9 ms·
Judge Releases Information about Police Use of Stingray Cell Phone Trackers
- declan 12y agoThis is great news. Kudos to the ACLU. And I'm happy to say it came about as a result of a note I posted on Twitter in January: https://twitter.com/declanm/status/429292173083688960 https://twitter.com/declanm/status/429292173083688960 https://twitter.com/NateWessler/status/473990510902640640 https://twitter.com/NateWessler/status/473990510902640640
- greenyoda 12y agoKudos to you, too! Here's the link from declan's tweet: http://caselaw.findlaw.com/fl-district-court-of-appeal/1650231.html http://caselaw.findlaw.com/fl-district-court-of-appeal/16502... "James L. Thomas appeals convictions and sentences for sexual battery and petit theft, contending that evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment, and article I, section 12 of the Florida Constitution, was introduced against him at trial. We reverse and remand for a new trial." So, because the police wanted to keep their use of the Stingray secret, they entered the accused rapist's apartment without obtaining a warrant, which caused the evidence they gathered, including the victim's phone, to fall under the exclusionary rule. The defendant will get a new trial, and may go free and commit other crimes, because of the police's preference for secrecy over the rule of law.
- deciplex 12y agoYou forgot the next step: "Thereby helping, in some small way, to (further?) turn the public against the doctrine of Fruit of the Poisonous Tree."
- joe_the_user 12y agoWell, Like freedom of speech, the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree principle matters most for cases and situations that look bad. The only effective counter to the talk radio blow-hard shouting "he got off on a technicality again!!!" is to educate the public. Otherwise, we have just abandoned the principle that a defendant needs to be not just guilty but justly proven guilty to be punished.
- deciplex 12y agoNot the only counter, just one of them. Another effective counter is to point out that, since the public airwaves are public property and a limited resource, organizations can't be allowed to buy up the whole spectrum and fill the air with bullshit as they please. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairness_Doctrine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairness_Doctrine
- vaadu 12y agoThe fairness doctrine is being pushed solely by those that want to muzzle free speech. They had no problems when the only source of news was the left wing 'mainstream' media and newspapers. But now that the news isn't being controlled by the liberal elite they cry foul.
- deciplex 12y agoBullshit. And the fairness doctrine doesn't apply to e.g. newspapers, internet, cable television, or any other media that doesn't have a technical restriction that limits the number of participants in the given medium. The fairness doctrine applies to e.g. open airwaves, and is about recognizing that when the government sells frequency spectrum to the highest bidder, it has a responsibility to regulate the artificial monopoly it just created. And when the fuck was the news ever controlled by any liberal elite. Here's a helpful link: http://www.rushlimbaughforum.com/conservative-forums.html http://www.rushlimbaughforum.com/conservative-forums.html I suggest you make an account there. You'll fit right in.
- Natsu 12y agoThere's also the opposite scenario, in some countries they would punish both parties and there is no exclusion rule, as I understand it.
- Shivetya 12y agoActually the people pushing the he got off on a technicality will be police sycophants, talk radio tends to drive for ratings but quite a few hosts across the country are not blind friends of the police, far from it. Warrant less searches are never looked upon favorably, let alone no knock warrants, and finally the war on drugs isn't the most supported topic. what you do have though is a very organized group out there whose job is to support the actions of the police regardless of how distasteful some may fine it, they will vilify the victim and perpetrators of crime to distract from abuses of police power. This of course leads to political pressure and chest thumping from hard on crime (at any cost) candidates.
- eyeareque 12y agoThis is great. I wonder if by making the stingray'd phones transmit at full power, it allows them to find the phone quicker/easier. How quickly can someone create a phone widget that shows when your cell "tower" has asked your phone to transmit at full power?
- greenyoda 12y agoTransmitting at full power probably isn't that rare. It could mean you're far away from the tower you're talking to, and that could even happen if a tower nearby is overloaded and you've been handed off to a more distant one to balance the load. It could also be due to noise on the channel, being in a building that blocks the signal, etc. Also, information from the baseband processor in your phone (the processor that handles the radio transceiver, and would know what power you were transmitting at) may not be easily available to the processor that runs the apps.
- Hello71 12y agoan attempt could probably be made to calculate the power usage assuming it is the main power consumer by subtracting other major users of power like CPU, screen brightness, wifi, etc. actually, scratch that. most android phones have per-component power consumption readings, so while you couldn't get the actual tx power, you could just base it off of the baseband power usage.
- MAGZine 12y agoDepending on what information is available, you might be able to get a good idea if it's fake or legit by looking at signal strength, jitter, latency when communicating with that tower. If the phone is mostly stationary, then there could be a cause for concern on the phone's behalf.
- RankingMember 12y agoPie in the sky idea: App that indexes cell towers to a central database. When a new tower goes up, it undergoes a confirmation process that verifies its presence for some given amount of time before adding it to the list of confirmed cell towers. The software would then give you the ability to choose to only engage with/respond to registered towers. This would only work if a good amount of people adopted it (and various other contingencies were satisfied).
- ipsin 12y agoIt's great news. I'm still stunned by the Florida case, also linked to in this page: https://www.aclu.org/blog/national-security-technology-and-liberty/us-marshals-seize-local-cops-cell-phone-tracking-files https://www.aclu.org/blog/national-security-technology-and-l... Can Federal Marshals really deputize state and local officers and retroactively seize their work product? Can these officers be involuntarily deputized? It seems like simple theft of state records to me.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- icambron 12y agoI'm not sure to what degree it was involuntary, but regardless, no, they don't stop being state records because the government handed him a title. I'm not a lawyer, but I'd be pretty shocked if the ACLU didn't win that one.
- jauer 12y agoI'm curious about the regulatory side of this. Did the FCC grant these police departments a license to transmit on frequencies assigned to cell companies? Did the cell companies in question allow the police to use their frequencies? The FCC is usually quite particular about interference with cell phones. For example, it's illegal for prisons to run a cell phone jammer but they can coordinate with call companies to run a fancy repeater that MITMs calls in the area and only allows authorized handsets.
- eli 12y agoThe FCC is clearly aware of what's going on and the FOIA denial suggests that at least someone somewhere has been authorized to use them: http://files.cloudprivacy.net/FOIA/FCC/fcc-stingray-reply.pdf http://files.cloudprivacy.net/FOIA/FCC/fcc-stingray-reply.pd...
- eitally 12y agoThe attached letters from the municipalities of Houston, Anne Arundel County, etc... indicate -- to me, at least -- that the authorization was granted. If they hadn't been, I don't see the FOIA officer bothering to attach them, but who knows.
- ekianjo 12y ago> In this case, police used two versions of the stingray — one mounted on a police vehicle, and the other carried by hand. Police drove through the area using the vehicle-based device until they found the apartment complex in which the target phone was located, and then they walked around with the handheld device and stood “at every door and every window in that complex” until they figured out which apartment the phone was located in. In other words, police were lurking outside people’s windows and sending powerful electronic signals into their private homes in order to collect information from within. Seriously ? And no police officer was ashamed of what they were doing during that whole time ?
- eli 12y agoWell, sure, it sounds bad when you phrase it like that.
- Smushman 12y agoanything sounds bad when you say it like that...
- chiph 12y agoHow is this not an illegal search in the same way that the use of infrared cameras has been shown to be? http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=93127 http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=93127
- gscott 12y agoInfrared cameras look into your domicile while the StingRay looks for signals being sent out. They are not looking in to see what is there, they are capturing what is coming out. It is different enough to be litigated up to the Supreme Court. That being said, I in no way support this. I have no choice but to use my phone which makes me into a tracking target. In America it turns out we are all targets in order to exclude each one of us from being Terrorists. Police cars now capture license plates and upload them to a central database (plantir), the whole Internet is being captured and held for 3 days at a time while parts are being kept for longer, the outside of mail is being scanned and captured by the USPS, every major mail facility (fedex, ups, etc) are mandated to have federal agents who open mail and then re-seal it so you never know, etc and so on. I have had to double the tin foil on my hat because one layer is just not enough! It is getting crazy.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- revelation 12y agoIf you want to detect the presence of an IMSI catcher such as the Stingray system, you won't be able to do that on Android, iPhone or basically any phone out there you can buy today. What you need is a phone that has been hacked to run the osmocomBB firmware and baseband software: http://bb.osmocom.org/trac/wiki/Hardware/Phones http://bb.osmocom.org/trac/wiki/Hardware/Phones You can then use the CatcherCatcher software from SRLabs who have been working on this GSM/mobile security stuff since forever: https://opensource.srlabs.de/projects/mobile-network-assessment-tools/wiki/CatcherCatcher https://opensource.srlabs.de/projects/mobile-network-assessm...
- jacquesm 12y agoFirst I heard about this: http://michiganmedicalmarijuana.org/topic/45943-police-departments-caught-covering-up-illegal-use-of-the-stingrayhailstorm-cell-phone-listening-device/ http://michiganmedicalmarijuana.org/topic/45943-police-depar... What is the legal status of using something like CatcherCatcher? (in other words, could you get in trouble for using it in the same way that you can get in trouble in many places for having a radar detector?)
- exhilaration 12y agoOnly if CatcherCatcher is made explicitly illegal, like the legislature of Virginia and the city council of Washington D.C. have made radar detectors illegal. Those are the only two places (and military bases) that radar detectors are illegal for passenger cars in the United States.
- gknoy 12y agoI did not know that radar detectors were illegal on military bases, let alone in VA/DC. Thank you for the heads-up. :)
- joekrill 12y agoDoes that mean this comment is incorrect? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7844350 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7844350
- coldcode 12y agoI can't see how this is constitutional without a warrant. How is this different than using an infrared detector outside someones home?
- forrestthewoods 12y agoThere's no way it's constitutional. These days that doesn't seem to be of much importance.
- ekianjo 12y ago> These days that doesn't seem to be of much importance. It's not of much importance because nobody is outraged by it and nobody is fighting it (apart from a few organizations whose only action is to complain through their websites).
- r00fus 12y agoThe corporate "news" media essentially ignores dissemination of this information and instead jams us full of useless blather about Benghazi and $random_celebrity. If enough people actually heard about this then there'd be a big furor.
- TwoBit 12y agoI wonder, can you make a device that's an anti-stingray? I mean a device that detects a stingray is present and compromises it somehow.
- dmitrygr 12y agowith access to the radio firmware if your phone you can good luck getting it though
- peterwwillis 12y agoWell you could detect if your cell tower(s) changed strength or location for no reason, and then spam the relevant radio frequencies with noise, or a clear signal. In general the co-channel interference is bad enough that most clients can't talk if they've got two or more radios broadcasting on the same frequency in the same cell at the same power. But increased noise is a sure-fire way to corrupt signal. You could also take up too many channels to keep it from servicing more clients. Or broadcast too many handset identifiers, flooding them with random traffic so it's hard to tell if they've actually found their handset or it just came up randomly.
- theA91 12y agoCurrently designing a device to do that it will use the same signal as the stingray under a tesla design it will reroute a fake signal to send a high electrical pulse safe to humans to the stingray causing it to become a receptor of the signal and frying it under electrical load kind of like a solar storms effects on electrical devices in space
- link15 12y agoHonestly, this is all being done over public airwaves. It may be an FCC violation (cell phone jammers?), but I don't think that's what the ACLU is upset about here. The part that seems shady to me is that Verizon appears to think it is OK to give out customer information to law enforcement without a warrant. Without being able to tie a device ID to a person, its all just a bunch of numbers.
- nness 12y agoI don't quite understand how this is a constitution issue? I get that the Fourth Amendment protects against warrantless entry, but if you're using a device that is producing a signal that leaves the boundaries of your property, is capturing that signal considered warrantless? I don't see the nuance between the Stingray device and Wifi networks. If a police officer were to identify your home via a wifi network SSID, would that be warrantless entry?
- throwaway0010 12y agoThere's a good deal of nuance to these sorts of questions. For example, police may look at your house from the street in the visible spectrum, but may not look at your house from the street in the infra-red spectrum without a warrant.
- dpeck 12y agoI seem to remember some interesting stuff about wireless in the US during the Google mapcar fiasco. Something about its not whether its in the clear and broadcast but if people think that it is determining a lot of the law around it. Memory is fuzzy and my searches aren't turning up the results I'm looking for. Does anyone else remember this?
- Terr_ 12y agoTechnically speaking, EVERYTHING in your house is giving off some kind of indication that could theoretically be captured and re-assembled. IMO the only reasonable interpretation is that the 4th Amendment protects you from anything beyond whatever passes for ordinary observation by normal people.
- crusso 12y agoAnd that's what the supreme court basically said. It's one thing for the police to look in an open window - but quite another for them to scan your home with a thermal imager. http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=93127 http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=93127
- TempleOS 12y agoFucken niggers! I told you it was God.
- chmars 12y agoStingray? Is that American slang? In the rest of the world, the device is called IMSI catcher: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSI-catcher https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSI-catcher
- mysteriousllama 12y agoTasker for Android can help notify you if this is happening to you. From the documentation I've gathered stingray devices appear to impersonate a cell tower with a stronger signal than the real one in order to get the device to associate. This means that stingray devices likely have their own cell ID so as not to trample the real one. If it didn't, it'd be a jammer not an interception device. A simple PoC Tasker script (I wish it had an actual text-based language..): Add a new state, "Cell Near", Scan and pick the tower with highest signal. Invert the action. Tie it to a Notification task. Whenever your phone associates with anything other than that tower you will get a notification. If you're good with Tasker it can be expanded to use GPS/Expected-tower pairs and alert you if something strange is going on. Yes, someone should write an app for the general public. Maybe even see if the EFF can help promote it!
- genericacct 12y agohttps://github.com/SecUpwN/Android-IMSI-Catcher-Detector https://github.com/SecUpwN/Android-IMSI-Catcher-Detector
- atmosx 12y agoHm, impressive. Nothing for iOs right? Android might not be as polished, but gets all the cool stuff.
- andyjohnson0 12y agoFrom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSI-catcher https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSI-catcher: "The IMSI catcher masquerades as a base station and logs the IMSI numbers of all the mobile stations in the area, as they attempt to attach to the IMSI-catcher. It allows forcing the mobile phone connected to it to use no call encryption (i.e., it is forced into A5/0 mode), making the call data easy to intercept and convert to audio." If it is possible for an Android/iOS app to detect when a GSM call is initiated without encryption then it should be possible to warn the user. Does anyone know if the encryption level is available to the OS, or is it restricted to the baseband processor?
- revelation 12y agoAs usual, everything interesting happens on the baseband processor. It would be trivial to detect that an IMSI catcher is used, even when it has support for encryption (unlikely given the age of the Stingray system and the need to communicate back with the mobile provider). But alas, all the baseband processors are propietary software designed by companies that will happily compromise your privacy.
- WillKirkby 12y agoI think it's restricted to the baseband, but I'm not an expert. Fun fact: SIM cards actually have a flag which tells the handset to display a warning to the user if they are using an unencrypted connection. Basically no commercial SIM cards have this flag enabled. Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKihq1fClQg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKihq1fClQg
- BuildTheRobots 12y agoI believe you have to enable a bit to _disable_ the warning (eg, it should be there as default). On my own network with my own sim cards, I've yet to find a modern handset that actually alerts me, though :(
- WillKirkby 12y agoJust re-watched the talk (was going from memory) and it seems you're right, it's "enable this flag to disable the warning".