8 ms·
No crankshaft, no problem: Toyota's free piston engine is brilliant
- stephengillie 12y agoAll it needs to do is generate motion, so they made it like those flashlights you charge by shaking them. Reciprocal! What will be revolutionary will be performing this with some kind of rotary engine.
- arethuza 12y agoThe Jaguar C-X75 almost made it into production - and it had miniature gas turbines linked to generators feeding the batteries and wheel motors: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaguar_C-X75 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaguar_C-X75 Given the current popularity of hybrid hyper-cars from Porsche, McLaren and Ferrari it would be interesting to see if something like the Jaguar is tried again.
- thesz 12y agoThis is what I was thinking about too. Rotation is better than reciprocal line movement.
- VBprogrammer 12y agoWhile in terms of reliability, simplicity and power to weight ratios turbine engines are great, they still suffer from low compression ratios. If I remember correctly about 3 to 1, compared to 10 in 1 for petrol engines and nearly 20 to 1 for diesel engines. Thermodynamically this makes it very difficult to achieve high efficiency.
- StillBored 12y ago"If I remember correctly about 3 to 1," That seemed strange to me given multistage compressors. Maybe 3:1 is true for a micro turbines, but for larger jets wikipedia says the pressure ratio is 30:1 to 40:1 citing the Trent 900 at 39:1 and the GE90 at 42:1. Which according to the same article says that a 40:1 PR is equivalent to a 15:1 compression ratio. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overall_pressure_ratio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overall_pressure_ratio
- VBprogrammer 12y agoI stand corrected. I'm sure I had read that some time ago but I can't find a reference at the moment.
- tomswartz07 12y agoMuch older than that was the Chrysler Turbine car: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrysler_Turbine_Car http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrysler_Turbine_Car This was quite literally a lower power jet aeroplane turbine used to power the car. I would imagine that this would have been great on fuel economy on the highway, but terrible in cities.
- arethuza 12y agoThat seems to have used a "conventional" mechanical transmission rather than using the turbine to generate electricity to feed the electric motors. Still pretty cool though!
- MBCook 12y agoIf you're interested there is a very good book called Chrysler's Turbine Car: The Rise and Fall of Detroit's Coolest Creation. http://www.amazon.com/Chryslers-Turbine-Car-Detroits-Creation/dp/1613743459 http://www.amazon.com/Chryslers-Turbine-Car-Detroits-Creatio...
- mpweiher 12y ago>great fuel economy on the highway Small turbines generally have terrible fuel economy. The Wikipedia page you quote says "...fuel consumption was excessive"
- marcosdumay 12y ago> What will be revolutionary will be performing this with some kind of rotary engine. You mean, like a turbine?
- codfrantic 12y ago>You mean, like a turbine? I think he means like a Wankel engine: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine
- exDM69 12y ago> You mean, like a turbine? There are rotary internal combustion engines, such as the Wankel engine. It has a triangular "rotor-piston" spinning in a circular cylinder and goes through four "strokes" per revolution. Mazda is a manufacturer that utilizes rotary engines in production cars today, particularly in their high performance models. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine
- maxerickson 12y agoThey last used it in the RX-8, which they discontinued in 2012. (at least, for production consumer vehicles)
- exDM69 12y agoOk, I didn't know the RX-8 was discontinued. They do, however, still build the rotary engines for use in racing applications, such as the Star Mazda racing series in the US.
- maxerickson 12y agoI didn't mean to be picky, I just had some vague memory of an article talking about how no production car was going to have a Wankel anymore and after I checked decided it reasonable to post the clarification.
- thesz 12y agoWhat is forgotten here is a reduction of vibrations. The crankshaft works as a (cheap) synchronizer for piston movement and can reduce vibrations when phases are aligned in special way. Motor vibrations are big deal - they take energy and also reduce quality of car.
- tankenmate 12y agoThis is why they mention that a two cylinder engine is balanced; e.g. a boxer configuration.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt's mentioned obliquely: Even better, a two-cylinder FPEG is inherently balanced I guess electronic timing is also up to the task of keeping things running smoothly without mechanical synchronization.
- yason 12y agoThe article mentioned a two-cylinder configuration where the movements of two pistons would be mirroring each other, nullifying the vibrations.
- mentos 12y agoSeems like needing the piston to change directions is a waste of momentum. What about a similar design where a ball is propelled around the inside of a circular doughnut to generate electricity?
- codfrantic 12y agoOr a Wankel engine[1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine
- Zigurd 12y agoA rotary engine isn't free-piston, but it also doesn't have reciprocating parts. But it also shows there are other challenges to efficiency than reciprocating pistons.
- sharemywin 12y agoI think the pressure would go around the donut on both sides and equalize.
- yxhuvud 12y agoWouldn't a more obvious solution be to change the direction by adding a second combustion chamber on the other side?
- kabdib 12y agoThat works great until you miss ignition on the opposite side, then wham it bottoms out and destroys the other side of the engine. A gas spring is a pretty simple mechanism and can't misbehave (too bad you can't put it to work, though -- probably a lot of heat being wasted compressing it).
- Already__Taken 12y agoThis would be why you wouldn't run 2 pistons facing each other sharing common valve and ignition set to balance?
- 12y ago
- daraosn 12y agoReminds me of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mazda_Wankel_engine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mazda_Wankel_engine Good think this seems to be efficient, but I would like that instead they would be putting more focus on improving batteries rather than gas motors.
- sharemywin 12y agountil you get most of your grid power from solar your still using fossil fuels for power.
- wtallis 12y agoAbout 30% of US electricity is produced from nuclear power or non-solar renewable sources. Solar may be a hot topic, but it's nowhere near being the top alternative to fossil fuels.
- rational-future 12y agoUS =/= world. Solar is growing far far far quicker than nuclear.
- nmcfarl 12y agoSure - but the grid + ev combo is still more efficient than a gas vehicle. And of course the grid uses a wide range of fossil fuels which reduces some of the geopolitical concerns. Finally in some places your power is already quite low on hydrocarbons - Seattle City Light is only 1.3% hydrocarbon.
- kalleboo 12y ago95% of my grid power comes from hydro or nuclear, so I'm good.
- mikeash 12y agoSmall engines are irrelevant to grid power regardless, even if you get all of your electricity from fossil fuels. Power plant generators are completely different beasts, as the tradeoffs change considerably as you scale up.
- Already__Taken 12y agoIt's also a big deal having electronic controlled valves, you can make them have a square profile for maximum flow rates.
- programminggeek 12y agoWhat people might not think about so much is that weight reduction is as important if not more important than the advancements we make in the engine. When Rocky Mountain Institiute was working on their hyper car concept, I believe the researcher said that weight reduction was more important than electric or gas engine. I think he said something like for every pound you save, you actually reduce an extra 2-3 pounds of supporting materials elsewhere. Lighter cars need less HP, you can reduce some of the support bracing as it's not as heavy of a vehicle, etc... Making cars super light would do a lot of good and so every time I see a giant battery for electric cars or a 2nd engine to act as a backup, I wonder how much that is costing in terms of weight and MPG.
- wspeirs 12y agoAlong with a weight reduction, they said that, "It can also be run like a diesel, using compression rather than a spark plug to ignite its fuel mixture." This is important as spark plugs require a decent amount of energy to function.
- tnorthcutt 12y agospark plugs require a decent amount of energy to function Are you sure about that? According to [0], "To ignite a stoichiometric air-fuel mixture (14:1) approximately 0.2 milliJoules of spark energy are required. Very rich or lean mixtures can require as much as 3 mJ." [0] http://www.mr2.com/TEXT/DavidKucharczyk/ignition.html http://www.mr2.com/TEXT/DavidKucharczyk/ignition.html
- schrodinger 12y ago(0.2 millijoules * 6 * 3000) / minute = 0.06 watts So yea, not much...
- IgorPartola 12y agoThere are lots of designs where the car is significantly lighter than a typical vehicle driving on American or European roads. The problem with them is that if you get in an accident, you are much more likely to suffer much more damage. There are in fact regulations in the US that effectively require you to build heavier cars. Motorcycles and scooters are great examples of personal transportation that are lightweight and can get ridiculous fuel economy, but in a Vespa vs 18 wheeler, the Vespa will lose every time, which is why you don't see them on the freeway.
- IgorPartola 12y agoIf you enjoyed this article, check out http://jalopnik.com/what-its-like-to-ride-in-a-car-with-the-camless-engine-1529865968 http://jalopnik.com/what-its-like-to-ride-in-a-car-with-the-...
- alkoual 12y agoThis could be used as a transition from gas to battery cars. Why? Currently one of the most important reasons holding back companies from producing electric cars is the lack of good batteries, but with this, companies can produce cars that convert gas to electricity in order to drive an electric motor. After a few years, when gas becomes even more expensive and batteries get better, we can switch this mechanism to batteries, and that's it.
- adrow 12y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7677197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7677197
- IgorPartola 12y agoI believe this is what Chevy Volt does, and it's brilliant. There are two reasons I like this design. First, the fossil fuel engine in the Volt spins at only three pre-defined speeds so it can be optimized better. By contrast, your normal car engine has to run at both 900 RPM and 6500 RPM, with the best fuel economy somewhere between 2000 and 3000 RPM. Heck, you could shut the Volt's engine entirely while it's "idling" and not have to worry about stop & go traffic: the engine is independent of the wheels. Second, and this is admittedly more long term, it doesn't really matter what type of engine you put into the Volt. This thought was presented to me by one of their dealers, but it makes a lot of sense. The current engine is a "tried and true" gasoline job. But if Chevy found that diesel or bio fuel, or natural gas worked better, they could swap it out without redesigning the rest of the drivetrain. I may sound like a walking billboard for the Volt, but I am honestly not. I don't own one, and do not work for Chevy/GM. I do happen to think that the Volt is the best compromise between price, range on batteries, and ability to drive long distances. While Tesla's are very cool, I think the Volt is a much more gradual transition from gas to electric.
- maxerickson 12y agoThis article is more about using the linear electrical generator on the piston than it is the configuration of the power train. No vehicles on the road today have anything similar to what is discussed in the article. Also, I'm not sure about the current model, but there was a bunch of kerfuffle over the Volt not really being a strict electric hybrid: http://www.plugincars.com/exclusive-chevrolet-volt-chief-engineer-explains-volt-drivetrain-says-volt-electric-vehicle-90758.ht http://www.plugincars.com/exclusive-chevrolet-volt-chief-eng... Some of the time, at least in the edition discussed there, energy from the engine goes to the wheels without ever becoming electricity. Maybe they changed it in later models (but I sort of doubt it, the capability is there because it can be the most efficient way to use the engine).
- IgorPartola 12y agoI did not know that. Looking at the Wikipedia article for the Volt [1] I can see that the gasoline engine may provide additional mechanical energy to turn the wheels, but it's only to assist the primary and secondary electric motors. In either case, I am not a purist going after a 100% electric car. I want to get more miles per dollar, and I want to produce less CO2 per mile. The Volt seems to do that, while still letting me drive from NYC to LA and back without having to spend more than three minutes at any given gas station. More importantly, any gas station will do, since it can run on just gas. For a daily commute, it will likely run 100% electric since the battery won't be depleted. To me, this is a great combination. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chevrolet_Volt#Drivetrain http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chevrolet_Volt#Drivetrain
- zackmorris 12y agoI drew almost this exact same picture in high school, along with just about every other kid interested in internal combustion engines (before I knew what a horizontally opposed engine was, like the boxer engine in Subarus). I'm just glad to see a car company talking about it, because the way we do it now with transmissions is pretty much ridiculous. This engine is roughly 7 times weaker than it should be, because Nikola Tesla had a 110 horsepower turbine in 1913 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_turbine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_turbine which was unfortunately ahead of its time because the country was barely getting wired with electricity at that point. But today a 95% efficient generator connected to a 95% efficient motor for 90% overall transmission efficiency would be worth it on a turbine or Stirling engine running at 40-50% efficiency (maybe 40% overall at the wheels). Compare that with an old gas guzzler from the 70s running at 25% efficiency with maybe an 85% efficient transmission for 20% efficiency at the wheels. Not to mention that cars used to weigh twice as much which halved city fuel economy again, and lacked regenerative breaking which halved it again, and so on and so forth. It’s no wonder that cars used to get 10 mpg when what I would argue are relatively simple engineering changes could have raised that to 30, 50, even 100 mpg. It’s almost like they were deliberately designed to be as inefficient as possible…
- pjc50 12y agoThey were designed for cost-effectiveness in an era of cheap fuel. Electric transmission wasn't feasible on the car scale until cheap microelectronics arrived. It was confined to diesel-electric locomotives.
- fulafel 12y ago> cars used to weigh twice as much which halved city fuel economy Nit: this is actually the other way around, cars have been gaining weight - so much that it has swallowed most of the mileage improvement we'd otherwise have gotten from other tech improvements. See eg http://newsoffice.mit.edu/2011/cars-on-steroids-0104 http://newsoffice.mit.edu/2011/cars-on-steroids-0104
- hyperliner 12y agoPardon my ignorance, but the video does not show and I am interested to see if they modified the system, but what draws the piston back towards the spark plug?
- juandopazo 12y agoIIUC, a spring.
- phea 12y agoIt's a gas spring, similar to a car shock.
- tnorthcutt 12y agoIt's not drawn, it's pushed, by the pressure built up in the "gas spring chamber".
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 12y agoAnyone know why hybrids don't use turbine generators? As I understand it, they are more efficient than even the best reciprocating engine. Aside from solar and wind, every large-scale generating station uses turbines, for example.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoIIRC, turbines are really ineffecient at small scales. It's only when you get up to large scales that they start making sense.
- DigitalJack 12y agothey are slow to get to speed and loud.
- Stolpe 12y agoI remember seeing something similar to this a year ago in a documentary series concerning the small Swedish supercar manufacturer Koenigsegg. See it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bch5B23_pu0&list=PLHa6PXrV-yIgnXSYFT07BouKhEhyFuWnf https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bch5B23_pu0&list=PLHa6PXrV-y.... It sounds really interesting.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoPretty cool, and I wonder if you could build the piston with two "heads" and put a cylinder head on either end and just shoot it back and forth. Magnetics of course have a hard time at high temperatures, so I'm not sure how you generate the stator field reliably.
- bradleyland 12y agoThe problem would be startup and shutdown timing. Any circumstance where you had a "missed" ignition (which occurs more often than you'd think) would result in a catastrophic failure (pistol slams in to the opposing head).
- marknutter 12y agoWhy was this article removed from the front page of Hacker News?
- zevyoura 12y ago>Even better, a two-cylinder FPEG is inherently balanced and would measure roughly 8 inches around and 2 feet long. An engine of that size and type could generate 15 hp, enough to move a compact electric vehicle at highway speed after its main drive battery has been depleted. Is 15 HP really enough to move a car at highway speeds? I had a CBR250 motorcycle that produced 22-24 HP and weighed around 350 pounds, and it was not particularly great on the highway. It's hard for me to imagine a car that's 3+ times heavier with less horsepower being safe on a highway.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]