6 ms·
> Apple will hit up the debt markets for more dollars, it being cheaper to use other’s domestic cash than its foreign reserves Can anyone explain why this is s
by jrochkind1 13y ago
> Apple will hit up the debt markets for more dollars, it being cheaper to use other’s domestic cash than its foreign reserves
Can anyone explain why this is so? Because they are somehow getting a higher interest rate return on their reserves then they'd have to pay to borrow? (That would seem pretty impossible). Because they'd have to pay taxes if they use the foreign reserves? Something else?
- zrail 13y agoIf they repatriate the foreign reserves they have to pay taxes. Taxes are more expensive than interest rates (right now).
- VonGuard 13y agoTaxes and delays make it easier and faster to get debt than to move a couple billion from, say, France or China, to the US. It's complex, but there's a lot of stuff explaining this in other comments around here. I'm sure someone will do the break down again.
- pbreit 13y agoTaxes. US gov wants to take something like 35% in taxes of "repatriated" earnings. http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2013-05/2/apple-borrowing http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2013-05/2/apple-borrowin...
- r00fus 13y agoMaybe the proper framing is that Apple (through Braeburn Capital) hid this money in offshore tax shelters much like Google and pretty much any other large corporation does. Bringing it back simply allows Tax authorities to "see" it again. Perhaps the fact that it's even possible for companies to shelter the vast bulk of their earnings from tax is the problem in the first place?
- protomyth 13y agoApple does earn a lot of money overseas.
- ericd 13y agoThey're selling the fruits of design and engineering work that happens in the US, and so this is arguably where most of the value creation happens, and that that should be taxed despite the fact that the nominal sale and creation is happening overseas.
- protomyth 13y agoSince the foreign countries tax the sales, they (and the earning of all Americans overseas) should not be taxed again to get the money back into the US. It is a BS way to operate and the US is the only country who tries it.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago> They're selling the fruits of design and engineering work that happens in the US, and so this is arguably where most of the value creation happens, and that that should be taxed despite the fact that the nominal sale and creation is happening overseas. There is an easy solution: Tax the corporation's US payroll. The obvious problem with doing that (or any other thing that causes effective tax rates to increase in response to employing US workers) is that it creates a large monetary incentive to move the "value creation" somewhere else. The whole problem is that we're trying to tax stupid things. Taxing corporate profits is stupid because profits don't have a nexus with any particular jurisdiction, so they get moved to whichever jurisdiction has the lowest taxes. The only way to avoid that is to tax something other than profits -- something that actually exists in your jurisdiction. Payroll tax, consumption tax, etc. And between them, the consumption tax is better because a disincentive to buy things made in other jurisdictions causes less harm to the local economy than a disincentive to hire the people in your jurisdiction would. Edit: People who downvote comments without providing any reasoning are cowards.
- encoderer 13y ago
- mullingitover 13y agoIt's perversely amusing to me that while an indiviual US citizen's overseas earnings are fair game for the IRS (and AFAIK no other country does this to their citizens), a corporation's earnings are totally invisible.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sjwright 13y agoThe reason is because these companies have children who are native citizens of the other country, which the parent company has full control over. They give the children some asset (e.g. intellectual property) and pay them an allowance (e.g. license fees for the IP). The IRS can't touch that money any more than they can touch the money of your Jamaican love-child.
- Tortoise 13y agoThe only other country to do this is Eritrea. In 2013, the Canadian government expelled the Eritrean consul for illegal efforts at collecting that tax. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_taxation#Citizenship http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_taxation#Citizens...
- eisa01 13y agoPart of the problem is that the US is unique in taxing world wide income. That creates a lot of problems both for companies and US citizens abroad
- gamblor956 13y agoIt's actually not unique. More than a dozen countries, including China (see, e.g., http://www.deloitte.com/assets/Dcom-Austria/Local%20Assets/Documents/Chinese%20Services%20Group/Deloitte_tax_highlight_2013_China.pdf http://www.deloitte.com/assets/Dcom-Austria/Local%20Assets/D...), tax worldwide income, and at higher effective rates than the U.S.
- ojbyrne 13y agoActually that says China taxes residents on worldwide income, and non-residents on China-sourced income. The US taxes non-resident citizens on worldwide income.
- gamblor956 13y agoChina has a significantly broader definition of residence than does the U.S. A Chinese resident company includes companies incorporated in China as well as companies managed from China; Chinese citizens are taxed on their worldwide income for several years after they leave China, possibly indefinitely if they maintain their household, familial, or economic connections to China. In practice, this means that China effectively imposes worldwide taxation on its companies and citizens. In the U.S. residence is a very straightforward. A company is a resident if it is incorporated in the U.S. An individual is a resident if he is a citizen, a greencard holder, or passes a mathematical "substantial presence" test. Non-resident U.S. citizens are subject to worldwide taxation...but they have a very generous $100k floor, plus foreign tax credits for foreign taxes paid on their income.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoChina will tax world-wide income for non-citizens if they spend 5 contiguous years in China. I recently had my month out (ok, it was more than a year ago) to avoid this situation. The $100k floor only applies to work done outside of the US. If you work for an American company, you'll invariably go on business trips back home, which mess up your taxes substantially as this isn't covered on the US/China tax treaty.
- darkarmani 13y ago> US gov wants to take something like 35% in taxes of "repatriated" earnings. You are surprised that the US wants to tax earnings? The US taxes everyone's earnings. If they want to keep it overseas they can avoid the tax. If they want to bring it back they need to pay a tax on the amount minus the credit for the foreign tax already paid. They would have been taxed if they earned the money in the US, so I'm not sure why this is surprising.
- lordgilman 13y agoYes, you have to pay taxes when repatriating that cash.
- dchuk 13y agoIt's because of the taxes.
- qdog 13y agoI believe it to be the taxes. If they repatriate those dollars they'll pay a significant tax. I believe there are also bills in congress that may someday make it through to address this, but it probably won't be soon. Getting to not pay tax on foreign profits is just bad policy, imho.
- guyzero 13y agoThey'd have to pay taxes if they bring foreign cash back to the US to pay dividends. Google floated $1B in bonds earlier this year: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-02-20/google-said-to-plan-1-billion-bond-sale-to-refinance-borrowings.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-02-20/google-said-to-plan... Probably for the same reason.
- mikeyouse 13y ago> Because they'd have to pay taxes if they use the foreign reserves? Yep. Apple can borrow at somewhere near 2.3%[1] on the public debt markets. They have billions overseas, but if they bring it back to the US, they'd have to pay corporate income tax on it (35%). They're just biding their time until the Chamber of Commerce lobbyists gain enough influence to get congress to pass an overseas tax holiday to repatriate the money at 15% or 20%. To this end, expect a huge PR onslaught near election time about how much economic stimulus would be provided if we changed the rules about taxes just this once (note: happens every ~10 years). [1] - http://quicktake.morningstar.com/StockNet/Bondsquote.aspx?cid=0C00000ADA&bid=d85cbb7dc2dfa4f872c5cfea9d1ba185&bname=Apple+2.4%25+%7c+Maturity%3a2023&ticker=AAPL&country=USA&clientid=dotcom http://quicktake.morningstar.com/StockNet/Bondsquote.aspx?ci...
- pitnips 13y agoLast tax holiday was the Homeland Investment Act in 2004. HIA II could be an issue worth debate in 2016.
- OnyeaboAduba 13y agoThe arguement for the holiday the last time was "job creation" which didnt really bear fruit. Dont think it will happen again unless it is part of a larger tax reform bill.
- michaelt 13y agoA cynic would say that if politicians want the tax holiday to appease their campaign donors, it doesn't have to /actually/ create jobs, voters just have to /believe/ it creates jobs.
- kevinpet 13y agoInsufficiently cynical. Voters just have to believe that politicians believed it would create jobs.
- rdl 13y agoGiven how low the interest rates are on Apple's debt, I don't think repatriating cash would lead to any job creation in the US, anyway, even at 0%.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago> Because they'd have to pay taxes if they use the foreign reserves? This is the main reason. > Because they are somehow getting a higher interest rate return on their reserves then they'd have to pay to borrow? (That would seem pretty impossible). This is also a possibility. Apple has extraordinarily good credit. They can consequently borrow at near-zero interest rates. They can then invest that amount of money in some (perhaps only slightly) higher risk security than their own bonds and turn a profit -- and if the money was originally held by a foreign subsidiary then so is the profit from the investment.
- MaysonL 13y agoIt's mainly a tax thing: to bring the offshore cash to the US, which it would have to do, it would have to pay income tax on it. The combination of deferring this tax and the reduced dividend payout which come from buying back their stock more than pays for the interest on the debt.
- WildUtah 13y agoYou got a lot of replies talking about the global taxation of US companies' profits. That is a problem; no other developed nation tries to tax foreign profits already taxed once again at home because it leads to just this kind of problem. But the really big problem is that the US has the developed world's highest corporate tax rates. At 35% federal and 0-14% state, US rates exceed all other first world jurisdictions. Few big corporations pay that much because the USA has a lot of special credits and deductions that lobbyists for big companies have slipped into the code for themselves, like executive entertainment expenses and "research" or "domestic" manufacturing and oilfield operations and banking interest and such. Foreign profits don't enjoy such deductions at the margin, so the full rate would have to be paid. President Obama and congressional Republicans have suggested that the rate be lowered and some of the deductions be eliminated. Congressional Democrats and special interests that each want to keep their own favorite deduction have been preventing a deal for years. It's more likely that we'll just get a overseas tax holiday at 20% or so sometime in the next decade while the system at home remains a mess. Apple can wait it out and see.
- tomcorrigan 13y ago> no other developed nation tries to tax foreign profits already taxed once again at home That statement is demonstrably false. I know for a fact that in Australia foreign income is taxed again. Credits are available for some or all of the tax paid in the foreign country depending on the existence and nature of bilateral tax treaties between the two nations. I believe similar schemes operate in most developed nations. Also of note is that the company tax rate in Australia is 30% but with far fewer special credits and discounts so the effective rate is quite close to the nominal rate.