6 ms·
Study participants typically did not enjoy spending 15 minutes by themselves
- ekianjo 12y agoPeople in solitary confinement can certainly confirm it's not very enjoyable to stay by yourself with your own thoughts.
- jpttsn 12y agoPeople who meditate can certainly reject it. I don't think it's categorically unpleasant. Confinement is unpleasant because of the high opportunity cost.
- watwut 12y agoPeople who meditate have way more control over when it ends, what they eat and when they turn off the light. Read up about psychological effects about long term solitary confinement and sensory deprivation that goes with it. The problem is not just the high opportunity cost. The experience can cause long term psychological issues.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- userbinator 12y agoThis is sad and a bit disturbing because it suggests that average people seem to dislike thinking. I'm quite the opposite, and 15 minutes of pure thinking for me would pass by quite easily - I feel like I can't get enough time to think more carefully about all the ideas that I have for the things I do, or want to. Then again, I'm introverted and definitely not representative of the average population. (Of course, I'm assuming here that their test subjects weren't secretly masochists who enjoyed shocking themselves, and ignoring some of the other biases that might be present - e.g. if their participants were self-selected, most of them might be those who are bored with nothing else to do.)
- 6cxs2hd6 12y agoDoes this study have any bearing on "hammock-driven development" vs. the compulsion to start writing code (with or without TDD)?
- notduncansmith 12y agoDon't know why you're being downvoted, this actually came to my mind as well - I'm a big fan of HDD (thanks Rich!). I don't think this study has much bearing on it though; the study focused on "the average person", who arguably does not share the same propensity for deep thought as a developer who'd be attracted to HDD.
- watwut 12y agoI read somewhere that they used device with 9V battery. We used to lick both 4.5V and 9V batteries as kids. I found 4.5V hit to be quite pleasant and I would repeat the "experiment" a lot. Licking 9V battery was less pleasant, but not really too uncomfortable. I did that multiple times too even through my room was full of toys. Their device could generate less pleasant feelings, sure. But I am kind of skeptical of big conclusions people take out of this study.
- opk 12y agoI don't think you can conclude too much from it being a 9V battery. It depends how it is connected up. The shock from an implantable cardio defibrillator which comes from a small lithium battery hurts more than 240V through your fingers.
- molbioguy 12y agoI get the point that people may prefer external stimulation to internal thoughts. But I think the result of this study hinge on whether the electric shock was really all that unpleasant. For safety reasons, I'll assume the shock wasn't large enough to be harmful or create anything but a momentary sensation. People are curious, and it would seem a fairly safe environment. What's to stop them from simply experimenting with a new sensation. Roller coasters and scary movies should logically be avoided, but they aren't. The guy they mentioned who shocked himself 190 times clearly must have thought it was fun.
- nwh 12y agoI've shocked myself badly a few times and to me at least, I'd much rather wallow in self pity for a while than do it again. Probably the worst was one I didn't expect, I slipped when opening a plastic case and caught my fingers over a fully charged high capacity 350v capacitor. The initial hit makes every muscle in your body hurt, then a wave of panic when you realize you could have died from the moment of stupidity.
- noir_lord 12y agoPutting your hand across phases on a 415V industrial supply will do that as well (which should never have happened but that is why we have training to show people how not to make other peoples fuckups) fortunately I was wearing heavy rubber boots and the contact was momentary. Lesson of the day when your co-worker/trainee/friend says the supply is isolated...check anyway.
- cdcarter 12y agoAlways follow lockout tagout procedures! Always!
- vidarh 12y agoMy "favorite" was deisolating a live phone wire with my teeth when I was a kid, and managing to complete the circuit via my tongue just as someone rang. It didn't actually hurt very much. But everything went white for a moment.
- robert_tweed 12y agoThis is getting posted a lot. Here's one from yesterday, where I commented: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7988759 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7988759 (edit: whoops, fixed the link!) This one elaborates a bit further, saying that the percentages of each sex that chose the shock were out of the group that had already had the shock and said they would pay not to have it again. Still would be nice to get the original text instead of all these piecemeal, borderline blogspam articles, but it's behind a paywall at Science, here: http://www.sciencemag.org/content/345/6192/75 http://www.sciencemag.org/content/345/6192/75
- _Adam 12y agoIt's not like they aren't capable of amusing their selves with their own thoughts. It's more like they aren't willing to try.
- personlurking 12y ago“All of humanity's problems stem from man's inability to sit quietly in a room alone.” - Blaise Pascal
- amouat 12y agoIsn't the main impulse behind pushing the button simple curiosity rather than boredom? I'd be sitting there thinking about what the shock would feel like until I gave into my own curiosity and pushed the button. However, I still definitely like spending time on my own with own thoughts.
- iak8god 12y ago> Isn't the main impulse behind pushing the button simple curiosity rather than boredom? I thought this too at first, but it turns out they exposed everyone to the shock along with a bunch of other stimuli in preparation for this part of the experiment. Also one guy shocked himself 190 times.
- encloser 12y agoThis seems like a poor study to gauge peoples' desire/aversion to thinking. You put me in a room with nothing but a button I'll probably press it out of curiosity. Put me in a garden with a enjoyable drink and I'll happily contemplate whatever comes to mind until I want to get a refill.
- jdiez17 12y agoYou didn't read the article. It says they shocked the participants before the study started so the curiosity factor was not present.
- Mithaldu 12y agoThe article says they exposed people to the shocks and other stimuli to get a response to the 5$ question. It doesn't say they took the people and gave them 15 minutes to play around with the thing. Curiosity is still very much in the game, especially when there's nothing else to do. A much more meaningful way to do this experiment would've been to have people sit and receive regular shocks (not under their own control), and to sit with nothing else to do, provide an incentive for staying 15 minutes and see how quickly they give up. And while i'm writing: The article also mentions they couldn't find people who enjoy the time alone, but didn't mention whether they asked people who habitually medidate.
- Aqueous 12y agoOne participant shocked themselves 190 times. I'd say I'd concede curiosity is the main factor the first one or two times.
- Estragon 12y agoYes, but the mean number of times was less than 1.5, with maximum 4 if you exclude that outlier. The vast majority of cases are perfectly compatible with curiosity, a scenario the paper ignored completely, and which could have been at least partially addressed simply by asking participants why they pressed the button. This is an OK study, sexed up in a very cynical and ignorant way.
- PeterGriffin 12y agoMany, many people willingly meditate ("alone with their thoughts") on their own will in order to focus and clear their mind, including me. And that's despite I do have traumatic events in my past that float up from time to time. No thoughts of self-mutilation or electroshocking myself so far. Either is this study flawed, or it was reported poorly (hey, what's new, right), but I'm so sick of shitty studies in popular media, I won't even try to figure out which one.
- alekratz 12y agoThink about the deeper implications of the experiment. Yes, people will shock themselves when there's nothing to do. However, that also means that when there's nothing to do, the majority of people will try to physically stimulate themselves because that's all there is TO do. To say that we're stupid because we would administer a painful shock to ourselves rather than sit in our own silence for 15 minutes is a very naiive way to approach the results. Come to a conclusion, dammit!
- userbinator 12y agoIndeed, "physically stimulate themselves", in every sense of that phrase. :-)
- shasta 12y ago> One person pressed the button 190 times. New study finds researchers trolled by subjects.
- bausson 12y agoNew study found short-circuits in study test materials.
- damon_c 12y agoLooks like time alone with thoughts is ready to be disrupted.
- jpttsn 12y agoWhat if there was no novelty factor? Electric shocks aren't so common; I'd play with a machine that let's me have a new sensation. I might prefer it to time alone with thoughts because I believe I'll have the latter available any time I want.
- joshvm 12y agoOf course the journal article isn't open access. But hey, Google. "To see whether the difficulty with “just thinking” is distinctive to college students, in study 9 we recruited community participants at a farmer’s market and a local church. The par- ticipants ranged in age from 18 to 77 (median age = 48.0 years). As in study 7, they completed the study online in their own homes, after receiving instructions to do so when they were alone and free of any external distractions. The results were similar to those found with college students. There was no evidence that enjoyment of the thinking period was related to participants’ age, education, income, or the frequency with which they used smart phones or social media (table S2)." So apparently it's not related to the prevalence of distracting technology - according to them. I would question the second (S8) 'at home' studies which only used 15 people per experiment. This was to test whether allowing participants to distract themselves had any effect. It's a very short paper, only a couple of pages, so I think needs a bit more digging to actually find out whether it's true or not. The whole thing seems very speculative.
- jasim 12y agoIt isn't surprising that we are most happy when we are able to forget ourselves. Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi's book 'Flow - The Psychology of Optimal Experience' talks about optimal experiences. He has found that humans are generally happy in what is termed as a 'flow' experience. Activities in which we immerse ourselves fully, temporarly forgetting ourselves, like programming, are flow experiences. A few relevant quotes from the book: "So loss of self-consciousness does not involve a loss of self, and certainly not a loss of consciousness, but rather, only a loss of consciousness of the self. What slips below the threshold of awareness is the concept of self, the information we use to represent to ourselves who we are. And being able to forget temporarily who we are seems to be very enjoyable. When not preoccupied with our selves, we actually have a chance to expand the concept of who we are. Loss of self-consciousness can lead to self-transcendence, to a feeling that the boundaries of our being have been pushed forward." "The similarities between Yoga and flow are extremely strong; in fact it makes sense to think of Yoga as a very thoroughly planned flow activity. Both try to achieve a joyous, self-forgetful involvement through concentration, which in turn is made possible by a discipline of the body." "When a family has a common purpose and open channels of communication, when it provides gradually expanding opportunities for action in a setting of trust, then life in it becomes an enjoyable flow activity. Its members will spontaneously focus their attention on the group relationship, and to a certain extent forget their individual selves, their divergent goals, for the sake of experiencing the joy of belonging to a more complex system that joins separate consciousnesses in a unified goal."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- maneesh 12y agoA perfect time for Pavlok: www.engadget.com/2014/07/04/pavlok-wearable/
- JonnieCache 12y agohttp://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2225 http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2225 Terrifyingly accurate.
- alexvr 12y agoI bet this is part of the reason most people are not independent & creative thinkers. And I would bet that it also has something to do with why creative people often end up with mental health issues down the road. It's definitely easier and more fun (and maybe even healthier) to whip out your smartphone and Google something you're wondering about, play a quick game, read what someone else thinks, etc. in otherwise idle moments, but doing so precludes having a bunch of potentially valuable thoughts.
- JohnDotAwesome 12y agoSometimes, I felt like I was reading The Onion - "... people basically found being alone with themselves not very fun and kind of boring." "It seems that the average person doesn’t seem to be capable of generating a sufficiently interesting train of thought to prevent them from being miserable with themselves."
- programmer_dude 12y agoSome people.
- j2kun 12y agoWhile I'm totally surprised people would shock themselves after only 15 minutes, now I'm more interested in the people who did not shock themselves. What are their ages and occupations? What could explain their ability to enjoy a bit of isolation?
- Dylan16807 12y agoThe title this was submitted with is pretty awful. There is a huge difference between "by themselves" and "time alone with thoughts". I was expecting a completely different argument.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoWell, how long have any of us tried to simply be alone with our thoughts? 15 mins is a long time - no music, books etc, quiet room. I think I would enjoy it, but I will happily admit that I might be wishing I had a book by 10th minute. And personally I think meditating is doing something.
- Asparagirl 12y agoClearly these people are not parents of young children.
- Xcelerate 12y agoI think the article makes a mistake in assuming that everything painful is unpleasant. Why do people eat spicy foods then? I find that as I get older, my tolerance for boredom has become lower and lower. When I was younger, I used to be able to just sit and think. Now I dread long drives because the sheer boredom of it drives me crazy. And it gets even weirder, because although I don't like social interaction that much, I find myself craving "going out and doing something" every night because the thought of just sitting inside watching a movie is painful. I blame the internet. My attention span and focus are noticeably worse than they used to be, and I feel like I need constant stimulation all the time now.
- StavrosK 12y agoAudiobooks + driving = bliss.
- greggman 12y agoAudiobooks are awesome for long drives. Podcasts too. For me especially Radiolab, This American Life, The Moth, Escape Pod, and The Dunesteef Audio Fiction Magazine
- DanBC 12y ago> I think the article makes a mistake in assuming that everything painful is unpleasant. Why do people eat spicy foods then? They gave people an electric shock. Those people said thu would pay to avoid that shock again. Later, when left in a room where the choice is to sit with your thoughts or give yourself a shock a bunch of people gave themselves a shock, even though they had previously said they'd avoid it.
- gibweb 12y agoKudos for posting this with a less sensational title than the original
- gress 12y agoDoes this have anything to do with thinking, or just the idea that most people are unhappy and want distraction? Is that a surprise given how much of society is devoted to creating distraction?
- dbbolton 12y ago>“It seems that the average person doesn’t seem to be capable of generating a sufficiently interesting train of thought to prevent them from being miserable with themselves.” Aside from being unnecessarily harsh and condescending, I think this comment is off-base and makes unwarranted assumptions about the nature of boredom.
- beachstartup 12y agowhen i was a kid i would touch 9v batteries to my tongue. even today occasionally i touch my electric flyswatter and it hurts like hell but i'm compelled to do it for some reason. maybe it's a mild form of cutting?
- krosaen 12y ago“All of humanity's problems stem from man's inability to sit quietly in a room alone.” ― Blaise Pascal
- suzyperplexus 12y agoI guess one way to test what might have happened in this study is to time yourself for 15 min and see what you'd do. In my experience, being alone with my thoughts and meditating or just sitting there is useful, but not particularly pleasant. Silence is often where people have to find and deal with all the shitty truths about themselves.
- bambax 12y ago> One person pressed the button 190 times. (...) The researchers were stunned. Well, the researchers weren't the only people stunned, apparently. Not everything in life is about being "happy"; just because one isn't happy doesn't mean they wasted their time.