is so beaten up from usage over the year that the magnetic stripe will become unreadable before the an unavailable balance is left to be transferred.
- macNchz 12y ago>This makes sense on the surface, but the confounding factor is that the NYC MTA cards are rather flimsy. Bend these cards just a little bit and they sometimes don't scan as smoothly. I have plenty of criticisms about the Metrocard system, but I've had no problems keeping my cards operational until they expire. I keep the card in a regular card slot in my wallet, use it 2-4 times a day and refill it once a month. No issues in years.
- rthomas6 12y agoI consider this a dark pattern. That's pretty underhanded of them.
- scrollaway 12y agoWhat a disgusting dark pattern to be put to use in public transports. I don't think this can be classified any other way than a scam. Sure, they scam you out of a couple of dollars, but they do it on a massive scale and at the expense of thousands upon thousands of people.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wdewind 12y agoNo, the point is to incentivize people to keep their cards, ie: conserve. It's a good thing, just like the charge for a new card. I'm a New Yorker, so at least some of us like it.
- yahelc 12y agoTo be fair, it's a less relevant tactic now that they charge $1 for the card itself. This is essentially seigniorage.
- tomp 12y agoThe correct way to do that is to charge a deposit for a new card. That's how London's Oyster cards work, although it's a scam in other ways (to get the "deposit" back, you need a proof of address, i.e. if you're a tourist, you can't get the deposit back (except on some specific tube stations)).
- Someone1234 12y agoThat wasn't my experience. I just went to a ticket desk and they not only gave me my deposit back but also the remaining balance on not one but two cards. Wasn't a hassle at all. That was at the underground Victoria station ticket counter.
- shawabawa3 12y ago> to get the "deposit" back, you need a proof of address, That's only for registered cards. Which makes perfect sense, because they're registered to an address to prevent people stealing them and returning them for cash
- brown9-2 12y agoDo public agencies in other countries also try to scam the public out of additional revenue?
- albinoloverats 12y agoIt's basically the same here in London; although if you're a local you're more likely to have an annual (or monthly) pass or possibly automatic top-up if you pay as you go.
- Sulfolobus 12y agoNot sure that is totally fair, especially as Oyster allows you to go into negative balance over a journey as long as you have enough for the minimum fare on your card when you touch in.
- radicalbyte 12y agoIn Holland it's much worse. You aren't allowed to use public transport unless you have minimal 20 EUR balance on your card (or agree to be tracked and I assume have your travel data sold / 'lost'). This applies for return journeys, so after the first leg of the journey you need to make sure there's 20 EUR left or you're screwed.
- thisjepisje 12y agoIf you don't want to use your card any more you can get the money back, though. Minus a 2,50 administration fee, of course.
- radicalbyte 12y agoCan I get the 7.50 I was forced to pay for the card back too?
- thisjepisje 12y agoDon't think so.
- bumeye 12y agoThat's only for trains. For bus/metro/tram you only need 4 EUR on your card. See https://www.ov-chipkaart.nl/reizen/tarieven/instapenbasistarief/ https://www.ov-chipkaart.nl/reizen/tarieven/instapenbasistar....
- chiph 12y agoOther than the obvious money-grab by the authority (1 million cards x 20 EUR x 1% / 12 months == 16666 EUR income each month), what's the reasoning behind this? Only financially solvent individuals can use public transport?
- yackob03 12y agoI'm assuming they have variable pricing based on distance traveled, and 20 EUR covers the highest fare for the system. That could just be my optimistic bias speaking though.
- mp99e99 12y agogreat article, thanks for posting I will use this next time I'm in NYC visiting, I'm frequently leaving with small dollars or change, and I end up losing the card or forgetting about it [as MTA's plan]
- nodata 12y agoCan you pay in part with a MetroCard and in part with coins?
- nhstanley 12y agoWait, how long has it been like this? Haven't lived in NY for a few years but they used to give you a nice round number bonus. This is the crappy kind of thing businesses do that governments should specifically not do nor need to do (trick you with dark patterns, force you to give a no interest loan/gift, etc.). And I should point out it's regressive. That $1.95 matters a lot to some people. Incredibly shitty, IMO.
- krschultz 12y agoI'm not convinced it is a giant ploy to screw you, I think it might be a hold over from before the last fair raise. I don't remember the bonus changing, but the fair changed.
- jrockway 12y agoHow are you being forced to give them a no interest loan/gift? If you add money to the card, they give you 5% extra. Good luck getting 5% out of your savings account. If you add only $2.50 to the card, then they receive no gift. The problem is waiting in line to add $2.50 to the card before every ride, which is why nobody does that.
- pjc50 12y agoThis is the antipattern that "Microsoft Points" used to use, except there you were forced to buy a round number that wasn't divisible into the quantity you wanted.
- Hawkee 12y agoI love the way they do it in Taipei. They have attendants at every station where you hand them your card and cash. 2 seconds later your card is updated. It's actually faster than using the machine as there's never a line.
- bkcooper 12y agoReally, the only people I see likely getting caught out on this are tourists leaving with unused balances. The argument that "they get the money sooner" seems like nonsense to me. They get the money when you put it on the card, either way. Re: the tourists, Metro in DC has an approach that I assume is for charging tourists more, which is that paper farecards (instead of the reusable SmarTrip card) get a surcharge of $1 on each trip. They're very open about the surcharge, so if you don't like it, then you can get a SmarTrip; however, it would then take a pretty involved computation to end up with zero balance at the end. I'm actually pretty favorable toward the DC policy. Increasing tourist revenue (who probably are going to be pretty willing to pay slightly more for limited subway use) in a tourist-heavy spot seems like a reasonable approach to subsidizing the heavier commuting users of the system. With Metro specifically that may not be a huge deal because so many people have their commuting paid for as a benefit, but I like the basic idea.
- 7952 12y agoTourists are also probably more likely to buy an unlimited pass and avoid the hassle of topping up completely.
- pwg 12y agoThe DC metro system does not offer an "unlimited pass". Each trip costs what it costs, and deducts that amount from whichever card you have. There's two rate schedules, rush-hour (pricier) and non-rush (slightly lower price). I suspect the reason advertised to the DC metro's govt. managers is that the paper fare card (the one that now has a $1 surcharge) is a disposable item. Once run down to zero, or rolled over to another card in a fare machine, the old paper card becomes trash. Therefore I suspect the govt. regulators were told the fee was an "encouragement" to save resources and buy the reusable plastic card vs. the throw away paper card. Now, the fact that they get an extra $1, per trip, out of most all tourists (and locals) who don't notice the surcharge up front (it is advertised, just not that boldly...) was never really discussed at the regulator meetings.
- jsight 12y ago
- skizm 12y agoIt is the same reason why hotdogs are sold in packs of 10 and hotdog buns are sold in packs of 8.
- zheshishei 12y agoA humorous column article on the subject: www.straightdope.com/columns/read/560/why-do-hot-dogs-come-10-to-a-pack-while-buns-are-8-to-a-pack
- ghaff 12y agoProbably--but probably not for the reason you're implying. In both cases, it's likely just how things ended up by reason of the various paths they took to get to where they are today.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Schweigi 12y agoDoesnt this $2.45 left over money make the bookkeeping more complicated for them? Because in theory someone could come back after a couple of years and refill his card so its not possible to book those $2.45 as profit.
- yincrash 12y agoMetroCards expire about two years after the date of sale. The balance from an expired card is still transferable (but rarely is ever transferred) for 2 more years after expiration. After that, it's fare :) game for the MTA. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/17/nyregion/unspent-metrocard-money-means-millions-for-mta.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/17/nyregion/unspent-metrocard...
- Sanddancer 12y agoTheoretically, yes, but most people don't. Most big transit agencies with passes like this have calculated unused values from transit cards as part of their budgets.
- simias 12y agoWith big enough numbers (and I assume there are a lot of these cards in circulation) it shouldn't be hard to make statistics and know exactly what percentage is never going to be claimed again. That's the same tactic used by banks at a different scale, if everybody attempted to claim all the money in their accounts (during a bank run for instance) the whole thing would collapse, but they know it's not normally likely to happen so they keep only a fraction of the total savings available at any time.
- otoburb 12y agoMy friend pointed me to an iOS app[1] that can generate tables based on target remaining balances. [1] https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/metrocalc/id328570105 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/metrocalc/id328570105
- somewhatn00b 12y agoAnother app that can do something similar: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/nyc-fare-finder/id578500857?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/nyc-fare-finder/id578500857?...
- warfangle 12y agoI just keep a $5 balance available on my unlimited use card. That way even when the unlimited time limit runs out, I don't have to go and stand in line to refill my card while I miss my train. I just put the $2.50 back on it (and renew my unlimited) as I'm leaving at my destination. I guess for those who don't ride enough for an unlimited to be worth it are gotcha'd this way.. I ride 20 times a week, though (break-even on a 7-day card is 12 times a week; monthly is 6.4 times a week. I tend to lose my card occasionally, though, and the hurt from losing a $112 card is a LOT higher than losing a $35 card. Yes, they have a recovery system. No, I've never gotten it to actually work).
- theIV 12y agoI never knew you could carry a cash balance alongside the unlimited use... This will save me from this incredible annoying situation. Thank you! Now, just to remember to refill the 5 bucks when I run out of that... Side note: I never really understood why they don't have MC booths _inside_ the station. My assumption is it's too costly between maintenance, and security when the machine needs to be emptied vs. how much they stand to make from it. But, ever since they introduced the credit/debit only machines, it seems like it could save people a bunch of time when they only realize _after_ they've swiped, that they are out of cash.
- error54 12y agoI've put money on an unlimited card and it doesn't work. When the card expires, swiping it merely brings up the "card expired" message and there's no way to deduct the remaining balance.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- happywolf 12y agoI doubt Metro can keep the money. There is an escheatment law whereby unclaimed money will need to be turned over to the state. It is a big hassle to them IMHO.
- Coincoin 12y agoThat's why here we have tickets on our cards, not money. The drawback being that a ticket for one city or zone can't be used in another one. And of course, every city's ticket bundles have different sizes, just like hot dogs and buns packages.
- mergesort 12y agoI really hated this too, so I wrote an app a few years ago for this, to tell you exactly how much to put on your card no matter how much you have on it. [Inserts shameless plug for Metroptimizer.] https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/metroptimizer-2/id649185762?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/metroptimizer-2/id649185762?....
- ErikRogneby 12y agoWay to scratch your own itch!
- sneak 12y agoThe MTA is no doubt using the same software or maybe even the same system as the NYPD for facial recognition. Reusing cards, or buying cards for anything other than cash, is basically like an automated license plate scanner. Use cash, and switch cards regularly. Never give them your name or bank card to associate with their unknown record in the facial biometrics database. I would be unsurprised to learn that this is used to get people to reuse cards in an effort to persist a unique identifier for facial matching, as the video data can be correlated with swipe logs.
- wingerlang 12y agoParanoid much?
- teddyh 12y agoIt’s not paranoia (at least not necessarily so) when there is every indication that they really are out to get you. Or all of us, really.
- wingerlang 12y agoOut to "get" you exactly how?
- sneak 12y agoHow do you equate not wishing my day to day local travel to be archived permanently by law enforcement with being paranoid?
- terminado 12y agoWeak. You can just buy a $20 card, pay $21, get the bonus, and then add on the remainder of the next closest $2.50 block, in a second transaction, by using the "Other Amounts" option, which permits any amount greater than $1 (including change, as in $1.99). If you can't fathom the math for this, while thinking on your feet, too bad for you. And yeah, this takes longer, and people waiting behind you might be impatient. But this is New York, so everyone else can go fuck themselves.
- stephenc_c_ 12y agoThis is why I'm so glad we can now use our contactless credit cards on the tube in London.
- glitch003 12y agoThat's a really great example of reusing capable hardware. The clipper card system used in the Bay Area by BART etc is technically capable of this as well, but it hasn't been implemented and probably never will :(
- podopie 12y agoTo be fair, this is price agnostic, and they are the same patterns they've had when the subway/bus price was 2.25. The remainders, while still more than a couple pennies, were definitely smaller than the current setup. It also allows for the MTA to continue price hiking (ugh) without people ending up with even larger remainders: "I have 2.50 on my card but now it's 2.75!" What they should have done was update these price points alongside the price change that occurred to keep remainders at or under a dollar. A "fill to the next ride" option could also be a great way to even out the remaining cost. While this still isn't perfect and screws over tourists (particularly when they removed the 1 day unlimited!), I imagine this is non-issue for the majority of New Yorkers (myself included). I also imagine there's good reason here. Imagine all the trash that gets created because someone will finish up their metro card completely. The extra $1 fee per new card was likely a newer solution to prevent people from throwing them in the streets or in the subway trench, and providing an odd remainder on the card may have been a historical way to do the same. Imagine, if you had an extra dollar sitting around on your card, you probably would reuse it, and not throw it out. That said, the fact that anyone can get from Sunset Park to the Bronx Botanical Gardens (a 20+ mile drive) for 2.50 isn't so bad of a deal.
- lorddoig 12y agoThere's a few comments here that say it only applies to tourists, because the problem is only manifest at the card's end of life: lose the card/stop needing it and that's the point you get shafted for the excess balance. Fingers crossed a resident won't see a card EOL, they'll just top it up over and over, and so it seemingly doesn't apply. But equating long life with infinite life isn't quite right here. Every card will stop being used some day. If the MTA know with certainty that X proportion of cards do EOL with Y USD on them, then they can safely consider X × Y as earnings and spend it immediately, ergo the moment of first top up is the true moment of shafting. I'd bet good money that the MTA's internal figures record earnings from excess balances by counting cards newly registered, not cards recently expired. I studied econ at a good school, and I can tell you that an economist would 100% equate this with theft. Because it is. edit: This - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8274314 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8274314 - is a very good point. Ensuring cards always have a meaningful balance on them is probably the best way to stop people treating them as disposable (I imagine their cost is non-negligible). If they're given out free, it's clever, but if you have to buy them (like London's Oyster cards) it's even more of a scam. To have a totally clear moral conscience the MTA should really let you return the card and cash out.
- wdewind 12y agoSerious question: why are you assuming cards EOL with balance on them more frequently now than when they had rounded amounts?
- tehwebguy 12y agoI would assume that people are more likely to throw away a card that is nearing the end of it's usable life if it had a zero balance. But if a balance remains it seems like one would be more likely to add more money to the card.
- cauterized 12y agoYou can also transfer your balance to a new card.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- moot 12y agoFYI, station agents will merge/combine MetroCards for you, so you can recover small balances from old/unexpired ones.
- kingkawn 12y agoWhen using unlimited cards I always back swipe as I leave the station to allow others to get free rides.
- u124556 12y agoWhy not just ask how many rides do you want instead?
- frankosaurus 12y agoThe current pricing has the potential to cut down waste. If your metro card has zero balance, you may as well toss it out. If you're carrying a balance, you'll refill it at one of the kiosks.
- diggan 12y agoThat's an interesting article. However, seems very confusing at all to have a card with money on it to travel with the metro. According to the comments here, most other cities (in USA I guess) have it the same way as well. In Barcelona, where I live, the system is different. You buy a card with travels on it instead. One travel is a entry to the metro until you leave the metro. So if you buy a card with ten travels, you're sure to get ten travels. If you buy 50, you get 50. This seems like a much more reasonable system.
- jrockway 12y agoMetrocard also works on other systems: the Airtrain JFK, which is $5 per ride; PATH, which used to be only $2.25 per ride; MTA express buses, which vary in price. These systems are used because people don't want to line up and buy tickets before every ride.
- diggan 12y agoThe same with the cards we have here. One travel is one ride, with metro, bus or tram. Also the "trains" that goes to up on the mountains use the same card. Having credits for travels vs money on the card won't make any difference on how you buy the tickets. Only how easy it is for the consumers/users to use.
- cpwright 12y agoIt isn't reasonable for the fares to be the same. They are determined by different transit agencies, and have different costs. The select bus service is a much different experience than the subway, and as such is priced much higher. Having a cash balance means you can decide what to use it on, when you use it instead of when you buy it.
- jrockway 12y agoIndeed. PATH and AirTrain are run by the Port Authority, which is a multi-state agency. The subway is run by MTA New York City Transit, which is part of the New York state government.
- davidf18 12y agoIn NYC you can get the unlimited monthly passes with auto-refill from your CC at the end of each month. Nothing could be simpler and is a great value esp. compared with prices of anything else in high cost NYC. It is much cheaper and easier to use than Wash DC. Also, the train frequency even at 11 PM and later is every few minutes in Manhattan. Just wish we had the Verizon WiFi access that the DC Metro has....
- hbosch 12y agoYes, I was waiting for this post to touch on the value of the unlimited pass ($112 for 30 days). If you work 20 days a month, and use the train to commute to and from the office, then you're paying $100/mo just to commute. If you take the train just 5 times outside of your daily commute per month, you start getting free rides. I don't think I ever met someone when I lived in NYC who was buying prepaid cards instead of unlimited ride cards. The "left behind" balance on prepaid cards are the same dark pattern as every gift card in existence: the issuers bank on some (most?) balances being lost or leftover or forgotten.
- adamzerner 12y ago> It turns out the MTA has designed it that way. That's awful. I'm no expert in economics, but bear with me. The MTA operates a natural monopoly. In a natural monopoly you don't have competitors, so your customers can't turn to someone else to receive better service. Furthermore, the government has granted them the right to be the one provider in this market. I think that this makes them somewhat of a public service. Normally quality of service comes from the pressure of competitors, but in this case there are no competitors. I think the government has a responsibility to see that this is clearly a dishonest tactic and fix it. If the government doesn't enforce honest practice, than it won't get enforced at all (because competitors aren't there to do it). (sorry for the somewhat confused argument, but there's really something wrong with this)
- cpwright 12y agoFor most intents and purposes, the MTA is the government. NYS sets up lots of various quasi-governmental authorities, because the authorities can issue debt without having votes, whereas the state government needs to have voters approve bonds.
- MiguelHudnandez 12y ago> You could even write it on the back of your Metrocard if you can figure out how to get ink to stay on it. If I want to write something on a credit card, I put some clear tape over the ink afterward. I've never seen a MetroCard, but based on photos online, it looks like heavy paper stock with a glossy finish. So a sharpie and some clear tape should do the trick for the lifetime of the card.
- yackob03 12y agoI have never seen the options ending in $9, does this only show up if you're paying cash? When I pay with credit card I always get $10 and $20 options. If it is only for cash users, $19.05 is a really terrible experience for someone paying with a $20.
- aganders3 12y agoIf all rides cost the same (i.e. price is not dependent on distance traveled) why don't they sell cards with X number of rides on them? The "rides" on the card could act like forever stamps, in that they would be valid even if the price per ride someday increased. This seems like a much fairer system that would still encourage people to buy in advance and keep their cards.
- peter303 12y agoMost tourist probably buy unlimited ride card, fixed period, so they they dont have to worry about refills. It pays for itself if you average three rides a day.
- savrajsingh 12y agoImagine the UI was framed around # of rides, instead of dollar amount.
- jacobbudin 12y agoThe author doesn't seem to realize the MTA has tried and failed to get rid of the bonus. The only reason the bonus still exists is because of political pressure. Therefore, it's unlikely a "dark pattern" by a nefarious public agency that the people need to "outsmart". As another commented mentioned, it's about charging a full dollar amount (after $1 new card fee) for people paying with cash. Sources: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/16/nyregion/mta-chief-signals-metrocard-bonus-wont-vanish.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/16/nyregion/mta-chief-signals... http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/13/nyregion/mta-may-eliminate-7-bonuses-on-metrocards.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/13/nyregion/mta-may-eliminate...
- masklinn 12y ago> Therefore, it's unlikely a "dark pattern" by a nefarious public agency that the people need to "outsmart". Sounds like bull. They could trivially offer whole-fare counts and give whatever price that represents with a "you save $x" note.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoThat sounds like something that would require internal coordination between departments at the MTA, and is therefore not trivial. I wish it was /s.
- mcguire 12y agoIs the MTA's approach to card balances different from the "mail in rebate" approach that took over from running sales on purchases? Or, really, the practice of requesting email addresses and mailing list subscriptions in exchange for coupons, etc.?
- sii 12y agoAnd here I thought the article was going to be about mail transfer agents.
- chillingeffect 12y ago1. It is deliberate. 2. It is merciless. (Would the city really lose out if it gave three rides for $2.50 and then one for $2.45? They already have a 5% bonus (whose main purpose is to trick you into a -20% bonus) would a 5.03% bonus be unheard of?) 3. To achieve fairness, this system burdens the entire city with a cognitive load. It's not theft, it's fraud. "But how can it be fraud?" you clamor, all of the terms are spelled out clearly. The fraud is not in the financial transactional terms, but in the trust to place in our leaders. We entrust them to choose fares and design a fare-paying system that is merciful, fair and doesn't enforce an undue cognitive load. This system violates that trust. How can they expect the public to remain peaceful and satisfied while they're deliberately infringing on our trust in this way?
- Istof 12y agoThey should at least have to follow the same law as gift cards for expiration date: can't expire within five years. http://www.ncsl.org/research/financial-services-and-commerce/gift-cards-and-certificates-statutes-and-legis.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/financial-services-and-commerce...
- SixSigma 12y agoMail Transport Agent ?
- JohnDoe365 12y agoStill fundamentally wrong. They should ask: "How many rides you wan't to buy" instead of offering an amount to load after which you have to make the math on your own.
- edge17 12y agoThe more insidious aspect of this are the psychological pattern of people like my parents (who belong to a different generation) that will pick the UI path that causes the least apprehension. My parents are both very intelligent people, but they struggle like many with user interfaces on machines. Every time I am in NY to visit, there is a stack of cards waiting for me - so I will spend 20 minutes in the morning down at the train station filling each of the tickets up to a sane number.
- dk0hn 12y agoMy way is far simpler: fill and refill with $50. The 5% bonus adds one $2.50 ride, for a total of 21 rides. Easy peasy, with no weird values to memorize.