10 ms·
The greatest juggler alive quit to open a construction business
- lnanek2 13y agoHonestly, the concrete how-to video description at the end is the most useful take away I got from the article. Good for him.
- hoodoof 13y agoBecause there's no money in juggling?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dang 13y agoGood point. The previous title ("Why did the greatest juggler alive quit to open a concrete business?) wasn't much of a question, so we changed it.
- insomniasexx 13y agoThis article is much more about the journey of his life and the journey of a journalist to answer the question. The final answer means very little; there are a myriad of reasons he quit. Perhaps you should read the article. It's very enjoyable.
- jay-anderson 13y agoThere certainly is some money in juggling. The article mentioned 50k starting salary at cirque du soleil. But maybe working in concrete lets him spend more time with his family for roughly the same amount of money (or more).
- hessenwolf 13y agoIn my youth, as a devastatingly mediocre musician, I got the opportunity to spend some time with a band. The sex and drinking looked fun, but the nighttime hours, and never being able to settle down with a nice girl and start a family, blow.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- scrollaway 13y agoIs there a punchline there? Let me try... "Why did the greatest juggler alive quit to open a concrete business?... Because juggling is insubstantial!"
- oska 13y agoI don't see any tragedy here and I doubt Gatto/Commarota does either. He did something amazingly well as a kid and young adult, had fun with it and has now decided it's time to move on. The tragedy with top sports-people is often when they retire and have a lot of trouble adjusting to not being the best in the world at something. From the article it sounds like Commarota finally got tired of the constant stress on his body and the difficulty of supporting and spending time with his family while professionally juggling and is now successfully transitioning to a very 'down-to-earth' career. Good luck to him.
- zhte415 13y agoI agree, I see no conflict or tragedy also. He is a man that has pursued excellence, understands quality, likes to work for himself (performer, landscape gardener, etc), seems to have a competitive edge but also seems wise to it, and has demonstrated keenness to carefully coach others or explain how to do things. It should be quite a successful business.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoThat's probably the most insightful view going - I was simply thinking of him as yet another construction guy. But add that to his story / marketing / brand and ... I will pay extra for the proof of a guy willing to be painstaking to achieve excellence. Given my current troubles with builders, this is a 2x pricing opportunity for him - quite seriously
- ZoF 13y agoThe company site has zero reference to his past and is registered under his birth name(different from his stage name), so I don't think that's a card he plans on playing. Do you think he could really have an opportunity to receive 2x pricing? I think there might be a certain opportunity in illustrating the novelty of his past somewhere on the site, but I honestly don't believe most consumers(even for something large like a resurfacing) would take to time to realize the extent to which he excelled at juggling, nor do I think they would translate that to an increased value in his current abilities(at least not a 100% increase). In reality I think that consumer is more often willing to settle for cheap inadequacy than expensive competence, but I might be completely off with that assumption in this industry(or in general). What do you think? If he could really stand the chance for a significant increase in revenue for something as simple as publicly touting past accomplishments, perhaps he should; he was that good after all.
- eruditely 13y agoThis article's existence, headline included is the straight-forward definition of ridiculous. "In the future, the truest sign of human existential crises came not from plague, wars, or conspiracy, but ineffable journalism." It also comes with a self-esteem hedge in the opening just in case you don't read. What might be an interesting story would the the meta-article on the set of these types of stories.
- DavidAdams 13y agoEven though the answer to the article's question is pretty easy (there are really very few athletic or show business fields of endeavor that you can actually make a good living doing), as I was reading it and watching the videos I was really glad that it was posted to HN. I think it's fascinating to learn about someone who's the best at something incredibly difficult.
- kamaal 13y ago>>Will it get me another job? ... If you can’t understand why I don’t waste my energy on doing seven balls overhead for a minute to make a youtube video for people to watch, then you haven’t entered the real world yet. I had a similar discussion with my office colleagues a few weeks back. When there was a call for a 'Hacknight' at our workplace to drive revenues up, when a SVP panicked he was going to miss his target. And the people where asked to contribute and magically rescue the whole situation out of nowhere. Nearly every one agreed that they would not contribute a minute to that 'Hacknight' When people just give up, start giving damn about things. Its generally because they've been taken for a ride, before. Once hard working night owl hackers stop doing things because they watch some jack ass four levels above them doing 1/100th the work but taking nearly everything that is right fully theirs. The Hack night was a big flop, ofcourse the SVP called for a meeting next day and lectured about motivation and lack of passion in the team(Meaning, people not ready sacrifice a great deal and give away their work for free). And how despite all the help from the leadership(Meaning, Arranging for biscuits and tea, and then going to home to get sleep) people were not ready to contribute to the company(Meaning, Help the VP make an additional million in yearly bonus). Ultimately you get what you pay for.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 13y agoHey, wait, I don't know about you, but I've always thought one of the most rewarding parts of working in tech was being lectured about motivation by someone with 10X my salary, 100X my bonus and 1000X my equity stake :-)
- x0x0 13y agoyou forgot being lectured about taking risks (or wasting my life on making better advertising) by assholes who've already made theirs and never have to worry about how they're ever going to afford to buy in the bay area, raise a family, pay for college, etc. It's easy to take a risk on a job when you don't need the money...
- 13y ago
- Schwolop 13y agoI used to run the world's biggest juggling video repository (JuggleThis.net, now defunct) which itself was definitely responsible for a lot of the irritation Gatto found with the new generation of camera-happy juggling kids. Certainly he was frustrated by newcomers filming 100 takes and showing just one (something I'm guilty of too!). But without being a juggler yourself it's hard to express just how much better than everyone else he really was. If being able to do a trick with N balls is unit difficulty, adding N+2 balls is a factor of 10-100 harder. Being able to perform it is another 10-100 times again. Gatto regularly performed things the next best jugglers could barely do at all. He was the Donald Bradman of juggling, and I'm very sad we now have to say "was".
- clarky07 13y agoI'm not ashamed to admit I had to look up Donald Bradman. Cricket? That's the analogy you went with? :-)
- artichokeheart 13y agoOP is Aussie. As a fellow Aussie this makes perfect sense
- Schwolop 13y agoIn terms of "sportsman who is so far ahead of his peers that it's almost impossible to explain how", then yes, I think Bradman fits the bill!
- zem 13y agothere is pretty much no one who has dominated a sport the way bradman dominated cricket, i think. consider - he has the highest lifetime test batting average of all time, at 99.94. which doesn't perhaps sound that impressive, out of context, until you see that the next three people in the record books have averages of 60.97, 60.83 and 60.73. he was more than 50% better than the second-best test batsman around.
- virtualwhys 13y ago
- IvyMike 13y agoI was very excited to see that there was a "Juggling" category on Grantland. I was very disappointed when it turns out this was the only entry.
- onewaystreet 13y agoThis is a case of a performer aging and not being able to understand a new medium. Gatto asks if posting videos on youtube will get him another job. He never considers that it can be a job.
- jay-anderson 13y agoGatto seems to prefer the well-honed live performance to the recorded performance that may have worked on the 100th take. This is a matter of taste. It's also difficult to judge the skill of a performer in a recording (are they that good or did they edit their video to just have their successes). This makes me think of classical music. Live performances have certainly been on the downward trend for many years. Glenn Gould devoted himself to just recording instead of live performances seeing this as the future of music (see http://www.newyorker.com/archive/2005/06/06/050606crat_atlarge?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/archive/2005/06/06/050606crat_atlar...). I think there's room for both live and recorded. Seeing only perfect performances can create unrealistic expectations in people's minds.
- mcguire 13y agoIf your specialty is getting things perfect (almost) every time, and you are competing in an arena where the other people only have to keep trying until they get it right once, then you are going to have a bad day. The comparison with live and recorded performances is spot on. There's probably a reason the major "live" performances of popular musicians are pre-recorded. There may be a lesson here for those who are spending years perfecting technical skills when your competition are taking three-month bootcamps.
- mcescalante 13y agoThis reminds me a bit of the Satoshi Nakamoto Newsweek article - A journalist who wants to dig up a juicy story but gets nothing because the guy just wants some privacy. And then he writes an article about being empty handed, accompanied by any research that might have been done along the way. The guy was a juggler, who probably didn't make tons of money and who was injured & discouraged, or even just going through some regular life struggles (we all have them). He's doing something different for now and harassing him won't change a thing. I feel like he just wanted to be left alone.
- pud 13y agoGreat article but it makes no mention of Michael Moschen, who many (including me) consider the best & most creative juggler in the world. Here are some mind-blowing physics that I think the HN community, in particular, would enjoy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjHoedoSUXY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjHoedoSUXY He's also well-known for "contact juggling," where the balls don't leave the hands: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8OTb8tga-yg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8OTb8tga-yg
- msellout 13y agoIt's easy to underestimate the precision necessary for those bounce throws.
- pepijndevos 13y agoIt's even easier to think juggling is about catching, while it is entirely about throwing.
- gcv 13y agoI saw him perform a few years ago. It was off-putting: he spent a bunch of time during the show complaining about other people "stealing" his tricks, specifically contact juggling itself.
- patrickdavey 13y agoAh - I do love a good contact juggling routine. I got to see this guy at the buskers festival in Christchurch NZ. They gave permission to reproduce one of their promo videos: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UB_I2YILI2o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UB_I2YILI2o You might enjoy too :)
- dasil003 13y agoBTW, if you remember the crystal ball contact juggling that David Bowie does in Labyrinth, that was Moschen.
- rkuykendall-com 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gcv 13y agoSpeaking as a juggler: I've seen Gatto in performance (in Kooza in 2008); he's every bit as good as the article says. I've also seen (and met) many other top jugglers. And yet, to be honest, while I appreciate the talent and skill required to do the kinds of numbers and moves Gatto does, and even though I understand the difficulty of pulling off, e.g., 7 clubs or 7-ball 5-up 360s or 6-club backcrosses — I find this type of juggling fairly boring to watch. No matter how much showmanship you put into it, every performing juggler eventually realizes that technical skill means very little and audiences get bored after about 3 minutes. Most good jugglers with long shows do comedy and variety routines. Gatto clearly didn't want to go down that road. I respect that. My favorite juggler to watch is Falco Scheffler: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_CmnaICnMiw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_CmnaICnMiw — no high numbers here, just 3 and 4 balls. And way more fun to watch than endless runs of 5 club backcrosses.
- dmckeon 13y agoA performing juggler once told me (an amateur), after he showed me a technically challenging bit: There are bits you do for an audience, and there are bits you do for other jugglers. It sounds like Gatto liked the doing the technical bits more than he liked working for an audience. Now, years later, I find that programming has a similar pattern: there is code that one writes for an audience (and that thus is more maintainable) and there is code that one writes that may show great technical skill - but that is more ... challenging to enjoy.
- ghshephard 13y agoInteresting - I would say it's the inverse. The complex, challenging, and spectacular code that gets blasted out is for the audience (user/customer) - but the most beautiful, simple, and maintainable code can only be written by those with the greatest skill, and are mostly appreciated by other developers of likewise experience. In a way, it's a bit like juggling - that non-flash, simple routine, which concisely and clearly expresses intent, with little room for error, may not look impressive - but other developers will recognize the raw skill that was required to create it.
- glenra 13y ago> The usual strategies of sportswriting depend on the writer and reader sharing a set of passions and references [...] but you almost certainly don’t know as much about juggling as you do about football or baseball. Nope, I knew more about juggling! The author only lost me at the end when it got into analogies with various names in basketball/tennis/golf that I was at most barely familiar with. But other than that, this is a great article. I realized midway through that I've actually seen Gatto's cirque act and didn't realize it was him at the time.
- galfarragem 13y ago>>Will it get me another job? ... If you can’t understand why I don’t waste my energy on doing seven balls overhead for a minute to make a youtube video for people to watch, then you haven’t entered the real world yet. Resuming: If you are at the top in one hierarchy that doesn't reward you according to your position, what should you do? a) Stay and struggle (even with some niceties ex:social status). b) Move to the bottom of another hierarchy where there's plenty to everybody (but where you don't have the skill or the passion to move up).
- hessenwolf 13y agoThere exists a continuum of possibilities between those extremes.
- galfarragem 13y agoYou can do anything, but not everything - David Allen I tried during last years (I'm also dealing with this problem) to be somewhere in the middle of this 2 solutions but doesn't work. To be in the top of one hierarchy (and get the niceties) you need focus. Nowadays to that continuum of possibilities I would call indecision.
- bitJericho 13y agoThis is really a great piece. I particularly enjoyed the intro. You must read it again after you've read the article to truly appreciate it.
- NAFV_P 13y agoA good alternative to clubs are Jack Daniel's bottles.