11 ms·
Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system
- mingabunga 12y agoI've been eating 1 meal a day for the past 2.5 years and have not been sick since (usually I'd get a few colds each year) plus I always feel great. I'd like to think I'm getting the benefit of an improved immune system such as in this article, but I guess time will tell.
- jotm 12y agoSo does working out - it's basically the same effect, only faster from what I understand.
- corysama 12y agoWonder if you can approximate the effect with regular blood donations? It's my understanding that regular blood donations are a good idea for males because it helps clear out old red blood cells with iron buildups. Clearing out old white blood cells could be yet another motivator.
- chrisBob 12y agoAre we likely to resume using leaches as a standard medical technique?
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoLike this? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hirudo_medicinalis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hirudo_medicinalis
- escherplex 12y agoLeechcraft (OEn) to medecine (OFr) and then back to leechcraft? Interesting progression you got there :)
- araes 12y agoYou joke, but I have a condition where my iron content builds up relatively quickly, and the best thing they've still figured out as a cure is blood letting.
- chrisBob 12y agoI have heard of this, and I think that is probably the only modern reason for blood letting. I think there is a similar condition in people who get frequent blood transfusions.
- dm2 12y agoApparently they're really good to use when re-attaching a finger, they prevent pooling and release a blood-thinner to prevent clotting.
- escherplex 12y agoThese are just nervous jokes following the ongoing demise of antibiotics. But, having to resort to venipuncture for treatment of hemochromatosis must be tough. Hope your phlebotomist also prescribed some chelating agents to reduce frequency of treatment.
- araes 12y agoLuckily they caught it relatively early on because a family member had it, so its been semi-easy to manage.
- dm2 12y agoYes, they have valuable uses in medicine, until we find a better substitute at least. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/body/leeches.html http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/body/leeches.html There is a mechanical leech but it doesn't work as well at the moment and there's no real downside to using real leeches.
- sp332 12y ago"Old" red blood cells? I thought since they didn't have any DNA to repair themselves, they died after a few weeks anyway. Edit: a few months, not weeks. But cells dying faster seems to be related to diseases, not health. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_blood_cell#Life_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_blood_cell#Life_cycle
- chrisBob 12y agoIt probably just creates a slightly acidic environment. All you need to create stem cells from adult human cells is a weak acid. http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v505/n7485/full/nature12969.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v505/n7485/full/nature1...
- wlesieutre 12y agoSadly, that research didn't pan out. One paper has been retracted and the other likely will be. I haven't followed it closely, but I understand there were some significant issues with edited images and results not being reproducible. http://blogs.nature.com/news/2014/06/last-remaining-support-for-controversial-stem-cell-papers-collapses.html http://blogs.nature.com/news/2014/06/last-remaining-support-...
- jimrandomh 12y agoThat Nature article was withdrawn by the author due to scientific misconduct. http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/06/04/us-japan-stemcells-researcher-idUSKBN0EF0SO20140604 http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/06/04/us-japan-stemcells...
- icecreamguy 12y agoThe body doesn't really work like that, pH is highly regulated in the body and even a slight imbalance causes enzymes and proteins to become unstable.
- DenisM 12y agoStop with the down-votes, you guys. Had there been no references cited by chirsBob, this comment would be an overall negative "hearsay"-type contribution, but the inclusion of a reasonably reputable, if outdated, reference allowed others to point out the paper retraction, and raised the overall quality of the discussion.
- chrisBob 12y agoNo, actually I submitted it knowing that the paper had been retracted, and was stirring up trouble. The down votes are perfectly reasonable in this case. I do appreciate the defense though as some times is is hard to tell which posts were inaccurate by mistakes, and which were malicious. [edited to thank the defending post]
- ihnorton 12y agoSome similar intermittent fasting studies related to autophagy and mTOR (rather than PKA in top article): http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20534972 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20534972 http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v468/n7327/full/nature09584.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v468/n7327/full/nature0...
- Yen 12y agoAs someone who doesn't know very much about the immune system - I wonder if this 'resetting' property could be used to treat allergies or other minor autoimmune problems. Also, I'd appreciate a medium-level overview of the immune system, if anyone has a good link.
- brm 12y agoAs someone with an esophageal autoimmune response I'd be very curious to know this as well.
- niels_olson 12y agoee?
- brm 12y agoYes though not a typical presentation of EE (EoE?). It ramped up dramatically around my 24th birthday and appears to be connected with my body's response to histamines. As such most doctors haven't known what to do with me and we've been feeling our way blindly along. If fasting even partially resets immune response i'd be interested.
- maxerickson 12y agoThere is always Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immune_system http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immune_system I'm not familiar with what is out there as far as materials, but I would speculate that beyond that to get an overview you would end up looking at a medical textbook (with shorter treatments being more specific).
- ihodes 12y agoThis book[1] is the best resource for a "medium-level" overview I've come across. Once you get beyond that, you're entering textbook and then paper territory. [1]: http://www.amazon.com/Immune-System-Includes-Desktop-Edition/dp/0470657294/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1402074187&sr=8-1&keywords=how+the+immune+system+works http://www.amazon.com/Immune-System-Includes-Desktop-Edition...
- awolf 12y agoFrom an evolutionary standpoint periods of famine were certainly a selective pressure for our ancestors. It could make sense that prolonged periods of no-food are not only something our bodies have adapted to survive, but have adapted to thrive upon as part of their natural cycle.
- jostmey 12y agoSorry for being nit-picky. It is not that we evolved to thrive during periods of famine. It is that we did not evolve under conditions where resources were plentiful. That is why so many people die from heart conditions brought on by excessive eating. The machinery in our body is simply insufficient to deal with the excess cholesterol.
- libria 12y agoHe's saying that even when people are universally weakened by starvation, the other mutations that exhibit advantages (a regenerative immune system in this case) are rewarded with further generations. I think "evolved to thrive in famine" is fair to say.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoEvolved to thrive on abundance of resources on the long-term, punctuated by brief intervals of scarcity.
- Goronmon 12y agoIt could make sense that prolonged periods of no-food are not only something our bodies have adapted to survive, but have adapted to thrive upon as part of their natural cycle. How do you make the jump from "Most able to survive famine." to "Thrive on famine."? It doesn't seem obvious to me that we would automatically evolve to the latter result over the former.
- noisy_boy 12y agoAside from the non-sense of miracles etc., it has been a tradition in yogis in India to fast regularly. Maybe the positive effects were observed/known even in those older times.
- Evgeny 12y agoI believe that is the link to the original study: http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/pdf/S1934-5909(14)00151-9.pdf http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/pdf/S1934-5909(14)00151-9...
- coldcode 12y agoFasting has always been a tradition in many religious groups. It would interesting to study groups that fasted regularly to see what affect it had on longevity.
- jostmey 12y agoCalorie restricted diets have been extensively studied. Radically reducing your food intake is about the only known way to seriously extend lifespan. The trend holds true for virtually every multi-cellular organism ever tested under laboratory conditions.
- MrBuddyCasino 12y agoThat and exercising. People who longer younger than their age usually have some sports routine, be it swimming, cycling or whatever.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoReducing one's calorie intake by 30% long-term seems highly unlikely for most people. I do wonder how many of the benefits can be had by just reducing glycation by reducing the amount of simple sugars one consumes.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoBut it doesn't seem likely that this is what our biology is adapted to. I think we're primed to function at optimum parameters on a baseline food abundance, punctuated by brief intervals of scarcity. I think that's a much better model for how our very distant ancestors lived. I don't think we're the descendants of those who lived in scarcity all the time. But it's quite likely that the hunting-gathering life had its periods of lean caloric intake regularly.
- yen223 12y ago"Radically reducing your food intake is about the only known way to seriously extend lifespan..." At risk of pointing out the bleeding obvious, famine victims would disagree with this.
- 12y ago
- exratione 12y agoThe paper, which is open access and worth reading (skip to the discussion at the end if a layperson). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.stem.2014.04.014 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.stem.2014.04.014 The more interesting part of this to my eyes was the material difference between 24 hour and 72 hour fasting in human chemotherapy patients, in that the former didn't do anything to the measure of immune cell populations and the latter did. Intermittent fasting is nowhere near as well studied as calorie restriction at this point in time, so it is interesting to see these mechanisms emerge. Now this is chemotherapy immune suppression, not aging immune dysregulation. I'll be mildly surprised to see the exact same result in people with age-damaged immune systems, as the character of the damage is very different. The animal results for aging rather than chemotherapy here are intriguing but that's all. There's still a lot of work to be done to arrive at the level of comfort with this effect that exists for other aspects of calorie restriction or intermittent fasting. But given that (a) obtaining human data on fasting and immune cell population in old people is a comparatively low cost study to put together, and (b) the group involved here seems to have a good flow of funding to study intermittent fasting in a broader context, I'd expect to see that data emerge at some point in the next few years.
- CreRecombinase 12y agoI couldn't access the article with that link, but I could with this one http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/pdf/S1934-5909(14)00151-9.pdf http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/pdf/S1934-5909(14)00151-9...
- e12e 12y agoNot having read the article, I wonder if this might be a common response in mammals -- if you're too sick to eat for two whole days, immune system "assumes"[1] it's missed something, and tries desperately to get you back to healthy enough to forage/hunt...? [ed: well, that's entirely wrong, based on the article -- it's the body killing off as much dead weight as possible in order to hang on a bit longer -- then healing back up when food is avaliable. Oh, well :-) ] [1] By which I mean there is some complex time-delayed protein-signal-avalanche that is somehow tied to long periods without nutrition...
- Florin_Andrei 12y ago
- wpietri 12y agoOne of the things I've been up to the last couple years is reducing the divergence between my life and the conditions I probably evolved for. E.g., much less processed food, reduced use of artificial light that diverges from the normal day/night cycle, more frequent modest physical exercise, very low sugar consumption, way less alcohol and caffeine. To me it feels a lot like when I'm debugging a system and am trying to get back to a baseline by eliminating complicating factors. Lately I've been wondering about fasting in that context. Not eating occasionally was presumably pretty normal for our ancestors. Have other self-hackers here experimented with this?
- niels_olson 12y agoI've been eating one meal a day for 2.5 years now. More about that here http://nielsolson.us/blog/2012/08/28/my-diet/ http://nielsolson.us/blog/2012/08/28/my-diet/
- consideranon 12y agoIntermittent fasting has long been a standard staple in the Paleo diet[0] and bodybuilding[1] communities, both for health and aesthetic reasons. [0] http://www.marksdailyapple.com/health-benefits-of-intermittent-fasting/#axzz33tNusXqJ http://www.marksdailyapple.com/health-benefits-of-intermitte... [1] http://www.leangains.com/2010/04/leangains-guide.html http://www.leangains.com/2010/04/leangains-guide.html
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoThere is a lot of evidence beginning to emerge on the value of fasting. This was once encoded in culture as almost every culture had some concept of fasting. We lost so much knowledge when we let nutrition "science"[1] completely overwhelm the wisdom of our ancestors. On a personal note, I found fasting became much easier after I changed my diet to be ketogenic. With a metabolism primed for burning fat for energy and not subject to a blood sugar roller coaster, going a couple days without food is more of a mental challenge than physical hunger. 1. We've acted like nutrition can give the same cut and dry answers that physics has, and the health of our population shows how well that has worked. Worse, nutrition seems to be driven by egos and media in a way that is nothing short of frightening.
- bane 12y agoBeware of pseudoscience. In the past, some things worked, something things didn't, but there's no understanding as to why they did or didn't work out of traditional models. Scientific models haven't been all that great either, but science hopefully will eventually self correct as nutritional models become more sophisticated. If there is light at the end of the tunnel it will be because of the eventual understanding that the scientific method provides, not reverting back to traditional models. Traditional models don't self correct and there are plenty of instances of people consuming outright poisons under such systems or people following traditional nutrition models finding themselves surrounded by an abundance of previously rare foods that the modern food supply system easily provides, and practically gorging themselves on it to negative health results.
- ellyagg 12y agoWe have to make decisions now. Do you think the prescriptions from the current state of nutrition science outperform ancestral eating heuristics in real life? I don't, and whether it's true or not is one of the major points under debate. The debate can't automatically be vetoed by invoking "pseudoscience". As an epistemic issue, I have to use all the evidence available to me. What I've noticed is that human physiology is a dynamic equilibrium of a massive number of variables and the current state of our analytic tools have had immense trouble evaluating it efficiently. Ancestral eating patterns looks like worthwhile evidence under the circumstances. Incidentally, essentially no one is blindly promoting traditional eating. Folks are using it as a guide and together with science to make decisions in the face of limited understanding. One of the most popular ancestral diet proponents is Stephan Guyenet, a Ph.D. neurobiologist who studies the link between the brain and obesity for a living[1]. Everyone is for science and no side on the issue owns it. [1] http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/ http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/
- andywood 12y agoDid you need to hear it from a non-monk? That's ok. That's totally fine. I heard it from a holy man.
- gwern 12y agoGiven all the other stuff monks and holy men say... yes.
- andywood 12y agoWe must discern ideas by the merit of the idea, yes? Otherwise, Argument Against Authority ;)
- gwern 12y agoNo. Expertise and authority is an excellent way to evaluate claims. In this case, monks and holy men have espoused so many crazy and harmful ideas over the years that knowing they have endorsed [all kinds of fasting, not just the ones being evaluated scientifically] is not useful because their endorsements have no connection to the truth.
- rdmcfee 12y agoI don't know that the biological benefits of fasting are associated directly with cultural fasting patterns in our ancestry. I suspect they're more linked with our ancestral hunter-gatherer traits. It seems logical that early humans would go periods of time without eating while hunting, then consume a large amount of protein and fat in a short period of time. Religious and cultural fasting, however, would likely have not occurred until the development of language which is estimated at 20k-50k years ago. That's not a particularly long time on an evolutionary scale.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoI agree that we're probably adapted, in our biology, to re-occurring intervals of food scarcity. I would not be surprised at all if it turned out that our bodies actually function better on that sort of regime (eat at will for a while, then forego all caloric intake for a brief period). I wonder if this was noticed at the dawn of civilization, and then got codified into religion and so on.
- rdmcfee 12y agoYeah it's interesting how ancient cultures seemed to have (by trial and error I suppose) incorporated specific behaviors into their culture which, in hindsight, solve a particular problem that can be scientifically identified. An example I love is the Canadian Inuit who traditionally ate no vegetables for 10+ months of the year without developing scurvy. The tradition of eating raw whale blubber and fish (including the broth) preserved the vitamin C and minerals from the mea, while eating cooked meat without broth drastically reduces mineral and vitamin intake.
- tiglionabbit 12y agoIt doesn't need to be the tradition that shaped our biology. It could be our biology that shaped the tradition. Assuming we already have some benefit to fasting, a group who make a tradition of fasting are more likely to survive than a group who does not. Thus the fasting meme takes over as the people who believe in it take over.
- themgt 12y agoYou know I've had a hunch for a while there must be something to these "detox" diets where you just eat a bunch of carrots or whatever. I think it's increasingly clear collateral fasting is the answer. The gimmick is "it's the carrots", the reality is you're inducing an extended fasting state which has all kinds of beneficial impacts on the body. The science is increasingly clear that humans should be putting their body in a fasting state far more often and for far longer than we in the decadent west do.
- rawland 12y agoMy humble summary based on superficial reading of the paper: * Prolonged fasting = Eating NOTHING for 48-120 hr. * BENEFICIAL effect started on cycle 4 (day 39). * 1 Cycle = 2-4d fasting&chemo; 8-10d recovery. * Prolonged fasting enhances cellular resistance to toxins in mice and humans. * Glycogen depletion required => switch to fat/ketone bodies-based catabolism (!!!). * They have no idea, what the effects on blood are in detail. * At the beginning WhiteBloodCell count went down. * After 6 cycles things stabilized. Article related paper: http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/abstract/S1934-5909(14)00151-9 http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/abstract/S1934-5909(14)00... Interesting figures from the paper: http://www.cell.com/cms/attachment/2014950454/2036225024/gr1.jpg http://www.cell.com/cms/attachment/2014950454/2036225024/gr1...
- tiglionabbit 12y agoThe article seems pretty obvious. If you don't eat food, your body will eat itself. It would make sense for it to eat the worst cells first. Then when you add new food into the system it can replace those cells. Perhaps fasting was more common in the past, so it was a reliable trigger for this behavior, and our bodies did not need to develop their own automatic trigger. Why waste resources rebuilding things, after all?
- tokenadult 12y agoLet's look at what the submitted article, which is a press release from a university, says. "In both mice and a Phase 1 human clinical trial, long periods of not eating significantly lowered white blood cell counts. In mice, fasting cycles then 'flipped a regenerative switch,' changing the signaling pathways for hematopoietic stem cells, which are responsible for the generation of blood and immune systems, the research showed." What's good about this line of research is that it is trying to show whether or not an observation found in a model animal will also be found in human patients. As preliminary research, this will have to be replicated by other researchers before we can rely on this finding (NOT extended fully to human patients in the current study) to guide treatment of human patients. This is good news that people are investigating this issue. Once there has been a thorough review article on this issue published in a different journal by a different author, summing up several well designed studies, then we will really have something to talk about here on Hacker News. I should comment on some of the other comments here. One very tricky problem in studies of human nutrition is that there isn't a good model organism for nutrition and its effect on human health. The study reported here, just like most medical intervention studies, begins in a mouse model. Mice are well understood organisms and their similarities to and differences from human beings for many medical treatments are well understood. Mice are not a particularly good model for nutrition studies, however, because mice are rodents (part of a clade of obligate herbivores) while human beings are primates (part of a clade of facultative omnivores). Moreover, human beings, the current species Homo sapiens, have evolved with co-evolution of the gut in the environment of the cultural practice of cooking food.[1] Cooking is a human cultural universal. No other animal lineage has evolved in a similar environment, so no animal provides a fully suitable model for studies of human nutritional interventions. Human nutrition studies are HARD, because they require minute-by-minute monitoring of the subjects and exact measurements of food intake to gather meaningful experimental data. (I recall a TV news report from the 1970s about a human nutrition study in which the study volunteers, who of course were paid for this, lived confined inside a lab in which lab technicians weighed all their food to the nearest gram and controlled everything they could eat for the duration of the experiment. Alas, I've never heard of results of that study, perhaps because the sample size, with such an expensive procedure, was too small to generate meaningful data.) Yes, let's see what nutritional interventions do what for human beings, but let's be careful not to jump to conclusions too soon, because careful data gathering on this topic is especially difficult, and anecdotes crowd out data in most popular discussion of this topic. [1] http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/cooking-up-bigger-brains/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/cooking-up-bigger-... http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2012-10/eating-cooked-food-made-us-human-study-finds http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2012-10/eating-cooked-... http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/why-fire-makes-us-human-72989884/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/why-fire-makes-...
- kumarski 12y agoI asked a question on quora regarding the difference between successful animal clinical trials and humans http://www.quora.com/Clinical-Trials/What-are-examples-of-drugs-that-showed-promising-results-in-clinical-lab-animal-trials-and-failed-miserably-in-human-trials http://www.quora.com/Clinical-Trials/What-are-examples-of-dr...
- mgulaid 12y agoI'll recommend fasting with fellow Muslim friends and co-workers for a day during Ramadan. it is very rewarding and revealing about our daily routines and eating habits. I enjoy high productivity during Ramadan, plus it is healthy.
- achille2 12y agoCan someone with access to the original paper kindly lookup specifically how long each fast lasted and how often? The article is a bit vague: periods of no food for two to four days at a time over the course of six months
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoCertain body systems only activate certain processes when the body isn't processing food. Firstly, the gut is an immune organ. Think of it this way: this inside of the digestive system is technically outside the body. It is a continuous tube mouth to anus, and functions as an interface between the outside world and systemic circulation - both blood and lymphatic. The gut has GALT - Gut-Associated Lymphoid Tissue [1]. Lymphatic tissue is an immune system organ and a waste disposal system [2]. It's important to note that all (most) fats are first absorbed by the GALT (specically Lacteals [3]), where it then takes some time to enter blood circulation - the Thorasic Duct [4] (largest lymph vessel) drains in to the Subclavian Vein [5] - so any fat soluble toxins (as in, fat soluble non-nutrients and / or outright toxic molecules) are absorbed by the GALT and removed by white blood cells. Only when this system isn't being stressed by our regular (and typically poor) food intake can the immune system attend to it's ordinary tasks of dealing with regular cellular waste products. Aditionally, Caffeine consumption reduces immune activity [6]. Alcohol (ethanol) is a Type 1 / Group A carcinogen [7] - why doesn't alcohol packaging state this in the same way cigarette packaging does (in Australia, at least). 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gut-associated_lymphoid_tissue http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gut-associated_lymphoid_tissue 2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lymphatic_system http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lymphatic_system 3. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lacteal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lacteal 4. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoracic_duct http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoracic_duct 5. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subclavian_vein http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subclavian_vein 6. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1567576904001924 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1567576904... 7. http://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancercauses/othercarcinogens/generalinformationaboutcarcinogens/known-and-probable-human-carcinogens http://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancercauses/othercarcinogens/g... Full Disclosure: this is my field of expertise, I hold an Advanced Diploma in Clinical Nutrition from an Australian Nationally Accredit Training organisation. I have been actively studying this field for over ten years. Edit: link to my blog http://thecurrentstandard.wordpress.com http://thecurrentstandard.wordpress.com
- mc_hammer 12y agoa lot of methods used by people throughout our history are no longer considered "good" by western culture... bath houses and sauna (sweat lodges also), fasting, fish and potatoe diets, beer and wine consumption (maybe was not considered good, but was common) all seem to have lost ground. i could also argue that eating sushi or seaweed is on the list, also, peace pipe (!), and 2-sleep days (sleep+"second sleep"). im currently leaning towards these being better for us that 9-5 coffee strung out + staring at a lcd all day... by a lot