10 ms·
How American Health Care Killed My Father
- Fannie 17y agoI can believe American Health care killed your father. The people who have insurance, are afraid to go to the emergency room with chest pain, afraid the pain is gas and they can't afford the high out of pocket costs they have to pay.
- bwd2 17y agoThe title is misleading, this article is actually an examination of economic distortions in the US healthcare industry, and a quite good one at that.
- joe_the_user 17y agoI don't see a contradiction between the article's title and the subject you mention. Various economic factors distort the provision of healthcare to the point that it kills people. The title naturally highlights this crucial point, understandably so given the author's personal experience with this.
- electromagnetic 17y agoIt's quite disturbing that Pronovost had to beg hospitals to adopt a free technique that could cut the average 100,000 deaths from hospital acquired infections down to ~30,000 overnight with nothing but telling your doctors to wash their hands. This was adopted a long time ago in the UK and became cemented in place with the MRSA outbreaks. Visitors can actually be removed from the hospital if they're seen not using the alcohol based sanitizer.
- jacquesm 17y agoIf there is one place to avoid if you want to stay healthy it's the hospital.
- mrkurt 17y agoThe last paragraph of the article addresses this specifically: "Imagine my father’s hospital had to present the bill for his “care” not to a government bureaucracy, but to my grieving mother. Do you really believe that the hospital—forced to face the victim of its poor-quality service, forced to collect the bill from the real customer—wouldn’t have figured out how to make its doctors wash their hands?"
- DannoHung 17y agoNope. Because collections are outsourced.
- kingkongrevenge 17y agoHe says he is a democrat, but a reasonable interpretation of the article points towards the republican solution of taxing health care benefits. The problem is that both the industry and consumers are very insulated from price sensitivity, so costs shoot out of control and providers have little incentive to improve quality. People need to be paying for far more of their care out of pocket with cash. We need price wars between hospitals.
- run4yourlives 17y agoWhy is it that you Americans are so two dimensional? Every possible idea for social reform must either be the republican or democrat position. If it can't be pigeon-holed into one of those viewpoints, it's not worth discussion. If it can, it quickly devolves into some form of partisan debate. Your two party system is killing you in every area, and you don't even know it.
- pixcavator 17y agoDo you mean "one dimensional"?
- run4yourlives 17y agohehe, yes I suppose. I was thinking two dimensional with the understanding that the number of dimensions to an argument (dimension == viewpoint) was infinite. The argument itself though is very one dimensional. :)
- kingkongrevenge 17y ago> social reform must either be the republican or democrat position Uhh, no. It just so happens that in this case some Republicans are the only people putting forward the idea of taxing medical benefits as ordinary income, to reduce the role of insurance in the system. I don't even vote, let alone think in terms of democrat vs republican.
- grandalf 17y agoI'm an American and I think the one dimensional political spectrum idea is nonsense. I have also never voted for a mainstream party.
- pragmatic 17y agoEt tu, Hacker News? The political pieces on HN are starting to overwhelm the technical articles. Isn't there enough of this on Reddit?
- jgrahamc 17y agoYes, there's plenty of this on Reddit. That's why I used my 'flag' power to flag this article. This article bugs me for two reasons: 1. It's about a non-technical political topic 2. I am British and care very little about the internal political arguments in the US concerning their health care system.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"I am British and care very little about the internal political arguments in the US concerning their health care system." Amen Brother! Political articles should be (imho) shut down very fast. The "flag and wait for a moderator" tactic doesn't seem to be working as well as it used to.
- biohacker42 17y agoI flagged it too, but I don't know if we have different moderators or if more people are voting politics up and that negates our flagging it. And by the way, the article is quite good, I just don't want it on HN.
- callahad 17y ago"The 'flag' and wait for a moderator doesn't seem to be working as well as it used to." How can we judge how well the system is working when we have no direct insight into it? Perhaps a moderator reviewed the post and found it to be of merit?
- plinkplonk 17y ago"Asserting that the system is not "working as well as it used to ..." I said "The "flag and wait for a moderator" tactic doesn't seem to be working as well as it used to." there is a subtle difference between what I said and what you claimed I said.
- protomyth 17y agoI kinda wish Hacker News would skip the political articles. There are plenty of technical things about health care to cover (e.g. databases for health, clinical trials, input cost reduction). That being said, I lived under US government health care for a goodly chunk of my life (IHS), and until they fix that, they really have no biz working on anything else.
- kragen 17y agoIHS is the Indian Health Service? They don't care about that because Indians have no political power. It's unbelievable the kind of corruption and incompetence that exists inside that agency. FWIW, Medicare, Medicaid, the VA, and medical care for soldiers are all pretty good on the US scale.
- ahoyhere 17y agoReally? The VA? Did you miss all the scandals about the Walter Reed medical base in DC, where soldiers were mistreated, ignored and neglected, and even one killed himself in his room and no one noticed for 2 days? The hospital had no idea until his parents called and forced them to look for their missing son. This was a guy who was evacuated due to a semi-suicide attempt, and they didn't even bother to monitor him. Shameful. Not to mention the older vets, especially from Vietnam. They are screwed at every turn and the previous administration cut their benefits even more.
- yardie 17y agoThe Walter Reed scandal would really reinforce what people have been saying about for profit healthcare. Walter Reed is a huge military complex with Army and contractor buildings on the base. Most vets that go to Walter Reed end up under the military care. This is the old colonial style buildings that most people see. They are in pretty good shape and most vets don't have a complaint about Army care. The real fiasco is the private contractors. This is the part of Walter Reed people read about in the paper. They work under VA but since they are for-profit companies, you know the rest. People like to use Walter Reed of why the gov't shouldn't get into healthcare at all. Walter Reed is an example of why private, healthcare companies have no business being in healthcare.
- mustpax 17y agoFor the whole article on a single page: http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/print/200909/health-care http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/print/200909/health-care
- tptacek 17y agoThis isn't a political article. Its author has contributed tens of thousands of dollars to Democratic political causes, but the article itself is almost completely opposed to the Democratic Party's thoughts on health care. Instead, this is an article about business, efficiency, the impact of IT and modern business process on health care, and the impact our current system has on consumers and businesses.
- pg 17y agoI agree. This kind of article is a de facto test of flagging judgement. For a while now I've been considering having HN learn whose flags to pay attention to. (I already have code to collect stats about rates of crying wolf, but I don't do anything with these numbers yet.)
- davidw 17y agoAs someone who certainly "cries wolf", I'll go ahead and ask: how are we to judge "good" politics articles from bad ones? I read The Economist, and think they occasionally do some pretty good politics articles, and having an on-line version, it would be easy to post them here.
- mhb 17y agoHere's the answer: No one wants politics articles here. You can tell that this is not a politics article by 1) reading, instead of ignoring, the multiple assertions in the comments that this is not a "politics" article or 2) reading it.
- davidw 17y agoI read it, and it boils down to a discussion of the allocation of health care resources, which is economics/politics. For instance, if you're going to critique it, he says: > Such a transition would require the slow reduction of Medicare taxes, premiums, and benefit levels for those not yet eligible, and a corresponding slow ramp-up in HSAs. And the national catastrophic plan would need to start with much broader coverage and higher premiums than the ultimate goal, in order to fund the care needed today by our aging population. It's very difficult to take away benefits that people already have, which is eminently a matter of politics. Also, note the "POLICY" at the top of the page. That's pretty indicative that it is politics. I'm not saying it's not a good article, but it certainly isn't about hacking code or electronics, and only tangentially related to startups (in a way that lots of things are, if you want to make tenuous connections). pg, however, thinks it is worth having this sort of article, so I am asking, honestly, how one distinguishes a good politics article. It strikes me as being a difficult thing to do, but perhaps he has some insight that I am not picking up. Perhaps it's simply a matter of taste. The article obviously appeals to hackers (myself included), but I am not sure that it appeals more to hackers than to other intelligent people, so that test doesn't really work.
- jpwagner 17y agotheatlantic: "wow this story is amazing, thoughtful, and powerful, but the title has got to go. How about something catchy like: How American Health Care Killed My Father" author: "umm..."
- towski 17y agoI'm tired of health care articles based on anecdote. His entire article is seems biased by the fact that his dad died.
- davars 17y agoAppealing when presented in the abstract, but I have nightmarish visions of such a system. On the one hand, you'd further motivate those consumers who were already likely to avoid preventive care and ignore symptoms until they require costly (to me as contributor to the catastrophic plan) emergency and intensive care. And the author's position that folks would be able to withdraw funds that exceed a certain ceiling adds the perverse incentive to risk not spending this money, with the downside being absorbed by the catastrophic plan. On the other hand, you'd do nothing to discourage consumers with irrational fears about their health from distorting prices upwards, or to discourage unscrupulous providers from fomenting those fears. The plan he describes takes fee-for-service and all its problems to a whole new level. I think of things like the celebrity anti-vaccine mess and the healthcare debate with its distorted media coverage and disingenuous advertising, and I have hard time accepting a consumer-driven market succeeding, even with all the government-collected and -analyzed data in the world. Even worse, I fear that such a system would result in a tiered system, where the best and brightest providers provide excessive care to those with means while the rest of us continue to struggle with barely adequate, barely affordable care. I don't think that any system that relies on healthcare consumers making the choice between limiting their usage of healthcare services and spending money is destined for success. Providers need to be rewarded for providing the best outcomes for the lowest cost with the fewest mistakes, not the most and most expensive services. Significant efforts must be made to improve the public health of Americans. The conversation should be about how to make those things happen. All this debate about who pays when is just a side show that is obstructing real reform.
- donaldc 17y agoYour fears are ones that one could have about any market. But in general, free markets seem to work better than any of the alternatives across a wide range of markets, and I really doubt that health care would prove an exception to this. It won't be perfect, of course, but a perfect system doesn't exist. I'm absolutely appalled that I'm paying (on average, as an American) over $1.5 million over my life for the present system, and can't imagine this would remain the case if pricing and outcome transparency were drastically increased. I think that quality and service would improve, while cost would decrease.
- 17y ago
- nazgulnarsil 17y agomedical reform isn't political in the sense that what we currently have is obviously bullshit and what the politicians propose is obviously bullshit. if we're talking about a non-bullshit solution we're in the realm of fantasy, not politics.
- Xichekolas 17y agoSome of my favorite parts: "But health insurance is different from every other type of insurance. Health insurance is the primary payment mechanism not just for expenses that are unexpected and large, but for nearly all health-care expenses. We’ve become so used to health insurance that we don’t realize how absurd that is. We can’t imagine paying for gas with our auto-insurance policy, or for our electric bills with our homeowners insurance, but we all assume that our regular checkups and dental cleanings will be covered at least partially by insurance." "For that matter, try discussing prices with hospitals and other providers. Eight years ago, my wife needed an MRI, but we did not have health insurance. I called up several area hospitals, clinics, and doctors’ offices—all within about a one-mile radius—to find the best price. I was surprised to discover that prices quoted, for an identical service, varied widely, and that the lowest price was $1,200. But what was truly astonishing was that several providers refused to quote any price. Only if I came in and actually ordered the MRI could we discuss price." "By contrast, consider LASIK surgery. I still lack the (small amount of) courage required to get LASIK. But I’ve been considering it since it was introduced commercially in the 1990s. The surgery is seldom covered by insurance, and exists in the competitive economy typical of most other industries. So people who get LASIK surgery—or for that matter most cosmetic surgeries, dental procedures, or other mostly uninsured treatments—act like consumers. If you do an Internet search today, you can find LASIK procedures quoted as low as $499 per eye—a decline of roughly 80 percent since the procedure was introduced. You’ll also find sites where doctors advertise their own higher-priced surgeries (which more typically cost about $2,000 per eye) and warn against the dangers of discount LASIK. Many ads specify the quality of equipment being used and the performance record of the doctor, in addition to price. In other words, there’s been an active, competitive market for LASIK surgery of the same sort we’re used to seeing for most goods and services."
- ahoyhere 17y agoThat's because the notion of insurance is wrong. People need healthcare coverage, not insurance. We are all connected in this stupid country - if the family down the street can't afford preventative care, and the wife gets sick, and can't take care of the kids, and the husband misses work and gets fired from his job, and then they can't afford good nutritious food for their kids, so the kids go to school hungry and don't learn as well and don't test as well, the ripples can last for generations. Here's the thing. People act as if healthcare is something that has to be earned, and deserved, and not only is this viewpoint inhumane (in the Greatest Nation in the World!), but it's economically indefensible. If people don't get early medical care, their lifetime economic output can be greatly reduced. And their children are affected. If children aren't taken care of with nutrition and care, their mental abilities, abilities to stay in school, are affected -- and their lifetime economic output is reduced. And targeted poverty (as opposed to where everyone's poor) breeds crime. Which creates greater loss of human economic potential AND greater costs for the government. The country benefits from more, healthier workers, who can think straight, and don't spend significant portions of their time figuring out how to scrape by. These people can then spend money. Middle- and lower-middle-class people spend far more of their income than higher income brackets, if only they have the money to spend. Net effect: The benefits to the entire country outweigh the costs, in a system where costs aren't an arms race between health insurance providers, malpractice insurers, and other for-profit companies. A stitch in time saves nine.